Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

AI Security, AI Cloud Ops & Infrastructure | ClearTech Loop

AI Security, AI Cloud Ops & Infrastructure | ClearTech Loop artwork

AI Agents Are Roaming Without IDs. Enterprise Security Isn’t Ready

Oct 6, 202619 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Send us Fan Mail AI agents are moving across systems, making decisions and, in some cases, creating other agents. But enterprises still do not have consistent standards for identifying them, governing their permissions or tracing what they do. In this episode of ClearTech Loop, Jo Peterson talks with Rob Tiffany, Research Director at IDC, about why traditional identity and access management may not be enough for the agentic AI era. Rob argues that the identity problem becomes much bigger once agents begin operating beyond a single enterprise. Companies need to know who an agent belongs to, what it is allowed to do and whether its activity can be audited and traced. As Rob puts it, there are still no consistent standards around agent “identity and permissions and auditability and traceability.” He also discusses an idea he is exploring with Cerf: whether AI agents may eventually need something similar to a global registry, analogous to DNS, so their identity, permissions and traceability can be verified across networks and organizations. The conversation also gets into shadow AI, employee adoption and why the most productive people inside an organization may be among the first to use AI tools before governance catches up. In This Episode Why traditional IAM was not built for autonomous AI agents How software agents have existed for decades, from scripts to RPA Why identity becomes harder when agents create other agents The need for permissions, auditability and traceability across organizations Why AI agents may eventually need a global identity layer How shadow AI is entering enterprises faster than governance can respond What CISOs should be thinking about when AI adoption is already ahead of controls Why productivity cannot come at the expense of enterprise security ▶ Watch on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@ClearTechResearch/videos 📰 Subscribe to the Newsletter: https://www.linkedin.com/newsletters/7346174860760416256/

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Jo PetersonHey everyone! Thank you so much for joining this week's episode of Clear Tech Loop. I'm Joe Peterson. I am the CIO of Clarify360 and the chief analyst at ClearTech Research. I've got a great guest today. I've got Mr. Rob Tiffany, hi Rob.

Rob TiffanyHey Jo, how's it going?

Jo PetersonGood. In case you are not following Rob, you should be. He is a researcher and a director at IBC, and he just wrote an amazing book, which he's going to take a second and tell you about here.

UnknownAll right, thanks for the plug there, Jo. Yeah, new book just came out, many years in the making. It's it's called Saving the Earth with the Internet of Things, and the gist of it, if you've ever heard of the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals, there's about 17 of them. Over the years, I've done lots of keynotes and things and panels where I kind of talked about how I can use different kinds of technology to

tackle some of these categorieshunger, poverty, climate change, life below the ocean. I mean, sustainable cities. And I've been doing that probably since 2019. And I basically said I need to turn all these PowerPoint decks and articles and podcasts and keynotes into a book, and so slowly but surely I piece those together, and so it literally is 100 use cases, 100 recipes that are actionable. Like I can give you the book, and you can go in. You know, you only really you need to read just the first couple chapters that kind of tells you how to use the rest of the book and the rest of the chapters-they all stand on their own. Each chapter is an SDG, a Sustainable Development Goal, and then within there, there's a bunch of use cases. You know, like for for hunger, I've got about 14 different recipes, mostly related around agriculture and water and things like that. And then I make sure they're all understandable. That you don't have to be a techie to figure this out. If my original thinking was, you know, I want to give this to NGOs, you know, working on tough stuff out in villages and whatever. Anybody who like, if you're a ESG or person, you know, sustainability person or corporation or a student, this also it's a textbook. It's going to look like a textbook. It's hardcover.

tackle some of these categoriesIt's big, but it's got questions and answers at the end of each chapter. And so I'd say high school kids, teachers could do that for classroom projects, and then university students, like if they want to do their capstone project around one of them, that's doable. It's also, I you know, probably like you do a lot of guest lecturing at universities. I've had professors tell me, Rob, write this book and do it this way with all the questions and answer key and all this other material, and you could turn this into curriculum at universities. And so that's kind of what I did.

Jo PetersonThat's so cool, and I know that this is a topic that you're passionate about. Actually, you've married, in my mind, you've married two things that you're passionate about: saving the earth and the Internet of Things together. Right. So, in case somebody wants to buy the book, what is the name of the book?

Rob TiffanyOkay, Saving the Earth with the Internet of Things, and it's it's live on Amazon now all over the world and so just just go track it down. But it's big, it's heavy, it looks like something you'd see at the university bookstore.

Jo PetersonAh, okay, my kind of book, my kind of book, right?

Rob TiffanyThere you go.

Jo PetersonLove that. All right. Well, thank you for taking time to visit today.

Rob TiffanyYeah,

Jo Petersonwe're an AI security focus podcast, and I've got three questions in that vein, and love to hear your thinking of them on them because I think that you and I probably go to the same number of conferences every year. Maybe you beat me by a couple, but AI is the topic du joor, so I know you're going to have some thinking on these. So AI agents hold delegated credentials. They make authorization decisions in real time, and they can spawn subagents with their own permission sets. Traditional identity and access management and tools in that vein weren't built for this.

UnknownRight.

Jo PetersonWhen you're thinking about it, what does a realistic path to least privilege access for AI agents actually look like for a large enterprise today?

Rob TiffanyYou know, Jo. Surprisingly, I've given a lot of thought into this because, well, and I'd probably say from two or three different angles. The first thing, you know, when the whole notion of agentic AI started popping up, and all the CEOs started parroting that and saying those words, you know, a couple years ago, whatever it was, and I remember thinking about it, and I was like, you know, we built this agent stuff forever. You could say a a script or a bash, you. Whatever could be a could be an agent, or in my world, since I kind of came through the Microsoft world, I thought of an NT service, a Windows service. It's running in the background. They run in the loop. I'm hearing the term loops a lot lately related to agents. It's because they run in loops.

Jo PetersonYeah.

Rob TiffanySo and so background processes. If you're a Unix or Linux person that's a daemon, those those were the kind of the early agents. Except and then scripts that are kicked off by cron jobs, those are the early agents. But they were not, you know, like generative AI, you know, which is you know kind of dynamically configure stuff out, right? It was always, you know, I'm writing code and it's going to do this specific thing at this time, that kind of deal. And so, asking about least privilege, I'm taken back to building Windows NT services on Windows servers and things at Microsoft during my time there, and even at Azure, we have the notion of some background agents that are part of Azure that have been there from the get go, and it's just a background process.

Rob TiffanyIt needs to do some work, right? And so, how much work it can do depends on what you give it access to, right? And typically, it's like, well, okay, you can talk to these APIs to go do this thing and that thing or whatever. Grab data here, talk to this database, call this API for whatever company and take an action, and so you you kind of declaratively give it permission things. But the least privileged thing, in my mind, I am still here. You know, people are going to think I'm such a weirdo. I'm imagining that on going back to Windows NT and then Windows Server, that kind of console where you've got your background services and you right-click on them and and that's where you give it privileges, and so so many things are based on that.

Rob TiffanyActually, installing a database initially starts just like that. Lots of lots of background, you know, a web server, all those things. They run as a background service, and guess what? They're on a loop, waiting for something to come in to do something, or they're taking action, and so I

distinctly rememberdo I give it system privileges? There was that notion of I'm gonna or I'm gonna give it privileges under me under my domain account, my Windows domain user account, and I'm and so basically it can do stuff that I can do, and so that's a world that sounds very familiar to me. You know how lots of times old things are new again.

Jo PetersonYeah, totally.

Rob TiffanyYeah, and so that hits home. There's another thing that hit me. I was at a conference. It was an oil and gas conference in Houston back in 2018, and do you remember when the whole RPA robotic process?

Jo PetersonOh yeah,

Rob Tiffanyokay, like UI that stuff. Those are agents, and they were designed to take all those Win32 apps that we built in the 90s that are basically running all businesses today still.

Jo PetersonYeah,

Rob Tiffanyand they could scrape along. It was almost remember how we did screen scraping? Never mind.

Jo PetersonI know what screen scraping is.

Rob TiffanyYes, and so and so those were they were agents and they had privileges and stuff like that. And that's not new either. And they were kind of they were more AI-ish, and so they were designed to be able to go and do a work log. Got this Visual Basic six app and a Power Builder app that I'm using to run my company, and it would automatically know how to go through and do the workflow that a person used to do. And I remember being in a session at this event, and some woman from Chevron was talking. This is 2018, and she says at some point we came to the conclusion this thing is acting like another employee of our company, and so we put it into Active Directory, just like we would any other employee of the company because it was carrying out tasks. How does that? But that sounds like anything we'd be talking about today, right? AI agent. It's like, oh, it's an employee, kind of.

Jo PetersonYeah, yeah, it is an employee.

UnknownYeah,

Jo Petersonthat's what's old

Unknownis new. Old is new.

Jo PetersonI guess the thing that's you know we're starting to see, and we got a little taste of it with the whole hugging face incident, is that these agents are creating ephemeral agents of their own,

Unknownyeah,

Jo Petersonand they're giving them permissions in some cases, and so they're starting to do their own thing. Yeah, that's that's the kind of the no bueno thing, right? That's a good that's a good expression. So I will see. We'll see how that goes.

Rob TiffanyThat's the other. That's kind of the other angle. I was actually the third one I was thinking about about that specifically is identity permissions for agents in the wild. Because right now it's the wild west. People are just doing their own thing. Inside their own enterprise, I know a lot of people are talking a good game. They're oh yeah, we've got 1000s of agents running. They don't, but for people who do, there's no standards around how they should have identity and permissions and auditability and traceability and and all the rules for an agent. And so, not to name drop or anything, but I'm going to name drop. I'm actually working with Vince Cerf, who is the father of the internet.

Jo PetersonNo, you're not.

UnknownI am. We're working on this.

Jo PetersonAll hell.

UnknownAnd and so we've been working on this problem together. And I'm sure the path that we're going in. I know other people are working on it, and they're all going to come up with different outcomes. But from his viewpoint, he's not-he doesn't have like this corporate viewpoint of it, or it's inside this world. He's thinking of it like how we manage DNS servers and and hosts and things like that. He's thinking at a global level the idea of agents, and he's like, I want companies to have to register their agents at a global level on something equivalent to a DNS server, and their permissions and traceability and where they go, so that it's not just this closed. Oh, it's inside my domain, my company, my whatever.

UnknownWhich I like that. Who knows if it'll be a success or not? You know, everybody's you got to try, right?

Jo PetersonThat's so cool. But well, so first of all, that you're getting to work with him. I mean, what an amazing mind!

Rob TiffanyOh yeah, he's awesome. He's a great guy, super nice guy, and obviously he's done so much for the world. It's incredible.

Jo PetersonHe has. He changed how we work.

UnknownYeah.

Jo PetersonHow many people can say that, right? So

Unknownyeah, cool stuff. So we're down some path there. I don't know how to land on. All

Jo Petersonright, we we'll have to have you back, and you'll have to tell

Rob Tiffanyus. Yeah.

Jo PetersonSo kind of some of what you were saying leads right into the next question about who's on first. So it's you know it's a little shady, and I want to see hear what you have to say. But 50% of large enterprises now have dedicated AI governance committees. Is that structure actually working, or is it kind of creating the appearance of governance without any substance?

Rob TiffanyI don't want to bash those people. I think they all have the best intentions.

Jo PetersonYeah.

Rob TiffanyI really do. I don't know how successful they're going to be, and it is kind of like what we're seeing instead of this global way to govern agents, and they're kind of thinking, "Well, I work at XYZ company. How do we govern agents? Which is fine. Which is fine. I don't. Who knows how much progress they've made? I, you know, I don't have a crystal ball. I'm sure they're working hard at it. I doubt they've made very many agents to begin with that are doing their own thing, but I no, I think it's good. I think it's good. I think it's good to have committees and put together working groups. We we did that with remember every kind of technology revolution that would show up at the door, like when mobile became hot or the cloud or whatever, and people like, wow, we better put a team together of our best architects and figure out how our X Y Z corporation handles this thing, so it's it's a good start. So

Jo Petersonyou're saying what I'm hearing you saying this is subtext, Rob, is that you and I are vintage.

UnknownWe're vintage. That's what I'm hearing

Jo Petersonyou say is a subtext.

UnknownYou're gonna find me at one of those vintage stores, and I'll be like off the rack kind of thing and really cheap, so we'll

Jo Petersonbe going. We'll have our walkers together going, you know, to a conference, right? Be great.

UnknownAbsolutely. Right. All right.

Jo PetersonSo last question.

UnknownYeah.

Jo PetersonI just walk in the door as a CISO somewhere, and I'm kind of looking around, going, "Oh, they got AI going, but they don't have any governance going on with it that I can see. And what I mean by that is no inventory, no agent-specific controls, no monitoring. And he calls you up and he says, "Rob, where do I start? What should I do first in the next days, what would you say?

UnknownThat's a tall order because what's happening, as you know, is a lot of people, a lot of employees of companies, are bringing their own AI with them. They're secretly, or not so secretly, into to Plot or ChatGPT or Gemini or whatever to help them help with their work, their job, their whatever doing, and they're all doing it. Actually, on the on one hand, the go getters who are probably going to be the most productive are actually the ones who are doing it, and they're probably going. They probably don't think they're going rogue, but but they are. What was the kind of remember we talked about shadow IT in the past?

Jo PetersonYeah, it's a shadow AI.

UnknownPeople bringing in these apps that aren't approved by. It's the same thing. It just reminds me if I go since we're vintage. If I remember back when Windows 95 came in and it was a consumer product, but people said, "Dang it, I want that." On my PC at work, and that's how it happened. Consumer demand brought it into the enterprise, and I think, I think that's happening here. the The problem is you have so much power concentrated in just a handful of companies and a handful of brains that are building these LLMs, the frontier models that people are using. And you're right. You don't know what trouble folks can get into, and obviously, we've seen them get into their own trouble with escaping agents, you know, going rogue on the internet. And so, I, you know, I feel like it's almost like you need an all hands meeting at these companies with a CISO, but they need to have the backing of the executive leadership team, because because they're going to say, "Hey, we got to shut this down. Are we going to do it this way or the highway? You know, and a lot of people are going to push back. And wow, I forgot how to do PowerPoint because my AI is doing it for me. And now you're asking me to be productive on my own. What? Dang it! So you know, you know, like when times when you wanted to do governance like really quickly, remember they would lock down ports on firewalls. Oh yeah, blocking websites and things like that. You know, you can imagine draconian-ish things like that kind of happening out of the gate, but I get it. You can't harm the company while you're trying to be productive, and so they quickly need to figure out do a deal. If you know, lots of companies have done enterprise deals with the big Frontier Labs, and if that's what the way you want to go, do a deal and say you got to go this way. You've got here's the corporate version, you know, Claude or whatever.

Jo PetersonThat's one way to do it. I think it's

Unknownone way to do it. You know, again, like gosh, how many times have we said, "Well, we're in the wild west of insert technology here.

Jo PetersonI know, right? Right. Yeah,

Unknownbut it's it's it's a tough job for CISO. So that next 30 days, what should the CISO do? They need to they need to have that all hands. They need to have the power of the CEO behind them in the company. If it's just send out that email initially, stop what you're doing. Here's how you're going to do it. And so I think they need to scramble and do a corporate version of what people can use inside the four walls of the enterprise, as as far as you know, doing using a chat bot or something like that to help them, or using agents. Gosh, agents is just going to be a mess. There's so much to do, and none of this is going to happen quickly, right?

UnknownNo. And are we? And now, and obviously, with the agents escaping everything, I know Congress is already talking about. You hear the term "kill switch" being yeah kill switch yeah how does the kill switch work?

Jo PetersonI know it is it is crazy times, right? It

Unknownis. I

Jo Petersonmean, the thing that you know struck me about that whole incident as I dug deeper into it and read some of the reporting around it was that there were 17,000 tries, unsupervised tries over the course of a weekend.

UnknownYes,

Jo Petersonright, crazy amount of tries, and so the AI agent isn't bad. It's just doing its job, or what it thinks its job is right,

Unknownand that way that it it may have had governance around it. Obviously, they talked it being in a containment. It's like a sci-fi movie. It escaped the containment vessel. It's like I

Jo Petersonknow, right? And it daisy chained. It was smart enough to daisy chain some things together, which

Unknownwhich sounds familiar, doesn't it? Going after a bunch of zero days and Daisy chaining zero days to like, I don't know, hacks and trifuges in Iran a long time ago. Yeah, I mean

Jo Petersonit's it's it's it's a brave new world, my friend, a brave new world. Well, thank you for taking time to visit. My pleasure. Love to have you back, and y'all, thank you for taking time to listen, and we'll talk to you soon.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. AI Agents Are the New Insider Threat. Are You Ready? With Tia Hopkins

    Nov 18, 202614 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail What if the next insider threat to your organization isn't a person at all? AI agents are moving beyond answering questions. They're accessing systems, executing tasks, requesting credentials, and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. NinjaOne Katana AI: Can AI Fix IT Problems Safely? | Jeff Hunter

    Nov 12, 202621 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Can AI safely troubleshoot and resolve IT issues without putting your entire endpoint environment at risk? NinjaOne Field CTO Jeff Hunter returns to ClearTech Loop to join host Jo Peterson for a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Shadow AI Is Already Inside Your Enterprise | Anthony Russell

    Nov 3, 202616 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Your engineers may be using AI agents your security team doesn't even know exist. Those agents could be accessing sensitive data, handling company code, or operating with credentials nobody is...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Your AI May Be Smarter Than You. Can You Still Control It?

    Oct 28, 202615 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail What happens when AI becomes capable of making decisions its creators can't fully anticipate or control? AI agents are gaining autonomy, accessing enterprise systems, managing credentials, and making...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Your AI Is Making Decisions Your Company Can't Defend with Maribel Lopez

    Oct 21, 202615 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Your company has an AI governance committee. Great. But when an AI agent makes a decision that harms your business, who actually has the authority to shut it down? And here's a bigger question: Would...

    Credit the people on this episode