In France, thousands of arrests have been made and partial curfews imposed across the country, after a weekend of protests that spiralled into violence and looting. The protest movement, which began four weeks ago with students demanding better conditions at high schools, culminated in half a million people protesting the rising cost of living on the weekend. In some areas, shops were looted, and buildings torched. Protests have also broken out in other parts of Europe - including Spain, Belgium and Italy. The French President Emmanuel Macron, has now demanded a full security review and “new operational methods” to end the rioting. Today, writer Sarah Wilson from Paris, on how the protests turned violent, and what it all means for the future of politics in France, and across Europe. If you enjoy 7am, the best way you can support us is by making a contribution at 7ampodcast.com.au/support. Socials: Stay in touch with us on Instagram Guest: Writer Sarah Wilson Photo: Oualid Abdellaoui / JNA PRESS
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1In France, thousands of arrests have been made and partial curfews imposed across the country after a weekend of protests that spiralled into violence and looting. The protest movement, which began four weeks ago with students demanding better conditions at high schools, culminated in half a million people protesting the rising cost of living on the weekend. In some areas, shops were looted and buildings torched. Protests have also broken out in other parts of Europe, including Spain, Belgium and Italy.
Speaker 1The French President Emmanuel Macron has now demanded a full security review and new operational methods to end the rioting. I'm Ruby Jones and you're listening to 7am. Today, writer Sarah Wilson from Paris on how the protests turned violent and what it all means for the future of politics in France and across Europe. It's Wednesday, October 21. Sarah,
Speaker 1you're in Paris right now where there's been more than 100,000 people on the streets over the weekend protesting. Tell me about what you've seen, where you've been.
Speaker 2Yeah, well, I'm sort of right in the middle of all of the protest action, actually. The protests that occurred on Saturday wound around where I live today. But as people started to congregate, the riot police wound up sort of closing off all of the exits.
Speaker 3From the sort of the square quite early on.
Speaker 2And I think by about 11 or 12 o'clock, they were throwing tear gas into the crowd. Now, this is a tactic that's been used over the last couple of weeks when there's been big protests and they've sort of corralled people the students, the young people into these sort of squares and started throwing in tear gas, which has caused a lot of problems. So from there, a bunch of violent outbursts started. Now, I didn't see any of this because I was kind of further up sort of on the parade line and it was incredibly peaceful. It
Speaker 2was like singing and dancing and kids with these really cute little bits of cardboard that they'd obviously been working on overnight. There was people of all different ages, families, parents with signs saying they were there to support the young people of the future, etc. But down back in Republic, there were grenades going off, tear gas, firecrackers. And then looting and burning of cars and bikes started. So there was almost two kind of actions happening.
Speaker 3But then by the late.
Speaker 2Afternoon and into the evening, things descended. And so you would have seen the imagery of.
Speaker 3rioting of these plumes of smoke. There were bonfires in the streets.
Speaker 2I went down there in the evening. I had to meet some friends, my poor friends from Australia who were visiting. It was a war zone. We got trapped in the city in an Uber and we were trying to get out, but all along where the Louvre was, it had been shut down by these young people in black balaclavas. They'd set fire to bikes and bins and The street was completely shut off and the cab driver and I had to get out of the car and negotiate with these young people to pass through.
Speaker 3And to be honest, it was pretty calm.
Speaker 2There wasn't really violence, any violence that I heard of or saw against everyday people. This was violence against property and looting and all this kind of thing. And violence, you know, in terms of fires being started.
Speaker 3Being created.
Speaker 2I should also point out, Ruby, that of the 110,000 people in Paris that day, police have identified only 500 to about 1,000 violent people. So it's a pretty small percentage, but they caused a.
Speaker 3Lot of problems.
Speaker 2Right.
Speaker 1And let's go back to how this all began, because a few weeks ago, it was just some high school students who were in a working class neighbourhood of Paris, and they were protesting conditions at their school. So how did what began as this fairly small group of young people, how did it turn into what we're now seeing across the entire country?
Speaker 2Yeah, so it started in one of the balieux, the suburbs, the poorest suburbs outside of Paris in Cotille. They were protesting really poor conditions. At first I was like, oh yeah, overcrowded classrooms, that happens everywhere. But it's actually more extensive than this. A large proportion of schools around France have asbestos. Now, that doesn't have to be a problem, but these schools are crumbling because there's no money to maintain them. So there's imagery of ceilings collapsing in and rats running through the classrooms. I've heard of students talking about how there's
Speaker 2only four toilet cubicles at this school and two of them have doors missing and haven't been repaired in two years.
Speaker 3Substitute teachers will just not be substituted or put.
Speaker 2In place for like two months. So there's kids that are just not having maths lessons. So when this happened, it actually prompted a whole range of, I guess, you could call schools in middle-class suburbs in Paris to join in because they said, well, listen, we have reasonably decent conditions. We should join this protest because this is unfair that there's other children living in these conditions at school. So eventually, I think it's a thousand schools joined the blockages and around France, it's a significant proportion of schools in the country,
Speaker 2and their demands were reasonable.
Speaker 4Meaning we're not being listened to, we don't have enough money, our priorities are not the government priority, and that also triggers lots of anxiety regarding climate change as well, regarding just money and our ability to have a proper future.
Speaker 3The French people actually pretty much sided with these students.
Speaker 2And so there was a march last Tuesday that brought in 450,000 people around France. And this was just on a Tuesday, a random Tuesday. And you saw parents, you saw firefighters joining the kids. It became kind of pretty much a movement fighting for conditions of.
Speaker 3Equality across the country.
Speaker 2What happened, though, was that over the course of the last couple of weeks, the police have become increasingly heavy-handed with the students. You've probably heard that one kid lost his hand, another kid lost his eye. There's been huge amounts of tear gases, thousands of kids who've been arrested and treated in a really appalling way. And this has brought out teachers, but also retirees, all kinds of people in support who have actually stood between the police and
Speaker 2the students to protect them. So what started out as a, you know, let's make schools more fair and improve conditions, turned into an anti-police, anti-fascist protest fairly quickly.
Speaker 1OK, and so protesters, they're angry about a lot of things, including the cost of living. So tell me a bit more about what it's like to live in France at the moment and how The pressures of the war in the Middle East have impacted people's lives and what it's like to actually be someone who is trying to carve out a life in France right now.
Speaker 3Well, I think it's a situation that we're seeing around.
Speaker 2The world, particularly fuelled by the increasing fuel prices. The main difference, though, here in France is the French don't stand for this. They basically expect their government to work for them. And there's this idea that the streets exist for the people. And that's a phrase that you'll see in graffiti around the city at the moment. And there's also a sense that protesting is an absolute right, that the people have the right to protest in this way. And that's, of course, existed since the French Revolution in 1789.
Speaker 3And they are so proud of this heritage. So this is the difference.
Speaker 2They feel that democracy isn't something that is being violated by all of these protests. Democracy is something that needs to be defended through these protests. And I heard somebody, a commentator, who is an expert in sort of, I guess, French culture, and he says that these protests are the French having a conversation with itself about where it's going to head. And I think, you know, French have always led the charge in this kind of thing and now, of course, it's rolling out around the rest of Europe.
Speaker 2So now we're seeing a lot of these protests taking off in Spain and Italy and Portugal and so on.
Speaker 1Still to come, the political fallout from the riots. Sarah, the next French presidential election is in about six months' time. It was already set to be a historic election. Marine Le Pen on the far right is the likely next president. When you look at the political landscape in France, you've got Le Pen on the right condemning the protests. You've
Speaker 1got Mélenchon on the left actually joining in with protesters. And then you've got the current president, Macron, kind of attempting to walk this middle line. So conceding that the protesters have some things to be angry about, but condemning the rioting and the looting. Tell me a bit more about the different responses that we're seeing and what that says to you about the future in France.
Speaker 2Yeah, I mean, they're fairly obvious responses. The far right is blaming the left. There doesn't seem to be any evidence that the far left party led by Melanchon is actually stoking any of this. Yes, he's been attending. Yes, he's been supporting the students' demands. One thing that should be brought into all of this is there is actually a militant group that seems to be involved.
Speaker 3It's called the Black Bloc.
Speaker 2It's not so much a group, but a tactic, and it's existed for a number of decades here in Europe. It essentially mobilises people. It used to be on Facebook. Now, of course, there's AI. And they mobilise. They dress in black. That's how you identify them. They actually arrive with balaclavas, goggles on and umbrellas to protect them from tear gas and water cannons from the police. They do seem to be behind a lot of the violence that we saw over the weekend. So this should be borne in mind.
Speaker 2The far left are distancing themselves from, you know, sort of what some of these black block tactics have been about. But they're also calling out what the police have done. The police behaviour has been quite extreme. And I think the French are quite shocked by this because it isn't usually this bad. And so there's a sense that Macron is getting heavy handed in order to appeal to the right and far right ahead of the elections. And so Marine Le Pen's party, of course, is weaponising everything that's going on and very much focusing on the migrant issue and,
Speaker 2I guess, the skin colour of some of these protesters who happen to, of course, be marginalised and happen to be the most angry about what's going on.
Speaker 3They are at the schools that are really missing out on funding.
Speaker 2So, yes, it's no coincidence this has all sort of surfaced ahead of the.
Speaker 3Election in April.
Speaker 2And it's really hard to know where this is all going to head.
Speaker 1And is the danger here for someone like Mélenchon that if he is associated with protests that ultimately become violent, that that could end up damaging his chances with a section of the community who might not want to vote for that?
Speaker 3There is that risk.
Speaker 2But I will say that the French do have a capacity to see through the nuance of this.
Speaker 3They've seen this happen many, many times before. So.
Speaker 2While there is a lot of concern about the violence and the looting and the rioting, what I'm hearing, and I went down to the Republic on Sunday morning where a lot of locals were just standing around talking about all of this together, just trying to comprehend what was going on. And for my limited French, I got a bit of an understanding that, you know, they're really, really fleshing out and distinguishing the violence.
Speaker 3From actually what the real cause is here.
Speaker 2So I think in France there's an ability to navigate the nuances of all of this. It really is going to depend on what the public debate looks like over the next six months, whether they're able to continue to discuss things in a nuanced way. And it'll probably depend on also how much the far right is able to leverage things. I've already seen this morning the far right in the UK with Tommy Robinson and so on escalating the tensions. I've also noticed that the media in Australia, the mainstream media, is reporting on this in a very
Speaker 2extremist way, focusing on the violence rather than the actual message and the 110,000 peaceful protesters who did things in the way that the French really approve of. So I think, yeah, I think there's probably room for the Russian bot factories to have a go at things here and for the far right to take things in a.
Speaker 3Bad faith direction.
Speaker 1And so what do the next few days and weeks look like? Authorities in France are cracking down more heavily now on the rioters. Thousands of people have been arrested. Do you think that Macron will be able to diffuse the anger that's underlying the protest movement?
Speaker 2Yeah, well, overnight the rioting continued and the violence continued, which I was quite shocked with. So some of these, you know, black masked kids, and they seem to be quite young, We're mobilising around the centre of Paris and causing more damage. It's early morning here. I can hear sirens outside. I suspect that this is going to continue. In terms of the radical anger that's behind some of this Black Bloc movement and so on, which are potentially opportunists in all of this, but I think there is
Speaker 2actually some legitimate anger going on too, I.
Speaker 3Can't see how this is going to end.
Speaker 2I think this is going to be ongoing and I think we're going to see this across the winter, across Europe. We're going to see these kinds of groups leveraging the anger, you know, the sort of, I guess, reasonable anger of the people and competing with the fascists, you know, the far right, who.
Speaker 3Are also going to want to sort of fill this.
Speaker 2Vacuum of meaning and sense-making at a very difficult time in history. There's two radical groups at the fringes who are sort of, I guess, misguiding what is actually going on. So Macron's got a big job ahead of him in terms of sense-making this for the French people.
Speaker 1Well, Sarah, thank you so much for speaking with us.
Speaker 3My pleasure. Thank you.
Speaker 1Also in the news, Victoria is contemplating increased security at next month's state election after independent Helen Haynes was struck twice by a foil drive outside her office in the state's north.
Speaker 3Late on Tuesday, the Wangaratta.
Speaker 1Community gathered for a prayer vigil for the federal MP who has lost a leg as a result of her injuries. 43-year-old Brendan Nugent remains in police custody after being arrested at the scene of the accident. It's been reported that police visited Nugent's property three months ago after neighbours became concerned about his erratic behaviour. And the National Australia Bank has become the latest of the big four to announce massive job cuts. 2,500 employees, about 6% of the workforce, will depart this financial year.
Speaker 3I'm Ruby Jones. This is 7am. Thanks for listening.
At COP31 in Türkiye, Australia has been helping lead global negotiations over the future of fossil fuels and the fight against climate change. But while the Albanese government pushes for stronger international action,...
Anthony Albanese runs a notoriously tight ship. Across his two terms as prime minister, there’s been very little leaking, very little sniping, and very few of his Labor Party colleagues willing to speak out against him....
This week, Australia’s leading health research body released its advice on puberty blockers, saying they should be available for some young people under 18. The Queensland and the Northern Territory governments, which...
In 1945, in the Crimean city of Yalta, three global superpowers - America, Great Britain and the Soviet Union - met to carve up the world between them, each claiming their own sphere of influence in the final year of...
Last week it was Qantas, last month it was NAB: two giants of Australian business cutting jobs due to the growth of AI. The explanations were familiar. Qantas says it will allow the airline to unlock innovation faster...