In this episode, Bryce and I catch up and chat about the AI generated ADSP Episode 211. Link to Episode 212 on Website Discuss this episode, leave a comment, or ask a question (on GitHub) Twitter ADSP: The Podcast Conor Hoekstra Bryce Adelstein Lelbach Show Notes Date Generated: 2024-12-10 Date Released: 2024-12-13 Gantt Chart ADSP Episode 211: Power, Politics and Misconduct in C++ ✨ ADSP Episode 211 GitHub Discussion Whisper AI Audacity Final Solution Blog Post: On "Safe" C++ - HELL IN A REFCELL Reddit Comments NotebookLM Intro Song Info Miss You by Sarah Jansen https://soundcloud.com/sarahjansenmusic Creative Commons - Attribution 3.0 Unported - CC BY 3.0 Free Download / Stream: http://bit.ly/l-miss-you Music promoted by Audio Library https://youtu.be/iYYxnasvfx8
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
ConorI'll be honest, the main reason I still go to C conferences is because the majority, 99.9% of the C community, in terms of speakers and attendees and you know listeners of this podcast, I love interacting with that community. And it is sad that I have to like miss out on that and not interact with that community. So welcome to ADSP the podcast, episode 212, recorded on December 10th, 2024.
ConorMy name is Connor, and today with my co-host Bryce, we chat about our thoughts on AI and LLMs, respond to feedback we got on episode 211, and elaborate on why we posted that episode.
BryceI have something to improve your mood. Look what I found at the NVIDIA vending machines.
ConorWait. Do the NVIDIA vending machines uh require compensation?
BryceUh they do require compensation, sadly.
ConorWhy do you because they have free uh soda at the cafeterias? Do they not have sparkling?
BryceThey're not currently functioning.
ConorOh, that is gradual.
BryceThe soda is broken.
ConorThat's yeah that is the number one reason that I love going to HQ, is they have free soda. Which is sad because like compared to all other tech re tech companies, they've got free food, free snacks, free bunch of stuff. The only thing that NVIDIA gives free soda, which is uh it's great.
BryceIt's great. We're very we're very cheap, but I'm gonna I'm gonna open this up now. Okay. I was not as graceful as you because I got some booblet on my laptop's keyboard, but fortunately I have a keyboard cover.
ConorA bubbly. A bubbly uh bubbly?
BryceI thought we were calling it buble.
ConorNo, that's that's just what Michael Bublet wants you to call it. I've been good. How have you been?
BryceOh, uh a lot of travel. Um I'm here at Nvidia HQ for an internal Python workshop, um, just for a few days, and then uh we m my girlfriend Rona and I, we were in uh we were in Poland and we went to her hometown, which uh is called Australeka, which means sharp grass. And that I just think that's like the the most badass name for a hometown.
BryceUm but I I love Poland, it was super fun. You know what was not super fun was the sun setting at like 315 every day. Uh yeah, there's there's uh I understand the the Central European like stoicism better now because it gets dark and cold in the winter.
ConorOh yeah. Well, I just looked it up. Australeka's uh it's north of Warsaw, and I've only ever been to Krakow, Warsaw, and Wrocław. And so that is and Poland's big, so that's you're getting closer to like Poland is big. You're getting closer to the Scandinavian countries, which yes are famous for having a lack of sunsets and uh certain parts of the year.
BryceI don't like we have we have a co-worker, um, Jeff Hammond, who who lives in Finland, and like like he's like in like Helsinki, which is like the southern part of Finland, but still, like, I don't know how people like survive the winters there when there's just like no sunset.
ConorI'm sure I'm sure Jeff has sorted it out, but it is shocking that the hotel infrastructure there has not discovered like blackout curtains. The only time when we were traveling through Scandinavia that they had we had any anything close to like darkness at night for sleeping was when we were on like the bottom floor of a cruise that was taking us from Helsinki to Stockholm because it had no windows. Every other time we were in a hotel, and they actually like we had an option to upgrade to get one with windows, and we were like, why would we want to do that?
BryceWe've spent like a couple You were what you were in a cruise ship room with no windows? I didn't even know that that was uh that was a thing. I thought that's where they put like the crew.
ConorNo, no, there's a like uh on the bottom floors of a cruise ship, and we were just doing it overnight uh to avoid having to drive and ferry uh during the daytime. And then we were like, this is perfect. We'll take the you know, whatever the the lowest floor to get the maximum darkness. It's great.
BryceMy first international trip was to um Ulu, which is like halfway. Oh like OU? OULU Yeah, we were there. We were there.
ConorIt's in the middle of nowhere. What were you doing there?
BryceThere was a committee meeting there. Are you serious? It was my it was 2016, yeah.
ConorI assume they have an airport with like flights in there.
BryceI I assume so because that that must have been how I got there. I remember connecting in Helsinki, but it's like it's like halfway between uh uh it's it's like in the middle of Finland, like halfway between uh uh halfway vertically.
ConorFrom the top vertically. Okay, yeah, because I was gonna say it's like it's not halfway between anything, my guy. It's just like it's like it's halfway between the bottom of Finland and the top of Finland, kind of.
BryceAnd we were there in June, and that the hotel did have blackout curtains, which was necessary because the sun did not set. Um it got like a little bit dark at like 2 a.m.
ConorWhat time of year were you there?
BryceIt was June. It was June. Like j j we were we were there for the summer solstice. What did we do? I'm I'm sure I didn't do it, whatever it was.
ConorWe happened to be there because we drove through Finland and we actually loved Olu. It was one of the highlights of the trip. Uh, because they had this sauna on the river that was like community run, and it was like super cheap. And you had to take like a a little kind of raft. It was on like you could have easily swum out, but you you take like a little raft that's like I don't know, ten or twenty meters, and then they have this like fire stove, very dark wooden sauna right on the river, and then like you just like you sit in there for however long you can last, and then you don't dive into the river.
ConorIt was unreal. Um I'm not sure if you did any anything like that while you were there.
BryceAnd we didn't do that, but when Ramona and I were in Bergen, um Norway in September, um uh we went and did like the river sauna thing, and it was it was very cold.
ConorOh, but it's so good though, like in between the saunaing. You only need to hop in for a second, right?
BryceLike oh shit, I I wouldn't go in, but she but she went in um and uh she's braver than me.
ConorBut aren't is it isn't when you get like you sit in the sauna for like 10 or 15 minutes and then you're just like dying. It like you're craving like ice cold. Like that's the benefit of like doing these hot cold circuit things.
BryceIt's like uh You know, I take I take it back. I did I did go in, but like very briefly. She like went in for like she a more legitimate period of time.
ConorThat's even a couple seconds is uh does the trick, I think. Um if you're just hopping in and hopping out.
BryceIt was like 45 degrees it was 45 degrees in freedom units, which uh I forget what the forget how you do the conversion. I forget how you do the conversion. That's like uh a few degrees above Celsius, so 32 is freezing, so but uh but it it was a pretty like I we wanted to do one of the ones where it's like a boat, like a sauna boat. We wanted to rent a sauna boat and then just like go out on the fjords. Uh that was a good trip. That was a good trip. And then we're going to um we're going to Morocco for Christmas.
ConorOh wow.
BryceWe have nothing planned. We have hotels and that's it. I'm a little bit panicked.
ConorWhat's the safety rating in is it uh uh one of those places where you have to cab from place to place because it's not safe to walk, or is that just a a rumor that uh is that a different country I'm so that's the thing.
BryceI I I don't know, but I did hear somebody mention to me the other day that it's not the safest place. So I feel like we probably ought to figure that out before we get there.
ConorI mean, uh a lot of places they say, oh, it's not and it's just like, you know, there's parts of every city. Like I'm sure there's like in every city in America, there's a d more dangerous neighborhood than Morocco actually is as like a a country. But um I ha there are certain places where like they actually have advisements and like curfews and stuff. Um so you just you just have to be smart about how you travel.
BryceAaron Powell When we were in Ecuador for our we went on this cruise to the Galapagos and we spent a uh uh two days in Guayaquil uh before and uh the cruise company was like very like they were like we will arrange your cab from the airport to the hotel and like don't leave the hotel because it's like super dangerous. Um and we just like we kind of like we kind of ignored that. We hired a local guide and like you know, we went out, but then like you know, we like we would walk around to go get coffee or something, and like we never felt unsafe, but apparently we we started learning like after we'd spent the two days in Guayaquil, and like when we were on the cruise, we started learning from the the like the the um the locals who were working on the cruise like more and more about what's going on in Ecuador, and we were like, oh yeah, we probably we probably should not have been walking around walking around in the way we were.
BryceAnd then like the day that we left Ecuador, there was some news story about the um the ex-vice president of Ecuador, who was in prison for I don't know, for some reason he was in prison, but they they broke him out of prison by they loaded up a drone with explosives, flew it to the the jail, and like landed on the roof, and then blew up the roof of the prison to try to get the imprisoned ex-president out.
BryceVice-president out. And I was like, yeah, maybe this is maybe this is not the most stable uh country. But you know, I I feel like if we just stayed in the hotel, we wouldn't have had as good of a time, and we never felt unsafe. So speaking of travel, we're uh in the process of booking our stuff for your for your wedding. Very excited. I've never been to Mexico before. Looks like it's a nice place.
ConorI guess the ADSP listeners haven't had uh any updates. Uh technically, if if you're dual listeners to my running podcast with my other buddy, we talk about it more over on that podcast. Because I feel like there's more freedom to talk about non-tech stuff. But yes, we have plans next year, 2024, destination wedding. Uh my parents have books, they're gonna come, which is uh it's always good.
BryceWas that in question? Were your parents like maybe, maybe we won't.
ConorI don't know. I uh I mean I don't you d uh you probably haven't had the experience of booking or or planning a destination wedding, but in the back of your head, you will you do think like, you know, I do expect my parents will will no question come, but like you do have like this thought, like you know, maybe they'll just be like we're gonna sit this one out. Uh anyways, all my I think all my uh uh family has booked, um, or at least put like deposits down and stuff. So um it should be fun. The wedding will be on the first day because even though we planned this like 12 months in advance, that weekend the Friday, Saturday, and Sunday were all completely booked with the venue that we wanted because they have multiple venues at the resort.
ConorAnd then we said, Oh well, either we take our like third pick venue or we do it on a Thursday. And the advantage of doing it on the Thursday is people are gonna get there on the Wednesday, and it's just like I don't want to say out of the way because it makes it sound like you know, we want to rip the band-aid off, but it's just like there's gonna be a certain amount of you know, anxiety and boxes you're trying to check. And I think if we had that in the middle of the week, we're just gonna be thinking about that like leading up to if I can use a tech analogy.
BryceIt's like when you're speaking in a conference, exactly. It is exactly like your talk at first. Yeah. You know, and it's not that you're not excited about your talk, it's just you know, you'll feel less stressed after the talk.
ConorYes, yes. That's exactly it's honestly like a perfect analogy. Uh you are looking forward to giving your talk, it's a positive thing, but it's kind of hard to not have that in the back of your mind while you're attending other talks. And like half the time you're just like, well, maybe I won't go to that talk because I'll I'll go prepare for my talk.
BryceAnd uh yeah, the sooner are you gonna are you gonna go do a big honeymoon afterwards?
ConorUh I think that is the plan, but we have not actually we spent so much time like doing the planning of the wedding that we kind of took a break from planning stuff. Although it is we are we have we have a Gantt chart. We'll link in the show notes if you don't know what a Gantt chart is, folks. Um this is courtesy of my wonderful fiance. And we are we have met the deadlines of all our Gantt chart stuff, except we are past the deadline of uh starting to plan and book the uh I really I really want to see this Gantt chart.
ConorUh yeah, maybe maybe we can arrange that at some point. Um anyways, yes.
ConorWe with our catching up out of the way, we want to address some of the feedback that we got about what will go down in history as probably our most controversial, at least uh comment inducing and probably negative feedback-inducing episode that we've released. Uh we're gonna read some of our just some highlights. We're not gonna bore you. Uh, and unfortunately that means we're gonna read some of the shorter some of the shorter feedback that we got, because we got some longer feedback.
ConorWe'll link in the description, in the show notes, to the uh discussion from the previous episode 211, even though this is episode 212. We had uh one individual by the GitHub handle, We're Lord, or we're Lord, say AI generated content is a hard pass for me. Uh, we also had from Goldfish Sound, this was painful to listen to, stripped of any human emotion and reflection. Please do not do this again. And then we had uh a few other folks that gave some uh you know uh more lengthy responses saying that they would have provided they would have preferred commentary from the both of us, not just some AI summary.
ConorWe then on X slash Twitter uh got uh a comment from uh someone that we've had interactions from with before, uh saying that I need to do a better job uh managing your interruptions, uh saying, wow, this latest episode is so disappointing, and I think it's the last straw for me. Uh and uh, anyways, to say the least, folks primarily I think hated the fact that it was AI generated. I personally, I will just speak for myself, I love I love the LLMs.
ConorAnd uh on one of my other podcasts, I've released, I think now, two, and shortly it will be three AI summaries of papers. And don't get me wrong, I understand that it's not as enjoyable as listening to humans. Uh, but especially when it comes to content that like people are not covering, I would rather listen to an AI summary of like a 1971 paper on some topic that I'm interested in than like have no one talk about it. But the people have spoken, there will never be an AI summary, at least for the next like two or three hundred episodes, but then once it gets so good and we can like feed our own voices in and then trick the audiences, maybe we'll do something like that.
BryceAnd I I think you can't you can't even do that today. Um, I listened to another podcast, Planet Money. Um it's like the one main podcast that I I listen to, whether I'm like driving or you know, bike riding or something. And they did an episode that they produced with AI. Um, and they used so there's some company that has um a technology where they you can feed in some voice samples. I think it's not like that much content, I think maybe a couple minutes or or an hour or so, and then it can it can build a model of your voice like very, very accurately.
BryceAnd so they did an AI episode with the the the voices of their hosts, and it was really good. It like was really, really good. And I honestly I thought that the the so you used notebook um LLM, which I hadn't previously heard of, but I thought it was really good. And there were some um there were one or two places where it was summarizing or explaining some concept like through an analogy that I thought were like really good.
BryceI don't remember the specific um the specific ones off the top of my head, but they were like one or two places where um it explained something in a way where I was like, huh, you know, I might actually use that if I was explaining something about the C committee to someone. Um and I I look I completely understand why people would dislike AI-generated content. And I mean, I, you know, have until recently been not a huge fan of uh seeing so much as much AI generated content as we are seeing.
BryceAnd um uh like I I can understand why some people would have an aversion to it. Uh but I when you when you first sent me those clips, I just thought it was super cool. I was super impressed that it wasn't like you had gone off and like spent like weeks like building something bespoke to generate this. You'd just taken an off-the-shelf tool and like generated something that I think was pretty good without too much effort. Um and I I thought it was cool. And I I I it was actually I think a pretty good summary and it was helpful for me.
BryceAnd I actually think I would probably use something like that to do something like summarize papers in the future. Because I I do use um large language models more and more these days for like, you know, if I'm trying to solve some problem or something, I'll go to Chat GPT. Um I find myself doing that more and more frequently. And I feel like I'm uh I'm slow to adopt things like this. So the fact that I'm starting to do it more and more um uh uh indicates to me that it really is like a 10x thing.
BryceBecause I think for me, to for me to make a change to how I work, something has to be like 10x better. Um but one thing I've learned about myself the past few years is that I uh like it's really difficult for me sometimes to get engaged with something that's purely textual. Um like if I'm gonna if I'm gonna read a book, which I do enjoy doing, like I have to be like really focused. Like I have to, I can't like do it with like some interrupts. And if I'm gonna read like an email, reading an email at work can be really challenging for me.
BryceBecause like I have to sort of get into like reading mode. Um but like listening to something is substantially easier for me. Um and I I'd never thought before about the possibility of using large language models to talk to me. Um and so now I'm thinking like hey, you know, if there's some paper I wanted to read, or if there's some you know email that that's really long that I want to get a summary at, maybe I can just have the some large language model talk to me about it. Um and I'd never considered that possibility before.
BryceUm different people consume information best in different forms, and uh it's very interesting to me to now have the option to be able to uh uh generate uh audio, like like have somebody talk to me from almost any content. And like I also like uh I I think it'd be cool if I could like for me the you know some papers people say like, oh, like this uh you know this meeting could have been an email.
BryceMe, I generally prefer to have a uh uh uh a meeting instead of an email. So sometimes I'm like, huh, I wish this email was a meeting. Well with AI, maybe I can take an email and then turn it into a meeting, because then I can have a meeting with some AI that talks to me about what's in the email. And I think that would be cool.
ConorYeah. There's a bunch of possibilities in the future that like I mean, I think we're both biased because we work for a company that is definitely profiting from the success of products like this. So it's so definitely we're both biased. But like there's a ton of stuff that I do that is that is just like jumping through hoops. Like, for instance, editing these podcasts. A lot of the work that I do, you can currently pay other folks to do, but it's like more money than I would be willing to to pay personally for what I think is a reasonable a reasonable amount of work for me to do, and it also gives me more creative control of like how the uh sound bites at the beginning get cut and you know, things like 10xing voices, or you know, uh I can insert some clip from some you know TV show.
ConorThere's I really enjoy doing that stuff, and I think it adds like uh entertainment and um like there was one time I added a a uh audio clip from Parks and Rec where um was it Ben Wyatt is his name, playing his the cones of Dunshire. And that's like one of my favorite things that I was able to do like in the 200 plus episodes, is like I love that scene, and I'm sure there's only a handful. Of folks that listen that like actually even know that scene, but uh probably hearing it for that handful of folks gives them as much joy as it brought me.
ConorAnyways, that kind of stuff I don't want to give up. But a part of that is removing ums, cleaning up when someone's talking over the other person, and all of that is gonna be the click of a button within the next couple of years. And so I'm my point being is that I think that like this is work that like I don't want to have to do, I'm not getting paid to do it, that is going to like disappear, which is why like any any kind of like jumping through hoops work that can disappear, I'm super excited about.
BryceAnd anyway, so the the point being So So when you say that you think that that part's gonna disappear, do you mean that you think that in a few years in your audio editor there'll be a button that you'll press that'll be like remove ums and interruptions? Or do you mean that you think in a few years there'll be some AI assistant where you'll be able to like or I guess what I'm what I'm asking is, do you believe that the task will be completely automated away where it'll be a click with a button and you will just have to review it?
BryceOr do you think it'll be something more where it'll be like an assistant, an aide, where you'll just um uh you'll just like be able to like interact with it some way, you know, through like like the generative um uh fill in in Photoshop where like it gives you a prompt and you like type out what you want the Photoshop to fill into that space. Do you think it'll be more like that or more like something where it's just like a button that you press?
ConorBoth forms will come, but the one that I'm picturing is the button. Like currently there's a tool called noise reduction and audacity where you give it a sample clip of like some background noise if you've got like a fan or an AC or something that's like a little hum, you give it, or maybe there's some people a couple meeting rooms over that your mic picked up a little bit of. You give it a sample of that, it it creates a noise profile, and then you apply that to the whole track and it gets rid of it. Like there's gonna be some like AI enhanced versions of this that like you give it some audio clips of certain words or something, or like and it'll it'll highlight, you know, you you give it one or two ums of an individual, and then it'll go and find every single um, highlight it, and then you can do like a quick, you know, I'm sure there's only 30 seconds of ums that one of us says in a 30-minute conversation.
ConorSo if it goes and selects everything, then I can just go hit play to make sure it's um, um, um, um, um, um. Although with an episode like this, it would absolutely just fall over because this is uh intentional ums that I want uh kept. Anyways, and uh and then you can just delete those and um it'll it'll do a lot of the stuff like the passes that I do to normalize volume. It'll probably be some just like you know, insert you drop your audio clip and it does a bunch of automatic, you know, filtering and um then I just need to go and do the creative parts that I want to do.
ConorAnd that will be 10 minutes compared to 60 minutes for a 30-minute episode.
BryceAlright. Is that is that how long it takes you?
ConorIt it'll it just takes you 60 minutes to to do the if I have decent audio tracks, yes. But also too, like I know that for other folks it takes like hours. Like I know that CPP casts and other folks they put like a lot more energy into editing their stuff, but like my philosophy is uh it I'd rather have like more content and lower quality. And I I still think I do a pretty decent job uh editing stuff, but there are times where you know some ums get left in and it's a little bit uh messier, but yeah, if if I have clean audio tracks, but every once in a while like is we'll have a guest on and their audio will pick up like uh echo from us, and then it takes like three times as long because I need to go silence their track when any s when any when any time anyone else is talking, and that that's like a nightmare.
BryceI would I would never I would never uh be able to do it in just now, or it would take me, it would take me uh so much longer just because I'm so much of a reflectionist. You know, it's interesting, um somewhat on topic. Um I don't think I've ever told you about the first time I used Audacity, um, which was uh when like sometime in the 90s, my grandmother recorded some conversations with her mother, my great-grandmother, who was the family member who was born in Russia and immigrated to the US um through Poland in the um the 1910s, 1920s, uh when it became not super safe to be Jewish in uh Russia.
BryceAnd so my my grandmother made these recordings um towards the end of my great-grandmother's life of her talking about her life in uh in Russia, but these were made on you know an old cassette tape. Um and uh I got interested in family history in the like 2010s era, and I got told about these tapes, and um somebody had remarked, like, hey, we should really digitize these because they're it the tapes are like 20 years old at this point, and the the quality may have degraded.
BryceAnd so I went and did that, and there was one, the record the initial recording was not particularly good because it was like recording done at a party, um, and it was like a mess. Um but then two, there was also some like degradation to the cassette tape itself. So there was like this, like every like three or four seconds, there was this like background like blip noise that was just from some damage caused to the tape. Um and it was like maybe maybe like an hour, an hour and a half of content. But I I got this device that would like digitize from a cassette tape, and then like I loaded it up into Audacity, and I went through and I must have spent like a week like carefully editing out every like three or four seconds this little blip of the bad audio.
BryceAnd I didn't know anything about audio editing, so I'm sure that somebody who was qualified could have done this a lot faster. But um I recently had uh uh dinner with one of my distant cousins, and I told her about this tape, and her her great-grandfather was the brother of my great-grandmother, and so she was very interested in it. And so I dug up my you know, digitized version of the recording, and I was gonna just send it with her, but then I was like, hey, you know, maybe I can get like an uh an audio transcription of it.
BryceAnd I uploaded it to this thing, Otter AI. Um, and uh it was super cool because not only did it give me a pretty good transcription of the audio, um, but it also gave me like a summary, um, and it you like it caught a few things that I hadn't because like I'd listened to the recording, but like, you know, I hadn't like taken notes or anything. Um and so like it caught a few things in its AI, like its summary of the whole conversation that I hadn't realized that were like important details.
BryceUm it was just like it was a super uh uh fascinating tool. And um Ramona, uh when we were in Poland, she got some, she made some recordings of some of her family members talking about their family history. Um, with the with the idea being that we'll also feed it into this this AI tool. Um yeah, it was it was it was really cool. Like I couldn't I wouldn't have been able to get that sort of summary and transcript um you know 10, 15 years ago.
ConorYeah, it's and uh yeah, we should mention Whisper too, which is uh anyone that's a programmer can go and look it up in Python. You can use it as like a command line tool and just you feed it any MP4, MP3, and it just does like auto transcribing. Umce again, like it's not it's not perfect, but that's that's where like we're headed is. I've actually thought about trying to add bad transcripts because I don't have the patience to go through and like touch up the mistakes, but like that's another thing. Like we don't have transcripts on ADSP. We looked into it, it's exorbitantly expensive, or like from what I think it should cost, uh, because we don't we don't collect any advertising money from this stuff, and we could go spend the money, but like it's it's not free at some point, like perfect uh transcriptions.
ConorI mean, technically, we're recording this in Teams right now. We could hit the record button and transcribe button, and then we could copy and paste that, and that does like a pretty good job.
BryceI actually do think we it automatically does the recording and transcribing. So it does we do have the transcriptions from teams.
ConorYeah, but the the problem is is that it doesn't I have to go and fix it because we're gonna dice this up, right? Whereas what I want to be able to do is like feed it the finished MP3, and that's the other thing, is some people have requested uh video and for us to upload it to YouTube of us chatting. But once again, like I edit the audio, and like having to edit the video would like increase the amount of work by a factor of like four or five. However, imagine you can just feed it a uh edited audio clip with the original video and just say, like, cut my video so that it matches what I did to the and like in the future, probably it's just one whole AI thing.
ConorI drop something in, it goes and cuts everything out. So, like, there's gonna be steps along the way, but the point being is there's a bunch of stuff that we don't currently do that we could do for free with AI, and a lot of the stuff that I do do currently, like I won't have to do, and like so I am just extremely excited because I have like 17 different things on the go at all times, and like I'm going to free myself up like hours of time a week. Anyways, that doesn't mean that we need to upload AI podcasts, though. The point being we're not gonna do it again.
BryceYou'll hear from us if we want to talk about something, and uh, anyways, that's that's but I'm not I'm not sorry that we tried it. I'm not sorry that we tried it.
ConorI'm not sorry we tried it either. Uh I'm not I'm not sure also too. We said we were gonna, or at least I was gonna provide a little bit of commentary on what our goals were. I mean, I think we wanted to highlight not just that these AI tools were cool, but you know, I think some of the content that was covered by Izzy. I I meant to say this earlier too. We added, or I added, an audio uh clip at the beginning of the episode that a lot of you might not have heard, so it's worth repeating it here. That Izzy, the author of the blog, after having listened to the episode, reached out and said that uh it didn't capture the essence of the blog correctly, and that if you uh do want to refer to anything from that episode, you should really go find the corresponding content from the blog itself.
ConorSo we'll link the blog again. Uh don't refer to our source as like the um official source because it's not. It's it's just a transformed version.
BryceAnd and we're we're sorry, Izzy. We we um you know, we should have should have checked with you and it's a lot of fun.
ConorI actually did try to reach out to Izzy beforehand. Uh uh Izzy's not on Twitter. I went to Mastodon, uh found Izzy on Mastodon, but they don't allow, or I'm not I'm not sure how Mastodon really works, but I'm on uh I'm on a different server than Izzy is and I couldn't DM uh there or there weren't DMs available. Anyways, I gave up after like 10 or 15 minutes and uh I shouldn't have done that. Anyways, everything's all good there, but the point being is uh refer back to the blog, not not to the the podcast. Anyways, but we did want to shine a light on some of that stuff, and I think it was frustrating for me when I was reading the blog because we both have intentionally decided not to talk on the podcast explicitly about a lot of this stuff, because this is now the nth time, I don't know how many times this stuff has come up, and I think this was kind of the straw that broke the camel's back for me.
ConorNot to the point where I wanted to have a whole episode where we talked about this stuff, but enough that I wanted to shed some light on Izzy's blog post. And it was the straw that broke the camel's back for me. I mean, I already, I don't know if I've ever said this, you know, on this podcast, but I made a decision back in 2021 that I was never gonna attend a committee meeting again. And there's a couple conferences that I also chose that I'm not gonna uh attend again unless you know changes were made. And the reason this was the straw that breaks the camel back is that there's a number of individuals who I will not name that I try to avoid for reasons.
ConorAnd that list of people I can no longer count on one hand, and it is it it's it's not even something that like really I am uh the most affected by, but I am affected by it. I run into these people at conferences, and I would prefer not to interact with these folks. And you have no idea who's gonna show up at a conference when you go there. And this year, I won't name, I went to many conferences this year, but this year I ran into people on this list that I would prefer to avoid. And it is unfortunate when this stuff comes up and then nothing happens about it.
ConorI go to a conference, and in the back of my head, I have to think like, am I gonna run into one of these people that I do not want to have interactions with? And this is my personal opinion here. It is a privilege, in my opinion, to be able to be a part of these communities. It is not, it is not something that like everyone is owed as a right, you know, just because you exist in society. I think that like if I'm organizing a conference, which I do not, but if I did, I would want to be creating a safe space that folks feel safe and welcome in. And if there are people that are showing up at these conferences, like that violate that safe space, uh, I'd prefer them not to be there.
ConorAnd I don't think that it is like, like I said, this is just my personal opinion that like I don't think it is uh you're doing something wrong by like having a not welcome at my conference because you make other people uncomfortable due to things that you've done in the past. Anyways, and and so all that to be said is that like there's multiple times where we have had private conversations about like do we want to talk about this on the podcast? We've always come to the decision that's similar to CPP cast, we'd rather talk about technical stuff or fun stuff or catching up than like these topics that are not fun topics to talk about. And this time I, you know, I talked to you about this, I talked to other folks about this before we posted it, and I decided that like it wasn't worth staying silent this time, at least as far as posting an AI summary of it counts as like not staying silent.
ConorBecause like we technically didn't say anything. And even to the this extent right now, like a part of me feels guilty that like you know, I'm I'm being very vague about everything. I'm not actually calling people out. I'm not I'm not saying specifics, I'm just saying that like personally, I think this stuff sucks. I think that like every single time this comes up, nothing and ends up changing. And there was like a specific incident that happened at a at the C national body, which I'm not gonna get into the details about, but I was not the only I didn't publicly cut uh step down from the national body, but there was another individual who I'm not sure if they want to be named.
ConorWe haven't talked to them, so I'm not going to name them. But at the time, they quite publicly talked about how they were really disappointed about what had what was happening. I was just as disappointed, if not more, and I lost a lot of respect for people that I I have respect for. And this is it's uh, you know, attending these committee meetings, you know, contributing to the evolution of C was just something I was like no longer interested in. Which is just it's a it's a personal decision, right? Like everyone can make their own decisions on this kind of stuff. Anyways, I feel like I feel like I've kind of said everything I've wanted to say. The point being is that in the future, no more AI podcast summaries.
ConorIf we do want to talk about this stuff, you will hear directly from us. And uh, you know, if some of this stuff happens in the future and you're wondering, oh, how come Bryce and Connor, do not think for like a second that we don't know that this stuff happens, and then we don't privately discuss whether or not we think about um whether we should discuss. Because we always do. Yeah.
BryceIt's just sometimes it's it's hard. And you know, it's um I think some number of people here know in the past that uh I've I I was I pretty publicly resigned as the program chair from CPPCon because of uh disagreements with other people in CPPCon leadership about certain decisions were made uh regarding, you know, uh certain people attending the conference. And I I think maybe the better way to put it is like I s I resigned as the program chair from CPPCon because there was a disagreement with me and other leaders about values.
BryceAnd uh and even just my resignation where I didn't air a lot of dirty laundry, I just sort of resigned. Um even just that, there was a ton of blowback and uh and nothing really came out of it. And I I I am always hesitant uh about like when should I speak up, uh when you know, like when when is it appropriate and moral to do so?
BryceBecause like, yes, on the one hand, I do feel an obligation uh to speak up when there's something like a safety concern, but like on the other hand, you know, if I'm if I learn about something in a context that's privileged, you know, I don't necessarily want to betray that trust. And also, it's not always my story to to to tell. And in a lot of cases, there have been things where, you know, i i I don't want to be speaking up because uh it's not my story, and you know, I I instead would encourage the person that if they want to, they can't.
ConorYeah, if they want to. Because uh some of the times the people involved in these incidents, they would they just want it to be forgotten about.
BryceBecause there's so much blowback. Because if people do speak up, there's so much blowback. And uh and and so in a lot of cases, what happens when there's a controversy like this is that people the people who are wronged try to get something to be done behind the scenes because they don't want to have the the controversy, the the the the blowback that they get from from sharing it publicly, but they want some change. Um but then you know nothing happens, and then eventually they get frustrated, and then they decide it's time to go and share something publicly.
BryceBut not everybody not everybody feels comfortable doing that.
ConorAnd the the other thing I want to add to is that a lot of the comments and like negative feedback, not with respect to the AI, but with respect to the content that talks about the unethical behavior and whatnot, is this kind of well, we're only hearing one side. I how should I say this? I do not want to go into details of how I know what I know, but uh of the folks that are on my list of people that I try to avoid, I'm not sure Bryce, we're not gonna get into the specifics of this, but I d I'm not sure if you remember at one point before the incident with this individual that I'm thinking of, which you might I'm being so vague, you might not even know what I'm referring to.
ConorThis individual they got we'll say promoted. That's not actually what happened, but we'll use the word promoted to something. And I was upset. I immediately messaged you. They were a nice enough person, but they had done some things that I was I don't know what the words are, like not okay with, but like uh wasn't comfortable with. And not not things that were necessarily code of conduct violations, uh, but things that like made me kind of like raise my eyebrows.
ConorLike, really, is this uh the kind of thing that you should be doing at a conference? And anyways, then this person got quote unquote promoted. I immediately messaged you and said, Should I talk to the conference organizer about my discomfort around this? And then we both chatted about it and we're conflicted, and like, well, we're not really in like I'm not on the board of this conference, I'm not super involved, like it's not my what who is what is my place to say that like I think that this is kind of an odd pick, and and also too, like what would I say? Like a couple things were done that made me feel weird or like uncomfortable.
ConorLike there was no actual code of conduct violations. I never spoke up at the time that the things happened because I didn't think they were worthy. It was just stuff that kind of made my you know, the hairs on the back of my neck stand up. Which it doesn't seem like enough to go and say, like, oh, I have a hunch. Fast forward, like what I don't know what it was, a year or two years, you know, and now they're on my list of folks. And I remember talking to you after the fact, and I felt like I felt bad. It's like we talked about this. It's like I had my suspicions, and then something ended up happening, and I never said anything before.
ConorAnd it's like, well, we talked about it. It's like, what are you gonna say? It's like when there's something that's not a code of conduct violation, but that is just kind of like it doesn't feel great, it doesn't like it makes you uncomfortable. Are the like I think we even chatted about like should there be something like less than a code of conduct violation, but more of like a let your anonymously like your friendly conference goer know that you did something that kind of made someone uncomfortable. And it's like, I would always prefer to know if I've done something that made someone well uncomfortable, especially if it's like a zero cost thing to me.
ConorMaybe I use some word or I I use some phrase. It was it was similar to that like uh YouTube comment that one time where I had used the words final solution as the name of a function in a YouTube video, and then I got a couple different comments being like, ah, great video, but like don't use final solution. And I was like, what? Like, I guess it's vague. I could have been more descriptive, and I had no idea. I was not did not pay enough attention attention in history class that like it's a reference to the Holocaust and link in the w uh show notes. The point being is that like that kind of stuff I would prefer to be brought to my attention because it's an easy enough thing for me to avoid, and it if it makes other people feel more comfortable, perfect.
ConorIt's not it's not like you know, uh censorship or like oh I can't say the thing. I don't care. Like it's not important to me to be able to say that. So the point being is that like I I don't want like people to be scared about you know what they're saying or the words they're using at a conference, but like I I think a lot of folks, if they were told that they said something or did something that just kind of like a little bit made someone uncomfortable and that there was a healthy way that they didn't feel like they were being accused, everyone would want to know I think everyone would want to know that information without thinking that like we're headed into like big brother territory or whatever. My point being of this long winded ramble is that is that like I I saw this happening like in slow.
ConorMotion and was not surprised at all that this happened. So it's like it's like some people are like, oh well, we haven't heard the other side of the story. I don't need to hear the other side of the story. Like I was already uncomfortable with some of the stuff this this individual had done in the past before they made my list of like short list of people that I want to avoid.
BryceAnd I mean like I do me personally, yeah, I always want to hear if I've said something that might uh offend or upset someone. And and uh to me, it's very low cost to change our language. And that's you know, I I used to a few years ago I worked on the the Insights Inclusive Terminology uh standard, which still work that I'm pretty proud of because I feel like like I why would I want to use language that has ambiguity? Like like setting aside an immoral argument.
BryceIf if I've said something in a way to you that you've taken some second meaning from it that I didn't intend, like y yes, I may have unintentionally hurt you, but also like I've just been unclear in how I've communicated. Like I'm I'm a whenever we're talking about naming stuff, I'm a big believer in avoiding what I call like like uh uh semantic overloading. Like, you know, using a word like uh in concurrency, like the word task.
BryceLike you should almost never call something task, because task just like it means so many different things to so many different people. Like there was a proposal for a thing, uh a sender's uh facility that was gonna be called std task. And uh I was like, no God, we can't call that std task. Like, like that's just that's gonna have so many different meanings to so many different people. Like just pick a different word. You know, like you just you why would you wanna pick a term that's gonna have so much ambiguity and and when you could instead, like there's so there's so many words out there.
BryceLike search for a different word that won't have this overload. And that's sort of how I feel about um like you know, uh inclusive terminology in the language that we pick. It's like why not just be as clear and unambiguous as possible. And I I I am sympathetic to the people who get that feeling that they are that they're being watched or that like they have to that they're being policed, that what they're saying is being policed. Like I get that, I understand that. And I understand that some some people feel a fear that that they're gonna be attacked for what they've said.
BryceAnd I think it's important that when somebody does say something that might be offensive to you, that we assume good faith unless there is evidence otherwise. Like, you know, assume that the person didn't mean to do that, and if you want to tell them about it, tell them about it in a you know uh a nice way, um, not you know, a way that's gonna, you know, feel like they're being attacked. Um, because then that will make people less afraid, feel less policed.
BryceUm, you know, it's more like constructive criticism. It's like if there's a ty if there's a type the same in the same way, if there's a typo in my slides, of course I want to hear about that. You know?
ConorYeah. Yeah, it's like like I said, it's the reminds me of the YouTube comments, because they weren't harsh about it. They said, great video, like really enjoyed this. However, like only piece of feedback is would prefer if you didn't use you know that name of a function. And they didn't even like explain, and then that that was like the I they didn't go, they they weren't even they they were too nice. They they they could have done said that and then dropped the link so that I uh uh because yeah, like I said, it's uh as long as you do it in a nice way. I think a lot of this stuff are like super low cost to like it's not the end of the world.
ConorAnd every every once in a while still I I will find myself, especially when I'm iterating, if I'm not even if I'm not naming a function the final solution, I might I might refer to some solution that I'm working up to as the final solution. And and like I literally, like in the last couple weeks, I've been recording a bunch of Aven of Code YouTube videos, and a couple times I've said that, and you know, I just pause while I'm recording, and I think one time I referred to it as solution two, or the other time I referred to it as the ultimate solution. Like it's the final solution to me, sure. Um do I mean anything bad by it? Absolutely not.
ConorBut like should I be getting upset about the fact that I'm I need to avoid it, or it takes me a couple extra seconds to like change my verbiage? I don't think so. Like it it there's a bunch of other things that I can refer to it and have the basically identical semantics, and nothing, there's zero cost to me in terms of like the educational or the entertainment value. Anyways, we're kind of off on a tangent here, but um the point is no more AI. We've we the people have spoken and we have listened. But also, too, uh I don't want in the in the midst of the AI it to get lost that uh there's there's there's a problem and it's not being fixed.
ConorUm we're not even really advocating for any solutions. Um I think in general I've kind of my involvement in CS C has just my my decision has just been to kind of step back from that. Primarily like I I write in Python for my research work these days.
BryceAnd it's funny because I'm doing more and more Python stuff too.
ConorYeah, and even over the last couple years, like the the main I'll be honest, the main reason I still go to C conferences is because the majority, 99.9% of the C community, in terms of speakers and attendees and you know listeners of this podcast, I love interacting with that community. And it is sad that I have to like miss out on that and not interact with that community. So that that's why I go to conferences like CPP North, where um I know that like they're really prioritizing uh welcomeness and safety, and there's a couple other conferences that are really trying to do that.
ConorAnd that's that is the beautiful thing about the C community. There are a ton of conferences, way more than any one person, although I'm sure some people have tried, if you're a dev advocate, to hit all uh in one year. And so you can choose the the one or two that you want to go to. And then I've just been prioritizing other conference circuits, to be honest, which is which is sad. Like there are some folks that I I really enjoy seeing, and uh we'll see less of because of this. But yeah, and until that change, or if that changes, um you know that that's kind of my personal decision.
ConorIt's sad to say it is what it is. Uh, you know, I hope that the people in charge do the right thing. I have zero trust that that's gonna happen though, because this has not been going this is not like the first time. This has been happening for years now, and I've seen that the right thing typically doesn't happen. At least at a certain level. There are certain conferences that have really, really tried to prioritize doing the right thing. And those those are the conferences that I'm gonna, you know, spend my time if if I'm going to one or two C conferences a year, those are the ones that I'm gonna prioritize.
ConorI'm not sure if you have any final thoughts. This is probably gonna be a super long episode because it's gonna be hard to chop this up into two things. So we'll probably just be one and done.
BryceAny final thoughts? Uh no, I've I've been desperate to talk to you about Python and algorithm stuff.
ConorAll right, so end of episode 212. That was fifty-eight minutes of recording, folks. I'm probably gonna trim it down to hopefully 40 or 45. Be sure to check these show notes either in your podcast app or at adspthepodcast.com for links to anything we mentioned in today's episode, as well as a link to a GitHub discussion where you can leave thoughts, comments, and questions. Thanks for listening. We hope you enjoyed and have a great day.
BryceLow quality, high quality, that is the tagline of our podcast.
ConorThat's not the tagline. Our tagline is chaos with sprinkles of information.
In this episode, Conor and Bryce chat with Zach Laine about C++26 Reflection vs CRTP, AI, kids & more. Link to Episode 313 on Website Discuss this episode, leave a comment, or ask a question (on GitHub) Socials ADSP:...
In this episode, Conor and Bryce chat with Zach Laine about the C++26 contracts fiasco. Link to Episode 312 on Website Discuss this episode, leave a comment, or ask a question (on GitHub) Socials ADSP: The Podcast:...
In this episode, Conor and Bryce talk with Zach Laine about his career and the career changes he has made. Link to Episode 311 on Website Discuss this episode, leave a comment, or ask a question (on GitHub) Socials...
In this episode, Conor and Bryce talk about Bryce's next chapter and where he is leaving NVIDIA for. Link to Episode 310 on Website Discuss this episode, leave a comment, or ask a question (on GitHub) Socials ADSP: The...
In this episode, Conor and Ben chat with Jason Turner about default construction in C++. Link to Episode 309 on Website Discuss this episode, leave a comment, or ask a question (on GitHub) Socials ADSP: The Podcast:...