Send us Fan Mail ABA on Tap is proud to present CartNarcs Special Agent Sebastian Davis (Part 1 of 2): A stray shopping cart can scratch paint, block a space, and ruin somebody’s day, but the bigger story is what happens when a stranger calmly says, “Hey, the cart return is right there.” We sit down with Sebastian Davis, the creator of Cart Narcs, to unpack 'why' a simple request triggers such outsized reactions and what it reveals about social norms, accountability, and everyday ethics. Sebastian walks Mike and Dan through how Cart Narcs began, why shopping carts are the ideal “caught in the act” public behavior, and the kinds of excuses he hears on repeat. Then we go deeper into the escalation cycle: why people rarely climb down once they start yelling, why bystanders sometimes side with the loudest wrongdoer, and how staying polite and steady can de-escalate conflict without surrendering the point. We also get practical about the legal myths people throw around in parking lots. Sebastian explains the basics of recording in public where there is no expectation of privacy, why “I don’t give you permission” is usually a deflection, and how his magnetic “tickets” are designed to avoid damage while still delivering clear feedback. Along the way, we connect it all to applied behavior analysis (ABA), including matching law and reinforcement, to answer the real question: what makes returning a cart motivating when no one is forcing you? Subscribe for part two, share this with your most “lazy bones” friend, and if you enjoy the show, leave a review and tell us your most outrageous shopping cart excuse. Tune In, Drink Up, Return Your Cart, and ALWAYS ANALYZE RESPONSIBLY. Support the show 🔥 Enjoyed this episode? Don’t forget to subscribe, rate, and review on your favorite podcast platform! 📢 Connect with Us: 🔗 Website: https://abaontap.com 🎧 TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@aba.on.tap.podcast 📸 Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/abaontap/ 🎥 YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@ABAonTap 💼 LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/aba-on-tap 💡 Support the Show: ☕ Love what we do? Buy us a virtual drink! Support ABA on Tap 🎙️ Interested in sponsoring? Partner with us 🚀 Join the ABA on Tap Community! Stay updated on the latest episodes, live events, and exclusive content. 🎧 Analyze Responsibly & Keep the Conversation Going! 🍻
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_03Welcome to ABA on tap. I'm Mike Ribio with Dan Lowry. So without further ado, sit back, relax, and always analyze responsibly.
SPEAKER_03All right, all right. Welcome back to ABA on tap. I am your ever-grateful co-host, Mike Rubio. Very excited today. Very, very special episode today. Now, a bit to my dismay, my dear partner, my esteemed colleague, is dealing with a cold. So he's joining us remotely again. Maybe a bit of a silent partner today. We'll see how much he gets to chime in. But Mr. Dan, you've lost your voice. I don't know how quickly you want to say hello or what you want to do here.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, um, I'm gonna have to focus on the quality of questions over the quantity today, I think.
SPEAKER_03But Question Man, Dan, I'm gonna miss you. I'm gonna miss you.
SPEAKER_01Such an exciting podcast. Couldn't miss this one.
SPEAKER_03All right. So I have to uh kick this off with a a brief but important story of a personal tragedy, what makes today's episode that much more meaningful for me. Imagine me out there, 17, 18 years old, happened upon my first vehicle, beautiful 1985 metallic burnt orange cutlass collet. Just I know, I know you're blown away by that already. Really like this car, you know, my first car. I get to hang out with friends.
SPEAKER_03Uh the girl I like gets to borrow it during her lunch period because we've got the two different lunch periods, so that's scoring me some points. Driving down happily on a main thoroughfare in my hometown, and my car suddenly struck very hard as I passed by a driveway into a major store, or Walmart, uh, as it were. And it was a shopping cart that had rolled all the way down this hill and struck my door, and I was devastated.
SPEAKER_03I'd seen the signs, I knew that if I called Walmart, they were gonna point to their signs on their cart corral that said, Look, man, you're doing this at your own risk. But I wasn't in their parking lot. So I took the fight up nonetheless, and I lost. Very early on in my uh future prospective career in psychology. I had lost faith in a just world in. Very, very tragic day. Luckily, we fast forwarded a day, and somebody, a social justice warrior out there actually doing something about this, taking on this problem firsthand, really is going to help us bridge that gap between parking lot justice and behavioral science today.
SPEAKER_03So we ABA on top is very, very excited to have special agent Sebastian Davis. Special Agent Davis, it is our distinct pleasure to have you on today. Thank you for your time on a lovely Sunday afternoon. How are you doing?
SPEAKER_00Uh, very well, very well. People could say, well, you said it's a Sunday afternoon, so that means I'm currently not out patrolling carts. So you've got about an hour or two of a free reign, lazy bones out there. Leave carts out without me being uh on hand.
SPEAKER_03We're taking you away from important work. We couldn't be more grateful. We understand that the world is a little less just in this moment, and we do apologize to everybody out there for that. The way we like to kick this off, and I I am very much interested in your particular origin story, is you know, given our guests tend to be more academic in nature, they sort of talk about their CVs or their experiences, but I think it's uh ever as important here in what you're doing. Tell us a little bit about your background and then bring us up to this idea of carton arcs, and we'll go from there.
SPEAKER_00Well, yeah, I I will freely admit that my background has nothing to do with encouraging people to put their shopping carts back education-wise. My degrees in chemical engineering. Oh wow. Uh nothing about sociology or or even shopping carts or or you know, law enforcement or anything of that nature. However, it's one of those things where I'm just I guess I'm just nosy. I or or I'm just I'm just it's you know, it's one of those things where you're just you're you're you once you see something, you can't unsee it.
SPEAKER_00The analogy I always use is like once you buy a certain type of car, suddenly you see that car out everywhere. Yes. So like, you know, so one day I I was just talking about shopping carts with a guy with a friend of mine, and we were, and and not about shopping carts in per se, but about things that people don't do that make the world worse for everyone else when they know they should be doing better. So littering, picking up your dog poop, you know, putting your weights back at the gym, you know, uh putting your tray back if you're eating fast food, for instance.
SPEAKER_00That there's a there's a hundred ops of these sort of things where it's you know what the system is, you're you're you're getting usually a price better a price break in order to do a little bit of labor. So for instance, what we're taking the shopping cart back or taking your tray back, so but but you're not being forced to, it's not against the law. Right, right. And so my I'm a very hands-on guy. I I I go places, touch things, talk to people, do stuff. And so this conversation about all these, you know, let's say, inconveniences or or people being in discourteous to each other.
SPEAKER_00Well, I was like, well, the one thing I can do real easily, if I want to ask people why they don't do this, is shopping carts. Because it's a big metal thing. They're they're coming out from a grocery store, right? You know, it's like with dog pooper littering, you gotta be you gotta be lucky. You just gotta be right there right then. So one day I just said, okay, I'm gonna go out and I'm gonna ask people. I didn't have the cartonarx uniform or the even the name at the time. And so I just very politely walked around, didn't take long, saw a guy, uh, didn't take his cart back, like, oh hey, you know, cart returns right over there.
SPEAKER_00What and and the excuses were everywhere instantly. Oh, this and that. I I I have skin cancer, those one, you know, all the stuff you hear in Carton Art's videos, but not only excuses, threats. Just like, who are you? What are you doing? Get away from me. I'll be I'll beat your ass, you know. And before I even had the magnets that I put on people's cars, just like a little ticket, uh, which we can discuss in a minute. But like, I mean instantly, all this pushback, I was like, whoa, there's something deeper here than a simple act of putting something away that you use.
SPEAKER_00And so that's what it was. My background, yeah, it's nothing to do with you know public behavior or the whole nudging of society, but uh it's just one of those things that I guess I I like a clean area. I like I like to be like picking up stuff, and and I don't use this as a as a real reason, but one thing we would do that I think of now, I can now back engineer this, is when I was a little kid, my dad would take us to this part uh this playground near our house. Not a public playground, it was the uh Catholic school down the street, but they let everyone, they let people use it, they didn't kick anyone out.
SPEAKER_00So my dad's deal with us was okay, we're going to the playground, but you're gonna pick up, you know, like three pieces of litter or something, you know, something like that. So if you can give my dad credit, maybe, but I think just in general, a lot of us, a lot of us to see this sort of thing. I just decided to do something.
SPEAKER_03Well, and there's so many layers to this, again, from a human behavior perspective. And it's interesting, you gave you gave a whole lot of rich background there in terms of what happened, what made you happen upon this particular circumstance versus the dog poop or some of the other things that you mentioned that are super important, and it was more about just visibility. So that's to say that the moment you went out, I mean, how many how many instances of this are you catching if we were to do some tamp time sampling? If you sit out in the parking lot for an hour, how easy is it for you to catch people doing this very behavior?
SPEAKER_00On average, it's probably half dozen per hour. Uh, you know, that's that's I know you know, bigger lots are more, certain neighborhoods are more. But I'd say on average, it's a good half dozen of just me by myself. I'm not I'm like if I had an eye in the sky and a whole team, it's probably more than that. But it's a half dozen where I'm like, okay, they have no good excuse. They're not elderly, they're not infirm. I give exceptions for people with small children, even though I shouldn't.
SPEAKER_00But I I I knock off a lot of of excuses people could give me, so it's super cut and dry. Yeah, it did some, you know, it doesn't take long. But on the good, on the good side, there are some places where I could be there all day. I might catch one or two, you know, in in nicer, in nicer, more friendly uh areas.
SPEAKER_01Okay, interesting, interesting. And that's the weight. When you talked about giving examples and you talked about putting weights back. Man, when I used to go to 24-hour fitness, that would drive me crazy. Like you got, you know, whatever the weight is, I don't know. 40-pound weight and the 80-pound, and that just creates a cascading effect because once one goes in the wrong spot, then the other one goes in the wrong spot, and then they end up in different parts of the weight rack.
SPEAKER_00So it's so funny you mentioned that because that's that's what I find myself doing. And I and I don't know, I'm sure I look like a psychopath to certain people in the gym, but when you go to gyms nowadays, especially in between sets, people are just on their phone or just screwing around, and I'm I'm memory racking weights. I'm like, I'm walking around. I figure like I might as well put myself to some good use. And I'm listening to an audiobook or something, and I I haven't gotten to the point where I'm like, I've like called people out on it because I don't want to get kicked out of the gym I go to, but that that may be a new thing where I just sign up for gym, you know, like a 24-hour fitness, for instance, go to a city I don't live in and just go ahead and get kicked out just to prove a point, maybe.
SPEAKER_03Wiping the machine down, right? I guess is a whole other than that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, completely.
SPEAKER_03And that certainly takes a little work.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, or I get a lot of this in your hearers with like, or they'll use a machine or like a maybe like a step-up box as just a shelf. Well, I've got a I've got a water bottle and a towel, I guess I'll throw that on there. Oh, I guess you can't use that now. Sorry, you know. There's there's a you once again, once you start seeing the Cartnark principle in action, it it can make you a little crazy because you're like, it applies to so many different situations in life.
SPEAKER_03So you I mean, I've got a a lot of questions about very detailed things, like even how you named yourselves. That must have been a slew of different ideas. Or I mean, I I know that that can get a little heady in terms of you know finding a good company name or a good band name or things that I've endeavors that I've pursued. Uh so I'm interested in that. And then yeah, in terms of how many other ideas you may have generated that maybe you've got on a back burner that you think would be viable for this format.
SPEAKER_03So in the gym, it's interesting, right? People people have had such a visceral response to you with this shopping cart. And you've got an open space to sort of defend yourself, evade any sort of threat or or attempt at you know, throwing something at you, whatever it may be. That could be different in a gym. People might actually also be in good shape, like you. That could be a whole that could be a whole different confrontation, right?
SPEAKER_01So that's tossed around an ego in a gym, too.
SPEAKER_00Yes, exactly. Well, back, yeah, to well, to the the name, there's a thousand different ways to name this, but yeah, I just uh literally I just thought it's like it's because called shopping cart shaming was one. And then somebody texted in to I was doing I was talking about this on a radio show, and they said, Hey, the name is Cartnarx, and I was like, Oh, perfect, boom, done. Nice, you know, because and but you could call it like, for instance, in England, they don't call them carts, they call them trolleys, so it'd be like trolley patrol or trolley tattlers, you know, there's it's just the cartnarks one was so quick and so easy at the top of the of the of the of the gate, and it was like boom, just easy and went with it.
SPEAKER_00But yeah, when you're talking about other areas, gyms well, there's there's always there's logistics behind it. So like at a gym, you really have to like catch them, not right when they're doing it, because they can say, Oh, I was gonna do, I was just, I was just, you know, stretching, I was just standing up, I was gonna get that in two seconds. See, so trust me, because I've I've I've I've plotted a lot of things.
SPEAKER_03I can tell you've been uh piloting some of these. Good for you.
SPEAKER_00Right. You have to like, so what I would have to do is basically I'd have to have, you know, uh I'd have to like videotape them, like kind of like watch somebody who I think is about to, you know, which and then we'll we can get into how do I how do you how do you know when someone's not gonna about to about to about to skirt their or shirk their responsibility, wait for them to go off and use something else, and then come back and say, you know, broad bring their weight to them, say, oh hey, you left this blah blah blah would be a thing at the gym. So there'd have to be like there's an A, B, C, because in Cartonarcs, I do the same thing where I've got to make sure that the the act, the deed has been done.
SPEAKER_00Because you hear that, especially in my earlier videos, where if I'm a if I'm a split second too early, that gives them an excuse. Even if it's a full lie, it's a plausible deniability. It's like, oh, I was just about to, oh, I was just I was just unlocking my door. There was a lady in Long Beach actually who did that early on where she left her cart in the spot next to her, gotten in her car, turned on the car, was about to leave. And I'm like, what are you doing? Oh, I was just turning the air conditioning on. Wait, you so you were and you got your car going, turned the AC on, and you're about to get out, walk out, move your.
SPEAKER_00I don't believe you. But you know, there that's the thing, is and we can talk about the psychology, but one of the excuses I get, I get, but you got to really button down the logistics of things first.
SPEAKER_03I imagine that applies to policy that's applicable within the space you're in. So in a parking lot, you're in a wide open, presumably public space, which is why their cart can hit your car and they're not responsible, for example. That might be, and I would love to get in some of the legal ease that I'm sure you've you've happened upon. Uh yeah, again, a gym that would be different. They might ask you not to, I mean, even though it's the policy that might be clearly listed somewhere, they might ask you not to bother the other patrons with this, despite it actually being, you know, a very admirable, if not very useful and practical social parameter.
SPEAKER_03Just, you know, pick up after yourself. Very basic.
SPEAKER_00You're you're you get you hit on something super important right there. And and where carts and and all these other things come into is it is not only a legal gray area, but it's a policy gray area. And I would argue that the people who leave their carts out and don't rack their weights and blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, etc., etc., they know that and they are exploiting and abusing that because they know that the gym or the grocery store, et cetera, will not come out there and bother them about it.
SPEAKER_00Will not come out because they because they want peace at all costs. And you see that in some of my videos where I deal with security and and other people and law enforcement, is they just want there not to be a problem because because ultimately they they don't want the friction, you know, or the one thing I've noticed since I started doing this, people bringing uh their pets into grocery stores, even though it's against the law, the health code, if not the law, in pretty much every state. But and they have signs at a lot of well, you know, places, hey, only support animals, no pets, emotional support is not a is a pet, by the way.
SPEAKER_00But they have that sign, and the dog still goes in the the store because they don't want to create that friction. And so, like you saying, if I go out and create that friction, even though it's fully in, you know, it's fully what the gym wants and what everyone else, what 99% of the people, 95% of the people want, the good, the good, you know, responsible users out there, the gym will tell, or this, or the grocery store in a lot of cases will tell me, no, just as a matter of policy, because I don't want the argument.
SPEAKER_03Right. Yeah, it it it creates a disruption despite it being for the greater good.
SPEAKER_00And despite it, and despite it being in in many cases, an absolute written policy.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_00I mean, I remember Go ahead, go ahead, sir.
SPEAKER_01I remember uh in work meetings at a at another company, there there would be issues instances where the boss would say something that was clearly not right, and people wouldn't like challenge it because it almost it's it's almost kind of like a gaslighting thing where if you challenge it, now you become the asshole, which then empowers that person. It kind of sounds like that's what you're talking about with the you know the weights piece. Like I'm now disturbing the piece by challenging it, which then reinforces their behavior to do the that behavior.
SPEAKER_01It's like a weird conundrum where it's it's almost flipping who's the asshole and who's not.
SPEAKER_00That's another great point to bring up because I'll get that. Now, I've been doing this long enough, and thankfully I have a lot of people that support me, and you'll see that in some videos. You'll go, yeah, correct narcs. But there's a whole other subset of society that blames me, not the per for for calling out the problem, even though I'm doing it in a polite, nonviolent, non-threatening way. And they'll jump on the side of the wrongdoer because they they either they either know that they do the same thing and empathi and sympathize with the wrongdoer, or they just have this all this sudden like I gotta save the because the wrongdoer, at least in my cardinar's videos, is loud, is screaming, is oftentimes committing crimes like assault and battery, but that doesn't matter.
SPEAKER_00The the ep the this the enabler will say, Oh, they're screaming and they're loud, therefore they're the victim. And like you said, it flips the whole thing back on me, at least among a certain sector of society.
SPEAKER_03And that's probably the most of what that that's the majority of what you're encountering probably fits that particular description. Is that fair to say?
SPEAKER_00It's it's weird because like there was one I did not too long ago where this lady's screaming and yelling at me, and I'm pointing out, look, you left in her case, like blocking the handicapped walkway, but leaving her shopping cart out. And I said, Look, well, you just you put it in the shot. And then two or three guys saw a middle-aged woman screaming and yelling at a single man, immediately jumped to her defense. But then it's funny, you know, a minute later, some guy rolls by and he's like, Hey, Carks! He's like, Tell the woman, yeah, put your car back.
SPEAKER_00So it's that's that's the benefit, I guess, of being a long-standing brand. I I suppose. But yeah, it doesn't matter to some people, it they'll just they'll just jump down the side at the person who's loudest.
SPEAKER_03How often do you encounter that initial escalation and then somebody maybe feeling bashful enough in that moment to go, okay, this guy's actually just being nice about something? Maybe it's annoying, but let me de-escalate. Or do you find that once people climb, oh you're gonna have to let it run? I mean, how often do you actually maybe have somebody come at you with the first couple statements and then be like, okay, you know what? I'm wrong, you know, or do you just see the tantrum have to run its course for a little while?
SPEAKER_00That well, yeah, the the the person working themselves down is very rare. Overall, numbers-wise, and I just put I posted on Instagram recently a video of myself and this uh comedian slash writer going around LA, and we had like three or four super nice, pleasant encounters. People are like, Yep, sorry, no big deal. And that's probably about half. That's probably about half the people I talk to are just like they either don't say anything or they're like, Oh, my bad, and they just go about their business. And the other half, probably half of those will kind of give a a performative sort of like, well, you know, they should have more shopping cart corals or you know, something.
SPEAKER_00They try to give themselves a little bit of excuse, but then they still do it. Now, that other that maybe that other quarter of the total people are the ones you're talking about who will not be convinced, and they're gonna meet me with a certain level of either verbal antagonism or or attempted violence. And and I've almost never have once they get to that level, do they then say, All right, you were right. Almost never.
SPEAKER_03So you've never seen a full de-escalation, you know, down to like maybe an apologetic and then resolution. I mean, and I I don't know if it's you know it might be a matter of editing and the way you post your reels, but that's kind of what I wonder from there. Either they they come at you and they're insulting you and then they storm off.
SPEAKER_00I don't know that I've ever really seen a full de-escalation back down to some, you know, total admission and you're right, it's very rare because either they're gonna scream at me, they're gonna do something violent that makes me either back down for my own, you know, because like, for instance, pulling out a gun, man, or they'll just, or they'll eventually give up and drive off. Uh, I'm thinking of one in particular, it was in Holland, Ohio, where older guy, he's yelling at me. He wasn't threatening me physically, but he was, you know, giving me the whole back and forth with the yelling and screaming and blah blah blah.
SPEAKER_00And eventually at the and eventually he says, you know what? I will take my cart back, and I'll take this other one back too. It was such a strange, but it was like again, it's one out of a hundred, maybe, that are like that. And and when you talk about editing, there's almost Except well, the re the the like the Instagram are just are edited because they're down to a minute. But if you go on YouTube where the you know the longer informed videos are, there's almost no editing. You see basically the whole story, unless there's a big pause in the middle, because a lot of times people, what they'll do is they'll sit, they'll see me, and they'll get on their phone and they'll try to like wait me out.
SPEAKER_00So there might be four or five minutes of me just standing there. I try to like you know narrate and keep things going on, but sometimes they have to cut that part down. But yeah, if you go to the YouTube videos for Card Narcs, uh there's almost no editing. You see basically the whole story in almost all cases.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, no, and that answers the the full question here. It's kind of a behavioral premise that we have to deal with with the idea of escalation and de-escalation. So what I was describing there was an escalation cycle. So the notion that when somebody kicks in, very rarely are they gonna come right down. They're gonna have to run the course of some escalation. And then sometimes in what we do every day, you might have somebody almost hit a period of refractory remorse where it's like, oh, I I can't believe I did that, and so forth. But yeah, I was wondering if you ever uh got to see that, and it sounds like it's it's rather rare, which makes a lot of sense.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. In fact, I I uh I was in, I want to say Oklahoma City a number of years ago, and a a guy who identified himself as a hostage and crisis negotiator for the local police department came up to me, and I I I wish I if I had known about I just now thought of that the moment you said, but he was saying, yeah, we watch your we watch your videos as like showing how and I wish I I can't think of off the top of my head what he said, the technique they used that somehow I I've kind of found, you know, discovered upon my yes, my uh my just just through repetition.
SPEAKER_00But he said, Yeah, a lot of what I see is a lot of what he sees as far as you know blame shifting and tactics used by people who are caught in the wrong.
SPEAKER_03So that means when people do return their card, so you're able to arrive at some peaceful resolution with them, you've been able to communicate something that I guess now they can identify with that you're partnering with, and then most a lot of the people just don't even give you the chance. So I a lot of times there's a phrasing that you use that's slipping me right now, but where you try to point out the irony and the idea that you know, like it's uh somebody else's job, or I don't really care, or you don't really care, but you know, yet you're blocking somebody's spot.
SPEAKER_03Like, I I think that there's there's a lot of psychological behavioral value that you've happened upon there in trying to engage people in that way, knowing that some are going to be so escalated they're not gonna hear you, and then maybe once in a while somebody identifies with outside of the irony, or are the are there particular statements that now that we're talking about this, you might now realize that you use commonly that might help those people de-escalate in that moment where they feel now, yeah, sure, a little ashamed, but maybe more supported in doing the right thing, and then it leads to that resolution.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's it's interesting because I think what you're talking about, what you mentioned there it was I I try to approach things very logically, and I think that helps in some cases.
SPEAKER_03Again, some people are not probably not gonna pisses people off board in some of the cases too, because you're so logical.
SPEAKER_00Because it it deflates their their excuse because I've heard everything, and so when they say I'm I'm too busy, or I it would it would it's too far for me to walk, or something of that, or I've got to go get somebody or something, I'm in a hurry, etc. And then you know, um two minutes later I say, Remember how you said you were too busy to do this? Well, you could have fucked walked it over, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. And so that's very satisfying for the viewers. I don't think it's very satisfying for the person involved, because it kind of it kind of deflates what they thought would be a an instant get out of jail free card.
SPEAKER_00But one thing I think I do that does give people that that opening is my language is always incredibly polite uh and and non like I don't meet their energy, in other words. Oh, that's that's what the that's what the guy was telling me in Oklahoma City, the uh the crisis negotiator, he was saying, and you see this a lot in in police interview interactions, is they are on you instantly with the yelling and because they want to establish dominance and establish compliance.
SPEAKER_00And so you sit down now, drop blah blah blah, you hear that you see any of these body cam videos that are out today, and so I'm very I'm very not screaming, not yelling, addressing exactly what's going on, not you know, they're gonna call me mother f this and that, and I'm not gonna meet that that language. So, in the cases where I think I could be helped, that definitely helps. And and and so I think that's probably the number one thing is calmness, is just be not meeting their not meeting their anger.
SPEAKER_03Dan, I know you want to chime in here, sir.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, sure. I I have a I have a few questions. One, have you noticed since you became more popular and people realize that you're recording and they might end up on YouTube, people like the percentages shifting where in the beginning they might have fought you more and now they realize they're gonna look silly on YouTube, so they fight you less.
SPEAKER_00I think that's that's definitely happened. Some people say, I know what's going on here. Or or they don't even say that, but you can you can tell when they this happened the other day, where looks up, sees me, takes them a half second, oh oh well, here would have never thought. Today's the day, you know, that sort of thing. They kind of they because then they know because they've seen the videos, oh, this is not life and death. This is just a guy who's out there doing things in a lighthearted and comical way. He's not gonna hurt me, you know.
SPEAKER_00You know, oh you got me, oh, you know, put the put the handcuffs on, sort of thing. How that so that's definitely happened anecdotally as a overall percentage. I I can't say that I that's that's that that's that good of a deal. It's just because you know, media is so fractured these days. Uh is you know, so we are all people who watch the same things as going less and less and less and less and less. So even though, you know, I'm much more recognized nowadays, I think there's a certain percentage of the population who never will see a cardinarc video and and they're gonna keep on behaving as normal.
SPEAKER_01Okay. And another question I have is how do you navigate the like right to record states? And I think some states have, you know, both people have to consent and things like that. Excuse my ignorance, but how do you navigate that piece?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's a great question because I I definitely had the same questions when I first started this. And so, right to record, first uh one party versus two party, only really again, not a lawyer, but I've talked to a lot of them, only deals with private conversations. And it really and it comes primarily from phone recordings and tappings. But now that we all have recording devices in our pockets, it's been widely expanded to those. So, for instance, if I'm in a place that you would expect to be private, your house, a bathroom inside your car, you that's a that's either a one-party or two-party consent situation applies.
SPEAKER_00Of course, I'm one of those two parties in all cases. Now, out in public, which of course a shopping uh lot or uh grocery store store would be, there is no expectation of privacy. Or else, every video that showed people in the background they could sue or ask you to blur out whatever, you know, and so on and so forth. So that's where that comes into play is yes, one and two party consent definitely makes a difference, but I'm not I'm never recording anywhere that would be considered private.
SPEAKER_03And that's across the board then, that you don't have to worry about your location, that's gonna apply. And I yeah, probably technology has made that more made the prevalence has made it open-ended. Yeah, you can't Right.
SPEAKER_00And yeah, it only if I somehow went inside their car or something or followed them into a bathroom, right? Would that would that be an issue? Yeah.
SPEAKER_03So again, that parking lot open space is just integral.
SPEAKER_00Right, because again, you were to think about that when it comes to everything. You know, you take a photo in front of uh the Statue of Liberty and or video, and you hear some other people talking in the background, you know, that would be illegal if if it were if you know, but that that's what that's where the first amendment comes in, is is I have is the ability to speak about or comment on society as I'm doing with my videos, is not abridged. So, and that includes the the recording of those incidents. So if I'm gonna comment on an incident, it's reasonable that I might have to record that incident to talk about it.
SPEAKER_00So the first amendment kind of try it, trumps anything again until you get to the level of expected privacy.
SPEAKER_03That's a fantastic point in terms of rule governed behavior and just kind of current political climate, First Amendment being so important, uh always having been important. But that's a really, really good point.
SPEAKER_00Well, it comes up in my videos is people will see the camera on my chest and they'll say, You I don't give you permission to record me. And I and I'll say, Well, uh that's fine. I don't need that, but let's talk about the cart. But it it's one of the it's one of the hundreds of ways people try to deflect from the situation. They'll they'll pick, you know, and it's another excuse essentially. It's uh oh, your camera, you can't do that. I was like, Well, you just walk, you just walked by 15 cameras inside that store and you didn't say boo. But when you know you're doing something wrong, and also it's a it's again it's a first amendment thing, because again, I can record your activity for the purposes of commentary and criticism, especially when you do that activity in public.
SPEAKER_03Mr. Dan, did you want to circle back to de-escalation, pulling the energy out? We're about to embark over the next week, uh, actually, on some very related training, but that's one of Dan's specialties is is de-escalation. So I don't know if you wanted if you had things to circle back on that. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01I have some behavioral principles that I wanted to tie in and check in, but before I do that, I have one other question, kind of more of the legal stuff. So that makes total sense about the right to record piece. The only place I could see somebody garnering sympathy and interactions that I've seen is like when you put like the bumper sticker on or whatever, somebody could be like, Well, I didn't give you permission to put that on my car or something like that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, there's there's there again. I I love this because there's there's a couple of different things that come into play there. Is and the most obscure one is trespass to chattels, which I don't even have all the information, but chattel is like your is essentially your car, oxen, I think, you know.
SPEAKER_03Oh wow, that goes way back.
SPEAKER_00Oh yeah, yeah, yeah. A tangible, movable piece of personal property. So, like a dresser is you know, it's not your house, but someone, if they were to do something to it that that somehow makes it unusable to you, then that's a trespass upon a channel. Yeah, goes back to it literally goes back to livestock. So, so yeah, you're right. They don't give me permission to touch their vehicle. And I I love doing that in some of the videos, like I didn't you can't touch my vehicle. I'll just go boop and I'll put my foot and I'll point to them because they'll say, they don't know trespass to channels unless they're fresh out of law school, but they'll say that's vandalism that people will use that term a lot, and I will explain to them well, no, vandalism requires a damage to you or damage or otherwise permanent defement of your property, your channel or whatever.
SPEAKER_00And the the magnets, people and uh people will, oh no, it scratches the clear coat, never has modern car cut, not modern car coats don't do that, especially for a short-term amount of exposure. And so I tell, and that's what every lawyer has told me, is like, well, yeah, you're not permanently defacing their car, or even let's say I keyed it or spray painted it, or causing there to be any sort of monetary cost to change what happened. So the same thing with trespass to channels. I would have to somehow hinder their use of their car, which let's say I let's say for you know Looney Tunes' sake, I threw a giant net over their car where they couldn't drive away until I and I said, well, I'll I'll take the net off if you if you take your cart back.
SPEAKER_00Then that would be number one, trespass to channels, because I've made it now harder to really use their car the way they would freely otherwise be able to use it, and false imprisonment potentially at that point.
SPEAKER_03False imprisonment. That's that's huge. Those are big terms, right?
SPEAKER_00So, and again, false imprisonment is it in what people get arrested for is a lot of domestic stuff where someone's trying to leave like the bathroom and you're you've got your door, your shoulder against the door. None of these things, you know, harassment's another one they throw out there, which is again more often stalking and persistent long-term patterns of behavior that are intended to threaten or intimidate. I'm not intending to threaten or intimidate anybody, which is why harassment, vandalism, trespass to chattels, false imprisonment have never even been tried, or else some DA would have done it.
SPEAKER_01So in the beginning, you were you were out to you know just kind of call people out, and it seems like you've had to get a doctorate in legal terminology and things like that. Is that accurate?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's again, I I I always say that I cannot take credit for all of the wrinkles and layers that Cartonarx has exposed as far as the law, psych psychology, sociology, you know, and and just general moral everyday behaviors, but it has it hasn't covered every new thing about Cardin Arcs. Like, oh wow, there's a whole world behind that.
unknownAbsolutely.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, shopping cart theory is actually uh it's a it's uh it's an academic topic. It it's uh books have been written about it. Have before I go off, Dan, you you were gonna ask more about escalation. Well, so maybe we can stick on the legal piece a little bit. Do you find that you're able to get ahead of some of those questions legally, or do you find that you face that you face some issue or circumstance in in doing this work, and then you go, oop, I better check that out because that could be trouble.
SPEAKER_03Or what's the mix of that?
SPEAKER_00How does that sort of involve it's most it's mostly been discovery by doing? Obviously, I know I know a generally obviously I can't, you know, point a point a slingshot at somebody, and you know, I like we're all aware of that. I you know, I can't r have a sword up there while I'm doing it, you know. That's that's assault aggravated assault. But like, for instance, the the false imprisonment one came about as a course of doing this where one day I was like, I was looking at what they did, and it's like, well, if you leave that with that person leaving their cart out, that potentially makes it harder for the next person to pull their, either open their door or pull their cart out, car out or whatever.
SPEAKER_00So, what if I took the very same cart they're using to block, I use that term very loosely because it's on wheels and anybody can move it. And what if I just put that behind their car so that they had to? And yeah, some lady she she was angry about that and and tried to file uh she she talked to the local DEA, they didn't file any charges, but both they and my lawyer who I consulted for this said, look, given the you know, that's not false imprisonment because and again, anyone can move that cart.
SPEAKER_00You're not standing there holding the cart in front of her. However, again, it's on wheels. She moved it to begin with.
SPEAKER_03There's an abstraction piece somewhere in there that right.
SPEAKER_00It's it's it it would the wrong DA who just didn't like you might try something. So they said, even though you're not getting charged, and you probably would never get charged, it's just not a great idea. Even though I still I see people who are, you know, let's say imitators, you know, one-off imitators will try something like that. And I and I get and people send me that comment all the time. Hey, you should put the car behind their car. That'll teach them, you know, what's good for the goose, sort of thing. Same logic I had several years ago.
SPEAKER_00But my the lawyer said, you know what? Just to again to remove any doubt, yeah, let's let's not, you know, remove that out of the uh the arsenal of moves.
SPEAKER_03Just for uh the sake of curiosity, did the lawyer come before or after also by discovery?
SPEAKER_00No, it was before. Okay, he was a friend, he was a friendly, friendly, I should say, before. And I said, Hey, I had a I had a question. They want to talk about this. He's like, Oh, I'd love to talk about it, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. And but it's funny because it's come up several times since then, not just that, but all the other laws around this harassment, stalking, vandalism, et cetera. And I've I've run on, I've talked to people who are real lawyers, and they'll come at me with with you know defacement and blah blah blah, harassment, etc. And I, oh boy, is it satisfying for me to say, well, actually, the elements of her actual criminal harassment are X, Y, and Z, and I don't meet those elements.
SPEAKER_00And so you're not really a good lawyer, are you? Yeah, you know, so it's it's very, you know, it's easy to do with lay people, but it's way more satisfying to do with actual uh jurists.
SPEAKER_03It's like attorney narc there. Uh that's a terrible, that's a terrible name for it. I'm sorry, but you know what I mean.
SPEAKER_00Well, no, there's there's a there's a guy actually has an Instagram channel called The Legal Beef, and he's featured a few of my videos, including ones with lawyers, where he's he's pointed out where the lawyers were wrong in the kind of stuff they said to me. It's very again, very satisfying for me at least.
SPEAKER_03I'm sure he's not very popular with his colleagues. So the attorneys, man. They're they're they're a unique breed. You you can't live with them, can't live without them. Yeah. Um wow, this is so again, there's so many legal parameters here in terms of the evolution. So even in deciding to use the car magnet, and you've got a couple different car magnets, and I'm gonna use this term very poignantly, and then uh we're gonna we're gonna allude for the first time to your Dr. Phil appearance here.
SPEAKER_03But the idea that you're a little bit of a nuisance, and that's what we you can use that word, and then you're also we can say social justice all the same. But how does that evolve, right? The idea that you had to think of ways to continue to get somebody's attention safely about this thing that they did. So you're you're you're walking a legal line, you're walking a social validity line. I mean, there's you know, this is this is quite a tightrope that you know, and I know you did it by discovery, or maybe you did some academic research.
SPEAKER_03I'd love to hear about all of it, but yeah, speak to that evolution a little bit because for us as behavior analysts, that's fascinating. Like, how did that evolve?
SPEAKER_00Right. Well, you you raise a good point because yes, legality is of course very important if I want to not be in jail.
SPEAKER_03You want to keep doing your work and that's gonna stop you from doing your work.
SPEAKER_00But number two, it has to I have to have the majority of the public when they see what I do say that was behaviorally or at least ethically or morally justified.
SPEAKER_03Or any of those, sure.
SPEAKER_00Right, or else, or else people will just say, you know, the the message won't get across. And look, it's not gonna get across to a certain percentage, no matter what, but like, but so that the majority of people will say, okay, he's he's valid in what he's doing. So at first, like I said, I just talked to people. And then they would sometimes it's some you can see in some of my videos, I'm still just talking to people. There was one I did in Ferguson, Missouri recently where I had, yes, I had the magnet in my hand, but I didn't make any kind of motion like I was gonna put it on their car. And the magnets say things like, lazy bones on board, or I don't return my shopping color like a jerk, or it's just a like an outline of a lazy bone or whatever.
SPEAKER_00Things like like you were mentioning, a variety of different things, or litter bug for when they litter or throw the magnet on the ground. So I when I first started, I was like, well, they'll either kind of blow me off, or some of them are yellow, they'll yell at me and scream at me, but then they will and they'll throw out one of the excuses, but then they'll just drive off or whatever. And I said, Well, there's gotta be something like a little ticket I should give them, you know, to like to let them know that I yes, I know what you did, and and you're not just getting away with it, so to speak. And I I tried like business cards at first, and people were like, I think it actually I think that just confused people because they're like, is he trying to like sell me a car cleaning service or something?
SPEAKER_00Like, think about the things people approach you for in shopping center parking lots. It's either panhandling, but I don't look like I don't look like a panhandler typically, or they're like trying a dent removal or you know, or something, or a flyer for a party or something, you know.
SPEAKER_03The child fund, you know, right, right, right.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, selling they're selling candy. So I was like, well, no, I need something like that's more of like like that shows what they did. And so they're like, oh, I should make a bumper sticker, but again, I can't cause damage to their car, I can't cause them a large amount of grief to repair my whatever I do. So I was like, Well, I'll just make it magnetic. And that happened pretty early on, but it was just it was you're you're right, it was a thought process of how do I get their attention in a way that explains because some of them don't even know what's going on, or they won't roll down the door or the window to talk to me because they've already closed the door.
SPEAKER_00So when it says I don't return my shopping cart like a jerk, then it's like, oh, that that says what I'm saying, yeah, you know, in a way that is not harmful to them, but is if we want to go back to uh what's his name, Nathaniel uh Scarlet Letter guy.
SPEAKER_03Hawthorne, Nathaniel Hawthorne. Yeah, Hawthorne. Scarlet letter is a perfect, yeah, perfect metaphor. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00It is a scarlet letter, it is a ticket in a way. Uh and I found that that's kind of the sweet spot, because again, it's non non damaging, but it still shows them exactly what I mean.
SPEAKER_03Which means they care about their social responsibility. But not enough to have propped, you know, maybe they instead of leaving it in the little median spot behind between the handicap and the regular spot, maybe they've propped it up on the you know the the tree uh embankment or whatever the curb or whatever. But I mean, yeah, everybody's got these different degrees of like social responsibility with these carts. It's so hilarious. And interesting how uh earlier you happened to circle back again from a social structure to this idea that the wrong DA, if you just make enough noise, if you're enough of a nuisance, despite not breaking any laws, you could end up, you know, in in the wrong crosshairs.
SPEAKER_03And that, I mean, that again, that has to drive your thought process somewhere all the time, even though you can't anticipate that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and I again because I because I'm very careful about that sort of thing, I I've never had another even conversation about a DA or a prosecutor of any kind. But where it does come into play is if with uh enforcement officials, so local police and and and below that security guards. So for instance, there was a cop, again, the one just recently in Missouri outside of St. Louis, he sees uh I'm not even I haven't touched the guy's vehicle, I'm just talking about the cart.
SPEAKER_00He's but he sees the guy screaming at me, and he immediately tells me, You get the you get out of here right now, leave, leave, leave, leave. Because he sees again a guy, a guy screaming at me. But then literally 30 seconds later, he's like, Hey, wait, are you the are you the cart next guy? Oh man, I'll see you in your videos, you know. So he's got his autopilot of establishing authority, showing that he's in charge.
SPEAKER_03You're the agitator, right? You're the nuisance. This guy wouldn't be yelling if not for you, yeah.
SPEAKER_00Right. Now, that being said, up, there's been cases where uh there was one in Huntington Beach where this couple, we've gone back and forth a few times, they've taken the magnet, they've thrown it around, all that stuff. And now they go to their next level, which is I'm calling 911. And I always say, Why are you wasting police resources over something as silly as a magnet and a shopping cart? And they say, Well, uh blah, blah, blah. Yeah, they don't have a good reason for that. They're just like, I'm, you know, they're just so happy to be a police cruiser in that parking lot. I walked up to them, like, I was saying, Oh, I'm gonna go talk to them right now. They're like, Hey, Carnarx, how's it going?
SPEAKER_00Like, you might get a call about me. She's actually making it right now. So those cops, because they didn't, you know, it came from a different, different point of view, I guess. They're like, Yeah, man, well, oh, sure, no problem. Yeah, yeah, yeah. I turn around, they're gone. The people who left the card out because they see me talking to the cops, being buddy buddy, chill, you know. So, yeah, that's that's where it kind of like and and security guards too. There's some security guards. I just posted a video where the guard smiles on his face, hey, how's it going? Yeah, man. Oh, I'm glad you're here. You know, he used to get other times where they're like, you get out of here right now, you you leave right immediately, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.
SPEAKER_00So that goes, I think, to the point of I don't know which version of that I'm going to get. Right, right. So I've got to be really buttoned up as far as and I always say, like, I'm not, I'm not there, I don't fight them on it. I I which which we would invite, which would invite a criminal trespass charge, quite frankly, number one. But number two, I'm not there to make their job or anyone else's job harder. I'm here to nudge uh public behavior in a in a good way.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, that line of being a disturbance, which would be the legal term, that's hard.
SPEAKER_00Right well, that's okay. That that's one more thing is technically you can always get a disturbing the piece. Always, yeah. Always that that is a cop's if if you're being a dick, you know, whatever, if you're drunk outside of a bar or or anything, that's always something they that's the that's their, they can at least if they want to put you in cuffs and stop the situation, disturbing the peace. Easy. Now, I avoid that largely because at the point wherein an officer uh either of the law or uh of the establishment tells me to do something, I say, yeah, you're right.
SPEAKER_00Okay, I'm headed out of here. Just let I might explain myself a little bit, but I never argue with them on the fact that I am leaving. I'm in the process of leaving, I'm obeying what you want me to do. So I think that's why I've never had any problem with that, is because I I think they really reserve the disturbing the peace for when you're just being a dick and they and they need to stop with they need to stop your behavior and they somehow.
SPEAKER_03So you don't push back at all, which brings us back to pulling the energy away, sort of a de-escalation technique. Mr. Dan, is that a decent segue for you?
SPEAKER_01It is. It is. I I actually was thinking about talking about two other behavioral terms. Do you think de-escalation is the better segue, Mike, or the behavioral terms?
SPEAKER_03Go go with what you feel, man.
SPEAKER_01Because I was thinking two things that we study a lot, that this is a really good representation of, is what we call matching law and variable reinforcement. So the matching law in ABA says we're gonna do whatever behavior is most reinforcing for us at that time. So, what that kind of means in the way we use it is we have kids that don't want to do homework or something like that. We're like, hey, if we'll give you a bunch of iPad or something like that. Again, I'm sparling it down here, generalizing it.
SPEAKER_01We'll give you a bunch of iPad if you do your homework because good grades aren't motivating enough to do homework. But good grades plus iPad might be motivating enough to do homework, so maybe they do the homework. If they don't, then we can assume that the iPad wasn't motivating enough. But what you're talking about is so interesting in that the what's reinforcing for somebody to bring the car back, there's not it's just like societal, there's not like a tangible thing. It's just like being a good member of society.
SPEAKER_01And what we would do to counter that is you either make the reinforcement so high that now the energy to do the behavior of walking the car back, however far that might be, is now worth it, or you make the punishment so high that people don't want to do it, i.e., traffic tickets, which we can talk about a little bit later. But I I kind of wanted to open that up. Mike, I don't know if you have thoughts, or you know, if either of you have thoughts on that matching law on two parts.
SPEAKER_01One is clearly for some people it is enough, even though there's not why do I do it? Just to be a good person. Like there's not a a reinforcer, just like membership in society, which I think kind of boils down to exactly what your whole point is, is like society's a better place if everybody takes their individual membership in that. And then also just the general thought of that. So hopefully that wasn't a lot of frog rambling with my voice right now. But that's the first thing that came in was this this matching law and why some people do it and some people don't.
SPEAKER_03What makes it reinforcing to return your cart other than being on cart narcs and looking cool for a little bit, right? Oh, and this may be uncool. But this ends the first part of our interview with special agent Sebastian Davis from Cartnarx. Please do return for part two and always analyze responsibility.
SPEAKER_02ABA on top is recorded live and unfiltered. We're done for today. You don't have to go home, but you can't stay here. See you next time.
Send us Fan Mail ABA on Tap is proud to present Richard Wagner (Part 2 of 2): One tiny checkbox can be the difference between a clean claim and a full-blown payer denial, and most ABA clinicians only find out after the...
Send us Fan Mail ABA on Tap is proud to present Richard Wagner (Part 1 of 2): If your ABA tech stack feels like it was built for billers instead of clinicians, you’re not imagining it. ABA onTap sits down to brew with...
Send us Fan Mail ABA on Tap is proud to present CartNarcs Special Agent Sebastian Davis (Part 2 of 2): A stray shopping cart is never just a cart. It’s a tiny decision with outsized ripple effects, and it can tell you a...
Send us Fan Mail ABA on Tap continues the brew with Holly Blais (Part 2 of 2): A school can be loud with “problems” and still be full of useful information, if you know how to listen. ABA on Tap resumes their chat with...
Send us Fan Mail ABA on Tap is proud to brew with Dr. Holly Blais (Part 1 of 2): A worksheet hits the desk, a student melts down, and the room labels it “escape behavior.” The Tap doesn't buy that shortcut, and neither...