Send us Fan Mail - Intro: MGD Betting & Paul Jones' Book (0-3mins) - Weekend Racing Review: On & Off Track (3-10) - Fred Done Interview (10-25) - Irish Betting Shops & FOBT's (25-29) - Alex Ballinger MP Writes Letter (29-38) - Final Demand & Willie Mullins (38-49) - Simon Cox Interview (49-53) - Matchbook Buys Betdaq (53-61) - Your Questions Answered (61mins-End)
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_02Now you're all very welcome to another episode of The Racing Room. It's Ronan Groom here with the Deadly Trio of Anthony Kaminskis, Harry Stewart Moore, and of course Tony Calvin. Gents, hope you're well. Looking forward to this chat this Monday morning. Coming up in the next hour, we'll discuss the latest comments of concern from Fred Doan, ahead of the budget. We'll ask if fixed odds uh betting machines are so vital to bookmaking in Britain, how do shops over here in Ireland manage to live without them? We'll discuss the fine for Willie Mullins and Cheltenham in the final demand case.
SPEAKER_02Has this been sufficiently covered in the media? We'll ask, and we'll touch on matchbooks purchase bet that that plus much, much more besides all your questions as well. That's the racing room this week. But I've been told to keep the intro quite tight, uh AK, but I will bring you in here. But you put up an interesting market on the budget onto the site last night. So did you want to just uh I'll give you the floor here to uh explain your thinking?
SPEAKER_03Uh explain my thinking. It's just topical, isn't it? It's going to be topical for the next nine or so days. Uh plenty, plenty of margin on the board, but you've got to do that when you haven't a clue how to price something. Um, it's uh it's it's very hard to predict what we've found previously with markets like that is somebody always knows the answer eventually. So uh we we didn't make money on our last one anyway. Maybe it was bad pricing, maybe it was somebody uh knowing the story, but uh, I don't know. We didn't make money the last time we put this this this type of market up. So it's uh it's more of a novelty than anything else, just for public interest to see see which way the wind's blowing.
SPEAKER_02Yes, this is in with regard to the machine uh gaming duty announced in the 2026 budget. So you'll find that on our website on the AK Bets and then click politics, scroll down to the button, UK budget special. So if you have an opinion, go and have a bet with AK. Uh before I let you away with the racing review, Tony Cavan, just a quick couple of notes. Uh, we just want to give another plug to the Paul Jones book, uh Punting feats and bad beats, which obviously Tony and AK have contributed to. Um it's all for charity, all the proceeds go to uh action for AT.
SPEAKER_02Uh so AT is a rare and curable degenerative condition with uh that appears in early childhood, leave suffers wheelchair bound by the age of 10 and gives a life expectan of just 25 years. So it's obviously a very noble cause. So I've heard the book uh reviewed uh a couple of times now and uh nothing but uh positivity and a good read. Uh so maybe an ideal Christmas gift for someone coming up this uh in the next couple of months.
SPEAKER_03Um Weatherbiz, uh my one negative is Weatherbiz might want to do something about that 22 quid postage and package to Ireland. Like it's not very uh conducive to selling books in Ireland. How much? It was 22 quid to post it. So I sorry I'm going off tangent here, but I know we contribute, and I was like, Do I ask if he's sending? I thought he said that he was sending one out to the contributors, and I was like, it's for charity. I said, I can't ask him again. Like, I was like, I'll have to just come buy a couple. So I went and bought a couple and sent one to my dad and sent one to myself.
SPEAKER_03There's a 20 odd quid for postage and package toine, it's more than the book. So get uh get get one on the black market if you're Irish anyway.
SPEAKER_02Um okay. Well, uh Tony, because we're in a tiny bit of a uh tight schedule, we say this morning. I'll let you away with the racing review, and then we'll uh we'll we'll kick on from there.
SPEAKER_00Alright, okay, low key. Um, yeah, let's start off with the titles uh that we're uh giving out on Saturday at Ascot. Uh Billy Noff uh Billy Lofname became champion jockey at the age of 20. Uh, a feat that hasn't been done that early for about 100 odd years, apparently. Uh, Jack Callan was champion apprentice, Henry Callan was champion amateur, and the thing about all of those uh three jockeys are they're all connected to the George Bowie stable, so uh some feat that.
SPEAKER_00Um, the trainer's title goes to the end of the year though. Uh, and obviously that's a pretty much a straight fight between Andrew Boarding and Aiden O'Brien now. They'd won a piece at Ascot on Saturday, as we'll come to. Uh Aiden leads by 83 grand uh and is around about a twos-on chance to win that. Um, he's currently got 18 of the 32 in the boot run for Turity at Doncaster on Saturday. But uh even if Aiden wins that, I'd imagine Andrew Boulding's gonna carry Chugger along to the end of uh end of December.
SPEAKER_00So unsatisfactory state of affairs, uh, but uh that's how it's playing out. Uh action on the track will start off with uh uh the stuff abroad on Saturday morning. Cayenne Rising was uh unbeaten on an unbeaten run of 21 going into that race, but uh he uh got chinned by Godolphin's tempted. Godolphin had a very good day. Uh an interesting feature of that race was Cayenne Rising paid 104 on the whirlpool, one point 1.35 on the tab, and 1.63 at Betfair SP.
SPEAKER_00So quite the differential. Uh, as was pointed out to me. Um, even though it's 104, that created uh value elsewhere, but uh I'm not sure that's entirely true looking at the uh overrounds and returns for the other ones, but yeah, 104 on the Whirlpool. Um, so I imagine a lot of people went skint uh by Saturday morning. Um the race was also notable for the finish from Zach Purton, um who would have got month span over here.
SPEAKER_00Um I don't know if you saw it, but go and have a look. He um it was a machine gun finish, so we say, and um, but apparently jockeys can use their whip without a fixed limit in the final 100 metres in Australia, and apparently it's the same in Hong Kong. And uh, judging from who you who counted, um 19 or 20 strikes in the final furlong or so, it was Harry said it was seven, I think. Yeah, yeah. Harry, yeah, Harry can't trust me. Harry wouldn't have got that down to less than 10 in the final furlong, I don't think.
SPEAKER_02But um, yeah, Maureen Hagas knew she knew all.
SPEAKER_00Yes. I uh I was gonna say uh one of the uh zak of shit I've got as a as a running uh uh uh headline for uh the name of the pod, but yeah, that was really, really a port. Uh Kingswood won the Caulfield Cup, ex-Irish Horse was over here in 2023. Uh that race was notable for two fallers in the race and one fatal, uh, one fatal fall. So that was uh not great for the uh a big race in Australia. Uh over here, uh Ascot was a triumph of the day for them.
SPEAKER_00Um they had uh 32,114 in attendance, up three percent on last year. That's only just been beaten once uh at that meeting by Frank in Frank all year. So yeah, they'll they'll be delighted at that. Uh, we did have a comment that the one of the only negatives of the day was uh the returns on uh better uh bet with Ascot, uh whatever it's called. But yeah, it's uh as we've as we've seen with uh Bangor Bet and Chester Bet, then they're not exactly uh the most punter-friendly returns, but uh uh I'll I'll try and get the uh the full returns uh for uh for a uh kind of like a more clearer example of what went on there.
SPEAKER_00Uh on the track, brilliant days racing. Uh night in Vegas continued his astonishing two-year-old Hall this season when winning the conditions race. I think he's won the thick end of about three-quarters of a million now. Um that one's Syndicate. Uh Mount Atlas uh notched up a 33-1 winner for Andy Broading in a long distance cup. Uh Almarack looks so he's been retired after winning the group one. Um, I think um Calpana has been retired. Uh, she disappointed in the uh Phillies and Mayors.
SPEAKER_00Uh AJ Bryan's mini hawk won that race. Uh Talker New York was a very good winner in the Group 1 mile race. Uh, and not often I get excited about a horse, actually, but that Ombudsman winning the uh champion stakes was one of the best domestic performances I've seen in years. Uh, it was a hundred remarkable 132 games of the race. God knows what they'll be now, but they must be tempted to rise that uh to rise that because that was an astonishingly impressive performance.
SPEAKER_00Uh, it was a really good day for um John Gosden. He had a quick fire dabble with fifth column in the Bell Moral. Uh Buick wrote his third winner of the day on that one there. Uh, and it just like capped off a great day for Godolphin after that Everest win earlier in the day. And over in Ireland, Aiden O'Brien and Wayne Lord and won six of the seven races at Leopardstown on Saturday. Um, and just a quick add-on action on the track. Gordon Elliott won the American Grand National on Western Fold at Far Hills in the champion hurdle with Lizzie Twigg.
SPEAKER_00Uh, and Kings Hill won the Munster National by Ted Lench, but um anyway, we're still in there pitching when falling two out, apparently. But uh, I didn't watch the race. Uh off the track very quickly. Uh it's quite a busy, it was quite a busy uh week off the track. We'll we'll we'll pull up three stories. Gary Moore's giving up training. Uh he's handing over to sons Josh and Jamie Moore. I think that starts this week. Uh more drought woe, cross-country race at Cheltenham on Friday, uh 13th of November has been cancelled.
SPEAKER_00Uh and other chases, other tracks continue to be scrapped. So uh it's meant to be a very wet week uh this week. So hopefully that will be bring some respite. And what I thought was quite a big story was floodlit racing is coming to Lingfield after the tracks local council approved its application of installed lighting around its all-weather circuit. So there were some um objections there because it's on the uh it's on the runway into Gatwick, I believe. Uh so they they've got that through, and obviously it gives Ark a lot of options about what they can do uh at Lingfield going forward.
SPEAKER_00So maybe they'll get some more racing there because we really need it. Uh but yeah, that's the racing review.
SPEAKER_02Very good. Thank you, Tony. Just uh just a note uh on anyway who fell to last in Munster National. Sadly uh had to be put down or lost his life there, which is uh sad note for the trainer, Ken Buds. Um, quite an unlucky horse. I remember he's unlucky at Cheltenham as well one time, but that was just a sad note out of the Munster National, unfortunately, for a small stable and small yard or star horse. But uh fortunately, that's the way of the game. Uh, sometimes um we will start topics with uh the Fred Doan stories.
SPEAKER_02So Betford made a profit of tax of 39.6 million in the 2025-26 financial year, according to the latest uh uh Bookmakers Council Company's house. But Fred Doan has come out swinging uh with regard to racing's finances. He was on the Nick Look Daily podcast on Thursday, and he said he'd walk away from racing if machine game duty was raised 40% in the budget uh next week. He had earlier said the day before, at 83, I'm probably the oldest in the game.
SPEAKER_02Betting shops have been my life, but I'm deeply worried about this budget. We need to be absolutely clear. Any increase in machine games duty will mean a bloodbat in terms of shop closers, job losses, and a free pass for the black market. Uh, later on the Nick Luck Daily, he also claimed that uh 79% of Bet Fred's profits to government went to government, 10% to racing, 11% left for Bet Fred. So, AK, do you want to kind of take us through the story and kind of nearly explain it from the bookmaker's perspective?
SPEAKER_02Because there are people kind of wondering about that, and then anything else you want to say on the situation?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I think it's a fairly big one coming up um to see what happens here. I think you I'm very negative. Sorry, I know I know you all know that, and I know all the listeners know that as well. But I think if it stays the same, like the the death spiral is is is in full effect here anyway. So um it's just how quickly we want we want to we want to start spiraling. Um I think one thing to say, and I know Harry disagrees with the approach and a few different things, he said it previously, but of all the people in the industry that own big bookmakers, bet Fred are one of the few that will speak publicly on this stuff.
SPEAKER_03And I don't know if that's because whether they're independent and not quoted on the stock market or not, but um Fred's been very active recently commenting, and he's you you see all these stories around the the the response is always oh you're scaremongering, you're scaremongering. But I think if if I had 1700 shops and now I've got a thousand, I think you can argue about what quotes were attributed in the past for how quickly stuff would decline. But it's it's this this stuff is obviously in in fairly terminal decline. I think Bet Fred's I think she's the MD there, Joanne Whitka um has been very forthright in her comments over the last year.
SPEAKER_03She's probably one that has publicly been quoted with quite forthright views on some of the taxation stuff. I think Stella David at N turn is probably the same two two two women have probably stepped up to the plate, and quite a lot of fellas in the industry and at big bookmakers have kind of gone missing. Um I think from a sponsorship point of view, you've seen they've ended the rugby league stuff. My understanding is to give a couple of million quid, don't they, to sponsor the classics. Like that's a lot of money.
SPEAKER_03That's that's that's a lot of lot of money. I'd say you'd be struggling to replace that even for classics. Never mind when it fills through to the to the to the lower end, lower end of the spectrum. I just can't see how I don't know what the rate's gonna be, obviously. I have a mark it up on it, as Ronan said in the intro. Um I just one of the points I would make is I think people get very confused with the numbers, and even we were talking now on WhatsApp about his quotes and things like that. But I was speculating to make that 40 million quid, which seems to annoy people.
SPEAKER_03Like I was speculating that they must turn over from customers, like it wouldn't surprise me if that was near 10 billion, like it like a colossal amount of turnover for in percentage terms, a paltry amount of uh net profit, essentially. Um, if I had a business, which I don't that employed, and again, don't know the exact figures, but just going off the shops and roughly what size I think probably head officers, I'd say they must they must employ 8,000 people, maybe, do they?
SPEAKER_03I don't know. I don't know what the number is that they employ, maybe it's slightly less. Just picking a number out of me, let me ask that. If I employed 8,000 people and I made 40 million quid, that is a colossal business in size and headcount. And when you're altering levers like taxation, like the anti-gamblers straight out, oh, he should give it up then. He's only making 40 million. If I was employing 8,000 people and bloody turning over 10 billion quid, 40 million is not a lot.
SPEAKER_03It's not a lot. I appreciate that. But people listening to this going, what you want about it, but it's genuinely not in percentage terms. You start messing around with the taxation levers and regs, you're very quickly in the negative or close to what are we doing here? So that that's my general opinion of it all. It's like people get are annoyed that an unbelievably entrepreneurial person is making 40 million quid. And I look at that business and go, Jesus, is it worth that effort?
SPEAKER_02Like Yeah. Um Harry, good afternoon to you. I haven't spoken yet, but you want to come in on any of that?
SPEAKER_01Um, yeah, the so the starting point, I suppose, is uh what is machine gaming duty. And anyone who wants to correct me on this is very welcome too. I'm not an uh accountant, let alone an accountant specializing in uh gambling accounts. Um it's the duty that is imposed on the activity of gambling. So unlike most products, gambling is in effect tax twice. You tax it at the at the point of the activity, and then you tax it before the profits made by the bookmakers.
SPEAKER_01Um and the way it works is that you calculate your gross gambling yield over the course of I think a financial year, and that is uh basically winning less stakes. You pay your tax on that, that then goes towards your bottom line, and then you pay corporation tax on that. So that's why this is quite a painable tax to go up. Uh the reason for that really is that you don't you can't really set any costs off against it, which you can with your uh bottom line corporation tax figure.
SPEAKER_01And uh so it hits hard. I think that bookmakers, generally speaking, would be more happy with a higher level of corporation tax than they would with um these duties for that reason. The problem with that, of course, is that corporation tax is a much easier tax to avoid paying through various um structures. You know, you can lease your own IP back from a company on Jupiter and avoid all tax altogether, or you can go and base yourself in Gibraltar from also. So that's why we get a pen and paper though.
SPEAKER_01Sorry, gone for that's why um that's why uh it it's a painful one. I just I suppose like okay, I just feel that we're perhaps careering toward towards a breaking point here, which is um the the clash between uh the anti-gambling sentiments and the realities of uh bookmaking, and you know, speaking particularly for horse racing, which is that uh whether we like it or not, it appears by all accounts that um casino machines basically keep the whole show on the road, category of machines, people seem to keep the whole show on the road, particularly when it comes to licensed betting offices.
SPEAKER_01Should that have been allowed to happen? Absolutely not, it shouldn't. And there are an awful lot of people to be quite frustrated with about that. But it does appear to be the uh situation that we're in. So I think I think we're in rock and a hard place territory. I I I I I personally don't see um any I I think it's gonna have to get an awful lot worse for bookmakers before it gets better. And the reason I say that is I think they're gonna have to see the realities of what's gonna happen if you just rem you know continue to tax um bookmakers to the extent that every one the product is just not one that consumers want to have anything to do with and go to the black market.
SPEAKER_01Um it's not very optimistic uh outlook, I'm afraid, but I uh you know, I think there are an awful lot of people who ought to have seen the way society was turning against machines and that efforts should have been made to try and get ahead of the uh try to get ahead of the curve, but that didn't happen. And um, we are where we are.
SPEAKER_03I agree with all that. I think I think the whole evolution of it is you put them machines in the shops, the bookmakers see it as easy. Money they focus on that stuff or the other stuff. What is often missed in that is then horse racing goes, Jesus, we can jack the price of our product here massively. And that is what happened that's what's happening. Why? Because there are people in because there are people in the shops, yeah. Because bookmakers are making more money. So the bookmakers are making more money. You can really ramp up, oh, we're gonna put up uh media rights at this, now they're going up to this, now they're going up to this.
SPEAKER_03This product that used to cost you this, now it costs you this. Like, that's what horse racing did. Horse racing that's not corrected though, really, has it?
SPEAKER_01No, and other than other than a bit of pushback from funny enough, Fred Done or Bet Fred, it's not there's not been there's not really that's not corrected that, has it? The media rights market. No, but it's very hard.
SPEAKER_03Like I always say, I say about online casino, but it yeah, it applies here as well. Is it's very, very hard, and you've said it about tax as well. It's very hard to put um genies back in bottles. I always say that. Like when it's out, it's out and the game's changed. And from my point of view, erroneously, undoubtedly, in the long term, high street bookmakers got rich and fat off casino products. Like, that's that's undoubtedly true. Um, like you would have seen, like, there was literally cases like Ladbrooks, for example, would have had you could only have four machines per shop or something.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah. There were cases in London where they were opening shops in shops, so they'd have a big footprint of a shop and they'd build internal walls and say that the shop in the middle is a new shop. Like, that's just it's so short-sighted. It's it's yeah, it's the kind of behavior that's gonna come back by it deserves, but this is the thing when you're looking at these big and that's where my frustration is. Like, it's like, what are you doing? But the people that made them decisions just aren't there anymore, and it's everyone else that's in this game for the long haul that ends up carrying the can.
SPEAKER_03But my point would be horse racing saw this happening, got on board with it, which you can say is also probably not a wise move, but then it jacked up the price of its product, right? And then it then it became reliant on the prices for its product. So now everyone horse racing thought it was being spurred by no tax rises. It's gonna very it's it's gonna find out imminently that it's the legs have been chopped out of the game, and the first thing that goes I one of the I do not understand.
SPEAKER_03I might be useless at business, maybe I am. I don't understand how anyone is sponsoring any races. Like, I have no money to do it. I can't afford to do it. I can't afford to go, here's your crap card at Plumpton. I'll give you four grand to sponsor that. Like, I literally can't do it. It's it's so thin. The margins are tiny. And I don't understand. People are saying, oh, he would say that he's holding horse racing hostage. He's gonna not sponsor the classics. I'm like, how is he doing it in the first place? Like the margins aren't there.
SPEAKER_03Horse racing is gonna find out bloody soon. And I think bookmakers' um fortunes are very intertwined with horse racing. Very, very intertwined. And there's a lot of knock-on effects both ways. It's kind of like bookmakers and smart puntners, right? Bookmakers win money, tend to when the outsider wins, but so so do smart puntners. Like the interest, the results they want are often aligned. And I I find that with horse racing and bookmakers, their interests are often aligned.
SPEAKER_03When horse racing's thriving, bookmaking's thriving. I think both of them are in a death spiral. I think it's absolutely doomed. It's literally survive, try to survive the next couple of years. Like that is the situation we're all in here. And horse racing is as well, not just bookmaking.
SPEAKER_00It's really weird, isn't it? Just listening to uh and reading all the articles that come out in the last couple of weeks or so about everyone in racing has to get behind machine gun, uh machine gun, uh machine gaming duty. It's kind of like I mean, after all this is played out, I mean, a lot of people are gonna have to go for a a good wash, aren't they? I mean they they don't really they really don't believe what they're saying, but they have to say it because racing won't survive without it.
SPEAKER_00I mean, you've got a situation, everyone makes a big thing about racing, it's a second biggest spectator sport, it's a massive industry, you know, employs hundreds of thousands of people, etc., which it does, but it could all crumble on machine gaming duty going from 20 to 40 percent. It's it's it's just a house of cards. It's like you said, it's it's astonishing how it's got to this level.
SPEAKER_01I mean, I think the interesting question will be will anyone learn the lesson from this if there's a reprieve? Will will there be an attempt to try and rely less on a product that does appear to have its days numbered in the regulated market, or will everyone just do what everyone's done previously and thought, oh, but you know, I can make money this Saturday? Which just seems to be the approach the entire industry. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Well, one thing I I was gonna one thing I I stuck on the running wall because it just there wasn't been a story about it, but it just appealed to me. Um, I think bookmakers have played a role in their own downfall as regards shops, but you know, we won't go into it here. But why is it that Irish shops who don't have machines, as far as I'm aware, how can they be viable businesses without these machines that prop up racing and the UK betting shops? So, how how how can the business model in Ireland survive without machines, but they fall apart in the UK?
SPEAKER_03It's it's for me for me, and I don't have shops, and I've got a race car shop, but it's open 10 days of the year, and it's a sample size of one, it's a sample size of 0.03 if you're talking per year. It's uh it's it's totally irrelevant. Um, how do they survive? In general, they don't only the closing at a rate of knots over here as well. Um, it's a different taxation model. There's a there's a two percent turnover tax, and uh you pay, I assume they pay levy on um on on profits or something.
SPEAKER_03But I I think that the the taxation is is totally different, and then there's a different culture over here as well. It's it's a more it's more betting is more ingrained in the psyche and racing and this kind of thing. It's more so I think there is more interest. I think post-COVID the the like he he's rewriting history a little bit for me, but our friend of the podge, Stuart Kenny. The reason FOB teas aren't in Ireland is because when Paddy Power were campaigning for more FOBTs in the UK, they were campaigning for none in Ireland, and the reason they were doing that is to stymie the market to suppress competition.
SPEAKER_03Celtic bookmakers, Ivan Yates, 50, 60 shops, they were making waves going into the financial crisis. Financial crisis hit, and one of the things that might have saved them and served some other independents might have been the introduction of them. And when Paddy Power at corporate level were campaigning for and showing no objections to the increase in the amount of FOB teas in the UK, they were vehemently opposed to them in Ireland, and it wasn't uh it wasn't Shuk Kenny will be quoted in the press as saying that he campaigned not to have them, it's absolute nonsense.
SPEAKER_03He campaigned not to give a fucking uh injection of hope to some smaller rivals, basically. That's what they were doing. Um, so it's it's totally different. The the taxation model is different, the makeup of the point is different, it's a it's a it's a it's it's different essentially. Um, but they are closing post-COVID at a rate and not the closing all around us here in Dublin, in central Dublin, never mind, down the country. We talked about powers. I talked to the staff to be at the race course, the staff I know from Benson around the shops and bits and pieces, and uh sure they're all on notice for there's gonna be a big change and redundancies coming and more shops closing.
SPEAKER_03And um it's it's it's it's not all rosy here without the um in furnace, but I think the different rates of taxation is a big one.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and I think that dates back to whenever they upped it from one to two percent, isn't it? AK when it was that 10 years ago, the shops started closing basically.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, you're dead right. The turnover, we mentioned it on here before, the turnover tax went from one percent to two percent. You had idiots like Jim Bojer in the racing post asking for three, four percent, five percent recently. Like, absolute no idea. It'd be like me quoting him a Bible passage. You wouldn't listen to me about that. Like, I'm not listening to him about turnover tax rates and the on the game. Absolute nonsense.
SPEAKER_02Uh so we're moving on, lads, to our next topic. We're just going to talk about Labour MP Alex Ballinger's letter. Uh, he got it signed by 90 other Labour MPs, uh letter to the Chancellor. Um, don't need to go into all the details here, but I'll just read you a passage. Uh it's time to raise taxes on harmful gambling machines. Today, 90 Labour MPs have written to the Chancellor calling for an increase in machine games duty for harmful high-stakes gambling machines. Uh, so Harry, I guess when uh we see these things, these kind of things thrown up by MPs all the time.
SPEAKER_02And I I guess the to the layperson you're wondering how harmful is this or how damaging is this to the industry. Could you give us any insight there or whatever you think yourself?
SPEAKER_01Um it rather goes back to our last question, doesn't it? About the uh approach that seems to now be pervasive. We're in a bit of a perfect storm, money is required by the Treasury, um the reputation of gambling as an industry appears to be at a low ebb. Um, and as it did, whatever it was, six months ago, it looks like easy pickings. And um we have in government, you know, there appears to be a large well, it's not just in government, apparently we're told that it's across across the parties.
SPEAKER_01We saw um something from the Tories the other day suggesting that there was a large uh level of support for uh uh increased taxation uh on gambling operators. It's hard to know what kind of damage it has. We're gonna find is it the 29th, I think, is the um is the date of the budget, is when we uh when we find out. And um you just hope that things are happening behind closed doors, I suppose, that uh that are making it clear enough to government that there is a um that there's a significant cost, you know, that the the approach that is taken by uh anti-gambling is always that there's this pool of money that just isn't being used as is going as profits horrible bookmakers at the exploitation of uh of what they consider to be morons who go into betting shops and place bets.
SPEAKER_01And um that that that why why aren't we just getting our hands on that pool of money? And there never seems to be any recognition of the fact that um taxation is a careful balancing act, and if you overtax something, um then what actually happens is you personally you cause sorts of other problems, but actually you can also reduce the the tax take if you do it badly, particularly when you have a thriving um uh black market, and of course, that's one area that you will really struggle to get any of the anti-gambling types to really grapple with.
SPEAKER_01In fact, they get quite irritated when the black market is brought up because it is considered to be just a sort of um uh uh self-serving argument from operators, and it is a self-serving argument from operators, but as I've said in the past, it also happens to be glaringly obviously true that um money is going to the black market where which isn't regulated and which isn't taxed. Um so we'll see. And and and one answer to all of this is you know, the history of taxation of gambling is always is always when it's got too heavy or it's gone past certain lines, it's had to retreat because you can stop the operators operating.
SPEAKER_01What you can't do is stop people gambling. People will gamble. Um, and and that almost is the most difficult point, I think, for anti-gambling people to accept is that they see it entirely. I think Dawn Butler used in uh uh her article the other day, uh, the term exposed. Um people from poorer communities are exposed to bookmakers as though that there isn't something in them inherently which enjoys gambling. Um, that it that it's only as a result of being exposed to uh the um the glamour of uh of a bet thread on um Halston High Street that they decide that they're gonna go in.
SPEAKER_01And that's not true. So people will people are going to gamble in the absence of operators. I mean, if you got rid of all the bookmakers tomorrow, people are gonna there's still gonna be an awful lot of gambling going on, and just no one's gonna touch the tax take. You know, so um it's it's it's pretty bovine thinking, but it's it's it's for people who are trying to score political points, isn't it?
SPEAKER_03It'd be interesting. Like I obviously not don't desire it to happen, but I like making my whole life has been making predictions and trying to make money if they come true. I think that if that tax went to 40%, I think the number of burn shops would more than half. I think it'd go from about 6,000 to 2,000. Um you'd obviously make less from the doubling of the tax of the 2,000 that are left. Um, and I think the 2,000 that are left, which is often missed by these Neanderthals that come up with these policies and stuff, is that the prices get worse in what's left.
SPEAKER_03The margins just people lose faster with what's left. It's mental, it's absolutely mental. Um it would be interesting to see if they did put it up what would happen, but that would be my prediction. Six would become two, you'd make less tax, and the ones that are left, you'd you'd be ramping up. Yeah, the return to players would be less favourable.
SPEAKER_00It'd be interesting to see if they've actually made the decision on this machine game gaming duty because uh apparently uh there were 15 MPs at Ascot on Saturday.
SPEAKER_03Um presumably they were going to be probably better, not they'd probably better be that's got that. I didn't have a clue what we're gonna do again. No wonder the fuming.
SPEAKER_00But yeah, so yeah, it's uh it's great.
SPEAKER_02Uh just come back to that AK race. I just thought that when is the point that they they actually realize what we're doing here is is is detrimental to everyone and everything because that is obviously what you explained there. Yeah, uh less book less bookmakers, uh prices get worse. That is just way beyond their thing. They can't even comprehend that because it's just not it's just too many.
SPEAKER_03Like I think but when when does it get to a point where oh they kind of say, oh fuck, we this maybe we shouldn't have done what does it what's it gonna take basically for to I think it was Nick Goff on Twitter who made the point that Betfred used to do 10 to 11, 10 to 11 on total points on NFL, which is NFL is genuinely one of the most liquid markets in the whole world. You could have a million quid on something and it wouldn't move a price. Like it's unbelievably liquid. Betfred, who would it previously bet 10 to 11, 10 to 11, and now 20 to 23, 20 to 23 both sides.
SPEAKER_03Like it's those little subtle things that people don't understand, whether it goes five to six, five to six, the stuff that I've said previously, essentially, that that that's that's what's being borne out here. What will move the needle? Unfortunately, what I think it will be is properly increased rates of harm and that harm occurring outside of the regulated market. I think that is going to be the thing. These people aren't interested in numbers, interpreting data correctly, they're interested in knocking on Gladys's door when the next general election comes around and say, I oppose gambling.
SPEAKER_03Oh, Gladys will give you the voter, and then they can then they stay in the job. That's that's the game, that's the game they're playing. It's not about making optimal decisions because they'd be in the private sector if they were doing that. Um, I think what will happen, I think what has to happen for people to wake up here is you have to put stuff in front of the face. Like they walk down the high street and they see vape shops and this kind of thing, and it's visible to them. You present data and explain this is now 20 to 23.
SPEAKER_03Doesn't resonate, I don't think. I think what resonates is a load of problem gamblers appearing, and where did you place your bets? Oh, it wasn't with Bet Fred, was it? No, it was with some crowd based abroad. That's what will move the needle, and that's why I think legal bookmakers probably need to be making more of the documentation when they can of the distinction between what's occurring legally. Like the example I give is the legal market from a compliance point of view and a regulation point of view, it's never been as clean.
SPEAKER_03It's like literally you can't breathe at the moment from a compliance perspective. You can't do anything, like it's we're we we we're regularly having stories here where people are going firms are going too far in protecting themselves and pissing people off. That's their environment, and the that environment is public facing, the reputation's never been worse. Like it's mental to me. It's like the total it's it's like you people are interpreting things in the most it's it's like very, very clean and very whereas 10, 15, 20 years ago, it was the wild west, and reputation was never higher, and everyone was embracing it.
SPEAKER_03It's like I'm seeing things that other people aren't seeing, it feels like all the time, which is nice when you're right, but it's pretty isolating as well.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think Harry's line there is good. Just uh you can stop people, you can stop the operators operating, but you can't stop people gambling. So um look, we'll uh we'll leave with summaries it there and we move on to this Willie Mullins final demand Cheltenham case, which uh which hopefully lead to an interesting chat. So I'll just give you the background here. Willie Mullins received a£1,100 fine, and final demand has been disqualified from the Brown Advisory Nonsis Chase after the horse tested positive for a prohibitive race day painkiller from an unknown source.
SPEAKER_02In addition, Cheltenham has been fined£5,000 after it discovered during the investigation that the race course did not have CCTV coverage covering one of the yards used during the Challenge Vessel, in which final demand was stabled for a portion of his time there. Final demand tested positive for the metabolic of Mabifacane or Mabifacaine, a local anesthetic, after finishing second to Kids Bill uh in the Brown Advisory. So, Tony Calvin, you uh put your hand up to take this one on first.
SPEAKER_02So uh the floor is yours.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, uh I I don't think this has been covered adequately. Um, it normally is the case when you get a very big name with uh medication involved and fines, etc. Uh, it's normally probably maybe not as uh run with as as vigorously as it should be. But yeah, there's this I I've I've just written down some notes about this. Um and and clearly this came as a a great shock to to Willie Mullins.
SPEAKER_00Um I think um the panel said he was visibly shocked when told uh about all this. Um yeah, but the thing about it is me, the well, I'll come on to what I think was the underplayed element in a bit, but you know that the horse apparently got a kick to the jaw on March the 3rd, which was dealt with by an outside vet, and it seems like there's been some kind of like confusion there about what was actually medicated at the time. Um, but the BHA stroke uh IHRB investigation said that the horse must have been administered with the same drug very close to race time.
SPEAKER_00Um and but there's there's bit there's various aspects of this. I mean the CT CCTV went missing um beyond this. I mean, it and again that's staggering. That's why Cheltenham got uh got fined for£5,000. But uh I'll just read out a part of it. I mean, a third-party supplier responsible for the installation of temporary CT TV for the yard at Cheltenham proved elusive and did not respond to several attempts to make arrangement to meet the BHA investigations team to supply the footage, which is just wild.
SPEAKER_00I mean, that is just wild, I mean that is just staggering. Uh, when you when you outsource something as important as that, and they just said, sorry, we've wiped the hard drive and we're not talking to you about it, it's you feel for the BHA investigators there, because where have you got to go for? And it obviously I think that led into the fact that the the BHA, quote unquote, accepted the failure was accidental and one off. Um, but my issue with this is I mean, anybody who's familiar with final demand in the run-up to Cheltenham would have been aware of all the rumours in the run-up.
SPEAKER_00The horse is out, won't be running, hasn't travelled, uh, big drift on Betfair. Um, that wasn't addressed by the inquiry, and maybe nor should it have been. In fact, I'm pretty sure it shouldn't have been, as Harry probably would underline, you can't base an inquiry on you know, on rumour. Uh, but it was discussed a lot up to the build-ups of the festival, and some people clearly thought that horse wasn't gonna go. And in fact, I think there's um a video during the rounds of owner Brian Drew was even asked about it by Matt Chapman on Sky Sports Racing, and he said the horse was A1 and he couldn't understand all the drift and the talk about it.
SPEAKER_03That's a mental video in Furnace. Like, that is a mental video, and you can get people to write columns and do stuff as long as you like. But what I've believed for a very long time is you're never getting told that the true story with any of this stuff, and use your eyes and and uh uh for what you see on the track and stuff. Like, I that is just wild to me. Like, he's either uh Harry doesn't like the word lie, but he's either telling a porky or someone's told a porky to him. This that's the only obvious thing to come out and so brazenly say that, and then some of the stuff that appears in in that report is just shows that that statement is not true.
SPEAKER_00The whole the whole story doesn't really kind of like stack up with a a thousand um you know, a thousand pound fine, and and it it just seems far more serious than people have made out. Now, like I said, nobody wants to piss off Willie Mullins on the road to Cheltenham, etc., editorially. But you know, um the fair fair play to me Ruby Walsh has just started his racing post column as we um as we touched upon last week, and like I said, fair play to him, he did touch upon it.
SPEAKER_00I mean, I I imagine the ghostwriter must have prompted him to do it, but his um his line of reasoning, which I found a bit hard to take, was he said the size or lack of side of the fine reveals how serious the BHA believes the breach was, but a breach was a breach and he was found guilty as charged. I mean, I don't think you can judge how serious a breach is by the actual you know, by the actual kind of like um fine imposed because clearly in this instance uh the lack of CT TV coverage maybe masked the fact that they might have wanted to go in harder, but they couldn't because of that was like just a glaring a glaring omission in the whole thing.
SPEAKER_00Nothing about that story, and like I said, the most important part for me is it seemed common some people must have been aware of something going on with that horse in the lead up to the festival, and then all this comes out. I just think it's like I said, I think it's a bigger story than has been made out.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I agree with Judah. Tony, just yeah, it's I I find that sort of stuff depressing when you can see it's just as I said, there's lie, there's lying going on somewhere here. Uh at some point someone is is not telling the full thing, and I don't know. Racing just shooting itself in the foot. Why can't people be more transparent there? Especially with a big name horse going into the biggest meeting of the year, and uh it's it's it's obviously something's been covered along the way. Anyone AK or Harry, do you want to do that?
SPEAKER_00CCTV footage needs to be needs to be sorted out because I think there's been two other examples of C T V CCTV footage not being available.
SPEAKER_03It sounds like something that tracks should be doing themselves, isn't it not? Why why is there external why isn't the BHA managing that for the 50 or 60 tracks? Like it feels like an important enough thing. Or maybe it's not important if you're getting a grand fine, but it feels important to me that you have to have that eventually.
SPEAKER_01So the the the grand the the£1,000 fine is a reflection of the level of of culpability, basically. The fact that they don't have these issues, the fact that um there's obviously you know the panel obviously accepted the most likely explanation, which was given by I think Mullins is Fed. Um if if you take out the rumors that were circulating before the race, this is really not a very controversial uh finding, in my view.
SPEAKER_01It's very difficult. I I I continue to say it's very difficult for trainers to be um uh uh on completely on top of these things. Uh and this was a painkiller that it appears to be there was talk about whether it was properly administered 10 days previously and whether what its half-life is and all this sort of thing. Um and then there's I think it's a suggestion ultimately that it was on a swab or a wipe of some description um that was applied to the horse. I think that what is leaving out perhaps a bad taste is the fact that so many people seemed to suspect this horse was not going to turn up at Cheltenham and then to find this out whatever it is eight or nine months later.
SPEAKER_03No, I think it is, Harry. I think it's videos like that of the owner coming out and saying, I have no idea where it drifted. This is absolute nonsense. The horse is absolutely fine, there is no issue here, and then you find out in this stuff that it's been treated for this stuff. I can't remember the specific of it. Sorry, I read it days ago, but it's a jaw issue, didn't it?
SPEAKER_00It got kicked in the jaw, and then and then it was kind of like you know, it was obviously being treated after that. And then when they try to say, Oh, that drug must have just lingered in the system, and the BHA come out and say, Well, actually, no, that's that can't be true. It must have been administrated that drug must have been administrated again, very close to race time. It's just it's highly unsatisfactory, and like you said.
SPEAKER_01So it it it it as I say, it in and of itself, it's not, it's it's really not very controversial. But when you throw in that backstory, um it it requires, it's possible that it's there have been coincidences, but it does require some significant, surprising coincidences for that whole thing to um to hang together. And that doesn't mean that anyone who's been charged has done anything remotely improper. I think what I the real lesson to be taken from this is if I'm William Mullins and his senior staff, is I think I'd be carrying out a pretty thorough internal investigation into what on earth was going on with the passage of information around that horse at the time, because you know we had all sorts of people um you know breaking that it was um that the the horse wasn't gonna turn up, and then when you throw this in, it just as you say, it it doesn't look great.
SPEAKER_01So I I would have thought they're fairly embarrassed by it and rather um keen to avoid it happening again. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02I think uh to finish on it, lads. I think what you said, aka is probably the one of the galling parts of the case of the CCTV situation. It reminded me a bit of the Viking Horde, Charles Byrne's case. I don't know if you guys recall that. Uh I think it was back in 21. I was just looking it up quickly here. That was uh Charles Byrne, which uh the horse viking horde was found to have been sedated, but they didn't have CCTV at Tremor um to fully see what was going on there. Uh I think he's got a lot of things.
SPEAKER_01There have been a few there have been a few of those cases. Remember that with where CCTV wasn't, you know, wasn't quite often isn't kept. There was one, do you remember where the BHA didn't ask for it? For months, I can't remember what that was for ages. It was one of those very long-running ones, and the BHA forgot to ask for it, and so it got to its six-month period where it's deleted, and it was just deleted. Um so there have been a few CCTV, but I'm pretty sure it's BHA, not the iShop.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I mean, uh, but not having CCTV, there should be CCTV at every track, and I think there was a big push for it after that, and it took ages for it to be rolled out on every track in Ireland because I remember uh when I was uh I was following up on that story years after it happened to see how it had been done yet, because that's what they promised. But not having CCTV at Tremor and then not having CCTV at Cheltenham Festival, uh at the biggest race course, the biggest jump track around, I guess. I don't know, feels a bit uh feels a bit off. But um we'll move it on, gents, because we're a bit tight for time. Um first move in earnest by the new BHA chairman Simon Cox, who you might have seen on the ITV coverage of ASCA on Saturday, but earlier uh he kind of made his first move, I guess, since he's moved into the job a couple of weeks ago.
SPEAKER_02So former Conservative MP Sir Philip Davis has joined the BHA board on an interim basis as the Race Course Association's member, nominated director. But the Racing Post understands he was not the RCA's first choice. It is understood that the RCA board put forward two names for the two director positions it is entitled to on the BHA board, the uh ARC Chief Executive Martin Curtis and York Race Course Chair Bridget Gearin. However, new BH chair Simon Cox, who had who has his first board meeting since officially joining the government on Tuesday, that's last Tuesday, said to have pushed back against their appointments, as he believed that there would be conflicts of interest due to their race court roles.
SPEAKER_02It's believed that a compromise was reached in order to give Cox the space to decide on the changes he wants to make in the BH's own structure, with Gearin withdrawing from the process and crudis like was saying he would not join the BH board, although his position would be held open. So, Harry, are you uh what do you make of this? Is this um from from Simon Cox's um first move, I guess?
SPEAKER_01Um yeah, I suppose it's uh fairly punchy first move, but the workings of the very top-level individuals at the BHA board always strike me as a uh you know a riddle wrapped in an enigma. I don't I it it is it is so alien to me that the actual kind of personalities involved and what it is that that that there are so many moving parts. I I strongly suspect that none of us fully understand um the dynamics between the various organizations at that level.
SPEAKER_01And I think actually, from what I gather, it it can it that the dynamics can be based on personalities as well. It's not just interest groups, it's that you know people just sort of don't get on with one another and that causes problems. So um let's see the proof of this pudding will be in the eating. Will there be more uh movement and fewer roadblocks as a result of this sort of thing? Let's hope so.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, just one thing. I mean, he was on the opening show taking questions on on Saturday morning. Um he didn't really say anything, but uh was quite impressed with me. He came across as quite measured, quite um, like he had a nice tone. Um he wasn't he doesn't he didn't seem the confrontational type, but then again, he's probably he's not going to be in front of a live audience, you know, behind closed doors, it might be quite different. But yeah, um yeah, I was quite encouraged by what I saw.
SPEAKER_00Uh what what I listened to wasn't a great deal of depth, but yeah, um I was I was encouraged by listening to it was only you if you go on the ITV racing uh actually, no, it's the BHA um Twitter feed, they posted the eight-minute section with Simon on Saturday morning. If you want to listen to it.
SPEAKER_02Yep, okay, we all agreed. Then positive start uh for Simon Cox there. Uh see what happens. Uh and let's do next story Matchbook bought BEDDAC. So Matchbook acquired fellow betting exchange bet for an undisclosed sum last week. The deal is understood to include racecourse data technologies, which provides hardware, betting software, and technical support to Encourse Monk makers and allows them to hedge into the BetDAC exchange. Matchbook said the BetDAC service would remain open for trading until October 21st to allow an orderly transition with customers' accounts open for withdrawals to November 4th.
SPEAKER_02BetDAC accounts will not automatically transfer to Matchbook. So, AK, you uh you come in here on this.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, it's a big enough deal, I think. Um there's probably three exchanges um Matchbook, BetDAC, and BetFair, obviously. I think BetDAC, just because the structure of it probably had a large percentage of oncles bookmakers, uh, definitely a larger percentage in Ireland, um, probably less large, but still the majority in the UK. And just going through the RDT technology, my operation uses elite technology, which I think is superior.
SPEAKER_03So it's an interesting one in the fact that will RDT stay operational beyond 12-18 months? Will um will will people migrate more towards elite? What what is the matchbook RDT opinion? RDT's advantage is they have support staff. Encourse bookmakers in general are of an older breed um and not amazing with computers uh in general.
SPEAKER_03Uh the more younger bookmakers tend to use elite, in my experience, because it's just uh it's better tech, in my opinion. So it'd be interesting to see what Maxbook's approach is there. We've got a lot of staff, they've they've taken a very labour-intensive business, I'd say, but it might have been a labour-intensive business that might not have been uh might not have been as optimal as it as it could have been. Um they're basically buying a lot of liquidity of Encore putt makers and dumping it into their pools, which is interesting.
SPEAKER_03It's interesting to me to see what Betfer's approach will be to that, given that a matchbook and beta combined, if they can get the majority of that liquidity moved over, it'd be interesting to see their horse racing markets might might comfortably surpass Betfer then. Um once you inject that liquidity into it. So that'd be interesting to see what Betfer's response is. It wouldn't surprise me if Betfer made a play to try and re-attract on course bookmakers now that they've got a proper significant rival um and maybe maybe a bigger firm uh in that regard for horse racing.
SPEAKER_03Um, I think Betfer might struggle to do that given the fact that they messed around with so many bookmakers' accounts, the the reputational damage there could be fairly colossal. Um, a lot of on-course bookmakers can't stand Betfur, to be honest with you, and given they've been messed around from a compliance perspective for a number of years and had phones tied up and this kind of thing. So um it'll be interesting. I think Marchbook's biggest headache is going to be migrating customers because they don't seem to have bought the database.
SPEAKER_03Uh, and I think that might be when you move platform or do anything like that, the amount of business that's lost in migration can be can be significant. So it's how they manage that piece I think will be quite important to them. But yeah, it's uh in general, I think it's probably it's probably good and bad in certain respects. It's good because there might be a massive pool of money there, um, which might suit everybody rather than fragmented pools in various places. Um so we'll see, we'll see what happens.
SPEAKER_00I I spoke to somebody from BetDAC, uh, sorry, from Matchbook this morning. I've got some notes here. Um, just a bit of logistics of it. Uh apparently the BetDeck site uh pretty much goes down on Wednesday night. Well, they'd stop taking bets then. Uh they're open to the end of the month uh for people to withdraw funds, etc. Um, the it sounds like Matchbook didn't buy the customer details uh of that customers, so that's why you have to manually kind of like you know transfer to uh or open an account with Matchbook, it doesn't, it's not a seamless process.
SPEAKER_00Um had a question on uh X this morning about anti-post positions. Um that seems quite muddled. Obviously, it's not as straightforward uh if you've got an exchange position as the fixed odds position. Uh, but like I said, I spoke to someone at Matchbook this morning and they just said, look, contact them and we'll go from there. It sounds like that could be done on a case-by-case basis. Now that's clearly not ideal, but um anti-post positions when bookmakers close or transfer their business elsewhere, that's always a bone of contention.
SPEAKER_00Um, I think the amount of anti-post positions people would have had on BetDAC would be minimal. But if you've got a position on the Premier League, for example, or the Super Bowl, I think the general rule of thumb speaking to Matchbook this morning is give them a call, they'll try and work it out on a case-by-case basis. Um but yeah, it's it's it's not a seamless transition, by the way, it's it's sorted out.
SPEAKER_03AK will probably know more than me because because of compliance rules, uh, different bookmakers have you just can't just say you've got BetDeck account, now you've got a matchbook account, because there's different compliance structures in a yeah, I think I think the point was made that um and it it does make sense, is that when you buy a business, so they bought them, they've essentially bought the name, I think, at BetDeck. I don't think they've bought the customer database, but the customer database becomes a lot less valuable because, from a compliance perspective, if you appear in an audit and you're talking about a customer, and oh yeah, he sent them all his docs, and where are they you sent them to BetDeck?
SPEAKER_03Like it's you're almost starting from scratch anyway, and stuff that might have been tolerable to one might not be tolerable to the other, and this kind of thing. So it gets very, very messy. What I would like to see, and I and it won't happen here, but I can see why it won't happen here from that compliance perspective. But I think that when you buy a business, another bookmaking brand, and you buy the goodwill and try and absorb it, it probably should be compulsory that you uh you're buying the anti-post liabilities as well.
SPEAKER_03I think that would solve a lot of problems. Like, what is to stop somebody setting up a bookmaker now, a betting exchange, boosting the price of every team in a Premier League, and it gets to April, and then sell the business, and sure you've got no, you've got no on the the liabilities don't pass over. Like, I think it's I think it's ripe for bad behaviour. It's not occurring in this instance, I don't think, but uh it's ripe for bad behavior that you can set up a business, offer unbelievable prices, and then just before those businesses, those markets settle, just close the business down or sell it technically to someone else without selling the database.
SPEAKER_03Like it doesn't make sense to me that that's tolerable. Um so my my all my dealings with matchbook is they sound a very, very fair if you speak to them on a level and like no issue there at all. And I think if I was a bet that clusterman and I had anti-post positions, I'd be taking screenshots of them now before they disappear, and then speaking to Matchbook about them is what I'd do. And I and I'd imagine you'll be treated fairly, but I I don't know.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, having spoken to them, I think I think they're they're set to be very reasonable here, but it's it's a tricky one when you've got exchange positions when you've been trading a market, etc. But yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah. Okay, uh, let's do questions, lads. Uh first one from Ed Johnson. Does the skeletons' sheer volume of horses now uh sorry, does the skeletons' sheer volume of horses they now have risk compromising day-to-day competition in the national home season? Every national home card card appears swamped by the runners, uh most are favs or second favs. Do you want to take that one, Tony?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, um, I was gonna put this in the racing review actually, but I I I kind of like transfer it to here. Just as a measure of how dominant he's he is and he's going to be this season. He's um he's already had 109 winners this season. Um, you know, it is a very much a numbers game. He's after Pipes record. Uh, but the answer to the question, no, I don't think it's risking compromising day-to-day competition. We've obviously we've got the O'Brien's um on the flat end island, um, and he's not going to be near that that kind of level of domination, but you know, maybe not far from it in in years to come.
SPEAKER_00Um, as regards, is there an element of kind of like um uh is there more of an element to kind of like questioning kind of the the integrity of uh of some races in there? Um again, I don't think that's a runner at all. Um but uh but uh what I was gonna carry on the racing. I was very surprised that the the Stewards didn't inquire into the running of Eile Francais at Foslash last Wednesday, very seriously. Uh when I say officially, I'm sure they must have had discussions with him.
SPEAKER_00But as we say tirelessly on this podcast, if you are gonna have those discussions, the stewards should think very carefully about uh publishing uh publishing them um then in the open, which I think they should do, because a lot of people have seen that ride and thought, yeah, maybe, maybe that's what it's like.
SPEAKER_02Uh okay. Um we'll take a question or uh more of a part question, part statement here from Andre. Uh, the hypocrisy of the bookmakers and much of the racing media in pleading to the government not to raise gambling taxes while many punters have to face affordability checks and bet restrictions. Uh while does have does racing have a plan for the future or is it going to stick its head in the sand as it usually does? Uh AK, do you want to take that one?
SPEAKER_03Uh it's uh it's weird to me that people like people who get restricted from a compliance reason uh would often be very profitable for bookmakers if that restriction didn't occur. Like it's mad that people think from a commercial perspective, bookmakers this is favourable to bookmakers, but they appear to be of that opinion. Um yeah, I don't know. Well, our biggest problem is the life cycle of customers because they get kneecapped too very quickly by complaints in the in the stay and edge.
SPEAKER_03That's the that's one of the big challenges of the whole industry. So it's not from a commercial perspective. Um and then the other stuff we've answered a million times.
SPEAKER_02Indeed, and final question from Simon. I'm pretty sure this is all the one question, not two questions, Tony. Yeah, um, so he's just talking about the layout of uh race meetings over the weekend. So one UK race meeting on Sunday, five tomorrow, or today, even which is Monday. How can that be right? This fellow's on from Fontwest staged an extra meeting when Brighton was on on the same day in the BHA as per to stage an extra meeting. Four meaningless meetings yesterday and Chalmers Day. Surely any two of these meetings could have been on Sunday. Who is planning this stuff, TC?
SPEAKER_00Uh well, the courses are planning the stuff. Um, yesterday was uh was so sparse because Kempton were due to have uh a meeting and that got abandoned and it wasn't replaced. But he Simon's point stands. Uh it actually absolutely madness they had only one UK racing yesterday and and five today. Um yeah, and the four on Champions Day, my poor old Sky Sports Racing had to have Newton Abbott straight after the Ascot races.
SPEAKER_00Uh they didn't have a clear runner on one of their biggest days of the year. So his point stands about there. Yeah, two of those meetings could have been moved to Sunday, but unfortunately, the courses can't make that pay from an attendance uh point of view, or for uh for sending hospitality packages, etc. But yeah, that's one of the that's one of the jobs that Simon Cox is going to try and have to sort out the fixture list, and good luck with that uh project.
SPEAKER_02Indeed. Any other business, gents? Are we good? All good. All is good. Uh brilliant. Okay. Uh just the the the usual sign-off. If you're having a bet this week, do check out the check out the AK Bet's Big Prices tab uh for all the biggest prices on the biggest events. If you're uh watching us on YouTube or listening on Spotify, we would really appreciate if you gave it a like or follow or a subscribe or whatever the whatever the platform uh allows you to do, it helps us to reach a larger audience, and we're very appreciative of that.
SPEAKER_02Uh the lads will be back this time. I actually won't be back. I'm breaking this story to the lads now next week, as in I'm on holidays. Uh uh well-deserved holidays, uh AK will agree. Uh and uh where are you going? So I'm down to the south of Spain.
SPEAKER_00Uh this year, in it, AK. Say that again. I see six six holidays this year. You want to put a stop to this, don't you? I know having a life outside of your company.
SPEAKER_03He's doing well in furnace, too. I need to learn from him.
SPEAKER_02Uh, I'm sure AK will do a fine job in the presenter's chair, but uh the lads will be back this time next week, so we'll uh uh we'll talk to you then, and the lads will anyway. Uh so thanks to them. Thanks to you for listening, and thanks for all the questions. And back this time next week. Cheers!
Send us Fan Mail Intro: Urban Dictionary & Safer Gambling Week (0-2mins) Weekend Racing Review: On & Off Track (2-11) Cheltenham: 3 Days of On-Course Betting (11-17) Cheltenham Issues: Wifi & The Ground (17-24) Inside...
Send us Fan Mail 0-3mins - Intro: No Harry & Worrying News in Oz 3-18mins - Racing Review & Bookie Percentages 18-23mins - Santander Ordered To Repay Punter Loses 23-28mins - Flutter's Q3 Billion Pound Woe 28-32mins -...
Send us Fan Mail Intro: No Chelmsford Betting & Dodgy TV Shows (0-9mins) Racing Review: Breeders Cup Wendigo Carnage (9-23) Good or Bad: Billy Loughnane Weight Loss (23-29) Melbourne Cup: Non-Runners & Calling Of The...
Send us Fan Mail Intro: Harry Goes Viral & Calvin Gets His Luggage (0-3mins) Racing Review: On & Off Track (3-17) The Tote: Restructure (17-22) Race Sponsorship: The Decline Begins (22-28) Book 1 Madness: How Does...
Send us Fan Mail Intro: Inane Chat & ITV Racing (0-6mins) Racing Review: Horses & Growlers (6-16) That Labour Party Conference Panel (16-27) Guardian: Black Market / SIS Story (27-35) New BHA Chair: Simon Cox (35-46)...