For years we’ve heard from older generations that the current interest rate pain is nothing compared to the horror of 17.5 per cent rates in the late ‘80s and early ‘90s. But now, as the Reserve Bank delivers its fourth hike this year, analysis shows the pain being inflicted on homeowners is comparatively worse. So, as the official cash rate hits a 15 year high of 4.6 percent - how bad could it get? Today, KPMG senior economist Terry Rawnsley on the chance of more interest rate hikes, the flow on effects of this latest hit, and whether we should be looking at alternatives like tax hikes, to get inflation under control. If you enjoy 7am, the best way you can support us is by making a contribution at 7ampodcast.com.au/support. Socials: Stay in touch with us on Instagram Guest: KPMG senior economist Terry Rawnsley Photo: AAP Image/Sarah Wilson
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1I'm Ruby Jones, and you're listening to 7am. For years, we've heard from older generations that the current interest rate pain is nothing compared to the horror of 17.5% rates in the late 80s and early 90s. But now, as the RBA delivers its fourth hike this year, analysis shows the pain being inflicted on homeowners is comparatively worse. So as the official cash rate hits a 15-year high of 4.6%,
Speaker 1how bad could it get? Today, KPMG senior economist Terry Rawnsley, on the chance of more interest rate hikes, the flow-on effects of this latest hit, and whether we should be looking at alternatives, like tax hikes, to get inflation under control. It's Wednesday, September 30th. Terry, this hike from the RBA takes the official cash rate to its highest level in
Speaker 115 years. Talk me through Michelle Bullock's reasoning here.
Speaker 2Yeah, and Michelle kind of outlined a whole range of reasons what's happening here. So she talked about the fuel supply shock coming through from the conflict in the Middle East.
Speaker 3Disruptions to oil supply could last longer than anticipated. and cause energy price pressures to last for longer than we previously assumed.
Speaker 2She talked about AI build-outs.
Speaker 3The AI boom is also adding to demand in the Australian economy at a time when we already have capacity pressures.
Speaker 2She talked about sort of lack of productivity in the business sector.
Speaker 3The bottom line is that productivity is doing nothing. And I know we talk about productivity a lot, but it's so important... if we want the economy to be able to grow and create jobs.
Speaker 2She talked about sort of excess demand coming through from the economy as well. So she kind of described quite a complex situation where there's a whole range of factors which are sort of pushing up overall demand and sort of pushing up inflationary pressures. And she's trying to tap the brakes by increasing rates to kind of take some of the heat out of the economy and reduce some of that demand.
Speaker 1And at the press conference, she was asked whether the solution has become detached from the problem in that inflation is being driven, as you say, and as she said, by oil prices, by the situation in the Middle East, AI, data centre spending, but the response, it hits households who have no control over those things. So, is that a problem here?
Speaker 2Yeah, and it's probably flagging that, as the Governor said many times, they only have one lever to pull, and that's really interest rates. So, even though we have this sort of complex economic patchwork of factors coming through. The RBA can either hold rates, cut rates or increase rates. So, they've got the one tool and today they've just pulled the lever to increase interest rates across the whole economy.
Speaker 1And so, do you think it's a good decision to raise rates right now?
Speaker 2Yeah, it's an unfortunate decision for all those mortgage holders out there and businesses who will be impacted. But it's the point the Reserve Bank Governor made was that there's this excess demand within the economy which we're trying to stamp out. And what we've seen over the last, you know, 18, 24 months is that the inflation has been too high. It's kind of been eating away into people's real wages. The whole economy has been suffering. So, this period of trying to increase interest rates, we're trying to stamp out that inflationary growth. And the governor also talked about inflationary expectations.
Speaker 2And this is basically where If people expect inflation to be 3% or 4% next year, they'll account for that. They'll be expecting their local cafe to put up prices 3% or 4%. Businesses will feel they can put up their prices 3%, 4%, or 5%. So, you don't want to get these expectations entrenched that everyone's like, oh, it's a new financial year, let's increase prices 3% or 4%. We want to try and squeeze back down on those expectations so that people go, okay, the cost of doing business goes up 2%, let's put up inflation by 2%.
Speaker 1This might not be enough to tame inflation though, right? There's already talk of another interest rate hike soon. The RBA says it's prepared to continue to lift rates if it's necessary to fight inflation. So how high do you think things could go?
Speaker 2The other sort of point the governor made was that this is the fourth tapping of the brakes this year. That whole one percentage point's worth of interest rates is still flowing to the economy. There's people who were making investment decisions at the end of last year are now probably rethinking those. People might have cancelled travel plans or eating out less. So, those previous four increases are kind of still working their way through their economy, but the markets are still seeing that we might see another interest rate rise later in the year, maybe Melbourne Cup Day,
Speaker 2and then it's probably going to be a wait and see to see how the rate rises during 2026 plays out in 2027. Okay. And so, interest.
Speaker 1Rates are now at their highest level since 2011. What does that actually mean for people who have a mortgage or other debts?
Speaker 2What we kind of see is that people with mortgages, they'll be paying more interest. And when we look across the whole household sector, on average, households are spending about 6% of their income just on household mortgage repayments. So, $ 100 of income, 6% of that is just going to interest rate repayments. And we sort of look back over the last 30 years, we saw a similar level sort of in the late 1980s, when interest rates were kind of 17%, and a lot of people of that generation will bring up that being a very tough time. But in terms
Speaker 2of the amount of money going towards interest repayments, we're kind of on par with that now. And the other thing is that we've been at this level for probably the last two years, whereas that late 90s was a very short, sharp period of, you know, six, 12 months of that level.
Speaker 1Yeah, let's talk about that a little more, because we often hear from older generations that what's happening today isn't as bad as that infamous 17.5%. interest rate in the late 80s and early 90s. Where Westpac has taken the plunge.
Speaker 3Australia's biggest private bank has pushed up its home loan mortgage rates to an all-time record high of 17%. Now I know that's hurt many people and it's hurting people but I think we must say to them they'll hurt much more if Australia is ultimately forced into a recession.
Speaker 1So what is the comparison?
Speaker 2What we had back then was a 17% interest rate but median house prices across the country were sort of a million dollars or so. Now, we're kind of down more about that 4.5%, 5% interest rates, but house prices across the country are a million dollars. So, whilst those interest rates were much higher back in the late 80s, the size of mortgages people were carrying was much, much smaller. So, we're basically kind of on parity. Interest rates are much lower, but mortgages are much bigger. So, households are spending about the same amount of their income on interest repayments.
Speaker 1And the figure is also averaged across all households. So that includes people without a home loan. Home ownership is much lower now than it was in the 90s. So does that mean that that figure can really understate the pressure that is being felt by households with these large mortgages?
Speaker 2Yeah. And so what you'll have is home ownership rates in the late 1980s were probably about 70% of all households were homeowners. Today, it's about 66% in terms of homeownership. So, you've got that same burden being carried across fewer households. And also, we know that some of those homeownership households, they're probably that boomer generation who have paid off their mortgage. So, we've got more of that Gen Y, the Gen Xs who've got the big mortgages they bought in capital cities over the last 5 or 10 or 15 years. They're
Speaker 2carrying the big mortgages. And the other kind of segment is that Renters are still being bit by this as well. So, we look at the amount of household income going to rents, it's about 4%. And that's sort of the highest it's been over the last five or 10 years because while renters aren't directly paying that mortgage, their landlords are seeing their cost of mortgages go up and they're trying to recoup some of that in high interest rates by jacking up the rents. So, it's not just the homeowners, but also we've got renters are kind of being bitten at the moment.
Speaker 1Still to come, could a recession be on the cards? Terry, we know that with high interest rates comes higher unemployment. So what kind of unemployment rate do you think we're going to be looking at here? Because Michelle Bullock, she has said that she doesn't want job losses. At the same time, the RBA has said in the past that it would like to see unemployment at 5%. Jim Chalmers,
Speaker 1the Treasurer, he says that's too high. What do you think?
Speaker 2We're thinking probably heading more towards that 4.7%. We're currently around 4.5%, 4.6%. So, we will see a tick more up, but there's still a lot of pent-up demand. So, the Reserve Governor sort of mentioned job vacancies are still at a very high level. There's a lot of businesses out there looking to employ. So, tapping the brakes through interest rates will sort of reduce some of that demand, but there's still a lot of vacant jobs out there which businesses are trying to fill, and that's across aged care, construction, engineering,
Speaker 2AI-related jobs. So, there's still a lot of demand in the economy. So, we probably won't see huge job losses, but the question is, do we land at 4.7%, 4.8%, or 5%? And that's kind of the narrow path people are trying to move across here with these interest rates going up. We want to see a cooling in the labour market. We want to see people having less money in their pockets as more is going into The mortgages, interest repayments, more into rent and just less discretionary spending. So we're just trying to tap the brakes so there's less demand in the economy without seeing big increases in unemployment.
Speaker 1And we've been staring down the possibility or the threat of a recession. for a while now. What kind of likelihood do you think there is of that?
Speaker 2Yeah, I think it's definitely a conversation that we're going to be having over the next six or 12 months, just how the economy is responding to these multiple challenges. So, we have higher interest rates, we have consumers who might be feeling a little less rich as house prices ease off, Those households are also seeing the cost of living pressures go up and up, so their spending will be crimped. But we also have government out still spending a significant amount of money across services, infrastructure, and that's both at the state and federal level. You've got this big pent-up
Speaker 2demand that we're seeing coming through through data centres. So, billions of dollars investment from companies who are kind of immune effectively for interest rate rises domestically with very deep pockets investing tens of millions, hundreds of millions in Australia across data centres. And we've also kind of got a housing shortage where there's a pent-up demand where housing construction will still continue. So, there's a whole range of growth factors across there. But regardless, we go into a technical recession, which is two quarters of negative growth. The next sort
Speaker 2of six or 12 months, it's going to be a real grind. The economy will not be growing rapidly at all.
Speaker 1And we all know that interest rates are this blunt lever as a tool to bring inflation down. Do you think that it is still the best option? Because last month we talked with economist Saul Eslake about super as an alternative. There are now some calls for targeted tax rises as a way to cool demand. What do you think of those ideas?
Speaker 2This is where the interest rate is kind of a blunt tool, but it's a very quick and easy one to bring into being. So announcement today, interest rates are going up effectively at midnight tonight. rates will increase and it'll flow through the financial system. If the economy was to slow dramatically at the start of next year, very easy to cut rates. If you're starting to talk about like changing taxation rates or different fees and charges across the economy, it takes it longer for those to be administered. So that's kind of the trade-off. You have some ability
Speaker 2to kind of craft some very focused policies to try and take some heat out of the economy, but that takes time, whereas the Reserve Bank's interest rates It's a blunt tool, but it happens pretty much instantaneously.
Speaker 1And just to finish on housing, does your research ultimately suggest something bigger about Australia's housing system? Because we now need such enormous mortgages to buy a home, and so households have become unusually vulnerable to even relatively modest interest rate moves.
Speaker 2Yeah, the Australian housing system, nothing's gone right in that sector for probably a good 25 to 30 years. We've had probably the taxation settings not being quite right. We've had local planning controls blocking development in well-located areas. We've had greenfield areas not having enough infrastructure to support bigger populations. We've had this big demographic shift where the boomer generation are holding onto their houses for much longer. So, not much right has gone for the Australian housing system over the last 25 years. And once again, there's been a
Speaker 2lot of good reforms over the last five or 10 years around getting more density, especially into established suburbs in Sydney and Melbourne. But those things take two, three, four, five years to come through. So, all these changes are coming through, but the housing system is still in a very tough spot and will be for a few years.
Speaker 1And I mean, how dismayed do you think people are going to be by today's announcement and the prospect of future rate rises in the context of this housing market in which, as you say, not a lot has gone right.
Speaker 2Yeah, there'll be no champagne corks popped for recent home buyers or people who've purchased over the last five-year period who have still got big mortgages. They may not have built up much of an offset account for them or built up a lot of equity depending on where you've bought. So a lot of the community is not going to be very happy about that. We sort of looked at some life satisfaction data from the ABS and in 2021, During the height of the pandemic, Australians said that on average, out of a scale of zero to 10, they were
Speaker 2about 7.4% was their life satisfaction. We fast forward to sort of 2025 and they asked the same question again, and it was 7.1%. So on average, Australian society was feeling sadder about things last year than they were during the pandemic. And that's because they've been sort of ground down by two or three years of high cost of living pressures. They've seen the mortgage go up and up. They've seen the rent go up and up. So it's no surprise that the average Australian household is feeling pretty glum because it's not just been six months of sort
Speaker 2of challenges. It's kind of been a very challenging period over the last three or four years. You throw in the pandemic before that. So a lot of society has been under a lot of stress and strain over the past five years.
Speaker 1Well, Terry, thank you so much for speaking with me. Also in the news, OpenAI has apologised for its AI agent breaching Australian government systems and shelved the planned release of its next chatbot model. In a blog post on Tuesday, the company admitted it should have notified Australian authorities sooner
Speaker 1about a Medicare breach... in which an AI agent gained unauthorised access to its statistics service and retrieved non-public files. OpenAI says it was aware of the breach in August, but only notified the Australian government a month later. It has also stated the planned October release of its next model has been delayed after it failed internal safety tests. And Sarah Hansen-Young has announced she'll run to replace Larissa Waters as leader of the Greens. Waters resigned on Monday due to worsening kidney disease, but will remain in the
Speaker 1Senate after taking medical leave. The Greens are expected to choose their new leader at a two-day party room retreat in Sydney this week. I'm Ruby Jones. This is 7am. Thanks for listening.
At COP31 in Türkiye, Australia has been helping lead global negotiations over the future of fossil fuels and the fight against climate change. But while the Albanese government pushes for stronger international action,...
Anthony Albanese runs a notoriously tight ship. Across his two terms as prime minister, there’s been very little leaking, very little sniping, and very few of his Labor Party colleagues willing to speak out against him....
This week, Australia’s leading health research body released its advice on puberty blockers, saying they should be available for some young people under 18. The Queensland and the Northern Territory governments, which...
In 1945, in the Crimean city of Yalta, three global superpowers - America, Great Britain and the Soviet Union - met to carve up the world between them, each claiming their own sphere of influence in the final year of...
Last week it was Qantas, last month it was NAB: two giants of Australian business cutting jobs due to the growth of AI. The explanations were familiar. Qantas says it will allow the airline to unlock innovation faster...