Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

ADHD Mums

ADHD Mums artwork

42. ADHD and Screen Time: Why Taking the iPad Away Won’t Fix Homework

Nov 4, 202626 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

‘If you can focus on that, you can focus on this.’ You said it standing at the bench, and he looked at you like you’d said it in another language. He’s just died fifteen times on the same level and gone again. Ten maths questions, Year 4 stuff he’s done before, and a minute and a half later he’s picking the sticker off his drink bottle. Is he lazy? Is he doing it on purpose? Is he choosing? A listener asked all three, and the answer isn’t the one the screen-time argument gives you. Taking the iPad away doesn’t fix it, and there’s a reason. More on school and homework: the school collection https://tr.ee/schoolcollection Mentioned in this episode: Why You Snap at 4pm When You Were Fine at 9am https://tr.ee/qa3RcmxWoq The free Energy Accounting Guide I mention, for working out how much your child has left by homework time https://adhdmums.com.au/product/adhd-mums-energy-accounting-guide/ If homework is one more thing the school hands you to sort out at the kitchen bench, When School Isn’t Working is the guide I wish I’d had: the scripts, the rights and the plans for when the system doesn’t fit your child. Doing this on your own and money’s tight? Email me at jane@adhdmums.com.au. https://adhdmums.com.au/product/making-school-work-parent-guide/ References Sonuga-Barke, E. J., Taylor, E., Sembi, S. & Smith, J. (1992). Hyperactivity and delay aversion I: The effect of delay on choice. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 33(2), 387-398. Antrop, I. et al. (2006). ADHD and delay aversion: the influence of non-temporal stimulation on choice for delayed rewards. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 47(11), 1152-1158. Lemiere, J. et al. (2012). Brain activation to cues predicting inescapable delay in adolescent ADHD: an fMRI pilot study. Brain Research, 1450, 57-66. 📬 Listener Questions & Community 🎙️ Ask a Listener Question (voice) Voice notes are preferred when possible - hearing your voice helps add context - but you’re very welcome to submit a written question instead. Send a WhatsApp voice or written on 0403 457 313 All the top rated episodes sorted by topic 👥 Join the ADHD Mums Facebook Group 👥 Receive the episodes in your inbox Mentioned in this episode: Free Resources Free Resouces

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Hi there, gents. Welcome to ADHD mums. I'm Jane. I've spent years studying this brain, which has done absolutely nothing for the state of my car, and yet, here we go. Thank you for being here have you ever watched your child play on technology and lose the same level over and over again on a game? Maybe they get frustrated, they start swearing, throwing things but yet they go straight back on it over and over. But then the same child gets a set of 10 maths questions And he absolutely cannot concentrate, persist, or complete the task.

have you sent that same child to go and get dressed for school? You go find him 20 minutes later, he's only found one sock and he's reading a Lego catalog. Have you ever heard yourself say those actual words? Hang on a second, but you can focus on that game, but you can't focus on getting some socks or this little piece of homework?" Have you ever got a look back from that same child as if you'd said that question in another language and they look completely confused as to why you would think that's the same thing? this week's listener question is a mom with a nine-year-old and a maths sheet

Can someone please explain my kid to me? Because I've got nothing. He's nine. He's got this game, I don't know what it's called, and there's a level he's been stuck on for about a week, and he dies over and over. I counted 15 in a row the other day. 15, and he's swearing. He's chucked the controller twice. I nearly took it off him, and then he picks it up, and he goes again. Every single time. Then I put a math sheet in front of him, 10 questions. Year four stuff I've watched him do before.

Minute and a half, gone. Not a fight, not a tantrum. He just sort of wandered off. Went to the fridge, came back, started picking the sticker off his drink bottle, asked me what's for dinner. And I'm standing there like, "Mate, you just sat through 15 deaths without getting off the beanbag, and you can't do 10 questions?" So I said, "If you can focus on that, then you can focus on this." And he looked at me like I'd said it in another language. Is he lazy? Is he doing it on purpose? Because I swear, it feels like he's choosing

And what a question. when I listened to it, oh my God, I could relate. that is so my house, and I see that question all the time in Facebook groups, particularly around is ADHD real? My partner, my extended family doesn't understand how my child can focus on a game, for example but then can't concentrate on homework or something that you really want them to do. And is it really ADHD? Maybe that child is choosing. Maybe ADHD isn't real Maybe it's behavior-based.

Maybe that child needs more discipline You know the part that got me in this listener question? It is the sticker. When the child starts picking the sticker off his drink bottle and asks what for dinner-- I feel like all of us have had that child when you're trying to get them to do something and they stand at the bench picking a sticker off something. Oh my God, it's infuriating. A drink bottle, a lunchbox, a sticker that's been stuck on a chair for two years, and suddenly the child starts picking it off The level of

frustration, the sticker just got me. So the listener has asked three separate questions . One, is this lazy? . Two, is this on purpose? . Three, is he choosing? But one thing the listener said that didn't quite make sense to me was the 15. Fifteen deaths on a level that he had been stuck on for a week, swearing, controller on the ground, picking it back up, going again. So this is a child who handles hard better than most, better than I do.

I absolutely would not be persisting at that point. I think I would've quit at four times and then just told everybody the game was broken The listener has also told us that the maths isn't that hard. It's maths that the listener has seen her child do. So it's not that the homework is hard and the game is easy. That would be easy to assume. But actually, this child is really good at hard. and the homework is actually easy. So It is not about whether it's difficult or easy.

It is something else entirely So let's go back to the listeners' lounge room for a second. when the child is playing the game and he dies in a level, what happens? In the game, I would imagine, I've got my own nine and seven-year-old boys, I have to watch gaming a lot. But what happens when they die in a level? It's probably about two seconds long generally. The screen goes dark, there's a sound, ba-bow, and then they're back at the start of the level. The child doesn't have to do anything to make that happen.

He doesn't have to decide to go again. The game decides for him, and he's kind of already moving through it. So 15 deaths, 15 restarts, and nothing in between. Nothing. There's no gap. There's never a moment where the game just sits there and waits for him to feel like it again, and there's very rarely any loading this day and age, is it? Everything online is quick and lightning fast. So back to the bench. The maths homework, question one.

The child reads it, he works it out, he writes a number. and then what? Nothing. Nothing happens, right? There's nothing. Nobody says anything. The sheet doesn't do anything. Question two doesn't come up automatically. He has to go and find it. and there's this little pocket of nothing between the end of one and the start of the next, and that might be 10 seconds or 20 seconds. so if there's 10 questions on this math sheet, then nine of those have pockets of time with nothing in them.

Now, one of my children lasts about a minute and a half doing homework at a time. That might be one question and one pocket of time afterwards, or it could be two questions possibly, and then he's sidetracked and when I say sidetracked, I mean an urgent need comes up. Maybe your child has to go to the fridge. Maybe they go to the toilet. Maybe they have to pat the dog. Maybe they need to sharpen all of the pencils in the house And think about at this point what a sticker does.

A sticker and peeling it off is something to do with your hands while there's nothing happening So is the question really the child escaping the maths homework? Or is it escaping the pocket of time in between questions? some of you listening might be quite impatient. And so when we have impatient children and we are impatient ourselves, it can be quite aggravating, right? But it's not like we can't relate. You might be someone like my hubby. He's always late, and when I've asked him about it, he said he can't stand waiting

for the other person So he turns up five, 10 minutes late or whatever it is, because then he knows that they'll be there. And of course, the first thought, is , "Yeah, so he doesn't like waiting, so he makes the other person wait." Yes, I've pointed that out to him. He doesn't care because he finds actually waiting himself so painful and irritating that he just says he can't do it So for people with ADHD, it can really create an avoidance of waiting, of the gap, of nothing happening.

If you have children that say, "I'm bored," instantly, it's not even a second and they start saying it, this is this avoidance of waiting or nothing happening. So if, for example, you're trying to get your child off the iPad and you say, "Why don't you do something else?" Then they start saying, "I'm bored, I'm bored," it's because that period of trying to think of what to do what to play is so difficult, they just prefer to go back on the iPad because it's consistent "Let's go play soccer now. Go play handball.

Here's the ball," reduces that gap where the kids just want to avoid. the research supports this, it's called delay aversion. and basically, kids with ADHD seem to find empty waiting periods more unpleasant than other kids. And it isn't the word boring here. The research found unpleasant was the experience. in the research, you would give these ADHD kids a choice, a small reward now, or a bigger reward later.

and the ADHD kids picked a smaller reward now more often than other kids that seemed like something I would expect, but the next part I found really interesting. In another small study, they took 23 kids between the ages of seven to 12 And they looked at the reasons why the ADHD kids would prefer the quick smaller reward now than waiting for a large one And you would assume looking at this that it's because they're impulsive. like I want the small thing now, I'm just gonna take it because that's what I wanna

do right now in this moment, impulsivity. However, this study showed the reasons why, and the reason why the ADHD children were taking the smaller, quicker reward was because they didn't want to wait overall Even though the thing was bigger and the reward was greater, it didn't offset how much they didn't wanna wait So in this study, they went ahead and took away the weight And interestingly enough, the difference mostly went away. it really showed that it wasn't about the ADHD kids being impulsive, it was

because they had such a large aversion to the waiting period, to the part where nothing is happening that study was only on children between seven and 12, so I wanted to have a look at teenagers. I had a look at a brain scan study for teenagers And it actually took the whole thing further. it found that when ADHD teenagers were faced with waiting, their brain actually lit up with it being unpleasant. So it wasn't just boring, it actually cost them. It felt unpleasant So let's go back to the listener's kitchen bench

Let's look at the 10 questions in the maths homework and the nine gaps where there is a gap between after the answer is done and the next questions, whilst a neurotypical teenager might go, "Ooh, that was a bit boring," trying to figure out what to do, the ADHD child actually has quite an unpleasant experience. Like, I'm feeling taxed and tired." Now, if we look at overall capacity of that teenager , and this is at the end of a day which will impact them as well . If you'd like to know more about capacity, check out my energy accounting free download.

I'll pop it into the show notes. And it's basically about everybody has a certain amount of energy or capacity that they have to start the day. And that capacity or that money goes down and down and down as the day goes on. So if we look at this for children or for teenagers, the school will drastically cost them energy, time from masking, stress, whatever it is, learning, and then when they come home, they might have very little capacity, or they might even be in the negatives, and then we sit down with some homework.

But in this homework experience for them, it is not neutral. Those gaps, that waiting period between questions costs them something, and they might not have much left And at the same time that we are trying to motivate them or help them with their homework or keep them on track, what do we also have? Less capacity if you take ADHD medication, your medication's wearing off. If your child takes it, theirs is wearing off too. What a recipe for disaster. If you'd like to know more about that, I have an episode called "Why You Snap at

4:00 PM and You Were Fine at 9:00 AM." I'll put that episode into the show notes So really what I'm wondering with this listener question, and this is my opinion Is that this waiting gap between questions might be a large part of the problem A game lines up the next thing in under a second or two seconds, and the math sheet makes him wait for it Particularly if you are sitting there with a child and you're low on capacity, you've got lots to do, and they're sitting there trying to work out a question. The first thing I do is get up and go do a load of washing.

Do I come back? If I remember, maybe not. And then they're sitting there even longer asking you to come back or they wander off themselves Let's look at the three things that the listener asked. The first one, is he lazy? No. A lazy child does not die 15 times on a level and go again A child lacking motivation or laziness, as she says, might be a child that dies twice in a game and says the game is dumb, throws the controller across the room and goes lies on the couch. But what the listener described, swearing getting so frustrated,

but then just continuing on, that's a child who's grinding. They're pushing. And it can be kind of frustrating and kind of funny. I'm trying not to have a giggle because that child grinding that level of persistence, wouldn't you want that in another area that's not a game? Like I would But we can see the amount of effort that goes into some of this gaming. And then of course we want it and we wonder why it can't go anywhere else. So it is not laziness. The second question that the listener asked was, "Is it on

purpose?" No, it is not on purpose. He is not purposely being persistent on the game and then ignoring, getting frustrated, or avoiding the homework. Third question the listener asked, choosing. Is he choosing? This is the closest to what I think is happening, because I think he is choosing. The child is choosing between sitting in a pocket of nothing So finishing a question, having nothing to say, "Well done," no tick, no acknowledgement.

He doesn't even know if he's done it right. And then to get to the next question, he has a gap that he has to then get motivated and , something that he has to push himself out of. So he has to choose between that gap between question one and two and anything else in the house. Picking a sticker off a drink bottle is anything else. Patting the dog, getting a snack, going to the toilet three times, that is picking anything over that gap of boredom, of nothing in between

questions Which reminds me of what? The fact that I cannot wait on a hold for a phone call. I'll do anything else to avoid that gap of just waiting, but then I get so sidetracked I never come back to it and I have to restart again. No matter how important it is, I still do that How many adults do you see that can't wait two seconds waiting in line or anything? They'll get on their phone, anything to fill the gap. So whilst we can look at it and go, "Why can't he do that? It's so easy.

Do the 10 questions. I wish that's all I had to do." He's actually got a gap there, which is the one thing that I personally really avoid So I'm sure that you have said to your child at some point, Why can you focus on that game, but you can't focus on the homework? How come you can do that for two hours and you can't do this for a minute?" And your child's looked back at you like you're speaking another language, because to that child, you are If we look at it from the child's perspective, when they are asked, "How can you focus on the game for two hours but not

on your homework for over a minute?" From the child's perspective, it sounds like the mom thinks that those two things are the same. So pick the right one, the homework, and do that. and he might be thinking to himself, "They're not the same. One of them sucks and it has waiting and sitting and nothing in it, and the other doesn't." Is he right? Yes When I received this listener question, I ran a poll on my Instagram and Facebook stories. If you took screens away, does homework improve?

80% of people said it did not improve homework to take the screen away. Oh my God, so many people think that if you take a screen away, homework will improve A lot of mums replied to the stories and said things like, "My child went to the toilet five times, sharpened eight pencils wandered off. Lots of long stories about children doing tasks you've always wanted them to do except for the homework. And so this is when screens were not accessible.

So that didn't mean that if there's no screen, they went and did their homework easily. That didn't happen so what can we do? Two things. You can pick one or both, see how it goes. The first one Put something into the gap. If we go back to the study with the ADHD kids where they could either pick a small reward now or a larger reward after waiting And most of the ADHD kids picked the smaller quick reward but a follow up study took the kids with ADHD that took the quick small reward and said to them,

"Now you can have a cartoon or something to do in that period. Would you like the small reward now, or the larger reward later after waiting, but in the waiting period you have a cartoon?" And what happened? More ADHD kids picked the larger reward later which really illustrates this point that the wait is the issue, the empty waiting. Something that I have seen other mums do is that you could have a game on, paused

on the bench right next to the math sheet. One question, one round of the game. This works for some people and not others because you are relying on a child being able to transition between a game and homework, But it's a way of filling the gap with something that your child was gonna fill anyway. So if your child is gonna struggle in that gap and they're gonna go and start picking stickers off drink bottles or doing random task and not coming back, you fill that gap with the game, and when the game round finishes, they do the next question It will take some monitoring to make sure they do

the next question on the math sheet. This will not work for everybody. Your mother-in-law might have opinions. Your partner might say that you're bribing him. However, for some mums, I've seen this work because It's actually about filling the void You might look at this scenario and fill the gap or the void in a different way, and that's okay too. If you have a really great strategy with this, Please join the Facebook group and post. I'd love to see it. Number two the second thing that the listener could do with the homework sheet

Is to mark every question as he does it. So not at the end when they finish the 10 questions. Do one question, tick it, well done, done. Put a sticker on it. Your child might go better on the homework if something happens at the end of the question If you have a child that will do learning on an iPad, for example, sometimes parents say kids stick at it longer because it goes da-ding when you get the game right If you have a reading log, for example, and you fill it out once a week or once a term, that might be way too long for your child.

You might need to sign that every night after they do it. Or if there's a spelling test, Tick it after every word or three words. Don't necessarily tick it once a week. So it's not that you need to have a bigger reward, but you might need to bring the reward in sooner So what you are doing is instead of having the nine pockets of nothing, you're making them so short that he never actually gets to go and wander off Now, when I did this poll on Instagram and Facebook, A lot of mums said very similar things.

"Homework goes okay if I sit there and tick every question, or I monitor him and say, 'Keep going, well done.' And if I don't do that, it doesn't happen." So if you have multiple kids, you work till 5:00, maybe your partner's FIFO or you're a single mum, Sitting there and ticking every question just isn't possible Not many moms I know have that time, particularly with multiple kids And so what that really becomes is a job or something that you might have to do for your child to achieve doing their homework.

And if you don't do it, what then? Oh my God, you feel guilty. "It was my fault I didn't sit with them." Another thing you've got to remember. And so these constant small wins of filling these gaps means that someone has to be there constantly with that child. And who is someone? That someone is probably gonna be you and then of course, what does the parenting advice say? Just ask for help. Well My middle son, who really struggles with homework, his homework is due on Fridays.

And I would help assistant coach at netball on Thursday afternoons. And so my middle son, who avoids homework like no other, would never, ever, ever do it before Thursday afternoon. And so I would be out with my daughter at netball training, and I would say to my hubby, "He has to do his homework. You really have to sit with him, supervise it," et cetera, et cetera. However, on Thursday afternoons, I would come home, and it would still never really been done. They would have an argument, something would happen, and either my hubby would say, "It's impossible.

He won't do it," or my son would say, "It's too hard. I can't do it. I don't know why." And then I would end up doing it with him on Friday morning with a coffee But when I've reflected back on this research and this episode, I've really started to wonder if what I actually said to my hubby was the problem here. Because I said to him that he had to sit with him whilst our son does his homework. hubby was probably sitting there on his phone looking up now and again saying, "Keep going, mate," every few minutes And my hubby was there in the room, but was he really filling those gaps?

And when I've reflected back, I think about the instruction that I gave him, and I think it was wrong. It wasn't to supervise him doing his homework or to body double him and sit there. It was actually to actively engage and when our son writes the answer, mark it, tick it, next one, good job we might actually be being the sound that the game makes when they clear the level. Cha-ching, bing, boo, whatever it is. And yes, there's a dopamine element here.

We all know that with ADHD, But without that instruction, my hubby just sat there, I would imagine looking up going, "Well done." That's not the same thing So let's go back to the listener. She said, "I swear it feels like he's choosing." And you know what? You're right. He is choosing but the choice that your child is making, I don't think is the one you think it is. I don't think he's choosing between the game and maths I think the choice is the gap between questions and the waiting period

And doing anything else in the house And the great thing about identifying a problem properly is that once we really know what that problem is, we actually can do something about it. If we think that the problem is choosing a game over homework , we can see from the Instagram and the Facebook polls that when you take the game away, you don't actually get the child to do the homework and that's where sometimes some people, extended families, partners, whoever it is, can say it's behavior

He's still not doing his homework. Why? It's discipline. It's parenting. You need to do more. But I would ask the question whether the gap between questions and that void is being properly addressed Next time, watch your child choose and see how they do it let's say they're going to sit on the kitchen table And I know it's frustrating because by the time we've got the child over to the dinner table to do the math sheet, we're so frustrated, and I also want to avoid

the waiting period where I have to sit and watch him do the questions, which is hilarious because that's what he's also trying to avoid And so resist the urge to put the sheet down and walk away. Stay, lean on the bench, sit down at the table with him and don't say anything, and watch the child do question one. Watch him write the answer and watch the face When they finish, look at the three seconds. The pen stops, the eyes come off the page.

Watch what they do. Does he look out the window, to the dog, to the drink bottle? Does he look at you? What's happening? Does he look at the TV? And somewhere in that three seconds, it might be that he might try and look up or find something else to do If that is what is happening and you can watch and see it, then make those three seconds shorter. Tick the question the second he finishes it, say, "Well done," and say, "Let's go the second one. Let's go the third one." Or bring out the game, he plays

one level, stop, next question. Fill in the gaps for him I hope you've enjoyed this episode. Thank you so much to the listener for sending this in. if you have questions on the episode, anything to share, maybe you have the magical answer and you've had a child like this and you've got something that works, oh my God, Share it into the Facebook group. Send me a voice memo or a text message on the ADHD Mum's phone. It's all in the show notes. Thank you for being here. See you next time This is ADHD mums.

Let's keep killing it. See you next week

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. ADHD at Christmas: 4 Ways to Stop Forgetting the Thing You Think About Every Day

    Nov 18, 202621 minAudio

    You think about it every single day. It feels like you’re doing the work. But the thing still isn’t done. Monday you found the note under a brown banana: angel costume, white, needed Thursday. You thought about it in...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. AuDHD vs ADHD: Sensory Processing Differences Were Never Part of ADHD (with Amanda Moses)

    Nov 16, 202626 minAudio

    You started ADHD medication and, for the first time in years, your head went quiet. Then the chewing at dinner became unbearable. The tag in your shirt. The hum of the fridge. Everyone online has an answer. Half say...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. 44. AuDHD in Women: 'Classic ADHD' Gets a Laugh. 'Classic Autism' Gets Silence.

    Nov 11, 202623 minAudio

    It’s Sunday night. You’re in bed reading a list of what autism looks like in women, and every line is you. Rehearsing the phone call in the car. Needing three days to recover after a birthday party. The tags on your...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. 43. Kids and Chores: ‘It’s Easier to Just Do It Myself.’ Why We Keep Asking the Easy Kid (with Gen Muir)

    Nov 9, 202640 minAudio

    ‘It’s not fair!’ You’ve heard it so many times you could scream. And the worst part? Sometimes they’re right. You keep asking the kid who says yes. The one who does it properly, first time, without the whinging. It’s...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. 41. PDA and Low-Demand Parenting: When the Demands Don't Disappear, They Land on You

    Nov 2, 202652 minAudio

    Have you ever done everything right - dropped the demand, softened the ask, delivered it the one way that works - walked out of the room for two minutes, and come back to a child on the floor who won't get up for an...

    Credit the people on this episode