The apparitions of Mary are a phenomenon that is going on today. There are some people who, every day, believe that they see a vision of the action person of Mary the mother of the Lord Jesus and interact with her. They ask her questions, she speaks with them, she reveals secrets and prophecies. What are we to make of something so apparently supernatural and so thoroughly Catholic? Mark Sell and I take a moment to discuss this important subject on this episode of Acts242.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_03Acts 2, 42. And they continued steadfastly.
SPEAKER_00Jeremiah and Ibn Belech both said two words. They said, Yes, Lord.
SPEAKER_03Steadfastly in the apostles' doctrine and fellowship, you study him, you read the scriptures, you read the four gospels, you trace his steps, you hear his words, you see his works, you see the compassion and the love of his father. And in breaking of bread, he is all together. Lovely. And in breaking of bread and in prayers.
SPEAKER_02We started off with this prayer last time, and I want to read it again to sort of just set our minds, if you will, into exactly how a Catholic thinks about Mary. So here is this prayer. Again, it's from the uh book of novena prayers in honor of our mother perpetual help, published in 1948 with official Catholic Church approval. It says, quote, Have pity, compassionate Mother, on us and our families, especially in this my necessity.
SPEAKER_02And then you say what that is. Help me, O my mother, in my distress. Deliver me from all my ills, or if it be the will of God that I should suffer still longer. Grant that I may endure all with love and patience. The grace I expect of thee with confidence, because thou art our perpetual help. We have no greater help, no greater than hope hope than you, O most pure virgin. Help us then, for we hope in you, we glory in you, we are your servants. Do not disappoint us. Come to my aid, dearest mother, for I recommend myself to thee.
SPEAKER_02In thy hands I place my eternal salvation, and to thee I entrust my soul. Count me among thy most devoted servants, take me under thy protection, and it is enough for me. End quote. And we'll just start off with that again today. Um, one of the places, Mark, that we know that that is that kind of prayer is prayed often. Of course, it's prayed in people's homes all over the world all the time. But one of the places where that kind of prayer you'd hear maybe a little bit more than elsewhere would be at one of the sites of the apparitions of Mary.
SPEAKER_02Is that right?
SPEAKER_01I would say so.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_02So um, this was a newer subject to me. You mentioned it to me, Mark, and um I I looked into this and I I guess I was really surprised in a lot of ways. I wasn't not aware that this was a thing in Catholicism at all. A couple of quotes to start with. Quote There have been more than 200 reported apparitions since the 1930s alone. Could you give us maybe a just a basic definition of what an apparition of Mary might be?
SPEAKER_02Sure.
SPEAKER_01First of all, the reason you hadn't heard about it is very deliberate, I believe, because uh Catholic apologists really don't want to discuss this subject. They they know it's difficult, and they would rather have you drawn into the Catholic Church first, and having already taken the big step and then slowly introduce you to these kinds of things. So very few Christians know anything about the this subject, but it's a very important subject because I believe it really reveals the character of the falsity of the Catholic Church is really shown out through these apparitions.
SPEAKER_01By way of definition, I would just say a Marian apparition is a supernatural vision where the Virgin Mary, mother of Jesus, allegedly appears to an individual or group, delivering messages about prayer, penance, judgment, and sometimes makes prophetic statements about the future. The Catholic Church investigates these claims, often approving them as worthy of belief if they align with Catholic teachings and produce good fruits, like increased devotion or conversions, though belief is not required for salvation.
SPEAKER_01Now it's very interesting. Uh the church they hold these apparitions up in a very high place, but they will tell you, and especially to a prosp prospective convert who might ask questions about them, they will say, Oh, well, you're not required to believe them. The church doesn't require belief in marrying apparitions. And I'm going to just say from the start that that is ridiculous on the face of it, because okay, granted, technically, a Catholic may not be required to believe in them, but I don't know of any devout Catholic who doesn't believe in them.
SPEAKER_01And I would just challenge any Catholic apologist, Trent Horne or any of the others, to name uh a single pope who would who would not believe in Marian apparitions, or specifically, say, for example, in the apparition of Our Lady of Fatima. Um name one Pope, name one cardinal, name one bishop who doesn't believe in it, name one devout Catholic who doesn't believe in Marian apparitions and in, say, Our Lady of Guadalupe and Our Lady of Fatima.
SPEAKER_01You can't. And to say, well, it's not required, well, no Catholic would be taken seriously who doesn't believe in those apparitions. I will tell you that. So it's really disingenuous the way they say that. Well, you're not you know required. You can be a Catholic and not believe in that. Well, no Catholic would be taken seriously who doesn't believe in them. Do do do they kind of mean like you can still go to heaven if you don't believe that?
SPEAKER_01Oh, yeah, that that's that's what they would say.
SPEAKER_02Sure. But it's I mean you're supposed to submit within Catholicism. We talked about that to what the popes and the bishops, what the magisterium teaches, and this is clearly what they teach uh in some cases that that these things are are real. A few of them are approved, if you will, and wrapped into into church um teaching. And so while you're not maybe required to believe them to go to heaven, they're not a dogma like the Marian dogmas, um, they certainly are uh what you're supposed to believe.
SPEAKER_02Would that be a fair way to absolutely?
SPEAKER_01They are a major part of Catholic piety and devotion. There's no question about it. Millions of pilgrims go to these apparition sites every year, and it is something that is strongly encouraged. I might just add, um, you asked what is a Marian apparition. Some common characteristics of Marian apparitions that we might want to note are that the seers who witness these manifestations often enter into a trance-like state of ecstasy. Others who are observing cannot see or hear the voice of the apparition.
SPEAKER_01The apparitions are often accompanied by apparent miracles. And so the seers who hear, who who see the vision and hear the voice of the uh vision, which whom they think is Mary, um, they will hear a message. And um there's two ways that they claim that they hear this. It may either be just mentally or it may be through the ear. And they have terms for these.
SPEAKER_01Uh but in either case, uh the the seer receives these messages while they're in this state of ecstasy. It's really a paranormal experience, is what it is. And those who are gathered around could be thousands of people observing, they'll they'll just see the facial expressions of the seer who's having this communication with the apparition, but they won't see or hear anything themselves.
SPEAKER_02So I thought maybe a good way. Here's another quote. Um, some Catholic theologians have speculated that there has been as many as 21,000 claimed settings of Mary throughout history. End quote. So this is not like one or two times, or you know, this it's not like a comet going by, you know, with that kind of inf this is 21,000 throughout history. This is not uncommon. And um I thought maybe it'd be good to just reference a couple of these to essentially say what happened or what supposedly happened or whatnot.
SPEAKER_02So in Guadalupe, Mexico, that's one of the ones you mentioned, Our Lady of Guadalupe, um, this virgin appeared to this man. Um I'm just gonna give the shortened version of it. You can expand, Mark. But basically, this this lady appeared, um, demanded that a temple be built to her, said I am the Immaculate Conception, and uh consequently a temple was built to her in 1533. It was rebuilt later, and there's still a building, you know, commemorating this, I think, in Mexico City now, uh 1945.
SPEAKER_02So I don't know what that is. It's like 350 years later, 375, whatever. Pope Pius XII stated that the Lady of Guadalupe was, quote, the queen of Mexico and the Empress of the Americas. And this is believed to actually be Mary, right? Uh coming coming down and appearing to this kind of random man. I mean, he wasn't anybody important, and uh nobody believed him when he first told them and whatnot. Anyway, is there anything else you want to say about?
SPEAKER_01Well, he was an Aztec man named Juan Diego. And remember that at this time this was kind of the the new world, so there was uh, you know, there weren't a lot of um uh Europeans yet uh in Mexico at that time. But what happened is so uh Juan, there was only one bishop in the whole territory, in fact, uh, but there was a bishop there, and this is an important part of the story, because Juan Diego uh saw this vision of Mary, uh as you said, and he and she wanted this, as you said, this church or shrine built in her honor.
SPEAKER_01And uh Juego said, well, how, you know, when I go to the bishop to make this uh request or demand, uh how will I be able to convince him that this is real? And so supposedly, as the story goes, um she told him to he would find these flowers that don't ordinarily bloom that time of year, and sure enough, he found them and and he picked them and put them in his cloak, and then he uh he was to go to the bishop and open his cloak, and these he did that, and the flowers fell out, and this was an amazing thing.
SPEAKER_01But what what was even more amazing was that there was an image of uh the Virgin Mary uh on his cloak. And um you can see this image. In fact, you probably have seen it and not knowing what it was. You'll see it on billboards sometimes. Um it it's obviously an Aztec style uh depiction of Mary, um, not at all uh fashioned after what we would expect her to look like.
SPEAKER_01But um and this this um what it is, uh truthfully is it is a painting. But of course, they don't believe that. They think it's in a it was it's in a miraculous image on this Tilma is what it's called. And this is actually s on display in that shrine to Mary to the to this day in Mexico City. You can go there and you'll see this thing up on display behind glass. Uh what's interesting about it is that unless you are absolutely have to believe in it, it it to me it's really obvious that it's a painting.
SPEAKER_01Uh it just so happens there was an Aztec artist of that day who did paintings like this. I don't remember what his name was, but this is a known fact. And um uh you know, this thing is on display there. And also it is said that the Tilma is way too big to have uh fit a small statured Aztec man of that day. It is not very unlikely that it could have been really a Tilma for an Aztec man. Um what else is interesting about this is that um there is no there's really no historical evidence that a man uh named Juan Diego ever lived, actually.
SPEAKER_01Uh the bishop who um is involved in this story uh in his writings, which are somewhat extensive, uh never mentions Juan Diego or this incident of the Tilma and the Flowers in his writings. There's no mention of it. You would think, surely, if this was true, he would have said something about it, but there is no mention of it in his writings. So um we have here a man who very possibly did not even exist, but was recently, not very long ago, made a canonized saint in the Catholic Church.
SPEAKER_02So I think it's pretty clear. Uh I'll ask the question anyway. Do you believe any of the story?
SPEAKER_01No, that particular one I put into the category of a pious fraud.
SPEAKER_02Okay. So, and I mean the the thing that stuck out to me is whether you believe it or not, whatever it was, let's just say that it was real for a minute, this this vision or whatever. Um would it what what would you think if I came to you, Mark, and I said, I want you to build a shrine for me? And you'd think, I I I believe that you you would say, well, that that would be wicked, right, to build a shrine for you, Alex.
SPEAKER_02But um just think about um Peter on the mount telling the Lord, Oh, it's good for us to be here, let's make three tents. You know, not even shrines, right? Just tents. One for you, Lord, one for Moses, and one for Elias, right? And the immediate uh response of God coming over in the cloud and saying, This is my beloved son, hear ye him. And then they rise up and they they don't see anybody but but the Lord. And I think it's pretty clear that God is very jealous of his own glory.
SPEAKER_02And so having some vision like this come and say, Hey, make me a temple, which is a theme. She does this, you know, whatever this vision is, does this in other instances also. Um, to me, I don't see how you could look at that and say, Oh, surely that's a righteous request because this person identified themselves as the Immaculate Conception. Well, any kind of angel or demon or whatever could appear in some glowing thing and say, I'm the Immaculate Conception, make me a shrine.
SPEAKER_02You know, right? I mean, that's not hard.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Um there is a message that is attributed to her, supposedly, and I might just read it, what she supposedly said to Juan Diego, my son, I love you. I desire you to know who I am. I am the ever Virgin Mary, mother of the true God, who gives life and maintains its existence. He created all things, he is in all places, he is Lord of heaven and earth. And I desire a church in this place where your people may experience my compassion.
SPEAKER_01All those who sincerely ask for my help in their work and in their sorrows will know their mother is near in this place. Here I will see their fears, I will console men, and they will be at peace. Know for certain that I am the perfect and ever virgin Mary, mother of the true God. Here I will show and offer all my love, my compassion, my help and protection. I am your merciful mother, the mother of all who love me, of those who cry to me, of those who have confidence in me.
SPEAKER_01I will hear their weeping and their sorrows, their necessities and misfortunes. Listen and let it penetrate your heart. Do not fear any illness or vexation, anguish or pain. Am I not here who am your mother? Are you not under my shadow and protection? Am I not your fountain of life? Are you not in the folds of my mantle? In the crossing of my arms? Is there anything else you need? So that's the end of that little message. You will notice that while God the Creator is mentioned in passing, the emphasis is clearly on Mary being the one whom the faithful should flee to for mercy, protection, and comfort, not Jesus.
SPEAKER_02That's very interesting. Makes me think of the uh verse there, uh tests of spirits, right, to see if they be of God. And um it references the need for a spirit to confess that Jesus Christ is Lord, that Jesus Christ has come in the flesh. That's in 1 John, Jesus Christ is Lord as in 1 Corinthians. There are tests, if you will, that can be done, um, if you will, to see if something is truly of God. And there are good things you could say in the beginning of that about God being in all places and certain things like that.
SPEAKER_02But I didn't hear anything about Jesus Christ as Lord and God. I didn't hear that.
SPEAKER_01And savior.
SPEAKER_02And savior, right.
SPEAKER_01You don't find the gospel in any of these messages.
SPEAKER_02So um should we go on to another one, Mark? Yes. Okay. Well, I'll just reference this and we can pass through it. So Lord's 1858, a 14-year-old girl, and it's actually the the man in uh in um Guadalupe was the only one instance that I found, or that that was referenced to me that included a a man. All the rest were younger people. Uh, but anyway, this was a 14-year-old girl. She had 18 apparitions of Mary.
SPEAKER_02The apparition demanded prayers to herself that Bernadette, which was the name of the girl, walk on her knees, eat grass, and drink from a stream. And she told Bernadette, I am the Immaculate Uh Conception. And that's I mean, she didn't just show up and say, Hey, do all these things and leave. I mean, there was 18 of these apparitions, and I'm just giving you a real, you know, hasty rundown. But five million people visit that shrine each each year and try to drink from that stream, and there have been reported healings and miraculous things that have come about as a result.
SPEAKER_01Yes. Um you mentioned the part about eating grass, and there were some very strange things associated with that apparition. And as you said, uh most apparitions are experienced by women and children. Yeah. Yeah, most of them are. And I had a friend um in college who was born with a very severe disability, so he was a quadruplegic, actually, in a wheelchair all the time, but a very smart young fellow. And uh, we went to school together and spent a lot of time together, he's a good friend.
SPEAKER_01And he said when he was um very, very young, his mother, his Catholic mother, he was raised Catholic, and uh took him to Lourdes because they claim there's all these miracles, and that if you dip or you go into this um this water that's there that um you might be uh miraculously healed of your affliction. She she placed him in the water and he said uh nothing happened. So uh so so but that claim is made. A lot of people, millions of people go there every year, pilgrims go there, and many, many of them go there seeking and hoping for a miracle.
SPEAKER_01But um I I I do recall and having read of these things in the past, that um, you know, these first of all, these alleged miracles are few and far between compared to the numbers of people that go there seeking uh miraculous healing. These healings um are very dubious and as to whether there's any legitimacy to them at all. Uh so I don't put much stock in that.
SPEAKER_02Let's talk about uh you pronounce it Fatima. Fatima. Fatima, Portugal.
SPEAKER_01There's a lot to say about that one.
SPEAKER_021917. Maybe we'll make this uh our our last one. I mean, there's there's a list of others, but uh you kind of are, I think, hopefully starting to get the idea. So let's talk about Fatima. So three children, 10, 7, and 9. Um, there were some miracles. So, first of all, uh this vision prophesied that the war would soon end. Of course, 1917, uh World War II, World War I ended uh what, 1918? Uh-huh. Some history buff's gonna attack me for that because I don't I don't know exactly.
SPEAKER_02It was it was basically it happened, right?
SPEAKER_01November 11th, 1918.
SPEAKER_02Not November 11th, 1918. Thank you. Um but that another war would break out and that Russia would, quote, spread its errors throughout the world, causing wars and persecutions of the church. End quote. And I mean that seems to have been fulfilled. Certainly, World War II broke out um not many years later in 1941, and then uh Russia, of course, was the font of communism, and there was a tremendous persecution of the church and still is uh in China, even right now in North Korea.
SPEAKER_02There's a persecution of the church in communism. This uh apparition, it required penance and prayers to herself. Again, you kind of see the uh the trajectory uh of all of these, you know, pray to me, I'll protect you, that sort of thing. In the fourth uh month, monthly uh she appeared monthly for a short period of time. In the fourth one, she requested that a chapel be built for herself, which of course was. Um then later, I'll just give this, so later, quote, here's a quote now quote On that date, in wet and dismal mether weather, she announced to them that she was our Lady of the Rosary and called for amendment in men's lives.
SPEAKER_02Then the sun appeared and seemed to rumble, rotate violently, and finally fall, dancing over the heads of the throngs before it returned to normal. Many of the crowd reported having seen this miracle of the sun that was repeated twice more, end quote. And um this was also that kind of miracle of the sun was reported at uh Mejigoria in the 1980s. So um it seems like that may have been something that that people really did see. Uh at least some people really thought that that they saw it.
SPEAKER_02It it seems like they did. Um, this kind of miracle of the sun. Obviously, the sun did not you know rumble, rotate violently, and finally fall, or the earth wouldn't be in existence if the laws of physics hold. But um and you know, it's obviously impossible. But um, but they they they apparently saw this. There have been, again, sort of the same thing. There's been some healings from this holy water. Um, the the visitors really worship uh Mary. There is some healing of sicknesses that that is is seen kind of here.
SPEAKER_02So that's sort of what I have on on Fatima.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Uh first of all, I would say that something really did happen at Fatima. Uh the names of those children who had this vision were Lucia, age 10, Jacinta, age seven, and Francisco, age nine. Um Jacinta and Francisco were cousins to Lucia, and they are the ones that had this uh this the experience the apparition there. And we might just uh before we go on with this, um I said something really did happen there.
SPEAKER_01And the question is, what was this entity that appeared to the children? They thought it was Mary, um, but how did they know that? This was certainly something that was masquerading as Mary, I believe. It was a spiritual being masquerading as Mary, and I believe something really did happen there. I believe they really did experience something. And there are some scriptures we might just go to, because we we want to go to scripture in our discussion to be grounded when we're in this subject.
SPEAKER_01And so um let's look at 2 Corinthians 11, 13 through 15. It says, Paul speaking, says, For such are false apostles, deceitful workers, transforming themselves into the apostles of Christ. So he's speaking of false teachers. But then he says, and no marvel, for Satan himself is transformed into an angel of light. Therefore it is no great thing if his ministers also be transformed as the ministers of righteousness, whose ends shall be according to their work.
SPEAKER_01So he says that Satan has this ability to transform himself into you know a spectacular-looking being, an angel of light. And this is the way these apparitions are often described, especially at Fatima. If you read the account, the children, Lucia is really the one who explains all of this because the two her two cousins die shortly after this. But Lucia lived a long time, and she describes the vision as being as bright as the sun, this this manifestation that she is seeing, witnessing.
SPEAKER_01So it really fits well as Satan being transformed as an angel of light. In 1 Timothy 4 1, he says, uh Paul says, but the Spirit speaks expressly that in latter times some sh shall apostasize from the faith, giving their mind to deceiving spirits and teachings of demons. So this is something that has to be considered as something that happens. There are these deceiving spirits. Could this be the case here?
SPEAKER_01I believe it is, in this and and many of these other apparitions. These are deceiving spirits. And really the the m and you know this too from the messages that they give, that's just not glorifying to the Lord Jesus Christ really at all. It's really something that exalts a created being, then that is Mary. Could I add one more? Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Or maybe you're going to mention it, Galatians 1.8. I was just going to read that.
SPEAKER_01Go ahead. Go ahead then. Okay. Paul says, but though we are an angel from heaven preach any other gospel unto you than that which we have preached unto you, let him be accursed. So again, he describes this ability for someone to be deceived by what appears to be an angel or a being from heaven. And in these Marian apparitions, you often the entity that appears often describes itself as being from heaven.
SPEAKER_01She'll say, I'm I'm from heaven. And then 1 John 4 1, and I think you mentioned this already, beloved believe believe not every spirit, but try the spirits whether they are of God, because many false prophets are gone out into the world. So as you you mentioned that one. So we know that Satan is capable of appearing in this way, to deceive. And I believe that that explains a lot of what these things are. Now the apparition pr uh describes uh the s the soon deaths of J Jacinta and Francisco, the cousins of uh Lucia.
SPEAKER_01So she prophesies that they will die very soon, and this was uh upsetting to Lucia. She also prophesied that the end that World War I would end soon because it was raging at that time, you mentioned that, and the start of World War II. The um the date of the fulfillment of these prophecies, we know uh that Jacta and Francisco died in 1918 and 1919, so that's pretty impressive prophecy. She said they would die soon.
SPEAKER_01Um she said World War I would end soon, and indeed it ended uh November 11, 1918. So that's pretty impressive prophecy there. Although you could say, well, you might have just kind of figured that one out. The war had to come to an end soon. Whatever soon means. But then uh the start of World War II, which was described as you just said that that there would be uh an even worse war to come if men didn't didn't amend their ways and do penance, uh, that there would be a worse war coming.
SPEAKER_01And this is everyone says, well, this is a prophecy of World War II, uh, which started September 1st, 1939. Well, that's pretty impressive. So these prophecies are given and and have this fulfillment. You say, well, that that must mean this is from God. But what most people don't know and what they won't tell you, is that when Lucia told about these prophecies, the one about the deaths of her cousins, she didn't tell about it until December 17th, 1927, almost 10 years after their deaths.
SPEAKER_02Oh.
SPEAKER_01Isn't that convenient?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, that'd be like, you know. Uh after the fact. Last week I prophesied that you would have an accident today, and I see that you have, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Exactly. And there's more. The one about the or the the ones about World War I and World War II, um, she she revealed those prophecies on October 7th, 1941, 23 years after World War I ended and two years after World War II started. I that's so again very interesting. Yeah, and most people don't know that. I didn't know these are not prophecies at all. Um this just shows the um the absurdity of of the Our Lady of Fatima in so many ways.
SPEAKER_01And regarding the miracle of the sun, which you mentioned, um that too is very suspect. You have uh there were uh I won't dispute that there were tens of thousands of people there. You know, when when when the vision told them to uh or that she was gonna give them a sign on the 13th of May, October, excuse me, uh 1917, that you know, word spread around like wildfire. So people came out to see well what's gonna happen. They came out on that day.
SPEAKER_01And it was raining very hard, and there were they say there were 70,000 people there. Well, okay, I won't, you know, some say more, some say less, but whatever the case, there were tens of thousands of people there. And it was raining, and then when it stopped raining, well, the sun came out. And you know, sometimes that looks pretty interesting when the run sun comes out after a after a rain, real suddenly the clouds part, you know, and there's uh water in the atmosphere, and uh the sun can can look a little strange. Um but there were many people oh yeah who said they that they say saw something miraculous as and it's been described as you said uh the sun spinning, changing colors and crashing down to the earth, and and then it it goes right back up to where it was before.
SPEAKER_01But there were also others who said, well, uh, you know, I didn't really see anything. Many people said they didn't see anything. Unusual. Interesting. Yeah. Uh and and uh it seems that uh uh as time went on and the original witnesses of this incident died off, that the story just became embellished and just grew and grew, you know, and then there were there was a movie made about it in 1951 or 52, I believe. And it just it just uh exalts this this whole story and how miraculous and wonderful it was and all this.
SPEAKER_01But um when you really look at the um the uh primary sources on these things, you find all these problems and and inconsistencies, but most Catholics don't know about those.
SPEAKER_02So uh there's one thing I want to uh just talk about a little bit, and that is there are apparitions of the saints too, right? I mean, there's apparitions of Peter, and there are some other apparitions, is that right?
SPEAKER_01Well, there are apparitions of Jesus sometimes, but I'm not really f familiar with apparitions of any of the apostles or saints. Uh I mean I I'm sure you're right about that, but I don't know anything about them.
SPEAKER_02I don't know anything about them either. I I read one reference to apparitions of of other people as well. But it's this apparitions of Mary that are the primary thing, right? And um that to me raises a question about okay, it does seem that, like you said, those people in Fatima, they did see something. There was something there. And you've read those verses, and I think it's well attested to. And it's something that we maybe aren't as comfortable with uh in our very Western, very um that kind of uh very you know scientific kind of mind where those sort of things can happen, but they certainly did, and they certainly do.
SPEAKER_02And um, so when that happens, the the question that I guess comes to my mind is why would let's let's just say it happens and it's of demonic source? That's how I would see this. If you're taking away glory from Christ and seeking to build shrines to, you know, this uh Immaculate Conception or something like that, that is, I believe, very much uh the work of Satan. Just take your eyes off Christ and place it on somebody else. So the question that I would have is why would Satan, why would the demons, why would these ones, why would they have Mary as this primary person to lead off these apparitions?
SPEAKER_02Why not use Peter? Peter's certainly very exalted in the church. Why not use some of these other individuals and have visions appear as Peter and say, I am Peter, I am the great apostle, and I want you to build me a shrine. Why doesn't that happen? Why is it Mary? And I want to read this quote. It's a longer quote, but I don't even know how to say this name. M. De Boeg, it's a French, I think. Buegnat. I don't know. I'm sure I'm saying that wrong. I apologize to Mr.
SPEAKER_02Boyg Bouegno, a very learned Romanist whose work was crowned by the Institute of France, says this quote After the Council of Ephesus, remember that was 431, the churches of the East and West offered to the adoration of the faithful the Virgin Mary, victorious over a violent attack. She had been decided to be the mother of God then. The people were dazzled by the image of this divine mother, uniting in her person the modesty of the Virgin and the love of the mother, emblem of gentleness or resignation, and of everything that virtue presents of sublime, who weeps with the unhappy, intercedes for the guilty, and never shows herself but as the messenger of pardon or of kind succor.
SPEAKER_02They received this new worship with an enthusiasm sometimes too great, since for many Christians this worship became the whole of Christianity. The heathen did not even endeavor to defend their altars against the progress of the worship of this mother of God. They opened to Mary the temples which have been kept shut against Jesus Christ and confessed themselves conquered. It is true they often mixed with the adoration of Mary those heathen ideas, those vain practices, those ridiculous superstitions from which they seemed unable to separate themselves.
SPEAKER_02The church, however, was delighted to see them enter into her bosom, because she knew well it would be easy for her, with the help of time, to purify from its alloy a worship whose essence was purity itself. Among a multitude of proofs, I choose only one to show with what faculty or what uh facility the worship of Mary spread before it remains uh before it the remains of heathenism, which still covered Europe. Notwithstanding the preaching of Saint Hilarion, Sicily, had remained faithful to the old worship, heathenism.
SPEAKER_02After the Council of Ephesus, that which declared Mary the mother of God, we see its eight finest pagan temples become the in a very short space of time churches under the invocation of the Virgin. These temples were first the Temple of Minerva at Syracuse, second, the temple of Venus, uh Eresina on Mount in etc. That's a longer quote. But that just shows how the Virgin, this concept that had been created by the by the Catholic Church at that time, was used to essentially bring in heathen who were worshiping goddesses and basically saying, look, just take out that image, throw it out, put in this one of the Virgin Mother, and keep worshiping, and we'll try to gradually essentially purify you over time to sort of bring you into Christianity or into the truths of Christianity.
SPEAKER_02And it worked. And as it says, you know, it just it's it swept before them because basically everybody was saying, Well, okay, it looks like we can keep worshiping and having our drunken festivals, and that sounds great to me. And we just have to take out that image and put in that one, and then we get all the benefits of the church too, and we don't get persecuted. So, hey, let's do it, guys. And so they did. And I I don't like if if that sounds okay to do in the name of Christ, then I there's I mean, there's you're just on a different planet, you know, you're just not reading the scriptures or understanding the person of Christ in even the smallest kind of a way.
SPEAKER_01Um Yeah, I that I believe you're right about all that. That's a that is exactly why and how it happened. It uh it did give them inroads into the pagans, and uh it was it was not a righteous way to do it, and it's caused a lot of a lot of false teaching since then because of that.
SPEAKER_02And I want to give so this is Mark Twain. Of course, he was not a Christian, right? But he he went on this tour of uh the the Middle East and of the holy area and of Turkey, I think of Turkey. Anyway, and he write he wrote a book called Innoce The Innocence Abroad. I don't know if you've ever read that book. My wife loves Mark Twain, so she read it to me once. And um I lifted this quote from it. So it was written in 1869, it was chronicling his cruise of 1867, and he writes this quote, I wish here to mention an inscription I have seen before I forget it.
SPEAKER_02This is the inscription. Glory to God in the highest, peace on earth to men of good will. End quote. It is not good scripture. He's this is him now, Mark Twain. It is not good scripture, but it it is sound Catholic in human nature. This in letters of gold around the apesis of the mosaic group on the side of the Scala Santa, Church of St. John Lutheran, the mother and mistress Lateran. What's that? I I messed something up there.
SPEAKER_01It's not Lutheran, it's Lateran.
SPEAKER_02Lateran. Okay, Lateran. Okay, thank you. Uh the mother and mistress of all the Catholic churches of the world. The group represents the Savior, Saint Peter, Pope Leo, uh that's obviously not the one that we have today, but you know, the one that was back in 1860, whatever, uh, or whenever it was built. Saint Sylvester, Constantine of Charlemagne. Peter is given the pallium to the Pope and a standard to Constantine. No prayer is offered to the Savior, who seems to be of little importance anywhere in Rome, but in the scripture below says, quote, Blessed Peter, give life to Pope Leo in victory to King Charles, end quote.
SPEAKER_02It does not say, quote, intercede for us through the Savior with the Father for this boon, end quote. But, quote, hopefully I'll be following all these quotes, end quotes, and all that. Anyway, this is Mark Twain now quoting the inscription, Blessed Peter, give it us, end quote. In all seriousness, without meaning to be frivolous, without meaning to be irreverent, I state as my simple deduction from things I have seen and the things I have heard that the holy personages rank thus in Rome. First, the mother of God, otherwise the Virgin Mary.
SPEAKER_02Second, the deity. Third, Peter, fourth, some twelve or fifteen canonized popes and martyrs, fifth, Jesus Christ the Savior, but always as an infant in arms.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Wow, what an observation.
SPEAKER_02So you can go and pick that up. That's an innocence abroad. That's in my paper copy. You can go read that. That was Mark Twain's honest assessment, not a Christian, not a Catholic, not anything, in 1869. And I I just thought that those quotes would give some color or some sense of why. Why would these demons show up as Mary and try to say, oh, I'm Mary and you should build me temples? That's why. Because there's all this worship, all this demonic worship that has happened, and I think they want it to continue.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. Well, you know, the the latest one, I might just mention we don't have we don't have to spend a lot of time on it. The latest major apparition is Mejigoria and in Bosnia-Herzegovina, the former Yugoslavia, which started in these visions, these apparitions started in 1981 over there. And what's interesting about that one is that they're still ongoing. Uh there were several seers in the beginning who experienced uh these apparitions, but now it's down to like one or two, but they have an apparition every day.
SPEAKER_01And millions of pilgrims every year go over there. And there's really there's a whole a whole town has been built around this with hotels and souvenir stores and restaurants and all this. And um you know, the the Catholic Church uh was wondering, uh, you know, what are we gonna do with this one? Because, you know, they in these large, these major apparitions, they they eventually make a pronouncement. It's either it's either of of they say of supernatural origin or or it's not.
SPEAKER_01And and um as as we know, like in in the case of uh Fatima, uh the Fatima apparitions were officially recognized by the church in 1930. And and you know, we know that site is a major pilgrimage site. So the but the Vatican gave official recognition to it, and uh, and others like Lourdes and and and Guadalupe and these big ones. Um but this Mejigorgio one, um there was hesitation. Now we we live in more modern times, it's not so easy to uh explain these things now, you know.
SPEAKER_01And so there was they just recently, uh I think just maybe a couple years ago, finally um came down with a decision on Megigoria, and basically they kind of uh kind of copped out on it because they said, well, there's there's nothing wrong with the messages. They gave it the Neil Obstat, which means no objection. Uh there's nothing wrong with the messages being given, and it seems to be producing good fruit because people go there and they're encouraged and inspired and conversions and all this.
SPEAKER_01Uh they say, but but we you know, but we can't say that the apparitions themselves are of a supernatural origin. Well, you know, I say my question is, why not? If the Pope, who is supposedly infallible, it's like, isn't it isn't it his job to protect the sheep? And if he's got this special charism of infallibility, this would seem to be the right kind of occasion to use it and to say whether something if something's of demonic origin, he ought to be able to to say so and w and warn the faithful.
SPEAKER_01But he just these they say, Well, well, we Just don't know. And they they leave it at that. And many of traditionalist speculate that they never will again approve of a Marian apparition because it's too risky.
SPEAKER_02Well, I mean, in that particular one, uh one of the books I read talked about that one at some length. And basically, one of the the writer of the book, he was there while one of these people, I forget what her which one it was, but one of the girls had her her apparition, her daily, you know, a apparition. And he said that she went in and she knelt down and she was talking, and then she like her lips kept moving as though she was talking, but he couldn't hear anything.
SPEAKER_02Right. And she, you know, she carried on basically a pantomime conversation, just like maybe I would if I was playing serades or something like that. My mouth would move and I would kind of laugh and you know, move and and act as though I was having a conversation, and then it would go on for a while, and nobody else could see anything of of anybody else in in the room. And then after some time, the voice would resume and say, Well, the operation has ended, and Mary, the Holy Mother, told me to say this. And so essentially you're getting these these messages.
SPEAKER_01And yeah, what's interesting about Mejigoria is that since it's modern times, you can go on YouTube and you can see videos of these of this happening. Okay. I haven't done that, but yeah, yeah. And and by the way, you mentioned that uh there's they claim there's the miracle of the sun there. Well, you can go on YouTube and you can you can type that in there, you know, Mejigoria Vision of the or miracle of the sun, and and it's comical what you'll see as the miracle of the sun. Uh, people believe it.
SPEAKER_01But does it look like I mean I haven't done that. Does it look like anything? The sun is coming through clouds, and there's somebody saying, Look, look, and people say, Do you see it? Yes, yes, I see it. I see. And it's just the sun coming through the clouds.
SPEAKER_02Well, there's a couple of troubling things. You know, we need to wrap this up on the apparitions of Mary. Um uh, but maybe just reference this as well with this particular one. Um, I mean, there's been uh a ton of these apparitions here because, like you said, it's been uh daily, so I don't know how many thousand they're up to now in terms of these, you know, visions of Mary uh in this in this place. But I'll just mention this one message of all of them, right? At one point a priest asked the visionaries to ask the vision, and this is what the priest asked, quote, are all religions good?
SPEAKER_02So then they asked the this vision, you know, is are all religions good? And their answer was that the lady says, quote, all religions are good before God, end quote. And then on another occasion, there was another message that came forth from the vision and says, quote, you are not true Christians if you do not respect other religions, end quote. And um at another time, I don't have a quote for this, but another time it was just a reference that divisions among religions is caused by man and and not God.
SPEAKER_02So I hope that that's troubling. Um, I mean, again, we could kind of go back to that verse that we keep coming back to with this whole discussion. I am the way, the truth, and the life. No man comes to God, uh, comes to the Father but by me. And so, do you get there through Muhammad? Do you get there through Buddha? Do you get there through any other person, any other religion? No. Do you get there through Mary? No. Right.
SPEAKER_01And this is not becoming the common teaching of the Catholic hierarchy, the Catholic Church. Uh it was Pope Francis who said that all religions are paths to God. Yeah. And that's so there that's the big push for ecumenism and the acceptance of all religions as being ways to heaven.
SPEAKER_02And let's just remember that there is an incredible amount of power that the demons do have. I'm just going to read a verse in Revelation 13, verse 14. It says, He deceives those who dwell on the earth because of the signs which it was given him to perform in the presence of the beast, telling those who dwell on the earth to make an image of the beast who had the wound of the sword and has come to life. And it was given to him to give breath to the image of the beast, so that the image of the beast would even speak, and cause as many as do not worship the image of the beast to be killed.
SPEAKER_02Well, I just want you to think if there was some big statute, and it's what an image of the beast is, that was an image of a person, and you, this unbelieving person, went in and you saw this statute, and the statute was was breathing and spoke, and um and it people who didn't who said, I don't believe, were killed on the spot. At least I take it, that's that's what this means. Um if you saw that, you know, with your unbelieving eyes, what would you do?
SPEAKER_02And people are going to see that in a future day. It's real. That's this is not just some image. This is going to happen. This is the kind of power that is possible for the enemy of our souls. And so God says He will strong send them a strong delusion. And I believe this is that delusion. And so it's just something to be very aware of, very uh careful about is visions and and these these kinds of things.
SPEAKER_02And that's why we have so many warnings in the scriptures about test the spirits. And I know growing up, I would read a verse like test the spirits to see if they are of God, and I would just kind of think, I don't know what that means. I guess it just means like be careful who you listen to or something like that. But it just means what it says. Test the spirits to see if that they are of God. And um, we just don't interact a lot with spirits here in America, right? But in other places they do, and they have, and it's coming more and more into America and into other places in the West.
SPEAKER_02So it's just maybe a good time to give a warning. I think that's probably all we have time for with respect to the apparitions of Mary. Um we should probably wrap it up there. Um is there anything maybe just a quick gospel or just anything to kind of, I don't know, bring I feel like we've been in the muck here for the last 45 minutes, uh, talking about what probably are demonic uh appearances? I feel quite confident are demonic appearances, you know, and I don't know how profitable it is to think about all of this, but it's important for us to know it.
SPEAKER_02Uh what can kind of take us out and see this again with with Christ in our minds.
SPEAKER_01Well, again, we know that the safe place to be is to be founded on the scriptures, the word of God, divine testimony. We know that's from God. These apparitions, they never give the gospel. They they don't talk about placing your faith in the Lord Jesus Christ for salvation. They they they present uh Mary as the uh refuge of sinners instead of the Lord Jesus Christ as the refuge of sinners. And so we know they're false and they're not of God, uh, but we can have confidence in his word.
SPEAKER_01There we find the the precious gospel of salvation by grace through faith in Christ alone, and uh there we can find r real comfort and peace for our souls. Amen.
In this episode, Alex Nash and Mark Sell continue their series examining Catholic doctrines through the lens of Scripture, turning their attention to Baptismal Regeneration - the teaching that water baptism is not...
In this episode, Alex Nash and Mark Sell continue their series examining Catholic doctrines through the lens of Scripture, turning their attention to Transubstantiation - the teaching that the bread and wine of the...
In this episode of the Acts242 Podcast, Alex Nash is joined again by Mark to examine the Catholic Mass from a Protestant viewpoint. What exactly is the Mass? How did it develop historically, and what does it teach about...
The Catholic church requires belief in four "dogmas" about Mary the mother of the Lord Jesus in order to be saved. They are as follows: 1. Mary is the Mother of God 2. Mary was perptually a virgin 3. Mary had an...