Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

A Continuous Lean

A Continuous Lean artwork

The Book Club

Aug 28, 202654 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In case you missed it, we are having a book club with James Salter’s Light Years. If you have read the book in the past few months with us, then you will be happy to know that the wait is over. Yesterday we recorded our thoughts on the book, on life, marriage, popularity and insecurities. Today we welcome you into that discussion and hope to hear your thoughts on Nedra, Viri, Hadji, Franca, Kaya and Arnaud. I told David that I don’t normally read fiction, but this book made me feel something - which perhaps is the point of reading. If you haven’t read the book, do that now and save this podcast for later. This was one of the most interesting and enjoyable conversations we have had on this podcast. I hope you all agree and thanks for waiting for us. -MW -Order Light Years. -James Salter in The Paris Review. -The famous James Salter New Yorker profile. -Thomas McGuane reads James Salter. -James Salter on Peter Matthiessen. -Order a copy of The Print Edition. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.acl.news/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Recording, David Coggins.

SPEAKER_01Michael, it's our first long, long publicized book club. I wanted to wear a tweed jacket, but it's too hot.

SPEAKER_00Instead, you brought your Chevy Avalanche. That's very, very kind of you to park it in the background. I have to admit, I've never been a part of a book club before, David.

SPEAKER_01I haven't other than when I was in college as an English major, which is sort of like a book club. I was known senior year, if I read the book, I would talk a lot, which wouldn't surprise you. But that set me up because when I didn't read the book, I talked not at all. And the teacher, the professor would be like, I sense you didn't engage with this topic as much, Mr. Coggins.

SPEAKER_00That's like your tell, your poker tell.

SPEAKER_01I know. I kind of screwed that up. You shouldn't talk too much when you've read the book. Before we get into that, a friend of mine works at Zillow and said that since you published Second City, that the real estate prices in La Jolla are out of control. You've changed the trajectory of

SPEAKER_00house hunting.

SPEAKER_01La Jolla real estate is out of control just

SPEAKER_00indiscriminately of me. Yeah, that was fun. You wrote a wonderful piece. I got a lot of responses from a lot of people about that.

SPEAKER_01That's great. For people who haven't read, Michael wrote a story about, well, living in New York and then Los Angeles and now

SPEAKER_00La Jolla. I think a lot of this stems, I think part of it's about me and then part of it's about life and other people and the time that we live in. But I do think if you spend time in New York, And I think you suffer from some of this. Oh, excuse me. I think if you spend time in New York, You end up feeling like it's New York or nowhere and nothing else exists. And I think that then it becomes scary to actually ever leave New York.

SPEAKER_00And you think like, well, will I be able to be relevant or will, you know, will this hurt me professionally? Will, you know, all these other things like, what does this mean for like, do I look bad? Do I look like a fool or all this stuff? And I think even moving to California, I thought some of that stuff. And then along the way, I'm like, well, I think you could – it doesn't really – where you live doesn't define you. And I think it's just important to – it's good to live in New York or it's good to live in cool cities.

SPEAKER_00There's also other things in life. And I think this relates – I mean, he doesn't, they're not kind of going through that. They never really live in the city, although there are sort of flirtations with city living in there. And there's second home thing. But I think, I don't know, I think it's like the big takeaway, you know, read the story, you know, read what I wrote. And, you know, I wrote that a long time ago, actually. I wrote that months ago and then I just sent it.

SPEAKER_00Cause I wasn't really sure if that's something I should be saying or if that makes me, again, it's

SPEAKER_01like, does that make me look bad

SPEAKER_00to say this stuff? Like, am I like admitting defeat? I mean, that's like, and then I talked to all my friends and everyone doesn't know where to live. Like everyone kind of wants everything, but you can't have it, you know, unless you're like, you know, bi-coastal, you know.

SPEAKER_01You published it from a lay flat seat on a flight from JFK to LAX.

SPEAKER_00You know, that's like, it's funny you say that. There's no lay flats between San Diego and New York. So it's like, you're just, you know, it's, it's, it's in a way it's like, but does that matter? You know, Dave?

SPEAKER_01I, you know, I have a very hard time sleeping around strangers. So I'm just going for an hour or two either way. It's, I, if I get a, if I have to drink enough that I pass out and then that's, I'm happy with whatever I have. I go, 80% of the way down. I don't like to be flat. You're very vulnerable. You don't know what's going to happen. Anyway.

SPEAKER_00That's sweet.

SPEAKER_01That was so ridiculous. No, of course.

SPEAKER_0080% down because you don't want to. You're like an armadillo. I've tried it.

SPEAKER_01I do go. I've tried the rest of the way. It's all right. I like to be able to raise.

SPEAKER_00Let's not get into this.

SPEAKER_01This is too much.

SPEAKER_00I can't handle this.

SPEAKER_01We've talked about this. How this came about was I saw you carrying a copy of Light Years, a book I've-

SPEAKER_00Performatively. It was a plant.

SPEAKER_01Let's just say, how did you choose to pick up that book and what type of books do you usually read?

SPEAKER_00What's your kind of- Nonfiction. Yeah. I like to read nonfiction, although, and this was, I think one, we can kind of get to this, but one takeaway for me with this book was- While it wasn't the typical book that I would – sort of like the easy, happy, comfort read perhaps that I would seek out or be interested in or – I think for me it's – I need a lot of – I need like a very strong pull from a book to sort

SPEAKER_00of stay in it. And my curiosity, I think, with nonfiction, that genre works well for me. But this was very rewarding because I sort of did and because of the book club made my way through. I feel like it's something I have perspective on and it made me feel something. I wouldn't say this is my favorite book in the world, but I certainly felt something and I think maybe Maybe that's the big takeaway here, Dave, is that reading makes you feel things, which is good.

SPEAKER_01Well, in this book in particular, I think it might surprise people to know that Light Years was published in 1975. So 50 years ago and more, the year I was born. And I think that surprises people because it feels so modern. It feels like it describes people we know. Why do you think it feels so modern? Why do you think we recognize people in it?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, I think that it, I don't know if it was a deliberate move by Salter to make this sort of not tethered to a specific time while he is calling things out, like things they're drinking or places they're going. There are like very specific references, but But he manages to do that in a way that's really not giving away the era. And whether or not that was deliberate, it's interesting because it's still a pattern of life that people are living.

SPEAKER_00And the places in it are still, you know, it's still relevant. I don't know. It's just, it's interesting. I mean, I think it feels very, very modern. I mean, it holds up in a way I think that is relevant. Like if he was trying to do it, that was like a masterful job. If he wasn't, this was still really, really good. I mean, I think that's the most interesting aspect of the book is just how untethered it is to like a timeframe.

SPEAKER_00You know, it could have been the 50s. Yeah, it's – It took me a while to figure out like when it actually was happening. For sure.

SPEAKER_01Well, and it's and it's it's he writes it in 1975, but it starts much earlier than one thinks because it isn't in that time. Only later do you realize. That it's going to focus on the children of this couple. Just to put it in perspective, when this book came out in 1975, it was absolutely panned in the New York Times. And Salter remembered that for decades. He was really hurt by it, affected by it negatively. Here's a line,

SPEAKER_01the reviews by someone named Anatole Broyard, who wrote, At one point said the characters had unusual names, which was funny because his name was Anatole. But he said, compared to his previous novel, A Sport in a Pastime, light years is worse in several ways. The characters and their alleged incompatibility are both less interesting and less convincing. Once separated, they are even more boring than they were together. Which is not great.

SPEAKER_01And I think, and he goes on in that review to say that a lot, it seemed like a lot of novels at that time focused on marriage. But I think when you, that the novel begins, and I think when people remember this novel, they're thinking about the beginning, about how we are seduced into their lives and how kind of wonderfully Nedra and Viri live. And I think that that, His portrayal of that is really strong and convincing.

SPEAKER_01And that part of the book is pretty short, actually. It gets darker more quickly than one might believe. You're like, wait a minute, we're only 40 pages in when we've got adultery going on. And I kind of want to go back to the happy days. But it gets into a more complicated picture pretty quickly.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah. I mean, I think, sorry, addressing the criticism of the book, too. I mean, I think it's one, it's like, these are such personal things, I'm sure, for Salter to be writing this, right? And so much work goes into it. And it's hard, I think, to take, you know, criticism, like their job is to be critical or, you know, basically to explain a book or support it to their audience. Excuse me. But they're not, you know, it's like they're kind of not in the arena.

SPEAKER_00I think that's why it's hard to just Listen to noise, listen to all these things, even if they're attached to institutions that you know matter and you know this affects your world. But it's hard to sort of, you know, take that from a critic and I could see how that would be difficult. But it's also so different from A Sport in a Pastime that, you know, it's like not doing, it's like the second album is not what the first album is and everyone wants another version of that. And there's only a few bands that could kind of do that or wanted to, right?

SPEAKER_01For sure. I think I love this book and it also makes me furious in a way. There's no better book with more annoying character names. I can't believe it's Nedra and Viri and Javan. And then that their dog's name is Haji is what put me over. But I think that he writes in a way that Even though it can make me, like, there is so much talk about, oh, lay the fire. And, oh, can you get me a drink?

SPEAKER_01You mentioned the drink. Can it be a San Rafael? Three or four times you talk about the San Rafael. Oh, and the fire is crackling. And we set the fire. Very, please set the fire. But I think why he does that is because that gives us the rhythm of their life. And he's such a sensual writer that it shows what's happening now. In their world, and also what they care about. If you visit their house, they're having a fire. You have drinks, you have cheese from Zaybars, and those things matter to them.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, no, he was doing, I mean, all of the All of that writing, the way that it was, I also struggled with. I found it to kind of be like saccharine, hard to sort of take it. But I do think he did a good job of illustrating the way that they live. And I think those details really help you understand. Like I could easily then, because of those things, like those specifics, And the way that they're living and the way that they drink and what they drink and all the,

SPEAKER_00all those details, it really, it really helped me identify kind of what type of people they were and sort of see them for maybe people I have in my life or people I've known, that's how they live. And so, and I also think like there, yeah, that's, it's, I think that that was helpful, but also like difficult to get through in a lot of ways. And, you know, I hated the structure of this book, uh, And I just found it to be very disjointing and and sort of hard to stay in.

SPEAKER_00But then, you know, it's hard because it's like, you know, then by the end, you start to see the full picture and you're like, understand it. And it takes a while to really like get like get in. And then when it does it, you know, you get you pretty hard.

SPEAKER_01I think that the one of the surprising things about the book is How carefully he lays the scene in the beginning, you imagine it's going to be a portrait of a marriage in a quite contained way. And just to remind people how kind of shocking it is, we see the marriage and then we see Viri have an affair with Kaia. And then you think that that's sort of it. So it's a little surprising then when she's having an affair,

SPEAKER_01Which is a little bit like in Goodfellas where he does a voiceover and then all of a sudden she does a voiceover and you're like, oh right, there's two sides to this. And then it becomes clear that the novel is in many ways about Nedra, not Viri. But then it becomes about their kids and all sorts of things. And all of a sudden we're like, wait a minute, now Arnaud is heard and the kids are growing up and we... He moves to all sorts of things, divorce, move to Italy.

SPEAKER_00His new wife.

SPEAKER_01And that's where I'm like, part of me, to your point, wants to go back to the first world. But I think he's making a larger point about the... How time moves in our lives, how these things end, how children grow up so quickly, how relationships end. And that's, I think sometimes I find that point is effective more than that makes me enjoy the book.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. It's like you're giving up. Book, you're giving up some of the enjoyment to sort of get to this bigger point that he's making.

SPEAKER_01Right, exactly.

SPEAKER_00I mean, I didn't, you know, first of all, when the kids start to get into it, I'm like, oh, God, please, like, let's not go down the, like, let's not, like, replay this with the kids. Right. Even if they're adults and, you know, grown women. It's, you know, I think this is more, I think his idea was to make the book about time, like the concept is about the passing of time. My big takeaway from the book was more of like, Your ideas of things and your expectations and how time affects your expectations

SPEAKER_00and your ideas of what your life should be, what your marriage should be, what childhood should be, what travel should be, like what all these things. And that to me was the biggest lesson in all of it. It's like that it was never in sync or never sort of, you know, they were younger than I was when they got divorced. Oh my goodness.

SPEAKER_01Yep.

SPEAKER_00So they, you know, it's like they weren't even, I don't think mentally divorced. At a place where they could decide whether or not their marriage should work or not. It was like very impulsive in a lot of ways. And that was like a theme in a lot of the book, I felt like. And it's just they were never sort of in touch with reality of what things should be. And I don't know. I think that's the hardest part about marriage is like staying in the, staying in the reality of like, even though I might feel a certain way, it's like, You know, see the bigger picture in, you know, what they had.

SPEAKER_00And I don't know, maybe that's.

SPEAKER_01No, I think that's a, I think it's a very good point. I feel like they, they were in love with this life that they had hosting, you know, she, she talks about her, her real, there's a quote, her real concern is the heart of existence, meals, bed linen, clothing. The rest means nothing. It's managed somehow. You're like, okay, well, that's an interesting way of, you know, interesting way of looking at it, right? But like, she clearly cares about,

SPEAKER_01you know, making a beautiful table, how well she hosts her friends. And then in a way that maybe she puts, you know, we get seduced by that at the beginning, or he describes it so lovingly, but then maybe we get seduced by that and the marriage is falling apart and the surface of things is great. Yeah. Substance is not.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. To me, it's a strange thing to obsess over. It's like the exterior of your marriage being beautiful and the interior rotting and then it falling apart and sort of how even more damaging that is in terms of like your image. Right. But then you're not addressing it. You're still focused on like this, like this veneer. It's a strange, I mean, I think like that's the point of all this too. I don't, I'm not mad about it. I think it's just, that's, that was like what he was trying to do in a lot of ways.

SPEAKER_01I think he has a very, a very clear understanding of certain types of people. I think he understood like a kind of New York cultural person. Attractive, maybe they've been married more than once. I mean, the secondary characters are great. I love Eve. I love Arnaud. And then a major part of the book is, here's another quote, there are really two kinds of life. There's the one people believe you are living, and there is the other. It is the other which causes the trouble.

SPEAKER_01This other we long to see. So that's saying there's like the way Viri and Nedra have this perfect life, but then we're kind of curious, what's that? I mean, this is before social media where you have this second life, this other one that's less than perfect, but those things are related in the sense of they put this perfect, they have these wonderful kids, they live in this perfect house, or not houses, house with a lot of character. You want to visit them, you want to eat their, you know, European food, but then you kind of, as you drive home,

SPEAKER_01From the dinner party, then you speculate about what their relationship is really like. And it's even worse than you think.

SPEAKER_00That's good.

SPEAKER_01Which is sad. So do you think, do you, reading this book as, you know, married father, do you think it would have been different if you would have read it when you were 25? But, you know, when you were.

SPEAKER_00Yes. I think it's, I think, you know, I think it's hard to really understand marriage. Completely and children, you know, and family life without being, you know, having that, I think it just is impossible to, like, you just feel like a different person. I think once you have kids and you maybe not when, just when you have a wife, but I do, I do think like, I wouldn't have probably understood this completely or had, you know, you, I think your understanding of marriage when you're not married is based

SPEAKER_00on your friends and your parents and you know, what you've seen. Versus like experiencing some of it firsthand and just like the, you know, the complexities of life. And then so I think it's, yeah, I think it honestly made me more like sympathetic to it in certain ways, you know, but, but also like, I'm, I felt like, oh, very, you know, I felt like both of them quit on it too easily. And it was just like, it felt very lazy and But I understand, too. I mean, it's like people also like kind of lose it at certain points

SPEAKER_00and they just like go do stupid stuff, you know?

SPEAKER_01Well, did you have the – when I go back to this book now and I look at Nedra more carefully or understand her more, do you see the themes or appreciate that she felt kind of trapped by this life? She was – really wanted to go to Europe. She was fascinated by these other lives that people lived. She had a huge sense of her own beauty, but she didn't have, she had never been to Europe. When she went, she wanted, I want to see everything,

SPEAKER_01she said, you know, and I think, so she felt that this perfect life contained her in a way, restricted her, and so she needed to get out of it, and there was only one way to do that.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, I think we talked about this at one point somewhere. You know, I think that there's a lot of, You know, I think post-war, post-World War II, the 50s and the idea of this like perfect life as an answer to like the bad things that happened in the 40s and how it shaped like culture and the ideas of marriage and then how in the 70s and 80s that was rejected in certain ways or, you know, it's like the free love movement, all these other things.

SPEAKER_00You know, I think... I do understand why people would reject the idea of that and why she would. And I also, you know, I think identified with Nedra in certain ways. She's from like a small town in Pennsylvania from like fairly humble beginnings. Obviously don't identify with her good looks.

SPEAKER_01She just started a lifestyle blog.

SPEAKER_00She'd be crushing on Substack. She probably would. And then she would have everything. It's just a product of the wrong era. I mean, I think honestly, though, that you always want, I mean, everyone's, I think, let's not underestimate the power of insecurity to drive human behavior, right? And I think like, that's a lot of why people do everything they do. And I think it's like, I can identify with that, certainly, you know, and it's like, You know, I'm even like going back to what we were initially talking about, like insecurity.

SPEAKER_00It's like living outside of like the place I should theoretically live. Right. So I think, you know, she wanted to go to Europe, see all these other things because she wanted she felt like she deserved this more complete life, cultured life or a different life. And and part of me thinks like then she went and it was just like, whatever, you know, and it's like not going to fulfill you. And then you just like, all right, let's find a new thing to focus on in a way. Or she's like going to be the spouse of like an artist or she's going to be an artist or an actor or whatever.

SPEAKER_01If you read the rest of the Royard review, that's exactly what he says. Like these people just keep searching for things. Here's a quote.

SPEAKER_00I mean, that's modern in a lot of ways, too, because it's the same thing now.

SPEAKER_01I think one of the interesting things about this book, why it's fascinating, is that I think that Salter has a very clear sense of his characters. I don't think he says these people are perfect. I think he and that makes it much better. So here's a quote that I think now knowledge does not protect one. Life is contemptuous of knowledge, passion, energy, lies. These are what life admires. Now that is very different than the,

SPEAKER_01I think we're meant to believe at the beginning of the book that these people are worldly in their sensibilities, but then in some ways they don't, they're not quite as maybe smart as they think. And I think that's a powerful friction when we realize that that's the case.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and I think it's don't underestimate Life's experience to shape your worldview and to help you, you know, it's like, I think you cannot arrive at these things, you know, without being shown it or living through it. So I think it's- Did you root

SPEAKER_01for them? Like, were you mad that they were like, did you want them to It sounds like you wanted them to fight and stick it out or what?

SPEAKER_00I did. I mean, I felt like Viri, I just struggled with Viri. I don't want to be too crass, but I just felt like Viri was like a bitch that whole time. And I think I said that to you at some point, too. I was like, come on, Viri. Like, even at the end with his wife, it's like he can't even stand up to, I don't know, he can't do what he wants or whatever. He's like being manipulated. But I did want them to be, you know, I felt like they had so much, like there was so much potential that they threw away for stupid stuff. You know, it's like, what did they buy into the Hamptons for?

SPEAKER_00For nothing, probably. They're like missing all the important things and focusing on this stupid stuff. But, you know, that's easy for me to say now, right?

SPEAKER_01I think that very... So it's important to say just a few other things about James Salter. So born James Solidus, known to his friends as Jim Solidus, James Solidus, and enters the Air Force Academy like his father. Um, when he wanted to go to Stanford and he was a pilot, um, and then started writing stories while he was still in the Air Force saying, but he changed his name to James Salter saying it was just

SPEAKER_01so no one could identify him, um, as the author of them because it would be frowned upon, but it was also to kind of hide his possibly depending on how you look at it to hide his, um, Antecedents, his ancestry. And he, James Salter, was a man who believed in the idea of genius and a great man. And it had to be a man, right? And a writer who, and he wanted that type of greatness. That's the theme in all of his work. And so I think he views Viri as someone who isn't great and knows it.

SPEAKER_01And that that's his, the reason he can't stand up and fight for these things is he's aware of He's smart enough to know he's not a genius and that that is his tragedy. And that's something Salter understands extremely well. I think he felt that himself. He probably wanted to be like Ernest Hemingway at that level of things. And he was never that. And even if the themes overlapped or something. And so I think that very, he feels for him in a way. And that's why he can write about it so well.

SPEAKER_01But it's also infuriating.

SPEAKER_00That's great. I mean, that's a really nice context to put all of this in. Do you know at what point the book sort of crossed over and was there one, was there something that happened with the book where people then said, no, no, this is like something you should consider. And then it became this like cult. Now it's like a beloved. Yeah. How would you describe it?

SPEAKER_01I think it's a, I think one, I think James Salter went through a kind of, um, His work was kind of rediscovered in a sense. He was writing for People Magazine. When People Magazine began, they would have profiles of Vladimir Nabokov. TV celebrity was like major people. So he was doing that type of writing. And then A Sport in a Pastime kind of became known as this, you know, for its raciness.

SPEAKER_01I personally, I find James Salter's sex scenes to be some of the worst writing I've ever read. I find it so, like, and not just the blue part of it, but the way he describes women, they're usually making some sound, like it sounded like a wounded deer or something. It's like very... Behind the time. So we should, it would not be a complete telling of this book to kind of discuss that. I think then his work was always appreciated by writers. Writers love his work because his sentences are so thoughtful.

SPEAKER_01And I think sometimes that is great and you just can't believe it. Anyone can write like this. And then sometimes I think it stands in the way of the plot or other things happening, or he's too in love with that. And then you're aware of his brilliance and the book in a weird way suffers, if that makes sense. You kind of admire it more than you enjoy it. I mean, now you're getting into my kind of zone. No, no.

SPEAKER_00But I see that, too, where I was like, it's almost like he's overcomplicating this to show that he can. And it's not something to me that felt like he had a lot of ability to do it. But the writing was sort of too much at times, you know, when I feel like it could have been more restrained and would make it more interesting for me. But

SPEAKER_01So there's this funny phrase, he's often referred to as a writer's writer, which is kind of a compliment and kind of not. In one sense, it implies these writers admire him. In another, it means that you're not successful. It's sort of like a cult band or something.

SPEAKER_00And he did

SPEAKER_01more than... He wrote screenplays, as most people listening to this know. He lived in Aspen early on. He was a great downhill skier, great mountain climber. He wrote Downhill Racer. He was friends with Robert Redford. He's written about this in Burning the Days. He was very disillusioned by the film industry. He had many things that he thought would be good that didn't turn out well. He lived in Rome while making...

SPEAKER_01Some of these films, which was great, and he writes about really well. So he didn't publish as many books as people think, and his life was, he never had a ton of money, but he always kind of lived well and spent money well. So that's like the house in real life in Bridgehampton. I just wanted to read you this other, speaking to this kind of idea of fame. So a character says, Viri says to another character, must fame be part of greatness?

SPEAKER_01Character responds, well, that is a difficult question. The answer is possibly no, but from a practical point of view, there must be some consensus. Sooner or later, it must be confirmed. And then Viri thinks about it later. He says, fame was the evidence of greatness. It's only proof. And I think that idea... If you believe that, in a different era, before fake famous people on social media, but when they were really like, okay, there's Norman Mailer, there's Pablo Picasso,

SPEAKER_01there's Fellini, these are major creative people that James Salter sought that level of fame. And that's Viri's tragedy, too, because he's an architect, he meets a more famous architect, and he knows his buildings will not be known forever. An architect is a particularly good job for him because a true building lasts and is known. You can't be a great architect, but no one has seen your buildings. And I think that's a huge part of this. And it makes it, those are eternal questions for anyone who makes something.

SPEAKER_01How are you going to Mm-hmm. Yeah, that's,

SPEAKER_00That was interesting. That's, I mean, the fame piece, I mean, it really like draws it back to how much of him is in this book too, in ways. So what did you, so how do you feel about this book overall?

SPEAKER_01Well, I think this, like, I think it's hard to, I have to separate what I want from it, from what it's trying to do. I think anytime we look at these things, I think he, he, His capacity to make me furious is very unique. And that means he speaks to something I care about and know. And I love him. And then I get so mad at some of his...

SPEAKER_01The day was bright white. They woke up to the whitest day. It's like, just relax. I don't even know what that means.

SPEAKER_00He did a great job of talking about the Hudson River, though. He knows me.

SPEAKER_01The Hudson is beautiful. That opening first phrase about we break the rocks, we ride the water. I mean, that is just so good. I don't have it right with me. But then, you know, he talks about You know, the great scene at the shirt makers where the shirt maker says, what earthly use do you have for a pocket, which is like a perfect sentence for like the shirt maker to say. And then he talks that one friend has just come back from fishing in England. And then later he's like, well, what would you do? There's a quote, I would rather spend a day fishing than anything in the world.

SPEAKER_01I'm like, oh, my God, you know, I just want to hang out with these people. So I think I try to not get mad at the characters. I try to understand what is happening. And I do have this feeling for Nedra that she's trying to have this other life. And I try to understand why she wanted that and why did she want to go to Europe? Why did she want to leave her family? And I think I got distracted. You know, this is a real book that...

SPEAKER_01It means different things to you at different times in your life. I think when I was young, I kind of liked reading about marriages falling apart. You know, when you get older, it's not as funny, you know, like this is like the time is different.

SPEAKER_00I mean, I think like Viri's affair was probably the most exhilarating aspect of the book. It was fun. I mean, maybe that's just me again, like sort of rooting for Viri. You know, in a way, even though he's like doing something he shouldn't be doing or, you know, ruining his marriage in a way. But I was kind of like, at least finally he's like taking control here. And that didn't last very long until she volleyed back. Him.

SPEAKER_01Well, I think that I viewed the both affairs as symptoms of something that had already gone wrong. You know, that's why she kind of had a sense he was having it. He had a sense. I mean, they're very subtle things in there when she pours some kind of Ouzo that I think Jivan, who she's having the affair with, gave her in the house and just very says, oh, I didn't know we had any Ouzo or Ouzo pasta. Ouzo.

SPEAKER_01And it's like, oh, where did that? Bottle come in the house. How is it mostly empty? Why has she been drinking it? Why has she had a taste for that? She's obviously had those in some life separate from him. So they have a pretty clear understanding about it. If we're kind of rooting for him bizarrely to at least be active with that woman, Kaya, then how humiliating is it when he goes to a party after she's broken up with him and he like Gets really drunk and dances or does this performance in the party. And then this woman says, who is that sad man?

SPEAKER_01And you're just like, oh my God, how far we've fallen. And that they shift, like he has such a brilliant salter, brilliant way of capturing what's at stake in a social setting. Like he is so, he understands like what it means to backstab someone or to be humiliated in a very specific way. For people that we know, it's like a very kind of bourgeois, whatever. I mean, like, and it's amazing because you feel the frustration or even vindictiveness or

SPEAKER_01the Italian woman doesn't want him to send money to his, you know, to Nedra and she's like, she'll never stop. She'll never stop. And you're like, whoa.

SPEAKER_00The Italian woman was funny. She was a lot.

SPEAKER_01Well, that, I mean, that got to some real like, oh my God, when they went on a trip and they kind of ran out of things to talk about. I was like, oh my, I don't even know if I can read. I mean, that was like, tell me what happened.

SPEAKER_00They went to Cuomo or something, right? And it was like, the weather was bad. And like, it was just a bad trip, like all the way around. Oh, yeah.

SPEAKER_01It's, I think it's good. I would say that the way we can come back to this book and the fact that it still connects to people and that it, That it underlies the, also just, I mean, you can appreciate it as like someone who has young kids, like these, I mean, the title Light Years and just so much about time and how we, these kind of beautiful days and parties with kids and, but also kind of how fast it goes and how, um,

SPEAKER_01That it happens before we kind of realize it and then punctuated by acts of kind of random tragedy, a sick father or Arnaud's accident where he's kind of jumped and beaten up. And I think that Salter is a master of that as well. You have this sense of kind of wonderful Easter egg hunts that are in wonderful performances, very... In some sense, I should say, these are a little bit like my parents. A creative household, and very playful parties,

SPEAKER_01and thoughtful presentations, and reading, and artistic cards, that part of it, and attention to those types of things. And so I very much felt part of that. And then, yeah, you're waiting for it to go wrong.

SPEAKER_00And it didn't seem to go wrong with the children. I mean, I think that they were – that was – those two stories were sort of parallel to each other in certain ways. I think that there – I think later when the girls got older, it became – the equation changed a little bit. But it felt like he was – like that was a counterpoint a lot to the marriage, the beauty of the children and the life with the children. And there were a lot of very – Sweet, beautiful moments with the kids in a lot of different settings at the house.

SPEAKER_00And I don't know where that house was, Ossining or like Croton or somewhere.

SPEAKER_01I think somebody said it was Nyack, but nobody even. Oh yeah, Nyack

SPEAKER_00could have been. Well, anyway, up there somewhere. Yeah. But there were like moments there. There were moments in the Hamptons. There were a lot of moments. And I feel like he did, the children sort of turned out, I was sort of, Bracing for the children to not turn out well. And it seems like that was one thing. He managed that relationship and the kids were okay. And Nedra had a good relationship with her father, it felt like.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, that was interesting too, because she comes from this working class background, but she isn't in any way, not that she should be, but now that she's in this new world, She wasn't in any way ashamed. I thought that was really like, that's the other part about the book that these characters, they still manage to surprise you. It isn't just like, oh, this is the way a typical person. And then they still have these varied things they do. You know, when she loses interest in Javon, who she's having the affair with, like, That kind of happens.

SPEAKER_01She just sort of said, like, she recognized it was over. That face was behind you. You're like, whoa, okay. Sorry, Javon. See you take your Uzo out of here. Now she's with us. You should never have introduced her to this poet who dressed like a banker. And you're like, uh-oh. And the guy calls her up and you're like, oh my God. And you're like, this is kind of, I mean, isn't it nice to read a book where there's no It's not just that there's no social media, but just the way people, you know, you call someone or you drive to someone's house or you can't text them or look them up or you run into them on the street like it.

SPEAKER_01Just that you park outside Zabars while someone runs in and you don't get a ticket or you go to Bonwit and Teller or whatever. I mean, I just I love that part of it because it's still recognizably in our world and the way they interact. It isn't like they're in a horse and buggy. And yet just without social media, you know.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's just very, I mean, I think the world was like much more linear then, right? Like that's just like a much more straightforward way of living. You know, there's only certain ways you can do things. And all those constraints and limits like help create just a world that's easier to understand versus now where there's like infinite ways to do everything. And I don't know, it's like everything's very complicated. I mean, I think it would be interesting though, as a, you know, just as a talking point for all of this,

SPEAKER_00Like if this book was written now and sort of how it would be different, you know, with all the other, you know, it's like meeting people or just like the way that everything played out, you know, would have been, would be interesting idea.

SPEAKER_01I think that the way that we experience places that we aren't. So this idea of her like wanting to go to Europe to see everything, that was amazing. Both could only be known through maybe some magazines and books. You couldn't be on Instagram looking at videos of this hotel in the south of France or whatever it is. And I think that in a way, it keeps you from knowing things that are happening.

SPEAKER_01But in another way, it motivates you to go and see them yourself. And I think that that desire and James Salter had it in his life. I mean, he went. He was stationed in Korea, and then he went to France, and he just couldn't believe France. That's what, obviously, A Sport in a Pastime is about, and he just fell in love with that country. Late in life, he went and rushed back to France with his very pregnant wife so his last child could be born in France.

SPEAKER_01He cared about those things, too. Yeah. I've got another note for you. So there's a really interesting piece in the Paris Review by William Benton, who's a poet and a translator and a writer. He wrote in his memoir a section about James Salter that was in the Paris Review. And it was... You get a real sense of what Salter was like,

SPEAKER_01his charm and charisma, but also his kind of competitiveness, how he could be difficult. But he said, he told Benton that one of the functions of a writer is to create envy in the reader, envy of the life that the writer is living. So do you think that Salter sometimes tries to prove that he knows... Like how subtle he is about, you know, Chateau,

SPEAKER_01the wine is wonderful, very, is like, well, you can still get some good Margot's at fair prices or whatever. Like, it's like he's, he kind of gets, does that help you create a world of desire or is it a little bit acknowledging, trying to prove that he knows things? Did that ever stand in your way?

SPEAKER_00No, I mean, I think now, I mean, I think that probably felt different in 1975 or whatever than it does now. I mean... To me, it's like that, you know, when we, if we get into like the world of like American Psycho or whatever, we're like, you know, do you remember the scene where he's like, no, he's like, what is that? What's that bag where he's like putting the body in the trunk of the car? And he's like, is that a Gurkha or whatever? And it's just like, oh my God. But you know, that book is like littered with that stuff, right?

SPEAKER_01It's like signaling. Status symbols, yeah.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And, you know, but I think like we're in a world now where like everything is like, You know, if you post any photo, it's like, what shoes are those? Or like, what, you know, like, ID the pants. Yeah. And so I feel like it was, in a way, like, it's sort of light work now looking at reading that. But I think at the time, I think it probably was different. And it probably felt different to people sort of seeing those. But in certain ways, it felt like, I don't know.

SPEAKER_00I don't know Salter well enough, and I haven't read everything else. But I don't – I'm not totally convinced, you know, that Salter is like the real deal. And it's different than like a guy like Hemingway or whatever. And, you know, it's like Hemingway was also trying to – you know, whether or not people, you know, in the era were seeing that he was – You know, creating a narrative of himself and projecting a lot. It's like Steve McQueen. You know, it's like he was dressing a certain way on purpose.

SPEAKER_00He was a movie star.

SPEAKER_01It's, yeah.

SPEAKER_00And I felt like a little bit of that out of Salter. You know, so, you know, I read... Between Meals, A.J. LeBlanc. Oh, my favorite. And Salter wrote the introduction to the book. And I was like, this introduction is so amazing. And that's kind of how I ended up getting into it. That's why I had Light Years, because I read that.

SPEAKER_01It's so funny you say that, because I have this theory that I've saved, is that I prefer James Salter's nonfiction. Um, to his novels because he writes in a way that's a little more, and even some of his faster things like that introduction. So it's not a whole book. It's just his introduction for A.J. Liebling. He wrote very wonderfully about male friendship. Um, he wrote, um, uh, Piece about Frank Conroy when he died. That was very short and absolutely wonderful. He wrote it for The New Yorker about Peter Matheson when he died.

SPEAKER_01Again, just incredibly written. A lot of the same themes of friendship and meals together and families overlapping and living in kind of beautiful ways. But, you know, drinking and adultery and all these things coming together. The writer's life. And it's pretty good. I mean, for people listening to this, hard to believe you made it this far if you haven't read. I mean, definitely this book, but I would read Burning the Days, his memoir, if you want, because that touches on all sorts of things. Probably the longest memoir ever written before someone mentions that they have a wife and kids.

SPEAKER_01You sort of think this guy's single, you're on page 300, and you're like, and my kids and family, you're like, wait, what?

SPEAKER_00You're like 45, what's going on here?

SPEAKER_01They're not in the picture. And he had multiple marriages, kids from different marriages. He was a difficult man in a lot of ways. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00I'm not picking on Salter.

SPEAKER_01No, no, no. It's a fascinating, you know, it's funny to think about like male to pull back into the popular culture and you have like Hemingway, who most people have never heard speak, if you think about it, but it was image everywhere in like first half of the 20th century, kind of what we had an idea of kind of American masculinity. Then you have like Steve McQueen, Robert Redford, you know, he's kind of, Salter's kind of in between all of those people. And then you can evolve that into more complicated ideas after that.

SPEAKER_01But he does compare in an interesting way to all of them, but probably survived in a way better by not being so famous. He wanted more fame, but I think that probably ultimately suited him better, easy for me to say.

SPEAKER_00You know, it's interesting if you think about like Tom McGuane in Key West with all those guys and the sort of competition between them. And I think if you think about Hemingway and other writers, F. Scott Fitzgerald, other people, they were sort of at the pinnacle of celebrity and culture in the world, but particularly in America. Yeah. And people in a certain generation grew up with that as a goal. And I think we've lost that to a degree where people don't think like,

SPEAKER_00I want to be the next James Salter, right? Or I want to be, you know, I think like Hemingway now is like taken on this mythical role. You know, idea. And so people understand him and maybe try to live his life to a degree on Instagram or something, but it's like, no one's really trying to do that anymore, you know? And so it's, but that, but to me, it's like him, Salter's, you know, path or career or fixation or whatever, his drive for all these things is interesting because it is almost a product of

SPEAKER_00the era. And we're kind of beyond that now for better or worse.

SPEAKER_01Well, in one sense, we're beyond the idea of a literary celebrity. If a writer is famous, it means their writing has been made into a movie. That's what success is for a writer, that they made an Apple series about it. No writer who just writes, for the most part, at least in America, has that sort of level of celebrity. But then in another sense, Salter has these extreme obsessions with The ideas of being a hero and being noble and being brave. And that goes to his time in the Air Force.

SPEAKER_01And he is very like what what you have that you would risk everything for. But in a sense, it means nothing than the meaning you bring to it. So that's what That's why if you got what you would do and you're trying to, you know, get a kill or whatever, and he, I think he got one and he didn't get credit for a second one, but he's always writing about people who did, you know, climb certain mountains. Their name was invincible. That anyone, like there was, they did something that could never be taken away, whether they became an ace pilot,

SPEAKER_01legendary mountain climber, you know, heroic writer. Those were the things that he cared about. And that set a pretty high standard for himself. And I think probably struggled to reach that in a way. This was fun, Michael. Are you going to be a novel reader now? Should we do John Cheever? What's next? Do we need to do something modern? Do you want to read the classics? Talk to me.

SPEAKER_00I'm open. I will say that in all of this, well, this, again, I had something to reiterate slightly. This wasn't a book I probably would have just naturally, like it was sort of off the normal path for me, but it did really make me feel a lot of things. And that was interesting and enjoyable. But I'm open to it. I think it's fun to have this conversation. I mean, I think The book was good because we also have the backdrop of James and his life.

SPEAKER_00And that helps. And I think it like gives it more context. It's not just like a thing on its own. But I'm, I'm, I mean, I'm very open. I mean, maybe, yeah, I'm open to ideas. Maybe you should suggest this because I sort of picked this first one.

SPEAKER_01No, I, it was, I saw you with it and I said, you know, it's like, um, What are you doing with matches, young man? It's like if you see your boy running around. I said, what are you doing with light years? And I was so excited. I said, oh, well, where did you find this? And I said, well, let's talk about this.

SPEAKER_00It was a good change of pace for me, and I think it's good to get out of your... I think it's good to just not read the same things over and over. I do too.

SPEAKER_01I think the hardest part with novels, and one reason people, including myself, read fewer novels as they get older, is because it's hard to give yourself over to this other world. And that can be annoying for sure, but also when it works, you open yourself, like you're saying, to a different type of I think that's especially true.

SPEAKER_00Now with like everything, it's like you never, you never just like stumbling into anything. It's always like the algorithm suggested this or something. It's like just walking into a movie theater and you don't know what you're going to see and get through it, you know, and at the end you could be delighted and you could also just not understand it or whatever. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. I think it's worth letting yourself feel the emotion and even And kind of going with it. I think there is actually an art to reading a novel and to not say, oh, he would never do that. Or this is this. But going with the author. And then you can critique it later. But giving yourself over. In any case, I'm very glad we did this. This was really fun. I'm sure people will have some suggestions for further books. We're not doing Lonesome Dove next. People can relax.

SPEAKER_00A lot of people. I saw Chase Winfrey reading Lonesome Dove the other day. I mean, that's such a different thing, but this was really enjoyable. I think if anyone, too, has thoughts or comments or, you know, if we could do a different format, too, I think we would be open to ideas.

SPEAKER_01So discuss. But yeah, David,

SPEAKER_00make it happen. Take care.

SPEAKER_01All right.

SPEAKER_00Bye.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Print Edition

    Jul 11, 202636 minAudio

    Hello, hello. The third incarnation of The Print Edition is here. Meet The Summer Issue, just in time for relaxation, grilling and nostalgic beer. The cover is a wonderful Fairfield Porter painting of Maine, which sets...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Print Edition

    May 4, 202632 minAudio

    To celebrate the return of The Print Edition we got dressed up and went to Chateau Royale to raise a martini to the new issue. The theme is sports, which evoke leisure, play and childlike pleasure. Many people enjoy the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Masters Edition

    Apr 9, 202650 minAudio

    We celebrate our beloved Masters at Augusta. Then we consider the incredible setting, remarkable patron experience and the wild world of golf clothes. Hope you like it! Read David’s new story on the quiet side of The...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Print Edition

    Nov 18, 202529 minAudio

    We started our podcast five years ago because we wanted to talk about the things we’re into. By now you know what they are: travel, style, sports (and airline lounges!) and the details that make those things better. Oh,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Power Lunch with Michael Williams

    Aug 28, 20255 minAudio

    This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.acl.news

    Credit the people on this episode