Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

ADSP: Algorithms + Data Structures = Programs

ADSP: Algorithms + Data Structures = Programs artwork

Episode 136: πŸ‡¬πŸ‡§ C++ On Sea Live πŸ‡¬πŸ‡§ CppCast, TLB HIT & Two's Complement!

Jun 30, 202346 minAudio

In this episode, Conor and Bryce record live from C++ On Sea 2023 and interview all the other C++ podcasts: TLB HIT, Two’s Complement and CppCast! Link to Episode 136 on Website Discuss this episode, leave a comment, or ask a question (on GitHub) Twitter ADSP: The Podcast Conor Hoekstra Bryce Adelstein Lelbach Guests Interviewed JF Bastien Matt Godbolt Jonathan MΓΌller (Briefly) Tristan Brindle (Briefly) Phil Nash Timur Doumler Show Notes Date Recorded: 2023-06-29 Date Released: 2023-06-30 C++ On Sea Conference C++ On Sea 2023 Keynote: Endnote: AI-Assisted Software Engineering - Bryce Adelstein Lelbach C++ Club Podcast TLB HIT Podcast Just-in-Time Compilation - JF Bastien - CppCon 2020 C++ On Sea 2023: *(char*)0 = 0; - JF Bastien Translation lookaside buffer (TLB) Photo of JF, Bryce and Conor on Twitter Two’s Complement Podcast Croc: Legend of the Gobbos Compiler Explorer C++ On Sea 2023: Throwing Tools at Ranges - Tina Ulbrich Circle Compiler C++ On Sea 2023: What’s New in Compiler Explorer? - Matt Godbolt Think-Cell Is Hiring C++ On Sea 2023: Iteration Revisited - Tristan Brindle CppCast Podcast C++ on Sea 2023: C++ and Safety - Timur Doumler C++ on Sea 2023 Keynote: All the Safeties - Sean Parent C++ Lambda Idioms - Timur Doumler - CppNorth 2022 Intro Song Info Miss You by Sarah Jansen https://soundcloud.com/sarahjansenmusic Creative Commons - Attribution 3.0 Unported - CC BY 3.0 Free Download / Stream: http://bit.ly/l-miss-you Music promoted by Audio Library https://youtu.be/iYYxnasvfx8

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Matt GodboltAnd I also have a podcast called TLB Hit. TLBHIT.it. Uh you should listen to us if you want to hear two friends just chatting about software engineering practices, which sounds kind of familiar, I think, for you two. But there's far fewer conversations about the uh interior design of either of our houses.

BryceLike it was one time!

Timur DoumlerHello, my name is Timo Dumler. I'm the co-host of CPP Cast. I'm here at the CPP on C conference.

Phil NashJust talking to uh to Timo about this actually, he was saying that uh our podcast's almost like complete opposite, because we're sort of like very structured and follow a bit of a formula, whereas you're completely chaotic. But it's like we complement each other. I think we have room for for both.

ConorWelcome to ADSP the podcast, episode 136, recorded on June 29th, 2023. My name is Connor, and today with my co-host Bryce, we interview live from C on C 2023 some of the hosts of three other C podcasts. We interview JF Bastion of TLP Hit, Matt Goblet of the Two's Compliment Podcast, and Timur Doomler and Phil Nash of CPPcast. We're here live. Live! Except we're not actually live.

BryceWe just like to say that. We just like to say that.

ConorWe're live at C on C2023.

BryceIt is been a great conference so far.

ConorWe got Bryce's keynote, last keynote, happening tomorrow.

BryceAnd the good news is the slides are mostly finished. It's only 9 30 p.m. the night before the talk.

ConorWhich is why we're doing this interview right now. We're gonna we are gonna talk to all of the C podcasts, except for CPP Club, because they're not represented here.

BryceCPP Club, should I maybe take away that glass of wine? Is CPP Club a real thing?

ConorListen, it's a real thing. And uh they're the least subscribed to C podcasts.

BryceOh, we gotta think of a more polite way to say that.

ConorNo, we're saying that so that people go subscribe to them.

BryceOh, yeah, definitely. Go subscribe to whatever this is.

ConorActually, I actually don't know. TLB hit might be might be less subscribed to.

BryceWell then we should start with them. We should start, let's go find JF, folks. Alright, I know where he is. We've got Mr. JF Bastien. I'm sure that's not the right way of saying his last name, which I should know because we've been friends for many years. How do we say your last name?

JF BastienBastien.

BryceOkay, I I I was close. I was close. The chair of the C committees evolution group, and uh, what else do you do?

JF BastienUh so I work at Wolven for Toyota, uh, and I also have a podcast called TLB Hit Twitch.it.

BryceYeah, and why did we decide to start with uh with this podcast?

ConorUh it may be the lowest subscribed to podcast, definitely the lowest subscribed to podcast represented here at C on C. Is it the lowest subscribed to of all?

JF BastienProbably not, I think. Maybe, maybe. It's a love project that me and my friend Chris put together, and and I have to say it inspired you guys to start your podcast. Oh, definitely, definitely.

ConorOh, you can turn that?

JF BastienYeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah, you guys and Matt. Matt Godball, too. Yeah. I inspired you guys, and then I can I get to claim points from your success.

BryceYou know what? You know what, buddy? I'm fine with that because we are not the least subscribed C podcast. It's okay. It's it's quality over quantity. What do you talk about on TLB Hit?

JF BastienOh, we have like a whole six episodes or something. There's actually a secret episode that we've never released that we recorded two years ago. We should probably release it. Uh but but we talk about like uh uh just like how computers work or deep programming topics, but we're very particular about it. There's a lot I was telling Connor our process, and it's multiple hours go into a single episode.

BryceOh so you do you do this like preparation thing.

JF BastienYeah, so we have a list of ideas for episodes, we collaboratively write it on a Google Doc like asynchronously, then we block off time to do a rehearsal because we have like a script that we write, we we decide who's gonna hit which topic, and that's like an hour and a half to do that prep, and then we do the recording. We used to do the editing ourselves, now we outsource, we pay a company to do the editing. Uh and and yeah, it's quality. They only have six episodes though, so it's not that expensive.

BryceConnor and I kindor got out all the recording equipment, and he's like, you know what we're doing here? We're gonna make all the other podcasts look bad, and then this guy comes over and he's got a process, there's a Google Doc. What what's um what what is the next episode that we can expect?

JF BastienOh, I don't know. Chris and I haven't decided. We just like so so it the thing is with the time zones, because I'm in Japan, he's in California, we both have kids, it's hard to find a time that works, right? And so, so like we uh we did a call last weekend just for the kids to talk because they're friends. Um that means we didn't record because we just had the kids talk. Uh and and so like eventually we'll we'll be like, oh, we should do another episode. Right around the time I think Connor was gonna remove us from the active podcast list uh that he maintains.

JF BastienWell, uh, so what what were you doing here this week? Tell us about your talk. Uh so my talk is actually I we had a podcast, our episode number one, second episode, because we count from zero, is uh Star Car Star Zero equals zero. So it it it's an idea that I had years ago to do as a talk, like a conference talk. And I told Chris about it and he was like, let's do a podcast about that. So we did a podcast about it.

BryceUh it's the what is the what is the premise of this talkslash podcast episode?

ConorAnd also, what this wasn't the talk that you gave at a committee meeting at one point on different programming. That was totally different. No, it's uh I only give talks once usually, so it's uh it's a one-off like it's a shame that that talk that you gave, I can't remember if it was at Cologne or at Belfast, but that talk was fantastic. You should give that at a conference. It was different programming language histories.

JF BastienNo, uh I gave I remember that, yeah. CPBCon 2020.

ConorI gave that talk about JITS. Oh yeah. Link in the description, folks. We'll find it, we'll link it, go watch it.

BryceAll right, but back to this talk. What is what you gave the title of this talk, but what is it about?

JF BastienYeah, so star car star zero equals zero semicolon. And so it's an interview question that I've used more than a hundred times. You are a cruel interviewer. Yeah, but it's for systems and compiler people that have used it. And and so the idea is I write like int main curly brace, star car star zero equals zero semicolon, return zero curly brace, and I say, talk to me about this code, right? And and sometimes they're listed emotions, like this is terrible code or things like that, but it's the goal is to see your systems or compiler person, like what calls out to you.

JF BastienDo you want to talk about the front end, about undefined behavior, about things like that? Do you want to talk about how the machine works? Do you want to tell me how silicon works? Uh, and I've never gotten the same answer ever. And so my talk is kind of breaking down the different approaches, how you could answer that, and and showing, like, you know, a lot of the systems and compiler people like to look under the hood and poke at stuff and see how it works. And so that's basically the talk. And it's also a bit of an art project because I have nice animations and stuff. It's definitely better than your talk, Bryce.

BryceThat uh that may be true, but we won't we won't know until I finish making the talk.

ConorAlso, you haven't given your you're talking about this talk quasi in the past dance. It's tomorrow, correct? It is. It is tomorrow.

BryceWell, I I totally thought it happened today.

ConorIt's gonna be amazing.

BryceIs it is it scheduled against my talk?

JF BastienNo, no, it's not against my keynote. You're a keynote. You don't have He's not a keynote, he's an Endnote. Endnote.

ConorThat I don't think I've ever been more upset live on the pod than right now. Stop it, right?

JF BastienI thought you were daft. Link link in the description to the pictures of Connor being mortified.

ConorI thought you were being daft. And I you said I'm not, folks, I'm not I'm gonna back off for the rest of this pod. I've clearly had too much wine, and I'm just gonna be in the background.

BryceWhat happened there is that Connor thought he had a chance to get me, and he he activated my trap card. So uh anything else you want to tell the people?

ConorWell, how about a question about how you um have you been to C on C before? Is this your first time? How'd you find the conference?

JF BastienOh, yeah, first time here. Uh so so I decided I wanted to rotate different conferences because there's a lot of new ones coming out that are really interesting, like Core CPP, the C North. And so with kids, it's a bit hard to travel, so I picked C on C because it seemed cool. It's a place to give a talk. Next year I'll try some other one. It's it's nice to meet different people and communities. And so far, it's it's a really nice conference. You can see France from the balcony here, which is funny. Uh so we're we're on the sea in the south of England. You get to see France sometimes, it's funny. Uh, but yeah, it's a great talks have been great, people are nice, so really, really enjoyable.

JF BastienThe one downside is Bryce is here, but otherwise it's great.

ConorSo, wait, uh last question is I I don't actually think you have necessarily told the our listeners why they might want to listen to TLB Hit. You haven't actually explained what the acronym is, because when I first started listening to TLB Hit. Wait, you don't know what TLB is? Okay, listen, don't shame me, okay? I'm a high-level person, we've discussed this, you're the low-level person. You work at NVIDIA, yeah. You know what? And I told them not to hire me, okay? I said, I don't know anything about hardware. So, anyways, give a little pitch for your podcast. Why might our listeners?

BryceAlso explain what a TLB is.

JF BastienYeah, so I you don't necessarily need to subscribe, it's just a LovePad project, so whatever. Uh I think our episodes are pretty good, but you know, it's fine. Definitely better than ours. But uh yeah, so and if you work for NVIDIA, you don't necessarily need a TLB, right? So Nvidia is all about throughput, not latency. Uh the you could turn off the caches and it's like a 10% perf hit, whereas for CPUs you don't get that. But so a TLB is a translation look-aside buffer when they do virtual to physical address translation, uh, either within the cache or in the the MMU just before the memory.

JF BastienAnd so it's a cache for the address translation from virtual to physical. Uh and so it makes your hardware faster, unless you're NVIDIA, in which case you don't care because you hide that latency with a lot of throughput. So it's you don't need it, Connor. You're okay.

BrycePerfect. Alright, I think we should wrap there because I see that they're bringing out my dessert and I don't want my ice cream to melt. We're gonna take a break. We got two more people here. I know, but we're gonna take a break.

ConorYou know, I I told Bryce, why don't we do this after dessert?

BryceAnd he said, I got a schedule, we're gonna take a little break. You're gonna finish rewind. Uh any final words?

ConorAlright, well, enjoy dessert. Alright. Wait, do you want any any uh you know hot takes you wanna just uh trash the other pods? What do you you know?

JF BastienI mean, I don't listen to your pods, so it's okay. Mic drop.

BryceAlright, I think we're gonna leave it there, folks. We'll be back in a few minutes.

ConorLet's go grab him.

BryceLet's go ambush him. We get we have we have refilled on wine. I have stolen a bottle of wine from my table. Mr. Godball.

Matt GodboltHello!

BryceWe require you.

Matt GodboltYou require me. Alright, well I'm being ushered away from my table.

BryceOh, he's tripping over the chair. I'm falling over chairs. Yeah. I'm not doing a great job of holding the microphone.

Matt GodboltAnd actually holding it in my face. Well, we have to hear you too, right?

BryceI I guess we well, but I'm very loud. But anyways, we are back again. Connor has a fresh glass of wine.

ConorWait, wait, yes, I do. Don't worry. Uh Teamer's off. We will find you and Phil. Actually, you want to say hi first, Teamer? Interrupt uh Hello, how are you doing? Good. Alright, well, we'll find you and Phil. So that's Teamer from CPPCast, but we're talking to Matt Gobble from Two's Compliment. I don't even think Bryce knew the name of your podcast.

BryceI did not. You saw it on my face.

ConorWhy would Bryce know my podcast? Who listens to it, honestly? I mean, I do, and many others do. Bryce does not even listen to our podcast.

Matt GodboltYeah, well, but that gives you a certain amount of time.

BryceOkay, okay, alright, but to be fair, I'm here when our podcast has recorded, so I've listened to it once. I listened to it live. I had the best experience of it.

ConorI mean, there's been at least six or seven episodes now that you weren't there for, and you've definitely never listened to those.

BryceAnd that is true. No, I listened to the CPP now one, the first one that I wasn't on. I listened to it.

ConorThat's true with Ben uh with Ben Dean, which Tony joined halfway through. Anyways. Right, right. We're here with Matt Gobble and unfortunately Ben Rady. We're very sad that you're not here as well. Uh your your voice is missed as the co-host of Two's Compliment. Tell us about your podcast, Matt.

Matt GodboltWhat do I need to say about my I mean, my podcast is not really specifically about anything, it's just programming in general. But because it's me, I do do a lot of C related stuff. So I guess in a way it's a bit like ADSP, where notionally it's uh about languages in general, but it kind of has a bent towards the kind of stuff that you do in your day job. Uh mine is more towards what I I guess I like doing rather than what uh what anyone really has asked for.

BryceYou like doing C? Because I'm not here by choice, man.

Matt GodboltI mean, so we tend to talk a lot about like more low-level stuff, although Ben then talks about testing, so we get a bit of both.

ConorI was gonna say Ben Rady does that his you're the C low latency guy, and Ben Rady is the testing guy.

BryceThat isn't that's an interesting dynamic.

Matt GodboltIt is, it is, and then and I think it's it's what makes it uh an interesting combo. So our sort of origin story is that we were both planning to go into video games, and then life caught up with Ben, and he went off into the trading industry via a bunch of other ways, and I did do games for a while, and then we have rendezvoused in the trading industry, so we're like, it's the sliding doors kind of feel that like here's the same person that's taken two routes to get to the same place. So what uh what games did you work on? So I worked on a PlayStation 1 game, which was probably maybe before you were born, Bryce.

Matt GodboltNow I'm saying this.

Bryce94 Not before I was born. Not before I was born. I was all of two.

ConorOh my gosh. Actually, I think it was a little extra. I don't I don't think the internet agrees with that statement. I know Hannah definitely has an issue with opinions about your age.

Matt GodboltYeah.

BryceSo you worked on this PlayStation 1 game, what was it called?

Matt GodboltIt was called Croc Legend of the Gobos. Uh I worked on a SWAT, yeah. Stop it. So inevitably, you know what my nickname was during that the process of that. Yeah. I don't. Alright, well, Matt Goboltz. Matt Gobo. Yeah, yeah. There's a lot of laughing that you probably can't hear off of the mic right now. It's getting picked up. You're getting picked up, okay.

JF BastienWe got it. We got it.

Matt GodboltYeah, he is, yeah. But um, so that was a PlayStation game, and uh I worked on the PC port of it. I also did uh SWAT, it's one of the SWAT franchise games for the Xbox and PlayStation 2.

BryceUm what was it like programming on uh uh the PlayStation 1 platform, which I can only imagine was quirky and specialized and challenging.

Matt GodboltAll of the Sony platforms are exactly that. They are bonkers. I didn't spend very much time working on the PlayStation 1 version, so I didn't get to really get to grips with it. I spent I was originally just a tester. Um I'd been hired in my uh during my my university degree, and they were like, we want you to stop and start working for us, and I'm like, I can't. I said, well, I can come back in the summer holidays, but I didn't know what to do with a programmer who was going to come in and be there for a few weeks. And I said, here's a controller, you can be a tester. That was a really interesting experience, right? We had just decided, or we just discovered the that if you videotape the PlayStation while you're playing, it's an amazing reproduction-like system.

Matt GodboltSo if you get it to crash or blow up or you jump through a wall or whatever, you can rewind the tape and show the developer, look, it happens! I actually have proof, because you know, they'll be like, there's no way you could get through the wall there. Um, but then yeah, the PlayStation 2 was a real class device. I mean it was it was bonkers and crazy, and all in a sort of good ways, if you love the kind of like the way that uh uh disparate group of awesome hardware components are put together in a box, shipped to you with a Japanese instruction manual that no one speaks Japanese, and no standard libraries at all, and off you go.

Matt GodboltIt took us like three months to get like a single triangle on the screen, which was like so awesome. And then add to the mix of it, uh Microsoft were doing the Xbox, the original Xbox at this time, and they, you know, the whole Steve Bournemouth jumping around on stage chub thing, they were like all about the developer. And so they shipped us a device with Visual Studio, a plug-in that you just press a button and it goes off of your machine and it starts running on the Xbox that's plugged in. It was amazing to see the difference between this arcane thing that was like an embedded system that you didn't really understand, and the full bells and whistles you can put breakpoints in, they just work, and all that kind of nonsense.

Matt GodboltIt was awesome. And that was my first run in actually with NVIDIA. So that was what no, actually, I tell it lie, that was my second run-in. I remember getting a Reaver TNT, one of the original ones, they shipped out in this beautiful uh brushed aluminium case that was like a briefcase, and you opened it up and it was all foam except for just the card in the middle, because they were trying to woo developers like us to actually like port our games to use it and stuff.

BryceHow this was back, this was back when like NVIDIA was like a scrappy young company.

Matt GodboltYeah, it certainly was. I remember going to uh conferences like uh E3 and chatting to some of the original engineers that were around, and the name is escaping my right right now, but like they were definitely the underdog in this, right? They were contending with with you know uh 3D FX was like their main competitor now, and look how different the world is now.

BryceYes, we are now a trillion dollar company, and we do not send developers shiny brush aluminum cases worth our cards.

Matt GodboltThey come and knocking on your door, like they're like zombie hordes outside, they give us them, yeah.

BryceDo you do you uh miss the time that you spend as a game developer? Is there anything that you miss about it?

Matt GodboltI I do miss having a very uh constrained environment in console development for sure, and now uh I'm being tape photographed here. Um in console development where you have a very well-defined system that everyone's gonna have under their TV, and you can do any hacks you come up with are almost certainly gonna work on all the consoles, at least the generation that I was involved with. I don't know if that's true anymore. I think there's a lot more leeway in terms of the parts that they can switch in and out. So, you know, I used to sit there with the PS2 maps manuals open in my lap, and you would sit there and count how many cycles it would be, and it would you'd open the thing and go, like, oh, I can fit a divide in here, and you knew you could definitely get a divide in, or you knew that you could get a transfer over um over through the uh the memory bus to something in a particular time, and it would always be that time because it was the one thing, and now you can't do those kinds of tricks, I don't think.

BryceBut very different on PC gaming environment, I imagine.

Matt GodboltAnd yeah, and most consoles these days are have a that thing where you've got so many layers of drivers between you and the hardware instead of just literally poking registers. So, yeah, going back to the Xbox, my sort of NVIDIA story about that was that like Microsoft couldn't tell us, you know, we're we're we're used to this idea of like, you know, we've got registers, we poke registers, we we write memory in places, um, and then we were given direct X and we're like, I can't say next word on your podcast, but please don't do that. We would like to see how the hardware works. So Microsoft were like, we can't tell you how this works because we have an agreement with Nvidia, and they won't let us tell you how it works.

Matt GodboltSo you have to use the D3D interfaces, and then they would go, they would politely cough, and then they say, if you open up d3d.h and look at that what the macros actually correspond to, you can probably infer how it really works. And so that was the first thing we all did was like crack it open and go, oh, that's cool, and then we immediately went off and did a whole bunch of stuff with with with with other lower level stuff, you know. So that was a lot of fun, and I do miss that aspect of it, but you know, I now work in trading, and we've got a similar-ish issue there. We've got you know, certainly in the lower latency stuff, which I'm not doing this uh at the moment, but um there's only so much that money can buy, there's only so many computers uh that you that exist, you know, you can overclock them to some extent, but ultimately you've got like a um a physics constrained set of uh uh constraints, right?

Matt GodboltIt's like well, how fast can this go, and how long can the cables be? And how how many few clock cycles can it do? Everyone's got an Intel machine or whatever.

BryceBut but can't you make sure that your rack's closer to the where the net the cable's plugging into the wall and the other guy's racks?

Matt GodboltNo, that is a really big deal. So, in between uh my current gig and the previous gig, I actually worked at an exchange, and so I got to see what happens on the other side of the TCP connection. And one of the most fancy bits of equipment that we had at the time was a super cool thing that fired a laser beam down a cable and it measured the reflection of it not being plugged in at the other end, and it could tell us how long the cable was and how kinked it was, so that we could measure exactly how long they were, so that we could give our clients the guarantee that they had exactly 800 feet or whatever it was, so that nobody was privileged in any way.

Matt GodboltSo, I mean it's a big deal, it's a really important thing when you're telling traders like, hey, look, we want to sell you this access, everyone has a level playing field. Level, I'm gonna say with air quotes here, but yeah, it's uh it's an interesting, it's an interesting world, but I don't do that kind of stuff anymore. I do miss that a bit as well because again, there's this kind of like uh arms race type thing, and it's a purely intellectual exercise of like how can I do this with one fewer cycle or this much faster stuff, but yeah, no, it's good fun.

ConorThat is fascinating. We're gonna have to have Matt back on a few more times. We definitely have to have Matt back on for a recording that will get turned into three or four episodes. In case folks have forgotten, we're talking to Matt Garble, co-host of a podcast of Two's Compliment.

BryceSo why don't you tell us a bit about your podcast and why people should listen to it?

Matt GodboltUh you should listen to us if you want to hear two friends just chatting about software engineering practices, which sounds kind of familiar, I think, for you two. But uh there's far fewer conversations about the uh interior design of either of our houses.

BryceLook, it was one time!

ConorIt was one time it was not one time, it was like seven episodes. That's what started the whole 10x speeding up your own.

BryceI was moving, I was moving into the apartment. I was excited that the furniture had arrived.

ConorIt hadn't arrived, Bryce. You were explaining to the listener your like arrival schedule of your bed. They did not hear it because I 10x the hell out of your voice. Yes, there's no furniture. Probably why To's Complet is a better podcast to listen to. It's more on topic. That's probably true.

Matt GodboltMaybe a little bit more on topic, but we are we're nowhere near as uh as uh uh consistent as you two. You seem to get something out every week. How many episodes now? The key is low quality, the key is high quantity.

BryceThe key is low quality and also Connor's dedication and the hard work. And also we are we are young 30-something men.

ConorThat's true. Sometimes I hear kids in the background and it warms my heart. You've also got, I think, a couple pets. Yeah, dogs, cats, yeah, yeah. And I and that is a lovely touch when I hear it, and you're like, oh, I'm sorry about that. And I was like, no, that's like that proves that you're not a robot.

Matt GodboltOh, uh, thank you, I think. I passed the Turing test because my wife might make a noise in the background occasionally.

BryceYeah, Connor, I think you had a question from Matt.

ConorOh, yes. Uh so well, we've been talking about the fact that you are co-host of a podcast and a lot of your work experience, but also today, we competed in the same time slot, both speaking at the same time. So, and uh the title of your talk, if I'm not mistaken, is which is also for maybe the 2% of our listeners that don't know, but if this if this podcast pops off on the Reddits or whatever, and there are first-time listeners, Matt Gobalt is infamous in the C community and should be more famous in other programming language communities because you have a website called Compiler Explorer that does uh decompilation, uh, so you can look at the assembly.

ConorI guess it's not decompilation. But anyways, the point is there's like now, I don't even know how many websites. Yeah, we gotta lift up the wine glass. We have we have a thousand dollars of recording equipment that Connor is holding a wine glass over. But there's like, I want to say 30 languages, including like languages like Haskell and ADA, which have nothing to do. Is ADA one of the languages, I think?

Matt GodboltAda is one of the languages, one of the main contributing contributors. Because one of the main contributors wanted to uh uh add the language that they work in in a day job.

BryceI I I actually can't. I know some of the ADA people from the the US from the US programming languages committee, yeah.

Matt GodboltUm but no, we have 50 languages now. Woo! Yeah, we we've been we've the the the trick has been making it into a sort of self-service thing to add your own languages, add your own compilers.

BryceEverything's open source. I would argue that Godbalt has been transformative to languages like C because it allows you to just go and do the like REPL style programming that you can do easily in other languages.

ConorThere's two things I'll say. One, that's 100% true. The best thing to happen to C in the last well, I well, because C was big. Was God Vault bigger than C11? Yeah.

BryceI mean, it's definitely bigger than bigger than 20, bigger than 20.

ConorWhat year, what year did uh Compiler Explorer come out? 2012. 2012. So yes, definitely in the last, well, that's just over a decade. In the last 12 years, or since C11, Compiler Explorer is the best thing to happen. How do we know that? There's only one Patreon project I've ever sponsored, and that's Compiler Explorer, because if I pay $10 for uh YouTube premium and $30 for Amazon Prime, there's nothing that I use more than Compiler Explorer. Proof is that in the same time slot when I was giving my talk, every single code example, not just C, but also C Circle, had a link and was running on this website, which is what percentage of your day-to-day code development is.

BryceMore than 50%.

ConorMore than 50%.

BryceI don't I don't use my terminal anymore, I just use CotLa.

ConorNo, no, no, like so. Literally, there I was watching Tina's talk this morning, which was throwing tools at ranges. I tried to open my Linux laptop, which crashes every once in a while. It crashed, and when I restart it, it makes a big beeping noise, so I didn't want to do that in the middle of the talk. And then I realized, because that's where uh Sean Baxter's uh executable for the circle compiler is. Right. And so I was like, oh, I guess I gotta wait to type this in to see if I can get her code to compile on Circle. And then I realized, what am I doing? Let me just open my other Windows laptop, which definitely doesn't crash, and I can just run this on God Bolt because all the Circle stuff is there.

ConorAnyways, we're supposed to be letting Matt talk here. The point is.

Matt GodboltNo, no, no, no, no, this is better.

ConorThis is like I got my own private podcast here. This is brilliant. Compiler Explorer is absolutely phenomenal. So give a.

BryceAnd let me say Matt only paid us a very reasonable amount of money for this sponsored content.

ConorSo the the the point that we're getting to is that Matt is the creator of this website. And honestly, like we're we're kind of joking, but it is actually like a transformative thing. No, I think it was.

BryceAnd not just C but other languages because it used to, if you wanted to just open up your laptop, if you want to just open up your laptop and start hacking away or prototyping something in C, it used to be that you had to like go like open up, you know, a terminal and go find your compiler and inevitably the.

ConorIt used to be worse than that. When I was back in university in 2009, trying to install a C compiler was a weekend affair that would fail.

BryceI I the the reason so very early in my career, like one of the first things I did was build the Linux kernel with Clang. I'm just like, why did I do that? Because I wanted to build the Linux kernel myself, but I also wanted to build the compiler I was using to build it myself, and I couldn't get I couldn't figure out how to build GCC, so I was like, you know what? This is building GCC was so complicated at the time, it'll just be easier to figure out how to get Clang to build Linux than to figure out how to build GCC. Like at the time, I did learn a lot, and at the time I think it was absolutely the right choice.

ConorSo ten minutes later, the point of this long monologue between Bryce and I is that Matt is the creator of this website, which is actually a big deal. So tell us a little bit about this webs website and how this dovetails into the talk slot. Is that I believe the name of your talk today is what is new in compiler explorer. So give us a small pitch for what is new in compiler explorer.

Matt GodboltI can't believe it, Matt. After 10 minutes. I can't believe you even remembered where you were going with that. I was quite impressed by one talent. Wow, that's a you keep a hardware stack of what you were going, right, right. I've I've I've noticed this by programmers, we hate it when people forget where the conversation thread went because I think we do fear the stack overflow and the whatever. Anyway. Exactly. So uh, what's new in Compiler Explorer was a talk where I was luckily able to celebrate a whole bunch of things because like compiler explorer is not me anymore. I I lend my my name to the domain name that it's on, and many people, including the person pointing the microphone at me right now, call it my last name, which is weird as hell to me, but also I accept that it's a shortened version of what it is, and it's kind of cool, so I'm down with it.

Matt GodboltBut um, it celebrates the uh the sort of team of people who supply uh pull requests and who uh maintain the site and administrate it, and I mean I am still the the the in charge of all that nonsense, but um there are so many cool things in the site that most people don't even know are there, right? There's there's views like um the control flow graph, you can see the assembly and control flow mode, you can see um the internals of the compiler. So many of the compilers have loads of crazy options to let you emit like uh optimization reports, or hey, at this point I did this, and uh uh and then we compile those files out, and so we've got a view where, for example, for Clang, this is my favorite one, um, you can say, here's a bit of code, C code, compile it, show me the internal representation, and then show me every single pass.

Matt GodboltAnd there's like 150 passes that your code goes through where various optimizations take place, and we show them in a like a pane on the left-hand side. I believe we're about to be trolled. Uh-oh.

BryceTrolls. We are definitely about to be trolled.

Matt GodboltYes, there is a troll here. Hello, troll. How's it going? Haven't you already had your slot with this?

JF BastienI I didn't know it was a slot. It was like it's a it's a continuum. Yeah, it's a continuum. Yeah, it's not a slot.

BryceAlright, alright, alright, alright. Most important Cabalics or question.

Matt GodboltYes.

BryceChat GPT integration win?

Matt GodboltI know, I know we've if we've discussed it, and uh, I don't know, the the uh I don't know how to do it for the best, but I I hear somebody's giving a talk tomorrow that might be.

BryceI I am, I am. Uh possibly.

Matt GodboltYeah, yeah, you've what have you finished your slides?

BryceI have finished my slides, I just have to make the slide notes. So I have content, I just don't know what I'm gonna say about it.

Matt GodboltI mean, well, who whoever knows what they're gonna say about their slides? That's what they're looking for.

ConorNot Matt Gobble in his lightning talk today when he hit the summary slide and he was like, oh, and we're done. That was an old slide I hadn't looked at.

BryceOh, I think we uh we need some people.

Matt GodboltYou need to probably move better. Uh no. So, super excited to talk about what's new in Compiler Explorer, and there's a ton of it. Go watch the slide, the talk when it's up. Link in the show notes. There you go. It's quite good. Thank you.

JF BastienAnd you told us in advance you had 55 minutes of content and you hit it right on the notes. It's impressive.

Matt GodboltI have been practicing, my friend. That is that is a thing to do.

BryceI see, I don't practice. I just I just hear it on too much.

Matt GodboltIt's like you're putting it in the look at the conoscence right now.

BryceI just, look, I just make this, honestly, I have not practiced a talk in five years. I make the slide deck and I just I just have a gut feeling for how long it's gonna be. Usually I'm within plus or minus two to three minutes.

Matt GodboltThat's cool. I mean it's good. Everyone has their own process. I can see that Connor and I, who actually I don't who talks the fastest out of the three? I think we're all It's Connor, it's Connor. Yeah, Connor. I feel I feel, but yeah, I think.

BryceSo con Connor tried to make me listen when he's talking, no, Connor, Connor tried to make me listen to some podcasts on the road trip at like two or three X speed or whatever, and it was like, I don't I don't think Connor's human. I really don't think he's human.

ConorIt's a it's uh you just started greasing in and you don't notice. Matt's got some thoughts.

Matt GodboltYeah, I'm exactly on that. I I I'm regularly at 1.9 now. I can't quite make two comfortable, and sometimes when I'm walking the dog, I just need it to be back a bit slower because there's you you kind of want to enjoy it. You forget sometimes that it's not just about the pure information being wired into your brain. It's actually kind of nice to listen to humans talking like normal humans. And I'm just looking around here and thinking, I don't see very many of them around here.

BryceYeah, there really are not. There really are not. Alright, I think we should probably go talk with uh some other people. No, you got other questions? No, it's just JF wants to close. I mean, yeah, JF. Any closing words of wisdom? We've got it.

JF BastienWell, it's good to see you, Matt. Uh Bryce, Connor, hi.

BryceYou came over here to troll, but you had no agenda.

ConorYou are too Canadian, my friend.

JF BastienGentlemen, Bryce, good to see you.

BryceAlright, we're gonna wrap it there. Let's go get our next set of people. That was amazing. Do you want to stay here and I'll get them, or should we both? Let's let's we can walk. Let's walk and talk.

ConorUh yeah, let's walk and talk.

BryceHey Jonathan, you want to say hi?

ConorHi. Don't you just fuck around to annoy people all evening? That's correct. 130k. Hey, see, link in the description.

BryceLink in the description.

ConorYou know, here we are with Tristan Brindle, author of the Flux Library. He's given a talk, iteration, revisited tomorrow. Should people go watch, even though they're listening to this after the talk has happened? They should absolutely come and watch my talk tomorrow. Yes, 100%. And by people, we're talking to people of the world, and uh, so link will be in the description when that talk goes online. You want to go over to the corner for this or what? What's the point? Great follow-up, Bryce. Tristan, good luck on your talk tomorrow.

BryceTristan, did you figure out the pro the the homework problem that I gave you earlier?

ConorThe homework problem has not been top of my mind, but I will uh I will devote some uh brain power to it. Alright, good. Alright, thank you, Tristan. Good luck on your talk tomorrow. Thank you. Alright. We're handing it over to Bryce. It might be a bit confusing on how this whole live interviews has gone down, but we are actually interviewing the co-hosts of three different podcasts. If that's not clear up until this point, that is definitely on Bryce. It is not on me. It's on Bryce. The first podcast we interviewed was with JF. That was oh Jesus. TLB hit.

ConorThe second podcast was Two's Compliment with Matt Gobble. Both of the co-hosts were not there, Chris and Ben, respectively. And now we are here with both co-hosts of the most popular C podcast of all time, the first C podcast of all time, handing it over to Bryce to do the introductions.

BryceAnd also the organizer of the conference that we are at, Mr. Phil Nash. Oh my, how are you doing? We are doing pretty good. So what is the name of your podcast?

Phil NashOh, um, I know this one. Uh it's one of three, isn't it? I think it's currently CPP cast.

BryceThat is a podcast with a long and storied history of excellence. So, what do you think about this year's conference, Phil? I mean, why don't you tell us a little bit about the conference? Because you're the one that started this conference, yes?

Phil NashI am, yes. Well, it's this is the fifth year, but the third in person. But really, it's like the second in person because last year was a reset. So it's all very complicated, really. But uh yeah, been running for five years, and uh I think it's things going pretty well.

BryceWhy why did you decide to start a C conference south of London? Well, everyone else is doing it.

Phil NashI felt a bit left out, so I don't know, this just seems to be a gap in the market at the time. Um had some ideas, what I wanted to do, and uh thought I'd see how they play out. What would you say makes this conference unique? Mostly the C.

BryceOkay, fair enough. And uh what about you, Timur? Why don't you say tell people who you are, what you do?

Timur DoumlerHello, my name is Timor Dumler. I'm the co-host of CPPcast. Um I'm here at the CPP on C conference. Uh yeah. Um where do you work? I work at JetBrains. Um we make tools for developers. I'm uh developer advocate there.

BryceWhat what does it what is a developer advocate? What does a developer advocate do?

Timur DoumlerWell, that's a good question. It's kind of uh it has nothing to do with uh law, even though it has advocate in it. Uh although I guess that doesn't mean anything in English, does it? It's more other languages where advocate means something.

BryceThis podcast is not legal advice. Consult your own lawyers, folks.

Timur DoumlerRight, no, no. Anyway, um so a developer advocate uh basically advocates for uh developers that use a developer-facing product. Um basically an IDE. So, yeah, like we make IDEs and other developer-facing products, like we have a backtracker, we have you know build server, that kind of stuff. So, on the one hand, I'm representing the developer community uh for the team. So I'm advocating for what the developer community actually wants, but also uh I kind of work with the team to make sure that we meet those needs. And I also create lots of content like blog posts, videos, I go to talks, like conferences like this one.

Timur DoumlerThis is kind of very much part of my job as well. Kind of developer outreach, that kind of stuff. Yeah. Teaching people how to write good code, how to use our products.

BryceCool. So why should people listen to your podcast?

Phil NashI was just talking to uh to Timur about this actually, he was saying that uh our podcast is almost like complete opposite, because we're sort of like very structured and follow a bit of a formula, whereas you're completely chaotic. But it's like we complement each other. I think we have room for both.

BryceWell, what what is the what is the structure, like what what does your podcast aim to deliver to its listeners?

Phil NashI think it's just a mixture of like bringing like some of the big names and you know the people who are really influencing the language and the direction that we're going in in the community, um, as well as like new voices, bringing them up to the fore and just letting people know real well people are actually doing with C. So the whole spectrum, really.

Timur DoumlerSo we both kind of were very sad when Rob and Jason stopped doing it, and so we kind of both, I guess, independently thought, wouldn't it be great to like a revive it somehow? Um but then we also didn't want to change too much stuff, right? Because uh it was, you know, it's been running for what, like 10 years or something?

ConorSeven.

Timur DoumlerSeven, yes.

ConorOf course, Connor would know that off the top of his head. Roughly 349 episodes.

Timur DoumlerI I should know that. It's mildly embarrassing.

Phil Nash353 episodes.

Timur DoumlerSo you wanted to keep the formula as much as close as possible to what Rob and Jason were doing because we knew that it's gonna be different, obviously, because we're different people, different personalities, but we wanted to keep like the formula as close as possible. So that's kind of what we're doing. I think it's kind of working. We're making little changes, you know, where it makes sense, but we're gonna keep like the format more or less as it is because we like it. I like it personally a lot.

BryceWhat what's been your favorite thing at this conference this year? Like what tell me one thing that you've learned or found really interesting.

Phil NashAs the conference organizer, I've only had time to actually see two talks. One of them was actually Tima's talk uh today on uh safety and C. And I like the way he finished.

Timur DoumlerI I never thought I would say anything like this, but yes.

BryceWhat what was what was said? Well, can what was said be repeated on a podcast? We're about to find out.

Timur DoumlerRight. So apparently uh the last words of my talk were use Rust.

BryceSo them fighting words. So what what what was your talk about?

Timur DoumlerIt was about the whole safety and security debate that's been going on like for a while, but like quite intensely for the last year or so. And uh, you know, there were lots of talks, lots of reports, lots of news stories about how we have a big problem with safety in C. And obviously we do, and we need to address it, and we haven't maybe in the committee done a great job at that lately. But I wanted to provide a counterpoint a little bit to this thing of um oh we're all doomed, C is gonna die unless you figure out how do we make it like absolutely memory safe the way Rust is. And kind of the point of my talk was well, we can't really, unless we change it so much that it's actually going to be a different language.

Timur DoumlerBut maybe we shouldn't. We should focus on what C is good at, improving safety where it makes sense and where we can, and just be very clear about that, but not be like, oh, we're all doomed and unless it's all memory safe, because you can't really do that anyway.

BryceA lot of those points sound similar to points that were made in Sean Perrin's keynote the other day.

Timur DoumlerIt was actually funny because um so I submitted this talk because JF Bastian nerd sniped me into submitting this talk on Twitter. I was like just tweeting, hey, what should I talk about? And JF was like, why don't you talk about safety? And I was like, okay. Because I don't understand how humor and irony works, and so I just said, okay, I'm gonna do what he said. So I submitted a talk about safety. And then I found out from Phil that Sean is gonna do a keynote on the same topic. So I was like, oh, well, Sean knows a lot of stuff that I don't, so maybe I should just retract my talk.

Timur DoumlerBut then I actually got in touch with Sean, he was really lovely. He spent like two hours with me on a call, talk to me about you know his ideas or what he wanted to talk about. So I was like, oh yeah, there's ways in which I can make that complementary to that and like provide a different perspective and talk about different stuff that kind of complements that. So I hope I achieved that kind of a little bit. Um but yeah, it was good fun.

BryceOkay, so you you heard it here first from the hosts of CBBcast, used Rust.

ConorSo I do have a question, Timur, and I'm gonna preface this by saying that my thesis is that you are C's biggest troll.

BryceYou Oh I I'm sorry, there's Victor. Sorry.

JF BastienThe biggest troll.

BryceHe claimed you were C's biggest troll, which cannot possibly be true because of Mr. Victor.

ConorYes, that's true. Okay, maybe C's second biggest. But here's here's my thesis, and this is why. You gave a 60-minute talk about C and safety. And the two major things that I took away from that talk were that C is not doomed, definitely not as doomed as people think it is, and two, that people are overblowing how important safety is. Not that it's not important, but that C prioritizes performance. However, you then gave a lightning talk at the end of day two of this conference, aka a couple hours ago, where you proceeded to show one of the biggest gotchas that I've seen, and I can't reconcile how you say that C is okay and that safety is not important with your lightning talk, which everyone was just sort of, and in your lightning talk, you had a gift of someone saying expletive silently three different times.

ConorI counted, teamer. How do you reconcile those two things? What are you up to?

BryceWell how do I answer that? Well, what was what was what was the lightning talk?

Timur DoumlerI mean, as teamer. Okay, so so we have this feature called lambdas, which is, you know, you you have like a function that you define in an expression, you can pass that to other functions. And apparently it's so hilariously complicated that I actually spent quite a lot of time preparing a one-hour talk about how this works uh last year, and then I actually had your conference, uh, Connor, the one that you were the program chair of last year. Um, and then after doing all of this work, I still have no clue how lambdas actually work because literally the next day somebody came to me and said, Hey, I have a lambda here, like I don't understand why it does the thing that it does, and I was like, what?

Timur DoumlerAnd then I looked into the standard to try to understand what's going on. I was like, what? And like, so it's this weird thing where kind of I've been doing C for a long time, and here's the thing. I I'm learning more C, right? Uh as I as I go, as I as I do these talks, I work, I write C during the day. So I learn more C. But the language actually gets more complicated and bigger faster than I can learn it.

Timur DoumlerWhich means that the relative like the proportion of C that I know actually shrinks over time. And I I find that quite fascinating. It's like it's like quite a unique property for a programming language, I think. Like so I I kind of I haven't really figured out how to reconcile that uh with like anything really. But yeah, I guess that's my I don't know what my point is, but this is kind of the this is yeah, you in closing, what did what did Phil just say?

JF BastienUse Rust. All right, I think I think we're gonna wrap there. I think we're good.

Timur DoumlerThank you guys. This was it was a lot of fun.

ConorThank you guys.

Timur DoumlerThank you so much.

ConorThank you. And also, uh, as we're closing, any uh exciting things or different things that are happening in 2024 for C on C or they should just tune in to uh the Twitters on a different C. Or yeah, so uh if people want to follow the latest and greatest, the upcoming news, uh what should they do?

Phil NashOh that's a good question. But uh yeah, there will definitely be a C on C 2024. It's gonna be slightly bigger, I'm hoping. And judging by how this week went, I think there are gonna be at least three coffee machines. So you heard it, heard it here first.

BryceCome to C for the best coffee. We're gonna wrap here. We got we still got one more person we're gonna interview.

ConorThat's true.

BryceAnd who is that person? Mr. Sean Parent.

ConorIt's been too long, Sean. We're having you explain. Except we're coming for you. This will probably be the end of episode 136, I believe. And so you'll hear from Sean next week because this podcast is already over 40.

BryceAnd don't worry, we we have heard your requests for more Sean, and there will there is a lot more Sean coming in the future.

ConorThere's a lot more Sean coming in the future, folks. All right. All right. Be sure to check these show notes for links to everything that we mentioned in today's uh episode, as well as a link to the GitHub discussion where you can leave comments, thoughts, and questions. And thanks for listening. We hope you enjoyed and have a great day.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Guests

  • Jonathan MΓΌller Guest Inferred
  • Matt Godbolt Guest Inferred
  • Phil Nash Guest Inferred
  • Timur Doumler Guest Inferred
  • Tristan Brindle Guest Inferred

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Episode 313: C++26 Reflection vs CRTP, AI, Kids & More with Zach Laine

    Nov 20, 202647 minAudio

    In this episode, Conor and Bryce chat with Zach Laine about C++26 Reflection vs CRTP, AI, kids & more. Link to Episode 313 on Website Discuss this episode, leave a comment, or ask a question (on GitHub) Socials ADSP:...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Episode 312: The C++26 Contracts Fiasco

    Nov 13, 202652 minAudio

    In this episode, Conor and Bryce chat with Zach Laine about the C++26 contracts fiasco. Link to Episode 312 on Website Discuss this episode, leave a comment, or ask a question (on GitHub) Socials ADSP: The Podcast:...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Episode 311: Career Changes, GPUs & More with Zach Laine

    Nov 6, 202628 minAudio

    In this episode, Conor and Bryce talk with Zach Laine about his career and the career changes he has made. Link to Episode 311 on Website Discuss this episode, leave a comment, or ask a question (on GitHub) Socials...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Episode 310: Leaving NVIDIA for... ?

    Oct 30, 202624 minAudio

    In this episode, Conor and Bryce talk about Bryce's next chapter and where he is leaving NVIDIA for. Link to Episode 310 on Website Discuss this episode, leave a comment, or ask a question (on GitHub) Socials ADSP: The...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Episode 309: Default Construction & CppCon 2026 with Jason Turner

    Oct 23, 202629 minAudio

    In this episode, Conor and Ben chat with Jason Turner about default construction in C++. Link to Episode 309 on Website Discuss this episode, leave a comment, or ask a question (on GitHub) Socials ADSP: The Podcast:...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode