Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Advisors Off Script

Advisors Off Script artwork

Advisor Communication Skills: Connection Before Content | John Gatewood

Oct 8, 202647 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Most advisor training teaches knowledge. Very little teaches the skill that keeps clients: communication. Shelby Nicholl talks with John Gatewood, founder of Gatewood Financial and author of The Listening Advisor, about why 72% of new advisors fail in their first few years and why only 7% of advisors are under 35. John argues that an advisor's real job is to motivate clients to act, and that listening and speaking are trainable, measurable skills. He walks through the practical tools he uses, including "tell me more," feel, felt, found, and scripted stories, and explains why AI makes human connection more important, not less. You will hear: Why information alone does not move clients to act How to ask better questions and uncover the real objection How to practice before the meeting, not during it How new advisors can build confidence faster John's book, The Listening Advisor, is available now on Amazon. Know a new advisor? Send them this episode. Hosted by Shelby Nicholl. Produced and edited by Aaron Sherman. Operations and Guest Coordination by Shelly Hadel.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

I've been thinking a lot about what is the actual job of a financial advisor. Is it to build the plan? Is it to develop the recommendation? Explain the numbers? Or is the real job getting a human being to actually do something with all of that advice? Today's guest is John Gatewood. And John built Gatewood Financial, has sold it, has exited from his business, or nearly so, and now has a new book called The Listening Advisor. And he's here with us today to talk about his book, but most importantly, to talk about the opportunity ahead for new advisors coming in and how we can better support them in this industry.

John, thank you so much for being here. Thanks for having me. I I appreciate being here today. Well, I'm so, so glad to have you here. I think your story really resonated with me and just this idea of this book and what you're talking about with the listening advisor and communication, especially in the age of AI, is just so timely for us. So, John, as we get started, kind of share with share with the listeners about your career path. Well, I have a ~ ~ an interesting career path.

I grew up in Washington, DC because my dad went to the Naval Academy, became a Russian translator for naval intelligence, but then he had thirteen kids. So he had to find a career that actually paid the bills. So he went into the life insurance business. And imagine this in the nineteen sixties he found a niche within the ultra high net worth families because you didn't have any coordination of all the different advisors. So he had an office in Washington, DC with One wall painted black. He would invite in the high net worth family, the attorney, the accountant, the stockbroker, and the banker, and every quarter they map out the next quarterly plan with chalk on the wall. And then he would take a Polaroid camera, take a picture of it, and give one to each of the advisors in the family.

Then he had a team of professionals that would follow up with the attorney, the accountant, and so on. And he would put together a quarterly report in this blue binder for each family. So they had a consolidated target. So he was really a precursor to the family office and he charged a fee for that. But then when the ~ estate tax laws changed where you could where the estate tax was owed at the death of the second spouse, he had an insurance company design a policy that would be paid at the second which is now the second to die policy.

So that was kind of the heritage that I I grew up in. ~ I worked or I worked with them or interned with them for a year between my freshman and sophomore year saw that but what I wanted to do was to do that for the mass affluent. I wanted to be that central advisor for the mass affluent to help them find a way to get to the point where they're financially in their in their lives. So what I did was I I did some research after college and I found this guy in Chicago. ~ he happened to be affiliated with Northwestern Mutual at the time and he had the same type of vision where you would go do fact finding but not just the facts.

It wasn't about selling products because really that's what most everything was back back then. It was product selling. ~ But we would create these rudimentary plans. ~ And one day he sat me down and he said, Hey John, you have to learn a really important lesson. The decision to do something someday is a logical decision. For example, you sh everybody agrees, you know, I should probably buy life insurance someday. I should probably start saving and investing someday. But the decision to do it today is an emotional decision.

And emotions are caught, not taught. So what did I learn from that? Is that information alone doesn't motivate people to action. By the way, how do we know that? Gyms Are full in January and empty by March, right? I mean, look at all the different tech tools that are out there on you know physical fitness, nutrition, yet that's not what motivates people. And when you ask about what is the financial advisor's job, that is the job. Our job is to motivate people to take action on the things that we know are in their best interest.

It's no different than a coach, right? They know. what the exercises are that would be good for that particular person after they've done an examination. Well we're doing the same thing. We're creating a financial plan with recommendations, with investment strategies, insurance strategies, tax strategies. All those we know ourselves that they are in the best of the client. But how do you get them from let me think about it to let's do it? That's where the emotional core has to be, has to happen.

So That was the whole purpose of the listening advisors, because I always wondered what is it that separates the elite advisors from everybody else? I wanted to be elite. by the way, another little story off off offhand is that when I grew up, I stuttered. So I had to go through to therapy to go st to learn how to speak. ~ I still have a little bit of it today, but what I've learned from that is that why don't we do the same type of practice with the way that Mm mm.

we speak to people in the way that I had to practice when I was learning how to speak. But we don't. Yeah, I've often thought about that. So I have a couple of neurodiverse kids. And one of my sons has spent a lot of time in social and emotional learning and really learning how to read people's body language, et cetera. And I'm thinking, gosh, these lessons are just really good for everyone. ~ you know, he even had to learn there's five parts to a proper apology, and you know, we name them off so that he really learned how to how to do that in the right way and in a way that really resonates with the other person.

~ but it's interesting how these things that we that some of us are taught or that we have to go through and learn how those lessons could be applied to just everyone. So I I I love that story about about the stutter and you're like, gosh, why don't we just practice this more? And it is something that I think about too. You know, your book is so interesting. I think part of the premise is the idea of teaching people these skills, right? Because we have this Looming advisor shortage, we have a whole bunch of fallout in the industry. But what's interesting to me too is that when I was at Edward Jones and at some of the larger firms, they spend thousands of dollars, millions of dollars, hundreds of millions of dollars on training new advisors.

And yet we still have this huge, very large fallout rate. how do you think this book could make a difference there? So you bring up a great point that there's seventy-two percent of advisors fail in the first few years. And we're in a position where more advisors are retiring than are coming into the business. By the way, do you know what percentage of advisors are under the age of 35 today? Seven percent. I don't know. Seven. my gosh, that's crazy low, right?

~ I do know a lot of people who start right out of college. I'm thinking about you know, a a ~ kind of recent college grad named Sawyer who I helped land a a really great role with an RIA And it was interesting because it was very hard also for for him to find a role. And yet there's only 7% that are under 35%. That's that's incredible. So think about that. Why do people not come to the field? Because they see that there's a high attrition rate. Why is there a high attrition rate?

Because we have a training crisis in our industry. Yes. The vast majority of those millions of dollars of training that you were talking about at Everett Jones and all other firms is about knowledge, financial planning, portfolio management, strategies, ideas. But very, very little of it is on the skill that matters the most. How do you communicate with a client? How do you present to a client? And that's why I wanted to write this book, because I want to be the solution to the problem.

So what I've done over my career, I've studied and researched what are the things that make the elite advisors elite. And to me, it's that they somehow had this way of connecting with clients, where clients felt truly heard and motivated to act. So, well, to me, those are just the two communication skills, which are listening. How do we listen so deeply that the clients say, wow, Shelby knows me so well. She knows what it's exactly like to be in my shoes.

She knows what my needs are. And she speaks so clearly that it makes total sense for me to go ahead and act on what she says. Well, what are those two things? The listening, the speaking, those are the two things that create that authentic human connection. And as the authentic human connection, that connection of trust that builds clients who refer, advocate, and never leave. So one of the things I say is connection before content.

Mm. Okay. So let's I want to like even back up from that a little bit for a moment and and go back to your conversation about training on this, though, right? Because you're saying connection before content. We've got a bunch of training on content, not a lot on connection. So that is the core of what people need is they need that content on the they need to be taught how to do the connection piece. And that's what you're seeking to teach with this book. Yes. Well the idea is to have the skills.

But here here's the thing. You can't read the book and all of a sudden be a pro. This is something that Mm-hmm. Yeah. has to be mastered. What I tell people is that the meeting is not the dress rehearsal. Do you think it can even be mastered, or is this somehow just innate to people? So that's a great question. People have asked me that all the time. Either they have it or they don't have it. People talk about communication skills or connection skills as being a soft skill.

I don't believe that. I believe that communication skills are real, identifiable, they're trainable, learnable, and measurable. So as an example, at Gatewood, we now use jump AI, for example. There's all these systems out there that that record meetings and they produce the AI generated reports, the CRM action items. they also re create scorecards.

Well I created a scorecard based upon the metrics of of the book and then created a coaching system. Well lo and behold after a six month beta test everybody's started at here and now they're up here. Now we have client satisfactions better, we have more opportunities that we are identifying, more times that people are getting referrals, they're learning to ask open-ended questions, be more concise, they're learning to ask great questions, learning to uncover the elephant in the room.

But all that is because they're being trained on it. They're being reminded of it. They're being scored on it. So yes, I truly believe that this is a learnable, trainable, measurable skill, and it's something that we're not doing in in in most places today. Yeah, I agree with that. I I also believe that it's a skill. I believe anyone actually can learn to do anything if they so desire. Does it mean that you can will be intuitively the best? Maybe not, but can you learn the skills so that you can do the job very well?

Absolutely. ~ core belief in for me is that you can learn to do anything. ~ maybe it's all those books I read as a kid and, you know, continue to. Yeah, it's interesting. I I've been getting feats. I spoke on three occasions at ~ LPL's National Focus Conference and then I've had ~ a number of people respond with reviews that told me, my gosh, I read the book, it was great. I just tried this one thing and in my next client meeting it was so awesome. All of a sudden I started learning things that I didn't know about the person because you told me about one thing that I could just try.

And Yeah. that's the type of feedback that that that I'm getting. It's really helping people to deepen the client relationships and finding more ways to get clients to agree to take action on the things that we're advising. I think that's so interesting, this idea of them agreeing to take action. ~ ~ I had a a podcast guest a couple of months ago named James Bogart, and he's built Bogart Wealth. They have built an enormous enterprise in a very short amount of time. But he does say, you know, the job of the advisor is to solve people's problems, right? I think your your kind of crack at that, if you will, is just slightly different but similar.

It's to solve people's problems, it's to motivate them to actually do the action to solve that problem. you mentioned these reviews and the feedback that you're receiving. What are some of those very specific things that people are taking away from book and doing, or what is the top two things that you wish people would take this book and then begin implementing because they would make such a difference? Okay, the first thing is advisors tend to want to tell people how smart they are. And what we have to do is to learn to ask questions, not just closed-ended data-based questions, but open-ended questions. And then once people respond, so for example, you say, you know.

What are your retirement goals? I'd like to retire at 65, have $20,000 a month,~ you know, I I I want to be able to stop working, yada yada yada. And then they go in and they they create a financial plan. Well, what have they actually learned? It's just surface level information. The question is, remember, people make decisions based upon emotion. Well that data is not that information is not ~ emotion. So one of the things I regularly do is to say three simple words.

Tell me more. Well tell me more about that. Yeah. Tell me more. And then I'll continue on. Well that's interesting. Tell me more about why that is important. I'm I'm just trying to understand the emotional core here because the more you drill down to find out what the money is for, because it's not about the money, it's not about the math. It never is. It's about what the math does. What are those things that are doing that people are very attached to and want to.

And those are the things that we want to bring up. So rather than just providing information, we're providing motivation around the things that they want to do. Yeah. It's interesting the tell me more. It's such a you know, I I I made my living for for a while in client insights and talking with investors and clients and financial advisors about what they wanted in the future of our industry. And so I was running focus groups and survey programs and things like that. And I would moderate kind of focus groups, right? All the people around the the table and two way mirrors, the whole thing. And tell me more is a tactic that we would use in those in those focus groups to just uncover insight. And it's that's exactly what you're doing here is you're just additional insight.

Yeah, ~ ~ that's remember, we want to learn how the client truly feels. And people come and stay because of how we make them feel. Well we have to know how they feel in order for us to go and then create the plan that matches that. So another way to put this is that it's the tell mode versus the ask mode. How much time do we spend in the tell mode versus the ask mode?

So for example, let's say that you and I were in a client meeting and I asked you a question and then you you start speaking. What would what would the normal advisor be doing when you start speaking? Probably thinking about the next thing that they're going to say. Thinking about the next thing they're they're going to say. Rather than thinking, hmm, what questions should I ask beyond this? Now, you don't have to do this for every single piece of the conversation, but when it comes to understanding the goals, the person, what matters, those are the things that we have to dig deeply on because the more we know them, the more we're going to be able to motivate them.

Yeah, I think a a fear some advisors would have is that they're going that the client will feel like they're being interrogated. How do we how do we keep it natural? And and is that maybe just part of the practice that we receive? I'd say it's part of the practice, it's gonna be uncomfortable for for many people because think about it. It's like the Bogart firm, his firm is there to provide solutions. This is what we've been trained to do our whole life. It's everything is about knowledge, solutions. The issue with the solutions is yes, we have to know that stuff.

But if we can't get them motivated to act on the solutions, have we really done our job? And that's the hardest part. To me, the easy part is to figure out the solution. The hard part is how do I learn how to motivate people to action? So listening is just part of it. But the other thing is, how do I speak in a way that is concise, compelling, clear? ~ and these are things that we don't practice. So let's think of it this way.

I was in a band when I was in college in Washington DC and I would spend hours playing the guitar, playing the songs over and over and over again trying to perfect them. And then we would get together with the band and we'd do it over and over and over again. We'd make some modifications. Well by the time we got to the performance, we were ready. I mean we were we were we were not there to just jam. Well what do most people do when they go to a client meeting? They jam. You know, they're swinging it. They wing it. ~ ~ think about the things that you discuss, concepts. We start talking about a concept and then but we don't ever script it.

Why not take those things that you normally talk about, script it? And here's where AI can help out. AI can prompt AI to tell me help me to script this where it's clear, concise, compelling. Is there an analogy that I can use? Is there a story that I that I can use? Take that take that ~ output and then keep skinning it down and then practice it. So, for example, another thing that that my mentor in the business told me early he says that we he sat down here one time and he says, Hey John, I want you to listen to these poems and tell me if you can find the common thread.

I said, Okay. So he said, Some sail east, some sail west by the very same breeze that blows. It isn't the breeze, but the set of the sail that determines the wage goes. And I thought, hm, math nerd John Gatewood, that's you know, not really my my stuff but he said okay I'm gonna tell you another one so he told me another poem and this time he got even more animated and at the end he said you see the common thread I said Al man I'm I'm not really sure what you're driving at so he said okay I'm gonna tell you one more so he told me a third poem and I mean he was ready to get up out of his chair and at the Yeah.

end he said you see the common thread I said Al help me out here man I don't see it he said the common thread is that these are poems that move Me. When I say these things, I get excited. And when you say things to your clients, you have to say them in a way where they get excited. So our part of our job in terms of working with clients is to find ideas that move people's minds. So that's what I've been doing my whole career.

Whether it's explaining an RMD or creating a complicated tax strategy, what I try to do is to find ways To explain those things that in a way that it motivates people to action. It moves their minds. Because information is not going to do that. But the way that we explain things,~ you know, stories, analogies, being clear-cut, that's how we I think can. yeah, I think it's so interesting and and and I didn't mean to to to cut you off there, but that No, yeah.

stories and the analogies, it seems like that's a really pe key piece of the of the emotional connection as well, right? It's the telling of stories that that resonate and make sense. You know, for example, even I was I was on a call with with ~ with somebody earlier today and I was talking about our approach for how we Talk with advisors about the right kind of future homes for them, whether that's joining a new firm or building,~ ~ building a new RIA. And one of the things that we talk about when it comes to building a new RIA is what are the buttons that they want to push and which ones don't they want to push, right? And just using that word of buttons they want to push.

~ that it's so simple and clear, but it immediately gave gives people this picture in their mind. And then they're like, that's right, it's buttons to push. Now which ones do I actually want to push? So things like that are what you're talking about here is we've got to find those those common ~ phrases and stories and elements where the esoteric or the you know the theoretical becomes tangible.

That's such a great analogy, great story. So one of the statistics that's important to understand is when people see visuals, they process information thirty times faster than when they just hear words. So that's the first thing. Second thing is people remember stories, not the facts. So think about how you remembered the button story. People are gonna remember the stories that you tell more than anything else that you tell them. So in your preparation in terms of dealing with clients to motivate them, how well are you looking for stories?

How well are you looking for analogies? And then scripting them, learning to to to say them in a way where it's clear. ~ you know, one of the things that I I'm I'm very sensitive to today is people are so busy. Everybody's time starved. I mean it's hard to even get an appointment with a client. You know, they got millions and millions of dollars with us, but they're too busy to meet. So What does that mean for the client meeting?

When you do have them in front of you, we're not respecting their time if we haven't really practiced and been specific about how we're going to handle that meeting. So how do people prepare the meetings? They prepare the financial plans, the performance reports, the strategies. But how many times do they sit down and say, hey, what are the key questions that I should be asking this client so I can have a better knowledge of what's going on today?

Hey, there's a strategy that we want to talk about. How can I explain this in a clear, concise, simple and compelling way so that I can respect their time? ~ that's one of the things I always struggle with because I like to talk. So would talk too much. but Same here. I want to go to that practice because you you've you brought it up a few times and I'm completely on board with you, right? I can think about being in MBA school and and doing presentations and people videotaping those, right?

Are is that the type of practice that you're hoping that people or advocating that people should be doing? Is it videotapes? Is it role playing? What are what are specific ways that we can practice? It's it's all of that. So imagine what we used to do when I started in the business was we practiced. So I I had a script for the entire sales process. I would go into meetings and just say exactly the words on the script. I really didn't understand, you know, what was going on yet. I didn't quite get the connection, the products and so on. But we just I would come back I would debrief and then I would do that after every single meeting.

Here's what I said, here's what they said, he'd give me ideas of what I could do, and then we would have weekly role-playing sessions where we or we had a class of individuals that was led by a manager. And I remember the first time that we decided to do ~ videotaping. ~ my gosh, that was so embarrassing. Do you remember the first time that you were videotaped? I do. Yeah. Yeah. Well, I think videotapes, I think audio tapes, right? We all feel like we sound funny. ~ so it is embarrassing. It is ~ it's it's emotional.

~ and and then you get accustomed to it and it gets better. Yeah, so ~ ~ especially today since every meeting's recorded, why wouldn't you go back and watch the meeting? Have an accountability coach, have That's right. someone in in your firm, get a group together. The purpose of the book is to give an actual structure of things that they can use and and and practice with. ~ so I mean that's that that's what the motivation is in fact.

So my my plan is I'm gonna retire from my firm and then next year start a training company with, you know, speaking, workshops and so on, because I really want to help the advisors who are either new or who are plateauing to have a better successful career because that is what's needed today. Yeah. I am am glad that you mentioned that doing training and and coaching and and starting that that firm.

Because I think also, you know, we talked about some of the big corporations, the Edward Jones, the Northwestern Mutuals, right? They spend so Yeah. many millions of dollars on on associate training and associate advisor training. Obviously, it's not as successful as they would all want it to be. Any of us in the industry would want it to be. But what you're talking about with with your new training endeavor. ~ ~ I I'm making a a bunch of leaps here, but it seems as if maybe something even the the ev the the pr regular practice, a a firm like Gatewood in the old days or~ even in the current state could tap into.

Yeah, i ~ ~ imagine if more dollars were spent here, there was time commitment, and the actual commitment of the advisor. Imagine if that could ~ save one out of the ten who fail in the first few years. That would be huge. I mean that's almost Yeah, yeah. Well and I it would be huge. doubling the number of people that are staying on board. Well, and I think too it it to your point earlier, it gives us such a ~ a a bad reputation as an industry of that it's very hard to make it in when if we gave people the right skill set, perhaps it wouldn't be as hard to make it in.

If we gave them the a different compensation method, if we gave them a different job ladder, there's a lot of things that we could do in order to better serve a brand new advisor, especially a young person brand new advisor. Well, think about today, especially, because in the past, people did hire us for solutions. AI is gonna commoditize that. Okay? That's right. Mm-hmm. So if AI is gonna commoditize that, everybody's gonna have the same skills and come to the same same conclusions. What's left? The most important skill.

So to me What I'm talking about, that ~ authentic human connection through communication mastery has always been the most important skill. It's just that now AI is making it more urgent. Do you see what I mean? So that's why I think that today we have to, we have to find a way to help advisors make that connection with this~ ability, this skill to really connect with people in a way where they feel truly heard and ready.

Yeah. Yeah, so you gave us a a really practical tip earlier with the tell me more. And you've said we've got to ask questions and we have to practice. Those are a few of the key takeaways from today. Tell me what what else you would like people to take away from today? Because this is a nice size, nice thick book. We've got a lot of I mean, the type is even pretty small, John. ~ ~ you've got a lot of stuff in here that we can take away.

What's another really good takeaway from this book? By the way, that's because that's forty five years of stuff in there. Right. Yeah. If that and by the way, when when you look at it forty five years in my brain, that's pretty small. Well, that that's absolutely fair. I will totally give you that. I'm ~ ~ I just love it. And sometimes you get you get books right and there's so much white space, et cetera. And this is is just so well done. And I'm I'm really excited about it. So ~ yeah. Yeah. So so here's let's talk about pushback, okay?

Yeah. People get pushback. they're not ready to move forward or they don't agree with an idea. ~ or they say, Let me think about it. So what I wanna I want people to realize first of all is that an objection that first objection is not really an objection. there's something else behind it which is keeping them from making the decision. Do you see what I mean? So when somebody says, Well, you know, I'm I'm I'm not sure that I really want to do that right now.

Well then we cut what do most people do? They start coming up with a solution, the answer already. let's say for example you have an executive with~ significant equity compensation and you're trying to get him to go from a concentrated position to a diversified investment portfolio. He knows that's the logical thing to do, but he doesn't wanna do it. And so you What what what do most people do? They start, well, ~ ~ it's more tax efficient,~ ~ there's all these other things.

Right, the logical reasoning. Logical reasons. Mm-hmm. Well, if we just start giving reasons or answers to that objection, how do we know if we're actually answering what is on his mind? Okay. So the first thing is when I have an objection,~ talking about decoy objections. Most people don't wanna say no. How do how do we know Yeah, I agree. that? You know, have ~ ever had somebody say, Hey, love to have you and your husband out to to dinner this Friday?

And you're thinking, my god, I I I really don't want to go with that couple, There's no way. right? So so what do you do? ~ my kids have something going on. You lie, right? Right. Yeah. You make something up. There's some reason. well, let me get back to you about a date,~ ~ I'll get back to you. Right. Exactly. And then you just don't. Yeah. Well that's the same thing that happens when we're dealing with clients when they Mm-hmm. Yeah. don't want to move forward. So the first thing is you have to address the objection in a way that you that you want to find what the real one is.

So I'd say, Well, so Shelby, when when you said that you don't really want to do it now, tell me more about that. Okay, there's the tell me more. So you might say, Well I just don't wanna pay pay taxes on all that gain r right now. You know, I I I know I I should probably diversify. Say, well, okay, tell me more about that. Well I also I think the stock price is is gonna go up in the next twelve months, you know s so I'm you know, I'm I'll probably sell some then.

Okay. And So why else? No, that's that's pr pretty much it. So then I would feed feed it back. So so what you're telling me is that you you don't want to act on this today you don't want to pay the taxes. I certainly understand that. And you think that the stock price is going to go up in the next 12 months. Is that right? Yeah, that that's it. So what have I done? First of all, I've uncovered what's really behind not wanting to go forward today. Okay. Now I know what I have to address.

So the question then is how do I address it? The first thing I do is I do the feel-felt found. I'll say, Shelby, look, I certainly understand how you feel. You know, nobody likes to pay taxes. ~ there's always that possibility of getting more of gaining more in the in the value of the stock. However, that and we've had, you know, many clients have been in the same position, felt the same way, but here's what they've found. Yeah, yeah. I Okay.

love that framework. Feel, felt, found. So I understand how you feel. Other clients have felt it. We found X. ~ that's so good. So think about what that does though. You're reframing the conversation. You're reframing it by number one, you're giving him you're you're empathizing with it. You're you're acknowledging how he feels. but then it gives you the opportunity to reframe to address that. Yeah.

And and now, how do you respond to that? That's where you have to have. scripted language. Okay. So I've had that conversation many times. So how he would respond to it, I I would say, Shelby, you know, whenever I have a client in this situation, I always ask the question, Is the potential for that additional gain worth the risk of the loss? What do I mean by that? Do you know that you could lose More in stock value if the stock price drops than you would ever pay in taxes.

So let me so first I I have that. So that's something that I've scripted. Then I have a story that I would tell. You know, I had a ~ client at Malincrot, he was an executive, he had most of his net worth tied up in Malencrot~ equity compensation. And we had that exact same conversation. And I said, ~ ~ is the potential for the additional return worth the risk of the loss? And he was telling me the same logic that we were just talking Well, I said, knowing that, why don't we think about ~ taking half of that, take the chips off the table, okay, in case you're wrong.

And then leave half of it on the table in case you're right. So he did it. Lo and behold, 12 months later, the stock went from 110 down to $30 because there Oof. was there was some scandal at the company. And he was so thankful that that he had made that decision. So Yeah. It doesn't mean it's gonna work every single time, but you have to have scripted something. Is the potential for that additional gain worth the risk of loss?

What do I mean by that? Have a story. After the Yeah, yeah. story, hey, well then let's have a recommendation there. This is what I mean I think that's by by practicing, just a role play, you know, really scripting and narrowing it down until it becomes your script, your recommendation. Well, and one of the things I've heard you say is also,~ ~ when you we all feel it when a conversation has landed with the other right? Yes. You feel like, they heard it, they got I got through, they took action, ~ you know what worked.

And one of the things I've heard you say is in those moments, like, write it down, write down that phrase, Exactly. Right. write, write down that piece. Absolutely. And I think that that that writing it down, that scripting, the practicing, that's part of also kind of how we get conviction that we're doing the right~ Yes. and you know, one of the things we hear a lot about is brand new advisors. How do they kind of get out ~ their head trash and how do they have conviction that that they're offering the right thing to their client, right? And so One of the things I think about is,~ ~ can they borrow conviction from the team or from other situations?

What would be your response to somebody who says, Gosh, I just haven't been I haven't been an advisor long enough and I don't know. Maybe I'm maybe I'm giving them the wrong advice. I I think I know I'm giving them the right advice, but it's coming across in a way that is not as as strong as I wish it were. What would you give to advice would you say to that person? I think that that's a that's a really really good thing. Yeah. Can I just say one thing before I answer that question? ~ Yeah. I think this is an amazing opportunity for young people right now because the number of advisors is shrinking, there's gonna be consolidation, and this is just ripe for the right person.

It's going to be Yes. incredible. But to be successful, they have to have training. So to answer your question. what I would do is to make sure that you're with a firm that actually does So imagine somebody who's going I wonder did I give the right advice? Well this is where you have to have Pre-brief and debrief, ~ ~ what are you going to recommend? Let's see how did that meeting go? That's that's all part of the training. Mm. They'll have certain philosophies about how people should invest or how they should have financial plans. ~ one of the best ways I I think is to do it like an apprentice.

In other words, learn from the others. jump in to meetings right away over your head. That was what I did. I I decided that I was not going to wait to learn. I was just going to jump into things that I had no idea what I was talking about. And one thing I learned Ha ha. about that is it's okay not to have the answer. So for for young people, and I remember my dad used to tell me that people like to do business with young people. So don't be afraid.

Borrow that confidence from the team. So if you're a team leader watching this, that is your job. You need to make sure that you're giving the confidence, that training to the advisors so that they can be successful. Why don't we do it? Because it takes time. It's hard. And are people willing to do the hard work? I'm telling you, especially for a young person today, because~ everything's moving to digital modes. So I I think that they have a n a natural advantage on the digital side.

So I think that the person that has digital fluency plus is able to have this communication mastery where they're creating authentic connection with clients, they're gonna be the ones that really win in the future. Yeah, I couldn't agree with you more. And I think today's technology gives them a whole bunch of new opportunities too for really understanding what went right and what went wrong in a call, right? A lot of our business is with advisors over Zoom calls, right? And we use a note taker and ~ have a transcript of that.

And one of the things that I've done for myself and for our team is taking that transcript and throwing them into AI and saying,~ ~ this this conversation went well, except for this portion. Give me some coaching. And, Right. you know, like those opportunities exist. We just have to go and do it. So imagine take what you just said. Advisors are going into the meetings that they have these transcripts. As long as it doesn't have PII, put it into these systems and say, Hey, how could I have improved my conversation?

Where could Exactly. I have been more clear? Where could I have asked better questions? you know, all those it's it's AI has made the ability to train and learn the human side so much easier. But it's are you willing to do the work? It's like have to do the hard thing. That's right. That's right. Well, we have covered so much ground today. I want to do just a few rapid fire questions with you. Okay. Okay, so number one, best question that an advisor can ask a client.

Tell me more, although it's not a question. I knew that's what you were gonna say. ~ what is a phrase that advisors should stop saying? Do you have any? ~ Any questions? yes, that is a good one. ~ yes. Why is that? Because it's yes, no, no. You don't all you don't allow them to have questions. Yeah. Yeah. Any questions? It yeah, nobody wants to ask a question then. It makes you just feel like you are stupid and you shouldn't have had a question, right? It's it's the teacher in the front of the room and they'd say any questions, and they mean.

Don't ask me any questions. Yeah. Right. ~ what do you think is more maybe you know, kind of more useful? Is it role playing or is it live experiences with coaching after? I'd say that most of the time should be spent on the on the live coaching, okay, but you have to have role playing as well. Yeah, yeah. It's that was ~ ~ a false choice, right? I knew that you wanted to say both.

You needed both. Yes. Yeah. What is still a a communication habit that maybe you're still working on in in your own life? Listening at home. ~ okay. So you're good at work, but not at home. That's funny. Yes. Hilarious. All right. Well, and you know, you know, John, our our our podcast is called ~ advisors off script because we believe in living a life that is off script, a life that is full agency for ourselves and where we really are directing our futures and our lives.

What's a way that you are living maybe an off script, an unexpected script to your life? Well, the unexpected script is really turning this this book into a training company. ~ ~ I I I was Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Starting another endeavor. starting another so I'm I'm s I was I'm working part time and so now I'm starting a a company that's that somehow I'm gonna do full time work and part time hours. But but it's it's We hope so. Yeah, that's it it's it's exciting. Look, I I really feel that This is something that is needed.

And whatever impact that I I can have, that is great. I have no idea what what the end game of this is gonna be or how I'll be remembered, but I know that if I can help a few people actually have better success in this business, especially with the opportunity ahead, that would make me happy. Yeah. Well, I'm super excited. I'm thrilled that you came on the podcast to talk about it. I couldn't agree with you more. There's such an opportunity here, especially for young people entering the industry or for career changers that are are finding their footing in the in a new industry.

There is so much opportunity in this industry today for people to just do a great job with clients. And I think if you're able to have the smarts and and know know the content of course of the business, but to be able to communicate that in a way that is ~ persuasive and as you said, John, get things, get get people to take action, that is is just you're gonna have an immensely successful business as an Absolutely. Well, thank you so much. for our next generation of advisors, we definitely have to teach those skills.

The book is the listening advisor. It is out now. You can get it on Amazon. We're really excited about it, obviously. John, thank you so much for joining me today. Thank you. And to our listeners, please subscribe, send this episode maybe to a young person or a new to the industry person that you know. Recommend the book, and then we'll see you next time here at Advisors Off Script.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Living in the "And": Running a Growing RIA Consulting Firm Through a Family Health Crisis | Shelby Nicholl's 50th Episode

    Sep 24, 202650 minAudio

    Fifty episodes in, Shelby Nicholl finally takes a seat on the other side of the mic. For this milestone episode, Libby Greiwe - a past guest, trusted colleague, and one of the sharpest minds in advisor operations -...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Introducing The Vested Network: Fixing Wealth Management Hiring with Co-Founders Jill Barnett, Claire Vitale & Shelby Nicholl

    Jul 1, 202649 minAudio

    In this special episode, Shelby steps out from behind the interviewer's chair to talk about a company she just launched. The Vested Network is the first wealth management-specific talent marketplace, built to solve a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Problem Solver Mindset: How James Bogart Grew Bogart Wealth to Nearly $4B AUM

    Jun 11, 202648 minAudio

    James Bogart launched Bogart Wealth from his basement - folding tables, a garage postage station, and clients signing paperwork at the dining room table. Six years later, the firm is approaching $4 billion in AUM with...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. AI, Risk Surface, and the Fragmented Advisory Firm — A WealthTech Reality Check with Adrian Johnstone

    May 28, 202645 minAudio

    Most advisors are thinking about what a new AI tool can do for them. Fewer are thinking about what it does to them. In this episode, Shelby sits down with Adrian Johnstone, co-founder and CEO of PractiFi, for a direct...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Power of Niching: How to Build a Resonant Financial Advisor Brand with Natalie Hales

    May 14, 202642 minAudio

    In this conversation, Shelby Nicholl and Natalie Hales explore the intricacies of branding within the financial services sector. Natalie shares her personal journey into the industry, emphasizing the importance of...

    Credit the people on this episode