EPISODE 9: FIXED-TERM CONTRACT In this episode of 'A Postdoc's Journal', I read a journal entry from July 2013, reflecting on my contract renewal struggles and the lack of job security in academia. I discuss the challenges faced with funding gaps, self-doubt, and networking. I also explore the impact of limited networking and self-perceived inadequacies. Ultimately, this episode highlights the broader issues in academic culture with limited funding, fixed-term contracts, and internal politics. 00:00 Introduction to the Postdocs Journal 03:17 Journal Entry: Meeting with the Boss 05:50 Reflections on Job Security and Visibility 07:01 The Broader Issues in Academia 13:27 Personal Struggles and Mindset 18:15 Cultural and Systemic Barriers 20:04 Concluding Thoughts and Future Lessons 23:14 Outro For more information about the podcast and for my contact information, please visit https://a-postdocs-journal.captivate.fm/ Please leave a review on Apple podcasts or Podchaser Follow me on Instagram and/or LinkedIn and/or BlueSky For copy editing and proofreading services, see here: https://simitpatel.com/
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Hello and welcome to a Postdocs Journal, the show that takes you through my journey into and eventually out of academia as a post doctoral research scientist. My name is Simit Patel. Hello, thank you very much for joining me.
Welcome back to those of you who have listened to the show before, and a very warm welcome to those of you who may be listening for the very first time. If you don't already know, this podcast is based on my own personal journal. In each episode, I read out a journal entry from about 12 years ago, back when I was working in academia, as a research scientist, as a postdoc. Then I reflect on it, I analyze it, I try to make sense of it. And I shared my thoughts with you today with the benefit of 12 years of hindsight
If you are a student or a postdoc or just someone struggling in academia Or you may have already left academia or you may not work in academia at all And you can just relate to things like imposter syndrome Loneliness and mental health issues in the workplace. I hope that by sharing my own personal experience with you That helps you to feel a little bit less alone. In the last episode, it was just before Christmas 2012, close to the end of my very first year of my postdoc.
Over the next four episodes, including this one, I'm gonna share with you four journal entries from the year 2013. It was actually a very eventful year for me and I was journaling a lot more, but the other journal entries weren't really about postdoc stuff, because the focus of this podcast is my life as a postdoc. I'm not going to bore you with all the other drama that was happening in my life at the time. Despite only having four journal entries to share with you, the second year of my postdoc was actually a very pivotal year for me and my career.
In today's episode, we're going to jump to July 2013, about one and a half years into my two year postdoc. At this point, I was already in discussions with my boss about extending my contract by another year, but things are rarely that straightforward in academia. At this point I started to encounter some of the very harsh realities of working in academia. I always knew that things like limited funding and a lack of job security, fixed term contracts and internal politics were always a problem, but it
never really hit home until those things were really affecting me directly. I always understood those were challenges but I never really understood the impact of those challenges and I only understood the impact of those challenges when they were actually impacting me. So please have a listen to the reading now, I'll be back at the end to share some thoughts with you after 12 years of hindsight. Enjoy. 19th July 2013.
Just had a meeting with my boss about my contract. Oh boy. So my new contract can't start until the next funding period for the whole Research Institute, which will be around next summer in July 2014. My contract ends in January 2014. This leaves a five month gap between February and the end of June where I can't be employed by my research institute.
My boss is willing to gamble and use the remaining research budget to employ me for that five months. I forgot to ask, and I regret it now, if that would mean a pay cut for me. The only condition he gave me was that I need to have the snail project finished by the end of January. He also told me that I'm not visible enough. I have kept myself to myself and I haven't really networked with other professors or postdocs. Networking gives me more insurance, apparently.
It means my boss could ask someone else for some postdoc funding for a month or so. When he tried that, it didn't work because no one knew who I was. He has been really fair and he is being so good to me. throwing me these lifelines and investing in me this way. And his criticism of me is 100 percent valid. I just feel a bit like I've failed. Up until this point, I should have published more, networked more.
Instead of enjoying my life and laughing all the time, I should have been taking things more seriously. I think I've just been taken down a peg. And because I'm so insecure and weak, it really gets to me. These negative thoughts are like worms dangling from my head, I can't shake them loose. What I need is some good planning. Real deadlines and targets for the next six months.
I just need to once and for all change my attitude and apply myself. Just work harder and stop being so lazy and scared. Instead, I need to be brave and active. Okay, thank you very much for listening to that. As usual, I've written down some thoughts after reading that back and hearing that back. This is another one of those moments where doing this podcast, I feel like I
am re experiencing a lot of the issues I was having in the journal entry. In this journal entry, I write about how I feel like I failed and when I read that back, I honestly have the same feeling. I also remember how uncomfortable all of those conversations were with my boss about my performance and my contract situation and so on. And even after 12 years, all those frustrations around that lack of job security and All the other problems I was having still frustrates me.
I guess I never really addressed a lot of those feelings, I just sort of suppressed them over time. They say that time heals all wounds. That's total bullshit. It doesn't. It just makes you forget things temporarily so that you can continue to function. So I mainly want to reflect on the lack of job security in academia and the effect that had on me, and I want to talk about me not being visible enough. and whatever else comes up along the way. This journal entry highlights some of the issues around a total
lack of job security in academia. In my case, there were a few factors at play that contributed to that. Just to explain the wider funding issue for the whole research institute a little bit more. So the whole research institute I worked at was on a seven year funding cycle. And because it was public money, there needs to be checks and balances in place and of course lots of bureaucracy to make sure that the public money was not being wasted. The seventh year of that funding cycle coincided with the extension of my
contract and there was a massive review underway to determine whether or not the research institute would even continue. Everyone kind of expected it to continue, you know, at that point we had moved into a new building and we were Pretty sure it was too big to fail at that point, but no one could actually start any new work contracts until all the bureaucracy was dealt with. I'm not going to comment too much about the problems with public science funding. Honestly, it's a little bit beyond my field of expertise, and frankly,
I don't want to bring it up as a problem if I can't offer a solution, and I don't know what the solution is. But the detrimental effect on job security is obvious. Working in such a financially insecure environment can be very unsettling. In general, I think as humans, we crave safety. It's a fundamental human need to want to be safe in your environment. When you have the constant threat around you of financial instability and a
working culture where short, fixed term contracts are the absolute norm, it's difficult to feel a sense of safety. When you know your work environment isn't safe, it's natural to want to get away from it and move towards a safer situation. Or what you think is going to be a safer situation. And I think this laid the groundwork for one of the biggest conflicts throughout the rest of my time in academia. On the one hand, I was getting this signal that this is a very unsafe, insecure environment and I need to get away from it.
On the other hand, I was being given a five month contract to stay a little bit longer. And I actually wanted to stay longer. So it's like I was being pushed away by my instincts and pulled closer to academia as well, also by my free will. I heard something recently and I think it applies here. I think the quote said something like, people will prefer to stay with the pain that's familiar rather than risk the unfamiliar. Another factor that made things difficult for me was that I didn't have my own
research grant to be employed on. I've explained before in previous episodes that there are plenty of job opportunities in academia. Uh, it's just that you have to find a way to pay for the job yourself via a research grant. On reflection, even if I had managed to submit a grant application in the first year of my postdoc, I probably wouldn't have won it because my publication record wasn't too impressive at that point in time. In my case, my boss was able to move some money around and create a five month
cushion for me, but it meant that there was no money left to pay for any research. So yes, my boss wanted to continue working with me, but that didn't fill me with a sense of confidence like it should have. Instead, there was a sense that I was being a burden. A burden on the whole research group. And it was a problem for me to continue in my own job. There was a sense of guilt, you know, I was responsible for no one being able to pay for any research.
Now part of that is down to me, I know that, I'm sure there's something in my psychology that makes me feel like I'm a burden just for existing. There was a sense that my boss was doing me a favour. That was a little bit painful for him and painful for everyone else, and I should be very grateful for this very short fixed term contract. I should add that I didn't actually know if I could stay any longer after those five months until the very end of those five months, because of the whole funding cycle bureaucracy nonsense.
And I wasn't the only one in that situation, and pretty much everyone at the Research Institute was worried about that too. And I think this speaks to how normalized these fixed term contracts are in academic culture. In a previous episode, I spoke about how that actually appealed to me at one point. I thought it was actually quite exciting to be able to move around every couple of months or every couple of years. But when I actually had to experience living a life of having to Live from
one fixed term contract to another. It basically became impossible to plan my life. Living in a permanent state of insecurity and uncertainty is not really a good way to live. Now since leaving academia and working for companies in the quote unquote real world, I have enjoyed more job security in general. For example, I haven't had to deal with any fixed term contracts for the last 10 years or so.
And funding is never dependent on public money and all the bureaucracy that comes with it But I have to say that threats to job security Outside of academia still exist and those threats just come from different places. They don't come from fixed term contracts or Public money funding cycles and things they just come from other places So while I have had these so called permanent contracts over the last 10 years I've actually been laid off from companies twice in the last couple of years because of other financial
factors while companies may not be Directly dependent on public funds. They are heavily affected by macroeconomic conditions in general So the threat of financial instability is still very real So although I complained so much at the time back then of a lack of job security in academia I've learned that financial instability and a lack of job security are just an unfortunate reality of the world we live in today even outside of academia and that kind of thing can really affect your mental health because
Again, because of that fundamental need that we have for safety. I wrote about not being visible enough and how that was, uh, counting against me and that was to my detriment. There's a few layers to this one as well. On one level, academia can be deeply political, like in many professions. It's more about who you know and who you are kind of in with. That's just one of the rules of the game. If you don't agree with those rules, or for whatever reason
you don't play by those rules, it becomes much harder to survive. I really didn't play by those rules, and that was partly down to me, but partly down to the environment around me as well. I definitely witnessed others play the political game. There were people that would, you know, go to archery together, and they would go on dog walks on the weekend together, they would go hunting together, or whatever. And I could see how that would positively affect those people's reputation and status amongst other colleagues, especially amongst the professors.
And for my part, I never really wanted to get ahead that way. I feel like schmoozing people just to be kind of in with the right people just didn't sit right with me. There's something very disingenuous and superficial about that. I still hate playing the political game today as well. I haven't changed at all in that respect I prefer earning more genuine meaningful connections with people based on my merits That might also be to my detriment today But life isn't really always about just climbing a career ladder.
That's just one aspect of life And ultimately you realize after climbing that ladder what's at the top just isn't really worth it because you've lost so much along the way I think life is more about living authentically according to your values rather than trying to climb up The other thing that I think made me kind of invisible at the time was my lack of confidence and self worth Because I didn't feel like I was successful yet. I didn't want to put myself out there and network more with people because I felt embarrassed to say that I wasn't successful yet.
Successful in an academic sense, that is. I still felt like a fraud at that point. I didn't feel worthy to be there. Today, I'm a bit ashamed to say it, but I honestly still struggle with the same mindset issues a little bit. If things aren't going well for me, if I don't feel like I'm being successful I feel a lot less social. I don't want to network, I don't want to socialise, or even reach out to friends to catch up. When I meet people at networking events or see people, I want to
tell them about how successful I am. I want things to be going well for me, so that other people think better of me, I guess. In my mind, it's like I I have this need to be successful first, and then I can have the confidence to go and talk to people. Logically, I know it's actually the other way around. I need to talk to people first in order to help me become successful. But my instincts don't seem to know that.
Back when I was in academia, I needed to network more in the department so people would know who I was. And that would help me in these difficult contract talks today I'm struggling with the same issue with trying to start my own business I need to be networking right now and reaching out to people to get clients But I feel ashamed to do that because I feel like I need to be successful first I I feel like I don't have the confidence to go and try and drum up business And
that's holding my business back right now It's interesting to see how this mindset was holding me back in academia and it's still holding me back today As shitty as that makes me feel right now about myself It does give me some clear things to work on And I am old enough and wise enough to know that that's actually a good thing The sad thing is when I look back on it is networking was actually one of my key strengths before I started my postdoc It's actually how I got offered this postdoc in the first place But it's sad because I didn't capitalize on that.
I didn't Lean into my strengths and maximize my value. I think in general this highlights one of the key problems I think in our education system I was always taught that you have to work harder at the things you're not so good at. That's how you improve and become better at them. But in practice, what happens with me back then and now, I end up neglecting the things I'm actually good at and not nurturing those things and not leaning into my strengths so much. In this case, I became so focused on trying to generate data, trying
to publish, trying to get grants. All my focus was on those. Areas where I thought I was failing and I ended up just not capitalizing on one of my core strengths, which was networking But I also think it's worth mentioning here that there were various external things that were slightly beyond my control That actually made it harder for me to be visible in the department in many ways I did not fit the norm of the academic establishment at my research institute.
I'm a british born asian from a different academic system from a different country with no academic or cultural ties to anyone. And that makes it difficult for me to fit in compared to, say, another postdoc who may have grown up in the German academic system who does archery and likes to go on dog walks or whatever. In German academia, and I think in a lot of academia in general, you get these so called academic family trees across a small set of academic research
institutions where you get this one ancient academic supervisor who supervises a bunch of people who go on to have their own labs and collaborate with each other and they go on to have their own mentees and who have their own labs and they all collaborate with each other and so on. So you can pick any given professor in an academic department and trace back their academic lineage to the the same small handful of ancestral academics. It's very hard for someone to come in and fit into that structure right
away, especially someone who doesn't fit the norm of that genealogy. I was never really ready to fully integrate into that culture of German academia. It's very hard to when you don't speak the language and you don't know if you're going to be there in five months time. You just don't know whether it's worth making that kind of investment. Toward the end of the century, I started to make sense of my problems in the failure. I was telling myself that I was the problem, and I was generally being really harsh on myself.
I thought that I wasn't publishing enough, I wasn't networking enough, I wasn't planning well enough, I wasn't applying myself enough, I had the wrong attitude, I was being lazy, I wasn't working hard or smart enough, etc. And at this point I thought that I had to change myself to suit the needs of the job. This laid the groundwork for one of the most important life lessons I learnt from my time in academia, which is actually coming up in the next couple of episodes.
For now, all I'll say is that I know I was wrong for going down this line of thought, thinking that I was fundamentally the problem. There was one sentence that really stood out to me that makes me cringe and breaks my heart a little bit. I said something like I felt bad for actually trying to enjoy my life and laughing too much. I think this goes back to what we talked about in the last episode about my attitude towards work. I believe that work is something serious and that you weren't
really supposed to enjoy it. You can love it, and you can be passionate about it, but not necessarily enjoy it. So I was assuming that enjoying my life was a marker for me not working hard enough, and not taking it seriously enough. I really regret having this attitude at the time. I was really just making myself unnecessarily miserable, believing that that would be the path to success at work. From what I know now, I can tell you that it's not the path to success in the long run. I guess it depends on what your definition of success is, and
that certainly changes over time. But for me, I just really wasn't happy and that does not align with my definition of success I do hope a younger generation is growing up understanding that enjoying your life along the way and laughing as much as possible Is probably the most important thing If and when I have children, I want to make sure that they don't grow up with the same attitude to work that I had. So, there you have it.
As always, I do feel a bit better after having gone through all of that and saying it out loud. Actually, hearing it back in audio form seems to make me feel better. I think the, the editing process of this podcast helps me to structure my thoughts a little bit and understand everything in its entirety. When I was reflecting on the whole uncertain contract situation, it was really helpful for me to take a more balanced view of the internal reasons for why that situation was difficult for me and all the external reasons that were.
making that situation difficult for me. I do believe in taking responsibility for my own choices, but that doesn't always mean that it's all my fault and I should blame myself all the time. I think it's fair to say that there are fundamental problems in the academic system that made it hard for me to survive in that system. In the next episode we have another big time jump to December 2013. I'm in a much worse position at this point, and it really didn't help that I just fucking hated Christmas at the time.
But, this is the first general entry where I wrote down the most important life lesson that I took away from my entire time in academia. Thank you so much for joining me, I hope that was valuable for you in some way. Until next time, please be kind to yourself. Brute about it, brute until the day, one day I will clown the words to say.
Thanks again for listening to a Postdocs Journal. I've been your host, Sumit Patel. If you've enjoyed this episode and you'd like to help support the podcast, please share it with others who you think might find it helpful and interesting. You could also leave a review over at Podchaser or on Apple Podcasts. If you can relate to anything in this episode, or if you have your own take on this journal entry, I would love to hear from you. Please feel free to reach out to me on LinkedIn, Instagram, or Blue Sky.
Links to all my social media are in the show notes. Thanks again.
SEASON 2, EPISODE 10: CV WRITING. This episode is about trying to write a CV. This is the LAST EPISODE of Season 2!! I revisit a journal entry I wrote in September 2014. I had gotten some feedback on my CV from a...
SEASON 2, EPISODE 9: ANGER MANAGEMENT This episode maps out a cycle of thoughts, feelings, and behaviours I was stuck in. I would start by feeling very anxious and end in explosive anger and self-harm. I revisit a...
SEASON 2, EPISODE 8: AM I DELUSIONAL ABOUT STAYING IN ACADEMIA? This episode is about me trying to navigate the end of my postdoc. I revisit a journal entry I wrote in September 2014, when I had 4 months left on my...
SEASON 2, EPISODE 7: SHOULD I STAY IN ACADEMIA? This episode is about me trying to figure out how I can stay in academia. This journal entry reminded me that I actually tried really hard to stay and, today, I actually...
SEASON 2, EPISODE 6: GUT FEELINGS This episode is about using your intuition to figure out what you want. Sometimes, what you want is in conflict with the demands of the environment around you. I revisit a journal entry...