Shenane Hogg spent nine months in a coma after suffering abuse at the hands of her partner. During her recovery, she discovered her abuser had amassed $56,000 of debt in her name. Shenane’s story is just one of many that was heard at a parliamentary inquiry into how the financial system can be used to abuse women. The inquiry heard chilling evidence of a sharp rise in financial abuse that can manifest as offensive and threatening messages in streams of bank transfers, raiding of a partner’s super benefits, or making them liable for joint debts. This month, the Albanese government finally responded to that parliamentary inquiry, saying it supports, or supports in principle, 58 of the inquiry's 61 recommendations - but many of the proposed reforms are yet to be implemented. Today, journalist Karen Barlow on the cost of financial abuse, and why we’re failing to prevent it. This episode first aired in July, 2024. If you enjoy 7am, the best way you can support us is by making a contribution at 7ampodcast.com.au/support. Socials: Stay in touch with us on Instagram Guest: Chief political correspondent for The Saturday Paper Karen Barlow. Photo: AAP Image/Diego Fedele
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1I'm Daniel James, and you're listening to 7am.
Speaker 2Okay, my name is Shanine Hogg, and I'm a proud Torres Strait Islander woman. Today I am here to share my journey as a survivor of domestic violence.
Speaker 1In 2017, Shanine Hogg woke up from an induced coma. She had been attacked by her partner after years of abuse.
Speaker 2It is something that affected me deeply. Reflecting on what I endured, I consider myself fortunate to have survived it. knowing that many others, unfortunately, have not been as fortunate.
Speaker 1She works not only a traumatic brain injury, but also the tens of thousands of dollars of debt raised in her name by her abuser. It took Sinead 18 months to learn to talk again, and more than five years to clear the debt she should never have had. In 2024, Sinead told her story to a parliamentary inquiry looking into financial abuse.
Speaker 2No one should endure what I went through and I am determined to raise awareness and advocate for change.
Speaker 1This month, the Albanese government finally responded to that parliamentary inquiry. It says it supports or supports in principle 58 of the inquiry's 61 recommendations, but many of the proposed reforms are yet to be implemented. Today, we're returning to an episode recorded just after the inquiry with political correspondent for the Saturday paper, Karen Barlow, on what are uncovered and and why the banks said they couldn't stop the financial abuse.
Speaker 1It's Sunday, November 1. This episode first aired in July 2024, and a warning. It discusses domestic violence and suicide. So take care listening.
Speaker 3Karen, you've been spending your time following the inquiry into financial abuse, which is is where Sinead Hogg spoke about what happened to her. Tell me what she shared with the inquiry.
Speaker 2Yes, my name is Sinead Hogg and I appear in a lived experience capacity. Thank you very much.
Speaker 3And we might just get the volume up in the room a little more if possible.
Speaker 2Sorry, bit of a soft talker.
Speaker 1Bit nervous.
Speaker 4So Sinead Hogg is a proud Torres Strait Islander and she moved to Queensland and she got involved with what turns out to be her abuser, And what he had done was start to take credit cards out in her name.
Speaker 2My personal experience began with financial exploitation. I found myself footing bills, lending money, losing control of my own finances and even having debts occurred.
Speaker 1In my name.
Speaker 4She said that there was this honeymoon period where she knew it was happening, but she was not sure about doing something about it.
Speaker 2I felt trapped and powerless. Attempts to resist only resulted in escalated aggression and abuse. Despite holding a respectable job, I was suffering silently at home.
Speaker 4A year and a half in, she starts questioning it, and there it gets violent, and he starts hitting her. She ends up with a traumatic brain injury. She goes into a coma for nine months.
Speaker 2During my recovery... I discovered that my abuser had amassed $ 56, 000 of debt in my name.
Speaker 4There is $ 16, 000 worth of accrued interest and these debts are just building up. And it's a while before she can even attempt, like years before she can even attempt to do something about it. And even then, at no point can she get from the banks an understanding from them that this is not her debt. This is a debt that her partner has imposed upon her.
Speaker 2If only there had been more awareness and understanding than of the complexities of domestic violence and its impact on financial autonomy.
Speaker 4You can hear how hard it was for Sinead Hogg. She is still someone who is on a rental blacklist. She still is getting her life together. You know, this is a terrible situation. And she's still living in fear.
Speaker 3And this inquiry, it's investigating financial abuse on an individual level, but it's also looking at the systemic level, isn't it? So it's looking at the way that banks are actually allowing or even amplifying this kind of harm. Can you tell me about how that focus came about?
Speaker 4Well, the entire inquiry, I mean, there are many parliamentary inquiries, but this one in particular came from Labor backbencher, Zanita Macarenas. She's been hearing about this abuse in her community. It's coming from, I guess, the giant national conversation we're having about gendered violence. But this year in particular, 2024 has been a torrid year for women and children who have died in cases of domestic and family violence. Just in the past week, There was the man charged over the
Speaker 4fire in Western Sydney where three children, including a baby, died. And he's been charged with murder and attempted murder. We had a woman's body who was dumped in a wheelie bin in Melbourne's north. And there was also a man who stabbed a partner to death. That's just one week alone of a horrific year. So this is no ordinary parliamentary inquiry. This is an inquiry where banks are very firmly being told to listen to the victims. It's thousands
Speaker 4of women out there in Australia dealing with this dark, insidious abuse. Financial abuse is a red flag that can often lead to physical harm.
Speaker 3And Sinead's partner took out credit cards in her name, amassing tens of thousands of dollars of debt. Can you tell me a bit more though about other ways that financial abuse occurs? What kinds of things do people report being done to them?
Speaker 4So there were a lot of harrowing submissions to this inquiry. One that stood out was the case of Molly Wilkes. Molly Wilkes took her own life in 2022 in America where she'd moved with her partner. She had been hounded, hounded over a long period by her partner and that took its toll to the point where yes, She committed suicide. But what had happened was that the abuser got hold of her superannuation payout, her benefit, which was about $ 65, 000.
Speaker 4So financial abuse can be so many different things. It can be partners taking out loans on behalf of their partners and perhaps in some cases not even letting them know that they are a party to it, so they are being signed on without their knowledge or permission. It could be inheritance impatience, where we're talking about power of attorney being abused on behalf of older people. It can be the abuse of credit cards. It could be bank transfers.
Speaker 4And there are cases where abusers are sending really small amounts of money, less than a dollar, maybe even like a couple of cents, and they're sending hundreds and hundreds of these transfers. But the abusive aspect to this is threats in the naming of that transfer. So there can be threats or there can be just abusive messages and
Speaker 4that goes from one account to the other. There are so many sort of loopholes and problems that this parliamentary inquiry is trying to address and it's so ripe for reform.
Speaker 3Coming up after the break, what's stopping the banks from acting? Karen, you've been listening to the evidence given at this parliamentary joint committee looking into financial abuse. And something that is very striking about these hearings is not only are we hearing from victims, we're hearing from financial institutions. So from banks, from the people who work in the teams who deal
Speaker 3with financial abuse. Can you tell me a bit more about the insights that we're getting from these banks?
Speaker 4So we've heard from the major banks. They all gave submissions to this inquiry. They are aware that this is a problem. And look, we're also hearing the entirety of this problem, that we understand that this is a cost to the Australian community of $ 5. 7 billion to victims and $ 5. 2 billion to the economy every year. So this is a very large problem. But the evidence to the inquiry is that banks and other institutions feel hamstrung when there
Speaker 4are cases of abuse. They feel that they can't act.
Speaker 3I now call forward representatives from the National Australia Bank.
Speaker 4We heard from Jocelyn Turner. She works in executive resolution and remediation with NAB. Her testimony was really quite startling.
Speaker 5So if a customer calls us and says, I'm in danger, he's about to hurt me, something's about to happen, then we would refer that to the police immediately.
Speaker 4What about if he's about to hurt me financially?
Speaker 5That is a different challenge because we don't have anywhere to refer it to.
Speaker 4The National Australia Bank talks about calls that they're receiving.
Speaker 5We're seeing that in the region of about 200 calls a month. But to give you a sense of why I'm concerned about that, the same time last year, it was in the region of 60.
Speaker 4This is just one particular, although major bank, and it gave goosebumps to a Labor-backed venture, Zaneta Macarena's. I'm going to let.
Speaker 6You know that you've given me goosebumps because one of the things that they say about financial abuse is that it's an earlier indication of physical violence escalating.
Speaker 3So banks are reporting that they're seeing a rise in financial abuse, but it sounds like they are perhaps overwhelmed by what they're seeing. So what do they actually do when they get these reports of financial abuse from customers? What are their options in terms of responding to abuse or preventing it from happening?
Speaker 4The evidence to the inquiry is that banks and other institutions feel they're blocked by the Privacy Act.
Speaker 5Will you please state your full names and the capacity in which you appear today? Lisa Pogonowski, General Manager of Customer Solutions at the Westpac Group.
Speaker 4We heard from Westpac one particular case where there was a case of elder abuse.
Speaker 7Just in the last couple of weeks, I have one example of the monitoring. So we had a customer who appointed her son her attorney. Over the last couple of weeks, he had transferred $ 150, 000 in three or four payments from his mother's account to his account.
Speaker 4The bank was aware that this was happening and it did actually, in this case, do something about it.
Speaker 7We were able to speak to our customer, his mother. She said that he was not entitled to the money. So we revoked or suspended his access to his mother's account. We took the funds from his account and returned them to her account and then suggested that she take some legal advice about revoking money. her power of attorney.
Speaker 4But it said that if it was in a separate bank, it wouldn't have been able to do anything about it because of privacy laws and the separation of the particular banks.
Speaker 6So if he banked with a different bank account, like a different banking organisation, would that have been more problematic to recover that money?
Speaker 5We actually wouldn't have been able to recover that money because under the privacy legislation, we can't go and contact another institution to... to find those funds or to recall those funds.
Speaker 4So there is a recurring theme from this particular inquiry that the Privacy Act is something ripe for potential reform. So that is something that is likely. And getting down to the core of the matter is that financial abuse in most jurisdictions is not a crime. It is acknowledged in Commonwealth law, but that does not mean that police can act on that. When we get down to states and territories, that's where it could potentially be a criminal offence.
Speaker 4We have in New South Wales, it recently became a criminal offence and it hasn't had a chance to actually make an impact in the community just yet. It is an offence also in Tasmania, but it hasn't also had a chance to really do anything. But, you know, as I've been describing, this is an incredibly complex area, but, you know, there is a mood for change.
Speaker 3And Karen, violence against women, it's been characterised as an urgent issue, as a national crisis by successive governments now, yet, as we know, it continues to happen and we're in a particularly dark moment for it at the moment. What sense do you get about how committed to addressing this current government is? How high up on the priority list is it?
Speaker 4Well, it says it's very high. It has the 10-year plan to end violence against women and children within a generation, although it is rather ambitious. It has, it would say, a suite of measures that it is rolling out, but we are seeing moves right at the moment to do something about bankruptcy laws, which ties into financial abuse. There is a mood to do more in the space of superannuation. There is changes within the social services portfolio, but still
Speaker 4the numbers are growing and we're only halfway through this year. And, you know, there are 49, 50 women that have died and so many more thousands of women out there who are being terrorised, who are being hospitalised, who are just suffering in silence and we don't know. And it takes really brave people like Sinead Hogg to stand up and say, this happened to me, this is my name, this is my community and we need to do something about it.
Speaker 3Karen, thank you so much for your time.
Speaker 1Thank you.
Speaker 3If you or someone you know is affected by family, domestic or sexual violence, 1-800-RESPECT has a confidential hotline. 1-800-737-732.
Speaker 17am will be back tomorrow with a preview of next week's crucial US midterm elections. Donald Trump's popularity is plummeting and Republicans are struggling to hold on to traditionally safe territories. But have the Democrats found a strategy to capitalise? Or is this election exposing deep divisions over the future of their party?
Speaker 8You've seen this kind of radical resurgence of the young, vibrant wing of the Democratic Party. And many of their policy positions are in kind of direct opposition to the more, I guess, mainstream establishment wing of the party, especially around key issues, of course, like And so they're united around the question of the cost of living, but not in how to address it. And they're not united on those other key issues. And you can already see a kind of fight for the narrative around where power lies in
At COP31 in Türkiye, Australia has been helping lead global negotiations over the future of fossil fuels and the fight against climate change. But while the Albanese government pushes for stronger international action,...
Anthony Albanese runs a notoriously tight ship. Across his two terms as prime minister, there’s been very little leaking, very little sniping, and very few of his Labor Party colleagues willing to speak out against him....
This week, Australia’s leading health research body released its advice on puberty blockers, saying they should be available for some young people under 18. The Queensland and the Northern Territory governments, which...
In 1945, in the Crimean city of Yalta, three global superpowers - America, Great Britain and the Soviet Union - met to carve up the world between them, each claiming their own sphere of influence in the final year of...
Last week it was Qantas, last month it was NAB: two giants of Australian business cutting jobs due to the growth of AI. The explanations were familiar. Qantas says it will allow the airline to unlock innovation faster...