Send Hope a Text Ranking pain is one of the ego’s favorite tricks. We compare flu to cancer, an argument to war, “small” mistakes to “unforgivable” ones, then we wonder why peace feels out of reach. From Kehenna Beach Estates on the Big Island of Hawaii, we walk slowly through A Course in Miracles Chapter 3 Section 4 on innocent perception and apply a radical idea: the Course’s fundamental concepts are not matters of degree. We explore why truth and illusion are not coexisting polarities and why love and fear are not equal powers on opposite ends of a spectrum. The light and darkness metaphor becomes a practical tool for spiritual healing: darkness is not a force to battle, it’s the absence of light. In the same way, fear and guilt may be experienced, but experience does not establish reality. That changes how we approach forgiveness, sickness, conflict, and the temptation to make “exceptions” that sneak the entire ego thought system back into the mind. Then we get concrete with relationships and boundaries. We answer a key question: how can boundaries be appropriate without compromising truth? The distinction is purpose. A Holy Spirit guided boundary keeps content steady (innocence, non-condemnation) while letting form vary (distance, blocking, leaving, refusing). We also unpack why behavior looks erratic until the mind commits to one teacher, and why the best news is this: a firm commitment to darkness or nothingness is impossible. If you want clearer forgiveness practice, cleaner boundaries, and a calmer mind that stops grading people’s innocence, listen through and try the reflection questions along the way. Subscribe, share this with a friend who is stuck in “degrees,” and leave a review with the biggest insight you’re taking into your week. 🕊️ Go deeper with me Book a 1:1 Session 🌸 Give and Support my Ministry: Donate 📙 Read, Watch, or Listen Substack
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Aloha and welcome to a course in miracles deep dive with Hope Johnson coming to you from Kehenna Beach Estates on the beautiful big island of Hawaii. Yay! Yay! I'm so stoked to be here and I'm stoked to do this with you again. Uh have a lovely, uh, lovely uh deep dive presentation ready.
SPEAKER_00Uh let's begin by tuning in. Take a breath together, close down your eyes. Unless you're driving, then don't do that. Ah, so much gratitude. So much gratitude to all of our brothers who are joining today, and to every brother, whether they follow a course in miracles or not. Yes, thank you so much. We're so grateful to everyone because they are as God created them.
SPEAKER_00And thank you to God for creating all of us and everything, everything that lives, which is all that is. And thank you to Jesus, specifically Jesus, the Christ, the Christ in all of us, for bringing us this beautiful material and this way of learning to see things differently. Let's have a beautiful session today. Ah, I love you. Thank you, Mahalo. All right.
SPEAKER_00So to get started, I'll let you guys know where we are. We're on page 117 in a course in miracles. This is the complete annotated edition. Came out in 2021. You do not need the book to follow along with me, but just in case you are, that's where it is. And we are beginning section four inside of chapter three now. Section four is the innocent perception. And I'm just going to do a little review of sections one to three in chapter three.
SPEAKER_00So you are all caught up on where we are. So section one is called the need to study. In that section, Christ emphasizes that the course must be studied carefully, not merely read casually. That's what we're doing here, isn't it? We're studying it carefully, right? So we resist understanding because real understanding threatens the ego's thought system.
SPEAKER_00That's why it needs to be studied carefully. Because our minds are just programmed to resist real understanding. So the goal here is not merely intellectual mastery. Okay, it's it's actually to become willing to recognize and apply this distinction between truth and error, or it might be called truth and illusion, the distinction between life and death. That seems to be the hook for people is not being able to distinguish between what's true and what's an error in the mind, and trying to make errors into truth and trying to make the truth into errors.
SPEAKER_00The ego always flips those around. So healing, also in in uh section one, the need to study, we learn that healing ultimately comes from God. A course in miracles is giving us the means by which our mind are our minds are prepared to accept the healing that comes from God. So, in a nutshell, that's section one. In section two, called Special Principles for Miracle Workers, we learn that miracle workers must distinguish clearly between what God created and what the ego mind made.
SPEAKER_00Wrong-mindedness isn't corrected through judgment or punishment or attack. It's it's really answered with the desire to heal. That's what wrong how wrong-mindedness is corrected is through the desire to heal. True forgiveness contains correction, but not condemnation. So correction is that desire to heal. The miracle responds to error by denying its reality and affirming that the truth is true.
SPEAKER_00Okay, we also went over the Holy Spirit meets people where they are and communicates in a form they can receive without increased fear. In that one, we were talking about how teaching, true teaching, doesn't include making the student fearful. Okay. So forgiveness that contains correction but no condemnation means we're not judging people because they seem to be doing it wrong.
SPEAKER_00They seem to be attacking or anything like that. Forgiveness, true correction is just seeing them as they are, seeing that they are as God created them. Nothing they're doing is harming us in any way. It's certainly not extending time for us. Only our mind can do that. Also, the miracle worker must follow guidance rather than trying to decide independently where, when, and how love should be expressed. Always following guidance, okay?
SPEAKER_00Because a lot of the times, and you know, give you one example, what I see uh when I'm looking on Facebook on those groups, people will be like, I'm loving you, man. And by at the same time, they're arguing with them, bickering with them, stuff like that. So that's kind of an example. The Holy Spirit wouldn't have you bickering to express love. So listening to the Holy Spirit all the time, then you're gonna feel like happy and uplifted and uplifting when you're communicating.
SPEAKER_00Section three. This is the one we just went over atonement without sacrifice. In the beginning of that section, we learned that the crucifixion did not establish the atonement. The resurrection did establish the atonement, and that's what we were that that was basically the foundation of the whole section. God doesn't require suffering or blood or punishment or payment of any kind. Sacrifice begins with believing in lack, as if something is missing.
SPEAKER_00So someone has to lose in order for someone else to gain. The ego looks for victims because it believes guilt is real and someone must pay. So that's a common thing. Innocence is strength and not weakness. It has no need to attack, punish, project, or sacrifice. The body is not the cause of experience. The mind chooses the purpose, the mind chooses the purpose that the body would serve, and the body reports that choice.
SPEAKER_00Perception is interpretation. The eyes provide appearances, but the mind decides what those appearances mean. The eyes, the brain, the nervous system, that is what like reports the appearances, but the mind always decides what they mean. Here, healing only occurs on the level of mind. That's where the error is, that's why. So a lot of times we think of healing as healing a body. That's not really healing, that's an effect.
SPEAKER_00Body's always an effect. The error is in the mind. So only true true healing can be correction of the error in the mind. So the central correction is that nothing real has been lost. So no sacrifice is necessary ever to restore our wholeness. And, you know, if you just look at it, uh, I don't know if it's so widespread now, but for a lot of us, when we were growing up, our parents would spank us, and that would be a way that we would supposedly be corrected.
SPEAKER_00And then we learn too that correction happens through punishment, like you got to pay something, you know. But really, correction is revealing that nothing real has been lost. That's the real correction. Wholeness always is. We are still as God created us. There's no sacrifice necessary to restore the wholeness, not even apology. Okay, there's none of that is is necessary, none of it can really restore wholeness.
SPEAKER_00So the progression so far, section one is teaching that that we have to study and understand. Section two is teaching us how the miracle corrects error without judgment. And section three shows us what that correction reveals, which is God's son remains innocent, nothing real has been damaged, and so no one has to suffer sacrifice or pay. Basically, that is sections one through three in a nutshell.
SPEAKER_00And now we're on to section four, paragraph one, sentence one, and here's the text. We have repeatedly stated that the basic concepts referred to through throughout this course are not matters of degree, and then we have a footnote here, footnote forty-eight. And from Principles of Miracles, chapter one, the miracle makes no distinction among degrees in misperception.
SPEAKER_00Okay, so it doesn't matter if it's a small misperception or a large misperception, no distinction from chapter two. But the sonship itself is a perfect creation, and perfection is not a matter of degree. From chapter three, it is worth repeating that ultimately there is no compromise possible between everything and nothing.
SPEAKER_00Another one from chapter two. Any statement which implies degrees of difference in negation is essentially meaningless. So difference in negation, that's negation of the truth. There's no there's no meaningful uh difference in negating the truth. Basically, you either negate the truth or you don't, that you leave the truth as it is. So back to the original sentence here. We have repeatedly stated that the basic concepts referred to throughout this course are not matters of degree.
SPEAKER_00So the quotes in the footnote that I just read are some examples of that. So Jesus is repeating this for a reason. It's very important. He's beginning the section by reminding us that we've heard this before, and we're repeatedly returning to this because the ego is always thinking in degrees. So this is specifically about uh these concepts being not a matter of degree.
SPEAKER_00The ego would ask who is more guilty, who is less innocent, which mistake is harder to forgive, which problem is more difficult to heal? Let's say it's some kind of sickness, a cold or cancer, right? That that was something that we had an example of today. One of our friends uh is experiencing the flu, right? And then another one of our friends, uh first thing, first thing today, uh said, Well, I've got cancer.
SPEAKER_00I'd rather have the flu than cancer. Well, it turned out he went to get the cancer removed, and it turned out that it was just a scab. So he was like, I'm glad, glad I don't. Well, they're all the same. Is what you know, the thing is they're all the same. Uh, flu, cancer, all the same thing. Sickness is a defense against the truth. There's no degrees in this at all. It's not like some one person's more sick than another. And so he comes back from the doctor appointment and now he's feeling good because now he's less sick than the one that has the flu, right?
SPEAKER_00He's like, I beat her, I'm more sick, you know. And really, there's no degrees in it at all. Sickness is just a defense against the truth. And that's the thing about seeing that there are no degrees. Also, it could be which person is more worthy or less worthy. That's also a matter, you know, making it a matter of degree. Okay. So this course is not attempting to ask us to rank error at all. It's teaching us that error has no degrees in reality.
SPEAKER_00So the miracle doesn't measure error at all. There's not no measurement here. The first reference in the footnote says the miracle makes no distinction among degrees of misperception. So it doesn't ask us how serious or convincing or longstanding any error appears to be. It only distinguishes between is it truth or is it a misperception? Sickness is always a misperception. That's not saying you shouldn't take care of the person who's experiencing sickness.
SPEAKER_00Also, you know, take care of how you of how you frame it, you know, do they have cancer or are they experiencing cancer? That makes a whole big difference, you know, just the the way it registers in our mind. Do they have the flu or are they experiencing the flu? Because you're, you know, is it the truth? Is the flu the truth, or is it a misperception, right? So one form of illusion may seem more painful than another, right?
SPEAKER_00But that doesn't mean that they're a different degree. One pattern, you could say one pattern may have been maintained for decades. I've been like this since I was a kid, right? Or maybe a newer pattern. No difference as far as how the miracle works. One mistake could appear to have produced more consequences. That doesn't matter either. The miracle, it has no makes no distinction as to these degrees that the mind gives it.
SPEAKER_00Miracle works equally. This is describing, this is describing the mind's investment in the error when it's saying how many decades I've I've been at this or how painful it is or how much I'm attached to this thing. It doesn't really describe or make the error into anything real. So the miracle doesn't need more power for a larger illusion.
SPEAKER_00We don't need a bigger miracle for cancer than we do for the flu, for instance. We don't need a bigger miracle for war than we do for a minor argument. The miracle, all it does is recognize what is false has not become true. It doesn't matter what the degree is. So perfection itself is not a matter of degree. The second reference says the sonship itself is a perfect creation, and perfection is not a matter of degree.
SPEAKER_00So this is really important in this section called innocent perception because our behavior may express varying degrees of clarity or confusion. Some behavior could be loving, some can be honest or destructive or manipulative or fearful. Whatever it is, our perfection as God created us does not increase or decrease with behavior.
SPEAKER_00That's huge. So we need to distinguish between when someone is created and what or what someone is in creation and what someone is presently expressing in perception. Just it's not like it's not like we spiritually bypass what they're presently expressing in cre in perception, but you're aware that this is a perception rather than what they are in creation.
SPEAKER_00So distinguishing between these two things, it's recognizing that innocence isn't require requiring us to call all the behavior loving. It's not requiring that. And also, it's not requiring us to call it helpful in terms of the illusion. It may not be helpful in terms of the illusion, it's always 100% helpful, though, because of their identity in creation.
SPEAKER_00So whatever it is that they seem to be expressing may not be helpful in an illusion. Like let's say someone rams your car into a telephone pole. You can't say that's really helpful in the illusion. Now you got all these car repairs, maybe your car's total or something like that. In the illusion, that is not helpful. But in reality, it's helpful because it's giving you opportunities to undo the thought of separation. That's what makes it helpful. That's how we're all 100% helpful 100% of the time.
SPEAKER_00We really can't get it wrong. Okay. But it's not like a matter of pretending like it's helpful in the illusion. And also, those are two different levels. Those are two different levels. A lot of the times, what I hear people say is that you know, God is arranging things for their good, as in they got in the God arranged the car accident so that they wouldn't have to experience something worse than that. That's not it at all. God is not arranging a car accident for you.
SPEAKER_00This is an illusion playing out according to what's orchestrated based on how we've been seeing. Okay. It's not because it's saving you from a worse thing or something like that. You can say, okay, in the in a in the illusion, the car accident is not helpful, but everything is helpful because the way I'm interpreting it is giving me an opportunity to see things differently. So we're not looking for uh unhelpful things in the illusion so that we're not we're not needing, we're not specifically needing those things to happen, and they do occur as they are orchestrated for our highest good as well.
SPEAKER_00And you can say God is not doing those things to us, though. They're actually orchestrated out of a mind that's thinking in separation. It's just that it can't go wrong. So we can accurately recognize confusion without concluding that the conclusion has uh the confusion has damaged the Son of God, hasn't done any damage to anyone in reality.
SPEAKER_00Everything and nothing can't be compromised. So the third reference says ultimately there is no compromise possible between everything and nothing. So God and his creation are everything and have everything. The separation is nothing. So the ego tries to make a compromise. The separation may not be ultimately real, but it's real enough here.
SPEAKER_00I may be innocent in truth, but I'm genuinely guilty for this. Innocence may be the truth, but I'm really guilty here, right? Innocence may be their truth, but they're really guilty for doing these things. The thing is, no one's no one's been harmed, nothing's been done, there's no guilt to be projected at all. So it's like God may have created me perfect, but someone harmed me.
SPEAKER_00No one can harm you if God created you perfect. No one can harm you. So these statements allow the ego to remain partially real, but nothing which is separation can't become partly anything. There's no partly about it. There are two levels, and it's not that one level, the level of of illusion, you can say the level that's projecting from the thought of separation where we believe we are.
SPEAKER_00Does not affect the truth at all. But truth can actually affect and does affect the level of perception. So either separation changed God's creation or it didn't change God's creation. A Course in Miracles answer to that is it did not change God's creation. Okay, the next statement about degrees of negation being meaningless.
SPEAKER_00Another reference. This is from A Course in Miracles earlier on, chapter two. Any statement which implies degrees of difference in negation is essentially meaningless. So negation means denial of truth here. The denial may appear mild or it may appear extreme. It could be believed briefly or it could be defended for years. Once I picked up a dude hitchhiking and he told me that he was struggling and he was broke and he was poor ever since he got in a car accident 10 years prior.
SPEAKER_00That that messed him up and made him deficient. And I was like, oh, that's interesting. You know, just like watching how the mind works to make it as if something happened in the past and now I'm still like this. I've heard recently I've heard someone say that they're living with people who have uh who've had their children at when they were young children pass away. Another one car accident, these are coming up right now for some reason.
SPEAKER_00Uh the children died in a car accident way back uh 50 or more years ago. The people are in their 70s now. And the story was that they're alcoholics now because the children passed away all these years ago. See, so this is an example of holding on to something. You're just denying the truth, denying the reality for all these years. It's like I've been harmed, I'm less than, I'm depleted now because I've been through that experience.
SPEAKER_00So the miracle wipes all these things away. It's just a matter of a mind being willing to accept what the miracle's offering. So that's an example of defending a denial of truth, a negation of truth for many decades. So there could be degrees in our awareness, degrees in our willingness, degrees in our investment in illusions, uh, in our readiness to accept correction, but there's no degrees in truth.
SPEAKER_00There's no degrees in innocence, holiness, perfection, God's love. There's no degrees in God's son cannot be harmed. There's no degrees in that. So when we believe we've been harmed, something's been taken away from us. We've, you know, something's been lost, like that example with a couple in their 70s being alcoholics and still lamenting over something that seems to have been lost many years ago. Their children passing away many years ago.
SPEAKER_00You know, you could look at that as like, fuck yeah. Thank you. They realized they didn't need to be projecting illusions. They didn't realize they didn't need to take on the thought of separation that long. They're like, we're out of here. So this section again is called innocent perception. So this sentence that we're on right now, this is sentence one.
SPEAKER_00We have repeatedly stated that the basic concepts referred to throughout this course are not matters of degrees. Okay. So the innocent perception, it's not grading our brothers. This is the foundation here. This particular sentence is the foundation for this entire section, not matters of degrees. So it's not saying this person is mostly innocent or this person has gone too far. Now they've lost their innocence.
SPEAKER_00Now that they've eaten those babies, for instance, they have lost. I'm just taking it to the extreme. I know in our examples in our lives, we see like way less than that and think that they've lost their innocence, right? Now that they intentionally stepped on my toe, right? They didn't just do it on accident. They actually intentionally did it. They've lost their innocence, they've gone too far. This mistake is too serious. And you know what? In fact, Helen Schuschman, you know, I heard that she said that she knew that it was true that she needed to forgive all of these errors, but she said she wasn't gonna do it.
SPEAKER_00Some of these errors are too big. She's not doing it in this lifetime, right? She she knew that what she was she was channeling was awesome and really helpful, but she was like, I'm not doing it. It's for us to do. That's why. It's like saying this mistake is too serious for innocence to remain true. That's what one of my friends was relating to me a couple of weeks ago. She's like, How could you be saying that it's okay that these people are doing this stuff?
SPEAKER_00Like they're starting these fires on purpose. She's talking about one in California and one in Maui starting these fires on purpose. How can you say that they're innocent? I'm like, because they're still as God created them. There, they may be confused. They may be thinking that killing people is uh somehow helping them, but that doesn't change the fact that they're still as God created them, right? And this is really what helps undo the illusion, even in their mind, because it because we're one mind.
SPEAKER_00So it's like when we're willing to see that that's still an innocent mind, that's opening the way for them to see the truth as well. We're doing it for them, we're forgiving for them. So innocent perception sees the difference between confused behavior and changed identity. That's all it is. Look how simple that is. There's confused behavior, and is it changed identity? You just go, no, their identity hasn't changed. They're still the same.
SPEAKER_00No one's changed. The behavior may need to be addressed. I'm not saying that. It may need to be addressed, right? Is it for you to address the behavior? That's between your uh that's between you and the Holy Spirit, right? You ask it, ask the Holy Spirit, like, look at it, Holy Spirit. Are you asking me to address this behavior? I mean, when COVID was going down, shit, the Holy Spirit told me to go out and run around my car and bring pamphlets and let everyone know they didn't really need to wear a mask, right?
SPEAKER_00But still, the way I was doing it, it was not like they're harming me. It's not like they're harming anyone. It's just like, oh, thanks for this opportunity to let people know they don't have to wear a mask. So that's an example of the behavior being addressed, right? And it's and it might be for you, it might be for someone else. Eventually, most likely, the behavior is gonna be addressed one way or another. You just really don't have to burden yourself about it, whether you're called to do it or not. So a boundary may be appropriate, right?
SPEAKER_00Uh, depending on what the situation is and what the Holy Spirit is guiding. Participation may need to end. Your participation in something may need to end, right? Like for me at first, I was wearing a mask just like everyone else. I said two weeks flatten the curve. Remember that? So I've I put the mask on. I'm like, okay, I'll play. Put the mask on. I'm like, you know, going around like that. And then eventually, eventually, it was like, oh no, my participation in this is ending after two months.
SPEAKER_00That was it. I'm like, that one of those things isn't going back on.
unknownRight?
SPEAKER_00But none of that means that anyone's reality has been altered at all. So practically, practically applying this means when an error seems especially serious, because this is where we get hooked. We can ask, has this changed what God created? The answer is always no. And it's uh, but just ask, has this changed what God created? Feel that. Feel that no, feel that answer, right?
SPEAKER_00Am I confusing the strength of my belief that this is real?
unknownRight?
SPEAKER_00Am I being confused making this belief that this that it's real, making that the truth instead of letting the truth be the truth? Am I grading someone's innocence according to their behavior? That's another one. Look how simple it is, though. Look how totally simple it is. It's like no one's changed. Am I allowing nothing to become partly something? The separation is nothing. Are you allowing it to become partly something?
SPEAKER_00The answer here is consistent. What God created remains exactly as He created it, notwithstanding what seems to be going on in an illusory world. So the ego thinks in degrees because degrees are what make judgment possible. It makes it possible for uh for this judgment to be seeming real. And again, you're not really capable of judgment, but it makes judgment possible in your mind.
SPEAKER_00Like to you, judgment appears possible, and then you can't see the truth. It blinds you, it's a blind blind spot. So the miracle doesn't compare any errors with another, it compares all errors with the truth. That's the comparison. Here's error, here's the truth. Does this work? Is this error congruent with the truth? No, no error is congruent with the truth, right?
SPEAKER_00That's how you can see if something's true. So forms of confusion always differ, but innocence and perfection and reality do not change. So simple. Thank you for asking. Thank you for joining. I love you. All right.
SPEAKER_00Chapter three, section four, paragraph one, sentence two, page 117 from the complete annotated edition of A Course in Miracles. Certain fundamental concepts cannot be meaningfully understood in terms of coexisting polarities. All right. This follows from the previous sentence where Jesus just said that the course's basic concepts are not matters of degree.
SPEAKER_00Now he's explaining why the basic concepts are not matters of degree. And the ego is assuming again that opposites can coexist. This is the coexisting polarities that this sentence is talking about. Like they can coexist as two real forces on the same spectrum. That's what a polarity is. You have one thing on one side, one thing on the other side. Okay. So the ego shows it as love on one side, fear on the other side, innocence on one side of the spectrum, guilt on the other side of the spectrum, truth on one side, illusion on the other side.
SPEAKER_00And this is a spectrum, okay? It's like you got a rod, okay? Uh God on one side, the ego on the other side. But from that perspective, we're imagining that we can contain some of each. We think we can be partly innocent or partly guilty. There could be some love and some fear. We think love can be present while fear remains equally valid on the other end of the spectrum. Okay. So we think truth may be ultimately true while illusion is still true enough to be governing our lives.
SPEAKER_00Right. Christ is saying that this framework can't produce a meaningful understanding of this course. So coexisting polarities. A polarity is usually understood as two opposite ends, right? Hot and cold, attraction and repulsion, expansion, contraction. Both ends appear to exist within the same field, and they do for hot and cold. Yes, hot, cold. But that isn't not the same for love and fear. It's not the same. They're not on a spectrum like that.
SPEAKER_00All right. Truth, illusion. They're not on a spectrum like that. Expansion, contraction, that's on the spectrum like that. It's in the illusion, it's within the same framework, right? So both ends appear to exist within the same field and can be measured in relation to another. Like hot and cold. They can be measured in relation to another. But truth and illusion cannot. Okay. The ego tries to apply this same structure, like hot and cold, those measurements to love and fear, innocence and guilt, reality illusion.
SPEAKER_00That's not, they cannot be measured like that because they're not on opposite poles like that. So a Course in Miracles and Christ isn't treating these as two equally real poles. It's not like hot and cold. Truth and illusion is not like that. One is true, and the other is a denial of what is true. They're not on, they're not on a spectrum like that. They're not coexisting polarities. So love and fear aren't equal powers.
SPEAKER_00Like you can say, hot and cold are equal. They're equal powers. One's at one end, one's at the other end of the spectrum. So the ego would look at it like this: like love and fear are like that. Truth and illusion are like that. They're not like that. Fear is not a genuine power that can stand the as the opposite to love, like that. It can't stand like that. Love is all encompassing, right? If love is all-encompassing, then fear cannot exist as a second reality on the other end of a pole if it's all encompassing.
SPEAKER_00Do you guys see that? Fear is what seems to arise when awareness of love is blocked. All right. So it's not on the other end of a pole like that. Same thing with truth and illusion. Truth is reality. Illusion isn't over here on the other end of a pole. So this is why a Course in Miracles can say that fear appears to be the opposite of love, while also saying that love has no out no opposite.
SPEAKER_00Fear can appear to be the opposite of love, but love doesn't have an opposite. Illusion can appear to be the opposite of truth, but truth has no opposite. Fear can be experienced. Sickness, again, can be experienced. That's why I say they're experiencing sickness. It can seem like it's really compelling, it can direct behavior for a long time.
SPEAKER_00But experience doesn't establish reality. So innocence and guilt do not coexist. And this is really important in the section called innocent perception. Right? The ego believes innocent and guilt are two genuine conditions. It judges behavior, it decides how much of each a person possesses. How guilty they are, how innocent they are. Like, for instance, a a little kid, a little baby is considered really innocent compared to someone who's a murderer, right?
SPEAKER_00It's judging behavior, it's deciding how much, how innocent are they, really? And you know, our court system is set up to look like that too, isn't it? You're innocent until proven guilty. Innocence belongs to what God created. No one changes from that. Guilt belongs to a mistaken belief about what God created. It's funny too, in uh in a in a courtroom, when you go for arraignment in a courtroom, if you're you know, you're on trial for any kind of uh criminal activity, it's like, how do you plead?
SPEAKER_00Guilty or not guilty. One of the one of the options is not innocent. I'll take innocent, please. I'm still as God created me. That's right. It's a it's like there's a system set up, and you know, it's asking you to play in that system, and then and it's only giving you these two two choices.
SPEAKER_00You know, one judge came up, she was like, she was like an activist judge, right? She was doing uh she was doing traffic, the traffic court, and she said, before she took the bench, because when she takes the bench, she's supposed to abide by everything that she's supposed to abide by. Before she takes the bench, she tells everyone in the courtroom, I'm gonna come up there and I'm gonna read the charges. And when you come up, uh just say it wasn't me, and I'll dismiss your case. Then she goes and she takes the bench, right? And some people do it, and some people are afraid and they don't.
SPEAKER_00But everyone that she says it wasn't me, she's like, dismissed. Just say it wasn't me. She reads the charges. How do you plead? It wasn't me. Yeah, guilt is just a mistaken belief about who you are, it's a mistaken belief about identity. So a person can believe deeply in guilt without actually becoming guilty.
SPEAKER_00The belief can obscure innocence from our awareness, but it cannot alter the innocence itself. Nothing's gonna alter the innocence. So the mind can hold two thought systems. That's what's going on here. At the level of perception, the mind can appear to hold both. All right, the Holy Spirit's thought system and the ego's thought system. That's what's going on. We've got two thought systems. Basically, we choose between which thought system we want in the moment, which who's our teacher.
SPEAKER_00This does not make both of those thought systems true, though. Only one of them's true. So what's it what seems to coexist here is truth in the mind and then denial of truth and awareness. The divided mind experiences this conflict because it's attempting to give allegiance to two incompatible interpretations. So that's why it that's why there's any conflict, because it's attempting to give allegiance to two of them.
SPEAKER_00Whenever the conflict is occurring in your mind, that's what's going on. Um, and the conflict is as real as any experience. The ego's interpretation is not as real as truth, though. The conflict itself that you're experiencing that feels real, but the interpretation that gives rise to it is not real as truth is real. It doesn't, the the interpretation that gave rise to your conflict, it has no reality at all. That's why the correction happens in the mind where the interpretation is being made.
SPEAKER_00So the ego wants a compromise. The ego speaks in mixed statements. It says, I'm innocent in the in truth, I'm innocent in truth, but I'm guilty here. So that's the mixed statement. It's like here I'm guilty. Okay, I've heard people say stuff like that before a bunch of times. It's like they're justifying their feeling of remorse for some action that they believe they've done in the past. This is what's wiping all of that away for the mind that's willing now.
SPEAKER_00So love is real. It's like the idea that love is real, but fear is justified in this situation. Fear is never justified. You know, I applied that kind of lesson when the murderer was running around here. You know, when I notice a sense of fear of a murder, it's like, wait a minute, fear isn't justified. So it's just like bringing that illusion to the truth and remaining as God created me in my mind. So there's no conflict, there's no suffering in my mind, fear of a murderer coming to get me.
SPEAKER_00It's like I can just be released from that in the moment. So, because the separation never happened, the effects that we perceive about separation cannot be permanent. But the ego would say, okay, you know, in the ego would mix them. All right, fine. The separation never happened. You want to believe that? Fine. But these effects are permanent. They're going to affect this. This is the effect for the rest of your life, for instance. Right?
SPEAKER_00Let's say it's a diagnosis. Okay. It's like, okay, uh, the separation never happened, but this diagnosis, this lasts for the rest of my life. I have I'm going to have to take these pills for the rest of my life, for instance. You know, that's locking it in. And that's and that's conflict in the mind because that doesn't agree with the truth that you're still as God created you. Another one is God created everyone perfect, but this person has become damaged beyond recognition.
SPEAKER_00I mean, new age is always talking about kicking people out. Like people are going to get left behind. Like some of us are going to ascend, and a bunch of people are going to be left behind to be in hell or whatever. You know, that that's one of those kinds of statements. So some of these statements may sound moderate, but they give illusion a portion of reality, which, you know, this is what Christ is talking about that here. There's no degrees in negating the truth. You're either negating the truth, if it's only a little bit, it's total.
SPEAKER_00There's no degrees in this. So we're not asked to balance truth and illusion. It's asking us, we're being asked to distinguish between truth and illusion, not balance them out. So none of this, of course, removes practical discernment. So recognizing that innocent and innocence and guilt can't coexist, they're not coexisting realities, does not mean we're calling every behavior loving in the scheme of things, in the framework of perception.
SPEAKER_00We can still recognize when someone's being dishonest, we can recognize manipulation or in ourselves when we're being manipulative, right? Uh instability, mental instability, avoidance, attack, lack of readiness. We don't have to make any of these behaviors someone's identity, though. We're not asked to deny what's occurring in form. We're asked not to use the form as proof that the truth is changed. Right? That's it, see the difference there.
SPEAKER_00We're not asked to deny what's occurring in form. We're asked to not say that their identity is changed because of it, or our identity is changed. It's really the same. So it's not like you're guilty and I have to reject what you are, but it can mean I recognize the confusion being expressed here and I'm guided not to participate in this form.
unknownRight?
SPEAKER_00It's not like I'm not doing it because I'm not, I'm not hanging out with you, I'm not in that group or whatever it is, I'm not wearing a mask because other people are guilty. It's just that I'm guided not to participate in that form. You could say that's a boundary. So that preserves the distinction between the unchanged innocence of a person and the present usefulness or harmfulness of the interaction.
SPEAKER_00You know, some things are harmful in form, they're not ultimately harmful to the Son of God. They don't harm who you are, they don't harm your identity, they don't harm the ability of the miracle to change everything right now. So, practically speaking, when we're feeling pulled between two apparent truths, we could ask, are Am I treating both sides as if they're equally real? Like truth and illusion?
SPEAKER_00They're not really two sides in the first place. Truth is all-encompassing, innocence is uh all pervading. Am I trying to preserve guilt while affirming innocence at the same time? Am I calling fear valid? Because I'm experiencing fear. No. Uh one one time there was a person who was studying a course in miracles and they think they have diabetes.
SPEAKER_00They're experiencing diabetes. And it's like there's suffering over the diabetes. And a friend goes, Well, you know, the diabetes is not in reality, it's not truly affecting you, but you're making it as if it affects you. And she's like, No, the diabetes is real, you know. So that's one example of making it like I should be upset. I should be bummed out that I have this condition, that it is real. There's just really no cause. It's okay, you could do that.
SPEAKER_00It's not making you, it's it's not making you guilty for doing that, but it's just making you experience upset right now, which need not be. And that's what we're that's what we're learning to see things differently, or we don't need to be upset over anything that's occurring in the field of illusion. And in fact, we're not upset because of it. And that's why I use the word over that thing, because we're actually using that thing to make it seem like we're upset because of it.
SPEAKER_00So we don't recognize that we're really upset because we believe something untrue about ourselves, and that's what's bringing on the dis-ease in the first place, too, and the apparent diagnosis as well. So, am I calling fear valid? That's kind of an example of that too. Am I calling am I calling fear valid because I'm experiencing it? Just because you're experiencing fear does not make it valid. That you can give all the all the reasons why you should be afraid.
SPEAKER_00You know, for instance, I'm afraid of dogs because a dog bit me one time, right? You can bring it all, bring up all the reasons. Still, the fear is not valid. Another question is Am I making someone's behavior into their identity? That seems to be the most often, uh, that seems seems to be plaguing people the most often, too. Is this idea that's because someone has behaved a certain way, now their identity has been affected.
SPEAKER_00There's no way they're worthy of the kingdom of heaven, not after what they've done. Didn't what they've done take that away from them? And that comes up in a lot of subtle ways where you'll just wish something bad, have some ill will toward them. And you know, you're really not capable of having that kind of wish. It's just that it's a projected thought, and you're believing that you want it. You're believing that you want that. You don't really want any bad to come to anyone.
SPEAKER_00So the key insight of this particular hang on a sec, I'm gonna go. I was running around in my book here. Get back to page 117. Okay. So this sentence that we're on, certain fundamental concepts cannot be meaningfully understood in terms of coexisting polarities.
SPEAKER_00You see what that sentence means now? So it's like these fundamental concepts in a course in miracles, you can't understand them if you're thinking of them as coexisting polarities, as in truth and illusion, love and fear, uh, innocence and guilt. These are not coexisting as polarities. That's the fundamental uh about the that's a statement about the fundamental concepts. And that's the key insight of this particular sentence.
SPEAKER_00It's that love is real, fear is the denial of love, innocence is real, guilt is a mistaken belief about innocence. So it's not like innocence on one side, guilt on the other. It's more like innocence is the circle encompassing everything, and guilt is a mistaken belief superimposed on it, darkening that circle like that. It's kind of like clouds, though, it can just be wiped away, and innocence is always there.
SPEAKER_00Same, same deal with truth and illusion, love and fear. So healing doesn't come from reconciling the two, they cannot be reconciled. It comes from recognizing which one is true, which one's actually true. So if you have any questions about that, now's the time. I'm between sentences. There's right, there's no, yes. Basically, Christine asked that just so this just means in simplest terms, there's no opposite, right?
SPEAKER_00They're not on polarities like that. So you think of think of the truth or innocence or love more like a circle encompassing everything, not like hot and cold, which are on not a line, right? Not a line, exactly. All right, sentence three. It is impossible to conceive of light and darkness or everything and nothing as joint possibilities.
SPEAKER_00So now Christ is giving us two clear examples light and darkness, everything is and nothing. It's impossible to conceive of them as joint possibilities. So the previous sentence, we were talking about coexisting polarities. Same kind of thing. These are not coexisting polarities, light and darkness, everything and nothing. They're not joint possibilities. So he's showing us why the ideas don't work, don't work. These two pairs. These pairs are revealing that one side has presence while the other is only a pair is only uh the apparent absence or denial of that presence.
SPEAKER_00Look at light and darkness, everything and nothing. We'll look at it a little bit closer. So light and darkness, they're not equal substances. Light has presence. Darkness does not have a substance of an of its own, it doesn't creep into the light. Darkness can't, for instance, darkness can't come into the room and drive light away, can it? But look at the opposite of that. It can't, the darkness can't resist the light. Darkness can't re negotiate with the light.
SPEAKER_00Like, no, it's too dark over here. You can't come in. As soon as light is introduced, darkness is automatically gone, it disappears. So you notice that. That's why Christ is using this example. Okay. So light is a is a really useful symbol for truth. It's just like that. Truth doesn't need to defeat the error, just like light doesn't need to defeat darkness. Truth reveals that the error never had any substance.
SPEAKER_00Same thing with light and darkness. Darkness is absence of light. Error is absence of truth. So fear is just like darkness. Fear appears to stand at the opposite of love, but it really functions just like darkness. It's not a second power. Like darkness isn't a second power. And you know, even the yin-yang symbol, that makes no sense. Look at it, it's got one side dark and one side light. That wouldn't work. The light's just making the dark light, unless you got a divider in there that the light can't reach it somehow.
SPEAKER_00But if they're just chilling there together, that's not happening. Look at it. Makes no sense. But this is the way things are thought about. It's as if these two things, these two powers are coexisting, and like darkness is a power. So this is saying like fear is a power, like illusion is a power. So the second power, apparent power, is what seems to arise when love is blocked from awareness.
SPEAKER_00The only way you can keep something dark from the light, you have to have a partition there of some sort that's opaque. The light can't get through. Right? And that's what we're doing. Kind of like turning our back on the truth. So we see shadows, we see a world of shadows. So the mind may experience both love and fear, but that doesn't mean both are true. It means love remains present while awareness is being obscured. So it's the obscuring that's the thing.
SPEAKER_00Then the obscuring may seem like it's mild, or it may seem like it's severe. You might just have, you might just be making some shadows, or you might have it totally blocked. But the light itself, the light is still the light. It didn't change anything about the light. Okay, and then the next one, the next example Christ gives here is everything and nothing. Everything and nothing are even more absolute than light and darkness. If God and his creation are everything and nothing can't exist beside them as another possibility, nothing can't even occupy any portion of everything.
SPEAKER_00It can't challenge everything, it can't injure everything, it's everything and nothing. They don't coexist. The moment we treat nothing as an actual option, the separation is nothing. That's separation. We've secretly turned it into something. That's what the ego does with separation. It gives nothing. Okay, examples of nothing that the ego gives. Form, history, consequences, emotional weight, and apparent permanence.
SPEAKER_00Apparent permanence is a huge one. It's like this is the way it is. That's just the way it is. And one of my friends was saying, um, everyone must earn their keep in this world. That's just the way it is. There's the permanence. See, there's the permanence coming in. There's no opening in that statement. What if it's different? What if there's something different? But belief like this that doesn't make nothing real.
SPEAKER_00And the separation can't be partly true. It's not even partly true. So the ego wants to preserve this middle position. The separation may be ultimately unreal, but it's real here. It's the separation is real here. My innocence may be may remain in spirit, but here I'm truly damaged. I've truly been harmed. There's no coming back from this.
SPEAKER_00God may be everything, but fear still has power in this situation. So it's giving fear no power. There's absolutely no power in any situation. There's no call for being afraid. There's no justification to be afraid. So this is the kind of compromise being that's being undone right here. If separation is nothing, then it can't become partly something.
SPEAKER_00If innocence is still intact, then guilt can't be partly true. Partly true for you, partly true for anyone. If God is everything, then there's no rival power that's sharing reality with God. But the ego depends on joint possibilities. Conflict always requires two sides that are seemingly real sides. So the ego wants us to believe in love and fear, wants us to believe in innocence and guilt.
SPEAKER_00God and the ego. That's another thing. It's like as if the ego is the opposite of God, an equal opposite. You know, it's definitely experienced as an opposite, but God doesn't have an opposite. Okay. These are not joint possibilities. Truth and illusion are not joint possibilities. And once both sides are granted reality in our mind, then our mind has to believe it has to defend one against the other.
SPEAKER_00That's why everyone's trying to uh overcome the ego, kill the ego, get rid of the ego. And it's like it's just like that's the ego's darkness, and God is light. The ego can't withstand God, there's nothing to fight. Hey, that rhymed. Maybe I'm gonna be a poetry night. So to the ego, love has to defeat fear. You know the saying, love wins, and it's like it doesn't need to win.
SPEAKER_00And it's never been, you know, it can't lose in the first place. And what is it gonna win over? Right? It just is. To the ego, innocence has to overcome guilt somehow. And you know, look at how impossible that is from in the ego's framework, too. So it must the ego must make God into something that's conquering the ego. That's what that's what the ego does. It wants to make God into something that has to conquer the ego because as long as there's a war going on, the war continues.
SPEAKER_00The ego actually survives from that notion, you know, the the the ultimate battle between God and and the devil. You know, you got Jesus over there in his robe with his sandals on, and the devil's like this big buff red dude, and they go into a ring together and they duke it out. Saw it on South Park. So, so this is what gives darkness the reality, the reality darkness needs to survive in our mind.
SPEAKER_00It's like there's a war between good and evil. Healing is never a battle, though. Healing is not like light attacking the darkness. That's not what it does. You see that? That's a really good symbol. It's light revealing that darkness didn't have any substance in the first place. So the miracle, this is a course in miracles. The miracle doesn't fight with the ego at all. It just brings the ego's interpretation into the light and lets the ego's interpretation be seen as false.
SPEAKER_00What I thought happened didn't happen. Right? And that's the separation. The separation didn't happen. That's why these apparent things that are occurring in form, they are occurring in form, they are happening in the perceived world. It's just that they have no effect, they have zero effect. So fighting against these effects assumes that there's a real enemy, there's something to overcome.
SPEAKER_00The miracle recognized nothing needs to be opposed. You know, nothing nothing's going on. You know, I had a friend once say, uh, once say, uh, I don't like it when you say that stuff about my behavior. And I'm like, why not? And he goes, Well, it means this. And I go, I'm not seeing it as problematic at all. I don't see it as problematic. I don't see your your behavior as being pro problematic.
SPEAKER_00It just is what it is. This is the form, this is the form of it. It's not a problem. So guilt and innocence can't be joint possibilities. If guilt is real, innocence would have to be altered. So it's like if guilt is real, uh, if guilt is real, then it means that what God created has changed. Right. And what God created cannot be changed.
SPEAKER_00So the experience of guilt can be intense. Like let's say you experience yourself doing something and you're like, you you feel like, man, I hate that I did this. It seems like it was really harmful. It seemed to have consequences and everything else. And the behavior arising from guilt may be harmful in terms of form. You know, maybe you were, uh let's say an example, maybe you were just like pissed at your husband or something, and then you drove away really fast and you ran over a dog that you didn't see or a kid that you didn't see.
SPEAKER_00You know, like that's let's just look at it as something, you know, that that would really uh uh give you this sense like, wow, I'm guilty. I've done something wrong. And look at the consequences. I killed a kid, for instance, uh, because I was thinking insanely, right? It just never proves that your innocence has been destroyed. It just doesn't, it doesn't do that. It still, no matter how extreme the consequences may appear. It's still a forgiveness opportunity. It doesn't change the fact.
SPEAKER_00Yes, you were in you were in a you're in a confused, fearful, angry state of mind. And that made you behave erratically. You drove out without looking. And then someone died. And that was the consequence in form. See? Still you remain as God created you. It's still uh it's it's still an opening for the miracle, and there's no degrees. You know, whether you killed a dog on your way out or you killed a kid on their your way out, you know, to the ego, looking at it, be like those are definitely degrees, right?
SPEAKER_00But what this is showing us is that there are no degrees in in the truth. Innocence is innocence, it does not get altered by behavior in any form. Now, this doesn't mean we're ignoring form. You know, this is that how this, this is how this course, a course in miracles, gets taken as if it's something that's against humanity, against people, gets taken like this, saying, well, we should just go around killing everyone then, since it just doesn't really matter, and we can use it for forgiveness opportunities.
SPEAKER_00That is not what we're saying here. Okay, we can respond clearly to what appears in the world. We can name dishonesty, we can refuse manipulation, right? We can leave an unsafe interaction, we can use safety protocols, we can stop offering access in certain situations. We have boundaries, we can allow consequences to be consequences, to be natural consequences. It's without deciding that darkness has become real in someone, right?
SPEAKER_00So it's not like saying everyone should be let out of prisons on earth, right? It's not saying that. It's like as long as we seem to need them, then they're gonna be here. Uh, as we're recognizing more and more that innocence is really the only truth, those kinds of things will fall away on their own. So a boundary can say, I won't, I won't participate in this form. Well, the mind is clear. Well, the mind is clear uh that this form isn't changing what anyone is, you know.
SPEAKER_00Uh, like for instance, it's like my daughter has been asking me, not not recently, but some years before, she's asked me, like, why don't you hang out with us while we're doing cocaine? And I'm like, I'm not interested in participating in that. And it's like, it's not as if you guys are guilty or you guys are doing anything wrong. I'm just not interested in participating in that. Right? So, so the ego would take it as, well, if nothing is wrong, then you should just participate in everything.
SPEAKER_00And we could just go around harming people all day long. That's not what we want to do. That's not that's not something that uh makes our heart happy. So when something appears to be powerful or threatening, we can ask, am I treating darkness as though it has a substance of its own? When something appears to be threatening, nothing's threatening. Am I treating nothing as though it has become something?
SPEAKER_00Like, oh no, I'm really guilty now. Am I grant and I'm am I granting guilt a place right next to innocence? Are they like am I giving them equal validity? Am I fighting with an illusion, trying to make myself better is another one, self-improvement, or am I bringing it to the light? Am I really bringing it to the light? So this sentence, see where we are here. Sentence three, it is impossible to conceive of light and darkness, or everything and nothing, as joint possibilities.
SPEAKER_00So in this sentence, light and darkness are not joint possibilities because darkness is only the absence of light. And everything and nothing are not joint possibilities because nothing doesn't have any existence. So, in the same way, love and fear are not equal realities, neither are innocent and innocence and guilt equal truths. God and the ego are not competing powers. The miracle doesn't make truth victorious.
SPEAKER_00We used to say getting the victory over the devil when I was uh when I was I was raised in a Christian cult, being getting the victory over the dev over the devil, but the miracle doesn't make the truth victorious, it reveals that the truth never never even had an opponent in the first place. And that is sentence three. Yay! Thank you for joining.
SPEAKER_00We're on to sentence four, page 117. They are all true or all false. So this sentence is bringing the whole thing together. Christ has told us the course's fundamental concepts are not matters of degree. Also, they can they, the concepts, can't be understood as coexisting polarities, and that light and darkness are everything and nothing, can't be real possibilities.
SPEAKER_00Now he's making the conclusion, they are all true or all false. And this is the last sentence of this paragraph. Of course, in miracles, fundamental ideas form one complete thought system, they stand or they fall together. The truth side concepts belong together. If God is all encompassing, then separation is not real.
SPEAKER_00If the sonship is perfectly created, which we saw earlier, it was a quote from one of the footnotes that's from an earlier section. If the sonship is perfectly created, then innocence cannot truly be lost. If love is all that's real, feel fear can't be a second power to it. If everything is real, nothing isn't existing beside it. So the truth side concepts are supporting one another.
SPEAKER_00God is everything, love is all-encompassing, creation remains perfect, the sun is innocent, separation has not occurred, nothing real has been threatened. So these are not separate spiritual ideas that we can accept selectively. This one complete thought system, and that's why he's saying they are all true or all false. That's the fundamental basic concepts, what he's talking about in sentence one.
SPEAKER_00They're all true or they're all false. They're not separate ideas. You can just take one, okay. The son is innocent, but the separation has occurred, or the opposite of that. Okay, the separation hasn't occurred, but not everyone is innocent, right? When you do that, the whole thing falls. These are just different expressions of one truth. The basic principles are different expressions of one truth. So the ego's thought system also hangs together.
SPEAKER_00The ego's ideas depend on one another. Separation is real, innocence has been lost, guilt is justified, attack has occurred, they've attacked me. That's that's one of them. That's one of the ego's concepts. Harm is real. Fear and defense are necessary. Punishment can restore order. Those are all ego thoughts. Once one of those premises is made true, the others follow. See, they're they're both complete thought systems and they're side by side in your mind.
SPEAKER_00It's kind of like side by side. You choose in the moment between one or the other. So if separation is real, then guilt totally makes sense. And if guilt is real, then punishment is justified. We've been over this in this in this previous section. We're on section four now. If attack can really harm, then fear and defense seem necessary. Right? So you can recognize when there is an appearance of attack, but also recognize it can't truly harm.
SPEAKER_00It can't truly harm. That's why I was sharing with my friends. You know, they were like, they the like as in the powers that be are doing this to us. And I'm almost like, good thing they're 100% ineffective. They're like, what? I go, the only way they can even seem effective is if you're afraid. And and you know, there's probably like four or five people, they're just kind of like, huh. Kind of like, I like that. You know, I see a light bulb go on. It's like, oh, yeah, the good thing they're ineffective.
SPEAKER_00If innocence can be lost, then judgment becomes necessary to determine who still deserves judgment. Sorry, that's our court system, really. Again, I'm not saying it should go away, it's a mirror. It's really a mirror. Nothing should change about the perception. It's mirroring the mind, it's doing it perfectly. So the reason we can't mix the two systems is because the div the divided mind is trying to combine them.
SPEAKER_00The separation never happened, but I'm guilty, right? These two systems. God created me perfect, but another person has damaged me. How could they do this to someone like me? So innocent. They ruined my innocence, they took my innocence. Only love is real, but fear is justified, right here. In this situation, fear is justified. Innocence cannot be lost, but this person is genuinely sinful. Okay, so we can't be mixing the two systems because these statements may feel reasonable, but they preserve a spiritual truth while also making room for the ego's interpretation.
SPEAKER_00They are not internally consistent, they're they're they're not, they're not internally consistent. Okay, so if the separation didn't did not happen, then guilt cannot be true. Those that's that's the consistent application. If the separation didn't happen, then you can't have any guilt. If God's creation is perfect, then it can't be damaged by anyone. The innocence can't be taken away by anyone.
SPEAKER_00If love is real, then fear cannot possess an independent justification. It just cannot have a justification. Yeah, but I'm afraid of the IRS, for instance. There's the IRS, they can do this to me. You know, when you look at that, it has no justification. It's like not even that is fearful, not even death is fearful. Notice death and taxes, people say those are the those are those are the for sure, right? Apparently, according to the ego's world, those are the for sure, death and taxes.
SPEAKER_00So if innocence can't be lost, then behavior can't transform the innocent into a sinner. There's no way it can be transforming. The ego wants a compromise, though. The ego doesn't need us to reject a course in miracles entirely, right? Just to a degree. Just to a degree. Just to think it's mostly true, but not all the way true. It only needs us to make one exception. It only needs us to make one, the ego only needs one exception to these fundamental principles, the fundamental concepts, just make one exception to say, yes, innocence is true in general, but not here.
SPEAKER_00Yes, fear is unreal, but this is different. There's a different situation here. I really have diabetes, for instance. Yes, nothing real can be threatened, but what happens, what happened to me, that was real harm. They cut my leg off, for instance. That person cut my leg off. Now I'm walking on one leg. That's real harm, right? And that's look at how believable it is. Look at how believable that scenario is. They took something from me, they ran over my child and killed my child, for instance.
SPEAKER_00The ego's got proof, all kinds of proof in the world. So each of these are an exception that allowed the allows the ego's whole thought system to enter. That tiny mad idea. Any exception, any one exception, allows the whole thought system to enter. The ego survives by presenting compromise as wisdom. Now look at it. When we're looking at the previous sentences, they're not existing as polarities.
SPEAKER_00So it's a block to reality. It's like the fear is a block to love. And you know, it's just like if you have one blot on it, it's like that whole thought system of fear enters your mind. Because the truth is always always behind that. It's like the truth is the truth, but it's like you're allowing a shadow in to superimpose over what's true, and then that collapses the whole thought system of the truth for you in your mind, even though it remains always true.
SPEAKER_00So you allow one little, that's why, that's why uh A Course in Miracles puts it as a tiny mad idea. You're allowing the whole thought system of the ego in when you allow one exception to the basic principles. That's what's being taught here. The Holy Spirit teaches that truth admits no exceptions, all true or all false. Doesn't mean every thought is equal. It's not like that. They are all true or all false, is what Jesus says here.
SPEAKER_00So he's talking about the basic concepts. That's what he's referring to. They're all true or they're all false. He's not saying every perception we hold is true or every worldly statement is false. He's referring to the fundamental premises. Either God is everything, creation remains perfect, innocence is intact, separation never happened, or the opposite is true. We can't meaningfully affirm both of these.
SPEAKER_00So again, this is the innocent perception, and the innocent perception accepts the whole truth. It doesn't say they're innocent in spirit, but guilty enough to lose my love, for instance. No one is no one needs to lose your love. It recognized behavior may can recognize behavior may be confused, right? The interaction may be uh maybe blocking the peace of God, you know, by interacting this way.
SPEAKER_00The form may need correction, but the person remains innocent in truth. Form may need changing. So innocent perception again doesn't mix identity with behavior. That's really important. It doesn't make the form into proof that creation changed. So when any grievance in our heart feels justified, we can simply ask, which thought system am I making true?
SPEAKER_00Which complete thought system am I making true? Because in the moment, you're either making one thought system true or the other. You're not mixing the two. It may seem like you're mixing the true the the two, but when you introduce any bit of the ego's thought system, you're blocking the thought system of the truth and not accepting that at all. You're just it's either all all it's all or nothing. Okay, they're all true or all false in your mind.
SPEAKER_00Am I affirming innocence while keeping a guilty exception? Am I saying the separation is unreal while treating its effects as as if they're permanent? Am I trying to keep the Holy Spirit's conclusion and the ego's premise at the same time? So the fundamental ideas, fundamental ideas are one unified thought system. If God's creation remains perfect, then guilt, sin, and separation are false.
SPEAKER_00If separation is real, then the ego's entire system follows. That's what's going on here. The entire system of the ego is follow is following when we make one exception. And you know, if you if you look into uh different uh you could say spiritual traditions or something like that, it'll say the only your peace is going to be disturbed if you just have one tiny belief that's not true in your mind. It just takes one tiny belief to disturb your peace, similar to that.
SPEAKER_00The mind can't mix these systems without conflict. Healing begins when we stop asking the truth to try to share reality with illusions. Okay, and then I got a question here. This is a really good question, too. I'll get to it in a second. I'm just looking. Uh let's see, zoom. Okay. Uh, aloha, sweeties.
SPEAKER_00Okay. How can boundaries be appropriate without compromising between truth and illusion? So after hearing truth and illusion can't be mixed, as someone might reasonably ask this: would setting a boundary make the other person's behavior real? If everyone is innocent, why would distance or refusal ever be necessary? Wouldn't a boundary be a compromise between innocence and guilt? So the answer really depends on the purpose of the boundary.
SPEAKER_00What the compromise, what the compromise would be, a compromise would sound like you are innocent in truth, but guilty enough that I must protect myself from what you are. I must protect myself from you. So that statement attempts to hold both systems at once. And you know, that's not that that's not really what's meant by a boundary, anyways. It's saying that's really an accusation, that's a judgment being made. Okay, it's saying innocence is true metaphysically, but guilt has enough reality to define this person as as becoming a fearful person, right?
SPEAKER_00So, what a clearer boundary of a clear boundary would say, a Holy Spirit guided boundary would say, your reality is innocent, and I'm not guided to participate in this form. Okay. That's not compromising innocence at all. It's refusing to make uh make this confusion as if it's useful. Okay. It's not useful to uh participate, it's not useful for me to participate in this confusion. A person's identity is still the same, it's not changed at all.
SPEAKER_00You know, keeping the person's identity intact all the time. The form is simply being discerned. The form can be discerned, keeping the person's identity intact. So, a Course in Miracles is just uncompromising about content, but it is not rigid about form. The content remains. No one has changed what God created, guilt is not real, attack has not altered anyone's apparent attack, hasn't altered anyone's innocence, and fear is not a second power to love.
SPEAKER_00But forms within the dream are not all equally useful. The Holy Spirit may use closeness, distance, speech, silence, staying, leaving, practical protection, refusal, any of those things can be used. The form changes according to whatever serves healing. Whatever serves healing. The content is always the same. Non-condemnation. But non-condemnation does not mean unlimited access.
SPEAKER_00So innocent perception doesn't require to make ourselves available for every behavior. It also doesn't require us to deny what's occurring in form. So we can recognize all those things that are occurring in form, aggression, inconsistency, whatever, without making those behaviors into someone's identity. That's the content. There's the form and there's the content. There's the behavior and the identity. We can say, I recognize this is happening, but I'm not going to participate in it, without saying this behavior has made you guilty and you're dangerous.
SPEAKER_00Right. So a boundary can actually serve correction rather than defensiveness. So refusing to participate can sometimes be more loving than remaining involved. You know, if you're listening to the Holy Spirit, it may be that refusal may come up. But if you're dogmatic on concepts, you might be like, I can't do the refusal because that would be uh the wrong demonstration. See? So staying may actually, you know, staying in this in a situation or allowing something to continue may actually reinforce dependency, manipulation, specialness, guilt, fear.
SPEAKER_00So being open to whatever the form may be, let the form be guided as the form may be. A boundary can actually interrupt a pattern that neither person is actually being helped by. All right. It can refuse to use a relationship to support the ego's purpose. So a key distinction, ego boundary says, you're a problem and I have to keep you away to be safe.
SPEAKER_00All right. Holy Spirit boundary looks like I will not use this relationship to reinforce fear, guilt, dependency, or attack. I'm just gonna remain loving. And and the form may look similar. It's just the inner purpose is different, it's completely different. So is a boundary still based on perception? There's another question. Yes, it is. Bodies, communication, distance, relationships, and behavior, they're all belonging to perception.
SPEAKER_00But the Holy Spirit uses perception to lead beyond perception. He doesn't ask us to pretend like we're already beyond all these practical distinctions while we still experience ourselves in the world. All right. So there's no compromise between everything and nothing. No compromise means that we don't grant illusion any truth. It doesn't mean we must cooperate, though, with every form the illusion takes.
SPEAKER_00Right? We can refuse a role. You know, many times I've found myself, like in my marriage too, in a role ongoing for many years. And then with without condemning my husband, just say, I'm not doing that anymore. I'm not, I I know, I know I've been I've been showing you that I'm in this role for many years, many years, and many years, but I'm not doing that role anymore. And it's not because you're bad, it's not because you're guilty or anything like that. It's just that I don't, I'm not guided to be in that role anymore.
SPEAKER_00What a boundary actually is. It's not a mandate that another person has to obey, right? It's not, it's not really you gotta stop doing this. It's more like if this occurs, here's what I'm gonna do. A boundary describes our own course of action. You know, for example, uh, and this came from from Constance. Constance gave this to me from Facebook. It actually came from an attorney. It was great. Uh, for example, you can't speak to me that way. That's not a real boundary, okay?
SPEAKER_00That's an attempt to control a person. All right. A real boundary would be like if if you speak with me that way, I'm gonna be ending the conversation. That's a boundary, okay? The other person remains free to choose their behavior, right? For myself, I don't even need to speak that way. That's good because it just doesn't really, you know, it just doesn't do it, doesn't work for me. And it may be at a time that I needed to use a boundary that way. But at this point in time, when it seems like someone's speaking to me in any kind of way, I'm just thanking them.
SPEAKER_00Thank you. And on Facebook, it's thank you and block button. Right? It's just it's like if you if you speak to actually, you know what? Actually, that that does come in on a Facebook one. I noticed uh a couple months ago, maybe. I said, I said, yeah, I'm not really interested in relating like that. And if you're gonna continue to relate with me like that, just to let you know, I use the block button, just to let you know if you don't see me anymore. That's what happened.
SPEAKER_00So the other the other person in this, the other person is remaining free. They can have their behavior. You're not telling them don't do this or you should do it this way or something like that. It's like, if this occurs, then this is what this is what my course of action is. And so everyone's free to have their course of participation, however, they however they choose their participation. Apparent, that's still an apparent choice because we really only choose between love and fear. So before setting any boundary, we can ask, am I trying to control a person?
SPEAKER_00Am I making them responsible for giving me peace? Am I trying to punish a person? Or am I really refusing to reinforce a form that doesn't serve healing? Right? Can I say no to behavior without making anyone guilty? So the insight, the key insight here about boundaries and these questions about boundaries that have been coming up. A boundary doesn't compromise innocence when it refuses only the form while keeping the truth about everyone unchanged.
SPEAKER_00And it doesn't try to control anyone's behavior. The Holy Spirit isn't asking us to call every form useful in the, you know, in the in the field. Everything's useful uh for to us, for us. It's all useful. That doesn't mean we have to continue with a particular form. It's useful as it is in this present moment. It's not a mandate that you continue doing that form. Like it was useful at one point for me to wear a mask and then it wasn't.
SPEAKER_00Okay. Christ is always asking us to discern the form without using it to deny the Son of God. All right. We did a whole paragraph in less than two hours, you guys. It's something's something's shifting. I don't know. No, the paragraphs are just always different. Yeah, we still have another paragraph to get into. We're not we're not shutting down early or anything.
SPEAKER_00We still have another paragraph to get into. Paragraph two. Sentence that was only four sentences, anyways, in that paragraph. All right, so calm down. I'm talking to myself, of course. All right, we're still on page 117. We'll be here for a while, I'm guessing. Wait, is this 117? What is going on here? Saying something else.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's 117. I don't know why. My eyeball is going somewhere else. That's what happened. All right. Page 117, paragraph two in the section called innocent perception. It is absolutely essential that you understand completely that behavior is erratic until a firm commitment to one or the other is made. What is this one or the other? These two thought systems.
SPEAKER_00It is actually absolutely, this is strong language here in sentence one. It is absolutely essential that you understand completely that behavior is erratic until a firm commitment to one or the other is made. Why is he emphasizing this so strongly? He's not saying it's like helpful to understand. He's saying it's absolutely essential. And then he says, understand completely. Okay? That means we cannot understand behavior clearly unless we understand the divided mind behind it.
SPEAKER_00Behaviors appear inconsistent because the mind is still shifting between two thought systems, it's shifting between the Holy Spirit and ego. You know, you can't have both of them together, but you're shifting between the two. In the moment, it's one or the other. You're always shifting between the two until your mind is stabilized. Love and fear, truth and illusion, everything and nothing, right? Until the mind becomes firmly committed to one teacher, behavior will reflect whichever teacher is being chosen in that moment.
SPEAKER_00That's what makes behavior erratic. So a person can be warm and open in one moment and then distant and defended in the next moment. Loving one day, avoidant the next day. Peaceful in one conversation and then reactive in another situation. That's because, you know, the behavior, this is an example, some examples of the behavior being erratic because the mind hasn't become firmly committed to one teacher.
SPEAKER_00So this doesn't mean there are two true selves. It means the mind is alternating between two incompatible purposes, two incompatible teachers. So the behavior changes because the purpose changes. So the same form can serve different purposes. We can't judge behavior by form alone. Okay, for example, silence can come from peace or punishment. Leaving can come from guidance or fear.
SPEAKER_00You can't be judging the form, see? Staying can come from love or can come from dependency. Giving can come from generosity or it can come from the desire to be needed. See how the form might look the same. Setting a boundary can come from clarity or it can come from condemning a person. So the outer form can look the same or it could look similar. The inner purpose can be completely different.
SPEAKER_00So this is why a Course in Miracles in Christ is continually asking us to look beneath behavior to the teacher and the purpose directing it. It's not about the behavior, it's about the teacher and purpose and purpose directing the behavior. So knowing the course is not the same as committing to the Holy Spirit, knowing the Course. And now, this is what you see in a Course in Miracles groups. People know the Course as in know what it's saying in a Course in Miracles.
SPEAKER_00And that's not the same as being committed to the Holy Spirit. You can intellectually agree with a Course in Miracles and still behave erratically. So you can say everyone is innocent and then condemn someone whenever we feel hurt. That's an example of being erratic. So we might say there's nothing to fear and then try to control a relationship to feel safe. Try to control another person's behavior, let's say. We could say, I want peace, and then protect a grievance which keeps the peace away.
SPEAKER_00So this is an example of the erratic behavior. The issue isn't whether we understand these ideas, it's whether we're committed to following them when our emotions are activated. That's the thing. Our emotions get activated, and then it shows where our commitment really is. So what a firm commitment means, and this is not to guilt you at all. You know, you're just recognizing this is giving you another opportunity to see when you're noticing, oh, my commitment isn't that solid when I'm activated in this way, when my emotions are activated in this way, when this kind of thing comes up, then my commitment.
SPEAKER_00And then I'm like, no. You know, for instance, I get a diagnosis, and then my I see that my commitment isn't so strong anymore. So a firm commitment to the Holy Spirit doesn't mean that all of your outward decisions are going to look the same. It's not like that. We're not trying to uh manage the perception. It doesn't mean we always stay, it doesn't mean we always leave, it doesn't mean we always speak, and it doesn't mean we're always silent. It means form is given one purpose healing.
SPEAKER_00And that that purpose includes healing, joining, releasing from guilt, correction of perception. Form is just given this purpose all the time, restoring peace. That's the purpose the form is giving is given when your mind is fully committed. The form can vary, but the purpose remains totally consistent. So back to boundaries, because this is a question coming up right now. A boundary can become erratic when it's used reactively.
SPEAKER_00For example, access is withdrawn to punish someone. They don't deserve access to me. Watch when that thought comes up in the mind. They haven't been fair, so they don't deserve. Uh distance is created to provoke pursuit. You want them to act differently. So you so you give them you give them something to make them act differently. Silence can be used to make someone feel guilty, given the cold shoulder, right?
SPEAKER_00The boundary changes whenever reassurance will reassure you, and then the boundary changes, right? The boundary changes whenever reassurance is offered. Closeness re-resumes after one warm moment. Okay, you're giving me what you want now. Now the closement, what I want now, and now the closeness comes back, even though the larger pattern isn't changed. So this is just using it, using the word boundary as really manipulation. It's really manipulation.
SPEAKER_00So the purpose behind it, the purpose, and this is what people are dealing with too, when people are saying, you know, these people are people are using boundaries so much now. They didn't used to before, but they're using it so much, and they're using them uh to make people wrong all the time. And, you know, that's because the commitment to the one teacher hasn't become stable. So that it's going to affect boundaries as well as anything else. So uh a Holy Spirit guided boundary is not based on emotional fluctuation, it expresses a clear distinction about what we will and will not participate in.
SPEAKER_00So a relational example. Suppose someone offers an hour of deep connection and then returns to inconsistency. The ego may swing between this proves everything is changed, and this proves I mean nothing. The Holy Spirit doesn't require these interpretations at all. The Holy Spirit just shows the conversation, the conversation was meaningful and the larger pattern remains unchanged. So it's like, it's not like you, okay, they gave me what I want, and so now I'm going, you know, that's manipulation.
SPEAKER_00That's using manipulation. Uh that's what people are reacting to when they're saying, you know, people shouldn't be using boundaries because it's it's harming, it's harmful. And that's because they're listening to the ego as a teacher using the same word, maybe even the same form, but using it to punish. So it's always the purpose behind it. So practically, when our behavior feels inconsistent, when we're noticing our behavior is inconsistent, like sometimes we're we're loving and sometimes we're not, sometimes we're punishing.
SPEAKER_00It's like which thought system is giving rise to this behavior? My behavior, not another person's behavior. Look at yourself, right? Look at yourself. That's what you want to see. Which thought system is giving rise to this inconsistent behavior in myself? Am I acting out of out of clarity or am I reacting out of fear or a need to punish? See? Has my decision changed because the form changed, or because guidance genuinely changed? Notice when you're being manipulative.
SPEAKER_00That's when you're listening to the ego. You're listening to the teacher that wants to kill you. All right. Am I using this action, this boundary, let's say, to heal, or is it to control someone, or is it to control an outcome? So erratic behavior comes from this divided allegiance. The mind shifts between two teachers, so behavior shifts along with it. Our consistency, consistent behavior, doesn't come from rigid rules about how we should behave.
SPEAKER_00It actually comes from a stable commitment to the purpose, to one purpose and one teacher. We're gonna get into that a little bit more in sentence two. I'm gonna see if I have any questions or anything right now. And it looks like we're gonna be able to cover sentence two as well today. Friend said, I just blocked a neighbor yesterday. So this is helpful. All right, good. And look at the purpose behind blocking a neighbor. You know, it's like notice, notice the Holy Spirit uh uh guides from what is the most peaceful, what is the most joyful, not what is punishing, what they deserve, or anything like that.
SPEAKER_00The ego looks at it like that. They deserve that because of their behavior. The Holy Spirit looks at it is what is helpful for undoing the mind. And many times something like blocking or uh um or leaving or anything like that is helpful. Many times it is. It's just a matter of listening. Where is what's what purpose are you using? That's what that's what's to be aware of. Thank you for that, Starsha. All righty, everyone looks good on Zoom.
SPEAKER_00We are doing the next sentence. Sentence two, paragraph two, sentence two of section four, which we just began, and it's called innocent perception. All right, next sentence. Yet a firm commitment to darkness or nothingness is impossible. Thank goodness for that. Because in the previous sentence, in the previous sentence, it says, it is absolutely essential that you understand completely that behavior is erratic until a firm commitment to one or the other is made.
SPEAKER_00So you're thinking, well, shit, what happens if I make a firm commitment to the ego? My behavior may not be erratic, but man, that's that would suck. So now he's saying, yet a firm commitment to darkness or nothingness is impossible. So thank goodness. So yeah. So now this is a really important correction here. Uh, only one commitment can ever be truly firm. Now, a lasting commitment to truth is possible. Isn't that delightful?
SPEAKER_00A lasting commitment to truth is possible. And you know what? Also, I'm gonna add, it's not only possible, it is inevitable that everyone will have a lasting commitment to truth. Okay. And it'll happen sooner through your willingness that it happens sooner. You're just willingness to bring that about. It's gonna happen sooner rather than later. This is collapsing time. A lasting commitment to truth is possible. A lasting commitment to darkness is not possible. So, why darkness cannot support a firm commitment?
SPEAKER_00Because it has no reality of its own, which we just went over. Nothingness has no foundation. The mind can't believe in fear, guilt, attack, separation, deprivation, worthless, worthlessness, or it can believe in those things, but and it can also organize most most of its life around these beliefs. It can appear deeply committed to these things, but it cannot become permanently established in something that doesn't have any reality.
SPEAKER_00So the ego must be continually reinforced. A commitment to darkness, if you're committing to the ego, the wrong teacher, let's say, if you're committing to the ego, it requires constant maintenance, constant, it needs repeated grievances. You gotta have you gotta be repeating in your mind that something bad is happening. You have to renew the judgment, you have to continually keep on projecting. It's like on this ongoing fear, it requires this because your mind, because you know, the attraction to God is so strong.
SPEAKER_00If you're not repeating these grievances, repeating these judgments, it's like you're renewing your vows to the ego, your mind is just drawn right back into God. It needs constant reinterpretation of events, saying how things are harmful, bad, all these stuff, all these things. It needs fresh evidence that. That lack is real. It needs fresh evidence that you or someone else has been deprived. Okay. Truth doesn't require this kind of reinforcement.
SPEAKER_00So what's real remains real, whether we're acknowledging it in the moment or not. But the ego has to keep on persuading us that its thought system has a stable, a stable foundation. It has to keep on telling us this. And you know, it's and that's because it doesn't have a stable foundation. So the mind keeps on moving back toward the light. Beneath every apparent commitment to fear is still the desire for peace. This is we all do. We all desire peace, right?
SPEAKER_00Everything that even every ego thought that we take on and try to make true, it's coming from a desire for peace. The foundation of it is a desire for peace. It's just misguided on how to get there. Beneath every attack thought, it's still a search for love. Beneath every defense is still a wish to feel safe. All defensiveness is just a wish to feel safe. And beneath every withdrawal is this longing for relief. So this is why no one is fully or finally lost to the ego.
SPEAKER_00That's just not going to happen. Even severe confusion can't become anyone's permanent identity. So erratic behavior is evidence of an impossible commitment, you can say.
SPEAKER_00If darkness could truly satisfy anyone, then the mind would remain there. And this is why this is why it cannot hold, because it never satisfies anyone. Even you could say the people who are eating babies, they have a reason for doing that. And it has to do with it's going to be better. Something's going to be better. I heard it's because they can they can make themselves younger that way, right? I don't know. Or maybe they're sacrificing to some uh deity in their mind, and somehow they're going to give them something that's going to be peaceful. Ultimately, everyone's looking for peace and comfort and uh and relief and connection.
SPEAKER_00So some memory of the light continues to call every mind. So this doesn't mean that a harmful pattern should be ignored, though. You know, someone may appear committed to avoidance, attack, murder, even, or just emotional inconsistency. Really, it's all the same. It's all coming from the ego's uh thought system. So we don't have to deny that there's a pattern present. We just don't have to remain available to that pattern. Uh, we don't have to interpret every brief uh return to warmth as evidence that the pattern changed, the underlying pattern changed.
SPEAKER_00We don't need to conclude that this is what the person truly is, though. The pattern can be persistent. There could be a pattern of believing in darkness, believing in death. You know, I have one friend who pretty much tells me every day about death being true. Tells me every day. I see him every day. I think it's just about every day, just about every time I see him, first thing he says something about everyone's gonna die. He just likes to say that to me, and I just smile at him and give him a hug.
SPEAKER_00I don't tell him you can't talk to me like that or anything. If you don't, if you keep talking to me like that, I'm not coming over. Uh which is I'm not saying is a bad thing. It's just that I don't feel that at all. I just think it's cute, you know. I just smile. A person's commitment to confusion uh may not be permanent, but that doesn't make us responsible for waiting for them to change or stick or sticking around. You don't have to stick around. I mean, my guidance in this in this particular circumstance is just, oh, that's cute.
SPEAKER_00Laugh and smile and and enjoy. Uh so we can we, you know, but if a boundary was called for, it would certainly be the thing for me. I mean, I just I just do whatever the Holy Spirit is calling for because that's the most joyful all the time. So it's like someone's present behavior is not their final reality. So I don't believe that he is uh he's doomed, right? I don't believe that he's really gonna die, even though he keeps on projecting death every day.
SPEAKER_00He's not even here. Yeah, he's not even here. He wasn't even born. And so and so the interactions are just really light. Uh we can refuse access, though, without deciding that a person is beyond correction. That's not saying you should refuse access. That's always different in the moment. It's whatever is the most useful. So whatever is the most helpful, um, that's how we want to be used by the Holy Spirit. So we can always stop participating in something without turning some pattern that someone's repeating over and over again into some kind of eternal judgment.
SPEAKER_00Those persons are lost, so I'm going away from them. So a relational example, if someone repeatedly uh reconnects, offers warmth, what warm warmth, whatever, the pattern may reveal that they are offering something, but that's not, you know, that's not always what's being called for uh for continuation either. Okay, it doesn't require the conclusion though that they're permanently incapable, permanently incapable of being loving.
SPEAKER_00You know, they may go back and forth. Someone may be loving one moment. I have one friend who's telling me that 90% of the time her roommate is so good to her. She's constantly taking care of her, but 10% of the time, she's so fucking mean that she gets the sense that she's being abused in her own home. And I can tell by the way she says it, you know, that's very real for her for that 10% of the time. So, you know, what I'm saying is, you know, that the if that 10% of the time, you know, you feel like you're abused in your own home, it's like just listen to the Holy Spirit as to whether you should uh go forward with that relationship or ask the person to move out.
SPEAKER_00It's really up to uh up to the Holy Spirit as far as what's the most peaceful, what's the most conducive to the classroom of this relationship, to seeing that illusions are not true. You know, if the peace is disturbed too much, the Holy Spirit is going to advise you to leave the situation. So if you're listening, you'll hear the call there. Just don't make enough, you'll hear much easier if you don't make the person guilty. Don't make it your, uh, don't make it make it like as if it's uh your decision to make them guilty or innocent, like they're a bad person, so I'm gonna get rid of them.
SPEAKER_00They're a bad, they've been a bad person. It's like, is this conducive to healing? Is going forward conducive to healing, conducive to undoing the mind to the Holy Spirit's classroom? So their confusion is never the truth of who they are. So when someone appears deeply invested in darkness, we can ask, am I treating this present pattern uh as their permanent identity? If they're still only temporarily invested in darkness, it's still only temporary, and their mind may go back and forth.
SPEAKER_00You know, some friends aren't really interested in changing their mind at all. They want to stay committed to the darkness. So it's like, am I am I seeing it clearly without making it eternal? So it's like, notice you don't you don't deny behavior. It's not like they're not acting like that. They are acting like that in your dream. But am I seeing it clearly or am I making it eternal? Seeing it clearly is seeing that it's temporary, it's a temporary thing. It's like, okay, good to see that 10% of the time they seem abusive.
SPEAKER_00That's uh good to see. And then you just take all that to the truth. Is it reasonable? Is it helpful from the Holy Spirit's perspective to keep going forward? Can I stop participating in this relationship without condemning? Can I remember that truth remains attractive to every mind, even when behavior witnesses to the opposite? So it's not like, oh, they're just lost to darkness, they're never lost to darkness because the truth is always calling.
SPEAKER_00So the key insight for this sentence, I'm gonna read the sentence one more time. Yet a firm commitment to darkness or nothingness is impossible. Okay, because nothingness has no foundation. That's the key insight. Nothingness doesn't have a foundation. The ego can be defended, repeated, reinforced. You know, some people know about the the teachings, uh, the teachings that I'm uh that I'm teaching all the time.
SPEAKER_00And so they'll automatically talk to me in a certain way. Death is real, and they'll death is real. They'll say that to me. And you know, it's like recognizing that's not uh that's not their real identity, that's not permanent for them. That belief isn't permanent. It's like, okay, no one is finally lost to darkness, even when a clear boundary is still appropriate in form. Okay, so we got through sentence two and it was lovely.
SPEAKER_00And we will start again next Wednesday on sentence three, paragraph two, and we'll continue with the innocent perception. Until then, have a lovely five days, everyone. I'll be back on Monday for wisdom dialogues, which is usually a stream of consciousness. Thank you too. Um sometimes I got questions. I got questions I'm answering like this week, but uh stream of conscious use consciousness usually on Monday, three to five.
SPEAKER_00Um Tuesday, one to approximately 2:30 or 3. We're doing the next lesson, which will be 2.02, which will be a review lesson. Yes, hallelujah! I'm glad you had fun, Caitlin. Oh, you would love the baby metaphors. That's awesome. She has a baby. You love the eating baby metaphors. That's great. Thank you for enjoying that. Okay, yeah. So go to hopejohnson.org for all the links that you need.
SPEAKER_00Uh, there's gonna be all more of the dying babies. Okay. Oh, the dying babies, yeah. Okay, because a fear of her baby dying. I see. Okay, yeah, okay. That's a good one. Yeah, that is that is definitely a good one, especially, you know, in the parenting realm. I know that would come up for me too. Fear of the babies dying, definitely. And you know, fear is just never justified. And when, and you know, in my perspective too, in my in my dream, um, I came to, man, no one can even die.
SPEAKER_00No one can even appear to die unless it's maximally beneficial. That's what it came to for me. So I don't need to be worried about if someone's appearing to die in the dream, because if they do, it's actually cause for celebration. It's the opposite of what we've been shown. So that's fun. All right, hopejohnson.org. And uh feel free to donate. Your donations are really appreciated. You can also find all kinds of information there. You can find all kinds of videos.
SPEAKER_00Uh it's for years, going back years. Um, lots of content, written content too, and all the links that you need to get to all the different channels that I'm on. If you're hearing this later or you don't know, you can join me on Zoom. That's right on the front page. You can join me live. I'm constantly doing these talks, uh taking breaks here and there, but constantly having these talks. I'm doing three a week right now, and you're welcome to join. Just go to my website, hopejohnson.org.
SPEAKER_00Yay, everyone. So until next time, mahalo, aloha, and a hooey ho. Woo! Yay.
Send Hope a Text “I am in danger nowhere in the world” can sound unrealistic until you look at what A Course in Miracles actually means by “world” and “danger.” We start by pairing Lesson 244 with the section “What Is...
Send Hope a Text Something in you already knows the difference between clear seeing and anxious scanning, and we go straight for that nerve. We’re reading and unpacking A Course in Miracles (Complete Annotated Edition)...
Send Hope a Text Salvation gets weirdly practical when you stop treating it like a finish line and start treating it like a moment to moment choice. We sit with A Course in Miracles Lesson 237, “Now Would I Be As God...
Send Hope a Text The fastest way to suffer is to believe your judgment is a fact. From a power-off grid corner of Hawai’i, we follow a deceptively simple A Course in Miracles line to its radical conclusion: if nothing...
Send Hope a Text Peace isn’t something we win by getting life to cooperate, cleaning up our personality, or achieving a “higher” spiritual level. We start with a simple guided arrival into the body, then move straight...