Conversation w/ Neil Farber, MD, Internal Medicine (retired) and Author, “Treating a Broken System: A Physician’s Cure for the Healthcare Crisis,” about causes for communication breakdown between physicians and their patients, issues contributing to this problem, and advice to help patients have more productive physician visits. Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
[SPEAKER_01]: One of the things that's most pressing upon physicians is the fact that health care institutions are more and more focusing on technology. [SPEAKER_01]: If you look at the commercials on TV or on billboards, they all emphasize what kinds of centers there are, what kinds of technology is available. [SPEAKER_01]: There's not as much attention paid to physicians and because of that, there's more and more work that physicians have to do such that they don't have the time to communicate with patients like they used to.
[SPEAKER_00]: Hello and welcome to AJ Matters, a program featuring aging related topics of interest to older adults and their families. [SPEAKER_00]: I'm Cheryl Beverstor of your host. [SPEAKER_00]: Effective communication between physicians and their patients is the cornerstone of quality health care and directly impacts health outcomes, patient satisfaction and treatment adherence. [SPEAKER_00]: However, recent studies reveal that communication between older adults and physicians is becoming less effective due to a combination of physical, psychological, and systemic barriers affecting both the patient and the provider.
[SPEAKER_00]: My guest today is Dr. Neil Farber, retired internal medicine physician and author of a book called Treating a Broken System, a Physicians cure for the health care crisis. [SPEAKER_00]: He's going to talk about causes for the breakdown and communication between physicians and their patients and issues contributing to this problem. [SPEAKER_00]: Dr. Farber will also provide advice as to how patients can ensure more productive physician visits and enjoy healthier outcomes afterwards.
[SPEAKER_00]: So welcome Dr. Farber and thanks for joining me today. [SPEAKER_01]: Thank you for having me. [SPEAKER_00]: So Dr. Farber, let's set the stage here. [SPEAKER_00]: Obviously, we have a very serious problem to talk about today, but we need some information to get started. [SPEAKER_00]: So help us understand why our communication and interaction between physicians and their older adult patients shifting. [SPEAKER_01]: Well, I think one of the things that's most pressing upon physicians is the fact that healthcare institutions
[SPEAKER_01]: more and more focusing on the technology and various centers that can help cure disease. [SPEAKER_01]: If you look at the commercials on TV or on billboards, they all emphasize what kinds of centers there are, what kinds of technology is available. [SPEAKER_01]: And there's not as much attention paid to the physicians who were the ones who were seeing the patients. [SPEAKER_01]: So they're sort of left out in the cold. [SPEAKER_01]: And because of that, there's more and more work that physicians have to do such that they don't have the time to be able to communicate with patients like they used to.
[SPEAKER_00]: Would you even go so far as to say there's a declining trust overall in the health care system and I know that you often look at data, is there data to show that this is in fact what's happening? [SPEAKER_01]: Unfortunately yes, if you look at one study that was done at the start of COVID in early [SPEAKER_01]: reported considerable trust in their physicians.
[SPEAKER_01]: By the beginning of 2024, it dropped to 40.1%. [SPEAKER_01]: This is a report in the Journal of the American Medical Association. [SPEAKER_01]: And so, yeah, there are data to support the fact that patients are unfortunately less and less trustful of their physicians. [SPEAKER_00]: Well, let's dig down a little bit deeper into this situation. [SPEAKER_00]: Talk about the main causes of mistrust because you're absolutely right. [SPEAKER_00]: I can remember even in my nursing school days that the physician was the person that you went to for every type of situation and whatever he or she said was certainly accepted as gospel and
[SPEAKER_00]: That was what you did in terms of following the advice of the physician. [SPEAKER_00]: What are the main causes of mistrust now? [SPEAKER_01]: One of them is poor communication between patients and physicians. [SPEAKER_01]: Again, because of the workload that physicians have, there are also sometimes conflicting recommendations between different physicians in terms of different specialties. [SPEAKER_01]: the the rise of social media and the internet.
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, the internet is a wonderful thing because it allows everybody in the world to understand the world around them. [SPEAKER_01]: And that's a great thing. [SPEAKER_01]: The internet is a terrible thing because anybody can post anything they want on the internet. [SPEAKER_01]: And if you are savvy enough, you can make it so appealing to individuals [SPEAKER_01]: that they believe that, and oftentimes it's not accurate information.
[SPEAKER_00]: Let's talk about the actual interaction between the physician and the patient. [SPEAKER_00]: Would you say at this time that there's an increasing number of patients that are leaving appointments or the visits that they've had with their physician unheard? [SPEAKER_00]: that they feel like after they walked out the door, they really didn't think that the doctor heard even what they had to say. [SPEAKER_00]: And what does the impact then? [SPEAKER_00]: If this is the way they feel when they're leaving, the doctor's office, how is that going to impact how they react when they get back home?
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, you know, that's a really interesting question. [SPEAKER_01]: And that I know of has done a study. [SPEAKER_01]: looking at whether patients feel unheard or not, however, we do know that patients are more and more dissatisfied with the interactions that they've had with their physicians. [SPEAKER_01]: So one would suspect inclusive in that is the feeling of not being heard. [SPEAKER_01]: But we do know that studies have shown that patients who are dissatisfied with their physicians and again, one would think that includes not being heard.
[SPEAKER_01]: those patients are less likely to be taking their medications, doing what the doctor tells them, etc. [SPEAKER_01]: And that's going to have a tremendous impact on their health. [SPEAKER_01]: Think about the person who has high blood pressure, who is taking medication for it. [SPEAKER_01]: And if they don't feel heard, if they feel dissatisfied, and therefore don't take their anti-hypertensive medication, [SPEAKER_01]: they're likely eventually to develop a stroke, heart attack, or kidney failure, because of it.
[SPEAKER_01]: So it has a tremendous impact. [SPEAKER_00]: And let's think about that setting a little further, for example, if, say an older adult has certain concerns that they're expressing, let's start with that. [SPEAKER_00]: Do you think or is it true maybe that sometimes the expressions of [SPEAKER_00]: concerns that people have with pain or something else is just ignored that it's dismissed perhaps to the fact that well you're just getting old and this is kind of what happens.
[SPEAKER_00]: Does that happen a lot in visits between physicians and older adult patients? [SPEAKER_01]: One would think so, especially with the amount of work that physicians have, and the lesser amount of time they have with patients, so that if the patient comes with the list of 20 different complaints, the ones that are, quote unquote, more minor are going to be not listened to or ignored at least for a time, and those could be very important complaints if you spend the time listening to the patient.
[SPEAKER_00]: Another factor that might also exist is that an older adult is accompanied by a younger person. [SPEAKER_00]: Could be a caregiver, it could be an adult child, and that instead of the physician talking directly to the older adult, they talk to the adult child and instead sort of ignoring what the older adult has to say. [SPEAKER_00]: Have you heard of this too as far as communication? [SPEAKER_01]: Yes, that often times is, okay, especially if you have, let's say an adult child with the patient who sort of captures the interaction, you know, they basically are the ones who are talking, leaving the patient out of the loop.
[SPEAKER_01]: And they're not gonna focus on some of the patient's complaints, which could be really important in the long run. [SPEAKER_00]: I think another thing that seems to be more and more difficult now is why it takes so long for patients to be able to schedule an appointment with a physician. [SPEAKER_00]: I had something like that not too long ago. [SPEAKER_00]: I started trying to schedule something at the beginning of August and found that I wouldn't be able to go and tell the end of October. [SPEAKER_00]: Why is that happening?
[SPEAKER_00]: Obviously, physicians are retiring and you need to find a new primary care physician or whatever and finding somebody who's actually taking new patients is also difficult. [SPEAKER_00]: Talk about getting an appointment and finding new physicians. [SPEAKER_00]: Is this part of the problem that we're dealing with? [SPEAKER_01]: Absolutely, this is something that I experienced myself, even as a primary care physician, you know, you wouldn't expect somebody in the loop would have that kind of problem, and yet I did.
[SPEAKER_01]: And that sort of what woke me up to the fact that I needed to write a book like this. [SPEAKER_01]: And I talk about it in the book, basically, [SPEAKER_01]: If you look at it, there are three things that are causing physicians not to be in practice anymore or not as much in practice anymore. [SPEAKER_01]: One is the fact that physicians are leaving medicine even at an earlier age because they are burned out because, again, they are not able to cope with the amount of work they have, they're either lessening their hours.
[SPEAKER_01]: That's not to doing as many sessions of seeing patients, or the going into something called concierge medicine, or direct patient care, which is a different kind of setup. [SPEAKER_01]: But the bottom line is, instead of a physician taking care of 2,000 to 3,000 patients overall in their practice, they're now taking care of 400 to 600 patients in their practice. [SPEAKER_01]: to be able to get appointments or even see a new physician.
[SPEAKER_01]: On top of that, you have an aging population, and one which is now having better access to Medicare care, which is a good thing, but medicine wasn't prepared for this. [SPEAKER_01]: And so you have patients who also need the medical care not being able to access it. [SPEAKER_00]: You are also an academician and have done a lot of teaching. [SPEAKER_00]: Could you speak a little bit into what specialties medical students choose?
[SPEAKER_00]: Are they becoming geriatricians? [SPEAKER_00]: Are they thinking that gerontology is definitely the specialty that they would like to pursue after medical school? [SPEAKER_00]: Or is that less desirable, say, than some other specialties? [SPEAKER_00]: What are you seeing there? [SPEAKER_01]: residency that was most difficult to get into is the one I did, which was internal medicine. [SPEAKER_01]: I opted to do general internal medicine, but any of the medicine specialties were the ones that were most competitive.
[SPEAKER_01]: Not so anymore, anybody can get a residency in medicine like that. [SPEAKER_01]: Students are wanting to go into resonancies that are less time intensive, but more lucrative. [SPEAKER_01]: So you're talking about dermatology, radiation oncology, or radiology, or some of those surgical specialties, like orthopedics, or any of those. [SPEAKER_01]: Those are the ones now that are most competitive.
[SPEAKER_01]: And therefore, physicians, residents are going mostly into specialties and don't want to do primary care. [SPEAKER_01]: Geriatrics, General Internal Medicine, General Pediatrics, Upsthetrics, and Ecology. [SPEAKER_01]: They are the ones that are less attractive now to students. [SPEAKER_00]: It's certainly much more productive to take care of a younger patient where there's the chance of healing and full recovery. [SPEAKER_00]: Whereas the thought of taking care of an older adult, it's very complicated.
[SPEAKER_00]: You're having to deal more with issues that you may not even be familiar with. [SPEAKER_00]: As a younger person, maybe dementia or some of the other chronic illnesses that older adults sadly deal with, that's not as [SPEAKER_00]: enticing, say, as some of the other things like surgery or even some of the younger health conditions that are more likely to be cured. [SPEAKER_01]: But I don't know anyone has done a study about that. [SPEAKER_01]: I would say if I had to think about it and just from talking with students and residents, I don't think the age of the patient makes a difference unless it's pediatric versus adults.
[SPEAKER_01]: Once you get to adult medicine, 18 and above, it doesn't matter how old the patient is. [SPEAKER_01]: At least that's what I've experienced, not only in myself, but also in terms of the students and residents that I've talked with. [SPEAKER_01]: I think it's more the certain specialty in terms of workload and the lucrative of this specialty. [SPEAKER_00]: Let's get back to that patient visit that we were talking about a little bit earlier. [SPEAKER_00]: I'm even discovering that when I go see my physician and I'm taken to an examination room, I'm waiting longer to see my physician.
[SPEAKER_00]: Here she comes rushing up and saying, wow, sorry for the delay and sometimes it could be, [SPEAKER_00]: 15 minutes, 20 minutes, maybe a half an hour and is that also part of the problem in terms of their attempt to try to see other patients and too many patients and so each one who is there is just going to have to wait longer before they actually get examined. [SPEAKER_00]: Is that a factor as well? [SPEAKER_01]: It's not as big a factor as one would think there are data to show that basically there was a slight increase in average time.
[SPEAKER_01]: that patients are waiting anywhere from 12.8 minutes in 2023 to 13.3 minutes in 2024. [SPEAKER_01]: So only a half minute longer on average. [SPEAKER_01]: But that's an average. [SPEAKER_01]: And different physicians are going to accommodate the pressures they're feeling in different ways. [SPEAKER_01]: Some are going to keep patients waiting longer. [SPEAKER_01]: Others aren't. [SPEAKER_01]: but they're going to be making up the workflow that they have on days, for example, that they reduce their hours.
[SPEAKER_01]: So it depends on the physician. [SPEAKER_01]: In general, though, there's less access to physicians, either because they've reduced or because they've squeezed everybody in one or the other. [SPEAKER_00]: Well, and to that point, it sounds like then the appointments with older adults are more rushed or their shorter visits. [SPEAKER_00]: Sometimes there's an interruption, sometimes even again in my own experience, the assistant to my physician will say, gee, I just need to ask you about something.
[SPEAKER_00]: So that interrupts my visit that I am paying for quite frankly. [SPEAKER_00]: And as a result, it sounds like then there's less shared decision making in terms of discussing what the best outcome should be from my visit, but it's rather well here. [SPEAKER_00]: This is what you need to take, whether it's a pill or a treatment or whatever. [SPEAKER_00]: That all sounds like these are time pressures that are affecting what's happening between the physician and the patient.
[SPEAKER_01]: Would you agree? [SPEAKER_01]: Absolutely. [SPEAKER_01]: You know, when I came to the West Coast, and that was in 2007, we had 40 minutes for a new visit with a patient, 20 minutes with a follow-up appointment for a patient. [SPEAKER_01]: And those are probably enough time and you could expand it if you needed to. [SPEAKER_01]: And that's enough time to have with an average patient. [SPEAKER_01]: But we really had the 40 minutes or 20 minutes. [SPEAKER_01]: By the time I was getting ready to leave medicine, and this is seven years ago, about half of the time was taken up with the nurse having to do things that would bring in more income to the institution because the insurance paid for it, as opposed to my seeing the patient.
[SPEAKER_01]: So out of a 20 minute visit, I would have only 10 minutes. [SPEAKER_01]: at a 40-minute visit for a new patient, I would only have 20 minutes. [SPEAKER_01]: So, absolutely, there's shorter visits. [SPEAKER_01]: The visits are scheduled the same amount of time, but the physician has lost time with the patient. [SPEAKER_01]: And therefore, yeah, there's going to be impact on the relationship between the patient and the physician. [SPEAKER_00]: Obviously, I've been talking a lot about the reaction as a patient, but let's talk about the physician because of course we're hearing a lot about physician burnout.
[SPEAKER_00]: What is meant by physician burnout? [SPEAKER_00]: What are the causes that are making the situation occur? [SPEAKER_01]: These are the things that have been very well researched and I've experienced and I've included in the book. [SPEAKER_01]: Basically what we mean by physician Bernab is a physician beginning to feel like they're just a cog in the system or in the machine. [SPEAKER_01]: They're not getting the enjoyment of interacting with patients and seeing patients.
[SPEAKER_01]: It's more a question of just trying to get the work done. [SPEAKER_01]: And you can see that basically, [SPEAKER_01]: when you start feeling like you're on an assembly line and you just need to get the work done, you don't really have the enjoyment of being a physician anymore. [SPEAKER_01]: That's what we mean by burnout. [SPEAKER_01]: The causes are several. [SPEAKER_01]: One is the amount of work physicians have specifically clerical work
[SPEAKER_01]: interacting with insurance companies to get some of the different imaging studies that are necessary pre-approved because the insurance company wants to reduce their costs. [SPEAKER_01]: You know, all of these things add up. [SPEAKER_01]: Once Teddy done looking at the amount of time it takes a physician on an average day, was if you had everything up. [SPEAKER_01]: including sing patients and all the other things they have to do, it amounts to over 26 hours a day.
[SPEAKER_01]: Now the last time I looked, they were only 24 hours a day. [SPEAKER_01]: And obviously, you know, that's assuming the physician had to do everything. [SPEAKER_01]: Some of those things can be done by nurses, medical assistants, et cetera. [SPEAKER_01]: But a great number of those things actually have to be done by the physician. [SPEAKER_01]: So maybe it's not 26 hours. [SPEAKER_01]: Maybe it's only 14 hours. [SPEAKER_01]: That means on a 10 hour day, and that's more than most people have, but physicians often have a 10 hour day.
[SPEAKER_01]: You have 10 hours in your office. [SPEAKER_01]: You go home, and now you have four more hours to catch up on everything else you have to do. [SPEAKER_01]: Which means the physician isn't doing anything but doing their work. [SPEAKER_01]: The other thing is, physicians, therefore, are drowning and going to administration and saying, help and administration oftentimes looks at the physician and says, you just need more resilience. [SPEAKER_01]: Well, once they looked at physician resilience because of this kind of thing, if I'm that physicians are more resilient than any of the rest of the population,
[SPEAKER_01]: So that doesn't do anything except for the administration going, I don't want to know. [SPEAKER_01]: Those are the things that basically cost physician Burnett. [SPEAKER_00]: Well, and to that point, another term that I learned about, it had some sense of, as well, is something called fragmented care. [SPEAKER_00]: So explain that if these are the factors that are affecting the physicians and the ability to provide the care, it obviously leads to fragmented care of not being able to meet the needs of the patient as well, what are the key problems that can occur for the patients as a result of this fragmented care?
[SPEAKER_01]: fragmented care means that there are multiple different physicians seeing a patient, rather than one physician coordinating all the care. [SPEAKER_01]: So, I, as a physician, if I'm pressured like that, instead of me saying, okay, I'm going to send you two so and so, because they're better at this than I am. [SPEAKER_01]: But I'm going to call them and make sure that you're getting what you need in that we're coordinating the care. [SPEAKER_01]: Instead, I go, goes again, I don't want to know [SPEAKER_01]: because I don't have the time.
[SPEAKER_01]: And I'm not blaming the physician. [SPEAKER_01]: Don't misunderstand me. [SPEAKER_01]: It's just they don't have the time to do it. [SPEAKER_01]: What that means is that patient safety can be a major issue. [SPEAKER_01]: For example, I give the patient one medication. [SPEAKER_01]: I send them to another physician for a different problem because I don't have the time to take care of it myself or they're more expert at it or whatever. [SPEAKER_01]: I don't pay attention to that either I don't know about it or I don't look at their whole medication list and now these two medications interact and cause a problem.
[SPEAKER_01]: That causes basically a patient safety issue. [SPEAKER_00]: a further complication is the fact that if the patient ends up having to go into the hospital, then there's the hospital list who has no clue in terms of what the needs of this patient are other than, say, looking at the electronic health record. [SPEAKER_00]: So now you have a person who has gone into the hospital has no idea who this patient is and only can rely on what's in the record. [SPEAKER_00]: And in most cases, if one does have a primary care physician, they may not even know that the patient has been admitted to the hospital, or even some of the other specialists who have been working.
[SPEAKER_00]: So that makes it even more complicated, especially of certain medications or treatments are prescribed. [SPEAKER_00]: Any thoughts about that, or comments you'd like to share? [SPEAKER_01]: I would agree 100%. [SPEAKER_01]: By fragment of caring, [SPEAKER_01]: they're either referred to other providers or there are other providers as you said in the hospital or in the emergency room or they went to another health care institution which is even worse. [SPEAKER_01]: The primary care physician isn't going to find out about it that oftentimes not going to get the information unless they studiously go through every patient's chart on a regular basis which is just impossible.
[SPEAKER_00]: we've been talking primarily about physicians, if somebody also sees a nurse practitioner or maybe a physician assistant, that makes it even more complicated because all of these people are treating this one patient and the chances are they're not necessarily looking at the chart, which let's go to that now because that's another factor that we're dealing with the electronic health record. [SPEAKER_00]: as opposed to those days and again, I'm always reflecting on my own nursing school days when I saw the physician writing physician notes or I wrote nursing notes, but now everything is electronic.
[SPEAKER_00]: Talk about that because that's such a new situation for older adults to see this electronic health record, which is either in the office as the patient is being seen by the [SPEAKER_00]: How has that affect a patient care? [SPEAKER_00]: Oh, come. [SPEAKER_01]: You know, it was designed to be an improvement for both the patient and the physician. [SPEAKER_01]: Because here was a vault, if you will, where all the patient information could be stored.
[SPEAKER_01]: And that's true. [SPEAKER_01]: It is all there. [SPEAKER_01]: The problem is too faulty. [SPEAKER_01]: is difficult to enter the information into the progress record. [SPEAKER_01]: Initially, you had to type everything out, which was very cumbersome. [SPEAKER_01]: Now they have speech recognition technology and even going to AI. [SPEAKER_01]: But both speech recognition technology, meaning you dictate and it comes up in the record. [SPEAKER_01]: or AI, where just the interaction is captured by AI in place to the record.
[SPEAKER_01]: Both of those have a large number of errors that are made, and so the position has to be very careful to then edit the note. [SPEAKER_01]: which takes time. [SPEAKER_01]: The good thing is that anybody can access it. [SPEAKER_01]: But again, accessing it is difficult because of the fact that you have to log in, you have to get the patient's ID, et cetera. [SPEAKER_01]: And then different information is stored in different tosses, if you well, in the record. [SPEAKER_01]: and trying to manipulate that can be difficult and time-consuming.
[SPEAKER_01]: So it's not as easy to get to. [SPEAKER_01]: So basically it was a great idea, but it wasn't really well thought out. [SPEAKER_01]: Let's put it that way. [SPEAKER_01]: And it's just been things added one on top of the other to try and make it better and is only made it more cumbersome. [SPEAKER_00]: And if a physician or some other kind of health care provider is trying to access these records and they have so many patients, it's a time-consuming job to do that login process and all the things that you just described on so many patient records in a day or a week or a month.
[SPEAKER_00]: Another aspect that's now available for patients are these patient portals. [SPEAKER_00]: What are your thoughts about patient portals, you know, I can get in touch with my doctor while I'm sitting here at my desk and indicate some follow-up issues that I'm having or whatever. [SPEAKER_00]: Is that really helpful to me, to the doctor, to use these portals? [SPEAKER_00]: Does that accomplish as much as if I made an appointment? [SPEAKER_00]: What are your thoughts about patient portals?
[SPEAKER_01]: because it allows patients to communicate with their physician and physician to communicate with the patient. [SPEAKER_01]: A great idea. [SPEAKER_01]: There are two things to think about. [SPEAKER_01]: My physician sent a message to me. [SPEAKER_01]: Let's say they just saw me and I was having some issue. [SPEAKER_01]: And they were concerned that maybe the medical issue was one part of it, but maybe I was having psychological issues too. [SPEAKER_01]: And they want to find out how I'm doing. [SPEAKER_01]: So they type in, how are you doing today?
[SPEAKER_01]: And my response is, I'm fine, just fine. [SPEAKER_01]: OK, I can say that one of two ways. [SPEAKER_01]: And that's what I type in. [SPEAKER_01]: And they say, oh, he's fine. [SPEAKER_01]: Well, I could be saying, I'm fine. [SPEAKER_01]: Just fine. [SPEAKER_01]: Or I could be saying, I'm fine, just fine. [SPEAKER_01]: in which case it's clearly that I'm depressed, you don't get that, you don't see that. [SPEAKER_01]: So that's one of the problems.
[SPEAKER_01]: The other problem is patient portals have a lab patient to message their physicians and that, again, adds more work for the physician. [SPEAKER_01]: So in that sense, it's problematic. [SPEAKER_00]: Right. [SPEAKER_00]: In fact, I remember years ago, I had a primary care physician who actually made telephone calls rather than the patient portal, but obviously that now does not exist. [SPEAKER_00]: And so there's still is not that opportunity for the physician even to listen to the patient, which he or she could do, at least if they listened on the telephone, whereas the portal is pretty non-committal
[SPEAKER_01]: And yes, you know, anytime you're in the hospital, one of the nurses follows up to make sure you're doing okay. [SPEAKER_01]: But again, they're not trained as well to determine that and they don't know the patient often. [SPEAKER_01]: So they may not be able to see that Neil Farber, who's usually all happy and joking around and stuff is suddenly, you know, a much quieter. [SPEAKER_00]: I wanted to turn to another aspect that I believe is part of what we're talking about here in terms of physician patient communication, and that is how physicians talk with patients.
[SPEAKER_00]: Help us understand, first of all, if medical schools actually adequately train the students how to talk with patients. [SPEAKER_00]: What does that look like? [SPEAKER_00]: What is the current practice to help these students who are now in this new position to actually interact and get the information they need to their patients? [SPEAKER_01]: So yes, in terms of medical students, the licensing commission on medical education for less maybe 20 years has demanded that all medical schools include a curriculum,
[SPEAKER_01]: devoted to basically communicating with patients. [SPEAKER_01]: So that's open-ended communication and patient-centered communication. [SPEAKER_01]: Asking a question and listening to what the patient has to say. [SPEAKER_01]: Share decision making. [SPEAKER_01]: the physician listing everything out in terms of options for treatment of the patient, the goods and bads of each one, and then the physician's recommendation, but the patient and the physician coming together and making a decision about what's going to happen.
[SPEAKER_01]: Cultural sensitivity, so learning how to interact with patients who are not your [SPEAKER_01]: giving bad news, boundaries in the Dr. [SPEAKER_01]: Patient Relationship. [SPEAKER_01]: There's a whole host of things that I go into also in the book that medical students now are taught about and are required to be taught about. [SPEAKER_00]: Is there also an opportunity? [SPEAKER_00]: I mean, it's one thing maybe to learn textbook learning.
[SPEAKER_00]: But is there also perhaps as part of the learning process to do roleplay [SPEAKER_00]: patients with certain diseases so that not only are you verbally interacting, but what are the non-verbal cues you mentioned listening and maybe even going so far as to consider empathy depending on what the diagnosis is. [SPEAKER_00]: Talk about that. [SPEAKER_01]: Yes, in the answer to the standardized patients.
[SPEAKER_01]: I don't know if every medical school has a standardized patient repertoire. [SPEAKER_01]: I know that basically the medical school where I was teaching on the West Coast, yes, had a very active standardized facility and standardized patients who were hired by the institution [SPEAKER_01]: So here, yes, and I suspect most medical stools now have that.
[SPEAKER_01]: And you're right. [SPEAKER_01]: I mean, obviously a physician has to be sensitive to not only verbal cues, but also nonverbal cues, as I said the one about, you know, I'm fine just fine. [SPEAKER_01]: It's a sort of nonverbal cue or just looking down all the time, you know, again, nonverbal cue as to being depressed. [SPEAKER_01]: And empathy is something that's extremely important, especially, as you said, when giving bad news. [SPEAKER_01]: And that is the entire concept of how to give Ben News, including empathy, is now taught actively in most medical schools.
[SPEAKER_00]: Well, and let's talk about that because you also mentioned that in your book. [SPEAKER_00]: And I don't know how much you would like to share, but in terms of breaking bad news or [SPEAKER_00]: This is a very special ability that physicians need to be able to convey and express with patients. [SPEAKER_00]: As part of this training of learning how to talk with patients, do physicians, [SPEAKER_00]: get specialized empathetic tools or ways that they're taught as to how to convey bad news or end-of-life care to their patients.
[SPEAKER_00]: Help us understand more about your experience. [SPEAKER_00]: What physicians really need to know? [SPEAKER_01]: I spent my entire career being active in the area of communication skills. [SPEAKER_01]: I never was taught about how to give bad news because we didn't know how to. [SPEAKER_01]: It was only in the early 90s that this guy named Robert Buckman in 1992 came out with a book called Breaking Bad News about how to do this effectively.
[SPEAKER_01]: maybe at that cave before it really got incorporated into most teaching facilities. [SPEAKER_01]: It is now taught everywhere. [SPEAKER_01]: My experience that led me to look for this was in 1997, my wife was diagnosed with brain cancer, and the way we were informed was so terrible. [SPEAKER_01]: I talked about it in the book, I don't want to go into the whole story, but it was so terrible.
[SPEAKER_01]: that I began thinking there's got to be a better way and then I found Buckman's book and he also wrote a short article sort of condensing the book into sort of an easy to use guide and he calls it the spikes protocol which is something that we all now use in breaking bad news. [SPEAKER_01]: and part of it as being empathetic and that's another skill that basically we teach using standardized patients after teaching his students how to be empathetic.
[SPEAKER_01]: Not sympathetic, not feeling emotions that the patient has, but understanding the emotions that the patient has. [SPEAKER_00]: In your experience and Dr. Farber, do you think that all physicians learned about these tools and how to use them, or is there still sort of a disconnect because of all the factors we talked about earlier in the interview that compete, that even in this very serious time when [SPEAKER_00]: the physician really needs to be sensitive to their patients that these physicians really have the training and the knowledge and the tools to do what needs to be done in those situations.
[SPEAKER_00]: What do you think? [SPEAKER_01]: So I think anybody who has trained within the last 15 or 20 years has these tools. [SPEAKER_01]: I think most people keep them not everybody, some people because of the speciality they go into or because they're getting busier, don't pay attention to those tools. [SPEAKER_01]: But I myself had an experience where somebody used that tool on me. [SPEAKER_01]: And I was grateful that they did.
[SPEAKER_01]: It was somebody in an emergency room. [SPEAKER_01]: They were a friend, but they had been trained well and knew what to do. [SPEAKER_01]: I had a penicitis. [SPEAKER_01]: They did a CT scan to make sure it was just a penicitis. [SPEAKER_01]: And it there was a four centimeter tumor that looked like it was probably cancer. [SPEAKER_01]: And he broke that bad news to me very effectively. [SPEAKER_00]: You obviously have sat on both sides of the bench, so to speak, in terms of being a physician, as well as a patient.
[SPEAKER_00]: So, you were certainly the right person to write this book. [SPEAKER_00]: Another situation that I think often occurs in may impact physician patient communication is complex medical terms. [SPEAKER_00]: Do you find that doctors may tend to use these medical terms instead of plain language that is more appropriate for a patient's health literacy level [SPEAKER_00]: Is this something also that medical students are taught or other kinds of healthcare providers or should be taught so that people really understand when they leave the room what it was that they have in terms of diagnosis or treatment?
[SPEAKER_00]: What are your thoughts on that? [SPEAKER_01]: You know, we tell a different dialect. [SPEAKER_01]: Not a different language, but a different dialect. [SPEAKER_01]: It's still English, but it's one that patients don't understand. [SPEAKER_01]: And I have a particular way I introduce it to students. [SPEAKER_01]: I put up on the board a term from 1970's CBT Blangwich, you know, the trucker language. [SPEAKER_01]: And none of them get it. [SPEAKER_01]: And then I say, here's what this means.
[SPEAKER_01]: The sentences, there's a bear on 15 in a plain wrapper, doing flip-flops handing out green stamps. [SPEAKER_01]: It's like, what are you talking about? [SPEAKER_01]: Well, the answer is, there's a, I wipe trauma in a unmarked police car straddling the median, going on both sides of the road, handing out speeding tickets. [SPEAKER_01]: And none of them get that. [SPEAKER_01]: So that's the way I introduce it. [SPEAKER_01]: And then I said, that's jargon.
[SPEAKER_01]: And you've got to translate for your patients. [SPEAKER_01]: When you talk about a NLP, they're not going to know what you're talking about. [SPEAKER_01]: That's a limbar puncture, meaning a spinal tap. [SPEAKER_01]: And you've got to say that. [SPEAKER_01]: So that's what I do. [SPEAKER_01]: I don't know how often somebody teaches them that. [SPEAKER_01]: I'm one of the ones that is particularly sensitive to it because of my learning. [SPEAKER_01]: I suspect it's not usually taught a lot. [SPEAKER_00]: I would add, oftentimes, even the anatomy and physiology, people are not always necessarily familiar with, you know, if somebody broke their arm, what the arm bone is or the hip bone or the leg bone, this kind of thing, and I would also add, and this is my own, again, observation from my own nursing days, is that at the time when I was being trained, most
[SPEAKER_00]: Whereas over time, now we have all these generic names that are so complicated, and if there's some indication of, please be careful if you're taking this and this, which are all generic names, which you can hardly pronounce. [SPEAKER_00]: never mind understand what they are and then you're not supposed to take them because of side effects and this kind of thing. [SPEAKER_00]: And I would even add one more thing. [SPEAKER_00]: I just had a couple of medications recently where I pulled out the insert.
[SPEAKER_00]: And it was so complicated, it looked like a term paper of somebody who was doing research on a particular pharmaceutical product. [SPEAKER_00]: I could hardly find out what the reasons for taking the medication never mind side effects and things that I needed to be concerned about. [SPEAKER_00]: It is incredibly complicated. [SPEAKER_00]: And [SPEAKER_00]: I don't know if you have any thoughts about how the whole pharmaceutical and medicine prescriptions have changed over time, be glad to have you shared your thoughts about that.
[SPEAKER_01]: like not only cancer, other inflammatory diseases, migraines, you name it. [SPEAKER_01]: There's a biologic, now available. [SPEAKER_01]: People ask me, should I take this? [SPEAKER_01]: It's like, I have no idea what it is. [SPEAKER_01]: So yeah, and I was a physician for 40 years, but retired seven years ago, now there's all kinds of stuff. [SPEAKER_01]: I think you're right. [SPEAKER_01]: need to be careful about how they're presenting information.
[SPEAKER_01]: Okay, write everything out like that, but then include another slip of paper in with the medication that details it in playing language so that the average patient can understand it. [SPEAKER_01]: I think that's something that should be done. [SPEAKER_01]: I agree. [SPEAKER_00]: One other term that I think our listeners should understand and that's informed consent. [SPEAKER_00]: Explain to us why our physicians ethically and legally required to engage in the process of informed consent for any procedure that they propose to a patient.
[SPEAKER_00]: What should our listeners know about that? [SPEAKER_01]: So informed consent means that the physician has the obligation of informing the patient of all the different options available, not only the one they recommend, but any alternatives and the risks and benefits of each of those alternatives as well as doing nothing. [SPEAKER_01]: And once they carefully explain all that, making sure that the patient is able to consent
[SPEAKER_01]: that they have the cognitive ability to do so. [SPEAKER_01]: The reason for that is because there is only one person who can consent to any kind of procedure. [SPEAKER_01]: And that is the person who is going to be undergoing that procedure. [SPEAKER_01]: The physician cannot approve it for them unless they are incapable of making a decision. [SPEAKER_01]: their loved one, their friend, whoever does not have the right to do that, it's only the pension because.
[SPEAKER_01]: And that's from an ethical, as well as legal point of view, because we are the ones who have control of our own selves, and we're the ones who have to make that decision. [SPEAKER_00]: And let's talk about how we can address this issue. [SPEAKER_00]: So let's start with the patients. [SPEAKER_00]: Why should patients speak up and express their priorities for care during physician visits? [SPEAKER_01]: That is so that the physician gets to know them. [SPEAKER_01]: and gets to know what their values are.
[SPEAKER_01]: It sort of speeds up the process of informed consent, but more importantly, the physician then understands, oh, this person, you know, they may or may not have a living will, but this person is telling me they would never want to be on a ventilator, or that they would never want CPR. [SPEAKER_01]: Okay, so now I know that, and I can put that in a record, so that basically, when they come in, [SPEAKER_00]: Is that true in terms of any kind of do not resuscitate and any other procedures, too?
[SPEAKER_00]: Like, if one is 90 years old, they probably don't want to call anoscopy and those kind of thing. [SPEAKER_00]: That's just one thought. [SPEAKER_00]: But I'm just wondering if it's not only end of life care, but even in terms of other treatments that may be [SPEAKER_00]: given to somebody when they're younger in terms of prevention may not necessarily be as worthwhile to do or needed as a person gets older. [SPEAKER_01]: I'm laughing because recently my PCP did a call of guard on me and it came up positive.
[SPEAKER_01]: And so I had to have colonoscopy and there were a bunch of polyps. [SPEAKER_01]: And so they did another colonoscopy like a year later to make sure that they got everything and that there was nothing bad, and that was okay. [SPEAKER_01]: I just had a few months ago, and he said, and I'm 75, and he said, okay, so everything looks good. [SPEAKER_01]: So five years for the next one. [SPEAKER_01]: And I'm thinking, Edie, I don't think so, bud,
[SPEAKER_01]: Not that I want to die, I don't, but at 80, I'm not thinking that I really need a goal. [SPEAKER_01]: And I'll ask, be especially since it would just benign polyps and you got all of them. [SPEAKER_01]: And nothing's going to happen in the next 10 years and I'd be 90 then. [SPEAKER_01]: So forget it. [SPEAKER_00]: And I think that's a good point, Dr. Farber, because, you know, if you have some medical knowledge or health experience, you can make those decisions, but sometimes it's very difficult. [SPEAKER_00]: Tell us why it's so important for patients to learn how to ask questions and the right questions or advocate for themselves without feeling like a difficult patient.
[SPEAKER_00]: I think sometimes we older adults think, oh, you don't want to hurt their feelings or G, I don't know whether I really want to get a second opinion because my doctor would really be offended if I found out that I'd gone to another physician. [SPEAKER_00]: talk about that because I think we older adults need to understand why it's okay to ask questions and it's okay to get a second opinion because again we're looking out for ourselves. [SPEAKER_01]: Any physician worth their salt is going to be grateful that the patient has questions because then they are sure that the patient is getting it or that they don't get it and so they
[SPEAKER_01]: for second opinions, everybody has a right to another opinion. [SPEAKER_01]: Physicians shouldn't be offended by that. [SPEAKER_01]: If their ego is so fragile that they can accept the fact that a patient is asking for a second opinion, the better go back to medical school and learn how to do it. [SPEAKER_01]: because, basically, again, patients have the right to another opinion, and it's not anything on the physician, but the patient only has one life. [SPEAKER_01]: The physician takes care of 2,000, 3,000 patients, but there's only one you, and you have the right to be able to ask questions, get a second opinion, do what you need to do, to make your life as complete, better, long-living as possible.
[SPEAKER_00]: And I think as P.S. [SPEAKER_00]: to that response, I would say that in some cases it's not a bad idea to bring someone along either of caregiver or care partner or an adult child as long as again it's the interest of the [SPEAKER_00]: patient, the older adult patient who's getting the attention, but it helps catch everything that needs to be understood as far as follow-up care or whatever the diagnosis is and writing things down as well.
[SPEAKER_01]: There's a couple of other tips. [SPEAKER_01]: If I may, one is bring a list of your issues, your problems, questions, concerns, with you to the physician. [SPEAKER_01]: The physician may now have the time to address all of them in one visit. [SPEAKER_01]: multiple visits do that, but eventually you can have them all addressed. [SPEAKER_01]: And this way, he has a list of the things that he knows he has to go over, and the ones that are important he may pick out to do first.
[SPEAKER_01]: The other thing is, in terms of bringing somebody with you, not everybody has the ability to do that. [SPEAKER_01]: People are busy. [SPEAKER_01]: If you're driving to an appointment or getting a bus to the appointment or whatever, [SPEAKER_01]: someone may not be able to be there with you. [SPEAKER_01]: That's okay. [SPEAKER_01]: The physician should be accepting of doing either a phone call or a Zoom call, or you bringing a recorder to record it. [SPEAKER_01]: Any of those are okay. [SPEAKER_01]: When I had to have my kidney out, I'm a physician, I know to stuff, but it's always fraught with enough emotion that I wanted to be sure there
[SPEAKER_01]: to make sure, yep, this is what should be done, or yep, Neil, I know you, this is what you would want. [SPEAKER_01]: And so when I met with my neurologist for the first time, who is going to take out part of my kidney, or the whole kidney, depending on what I decided on, my daughter was on the telephone with me with him. [SPEAKER_01]: He accepted that. [SPEAKER_01]: And so she was listening in, I [SPEAKER_01]: Interacted, I said, Jackie, my daughter.
[SPEAKER_01]: Does that sound reasonable to you? [SPEAKER_01]: She said, yeah, that's what you would want. [SPEAKER_01]: It said, good, okay, so it was conferred. [SPEAKER_00]: Well, and what I'm hearing you also say, Dr. Farbert, is that it's really a shared decision-making process. [SPEAKER_00]: And as we're talking about solutions in better ways to address this issue of communication, would you agree or at least speak to a shared decision-making between the physician and the patient as an important solution to deciding what the best treatment option is?
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, absolutely, you know, physicians used to be paternalistic and make the decisions for the patient. [SPEAKER_01]: That's absolutely unacceptable. [SPEAKER_01]: And then we shifted to the 1970s where it was a rise of, you know, everybody having their own right and physicians would go, we could do this or this, which one do you want? [SPEAKER_01]: and explaining everything, you know, the pros and cons and whatever. [SPEAKER_01]: And patient would say, well, what do you think? [SPEAKER_01]: In a physician said, nope, I can't tell you, you want this or this.
[SPEAKER_01]: Now we know the best way of doing it is saying, there's this or this, here's the pros and cons of all of them. [SPEAKER_01]: My recommendation would be this one, but what do you think? [SPEAKER_00]: Well, we're just about out of time. [SPEAKER_00]: Gosh, we've talked with about so many different things here. [SPEAKER_00]: And many issues that pertain to the healthcare system, that impact the, of course, the physician patient, communication.
[SPEAKER_00]: What are your thoughts? [SPEAKER_00]: You wrote this book now. [SPEAKER_00]: Do you believe that these issues can be adequately addressed? [SPEAKER_00]: You've given some recommendations in terms of what might happen or what could happen to make things better. [SPEAKER_00]: Let's look more globally of what your thoughts are and what you've shared in your book as to how this can happen. [SPEAKER_01]: So, you know, when I first thought about writing the book, I'd gone through everything realized there was a healthcare crisis and thought, you know, no one's figured out and then looked at the different things that have been tried and nothing really
[SPEAKER_01]: They worked somewhat, but the patient was hurt, not really hurt, but it was kind of not paid attention to when the decisions were made and it wasn't in their best interest and it went, well, I'm not going to write a book. [SPEAKER_01]: How can I write a book? [SPEAKER_01]: I don't have an answer. [SPEAKER_01]: And then I started looking and lo and behold, there is an answer. [SPEAKER_01]: The answer is, [SPEAKER_01]: I give it away because I want people to buy the book because I give all kinds of tips and I think that's really important.
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm not keeping any of their money from the book. [SPEAKER_01]: I'm giving it to charity. [SPEAKER_01]: I want people to know that a little bit of it I have to keep for the promotion that I did for the book. [SPEAKER_01]: But other than that, I'm giving it all away. [SPEAKER_01]: Because my message is really what's important to me. [SPEAKER_01]: But I realize there is an answer, and that is basically physicians, administrators, patients only to come together, to sit down together, to listen to each other, and to allow physicians and patients together, to make the decisions with administrators backing them up, giving them the things they need to make changes.
[SPEAKER_01]: and then continuing that process. [SPEAKER_01]: That actually worked at the Mayo Clinic. [SPEAKER_01]: Physicians were terribly burned out. [SPEAKER_01]: They had physicians and administrators sit down together. [SPEAKER_01]: The administrators listened to what the problems were. [SPEAKER_01]: They allowed the physicians to make change with a administrator backache. [SPEAKER_01]: Burnout was gone. [SPEAKER_01]: Solutions were found. [SPEAKER_01]: And the patients were happy. [SPEAKER_01]: The physicians were happy. [SPEAKER_01]: The administrators were happy
[SPEAKER_01]: The other side of that is, okay, you do that. [SPEAKER_01]: You give the physicians more time to be with their patients, which is really what they want. [SPEAKER_01]: And be able to have a home life too. [SPEAKER_01]: But also they need more training in communication skills. [SPEAKER_01]: And so that would be an add-on that I think, [SPEAKER_01]: Once you make the change, so the physicians have time. [SPEAKER_01]: They have time to see their patients. [SPEAKER_01]: They have time to do training. [SPEAKER_01]: They have time to be at home.
[SPEAKER_01]: The time for training will be training in communication skills. [SPEAKER_00]: Any final comment you wanted to make? [SPEAKER_01]: The book I believe should already be out. [SPEAKER_01]: It'll be out on October 5th. [SPEAKER_01]: So I think it will be available as this airs. [SPEAKER_01]: Amazon, Barnes & Noble, and a bookstore if they don't have it on a shelf can order for patients, physicians, whoever listens in. [SPEAKER_01]: And as I said, the most important thing to me is that everybody gets the message so that we can make change for the better.
[SPEAKER_00]: Well said. [SPEAKER_00]: I want to thank Dr. Neil Farber, retired internal medicine physician and author of a book called Treating a Broken System, a Physician's Cure for the Health Care Crisis. [SPEAKER_00]: Thank you so much for joining me today, Dr. Farber. [SPEAKER_00]: It was a pleasure to talk with you. [SPEAKER_01]: Me too. [SPEAKER_01]: Thanks very much. [SPEAKER_00]: To learn more about aging matters, of course, you can visit our website, which is agingmattersonline.com. [SPEAKER_00]: And, of course, at this site, you can access all of the aging matters radio programs that we've produced, the TV show episodes that are available on the website as well as on YouTube.
[SPEAKER_00]: And, of course, the podcast, which you can find on Apple, Spotify, and Red Circle, and wherever you access your podcasts. [SPEAKER_00]: So, again, [SPEAKER_00]: Aging Matters Online.com. [SPEAKER_00]: Aging Matters is produced in association with Steve Lack audio and edited by Donalac. [SPEAKER_00]: So to learn more about that company, visit SteveLackAudio.com. [SPEAKER_00]: Thank you for listening to Aging Matters today and remember, age is just a number, not a label. [SPEAKER_00]: I'll be back again with you next week.
Conversation w/ Michelle Thomas, MPA, Coordinator, Virginia Insurance Counseling and Assistance Program, about Medicare basics, beneficiary enrollment, Medicare Advantage plans and Medigap policies, and Medicare...
Conversation w/ Sarita Mohanty, MD, President/CEO, The SCAN Foundation, about factors increasing the need for long-term services and supports, reasons paying for them are a financial burden for older adults and their...
Conversation w/ Sam Goodrich, Project Manager, Memory Café Alliance, and Bridgette Wisdom, Coordinator, Arlington VA Memory Cafe, about memory café purpose and activities, benefits of participation for people living...
Conversation w/ Michelle Fiscus, MD, Chief Medical Officer, Association of Immunization Managers, about factors that may prevent older adults from getting routine vaccines, staying up to date on immunizations, and...
Conversation w/ The Honorable Rev. Dr. John Unger, Professor, Shepherd University, about why AI-enabled technology holds potential to address challenges and improve quality of life for older adults, ways AI is currently...