What if you gave a little more attention to what you want, and a little less to everything that could go wrong? For writer and editor Dionne McCulloch, a surfing lesson in her late forties offered a thought that reached far beyond the water: “Don’t look down at the drop, look along the wave.” This week on A Thought I Kept, I’m joined by Dionne for a conversation about fear, creativity and finding yourself again in midlife. As her three children began moving into adulthood, surfing became a place to rediscover confidence, enjoy her own company and learn that she could do difficult things, even when she spent much of the time falling off. I first met Dionne at a writing workshop in Bath, where the ideas she shared felt as relevant to life as they did to the page. That thread runs through our conversation: what happens when the thing you want feels too important to admit? From the vulnerability of writing a novel to the discomfort of being a beginner, we explore how wanting something can leave us exposed, why difficulty and joy so often come together, and what it means to keep making room for desire as we get older. We also talk about storytelling, folk horror and imagining a hopeful future; how community action can build belonging; and why Dionne wants to keep creative work and “heart decisions” human in the age of AI. In our conversation, we explore: Starting something new in midlife and rebuilding self-trust. Fear of failure, creative vulnerability and facing the blank page. Motherhood, identity and asking what you want next. Finding hope and connection through community. What fictional monsters can reveal about our real fears. Dionne McCulloch is a writer, book editor, mother and surfer. Her debut novel, RAYNA, comes out from New Ink in 2027, and her folk-horror story Helminth was published by Dead Ink in Beasts of England. She was shortlisted with special commendation for the 4th Estate/Guardian Prize for a short story that became the novel Rayna. She is a freelance book editor of both fiction and narrative non-fiction and a writing coach. She is also the Associate Director of EMBLAZE-Black Writing Matters out of Bath Spa University, where she also sits on the advisory board of Paper Nations. She has been a judge for two international literary awards and is currently a reader for the inaugural Sareeta Domingo Prize. She lives between Bath and an off-grid cabin in North Devon, England, but she is probably in the ocean. Instagram: @dionne_mcculloch Also mentioned: Robert Olen Butler Island of Stangers film Wave Wahines The Wave, Bristol Emblaze This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit moregooddays.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01How do we belong? How do we forge a connection with the world and the people around us? How do we nurture a sense of belonging so we don't feel so isolated and afraid all the time? We do that by engaging with the messiness of life, the really awful things, the scary things, the things that we're afraid of, the things that we really, really care about but we might lose. And so we fight for them and take that risk. This is how we move into belonging and into connection with ourselves, with nature, with our neighbors.
SPEAKER_01And there is no better way to fight the dark forces that really want us to give up right now. [music]
SPEAKER_00I met this week's guest in a place that I love, but I found really vulnerable. And that is a writer's workshop. It was a Saturday afternoon. We're in Bath. It was part of an ideas festival. And a group of us had come together to understand story. And what I came away from that workshop really understanding were two things. One is that many of the thoughts that people bring to this podcast, they are essentially stories. They're about these moments in their lives when they didn't just hold on to a piece
SPEAKER_00of advice or a line from a book or something. The [music] second thing I realised is that I really wanted the workshop host to be on this podcast. Because what I came to also realise is that how much we think we bring to the page really happens in our lives beyond that. And that was something that I really felt that she understood.
SPEAKER_00So my guest this week is Diane McCulloch. Dionne is a writer and an editor, a mother and a surfer. Dionne is part of an anthology that came out this month by Dead Ink that's called Beasts of England, and her story Helminth is included in that. Her debut novel, Rayna, is coming out in 2027. We really get into so many aspects of writing, but also about wanting, about the stories that we tell a lot.
SPEAKER_00And the stories that we think we're able to tell at certain moments in our lives. Maybe there's certain stories that other people think we should be telling. We also get into folk horror, which I think was so fun to discuss. And we also really touch on, I think a lot of the things that we are thinking about right now, AI, technology. Environment, social justice, so many pieces of this that are around us and that kind of form the ecology I think
SPEAKER_00in which we're really all swimming. And so it's a really rich, meandering, wonderful conversation. It's really human. I loved it so much and I really hope you Enjoy also exploring the thought that Dionne brings this week and maybe even trying on in your own life whether you are a surfer. There's a hint there or not. I am Claire Fitzsimmons. This is A Thought I Kept, a podcast where I ask people about the one idea that has stayed with them
SPEAKER_00and I explore what it might just offer the rest of us. And here is my conversation with Dionne McCulloch. [music] Hi Dion, welcome to the podcast. Hi Claire, nice to be here. Okay, so let's get into it. You are a writer and editor, but you are also someone who describes yourself as a surfer. I think you said that you spend a lot of your time in the sea, and I know that you have brought a thought today that is very much connected
SPEAKER_00with surfing, and I'm really curious to hear what that is. Maybe we could go straight into it. Sure, let's do it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so I only started surfing about six years ago, and early on I did a coaching session, and the surf coach said, To me, don't look down at the drop, look along the wave. And in surfing, what that means is, you know, the most technical, tricky part of surfing is the pop-up, which is the moment where you're lying on your board on your stomach. There's this swell of water coming up. It lifts you up, hopefully steeply, so you can catch it. And in that moment, you also have to jump to your feet. You know, you have to do 100 million things all at the same time. On this like little piece of wood in the ocean.
SPEAKER_01So to explain it, I guess, in non-surfing terms, really what it means is don't look down into your fear. Look where you want to go. And what's happening is you're rising up. There's a steep drop all of a sudden in front of you. The instinct, and most people do, is to look at what they're afraid of, which is falling. But when you look along the wave, what you actually do is you position your body correctly, your head, which is actually quite a heavy... Object instead of going down and pushing you that way, it was now pushing you in the right direction.
SPEAKER_01And so every time that goes in my head, every time I'm surfing and I'm thinking about that. And every time it just hits me more and more how, what a good piece of life advice it is, because we so often think about what can go wrong. And instead, if we focus on what we can get from it, how our hopes can be fulfilled, how we can meet our goals, that becomes the direction of travel.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so there's a very really practical thing that you're experiencing during this surf lesson with the surf coat became something that you took out into your life.
SPEAKER_01Why do you think it landed for you at that time? What was going on around it? It was like quite a major life change. I'm 55 now and I started surfing in earnest. I always wanted to surf and loved the ocean, but I hadn't actually done it. And I started in earnest around 48, 49 years old. So not really that long ago. And... What was going on was quite big. I had three children and they were all coming into adulthood and leaving home and I was putting myself out into the world in a different way.
SPEAKER_01And in a way, surfing just came at this moment where I needed to learn to trust myself again, to find myself again. Motherhood can be so all-encompassing and even if You're doing other things at the same time. It's the primary thing. It becomes such a big part of your identity. And there's a really important thing for a woman, I think, what moving out of that to go like, well, who am I actually? And what do I have? And what is my purpose? And how do I want to be in the world?
SPEAKER_01And so there was a lot of things going on with writing and career stuff. But really it was surfing that kind of put me back into the space of confidence and assuredness. And I did a lot of surfing trips on my own and just realizing that I liked myself and like hanging out with myself and that I could do really difficult things and thrive. And I'm so grateful to it all every day, all the time. It's just become, it's my total obsession because I love it and it's pure joy, but also it's given me so much.
SPEAKER_00Was that your expectation when you started surfing? Did you suspect that it would become what it has become to you?
SPEAKER_01Not at all. I just... I don't really know, actually. I'm thinking back to it in the early days when I couldn't do it. And the reason that I was able to go from not doing it all to being okay at doing it was because the wave opened in Bristol, which is an inland surfing pool, which gives you the opportunity to go and surf a lot and go over and over and over again because in the ocean there's so many other factors. You have to get the right waves and all that, but it's all more controlled so you can actually practice. And so because of that...
SPEAKER_01I was able to go from terrible to okay much more quickly than for someone who doesn't live at the sea. But when I started there, I wouldn't ever catch a wave. I would just boom, boom, boom every single time. But still in that getting just tumbled in the water and often very cold water, there was just such a release. It was such a nervous system reset. It just completely cleared my mind of any thoughts and anxieties. There was nothing but trying to just stand up on this wave. And then even failing, as in not actually standing on my feet and surfing,
SPEAKER_01at the wave they take photos of people and then they sell it to you. But they don't take the photo if you fall off the wave and all I wanted was a photo. And so I've probably went three or four times where I just never even got on my feet. But for some reason it was just, it just grabbed me and it was all I wanted to do. And the fact of like failing, and I'm putting in quotes because it's not failing, it's so much fun to fail. Maybe that's another life lesson in there. But not actually standing up and surfing didn't matter. It was just the journey of it was so much fun.
SPEAKER_01And then when I could actually do it, of course, then it went exponential. And I think you'll hear this from a lot of surfers, but it's like definitely an addiction. I will go in the rain and the hail and the snow and wind on my own, changing in a parking lot somewhere cold. And it's just doesn't matter. I love it. I love it.
SPEAKER_00As you were talking about this wonderful expression that your surf coach had, looking on the board, it's such a beautiful analogy for midlife. Because I think so often in midlife, often what we do find ourselves doing is looking down or looking behind. And actually even looking ahead at that point, sometimes there is fear there too. There's a kind of a curious, like, where does fear live when you're in midlife? And sometimes it can feel like we are just in it, like we are in the wave, like we are flopping around in the water. I wonder how you've come to shift your relationship to fear because of this moment.
SPEAKER_01I think a lot of that is just even just paddling out on a stormy day and the sea is, I don't even know if I can do this, but then just going out into this absolutely uncontrollable situation. There's waves, there's wind, there's all kinds of things, there's other surfers, there's all kinds of things that you just can't control and you don't know what's going to happen and you have to trust yourself and you have to Just constantly be in the moment. There's no time to think about anything else. That beautiful moment when I just kind of jump on my board and push off of the land. It's like, ah, like, you know, there's no phone.
SPEAKER_01Nothing can reach me. I'm just out there, me and the elements, just doing this thing that I love. And it's so pure. There's nothing else, I think, in life that I found that gives you that. One of my other favorite things is when you're paddling out and the waves are coming and you're trying to go over a wave that's about to break and sometimes it'll just go bam and slap you in the face. And I always think, oh, thank you, because it's the ocean just going like, enough of your nonsense. This is real. Nothing else is real. It's just, it's the best.
SPEAKER_00It makes me think about writing, actually. I know that this is something that you teach and you work with and you work with, you know, writers. You are a writer. You work with creative people. I met you through a writing workshop. And It does make me think about the writing process, about how much fear there can be in that, how much vulnerability there is in that, how much anxiety exists around it. But also this need to stay focused on whatever that direction would be for you. Drown out the noise. Yeah, as well. Like how have you come to understand fear and how that shows up in the writing process?
SPEAKER_00So just being a creative person.
SPEAKER_01I mean, it always does. And even though I now have a book that I'm really happy with that's going to be published next year and I'm starting to begin the next one, which I'm doing just scribbling in journals because I have total fear of the minute I open that Word document and it's blank. And it's like, I haven't learned anything. And I have friends who've published five or six books and won awards and they sit down with like how to write a novel for dummies. They just completely go, I don't know how to do this. This is crazy. Because there's so much fear because it's exactly that.
SPEAKER_01You have to make yourself so vulnerable and so almost thin-skinned to the world. It's the funniest thing because you're supposed to be thick-skinned and put your work out there. But actually you have to absorb so much of the world and struggles and obstacles and failure and sadness and all these things in order to metabolize it and then put it into your writing. It's an unbelievable thing. I was just working with this author today. I've just finished working with him.
SPEAKER_01He's written a beautiful book. It's all about male vulnerability and loneliness. And he just told me at the very end of our whole time working together that he hasn't told anyone, not even his wife, that he's finished writing a book. And I'm the first person who's read anything. And just, I was like, you know, congratulations, because it is a half crazy, half bravest thing you can undertake, is to really put your soul on the paper and then give it to the world and say, here's me. It's incredible.
SPEAKER_01And I'm always in awe of writers, especially writers who are writing, and most are in some way or another, but are writing about Their own experiences and their own emotions and their relationship to the world. And it's so personal. It's how we connect. It's how we build empathy. And if we didn't do this, if we didn't have art and books, we wouldn't be humans. The most important thing we do, I think.
SPEAKER_00It is a real act of courage, actually, in both the sort of the practice of it. And you're right, also the putting it out there, like that moment that you become... In whatever form, like a published author or a more visible author or whatever that would be for you. What has it been like writing? Like I know your debut novel is coming out next year. So you've been writing Rainer. Could you tell us a little bit about what that is? You're talking that very much about midlife and also a version of a world no longer serving us, but that not being the end of the world. And I really like the idea.
SPEAKER_00How did you arrive at that particular story?
SPEAKER_01The first chapter just came to me and it was in the very... Dark days of early lockdown when we were all just shut in our houses and it all felt a little bit like what is happening to the world. But then I couldn't really write any more of it for almost two years because it begins with this woman who it's the morning of the fourth time that she's slept walked out of her house and she wakes up in the forest with the same group of strangers. I knew that the world was like now but a little bit along from now as the worst things that are happening. Have happened to do with climate change and war and all these external things,
SPEAKER_01which doesn't really go into in the book, but the result is that people live in a much more fearful and isolated way. And I think that where it came from, for me, having kids was thinking about them really. And like how wanting to, I had this belief that it all goes just so wrong with the world, whatever that looks like. And then you end up with five people in a bunker. Someone's still going to fall in love. Someone's still going to write a poem. Someone's going to tell a joke. That we would still,
SPEAKER_01that when you strip everything away, we would still be humans and it would still be okay in some way. And I needed to prove that, I think, to myself. That was my theory or question with writing this. And so the book is this 50-year-old woman who's living on her own in England, and it's not a good time for her because of who she is to be out and about, but yet this thing keeps calling her outside. And I didn't know where it was going to end at all the whole time I was writing it. That was the curiosity. This is like a kind of end times.
SPEAKER_01I don't believe for one second, and I never have, that it's the end of the world, but it's the end of a way we've been living, which might not be such a bad thing. What's that going to look like? And I think a lot of thinking about, you know, apocalyptic things that keep you awake at night. It's actually, oh, only occurring to me now. It's looking at the drop. It's looking at the fear. And really what I was thinking about was like if we really want to be part of our future and our children's future, we need to imagine the future. It cannot exist if we don't imagine it. Everything begins by imagining it.
SPEAKER_01So let's look at that. Let's look at what it could be like. And then maybe we can make it.
SPEAKER_00Yes. Okay. I love that you said they're looking at the fear because you also have a short story in this wonderful anthology called The Beast of England that comes out, I think it's actually this month, this week. Tomorrow.
SPEAKER_01Yes, tomorrow. Congratulations.
SPEAKER_00But also that feels like looking at the beast, looking at the monster, looking at the thing, looking into fear. And just really there's this beautiful moment at the beginning of the short story where the narrator, I hope I'm not giving this away, I'll be very careful here, where the narrator is revisiting a moment that has happened to her that Holds so much horror and fear. And she says, I think something like, hold my hand together. She brings the reader in and they revisit this moment. But it really has this feeling of really confronting that fear,
SPEAKER_00really having to look at the fear in order to, and that's sort of the shift in order to. Yes, exactly. And I'm just like, what is that to you? Like the moment that you do look at the peril, you do look at the fear, you do look at the kind of the darkest, most I don't know, fear-inducing, anxiety-inducing thing.
SPEAKER_01I suppose it's like that anxiety exercise, right? What's the worst that can happen? Instead of just having your fear, when it's unnamed and undefined, it becomes big and amorphous and some kind of wave that's going to swallow you up, some cloud. But when you really take it apart, you're like, what's the worst that can happen? Okay, now how do I prepare for that? Maybe that's not so bad. But also it lets you just kind of poof, like go away. I can't be afraid of something if I know what it is and where it's coming from.
SPEAKER_01And so, yeah, in that story, she's a girl remembering this moment. The collection is a folk story, folk horror stories. I decided to call my future folk because folk stories are like warnings. There's a societal purpose to a folk story, which is don't go into the woods at night or don't drink. Don't wash your clothes in the holy well because that's our drinking water. There's reasons for them. And if you put that warning or lesson for children or all of society and to wrap it
SPEAKER_01in a story, then it's remembered and it's adhered to. If you tell someone, don't go into the woods at night, you could get lost. They won't listen. They would invent a scary monster in the woods and they might. And so Mind's Future Folk because it's this woman from the future talking about now as a warning. Do you feel that hope? So you have an activist background and you're also very active in bringing more inclusive stories, thinking about environmental justice. Like where does the hope live for you right now?
SPEAKER_01And people, and people coming together in the power of community. And there's so many horrible people on the news and in our social media feeds, but they're a minority and they are completely powerless before acts of love and community. But their agenda is to destroy that through fear. If we lose hope, if we give in to fear, if we lose the love that we can have for ourselves and our communities, then that messaging and that ugliness wins. I've gotten involved in quite a few things locally, like saving Bath City Centre Library.
SPEAKER_01The council wanted to close it, and that was a two-year battle, which at a time when the government was closed about 10,000 libraries across the UK, we saved that library and it's still there. And doing that, show me two things. First, what I was just saying about the power of people, and also just how bad decision-making can just happen if nobody does anything about it. It's unbelievable how people in political positions will just let something really dumb happen. Another case in point is an area of land near Bath that wanted to be developed into
SPEAKER_01a superstore, but it's right on the river in an area of outstanding natural beauty. There's European badgers that are endangered living there, all kinds of wildlife, and it's so pristine. Once that happens, you can't undo it. But when people come together, They do a little fundraising. They do a little research. They do a little mobilizing. You can stop terrible decisions, and it doesn't actually take that much. And it's also kind of fun to get together with people for a common cause, people in your neighborhood who are of all different ages and abilities.
SPEAKER_01And when you meet these great people, what you have in common with them is just passion to save a piece of nature a library or a meadow. And I've met amazing people in Bath. And what that also did, because I had recently moved a transplant from New York, and it made me really feel belonging. This is my place. I've actually helped change elements of it for the better and met people and made friends with some counselors and really, really annoyed other ones.
SPEAKER_00But, you know, you feel like, well, now I really belong here. It's mine, too. Yeah, I love that. It's mine too. We don't just live in a place where you get to shape it, like the same way that you get to shape your stories. And in a sense, that's the direction. That's the thing that can give us hope, that we are fundamentally involved. We are part and can be part of decision making, although for whatever reason, often we choose not to be. Just talking about stories too,
SPEAKER_01it's the same thing. I also work with this project out of Vasfi University called Emblaze. And the whole thing is supporting UK writers of color from like grassroots, just reading and writing groups through like actual support for ambitious writers who want to publish or work in publishing. That's a program that I've been working on for a few years and it comes from a really strong, the strongest belief I have really is about stories and the power of stories and the way that stories can be used for good and not good. And that we are our stories.
SPEAKER_01We are just living, walking, breathing, The more you write stories and good stories and hear from different people and different people's stories, that's how you build empathy, that's how you build society, that's how you break down these false walls that people want to put up about you don't belong and you do belong. It's nonsense, but it's taking root and you see it everywhere and it's a dangerous time right now.
SPEAKER_01There is nothing that challenges that more than story and telling good stories.
SPEAKER_00I think I saw that you said you never use AI and I want to bring that in here because there is something about that we are our stories and there is something about making stories more inclusive and there is something about the power of connection and belonging. And also, we are currently navigating this curious moment that AI is in the room with us, right? And sometimes we are giving decisions, giving our words, giving our stories over to AI.
SPEAKER_00And I'm curious about where you are in this because, of course, it's in the news constantly right now. But also, it makes me think about, like I listened to, before I came on this call, I listened to this week's episode of The Daily, the New York Times podcast. And it was talking about this new app that can act as an agent for you. And one of the really heartbreaking things the reporter said was that he had this app call his local bookstore to ask whether a book had come in. And afterwards he could see the transcript of what the AI had said to the bookseller.
SPEAKER_00And he said something broke his heart. Not that the AI did something wrong and not that the book wasn't there, but because he realized how much he enjoys those interactions with the bookseller. And part of his humanity, or he had willingly given part of his humanity over to this app. And I thought that was really fascinating, not just in terms of the context of books and booksellers and independent bookstores, but also... In what those really tiny interactions and giving over those tiny interactions do for us. And I think it's the same with words, like how we give over our words and how part of us just shifts a little bit.
SPEAKER_00And I'm just curious to see where you are on that.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, well, I should clarify before you get hate mail. Obviously, I use AI because it's Google and I might look up what kind of tires do I need for my car? The boring stuff. Okay. Whatever you can do in a Google search bar. But I don't use it at all ever for writing anything or editing or anything creative. Because the difficulty and the joy inherent in those things, it's hard. But that's where the magic is. I know writers are starting to use it for different kinds of reasons.
SPEAKER_01And there's no point in saying, don't submit to me if you've used AI. I think, ultimately, I can actually tell. There's just nothing there. It makes me feel nothing, and there's no voice in it. It's flat. It's only going to harm a writer, really, and it's like your one job is to write. You have to face up against that fear and the joy that comes with it and the amazing moments of going, oh, my gosh. I wrote this whole book that's coming out last year, and it wasn't until I was almost done with several drafts that I went, oh, it's about this other thing.
SPEAKER_01And like, ah, like that is the most amazing thing that's ever happened to me. And then I know other writers who've had books out and they have people come up to them at a book talk and say, I loved this happened and this made me, and they go, I never saw it that way. They, you know, that's just the magic of creation and connection. And we're not going to get that if it's just AI because AI is only scraping stuff that's already existed. There will never be anything new.
SPEAKER_00So, so...
SPEAKER_01I think about it with my kids. They're going to use it to research their papers at uni or whatever, and get that you have to, but it's very insidious. And so if you start using it to ask it to do things for you, like what you were just describing, where it can be like your agent, or it can tell you what to wear based on the weather, or if that boy you went on a date with, if you should call him back. Real heart decisions, if it's something that should happen in conversation with your heart and your mind, Just have that conversation.
SPEAKER_01Don't farm it out because it can just take over so fast. They've shown this, right? Like it's so quickly can take over where people need it for everyday decisions. And that's sad. I think that's really sad because then you're not really living your life. And what else are you going to do?
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And I love the idea of a heart decision. That's such a beautiful filter. I thought like as you go to open, not to demonize this, but as you go to open the app or whatever it would be. And again, yes, I use AI too, but it's also knowing like in what moments and what are the impulses behind that? And when does it serve us and when does it not? And you said something about, you know, there is difficulty and there's joy. They're not mutually exclusive. It makes me think about your surfing, but also writing and just being in life. There are both things and they don't necessarily cancel each other out.
SPEAKER_01And our whole, It comes back to that idea of connection and belonging. Like, how do we belong? How do we forge a connection with the world and the people around us? How do we nurture a sense of belonging so we don't feel so isolated and afraid all the time? We do that by engaging with the messiness of life, right? The really awful things, the scary things, the things that we're afraid of, the things that we really, really care about but we might lose. And so we fight for them and take that risk. This is how we move into...
SPEAKER_01We have to take risks. We have to put ourselves over that drop and then purposely not look down it, but look out along the way in that scene.
SPEAKER_01Because that's where the beauty is and the magic and the potential.
SPEAKER_00Okay, let's go to this. I have prepared some words for you. And they're just a few words. And I'm just curious about what they mean to you or have come to mean to you. And the first one is desire. And I say desire because in the workshop, of course, that I did with you, as we're talking about storytelling, one of the fundamental ideas that I took away was this The importance of desire. And it's so much part of storytelling, but I also think it really does speak to this thought that you're bringing,
SPEAKER_00in my mind anyway, where we put our desire, how we even come into contact with it, particularly maybe in this midlife moment. So what do you think desire has come to mean to you?
SPEAKER_01Oh, I'm so glad you picked that word. What does it mean to me? First, I'll say what it means to me in story and writing, because... I think there's this great book on writing, actually, by Robert Olin Butler, where he is talking about, like, goal and main character goals. And he says, if a Buddhist, as a Buddhist will tell you, if you put a person on the planet within two seconds, they're going to want something. Like, we're born bursting and screaming babies with desire. It propels us all the time. And when we're looking at storytelling and narrative,
SPEAKER_01I've worked with, like, hundreds and hundreds of writers and read probably thousands of synopses, and nine times out of ten, When a story starts to fall apart around the middle, like around that kind of when the writer gets like, I don't understand why my story's growing. I've lost it. The plot is sagging. It's because at the beginning, the main character is lacking that fundamental, clear desire for something. And then alongside that is the stakes attached. Like what happens if they don't get what they want or need? And so that's because like in life, yeah, we want lots of things.
SPEAKER_01We just want to be happy. And it's a bit more vague. But in reality, like, If we really are honest with ourselves, we all really want something that's going to give us our purpose and make us feel like the best, most powerful versions of ourselves. But there's a lot of fear around admitting that because then once you put it out there, now you've made yourself vulnerable to saying I didn't get it or it didn't work. And so a lot of times we just keep that really secret deep inside ourselves and never tell anyone that we want to. Desire is a little burning furnace in all of us that we have
SPEAKER_01to pay special attention to and make sure that we look after it and are honest with ourselves about what it is. Externally, too, I think, just because this is what my book's about and what I am as a middle-aged woman, there's a lot of things that, you know, telling us we shouldn't be filled with desire of any kind for anything.
SPEAKER_01You should be quiet. This is your time now to just go and be quiet and stop bothering us with your crap. That's it. Like you're done now. You've had your babies and now we can put you in a box in the woods or something. And just not what I see in women in their 50s. It's like they're just unfurling their wings ready to fly. But it's a very tough time because you have to be ready to be told, no, you can't. Don't do that. It's wrong. You're being too much. You're too loud. You're You're trying too hard. You're asking for too much.
SPEAKER_01And we have to fight that and honor our desire and know that it comes from the real life place of our life force. Not be afraid of it, but actually nurture it.
SPEAKER_00I think there's a perception sometimes in midlife that there's an end point for wanting. There's a moment that we're not supposed to want anymore. And if we do want, then there's a big societal question mark around that. And who am I to want that? Who am I to need that even or desire that even? And desire can have this association with something, with maybe something unique. About youth even, there's a sort of funny age component I think sometimes to desire. But it is such a sort of a fire. It's such an energy kind of something that kind of can really shift things.
SPEAKER_00And I think there is something about nurturing it. And it made me wonder like when you started surfing, there is something that you wanted in that. But how do people see that you are late in your 40s and you are surfing for the first time?
SPEAKER_01The truth is serving as a very male dominated sport. Like when I first started going to the Wave, it was mostly men. They've since introduced sister sessions. There's been like, for some reason since COVID, a big, in the UK anyway, like a big surge around women, mostly younger than me, but women to get into the water and then form clubs and go together and build confidence that way. And it's incredible. It's really gorgeous. But I think, I don't know why I kept doing it. Like there were times where I felt intimidated, especially when I was on my own, for sure. And where things would happen to me that wouldn't happen to a male surfer,
SPEAKER_01like people telling me where I should or shouldn't be or, you know, and it was only through building up the ability to surf that I became confident enough to not care anymore. Now I just absolutely don't care. But it was definitely a bit of a journey. And there was times where I was really racked with insecurity, like I shouldn't be here. What am I doing? Oh, my God, this is insane. Yeah, you should be home looking after your kids.
SPEAKER_00What are you doing right now?
SPEAKER_01My chits were like, we don't need looking after her, go. But that, yeah, it's, I think whatever you're trying to do, you're going to face some element of that as a woman, particularly, and then any other thing. But there's so much joy on the other side of that, of being able to, of being able to confront that and push through it and to the other side, that it's worth, whatever it is that you want, it's worth pushing through that fear because you just have no idea what's on the other side and it's probably amazing.
SPEAKER_00When did that become part of your identity and your story? Because as I see your bio now, there's very much writer, editor, surfer. When did it become a public facing? So it's something that you do for yourself, but now it's something that is part of your identity.
SPEAKER_01It just really is. I don't know. There's no real thought to it. I just feel like that's who I am and I'm not going to get a sponsorship or anything else. Although, hey, open now. But I'm never going to be that good as it's, but then I don't care. Why does everything have to be about like, identity doesn't have to be about like money or commerce or some kind of award. You know, mother is also my identity and that's my reward. I have three rewards for that and that's it, but that's everything. But so I don't know. That's a good question. I have no idea why it became part of my identity, but it really is.
SPEAKER_01But for no real reason, except sometimes meeting other surfers, it's fun to talk about surfing. But it gives so much. Just as a tiny segue, there's this amazing woman I know, North Devon, who runs a club for women and girls. And it's for exactly this, to get women, and especially young girls, surfing. And it's called Wave Wahinis. And they just made a film about her for the Daily Mirror. And it's about part of the club where she takes girls from refugee and asylum seeker backgrounds surfing. And I went along and volunteered just in the water with the girls. And these girls are like probably from nine to 15, 16 year olds.
SPEAKER_01They've all come from other countries where there's been war and it's been really hard. And now they're in the UK at a time when people are saying girls with this color skin or who wear a hijab or whatever are not welcome. And then we just go in the water and some of them couldn't even swim. Most of them had never put on a wetsuit. And we had the most shriekingly fun, joyful moments. I think it was one of the best days of my life. It was so much fun. And my heart was just so full afterwards. And this experience that they had and the friendships
SPEAKER_01that they've now formed together and this sense of belonging, it's great for them. But actually, the real story is this is just outside Ilferkoum, this woman who also volunteers, who's an older white woman from Ilferkoum, whose husband passed away. And she was really depressed and kind of lost. And then she went along one day when they opened an asylum secret hotel in Ilferkoum. With messages of support with a lot of people in the community. Just came together and sang Beatles songs and held up red hearts and said you are welcome as other people were saying other things.
SPEAKER_01But there was more of the people on the side of love. And she's in this film too and she's talking about what this has given her. And it's what we were talking about, community and purpose and being a place of love. It's the most Wonderful, wonderful story. And it's about everyone on all sides of that story and how much more there is if we come from a place of love and acceptance and joy and playing in the ocean. I mean, it just doesn't get more pure. That's extraordinary. It's amazing.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it is amazing. Then my next word for you is going to feel very different. It's actually forgiveness. And I bring this up because there's a moment in the short story where Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Can I read this out to you? I probably do. Yes, of course.
SPEAKER_00But I think you say forgiveness is a funny thing and it happens all at once, but can be long time coming. And you have to edge towards it with an open heart, even while you're deep in hurt and wish only to shut yourself away. And I love, love, love that so much. And I wonder why forgiveness and what that has come to mean to you. It's such a difficult thing to put into words, really.
SPEAKER_01I guess you just
SPEAKER_00read what I did.
SPEAKER_01But it's hard to tell in words the power of it, and also it's impossible to say how you get there. I had, just to be personal, I had quite a difficult relationship with my father for many years because he was there and then he wasn't. And then when he would come back, he would leave again. And it was very hurtful, and it started as a child, so it was a really hard thing to do. And then... And it took me most of my life, but at some point I just, yeah, just decided to open my heart and stop having my own hurt and pain lead the program,
SPEAKER_01but rather just open up to the potential of something else. And I don't exactly know how it happened, but it felt like it happened all at once, all of a sudden that something just went and just was gone. And it was this feeling that I'd been carrying something that it was my choice all along to set down. That it wasn't, you know, that it was all me alone with this feeling that I could either continue to carry or I could just let it go. And the only way to let it go was to really properly understand and where his own difficulties and what he may have been up against and who he was and
SPEAKER_01then just to like accept it. And it didn't cost me anything. And it was just so much easier.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, there's such a sort of unburdening there, isn't there? And a softening as well. Yeah. As you were talking about that, I was thinking about that moment in the story of, there's a sort of, I don't want to talk about the ending too much, there's a moment in the story that there is this sort of, exactly as you described it, this letting it go.
SPEAKER_01Yes. Just letting it go. And that opens up inside of you a whole new kind of ballroom of space for new things and joyful things. And it takes a lot of space to hold onto pain. It takes a lot of energy.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it does.
SPEAKER_01And if you can find a way to just let it go, look at some of the conflicts in the world right now. If there was a way that, and everyone's always going, yeah, but then this happened, but before that date, this happened, and 2,000 years ago, this happened. Is there a way that we can just start from now and just go, let's just move on? It's a lot more complicated when you're talking about that stuff, but still, the conflicts, the world conflicts that have been solved in the past have relied on that idea. Mm-hmm. Maybe.
SPEAKER_00Okay. So my last word for you, I think it's going to be, let's think. So I have lots of words around beasts and monster and that kind of area because I'm really fascinated by the folk horror and how we find ourselves increasingly. I think there was a really interesting thing I read the other day about how horror is a genre that we're turning to in terms of movies, but in terms of understanding ourselves and our place in the world. So I don't know whether the word for you would be monster, whether it would be beast, whether it would be horror, but I'm curious about how you've come to understand that piece of things.
SPEAKER_01I think if you talk about like monsters and beasts and creatures that are lurking around the fearful parts of our imagination ready to hurt us, I think they're always us. Like we are the monster and we can't, you know, and it's those parts of ourselves that operate from fear or greed or I wonder why we do that. Do we do that maybe as a way to externalize it so that we can then fight it or say, this isn't me? Or maybe we do it so that we can actually fight it and defeat it and understand it. Is it easier when the problem or the
SPEAKER_01But there was something... And I've heard horror writers talk about this actually, that it's actually helpful because it puts the monsters into a place
SPEAKER_01where you can deal with them and understand bad things. Whereas like the actual world, it's like, you don't know, especially for a child, I know that bad things happen, but I don't know what to do about it. But when I read horror, they can be the most disgusting, horrific beasts, most violence and gore. And I used to actually take my grandmother's crucifix and put it on the Stephen King book when I went to school because I wanted to keep all the monsters in the book and thought they might get out and hide under my bed. But in a way, that was like a way of dealing with probably real stuff that I was afraid of
SPEAKER_01in my life and couldn't have any idea how to cope with it. So there was this more manageable version of fear that made sense.
SPEAKER_00What was it like to write your own monster?
SPEAKER_01So much fun.
SPEAKER_00It's just...
SPEAKER_01It's the best to have an assignment like that. Just really just unleash that imagination and make it as awful as possible. It's great. Yeah. There's a pretty real release in that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Okay, let's come back to your thought kept. So this sounds like it arrived at a really important moment for you. Things are really shifting for you. And it came to mean so much more than a technical kind of suggestion for surfing. How do you
SPEAKER_01hope you'll continue to remember it
SPEAKER_00moving forwards?
SPEAKER_01The good thing about it is that I have to think about it every time I'm surfing. So it'll always come back into my head. But I think sometimes when you really take something in and spend a lot of time with it and it shifts, and you probably know this from the kind of wellness, therapeutical perspective, but like when something properly shifts inside of you, it becomes part of you and you don't have to maybe consciously go back to it all the time. It helps. Surely we have to like always be reminding ourselves, but It can also just shift something in you and your perspective
SPEAKER_01and how you face challenges. And hopefully it will always be there for me, but luckily I can just go surfing and remember it.
SPEAKER_00That's a lovely way to remember something, isn't it?
SPEAKER_01Just to go surfing and just to
SPEAKER_00be like, there it is again.
SPEAKER_01There's that emotional muscle memory that I need to remember going forwards. We could do a whole podcast just on the life lessons of surfing and one wave after another. Because it's such a funny thing to do because it takes so much effort for seconds of the most divinely beautiful moment. Or you're just flying across a moving wall of water that came from a storm a thousand miles away. I mean, it's wonderful. What do you think the direction is now for you? I want to be writing more. I can't wait to do more things like this,
SPEAKER_01have these kind of conversations, whether in bookshops or with readers. That is just heaven for me. So the fact that hopefully having a book and hopefully more books in the world means that I get to travel around and meet writers. I love working with writers. I love getting into people's stories, learning about them and teaching writers. I just want to do what I'm doing, but a little bit more. With some surfing on the side.
SPEAKER_00I'm good.
SPEAKER_01If I can do what I'm doing right now for absolutely as long as possible, then I'm happy. Just keep riding the wave.
SPEAKER_00Thank you so much for being here today. Thank you for exploring all these different aspects of this wonderful thought and for sharing it with people who are listening.
SPEAKER_01Thank you so much, Claire. Thank you. This has been a wonderful chat. I really have enjoyed it.
SPEAKER_00At the end of the workshop that Dionne hosted, that I told you about in the intro, there was a moment that she asked, what emotions do you actually want writing to give you? And I love that question so much because it speaks to a lot of the work that I do with the people that I work with. But also, I wrote down a lot of the words that I felt talking to Dionne. Excited, energized, connected. And this is an interesting one for free.
SPEAKER_00Because I think to me what that thought really offers and what so much of Dionne's words and her stories can connect us to is possibility and our capacity to tap into hope and to set goals. Our direction in a different way than maybe we have already. I'm really curious about whether you will hold on to this week's thought, which is don't look down at the drop, look along the direction of the wave.
SPEAKER_00It's such a great one for people who surf, people who don't surf, people who haven't seen a wave in a very long time. You can find out more about Dionne and her work in the show notes. I've included links to Beasts of England, which I really enjoyed reading. And that features Dionne's short story, Helmuth. And you can look out for her debut novel, Rina, which is coming out from Dead Ink in 2027. Dionne offers a range of editing services to everything from developmental edits to copy edits.
SPEAKER_00And by now you might know that I'm somebody that loves words, loves writing, loves stories. I have my first book out right now. And anybody who loves to read and think about well-being and ideas too. My subscribe is called More Good Days and you can subscribe and follow my writing there.
SPEAKER_00If you want to stay a little bit longer in this space of fear, there are two episodes that I think you might want to check out. The first is by Sardia Hazanfar. It's called Be Brave Enough to Suck at Something New. And I think this would be just such a wonderful companion to the thought that Dion brought today. The other one is from Emma Simpson and it also ties to being in the water. Emma Simpson wrote a book about wild swimming and all that offered her in midlife and beyond.
SPEAKER_00And there is an episode with her about her thought kept, which is what's the worst that can happen. If you're somebody who is maybe feeling fearful right now or is figuring out a relationship with fear, I think these three episodes together would be really fantastic. Thank you to you for listening and I will see you next time with another thought, another story that one of my guests has kept and you might want to as well. Bye for now. [music]
Some podcast conversations are life-changing. For me, even as the host, this was one of them. Afterwards * I pitched to host a workshop at one of my favourite wellbeing festivals * I recommitted to my visibility in...
“Could try harder.” It’s the sort of thing you might have read on a school report, and it can follow you for years. We might even think about it with parenting, work and even the things we do to feel better. Reading...
When you’re used to noticing what everyone else needs, asking what makes you come alive can feel surprisingly difficult. Perhaps even a little selfish. But what happens when your own desires keep getting left out of...
Do you ever come away from a conversation replaying what you said, wondering whether you were too much, too emotional, or somehow not enough? What if being confident didn’t mean getting every interaction right? This...
How often do you find yourself thinking about what you should be doing? How you should run your business, show up at work, be more creative, become more successful or even enjoy your life? What if all those shoulds are...