Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Abundant Practice Podcast

Abundant Practice Podcast artwork

Episode #785: Increasing Private Pay Clients

Aug 19, 202630 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In today's episode, I chat with Abundance Community member Heather, who's three years into private practice, full at 25-27 clients a week, but working harder than she wants to. We dig into why increasing her private pay visibility, raising her rate, & taking insurance off her website will move the needle way more than hiring a clinician, subleasing office space, or building a course. We also talk about sliding scale and why it's worth sitting with what you actually want for your practice instead of what you think you "should" want. Sponsored by TherapyNotes®: Looking to switch EHRs? Try TherapyNotes® for 2 months free by using promo code ABUNDANT at therapynotes.com. Your practice is full or nearly full, and you're miserable. Check out Limitless Practice! Doors for our fall cohort are open now through August 21st. Whatever's holding you back (getting off insurance panels, changing your niche, raising your rates, etc.), you'll get a personalized strategy to work through it, plus weekly group calls and monthly 1:1s with Allison: https://www.abundancepracticebuilding.com/lp Need help building and filling your practice? Check out the Abundance Party. For only $345, you'll get access to on-demand courses, trainings, scripts, templates, plus monthly group calls and 1:1 opportunities: https://www.abundancepracticebuilding.com/party Still struggling to explain what you do and who you help? My $27 Know Your Niche course helps you get crystal clear on your ideal client so your marketing finally clicks, your referrals improve, and growing your practice feels a whole lot easier: https://www.abundancepracticebuilding.com/niche

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

(Transcribed by TurboScribe. Go Unlimited to remove this message.) Hi, welcome to the Abundant Practice Podcast. I'm Allison from Abundance Practice Building. I have a nearly diagnosable obsession with helping therapists build sustainable, joy-filled private practices, just like I've done for tens of thousands of therapists across the world. I'm excited to help you too. If you want to fill your practice with ideal clients, we have loads of free resources and paid support. Go to abundancepracticebuilding.com slash links. All right, on to the show.

So I've talked about therapy notes on here for years. I could talk about the features and the benefits in my sleep, but there are a couple of things I want you to know about therapy notes that doesn't typically make it into an ad script. First is that they actually care if you like their platform. They don't only make themselves available on the phone to troubleshoot so you don't pull your hair out when you get stuck. They also take member suggestions and implement those that there's client demand for, like therapy search, an included listing service that helps clients find you, internal and external secure messaging, clinical outcome

measures to keep an eye on how your clients are progressing, a super smooth super bill process, real-time eligibility to check on your client's insurance. In my conversations with the employees there at all levels, they all really believe in their product and they want you to love it too. Second, they are proudly independently owned. Why should you care about that? Because as soon as venture capital becomes involved, the focus shifts from making customers happy to making investors happy. Prices go way up, innovation plateaus, making more

money with as little output as possible becomes the number one focus. With over a hundred thousand therapists using their platform, they've been able to stay incredibly successful and they don't have to sacrifice your experience to stay there. You can try two months free at therapynotes .com with the coupon code abundant. Okay, a quick one before we get into today's episode. I hear a version of the same story constantly. It's not just, I should charge more. It's, I know I should end that session on time and I don't.

I know I should charge that no-show fee and I don't. You're not confused about the boundary. You are stuck on holding it because somewhere along the way, you started believing that your client's needs are more important than yours and that's not a business problem. That's a belief you'd probably flag in a client in about 30 seconds and you can't really change it in yourself on your own. The therapists who've gone through limitless practice weren't the ones with it all figured out. One of them was seeing seven clients a day because she didn't trust that if she set a limit, the clients would still come. She was pulling from savings some months just

to get by and now she sees four clients a day. She charges $3.50 a session and she doesn't flinch saying that number out loud. Limitless practice is for therapists whose practice is already full and they know it's time to change how it's structured. The doors are open this week, August 17th through the 21st. The cohort starts September 2nd. I'm going to put the links in the show notes and you can talk to a program grad if you have some questions. All right, there we go. How are you, Heather?

Good. How are you, Allison? I'm good. I'm good. What will be helpful? Well, okay. I'm at a different juncture. I took your course back when I first opened my private practice and it's been almost three years now. I have no lack of clients. It's just how can I optimize what I'm doing because I do insurance-based. I do do private pay and I'm just

working my ass off. I'm just wondering what else can I do so that I'm not... I just feel like I'm working really hard and maybe if I could optimize it in some way like and where do I put my attention I guess was my questions today because I have a lot of ideas but it's like I don't know what's the greatest payoff. Do I do marketing more for the private pay piece? Do I supervise because I'm already a supervised licensed clinician?

Do I take on clinical trainees? Do I run groups? Do I rent out my office space? Do I hire another clinician? What would be the best thing? You're the expert, right? I am with this. Yes. I'll own that. Okay. You're working more than you want to right now. Is that because of money? Is that because people call and you feel bad saying no? What's happening there? I think what it is is I'm taking...

I used to be more like 50% private pay, 50% insurance and then it started tipping more insurance base and I don't know how to... I don't want to say like I was afraid to ask for what I think I'm worth because I don't think it's that. I just think it was like Heather's not consistent enough with her marketing to really like put in the time, energy, and effort to kind of like keep it even and so I think that that's what happened and so then I ended up taking more insurance base

which obviously pays less and so then it's like well I need two of those clients to like the one private pay, right? So then I just think I got lopsided in that way. So I look back and I'm like I can totally see what I did and like I'm inconsistent with like marketing and psychology today. I'm on Headway, Alma, and then my own website and the other thing I know I'm doing is and I don't know if this is a big deal or not but like I'm not consistent advertising on each of them.

So like my website is the target niche that I created, that Kat Love put together, created this beautiful website, right? So I'm super grateful, launched that, got me the private pay clients that I have but then it just kind of like I didn't carry that over into other maybe areas. It's like oh I never changed my psychology today profile and I never did this or I never did that or and it was always like well I'll do it on the weekend and then I'm like I am so tired. I don't want anything to do with my business on the weekend and I like my

life with my family on the weekend which you know like that's what therapists always struggle with, right? Is like that work-life balance. So yeah so that's where I'm at. That's a lot of verbiage for you. It's good. How many clients are you currently seeing every week? 25 to 27. Okay how many do you want to see? I would prefer to see like 20 to 22. Yeah.

Yeah it would be great if I could totally take off Mondays because I would love Monday to be like Monday marketing day or like Monday's Heather's extra like I go to the dentist or I do the things that life requires that's hard to take time off for when you're a therapist, you know? Okay I want to go through your different ideas because I don't want to just say like here is the path. I want to talk through them and tell you why some of them are decidedly not

the path if the goal for you is to work less and to make the same amount of money or more. Okay. So hit me with the first one. The first one is just increasing my private pay visibility and like really pouring more time and effort into marketing. Yeah how are most people who are your private pay clients finding you now? That is a good question. I think it's just through my website. Okay but how do they find your website? I don't know.

I think I have a network of other trauma-informed therapists that I'm a part of in this community. It's called Anchored Relational Therapy formerly Air Network and I've did some training with these women out of that and I'm listed as one of the providers on their website. I'm also under the Minnesota Trauma Association's website and I do EMDR and so like and IFS and so I have like some and TFCBT so I have some specific things people

are looking for that are like oh you should talk to Heather because she does EMDR or like or she's a feminist narrative therapist like you would love her because that's the fit and oh do you are you the cultural trauma from like spiritual abuse and all of that like she does that really good. I think that's how that's I don't honestly really know because I have been getting these clients I'm like I don't know. Okay one thing I want you to add to your intake paperwork is how did you hear about me?

Okay and just leave a blank and that way it's not a big question mark anymore. I'm guessing it is these relationships it's like probably word of mouth from previous clients and these folks you've networked with that trust you that you've taught that know that you know what's up. So that leads them to your website which they're like sold because it's niched and it's beautiful and then they call you. So we need to know and understand where new clients are coming in from in order to be able to keep pulling that lever

essentially. How much is insurance reimbursing you on average now? Well that varies too so it depends on the insurance company right but I would say like probably 130 to 140. Okay and what's your private pay rate? 190. Okay and I didn't increase that this year either so that was another like Heather no no because I thought about increasing it to 230 and I took your course and I like I don't know I just calculated it

all out and I was like yeah that's what I'm going for and then I just I just didn't because I was like oh this economy oh Trump's fucking up the world oh just to be frank and I'm like oh I can't do that to people like everyone's already struggling and like and it was January and it was during the ice in Minnesota and like so there was a lot of stuff going on but maybe I just didn't do it then which I'm being gracious to myself for and not shame based. You know we have this program Limitless Practice

that's for people like you who are full and trying to optimize and almost everybody in there is like I meant to raise my rate or I meant to get off insurance and I just kept not so most of us go through a period of not doing the things that we know are going to make a big difference in our practice so you know you're not alone basically like I hear about this all the time. And what percentage of your practice is insurance based right now or what number whatever is

easiest? I would say like more like 75 percent and then like 25 percent is private pay which wasn't when I initially started. Right. Yeah. Right okay I'm seeing this interesting thing you might have heard me say this on the podcast if you've been listening I'm seeing this interesting thing for the first time in my career where private pay clinicians are getting full faster than insurance-based clinicians right now but only if they have premium rates. So 190 is coming close to premium rates

but depending on your city it might not be considered a premium rate and that is because the platforms have flooded the insurance-based practice space so significantly like a hundred thousand more therapists serving people with insurance than there were a few years ago. So it makes it actually tougher for insurance -based practices even though yours is growing it's because you've got word of mouth so if you take insurance they're going to use insurance right. Whereas I suspect if you've been private pay

these three years for a portion of your caseload even if it's dwindling it probably just needs some poking and prodding with whatever marketing got them there. Likely you need to reform these relationships so that you are top of mind more often with the folks that have been you know referring to you. So like looking at the numbers even if you got back to 50-50 that's a lot fewer clients that you would need to see every week. It'd be a lot closer to your goal.

Right, right. I just don't know how to do that. When people contact you through your website not through Walmart or Hedway do you ever just tell them your private pay? No because on my website it does say I also accept insurance so I don't know if they've done their research but. Yeah probably not. You have you are a contractor you are basically a part of two giant group practices and you have your own practice these are separate entities.

So when people call I would take it off your website when people call and they're like I would like to set up an appointment and you feel like a good fit and you let them know your private pay rate. If they're like oh I can't do that you have a couple choices. If you're like this person is like my dream client it's who I totally want to see you can say well I also do some work for these platforms so that's an option. But most people are like oh well if you take my insurance then like I just want to use my insurance right.

So I would consider leading with your private pay practice not your group practices you're a part of on your private pay practice website. Okay so take it off the website would I take it off of Psychology Today too? Yeah yeah and they might have even created a Psych Today profile for you they're not really letting therapists know when they do this so you may have one floating out there for Alma or Hedway. Oh really?

Yeah they flooded Psych Today also so Psych Today is not the powerhouse it used to be in terms of getting clients. So yeah okay so take it off my website Psychology Today do I need to increase my rate? Do you have it in your paperwork like I increase my rate every January like is it already? No. Okay so you should also do that like choose a month and stick to it choose whatever month you're gonna make it happen but yeah I think raising your rate when was

the last time you raised your rate? A year and a half ago because it was the past January okay so 2024 yeah 2025 to 2026 so I would have it would have been 2025 a year and a half ago. So my guess is your groceries went up too right and yeah your gas went up just like mine did so it's okay to raise your rates you know and it's your practice so if you have clients who are

like oh god like I'm not going to be able to see you at that rate then you can be like okay well could you do 200? You can negotiate if if you think you're going to lose this client that you really enjoy working with then you can figure out another situation. True okay yeah what is premium rate or how do you figure that out in your area? I mean I think ultimately it's looking at what you need like it's doing the math. Okay okay. So usually around 200 is where I start

thinking of premium rate so you're just shy of that so I usually think of it as 200 and up 190 I would say you counts close enough but I would really do I would do the math to see if you were to see 20 clients a week and you wanted to make as much as you're making right now how much do you need to charge and is your current income covering time off vacations retirement you know putting into your kids college fund like whatever

it is that you might want or need to pay for aside from just bare bones bills. Well right now it is but I guess the reason I was like okay I do need to increase my rates is because they will increase my rates here this office space like they don't have any problem with 30 percent so I'm like where why am I not like that's and I think people appreciate an actual office space if they are insurance

based they're like oh you're a real person you're not a bot out there on headway or whatever. Yeah yeah and you don't want to work as much like you need to not work as much 27 25 to 27 clients is a lot. What is the average for like private pay what would be a like a normal amount of private pay? It's all over the place because the thing about people who have private pay practices is they've figured out that you don't have to follow somebody else's rules they're already breaking the

rules right by not being on insurance so I mean I talk to people who are like my max is 10 a week and people who are like I love the money like my max is 30 a week and usually the people who the max 30 like they don't have a lot of other intense responsibilities going on in life right now so it works for them at this age and stage but it just you know if you know 20 to 22 is where you want to be my guess is you know that through experience so let's trust it and then see if once you get to 20 to

22 people while still making the same amount you are now or more if it feels like the right number for you now because things change you know like what I could do a few years ago is different from what I could do today. Right right I just know what I function best at five when I get past five clients a day I feel a little crispy and I go home and I'm not as present for my family and I don't like how that feels. Yeah and so that is happening right now

and I'm like oh I can't I can't do it you know and I love and I do love some of the people that call and reach out and want to look but I'm like oh nope I have a waiting list now so at least I'm being better about that. Yeah and if you want Mondays off so that you can handle life stuff then four days a week five clients a day you're at 20 perfect. Right right that's what I think in my head but it's not coming out that way in the math. Right because you need to you need to shift the insurance versus private pay numbers right

you need to raise your rate. Right okay where else would I like if in the next year I'm working fewer clinical hours where else would I put my energy I guess or where would you put it into marketing more? Yeah I would well I would see like if you shift either off a platform or you know downsize the insurance part of your practice and increase the private pay I mean is your ultimate goal to be a hundred percent private pay?

I don't know. Okay I want you to take some time to be still and quiet and fully permissive that whatever you want whether it's getting off insurance whether it's staying on insurance whatever you want is okay I want you to explore it. Okay that's hard to do. Yeah it is it's really hard and we don't have a lot of experience with it like what adults do you know who actually know what they want? Not many.

Yeah yeah true. We were literally just talking about this in my book club the other day that it takes concerted effort it takes intention to check in to ask yourself to be to allow yourself to want the thing that you think you shouldn't if it's what you truly want and you know in our industry that might mean you really want to stay on insurance that it feels right to you to stay on insurance when you've got other people being like oh you should just be private pay and it could also be the opposite that you don't want to take insurance anymore that you just want to be private pay but

you've got the other people who are like you're only a real therapist if you take insurance so it's messy and your voice is the only one that matters. Right yeah I feel like that that is a thing like somehow you're not a real therapist if you're not all private pay like I hate that right because I don't believe that to be true right but I also I'm like I don't want to I guess I don't I think it's my justice value that I don't want to be off insurance because I feel like people need some people

need it some people actually need it use it and like my insurance-based clients work just as hard as my private pay clients and it just feels like then I wouldn't see them and that doesn't feel good and let me just do math real quick because math is the answer to a lot of things. So if if you saw 18 clients at $230 a week and took six weeks off

a year you'd be making $190,000. Oh my gosh it's more than I am now. Which would allow you to see two people pro bono or low sliding scale and still stay at 20 clients a week and you would have enough money potentially to give money to causes you care about you could play with the math see like to stay where you're at now maybe you could see 16 clients a week at that rate and then you have four sliding scale people like you

could play with the math to make it work so I think sometimes when people are like I want to be accessible there are other ways to be accessible and that doesn't mean that the other ways are the right ways to be accessible insurance could be the right way for you but I want you to know that there are other ways while still making a good living. Okay can we talk about the sliding fee scale? Yeah absolutely. I feel like I'm not being fair then because it's like well this client is paying the full 230 and this one's paying 200

and it's not like they're going to talk to each other and figure that out but it's like something about that makes me as a business owner feel kind of like uh that doesn't feel fair and I don't know if that's just something I was not concerned myself with because people make choices right? Right. And if the 230 person didn't ask do you have sliding fee scale that's not like on me or like they didn't talk to me about it so. Yeah well when I say sliding scale I mean like 50 bucks. I mean like sliding scale because if it's

about accessibility it's about the people who can't afford private pay so like well you also said the person paying 230 didn't ask. I don't want you to hand out a sliding scale of 200 to anybody who asks right? Right. I had a sliding scale client at like 50 bucks a million years ago who whose father was the vice president of a multinational corporation who was paying for the therapy. She had all the designer everything and I was young in the career at the time

and didn't know how to have that conversation but it was there was resentment when she would go off to Europe and I was like you're on my sliding scale like somebody who actually needs this sliding scale could be using it. So look like somebody who can afford 200 I suppose that's a sliding scale for you but I don't want you to just offer it because it's asked. I want you to offer it because they truly can't afford 230 but they could afford 200 and I still would barely count that as sliding scale. Yeah okay.

I don't think I'd ever offer 50 dollars. Yeah totally get that yeah. It seems crazy. But that's what people's co-pays are right or less so like you are kind of like to them that's what's coming out of their pocket in the same way. That's true but yeah that just doesn't feel I mean it feels like no that's less than insurance based but if you're charging more for private pay and you're only taking x

amount of pro bono people. Right like if you're making more money overall then that's where that accessibility can come in is what I'm saying. Right. And it can come in at 200 if that's what's accessible for people but that the unfair thing it's because it's what's needed for them not because they asked. Yeah okay. So of all the other things on your list I think this is the one that's going to make the biggest difference and not create a shit ton of work for you. Like there's work involved but like taking on

another clinician the number of people in Limitless who have come in because they were in a group practice and they needed to go back to solo because the margins are so slim and they're doing so much more work and so much management that they don't really want to be doing. Right. Most people come in and they're like I'm really making like $40 a month after all the overhead and all the time that it takes. So I would not advise unless you were like gung-ho for a group practice I would not advise hiring somebody. Supervision's amazing but you're not likely to make

$2.30 an hour doing supervision and if what you need to do is work less and make more then that's not getting to that. Gotcha. Okay. What else did you have? I was in the leasing space. Is that worth my time? Potentially. I mean it depends on the space right. Like I have a friend who has a nine office suite around the corner that she barely pays any rent on and people pay her like subleasing and it's a nice income

stream. I think it's like two or $3,000 tops but it's you know two or three thousand dollars a month. That's nice but there aren't really any other places that I like. She just really lucked out there. So if there's something that falls in your lap or that you're actively looking at and the math makes sense then sure. But for her it was an anomaly kind of situation in our town. Okay. Running psychoeducational courses like you know.

Nope. Don't do it. Okay. Don't do it. Courses are going to for you to sell courses that are at a rate that makes you any money at all you're going to have to market like at least an hour to two hours a day specifically for that and with anything the AI could answer right now people aren't going to spend money. They'd rather get a mediocre answer from Chad GPT than a deeper answer that they paid for unless it's a really deep abiding pain in which case they might need to go to therapy not take a psycho ed course. So I feel like most courses are probably

on their way out and it's so much work. Okay. So don't worry about that either. Yeah. Okay. So I just need to increase my rates, figure out how people are hearing about me and then take this crap off my website. Yeah. About insurance. What else was that about it? I think reconnecting we just redid the entire marketing fundamentals course. So that might be a good thing to revisit. There's some pretty simple things you can do

that can be helpful. That doesn't mean they're going to move the quickly, but they can start moving the needle and yeah, reconnecting with the people that you have relationships with is probably the number one thing you could do right now. I know I have your coursework too. So just looking over that again, the marketing fundamentals course. Yeah. And it's all brand new from when you did it because it's updated for what's working now. Okay. I haven't looked at it in a while. I mean, I was reviewing it, but I'm like, I still felt like I was spinning my wheels.

So if in a month you haven't done these, like you find yourself at that space again, where it's like, I meant to do that. If you haven't done it, we're opening the doors in a month for limitless practice. And I think it'd be a really good, like a good support for you to get this stuff done. We'll send out an email for that. Okay. I'll watch for that then if I don't get on top of things. Sounds good. But hopefully you will like my, my hope here is that you do it. Yeah. You know, get through and it's great.

That's my hope too. Yeah. Awesome. All right. Thank you so much. I appreciate it. Allison. Have a great day. You too. Bye. Bye. If you're ready for a much easier practice, therapy notes is the way to go. Go to therapy notes.com and use the promo code abundant for two months free. If you're listening, you probably need some support building your practice. If you're a super newbie, grab our free checklist using the link in the show notes. I'd love for you to follow rate and review, but I really want you to share

this episode with a therapist friend. Let's help all our colleagues build what they want.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Episode #812: Can You Build a Practice with a Baby?

    Nov 21, 202613 minAudio

    You left your job to build a private practice, found out you were pregnant right after, & now your son is eight months old, in full-time childcare, & your website still isn't live. Today I'm talking with Rebecca Smith,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Episode #811: Taking the Privilege Out of Private Practice

    Nov 18, 202622 minAudio

    You know how private practice can feel like it's only accessible if you've got the privilege & the safety net to make it work? Today I'm with Alyssa Powers, who you can find at alyssapowers.com, to get into exactly...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Episode #810: How Do You Survive a Slow Stretch Without Panicking About Your Whole Career?

    Nov 14, 202611 minAudio

    You know that feeling of having a great first year in practice & then hitting your first real slow stretch that completely blindsides you, even though you knew logically it would happen? Today I'm back with Rebecca...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Episode #809: Private Practice Mental Load with Maggie Holland

    Nov 11, 202631 minAudio

    You know that feeling when sending one client email, something that should take five minutes, ends up living in your head for days? Today I'm with Maggie Holland, a private practice therapist, CEU trainer, & clinical...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Episode #808: How to Build a Referral Network When Your Niche Has No Obvious Community

    Nov 7, 202610 minAudio

    You know that worry that since nobody else in your area does what you do, you can't build the therapist-to-therapist referral network everyone says is so powerful? Today I'm back with Rebecca Smith, my Limitless...

    Credit the people on this episode