Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

7am

7am artwork

Who decided AI was inevitable?

Jul 27, 202618 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Cory Doctorow is the author and tech critic who brought us the term ‘enshittification’ - which refers to the gradual decline in the quality of digital platforms and services over time. Now he’s warning that what we’ve been led to believe is the inevitable march of AI towards world domination isn’t that inevitable after all, and actually what we’re marching towards could be the end of the AI bubble. Because every time you ask ChatGPT, Claude, or Gemini a question, companies like OpenAI are losing money. The more we use, the more they lose. And while those AI giants burn through billions of dollars a year, gambling that eventually they’ll figure out how to turn it into a profitable business, the world’s economy is hanging in the balance. Today, Cory Doctorow, on why the AI boom is being pushed into every part of our lives and what happens when the bubble bursts. If you enjoy 7am, the best way you can support us is by making a contribution at 7ampodcast.com.au/support. Cory Doctorow is in Australia this August for appearances at Sydney’s Festival of Dangerous Ideas, and in Melbourne at The Capitol, presented by The Wheeler Centre and Now or Never. His new book, The Reverse Centaur’s Guide to Life After AI, is out via Verso Socials: Stay in touch with us on Instagram Guest: Author Cory Doctorow Photo: AAP Image/James Ross

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Corey Doctor Rowe is the author and tech critic who brought us the term and shitification.

Speaker 2First, a company is good to its end users, then it locks them in, and then it is good to its business customers, who then get locked in, and then it takes all the value for itself, leaving behind a giant pile of shit that is in shitification, a tragedy in three acts.

Speaker 1Now his warning that what we've been led to believe is the inevitable march of AI towards world domination. Isn't that inevitable after all? And actually what we're marching towards could be the end of the AI bubble Because every time you ask Chat, GPT, Claude or Gemini a question, companies like open ai are losing money.

Speaker 3The more we use, the more they lose.

Speaker 1And while those AI giants burn through billions of dollars a year gambling that eventually they'll figure out how to turn it into a profitable business, the world's economy is hanging in the balance. I'm Ruby Jones, and you're listening to seven AM today Corey doctor Oh on why the AI boom is being pushed into every part of our lives and what happens when the bubble bursts. It's Tuesday,

Speaker 1July twenty eighth.

Speaker 3Corey, Welcome to seven AM. Thanks for coming on the show.

Speaker 2Oh well, thank you for having me on.

Speaker 1So I thought we could begin by talking about some of the claims that are made around AI and its inevitability. The way it's sort of framed is this technology that has arrived.

Speaker 3It's going to change the nature of work.

Speaker 1It's going to fundamentally reshape life.

Speaker 3As we know it.

Speaker 1So to begin with, tell me a bit about who's making these claims and why they are.

Speaker 2Well, I think that we've heard these claims before. We heard that cryptocurrency was going to replace all of our trains actions, that the metaverse was going to replace the web that NFTs, where we're going to replace all art.

Speaker 4We're talking about AI physics or AI biology for drug discovery, AI agents for customer service and support of diagnosis, and of course physical AI robotic systems.

Speaker 2This kind of claim to declare a fatal complete even before you've got started, is very powerful rhetorically. All of these AI capabilities that make you smarter, help you communicate better, improve your memory, improve your senses, and more. It's a way to exterminate any thought that things might be different before you can even start thinking about it.

Speaker 5Anthropic, we talk a lot about the exponential, and I think that's what we're all feeling right now. The jumps keep getting bigger and the intervals keep getting shorter.

Speaker 2And we hear it now from AI people who are desperately trying to explain how they can take a sector that grosses fifty billion American dollars a year and somehow turn it into a profit making venture, despite the fact that they've spent more than a trillion dollars just this year, and despite the fact that every generation of it is less profitable than the previous generation, and despite the fact that they're having to replace all of their hardware every two to three years.

Speaker 6Sard from opening I CEO Sam Altman with a fresh look at the company's financials. He says that they expect their annualized revenue run rate to top twenty billion dollars this year it was thirteen billion dollars before that, and to grow to hundreds of billions by twenty thirty. That's also a revision upward.

Speaker 1Yeah, so this kind of talk, it's led to what many people have speculated is in AI bubble, but believing big tech when it talks about what AI can and will do. We've now arrived at this place where we have vastly overestimated its value. So what is your view on whether AI is actually providing what it's promising the productivity and profit.

Speaker 2Well, the productivity and profit are nowhere to be found in the world. You have some ANNEC data from individuals who say, well, I've used AI and made myself far more productive. But when you actually look at the firms that have deployed AI, what you find is that even with the massive subsidy the AI companies are offering, and the subsidies can't be overstated. Basically, at this point, AI companies are selling hundred dollar bills at a dollar apiece, and even with that, you're not finding the productivity gains

Speaker 2that firms were hoping for. We keep seeing firms that fire large numbers of workers and then have to try and hire them back. But even worse was about a month ago when the AI companies were all thinking about their IPOs and they said, well, let's clean up our balance sheets a little and raise the price of these hundred dollar bills to five dollars apiece, and all of the CEOs, even the ones who've been most enthusiastic about using AI, suddenly turned around and said, wait, your one hundred dollar bills were barely worth it at a dollar each, but at five dollars each, there's just no way we're

Speaker 2going to be able to continue to buy these things. And they suddenly went from saying you're going to get fired if you don't use AI to you're going to get fired if you keep using AI, at least in the way you've been using it so far.

Speaker 1Yeah, so you're saying these companies AI companies like open Ai and Anthropic, they aren't actually making real profits. In fact, they're losing billions of dollars a year, yet the valuation of their stock is skyrocketing. So what is the impact of that.

Speaker 2Yeah, Well, the shares and affirm that are growing are worth far more than the shares of affirm that is mature. And that's because a share is a claim on the future income of a company. So if you can imagine two companies, each of which turns over a million dollars this year, but one of which is expected to double in size next year, you could see why shares in that company that's doubling in size would be worth more than the shares in the company that are static. And when your shares enjoy what's called this high price to earnings ratio, when they're valued this highly, they become extremely

Speaker 2liquid and you can use them in place of cash. And the advantage of shares over dollars is that shares are an endogenous product. They're made within the four walls of the company through the simple expedient of typing zeros into spreadsheets. And the corollary of this is that when you stop growing, when you become mature, which has to happen eventually. Right, if you're Google with a ninety percent search market share, you're not going to grow your search market share anymore, right, And so you know, when you cap out your growth, your company becomes grossly overvalued because

Speaker 2it's been valued as a growth company, but now it's a mature company. And at that point you see these panic sell offs. This is why every time tech companies announce very small slowdowns in their growth or reversals, you get these mass selloffs. You know, Facebook had a two hundred and forty billion dollars one day sell off in the first quarter of twenty twenty two, after announcing it had slightly fewer American signups than they'd anticipate.

Speaker 5It is on Wall Street this morning after shares of Facebook's parent Come company plunged yesterday.

Speaker 2Is stock continuing to tumble this week after a disappointing report this quarter, shares.

Speaker 1In Facebook now called Meta, plunging twenty six percent after results showed people are turning away from the social media platform.

Speaker 2It was the largest decapitalization of any firm in the history of markets until it happened again to Nvidia a couple of years later, this time to the tune of three quarters of a trillion dollars. But if you can't grow, well, the next best thing is to promise you're going to grow right, to say, well, look we're about to conquer a new imaginary market in NFTs or web three, or now that AI is getting a little stale as super intelligence. And you know, all of these things benefit in part from having technical meanings that aren't well understood or even well defined, So you can claim that you're going to

Speaker 2conquer a market that no one else understands, which means when they say that that market isn't worth what you say it is. You can repost by saying, nuh uh. I'm the only person in the world who even knows what this market is, so how can you tell me it's not as big as I claim it's going to be.

Speaker 1But the scale here when we're talking about AI is where this gets a bit frightening. I mean, you say, we've reached the point where the US economy, which really, by extension means the world economy, depends on AI and its growth.

Speaker 3So how precarious is that?

Speaker 2Oh, it's extremely precarious. This is the frightening thing about AI. It's not like that we're going to teach too many words to the word guessing program and it's going to wake up and become God and turn us into paper clips or something. It's that seven firms, six of whom are losing money to the seventh one represent thirty five percent of the S and P five hundred, the most important financial index in the world. They are all passing around the same one hundred billion dollar IOU and pretending that it's in all of their bank accounts at once, which you know, to call that accounting fraud is to do violence to the noble accounting fraud. And at the

Speaker 2same time, every new generation of AI is less profitable than the previous one. Every new customer for AI costs THEII companies money, and every time the AI companies have a customer that uses their products, they lose even more money. Meanwhile, the actual hard assets, the data centers, the GPUs, they're being replaced every like two to three years, and I think we underestimate just how much of that hard capital has to be thrown away with every generation of the technology. And often it's the case that to retrofit a data

Speaker 2center it would cost more than scraping into the foundation slab and building a new one when you buy new chips for it. So all of this stuff is basically disposable, and you add it all up and it just doesn't turn into a business you could bail out. It's not like buying a bunch of distressed real estate assets that when you're done, are real estate that people can live in. It's like buying a toxic waste dump that's on fire and you don't know how to put out the fire. In every year, you have to commit more resources to evacuating people from the region because it's poisoning their soil

Speaker 2and their air.

Speaker 3Coming up.

Speaker 1What will happen to workers in the AI boom and eventual bust. So Corey, you in your book make the case that nothing is inevitable about AI, and the best way to think about it is in terms of whether we are driving it to work for us or whether it's being used to force us to change our behavior.

Speaker 3Talk me through that idea.

Speaker 2Yeah, for sure. You know, this isn't the first time labor and automation have come into conflict, and one of its bedrocks is that when labor drives automation adoption, typically it's in service to making things better. Workers want to improve their outputs. When capital drives automation, they want to maximize quantity, not quality, and often it's quantity at the expense of quality. And so we see automation now in AI being driven almost exclusively by capital. You know, when you read the business press, it's not like the early

Speaker 2two thousands, where you know, Harvard Business Review was publishing panicked articles about what CEOs we're going to do about all the young workers who expected to use the web at the office. Now it's full of articles about how c are threatening to fire workers unless they use AI. Right, So you know this is very much capital driven automation. But when you are the weakest link in the chain, when you're the bottleneck and the output of the machine, then you're going to be worked at the absolute limit of your capacity by a machine that by definition can

Speaker 2last longer than you, move faster than you, and is stronger than you, which means that the minute you make a mistake, you're in for a world of hurt. You know, Amazon built the world's most automated warehouses. They're also the warehouses with the highest rate of injury. That's not a coincidence. It's the consequence you don't pay eight figures for warehouse automation and run the machine slower than you need to. And when you run the machine at the maximum speed of the people who operate in it and around it, it means that the minutes someone gets something wrong, they get impaled on a forklift.

Speaker 1Can we talk a little more about workers, because your contention here seems to be that tech companies are pushing the exponential growth of AI because growth is key to their survival. To do that, they are in turn convincing bosses of companies that AI can do the jobs of their workers, meaning that they'll be able to either fire those workers or pay them less, leading to more profit for the company. So where does all of this leave workers.

Speaker 2Yeah, well, you know, I think you just have to understand that, like, bosses are infinitely horny to get rid of workers because every day they have ego shattering confrontations with people who know how to do things that they don't know how to do, and who you know, tell them every time they show up with a great idea that it's illegal or moral or it's going to kill a bunch of people. And you can you know, dispel that fear that you're in the back seat with a Fisher Price steering wheel instead of in the driver's seat by using AI to like come up with the product idea and the AI craps it out and you don't

Speaker 2have to like actually talk to people about it. And what you get is a very dim world for workers. Which is not to say that AI isn't useful for workers. I mean, I think the way to resolve the paradox of for example, programmers who sometimes say, well, I use AI and my code is better than it's ever been. I can't believe how much I'm getting done, and other programmers who are also skilled and also reliable narrators of their experience, who say, I can't believe how much tech debt we're incurring at my company. You know, we make whatever av onics never get on an airplane again, because

Speaker 2we have shoveled so much bad code into the world's civilian aircraft that they should never be trusted to fly. And you know, you look at those two groups of people and you know, try to resolve this seeming paradox in what you find inevitably is that the first group of workers are choosing how they use AI, and the second group of workers, well, they've seen all their colleagues fired, and they're being asked to work at ten times the former speed, to mark the AI's homework and take the blame when it goes wrong. And so, you know, I think that there's plenty of useful things we can do

Speaker 2with AI. I just don't think we're going to do them in the conditions in which the imperative is to fire workers and replace them with software.

Speaker 1So we're at the point now where the tech itself is being used by corporations. Sometimes it works expense but it's likely vastly over valued. So what happens if that bubble bursts?

Speaker 2Well, you know, not all bubbles are created equally. If you remember the Enron bubble, where you had this energy trading firm that was just doing accounting fraud and sucking up the money of ordinary people who were just trying to save so that they wouldn't starve to death or be homeless when they got old. When they popped, there was nothing left behind for all the billions they stole. Meanwhile, there was another fraud at the same time called WorldCom, and WorldCom is also an accounting fraud, but wasn't a pure accounting fraud. WorldCom's claim was they had hundreds of billions of dollars in fiber optic orders, and to kind

Speaker 2of make the show look good, they dug up streets all over the world and put fiber optic in the ground. And that fiber optic is still there. So when you look at contemporary bubbles like cryptocurrency, it's not really going to leave anything behind. When crypto goes to zero, we'll have like ugly monkey JPEGs and stupid Austrian economics. But when AI goes to zero, was still have data centers, we'll still have GPUs, We'll have a lot of workers who know how to do stuff, and we're going to have these open source models that have barely been touched, barely been optimized, and every time someone looks at them,

Speaker 2they can find all kinds of ways to make them perform better. And I think, if anything, we'll probably see some pretty good stuff as a result of that. Notwithstanding that the economic crisis is going to be terrible, and when a third of the stock market is vaporized because these firms, you know, have to finally mark their assets to market and stop pretending that their IOUs are and all their bank accounts at once, we'll probably see governments around the world do austerity again, which is just going to drive more people into the arms of fascists. But in terms of the technology, it'll probably be a bit like Web two point zero, where all the stupid bosses

Speaker 2left the Bay Area and you could buy the servers they left behind for pennies on the dollar, and all the workers who had interesting ideas for what to do suddenly didn't have to convince their bosses that these were good ideas, and you know, they hired each other and made some interesting stuff. You know. I was living in San Francisco when the dot com bubble burst. One of the things that I'd always craved during that whole bubble was these very fancy ergonomic chairs from Steelcase called the leap Chair, that were about fifteen hundred dollars each. And I remember a day walking through the mission where I lived, and there was a dot com ceo in front of

Speaker 2the office where he just lost his lease, selling like a fleet of Steelcase leap chairs still in the plastic for twenty five dollars apiece. I bought six of them and use them as a dining room set for the next ten years. Right, you know the idea of like buying AI now, it's like buying your Steelcase leaf chairs in like the spring of twenty twenty, when you can see the fall of twenty twenty coming at you like a freight train, when you're gonna be able to buy things for pennies. Right, just just wait. If you really feel you need a sovereign AI, just wait and buy

Speaker 2it then.

Speaker 3Well, Corey, thank you so much for speaking with me.

Speaker 2Well, thank you very much.

Speaker 3Cory.

Speaker 1Doctor Rowe is in Australia. This August for appearances at Sydney's Festival of Dangerous Ideas and in Melbourne at the Capitol presented by the Wheel Center and now or ever, his new book, The Reverse Centaur's Guide to Life After AI is out now. Also when the news Victoria's Premier to Center Allen could today be rolled just months out

Speaker 1from the November state election. A group of ministers and MPs met with the Premier yesterday urging her to stand down. Deputy Premier Ben Carroll has advised the Premier that he intends to be a candidate for leadership in the event of a spill, which is likely to unfold a caucus meeting today and South Australia has recorded seven new suspected cases of H five bird flu. If further testing of the cases by the CSIRO comes back positive, it'll take the total number of bird flu detections in South Australia to fourteen. Today, there have been no H five bird

Speaker 1flu detections in the poultry industry, captive birds, pet or other wildlife and livestock andmory industries and wildlife organizations say they're working alongside the state government to state vigilant I'm Ruby Jones.

Speaker 3This is seven AM. Thanks for listening.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Guests

  • Cory Doctorow Guest Inferred

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. How Albanese killed the climate wars

    Nov 21, 202615 minAudio

    At COP31 in Türkiye, Australia has been helping lead global negotiations over the future of fossil fuels and the fight against climate change. But while the Albanese government pushes for stronger international action,...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Ed Husic on being ‘left in the dark’ by his own government

    Nov 20, 202617 minAudio

    Anthony Albanese runs a notoriously tight ship. Across his two terms as prime minister, there’s been very little leaking, very little sniping, and very few of his Labor Party colleagues willing to speak out against him....

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Puberty blockers greenlit: So why are state bans still in place?

    Nov 19, 202615 minAudio

    This week, Australia’s leading health research body released its advice on puberty blockers, saying they should be available for some young people under 18. The Queensland and the Northern Territory governments, which...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Will Trump, Xi and Putin try to carve up the world?

    Nov 18, 202616 minAudio

    In 1945, in the Crimean city of Yalta, three global superpowers - America, Great Britain and the Soviet Union - met to carve up the world between them, each claiming their own sphere of influence in the final year of...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. AI job cuts at Bunnings, Qantas, NAB: ‘Mass unemployment is the business plan’

    Nov 17, 202616 minAudio

    Last week it was Qantas, last month it was NAB: two giants of Australian business cutting jobs due to the growth of AI. The explanations were familiar. Qantas says it will allow the airline to unlock innovation faster...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode