Episode 24: C++Now 2021 with Ben Deane & Tony Van Eerd
1 hr 4 minAudio
In this episode, Conor has a conversation with Ben Deane and Tony Van Eerd while at C++Now 2021. About the Guests: For Ben Deane, C++ wasn’t even among the first 10 languages that he learned on his programming journey, but it’s been the one that has paid the bills for the last 20-odd years. He spent most of that time in the games industry; many of the games he worked on used to be fondly remembered but now he’s accepted that they are probably mostly forgotten. These days he works in the finance industry writing high-frequency trading platforms in the most modern C++ that compilers can support. In his spare time he watches a lot of YouTube’s educational sector, practices the Japanese art of tsundoku, reads about the history of programming, avoids doing DIY, and surprises his wife by waking in the middle of the night yelling, “of course, it’s a monad!” before going back to sleep and dreaming of algorithms. Tony Van Eerd has been coding for well over 25 years, and hopefully coding well for most of that. Previously at Inscriber, Adobe, and BlackBerry, he now enables Painting with Light at Christie Digital. He is on the C++ Committee. He is a Ninja and a Jedi. Show Notes Date Recorded: 2021-05-06 Date Released: 2021-05-07 C++Now 2018: Ben Deane “Easy to Use, Hard to Misuse: Declarative Style in C++” C++Now 2017: Ben Deane & Jason Turner “constexpr ALL the things!” Conor Hoekstra - ITM: My least favorite anti-pattern Functional C++ for Fun and Profit by Phil Nash YOW! 2013 Kevlin Henney - The SOLID Design Principles Deconstructed Breaking Dependencies: The SOLID Principles - Klaus Iglberger - CppCon 2020 SOLID Revisited: The State of the Matter - Phil Nash [ACCU 2021] C++Now 2017: Tony Van Eerd “Postmodern C++” C++Now 2018: Tony Van Eerd “Words of Wisdom” One Letter Programming Languages C++Now 2019: Conor Hoekstra “Algorithm Intuition” Simple Made Easy 2012 - Rich Hickey Slow Coding - Ben Deane; A View to a Thing - Jason Turner - 2020-10-11 The larger the island of knowledge, the longer the shoreline of wonder. LadyBug Podcast Intro Song Info Miss You by Sarah Jansen https://soundcloud.com/sarahjansenmusic Creative Commons - Attribution 3.0 Unported - CC BY 3.0 Free Download / Stream: http://bit.ly/l-miss-you Music promoted by Audio Library https://youtu.be/iYYxnasvfx8
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
ConorIt's all right. You're the uh you're the two-time best presentation winner of C now, so well they are named after him, the Tony Awards. Are they the are they called the Tony Awards?
Ben DeaneUh unofficially.
ConorI did not know that. Welcome to ABSP the podcast episode 24, recorded on May 6, 2021. My name is Connor, and on today's episode it's just me interviewing Ben Dean and Tony Van Faired on the first day of C Now 2021. I also want to quickly apologize for my echoey poor audio in this episode.
ConorI just moved into a new apartment and did not realize how much echo there was, so I will be sure to fix this for episode 25, but for this episode, you'll have to bear with me. Tuning in live from C Now 2021. We were supposed to have four people here. Uh we currently have two. Uh I'm here with Ben Dean, whose voice you may have heard in the pre-intro. And Tony may or may not be showing up. Um, I'm not sure, Ben, for those of our listeners that don't know you, uh, do you want to introduce yourself?
Ben DeaneSure. Um, I am probably known in the C community for a few of my talks, which I've done in the last five or so years at C now and CPPCon. Uh I worked in the games industry for 20 odd years, and I now work in the finance industry. I've been uh something which just went out of my head. I've I've been on CPPcast a couple of times.
ConorYep. That probably well, so I mentioned this. I'm not sure how we're gonna cut this up or if it's gonna be mentioned twice. So yeah, um the reason why we were we were trying to get both Ben and Tony, because they're they're quite well known, I think at C now. Ben in both if correct me if I get the years wrong, 2017 and 2018, um 2018, I believe, was the talk with Jason Turner. You won uh best best talk of the conference, or was that reversed?
Ben DeaneYeah, 2017 was the Contexper All the Things talk. Yep. Which was Jason and and me having a lot of fun. Uh 2018 was my declarative style talk.
ConorYeah, easy, easy to use, hard to misuse. That's probably one of my top five favorite talks of all time. Um, it was it was the genesis of my love for the immediately invoked uh lambda expression, which if uh I'm not sure if I've mentioned it on this podcast, but I had seen it before, but this speaks to sort of like where you are in your learning curve. Like it didn't hit me like I didn't, I think before that really appreciate what expressions versus statements were. Anyways, it was in that talk that I saw that and I was like, oh my goodness, this is amazing.
ConorUm, because at that point I think I'd known that other languages like Kotlin have if expressions, which are quite nice.
Ben DeaneI think Rust has the same thing now. Right. And now you have been very prolific in your speaking career, and you've you've given names to some of these things, like the the initialize then modify anti-pattern.
ConorYeah, well, I'm not sure. It's it's really just um like I I realized after the fact that Jason had basically given a quasi-same version of that talk. So I've given a talk called my least favorite anti-pattern where I termed ITM. Um and then after that, and it's all just about whenever you initialize a variable and then immediately modify it, if you can avoid that, like there's some cases where you're writing an algorithm with a for loop in it, which is not a raw for loop, it's just a for loop. And uh you're obviously going to have variables that you're you're modifying.
ConorBut in in the greater scope of things, a lot of times it's unnecessary. And if you can sort of uh try to avoid that pattern, I think it leads to more readable declarative code. And then I ended up watching Jason Turner's and also too, we've may mentioned Jason's uh name. I I assume like 80% of our audience knows, but Jason is also a speaker, um, and he's a C trainer, and um he is the co-host of probably the like the premier C podcast, CPP cast, which is one of my favorite podcasts as well.
ConorJason and Rob.
Ben DeaneJason gave a good talk at C now a couple of was it yesterday or the day before?
ConorYeah, it was um what was the title of the talk? Uh, because I've I've renamed it in my head to a different title.
Ben DeaneThe worst best practices.
ConorYes, yeah. I I after the fact it said it's uh the the longer title is probably uh Jason Turner's uh 20 year history in C and How to Self-Publish a Book. Um Right. Because he sort of talks about that. But yeah, that was probably one of the better talks. I so I guess yeah, we're we're hopping all over here. But anyway, to wrap up the last bit, well, this is what ADSP is though. Uh Jason basically gave a talk on uh best practices, and then while watching it, because I I never saw it live, I was watching it on YouTube. I was like, half of his talk is basically just a different statement of what I'm saying, and so now I'm I'm basically just plagiarizing, which is what I do in all my talks, anyways.
ConorThat's a good that's a good way to to give good talks, is just find other good talks and then cut those all up.
Ben DeaneYes, I've I do the same in the sense that well, I've sort of learned that um it's almost not possible to repeat a good idea enough. Like it always bears repetition, it always bears another talk, which brings a little bit extra. Um at the end of the day, a lot there's a lot of us who are speaking about things like strong typing, uh declarative code, expressive code. Um we all have our own takes on it. And it feels like you know, if you look if if I look back at the talks I've given, it feels to me like I've said the same thing multiple times.
Ben DeaneI'm sure it feels that way to a lot of people who give talks, they're sort of rehashing the same ideas. But you know, if they're good ideas, and I think they are, then repetition is warranted.
ConorYeah, and it's that's the thing, right? Is people when you're giving a talk, at least this is my experience from like both giving and watching, is that um different it the talk is gonna hit people different, uh, different ways, like depending on where they are on their learning journey. Like um, I think a lot of my talks, if you're just starting out, it's gonna be you know, over some of the folks in the audience's head. Um, and then for other folks, I'm just repeating things that they learned 10 years ago.
ConorAnd it's like, oh, this is sort of entertaining, but from an educational perspective, on an individual basis for them, they haven't learned much. Um, and then there's another proportion where it just sort of blows their mind and then opens their eyes. And um, there are that's the thing, is like Phil I I sort of have told this anecdote before is that Phil Nash gave a talk called um uh functional C for fun and profit back in like 2016 or 2017, which covered a lot of the same themes in your uh declarative talk, easy to use, hard to misuse.
ConorUm but when I watched Phil's talk, I wasn't like I wasn't ready to accept everything he like, I just I didn't have enough uh of like a knowledge foundation. And so, anyways, that speaks to the repeatability.
Ben DeaneUm the other thing I see and I've sort of come to terms with is the fact that you know nobody owns an idea. And so when I'm making a talk or when I'm having ideas about what to put into a talk, often I make the talk and then I see like other talks, maybe even that are coming up around the same time that are talking about what seem like exactly the same idea. And you know, there's no, like I say, nobody owns an idea. So someone else could totally independently create a talk which has a large overlap.
Ben DeaneI used to worry about that. Now I see that as a sign of like, okay, if if other people are having these same ideas, then it means probably that the the zeitgeist of C is ready for this. Like this is a good sign, not a not a sign of like plagiarism or other people scooping me or anything like that.
ConorRight. And like that's exactly what happened with uh one of the three, the Girdle, Turing, and uh church, right? They all came up with the same idea. Oh, right, yeah, back in the what is it, 30s, early 40s. And uh that was the funny thing, right? Because I'm I'm gonna mess up, or maybe you do you know the story of which person uh disagreed with one of the others, and then like I believe it was Girdle who took a lot of convincing. Yeah, and and when he found out that his uh whatever statement of the problem was the same as I think it was Turing's, he said, Well, obviously I'm wrong then.
ConorUm because he's definitely wrong. So if ours is the same thing, I must also be wrong. And then it took him a while to realize that oh no, Turing was Turing was correct, and I'm also correct, and they're the same thing, which I thought that's a funny thing that first you think they're different, then you think they're the same, then because you think his is wrong, you must also be wrong.
Ben DeaneYeah. I mean, what you said about you know, a talk just hitting someone at the right time in their learning journey is totally rings true with me. Also, it's a case that you know you can watch a talk and and and kind of not get all of it. But having watched it later on when you watch another talk, that's when another talk can actually like put a light bubble on your head about the first talk.
ConorYeah. Yeah, there's there's tons of dotted lines between um, well, I mean, if if you for those that haven't attended the conference, uh Tony gave uh Tony Van Eard, who may or may not join in a couple minutes, he might be working on his lightning talk uh for later today. Uh he gave a keynote yesterday where uh he showed a bunch of dotted lines um in between his solid revisited talk and what were all the talks he mentioned? Um uh Phil Nash's talk, um Klaus Eagleberger.
ConorI think I'm pronouncing that correctly. I apologize.
Ben DeaneKlaus Eagleberger.
ConorUm and then Kevlin Henney's given a solid talk as well. Um and he and then he went on to mention a bunch of other talks, like um Rich Hickeys, who's the creator of Clojure. He has a famous um oh look, there's the man the myth, the legend. Oh, while Tony appears. We were just talking about your keynote, Tony. Um and also, too, do you even do we just assume all the listeners know who you are? There might be a few like Swift developers that um have no one knows who I am. That's what I assume.
Ben DeaneThat's not true. Well I've come to yes, through working in the games industry, I've come to uh take this take this tack as well.
ConorAll right, so Tony, you should I guess uh briefly introduce yourself to the uh either C developers that um have never watched any talks online because I assume yours has got to be like in the first five talks that people watch. Uh well if I had to, if you're telling me I have to introduce myself, then let's just say everyone knows me. Uh I'm on the committee, C committee. I've worked at interesting places like Adobe, BlackBerry. I still find BlackBerry was an interesting place. Um, small places, big places.
ConorI know at Christie I do uh projection mapping, which is really cool stuff. And uh yeah, I give talks every now and then, seem to people like them. So I keep doing it. Yes, if you haven't seen postmodern C or Words of Wisdom, those are also two of my favorite talks um of all time. Very and I think I've seen uh the postmodern one like three or four times now, because you gave it once at C now, once at CPPCon, where it started to rhyme. And then I think you also gave it at the prog meetup at the last in-person C ISO meeting.
ConorYeah, rest in peace to uh three to three times, uh, and it's different every time. And uh you know, you gotta watch the next one. Then you can put piece together the secret message that I've left behind and all the variations. So I guess should we talk how or how are folks how are you liking virtual C now? What are the best talks? How did you you so Ben has not spoken this year, but uh Tony did give a keynote called Solid Revisited that we mentioned before him joining.
ConorWhat are how are people feeling? How was how was given your keynote? Well, you know what? That's the thing. I uh I have no idea. Like I to be honest, I didn't want to do uh virtual anything, right? Because it just feels like giving talks. I don't know if people realize giving talks is actually hard, right? It takes effort, and it really drains you. And then at the end, though, you're like, oh, this was really cool, this was fun, it was worth all the all the pain that you went through to do it, and and uh it's usually a good experience.
ConorBut this time it's all virtual, you don't feel the audience, you don't know what's going on, and then it's over, and you're like, huh? Have no idea what happened, right? Um but uh CBP C now is like one of my favorite conferences, so I wanted to make sure we it had a good year this year. I thought I had no idea if there was gonna be lots of talks or hardly any talks or what was gonna happen to it. So I'm like, I'm gonna put in a talk. I wasn't planning on doing a keynote, but uh thought I'll I'll do a talk, do my part, show up. But now I haven't seen any talks since then because as is tradition, I see no talks before my talk because I'm too busy doing my slides.
ConorAnd then uh I was gonna I've just been busy today, as as I forgot even that I was gonna talk to you guys. I was busy doing stuff. Um I'm going to see Lisa's talk, right? Lisa Lippincott is my my favorite speaker, maybe possibly my top one of my top five, you know, one of my favorite speakers. I love the stuff that she talks about. It's it's a little some people find it a little more theoretical and and whatnot or whatever. It's it's uh kind of very foundational talks of how what it what is a function, you know, like what is a program?
ConorUh but I love it. Just just love it. So I'm gonna go to her talk. That's tomorrow. And that's that's that's been my I had I had like two at least two talks circled. I wanted to see Barry's talk on uh ranges and stuff, and he was comparing different languages, but uh we were all sitting around at one of those little weird that was during the yesterday when we were when we all ended up at a virtual table. And we were in the hallway track. In the hallway track, yeah, which has always been the best track of C now. Um so I didn't see Barry's talk yet, but I will watch it later.
ConorIt's good.
Ben DeaneI watched it last night. Yeah and uh yeah, it he did a really good job comparing C and C and Rust and and D. And he sort of put them on a functionality versus uh complexity curve. I think it was a very sort of good comparison and breakdown.
ConorIt had the uh from finance, I think it's called the efficient frontier. It's a sort of curved line, and you put we won't spoil it, but D and C and Rust get ranked, and then we can spoil the fact that Java was below the efficient frontier. So you know, they there was a time when you you look at their uh iterator, right? And it's it doesn't feel like an iterator the way we know iterators, it really is just it's it's the it it is the collection, right?
ConorIt's it's their iterators feel it's like where you pull the value out of, and and it's like, is there another one? And then you get the next value, and and the like our C what Eric did with sentinels, right, with ranges, and he said, you know, begin end iterator, let's make the end not really an iterator. It can be a sentinel now, it doesn't have to be an iterator. It is just a big hack. Like that is a hack. It's a beautiful, beautiful hack, right? It's like now your end iterator, if it was because people used to do this in the past where your iterator had to be special, right?
ConorIt's it's not really the end, it just has a flag inside of it to say when I do the comparison, I will do the real check for for end. Um, and that was also a hack. Eric has made that hack, uh, you know, he stamped it as official now, and it's great. But but I I wonder if it's all I've run under this before that two iterators is wrong, just not the right way to go. So that's why I wanted to see Barry's talk. Um like in fact, like when you have the example is when you have an infinite range, right?
ConorI've got all the numbers, right? Now we can now do that with with C ranges. This range never ends. It's got an end iterator, but it's a fake iterator. And and uh, you know, if you're doing a zip or something else, you can you can zip infinite numbers with a finite vector, and now you've got a number for each item in the vector or whatever you want, right? Um that end iterator is just fake. It's the whole thing is is a lie. So why do we why do we force our iteration in our ranges to have a begin-end when that's a lie, right?
ConorIt should be one object that you ask, are we at the end yet? But uh we wanted to fit it in with what we already had, and so it works really well. It's really it's it is, it's really good. But it's also, you know, I I wondered, like maybe we shouldn't have gone done it this way. Maybe we should have, but I think if Eric had done the new ranges any other way, it wouldn't have happened. So it's the right way to do things. Yeah, there are also there's my there's my hot take.
Ben DeaneMy hot take. Did you need a hot take? I was that's a good one. It's good for the ratings. Sentinels are a hack. Yeah, that's what Tony says. Um, but there are some surprises there, you're right. When I remember playing with ranges the first time and getting that sort of surprise because um yeah, and a half infinite range, like natural numbers, it can be it has a bi-directional iterator, right? Because we know how to move it backwards and forwards, but you can't reverse it. So so you know that intuition kind of gets upended.
Ben DeaneLike we expect to be able to reverse something with a bi-directional iterator, but if you don't have a start place, you can't you can reverse it, you just can only you can't be able to read elements of it in reverse, but there's nowhere to start and say that reverse this.
ConorIt just takes you a long time, yeah. Anyways, so those are the two talks you were looking forward to. One you'll still get to see because Lisa's is this we're recording this on Thursday, Lisa's talk is on Friday, Barry's was yesterday. There's probably more that I also wanted to see, but that that's the ones that were in my head that uh, you know, if I went and looked at the schedule, I'd probably tell you, oh my god, I wanted to be at a talk right now.
Ben DeaneBut I really enjoyed um Gabor Holvath's talk from this morning about um it was about sort of compiler algorithms. Yeah, I saw that too. Uh that was I didn't see the talk.
ConorI saw a good one. Yeah, I wanted that was I I I saw that too late. I was looking this morning at the schedule and I'm like, oh, I missed something that I was kind of it looked interesting, yeah.
Ben DeaneIt wasn't so much about sort of classical algorithms as we might know them, but um he presented in particular a sort of algebra of um recurrence chains, which which the compiler uses to uh analyze loops and turn them into closed form expressions.
ConorYeah, I I there's gotta be a lot of magic going on in compilers, right? So there's there's been so many years of research into that kind of stuff.
Ben DeaneYeah. So that was a good talk. Uh there have also been a couple of good talks from um Peter Sommelat and I just saw Anthony Williams. They were talking about similar, you know, uh strong types. Strong types, yeah. Strong types.
ConorBig fan, big fan of strong types. Type types plus uh what did I say yesterday? Types plus types plus functions equals programming. That's my new thing, man. That's that's what my book my book is called types plus functions equals programming. No one's done a book with a similar name, have they? Practically the name of this podcast, which we stole from the book that uh yeah. Tony's joking. It's it's from Nicholas Virth's uh famous book, which I have not read yet. Uh Bryce and I said at some point we'll read it. You we can't steal the name of a book and call our podcast without reading it.
ConorWhat is what is the name of it? It's it's uh algorithms plus data structures equals programs. See, I I think that's almost redundant, right? You having a data structure without an algorithm tied to it isn't like they they kind of are the same, they're they're intertwined. Yeah, you know what I mean? Um, like you know, I've got a heap. Well, if I don't have the heapifying algorithms to go with it, I don't really I can't do much with this, right? I need the I need the two pieces together. Whereas types plus plus functions, that's open, that's open-ended, right?
ConorI've got I've got a string type, I've got a yeah, I've got an image type. I can write Photoshop. I meant I should have used Photoshop as an example yesterday. I want image.photoshop to be the function on my image class, right? No one makes member functions, like everyone makes everything a member function, but but Photoshop is not a member function of image. And unless unless it is, maybe I haven't looked at the Photoshop source code in a long time. Maybe that's what they've got to now. It's just like, oh yeah, just make it a member function like everything else. I'm pretty sure it's not. Sean, uh Sean allow that.
ConorYeah, he would not allow that.
Ben DeaneUm well, the other the dichotomy I've been thinking about lately is um computation plus I. Like it's a it's not as catchy, but like every program when you come down to it does computation and does Io. If it doesn't do one of those things, it's basically useless.
ConorWell, this is I I I always yesterday I was describing some threading, and I said for threads, the the you know, the rule is just don't share any data, right? People people write threads and they put locks around their data and then they try to share their data between threads. And and well, now you've slowed yourself down because they're gonna wait for each other. It's like what why did you make threads and then put them in line to wait on objects on a mutex or something? Um but You also get all these bugs and everything. But if you just hand off data to a thread and no don't share any data after that, then you don't have any problems.
ConorOf course, if you have a thread that never shares information, it's the same problem. It doesn't do it. It's out there calculating pi and then never tells you the answer. Just like, wow, great. Thanks, thread. You know? So eventually you yeah, you have to have I.O. You have to communicate data back or something, or it's kind of kind of worthless. Yeah.
Ben DeaneYeah. I think I saw a tweet a while back, which is like every program um transforms data structures until it gets the one it can print out. Yeah. Pretty much.
ConorYeah. I uh I almost think of now that like the data structures is like way less than algorithms. Because I'm falling in love with APR where they don't really they don't really have data structures, it's just an array. Yeah, I was gonna say there's vector. And then you're done.
Ben DeaneI need to apologize because Jason's talk.
ConorOh yeah. Which was another great talk. Another great talk.
Ben DeaneIt's a great talk. Jason, about two-thirds of the way through the talk, he talked about exactly what Connor's been talking about lately about the sort of foundational languages or languages that embody different computational paradigms. And he I was in the virtual audience, he sort of pulled me into his talk to say a few words. Um and I totally failed to mention APL. I was watching it because I even thought about it. You thought you didn't think it was Jason's talk. I didn't want to like interrupt and like take the mic away from him.
ConorAnyone's talk is worth being interrupted just for a short mention of APL. Um and and the the ironic thing is is I end I planned on watching Jason's talk live, uh, but I forgot that I had a podcast rehearsal for uh you know breaking news, a other podcast that I'll be on uh about array programming languages. It's I think it's gonna be called ArrayCast, um, and it's gonna it's gonna focus on languages like APLJ, um K and Q, which are lesser well known but are very popular in the finance industries. And what letter is still available?
ConorNone of them. Uh, there's actually uh I'll I'll link it in the show notes. There's an article that shows uh every single letter in the alphabet is taken. Some of them are less popular, like I think the predecessor to R, which is like a statistical language, was S.
Ben DeaneSo not many people know about S, but it was uh You're gonna have to go to non-Latin alphabets. Oh yeah.
ConorI want T. Is T T I want T. T is mine. I had this plan for you. You said you were gonna call it T E A though. So uh Yeah, I was I was tossing between the two of which which one to call it. So I wanted that pun in there. Something I wanted, you know, is it T for Tony or T for the drink, you know? But yeah, um, anyways, I ended up I ended up missing it live because I was doing some other APL stuff, and then I was watching it in the recording and then saw Ben come on talking about other languages, and I was oh, this is great.
ConorAPL is gonna get a shout out. He mentions Haskell, he mentions small talk, and then doesn't mention APL. Sorry, and my heart broke. Um this you know, C C Now has always been the conference that has is half audience participation. Like I've literally given the same talk in 45 minutes. It's an hour and a half talk at C now, and it's 45-minute talk somewhere else, right? Because I just expect it to be filled with with the audience. And I mean, I was doing a keynote and I had too much, I had too many slides.
ConorI had over 300 slides for my keynote. That was kind of scary. Um, I knew I wouldn't have time to just have a conversation with the audience, but there's actually we if we did it right, you know, we could we could have uh pretty good talks where it's like just let the audience speak live over Zoom or whatever we're using, right? Just instead of like the one version of my postmodern, the first version of postmodern, because I I went onto YouTube afterwards and fixed the uh closed captioning. And there's a point in the closed captioning where I say, you know, and it just shows up in the in the bottom, it says uh Chandler asking a question or Chandler says something, right?
ConorYeah, and then it has dot dot dot and then chandler still speaking, dot dot dot. And it's like there's it's like a minute and a half, and it's really good content. It's Chandler, right? And he's making a great point. It takes him over a minute to make this great point, and I am just standing on stage. So if you're watching on YouTube, all you get is Chandler still speaking, because you can't quite hear what he's saying, right? And then of course, someone's like, repeat the question, uh Chandler's talk for a minute, like yeah, but you know, if you had everyone had a good, you know, everyone's sitting at their desks or whatever, have have a microphone there, you can you could actually get a good conversation going, and you know, it might it might be advantageous if we did it, right?
Ben DeaneYeah, I did the captioning um I think that year um the context for all the things talk, yeah, when that went up on YouTube, I went and I curated the captioning, and I actually sort of turned up the volume, listened in my headphones so I could tell who was speaking and what they were saying, and I put them in the captions for that year. Yeah, to get most of them. But that's you're right, there were so many.
ConorChandler always sits at the very back, right? Though he's always at the very back row. Back right. That's his spot. I hate your const experts per talk, I have to officially officially hate it. Sorry. It it won the best talk. You know, my my postmodern did not win best talk. Oh the things were you the runner-up that year? Yeah, I think so. I see, so that's why. Because I was gonna say there's a don't there's a don't construct expert all the things tomorrow for David.
Ben DeaneSo yeah, I was interested in that one too. Maybe I'll watch that. Isn't it constellation though? The awards are named after you. Yeah, well, it's and then along comes Connor the next year and sweeps the board.
ConorHe made up new new categories that only he could fill. I didn't make anything up. Name starts with C. Like they never had uh first year speaker thing, first time speaker award. It's actually a really good idea, it's a good award. It is. I didn't have a chance to win that. Gretzky didn't win uh uh rookie of the year because they didn't, you know, they had they changed the rules on them. Here's an anecdotal story because I I do want to get back to the uh did we have a topic?
ConorUnique nature of C now. No, because I had something else to say. But uh when I joined the Canadian uh ISO uh national body for C, uh, you know, Michael Long uh sent out an email, who's the chair, I believe, of the C or Canadian C National Body, and said, Welcome. And then I'm not sure if it was the first reply, but it was it was in the first couple. Uh Tony replies because he's also a member and says, uh, my art genesis. And here I am, never having met Tony, never having you know conversed with him because I I I don't think I'd uh I don't yeah, I don't think I'd met you yet because you did you didn't come to C now 2019.
ConorAnd um and you're like one of my favorite speakers, and I'm like, what?
Ben DeaneWhat have I done? No, this was this was great for me. Like I saw some Twitter chat and I'm like, hooray, now someone else has taken the mantle of being Tony's name.
ConorBut uh but yeah, to come back to the the uniqueness of C now, it's it's interesting, Tony, that you said um, you know, that it's it's a lot of conversation because I think both Ben and I, we both have talks that we only want to give and have not given up till this point um that we initially uh had submitted to C Now 2020. Um and then like I thought about giving it at CPPCon, but like I in my head had like specifically designed this talk for like the C Now experience because it's just more interactive.
ConorYou get you get more engagement. Um and that's I actually I I wasn't sure what um John was gonna do because it's obviously difficult. Um, but I did there was a uh I thought there was a small percentage chance that it was gonna happen in Zoom and everyone would have the ability, if not to just sort of interrupt, but at least like sort of in in Google meetings, you can start a hand cue and then um and pass the mic off. Like I I thought there might be something like that, but you know, probably the technical challenges of doing that without it becoming a total mess is I I also have a talk that's C now only that that I've been holding off on.
ConorAnd it's and uh it's actually in in my head, which so it may never happen now, but it's it's a keynote for C now that uh that's been in my mind for years and years. But uh because it's a unique conference, and so I'm like, this this would not make sense anywhere else. It goes back to the basis of mathematics with uh Gottlieb Frega and Bertrand Russell and all this kind of stuff. It's like I I don't know where else to give that talk. So maybe someday. Maybe it won't be a keynote, maybe it'll just be uh I'll just give it as a talk.
ConorThat's what I should do. I should just propose it next year or the year after or whatever. Well, the benefit is that you get you get to sweep all the awards then. If you uh if you demote your keynote talk to a regular talk, you're basically uh sure to win everything. No, I took I took my best, I took my best shot. It's never gonna happen now.
Ben DeaneWell, I'm expecting you know the the first year back to in-person C now is gonna be a hallmark year with everyone giving their these saved up talks, apparently. Right, yeah.
ConorYeah, it it's that's the the other thing too is like the virtual conference has 30 minute breaks. Like the like the for me, the best part, which is you know, they call it the hallway track, but it's it's like the schedule, like everyone's on the same time zone, whereas right now we're not like I think Tony Tony and I are both in the same time zone, but Ben is two hours behind. And there's folks in Europe that you know signed up that only watch like the last talk of the day. So it's that's completely different, which is it's uh it's uh it's got a silver lining in that people from all over the world can attend that might not have been able to travel.
ConorBut one of one of the really nice things about C now is that they've got such long breaks in between talks. Um, not all of them are long, some of them are only 30 minutes, but they have like an extra long lunch break. Um, they usually have like a long break in between the keynotes in the evening, and and um I can't remember who if it if it was someone in the three of us or someone else that said that like the fact that at an in-person conference you go and see a talk, and then everyone upon exiting the the room is standing next to each other, and it's it's just everyone just starts chatting about it.
ConorWhereas here, you know, it's only a percentage of the folks that go to Gathertown. Um, yeah, so it's yeah, yeah. If we if we do ever do this again, or you know, the the CP con coming up or whatever, it we we need to make sure when people leave the talk, you just automatically end up in the same spot, right? Everyone's kind of nearby, or it's or it's really quick to get to because what happens in a normal in a in a live talk um or in-person talk, uh, people walk up to the stage.
ConorThe people who for whatever reason don't want to ask a question to everybody, but they still want to ask the question to the speaker, and so they go up to the stage after. And that's great. I I I I'm quite happy to answer those questions after the talk, right? And you end up, yeah, you end up with good conversations. And I mean, at C now, you end up going to lunch. That's like you right, and then writing a paper. Yeah, right. Whatever. If you ever want to get hooked into doing some work for the committee, all you gotta do is ask a question after a committee member gives a talk, and then uh you'll be writing a paper for them.
ConorWho doesn't want that? But then you get to say, I went out to lunch with, you know, somebody, somebody you want to go to lunch with. The Tony of the Tony Awards of C now. Um I think that's how I I think I first met Bjorn Bjorn by going to lunch, right? At a you know, he he came and spoke at uh Adobe one time, and it's like then we all had food, and I'm like, I could just go and sit next to this guy, right?
Ben DeaneYeah. Well that's how that's how it is a C now, right? You know, I I come in, never, you know, I roll into the conference, never really been part of the community before, and I'm having a problem with some C. So I go and ask Chandler how this is supposed to get optimized, and he tells me, right?
ConorYeah, that's literally the exact same.
Ben DeaneInteractions like that happen all the time.
ConorYeah, it's literally the exact same. Mine was several years after you, Ben, but I showed up. Absolutely no, like I'd never been to a conference in my life, let alone spoken at one, um, or vice versa, switch those two around. And then the slide in my algorithm intuition talk with adjacent difference calculating Fibonacci, like that came from a conversation with Ben where I was saying, Oh, you know, you can do Fibonacci with transform. And then Ben was like, Hold my beer, you know, you can do Fibonacci with adjacent difference. And I was like, No, you can't. And he's like, Yeah. And then I thought about it for a second, and that it was just like, oh my God, that's one of the worst named algorithms ever.
ConorLike, how are you gonna recognize that that's it's just adjacent elements? You can do anything you want, you don't have to subtract. And um, yeah, that experience is it's like uh I don't want to say it's a C now only thing, but it just it's those kinds of conversations seem to happen a lot more for whatever reason. Speaking of, you know, coming up with pieces of your talk while you're talking to people, uh I'm I'm making uh I'm making my lightning talk right now. Right. So you want to give us a sneak peek?
ConorYeah, no, I no, I don't want to give you, I want you to give me. I need I need stuff for my slides. All right, so what's the title? So so like I mentioned, I barely mentioned it yesterday, and and Phil I got it from Phil, right? Phil did a talk on solid, and in his talk, he references Rich Hickey, right, who did Clojure. And Rich Hickey does a talk called Simple Made Easy, right? And he goes into the Latin, simple and complex, they come from Latin plect plecto and plict care and all this stuff, and it's all about fold and and you know, simple is one fold and complex is many folds, interleaving.
ConorAnd he uses this old word called complex and complexing, um, to mean entangling and interleaving, right? And that's what happens in our software all the time. Things get entangled, like you know, it's kind of half of my talk yesterday, right? Um so it's kind of like while I was giving my talk yesterday, and after my talk, um I was real I realized it's like I want my lightning talk to be complexing made easy, right? Like because because it's exactly what happens.
ConorLike, why is our software you know turn into crap is because we make it too easy to let it turn into crap, right? It's it's the the easy answer to solve a problem is like the one that entangles your code, right? So you know having a lot of uh data uh close by is basically so and the other half is that easy, the the the term easy um also comes from, you know, you can trace it back to Latin. It's kind of fuzzy, they're not really sure, but it comes back comes from adjacent, which is you know, like adjacent.
ConorIt's it really means close at hand. Easy means close at hand, right? So complexing made easy is what our code does. We put things close at hand, and we're just like, hey, did you wanna you did you want to solve this problem? All you gotta do is is this thing's right here. You could just braid them together. It's just it we're just tempting you. We put all this stuff in the right spot. Why don't you just braid it together? So I mean, one thing I like global variables. I should I have to write this down because I keep forgetting it. Maybe I won't make my slides, but I'll write I'll write it down while we're talking.
ConorUm global variables, right? Global variables. It's just it's right there. I could just read this global variable and uh and and you know complex my code. And then the next best thing to a global variable is shared pointer. Shared pointer, thank you very much. Yep, shared pointer. Um what what we have in our code is a class called model that I always bring up, right? Everyone has a pointer back to model. It'd be okay to have model that owns everything because you always are stuck with a class that has to own everything, otherwise things just disappear, right?
ConorRight, but everything has a pointer back to model. So I have places in my code where there's literally five layers deep of I've got model is a member variable and just a raw pointer, right? Pointing back to my parents, right? Model pointing to foo, pointing to bar, pointing to thing, pointing, ah, that's what I needed. I needed this piece of information, and I can get at it through this five-step path. Model is the convenience store. Yeah, yeah, it's all there. You just go to model. So having exposure to model is complexing, made easy.
ConorIt's like it's right here. You don't have to make up an interface, you don't have to put in the right function for how you know. I should have this information should have been passed down to me through three layers of function calls. That that's that's hard. That's correct code made hard, right? Like uh simple is is not folding your code together. So simple is hard to do, and complexing is easy to do because we expose model. You know, that's the problem in our class. So I've got three examples. I need more. How is complexing made easy?
Ben DeaneUm, I can I think there's a time element I was gonna say because because Ridge Hickey in his talk talks about uh easy is a function of mental ease as well, right? Which is a function of time, yeah, right? What's close in time, what you immediately think of is the easy when you're given time to reflect and and work on the problem, then you perhaps come up with something that's simpler.
ConorUm yeah, and I also find people um you work from uh an area uh that you already know, right? It's like, well, I know this part of the code, and I'm I'm already I've I've touched this class before, so I'll just go from here, right? I've got I've got this is the information I know, and then I will just it's like, well, you know, if you just went over there and asked that other class to give you the thing you want to know, that would work. And you're like, yeah, but I've never touched that class before.
Ben DeaneI don't I don't want to touch that code. Right. It's easy to write code, it's easy to just type. It's harder to grep and find the interface that already exists, maybe.
ConorYeah, this isn't really an example, but uh twice now. This has come up like it's popped into my head while you've been talking, Tony, is um, I'm not sure if Bjorn Strushuk was the first person to hear this or to say this, um, but it's where I heard it first is that so many people mistake uh familiarity for simplicity. Yeah. Um and that because it's what you're used to working with, it seems simple. Um, and then some new thing that potentially is unfamiliar looks complicated, but if you take the time to restructure uh at the end of the day, it actually is it is objectively simpler than what you had before, but um what you know it like sort of affects what you think is simple.
ConorYeah, that that is, and that is what uh uh Rich Hickey's talk also mentions, right? That is it's almost literally close at hand, it's close in your knowledge base, right? It's like I already know this, and this is just one step away from what I already know. It's familiar, right? It's like, oh, I already know whatever this language, or you know, you you solve a problem. Like I we get that when we're doing interviewing people, right? Interviewing, I show someone this problem, hey, can you solve this problem? And you'll see someone solving it with uh with like I'm just like why would you think of this as their, you know, I'm gonna solve it with with probability, something, something, and and fine.
ConorI'm like, and I just listen to it, it's like, oh, because the last problem they solved, they solve that way, right? It's just like I'm familiar with solving problems with this technique, so I'm gonna try to apply my technique to this problem. And I'm like, okay, let's try something else. Because it's this is just not, you know, you don't want to just tell somebody you're totally going down the wrong path. But I I I give them time and then I go, like, that might work, but what else? Give me some more ideas on how that might work, you know. Like, give me some other way to solve this problem. But really, what I'm saying, I'll let you know if anyone interviews with me, if I start asking you for other ideas and I don't say your first idea is wrong, I'm really saying your first idea is terrible, just in a nice way.
ConorIt's like, oh, that that is pretty interesting. But what other ways do you think you could do this? This is this has caused now a great future moment, a moment that is yet to happen of when this happens when you're interviewing someone that just happens to have listened to this episode. You say that and they're gonna be like, Oh no, it's terrible. I listened to that episode, Tony, and you're gonna be like, Oh, well, we may we not be my what uh your your friend uh Ahmad, right? Yeah, we're just talking to yesterday. I he's he's I've been talking to him about like working here as a co-op, right?
ConorSo this that we could be like this far away from it happening. Cool. Like, yeah, there'll be an interview.
Ben DeaneI'll I'll I'll change my phrasing. I'll just try something else. So I gave a talk at the Denver meetup a few months ago now, and it was it was one of those talks that was I I want I needed to give it at the meetup because it wasn't a lightning talk and it wasn't a full talk, it was in that 20-25 minute range, which is so annoying. Um, but the talk was called the blacksmith and the gardener, meaning the two sides of you know what we do. Sometimes, sometimes you're a blacksmith, sometimes you're forging things, you're bending the code to your will, you're typing, typing, typing.
Ben DeaneUm, but that needs to be balanced with the gardener, which is you're just letting things bloom, right? You're letting yourself reflect your, you know, because so often I found myself having the experience, as we all have, like, you know, the cliche is like you solve the problem in the shower or on the run or whatever, you know, in times when your mind is quiet. Um and and the experience you have if you're lucky, is that you you solve you you get a task to do, you solve it, done, you manage to knock it out, done.
Ben DeaneAnd if You're lucky, like a week later, you realize there's a simpler way to do it. Oftentimes you're not that lucky, right? And so the thing stays in the code, complectified. I just do it right the first time.
ConorWhy doesn't everyone just I don't I never understood this why people are always like, you know, throw the first one away. I'm like, oh, the first one was good. That was one of the best parts of your talk when you just said you were like, Yeah, I don't want to come across as overconfident, but uh most of the time I just get things right. That's uh it's just happens to me all the time. Uh I had I had this, I had this student working for me years ago, and she was she was great. One of the her her best features was that you know, we'd be talking about some stuff and she'd go off to do some work, and she'd come back in about you know the end of the week or something, and be and she'd be like, Okay, I was doing this stuff like we said, and I ran into this little problem, and and I went this way, you know, and she describes the problem to me and she's like, it was it wasn't a big deal, but I I wasn't sure, but I went this way, and I'm like, Yeah, that was a good, good decision, right?
ConorAnd then she goes on, I also did this thing, and we hadn't talked about it, but I thought this made sense. I'm like, yeah, makes completely sense. And then she goes, and now I'm here and I'm not sure which way to go. And she was really good at knowing this was a big decision, and she should stop, right? And just like she had her opinion, but she knew that she should ask somebody because it was a you know, she recognized it was a big decision. I thought that was great. Like that's that's a good insight into the whole world of programming. And so she'd discuss the problem and and she'd be like, you know, I could go this way, I could go left, or I could go right, you know, blah, blah, blah, different ways of doing it.
ConorAnd I'm like, yeah, yeah. And and I I I find that I can always uh understand, yeah, that I see how that makes sense. I see how this one makes sense. You can give me five different things, I can see all five points of views, you know. It's really bad for being political or something, like, oh yeah, that makes sense, you know. Like, no, Tony, that one doesn't make sense. That'd be bad. Those people are evil. Well, yeah, but it sounded like, you know, but um, but she would go through the things, and she was like, which way should we go? And I have this gut instinct of which way we should go.
ConorAnd I'm like, well, this one makes sense to me, but I can't say why I think it's better than any other way. So I usually would just say, Whichever one you're most comfortable with, because you're gonna be the one writing the code. And unless I see like why it's obviously wrong or something, it's fine. They're all they're all roughly equivalent. Go in whatever direction you're comfortable with, and then she would go off into another direction and stuff like that. And then, like, three months later, it'd be like, Oh, we'd both see it. Like, that was not the right direction. This is we should not have gone down this way. It's like, let's do it this other way that I think just feels right to me.
ConorAnd it wouldn't, we had never come back to that. It would always be like, Yeah, that one worked out. And eventually, after she was there for a couple of terms and stuff, eventually she's just like, I'm just gonna do it your way, okay? Whichever way, like you don't have to explain to me why you think it's the right way. We're just gonna go with yours. And I'm like, All right, it's just let's just call it experience or something. It just it's just let's go with my way from now on. And it was good. We both agreed that you know that you're always right, yeah. And it worked out, like it was true. It just the stuff we did, it was right, and we went on third day.
ConorI don't know.
Ben DeaneYeah, no, that's a good that sort of rings true. You know, I was thinking the other day, uh the answer with C is always it depends, right? Right, once you get past a certain level, and so it becomes harder and harder to give a definitive answer when someone comes up to you and says, you know, they're look they're looking for your opinion, they're looking for what's the right well, they're not even looking for your opinion, they're looking for you to give the authority. What's the right way to do this?
ConorYeah, how am I supposed to do this? Just tell me not.
Ben DeaneThat's a really difficult question to answer because it's always it depends. And so, you know, maybe the way to go is well, you know, here's here's the experienced way. Uh, it's not necessarily the the authoritively right way, I'm saying, but but here's how I would do it.
ConorAnd I and I think isn't it because I've spent a lot of time trying to figure out because the sad part is I literally could not tell you why I think one way is better than the other. I just think it is, right? It's just like it just feels like the right way, and it wouldn't be till later on down the road where we're like, oh yeah, this is why it's the you know, that was bad and this is good. Um, but I know after I've spent time trying to figure out what is it, and it really is keep your stuff separate. Uh it's just like my instinct is to separate things, and I find that that instinct does not does not fail, right?
ConorI did it in I did it in math, I did it like you know, it's it's a mathematical thing in my head. It's it's abstraction and stuff. It's like, you know, these concepts are separate, keep things separate, and and then even if something isn't wrong, it's okay because it's all separate and you fix the one piece, right? It's like the whole the whole thing's not wrong. Right, right. I don't know. Yeah, Ben, when you were saying that uh when people ask, you know, how do you do this? That reminded me in my very first job when I had become experienced, sometimes folks would we would have some small job that needed to be done, and it'd be like, oh well, can you just give me the first couple of steps?
ConorAnd inevitably, like, if I were actually doing it, there's like a series of like six disjoint things that I would try, like, and I they're all ranked, and I would try the first one, realize, uh no, that's not gonna work. Then try the second one, that's not gonna work. And then on the fourth one of six, okay, no, this is the right way to do it. Um, but when someone asks you, like, oh, how to do this, you I typically just tell them the first thing. Um, and I'm just like, oh, I would go down this route. And then, you know, 60 minutes later they come back and say, Oh, I tried that and it's it's really not working. And then I go and sit down next to them and oh, yeah, yeah, that's clearly not gonna work.
ConorAnd um so why don't you just give them the fourth one first, man? Like it's not because I don't even know that the fourth fourth one is the right one. And that's why I think uh honestly, like pair programming. Uh I absolutely love um pair programming, especially when um there's a person at work, uh, his name's Ashwin that I work with at NVIDIA, and he's like a Python expert. And I'm a quote unquote C expert. And because of our library that we work on, it's Python bindings, yes, expert with the quotations. It's the only way to do it. Um this expert in other languages, the C you have to put the quotes on it.
ConorThis is a tangent, uh, but I have recently inside my head, uh, I used to put the Scott Sher quote at the beginning of my talks, whereas I'm not an expert, I'm just a dude. Um, I have a new quote that I don't even know who said, I just heard it and I was like, that is perfect. And it's the more I learn, the less I know. Um, and it's this idea that like I like learning a bunch about different languages and paradigms. And like, so I'm learning this stuff very surface level, and just all I'm doing really is discovering that there's so much more that like I don't know. And so as I learn more, I feel less and less of an expert and more and more of like an imposter.
Ben DeaneThis though is the hallmark of expertise, right? The way I've heard it said is um the larger your island of knowledge, the longer your coastline of ignorance.
ConorYeah. Hmm. That's wow. Where'd you hear that from? We gotta uh somewhere. You can Google it. Yeah, I'll be trying to find that's almost more eloquent than what I uh when I had said. And what's the word? I was saying uh expert, right? Because we were talking about pairing. And it's just fantastic because um we both sort of acknowledge like that we have our areas of what we know, and um, there's just so much teaching and and um where you're the driver and the expert sort of is the is the other person guiding you.
ConorUh it's just fantastic because there's so many times where inevitably you know that if you were by yourself, you're gonna spend an hour, two hours, or three hours trying to figure out how to do this. And then they'll quickly they'll see you going down the path and they'll say, Okay, that's a really good thought, but like let me just fix that. And it it's you just learn at it's like concentrated learning. Um, and I just it's it's fantastic. Um a friend of mine, a coworker, uh he he used to, if we if he was watching you code, he would just slowly start making a noise. He'd just be like, uh, yeah, uh it'd just get worse.
ConorYou know, if you just kept going, he's just like uh, oh, I should stop now. Yeah, if it was just like you're missing a semicolon, it'd just be a tiny little noise, right? Just like ah, the compiler will find it. But yeah, if you really start going down the wrong path, you'd just increase the volume. So you stopped. All right. Well, we're we're at like the hour mark here, and I realize I've already kept you 30 minutes into the next talk, which I was super looking forward to, so I'm not sure. Which is the next one you're going to? Uh there's one called Algorithms as expressions by I don't that sounds like something you'd go to.
Ben DeaneThat sounds great.
ConorYeah, it's by I'm gonna mispronounce this name, so I apologize. Uh Alexander uh Bakarikov. Um you could have just went with Alexander, just like you know, how many? This is probably not more than one talk by his first name. I can get the first name. I'm probably sure that I mispronounced the first name, anyways. Um but if if I hop into that one, uh I'll have to catch the first 30 minutes later. But is there anything I feel like too? We've mentioned a lot of folks by first name. So Chandler refers to Chandler Caruth uh from Google. Uh Eric refers to Eric Niebler from uh Ranges v3, uh currently works at Facebook, but is did the pioneering work behind what's become C20 ranges.
ConorI feel like we've mentioned a couple other people. Uh when I'm re-listening to this, if if I haven't mentioned the last name, I'll try and just just because the I recall listening to CPP cast episodes early on, and people would refer to like Herb, and I didn't know who Herb was. And we just as C we assume everyone knows that Herb Sutter is the chair of the C ISO committee. BRNA, BRNA's true stroke. It's yeah, that's it. I think I said his name, so it's like yeah. That's the creator of C for any non-C. I assume every C knows that, but there might be a you know what's funny?
ConorI I I hate doing um reviews at at work, right? It's it's the like you know, you get the yearly review or whatever kind of crap. Um which I I just don't if you're not reviewing. I'm sorry, you're trying to end and get out of here, but if you're um not reviewing all throughout the year, like you should know what your manager's opinion of you is, and your your people that you're managing, they should know how you feel. It's not a one-time a year thing, right? But you fill out these forms and like so I got to the point where I filled out the forms with quotes from from co-authors, from co-workers, right?
ConorIt just like it look just looks like a movie poster. It's just like awesome idea, Tony. You know, like and I just put I and I put down I remember this one, it said awesome idea, you know. Christine, Christine said awesome idea for something. It was like lunch plans, but you know, they don't need to know that. But I included, I remember including a quote from Bjorn. It said like a plus one from Bjorn or whatever, something like that. And then I realized my manager doesn't know who that is. Like, like it's such a good thing to put on my it's like, look, Bjorn Stroostrup likes something I said, and then I'm like, oh, this is gonna get lost on my manager, but yeah, every everyone else knows who he is.
ConorYeah, that's uh that's a good uh I listened to a podcast called the Lybybug Podcast, and uh one of the biggest things they say is whenever someone like says something nice, just jot it down. Just if you at the end of your year, when you're putting together like some it not all companies, but a lot of companies, you have to write your own sort of performance review and send it in. If you have like if 50% of it is just like coworker X, you know, said this positive thing about this PR, and and you know, uh coworker Y that I spent some time teaching said this was you know, increased productivity five 5x for a week or something.
ConorUm, that is like the best stuff that managers want to see. Well, especially when it depends what you do, right? Like if you are someone who just writes code and you can just say, like, look, go go look at the at the code, the source code, like you can see all my check-ins, right? Like, that's just here's all this work I've done. Half my job is not typing code, right? So I need to be able to say, you know, like, what did you do? Like, even in stand-ups, every day at stand-up, I say what I'm what I think I'm going to be doing today, and then I know that's not what's gonna happen because other things are gonna happen.
ConorI'm gonna someone's gonna have a problem, I'm gonna go do that, and like so. I don't know why I bother, and sometimes I do. I just say, you know, you guys know whatever I say is a lie. So just I'm gonna think of doing this and I'll do something else because that's the way it goes.
Ben DeaneYeah.
ConorAll right, any last uh parting C now, 2021 uh words? Oh, yeah, and also I said Ben, I cut you off, Tony. I just said Ben didn't give a talk, he did give a lightning talk um on four CCs, which featured featured the uh guinea pig, one of his four guinea pigs named Iota, um, which obviously everybody should love that name. And apparently you're giving another one. You've already heard Tony's giving uh do you know do you know what the name of your lightning talk is, Tony?
Ben DeaneUh and and Ben? Oh mine is uh wait when paradigms collide.
ConorOoh, maybe APL is gonna get mentioned. I I have to, I'm I'm like, I'm I'm under the wire here. I've got like an hour to make slides. I haven't even like put it in. I I mentioned to Michael that I might have a talk. I haven't formally put it in there, but yeah, we'll see. See to have to leave it as well. I already told you it's complexing made easy. That's that's what it's gonna be called if I ever get to it. If I don't get it to it now, I'll do it next uh conference. Yeah, and oh and here's here's the final parting words. You know, uh Tony gave a secret short lightning talk yesterday at the aforementioned conversation where we where we missed Barry's talk, um, where he showed his uh Fabio long hair from I'm not sure what what year, but um I'm sure that was just a couple weeks ago.
ConorIt wasn't a couple weeks ago, it wasn't 20, 30 years ago, yeah. 25 years ago. Yeah, no, this is my COVID look.
Ben DeaneYeah, maybe it's just it's too easy to type. That's the ultimate thing. Like it's too easy to type and code, add the variable, add the function uh parameter.
ConorWell, even even you know what? Even that, even writing code inside. I already just wrote like add a member very member function is easier than starting a new file, right? Right, right. So that that's why you make member functions. It'd be like because I I get this all the time. People are like, well, where would I put that function? Where like just do I put it in this file? Do I put it in a separate file? And same thing with like I could just write code here in the function I know I need to change. Instead of adding a function, and instead of adding another function, right? Okay, I've got enough. I've got enough for a talk. Sure. Sounds good.
ConorAll right, well, thanks for taking the time uh to to tune in and uh share your thoughts about the conference, and hopefully 2022 come May uh we're all gonna be in Aspen. Hopefully. Um, I mean, I've got my vaccine appointment for Sunday. I just locked it in last night. So the world's hopefully gonna be going back to normal.
Ben DeaneAnd uh, my second vaccination is coming up as well.
ConorThis is gonna be so weird because I'm not sure how many people are like me and go back and watch podcasts from like 10 years ago and go from zero to episode 150, but there's gonna be people like 10 years from now, you know, a handful of them that are listening to this as well. Oh, yeah, I guess there is that crazy virus that really messed things up for a while. Yeah, let me let me just slip in the rest of the political. Like, I there was a point where I was saying, even before, because COVID wasn't we really didn't know what's going on with COVID, but I was just like, I'm not going back to the states, like your country's on fire, and and like I just I'm just gonna avoid this country.
ConorBut like I'm kind of hoping the this not just COVID, but other stuff settles down, and well, I mean, I hope we it makes not just settles down because we go back to the way it was, but you know, progress is made. Uh but yeah, for a while I was just like, I don't want to go to this. Your country sucks, but it's not so bad. It's not so bad.
Tony van EerdIt's not Canada, you know.
ConorBut all right, on that note, and uh we appreciate all the American listeners that have tuned in up until this episode.
Tony van EerdLook fan to the move up to Canada. I think that's all that's an idea.
ConorYeah, we'll uh we'll start that. Uh Tony was talking about uh uh a second Canadian conference after CPP North, which hasn't even started yet. And it's gonna be like the Muskoka wilderness. Uh Muskoka Plus Plus. That's not a bad name. Um understanding.
Ben DeaneIs this gonna have the uh are you gonna do a talk which is also a hike?
ConorOh, that's still a plan for Aspen. Someday, someday I'll do the hike talk. I was talking to Bryce about that a little while ago. He's like, we have to really do this instead of just talking about it. To to be clear, this is not uh you know uh Tony with like a uh a GoPro giving a talk while he's hiking. It's him giving a talk while everybody's hiking. Right. Yeah, that's the plan. Tony, you're breaking up, you're breaking up. Ah, it's every second word. Uh my plan is actually you guys go for the the walk and I don't.
ConorThat that that is part of the plan. I'm I'm gonna put like little uh markers along the path for for you to discuss. That's that's my plan. Oh wow, that sounds like the problem is like we can't take we can't take 60 people or whatever together and and do a talk in in you know, because the path's too too narrow, you know. So you have to break up into smaller groups.
Tony van EerdSo we need a way that each group on its own can experience the talk, but you know, and and we need to put in the route with like CPP cones.
ConorYeah, exactly. That is that you're you've you've got it. That's what it's gonna be. Um and and I might need I need uh you know uh group group leaders, right? So I might you know hook you guys in to be like, okay, you're taking one group of 10 and you you go this way, and you take another group of 10, you go that way, and then I'll just hang out at the at the barbecue or something, wait for you to come back. This sounds like a whole new category of you know, this is gonna be it's gonna start in Ctopia and then it's gonna spread to every other language.
Ben DeaneUh yeah, yeah. That's a good idea. All right, let fool it to it. All right, we'll have to make it happen.
ConorAll right. 2022. Now you you've locked it. This is going out into the ether. People are gonna hear it and they're gonna be disappointed if it doesn't happen. So all right, we'll make it happen. We'll make it happen. We could be, we could save it for the Muskokas. Well, you start putting a conference together, Tony, and I'll I'll be the first one to sign up. I can't even organize uh I'm supposed to do I'm supposed to do talks at work every every second Monday. I can't get that organized. So don't don't expect me to be doing a conference. You do a conference, I'll show up. That's great. That's so much I'll do.
ConorI'll think about Muskoka Plus Plus. Uh although you know, if I end up setting up a conference, you know, like there's gonna be an APL dedicated track. Uh see if it's got nature involved, I will learn APL just for that. Wow, maybe that's the that's the angle. Is uh we gotta I'll make APL great again by uh you know bringing nature into the mix somehow.
Ben DeaneYep.
ConorAll right. Uh this is for the third or fourth time. Uh thanks for coming on. This is awesome.
Ben DeaneThanks, Connor. Thanks for listening and have a great day.
In this episode, Conor and Bryce chat with Zach Laine about C++26 Reflection vs CRTP, AI, kids & more. Link to Episode 313 on Website Discuss this episode, leave a comment, or ask a question (on GitHub) Socials ADSP:...
In this episode, Conor and Bryce chat with Zach Laine about the C++26 contracts fiasco. Link to Episode 312 on Website Discuss this episode, leave a comment, or ask a question (on GitHub) Socials ADSP: The Podcast:...
In this episode, Conor and Bryce talk with Zach Laine about his career and the career changes he has made. Link to Episode 311 on Website Discuss this episode, leave a comment, or ask a question (on GitHub) Socials...
In this episode, Conor and Bryce talk about Bryce's next chapter and where he is leaving NVIDIA for. Link to Episode 310 on Website Discuss this episode, leave a comment, or ask a question (on GitHub) Socials ADSP: The...
In this episode, Conor and Ben chat with Jason Turner about default construction in C++. Link to Episode 309 on Website Discuss this episode, leave a comment, or ask a question (on GitHub) Socials ADSP: The Podcast:...