Karl Stefanovic has spent decades as one of the most recognisable faces on Australian television. A household name from the largely inoffensive world of breakfast television. Now, that multi-million dollar career at Nine is officially over, after Stefanovic published an interview with Tommy Robinson, a British far-right activist with a long criminal history, who has built a large following based on hate-driven rhetoric towards Muslims, immigrants, the changing face of Britain; and on the claim that he’s being silenced by the establishment. But the fall out from the podcast, including his split with Nine, may have worked in Stefanovic’s favour as he tries to forge a new career in outrage podcasting. Today, Crikey’s media reporter Daanyal Saeed on Karl Stefanovic, the interview that ended his time at nine, and the audience he may have been chasing all along. If you enjoy 7am, the best way you can support us is by making a contribution at 7ampodcast.com.au/support. Socials: Stay in touch with us on Instagram Guest: Crikey media reporter Daanyal Saeed Photo: The Karl Stefanovic Show
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Karl Stefanovic wasn't always an anti Wod crusader.
Speaker 2Well, as we all know, I can be a complete tool right, Well, yesterday I was worse. I was an ignorant tool. When I say ignorant, I truly meant it.
Speaker 1Karl Stefanovic has spent decades as one of the most recognizable faces on Australian television.
Speaker 2Now, more than ever, we need to educate ourselves, laugh together and embrace each other's differences, and live with tolerance, compassion and most of all, love and respect for everyone.
Speaker 1A household name from the largely inoffensive world of breakfast TV.
Speaker 2This country is built on so many pillars, including those who come from far away lands with not much more than hope and a drive for a better life for their family. They have made this a better place. They helped make modern Australian.
Speaker 1Now that multimillion dollar career at nine is officially over after Stefanovick published an interview with Tommy Robertson, a British far right activist with long criminal history, a large following based on hate driven rhetoric towards Muslims, immigrants, the changing face of Britain, and on the claim he's being silenced by the establishment.
Speaker 2Key Starmer's out, Tommy Robinson's on the show tonight and Tommy, how you feeling. I'm good to go answer the question.
Speaker 3Yes, Keir Starmer is a.
Speaker 1Way, but the fallout from the podcast, including the split mid nine, may have worked in Stephanovick's favor as he tries to forge a new career in outrage podcasting. I'm Daniel James and you're listening to seven AM Today, Craikey's media reporter Danielle said on Karl Stefanovic, the interview that ended his time at nine at the audience he may have been chasing all along. It's Friday, June twenty sixth.
Speaker 1Only before we get to the details of how all this unfolded, let's start with where we're at.
Speaker 4Welcome back you.
Speaker 5Watching Today and look, we know there has been a lot of speculation about Carl's future with the show this morning. We wanted to inform you that Carl will not be returning to The Today Show or Tonine. Yeah.
Speaker 6Look, as you know, he's been pursuing a podcast project independently of nine for the last few months and it's been decided he'll be injecting all of his energy and attention into that as doing both is no longer possible.
Speaker 3So all we do know at the moment is that Karl Stefanovic. We don't know the details of the contract, but it appears that he has been either released for his contract or sacked.
Speaker 7Laurie knows that that.
Speaker 3Contract was due to expire in December, and it's been rumored for quite a while now that the Karl Stefanovic Show the Independent podcast has been increasingly extreme, increasingly involving fringe fire right actors, and part of the motivation for that, it has been reported, is because Karl wants out of that contract.
Speaker 2Hey guys, some weaker, so unfree, truly independent. I don't know what I'm gonna do, but I'll figure it out.
Speaker 1Okay, So let's go to the podcast and question. Karl had a guest on, a controversial far right activist from the UK named Stephen Christopher Yaxley Lennon, better known as Tommy Robinson. What can you tell us about him and why platforming him is so problematic?
Speaker 3So Tommy Robinson has been the face of the far right anti Islam movement in the UK, for the best part of the last fifteen years.
Speaker 7He's you know, this.
Speaker 3Anti migration actors. He was a paid up member of the British National Party. He was a paid up fascist before that, as part of fascist political parties in the UK sort of in the mid two thousands, and then more recently he has sort of been able to mobilize that following. It's sort of been retained with the sort of the anti migrant sentiment that sort of went with Brexit and then went with across the Western world with the election Trump and so on. That's been sort of parlayed into mobilized and followers for riots in the UK.
Speaker 8Violence is coming to us, It's already here. Hostile communities have been important into our nation. Who are not going to in the brain, they're not going to assimilate. It's head into a clash.
Speaker 3He has been sort of a big supporter of the predecessor to what is now the Reform Party UKIT. People that have been involved in that party sort of distanced themselves from him. Snigel Farad obviously the leader of Reform, was the leader of UKIT. He has said he would not be welcome in Reform and Reform is for our Australian listeners sort of the UK equivalent of one nation. Effectively, this is a man who where the Australian body politicans will get into, has welcomed into its. The UK conservative
Speaker 3body politic has said this is too much for us. I never wanted Tommy Robinson to join UK.
Speaker 7I don't want him to join reform a UK and he won't me.
Speaker 3And I think there's another interesting point there about the use of the pseudonym.
Speaker 7There's the class elements of that.
Speaker 3This is fundamentally not a working classman, and he wants to style himself as a working classman because it's politically convenient.
Speaker 7So what does he do.
Speaker 3He takes away the double barrel of Yasley Lennon and he styles himself as Tommy Robinson.
Speaker 7So there's an element of that too.
Speaker 3There's a reason he didn't use a big, long winded, double barrel pseudonym.
Speaker 7He used something that sounded in his mind more working class.
Speaker 1Robinson also presents himself as someone who's been punished for telling the truth, jailed, censored, silenced by the establishment. That's obviously central toward he would think his appeal is this idea that he's a free speech matter the media won't let you hear. But what's the reality of his legal history.
Speaker 3This is a man who has a long, long history with the law. You know, assault convictions, fake passports, morgad fraud, contempt of court. He's been convicted over and I think this is the most troubling part for someone who styles himself.
Speaker 7As a journalist. He has convictions for stalking and harassing journalists.
Speaker 4So you want to note this anti journalist, I will find you just that respect. Do you want to question any question, do not give the locations or potagraph do anything.
Speaker 7In front of my family.
Speaker 2Right.
Speaker 3There was a BBC documentary about him, which he sort of discusses as sort of silencing him. He produced the documentary called Silence with Info Wars Alex Jones again like sort of American conspiracy theorist.
Speaker 8This is a documentary about the length they will go to to shut down and silence anyone from bringing you, the British public, the truth.
Speaker 1And what can you tell us about the interview itself, DARNI because they looked pretty charming in the trailer tape and from what I saw, what did they talk about and did Carl push back on any of Tommy's extremism.
Speaker 3No, not really is the long and short of that. It is, Yeah, like a really really chummy interview. Karl doesn't speak that much, which again, like of itself, is not necessarily sort of a journalistic issue. But there are lots of points where Tommy Robinson quite rightly should be called out. He talks about the only people he describes as having an issue with his kind of rhetric are these Jahadi gangs. He describes Luton as this sort of
Speaker 3which is working class town in England, as sort of taken over by Muslims. You know, fifteen years ago we had one mosque, now we've got forty five. This sort of retric to the extent that was serious about things like social cohesion.
Speaker 7We really should be pushing back on things like this.
Speaker 1Okay, So Karl does the interview tease, The interview for his podcast goes out in the socials and then is published, but less than twelve hours later disappears from social media on podcast platforms. What happened?
Speaker 7So this is the million dollar question or the two million dollar question.
Speaker 1Yeah, two point three million dollar question.
Speaker 7It really is at the moment pretty unclear.
Speaker 3The only outlet that has claimed to have some sort of detail about this is the Australian who Steve Jackson, their media diorist, has published his piece and in it he says that Stefanovick brought down the podcast himself.
Speaker 7I'm quoting here from Australia.
Speaker 3Now it has understood Stefanovick and later made the decision to delete the interview from the social media channels himself after the network's boss has raised concerns about the chat and he began to comprehend the sensitivity of the situation.
Speaker 7But that nine never specifically asked him to remove the vision.
Speaker 3It's interesting, like if it is true that he has simply realized the gravity of it after the fact, then I don't think.
Speaker 7I'm allowed to swear on this. But he's a moron, Like he must be a.
Speaker 1Moron, very slow on the uptake.
Speaker 3If it is not immediately apparent to you that Tommy Robinson is a fire right experience and it is problematic for the fourth biggest Australian on the Spotify charts, the biggest man in television, the highest highly paid man in television. If it's not apparent to you that there's a problem with that, you're an idiot. I think we need to have a really serious conversation about the kinds of talent that we platform in this country, as is the face of breakfast television. I think there should be some serious reflection at nine. But nine are in this fine right. There's this really comical game of professional Chicken. Might understand
Speaker 3how problematic this is. They're journalists, are really upset about the impact it has on their reputations. But the minute you let ca' go, I am almost certain there will be an episode of the cast Epanovic Show along the lines of why I was canceled by the mainstream media. Why I here's my tell all about how and why I left nine? And I suspect nine would have wanted to avoid that for as long as possible worth noting that Carl took a half million dollar pay cut to continue with nine. The economics of paying television talent these
Speaker 3enormous salaries is that that doesn't work anymore, not in Australia. That gravy train across the industry, not just at nine, is over.
Speaker 7That's primarily I.
Speaker 3Think the reason why Karl wanted to exit is to make up that difference elsewhere.
Speaker 1Coming out. Does this play right into the hands of Karl and he's far right Rose Darning. I think for a lot of people this transformation from Becky TV host to Australia's Joe Rogan or Tucker Carlson has come as a shock. But you say this has been coming for a while. Now. What signs did you spot in this trajectory the.
Speaker 3Part of which it became really clear to me that Karl's media diet was changing. And he said this was an interview he gave right before he interviewed the Prime Minister, and he had two right wing figures. He had Sam Bamford from Two Worlds Collide, who's the next Soldier, and he had Chris Tavalaris. He starts himself as a big Chucky who's an online sort of right wing influencer as well, and they call for mass deportations during this episode.
Speaker 5We're not actually racist. We don't actually hate people for their color, we don't hate people for x y zed. We just want this country to remain as what we grew up in. And it's it's just that simple.
Speaker 2I think it's gone. I don't know. I mean, I mourned for the way I grew up and so do I. Man, I don't know how we get it back.
Speaker 6Look, how do we get it back?
Speaker 3Deportations?
Speaker 4It's very simple.
Speaker 3And there's a point where Carl says, I've been following New Sam for about a year, and I've been receiving correspondence within nine outside of nine across the industry.
Speaker 7Hey have you seen Carl today? Isn't that it? B Hey?
Speaker 3How you going in terms of his line of questioning on a cultural war issue or whatever it might be, for about the past year. And at that point I had put two and two together that Carl, for whatever reason, had begun to consume a different type of content and want to prosecute a different line of inquiry. That it was a few months lead time into what this is now. So I wasn't I wasn't shocked. I was obviously deeply troubled and deeply disappointed, but I wasn't shocked by seeing Tommy Robinson appear on the podcast.
Speaker 1As you mentioned, there's been a lot of speculation that Carl wanted to get fired to get out of his contract. Today show contract is up soon, and this canceled narrative really works for him given the audience, his coording with these far right guests. This all works in his favor in a way, doesn't it.
Speaker 3It does, And this is the bind I mentioned nine have got themselves in. It's not you know, it's not nice as fault. You can't afford to pay someone a half million dollars like that's not an ideological to see, that's a commercial decision. But it does work in his favor. He now gets to say he was canceled by the mainstream media and it appeals to his audience. And there is no shortage of former, you know, mainstream commercial television hosts who go independent and say they were canceled. Meghan Kelly is independent now, Tacker Carlson's independent. Now this this
Speaker 3is a big win for Karl economically at least. I don't know whether culturally it will do much good. But I suspect I suspect there's enough there.
Speaker 1Dangerous is this next period for Channel nine? Could they actually see a backlash when it comes to today from Carl's followers.
Speaker 7I'm really interested in this.
Speaker 3I think it's a fascinating question. I suspect, I suspect not. I don't think it changes your behavior. I'm going to be optimistic here. I may well be wrong. There may be egg on my face here, as there so often is when you're optimistic about the state of the Australian body politic. But I think reasonable people look at what has happened here and go that was a serious mistake. Might have taken fairly swift action, And so for the reasonable Australian who sees Tommy Robinson as a as a as a far right provocateur that he is, I suspect
Speaker 3nine come out of this okay, having relatively swiftly noting that you know, this has been a six month saga.
Speaker 7This has been a long saga for the nine network for sure.
Speaker 1And Dannie, what do you think all this says about the current media landscape? Because even five years ago, perhaps even two years years ago, the idea of a top pay presenter of a prestige Networklock nine putting that gig in jeopardy to pursue a podcast career like this would have been unthinkable. Whether there's anything wrong with podcasting, by the way, I just want to make that clear.
Speaker 7And long may the seven Am podcast live.
Speaker 3I think that, like we joke, but I think that is at the core of where we're at here is for commercial networks.
Speaker 7The gravy train is starting to end. For consumers, we.
Speaker 3Know, and the most recent version of the Digital News Report came out recently by the University of Canberra. We know that individuals, you and me, punters trust personalities much more these days than they do institutions, and they're choosing and picking the personalities that they trust, and so there is money to be made. There is media success to be had in going independent.
Speaker 7We've seen this for a little while.
Speaker 3Colors by no means the first big Australian media personality to go independent. Joe Aston left the Financial Review and started his own publication.
Speaker 7It appears to be going very well.
Speaker 3For him, and everyone has their own podcast now, myself included that it's separate to their day jobs, and increasingly companies are saying yes to that and approving that because they recognize that they can have their cake and eat it too. They can have this effectively free building the profile of someone who's also on the network. So I think there's value and economic opportunity there, commercial opportunity there. The problem with that is that there is if you take that to its logical end and you say everyone
Speaker 3should be by themselves, and everyone should have a substack, and everyone should have a podcast. We end up in like the cable or streaming market that we're in now, where if you want to consume a selection of things that you'd like, you're paying a million different subscriptions. You're paying a million different fees, and it's not economical for the consumer. So there is a risk that that market gets saturated very very quickly, and then we come full circle and we go back to aggregated models and we have things like newsrooms and commercial television networks.
Speaker 7When we watch, we share content together.
Speaker 3So there is an opportunity, but I imagine it will cap itself pretty quickly and we'll see that cat pretty quickly.
Speaker 1Dannie, you're one of my favorite pop thanks for coming on the show.
Speaker 3Thank you very much for having me one of my favorite podcast hosts.
Speaker 1Daniel also in the news. Channel nine is in the Aily network, looking to distance itself from Karl Stefanovic. His new radio show with Eddie mguire is expected to go ahead without him today after Carl pulled out. They've reportedly been conversations with Arn about Stefanovick's future with the radio network. Which recently came to a settlement was Kyle Sandalan's and
Speaker 1Zalie Steggel and Allegra Spender say the new Community Strong Australia Party will provide a centrist alternative for voters. After months of speculation, the Teals announced the party yesterday, denying the move was to skirt new spending and donation laws which disadvantaged smaller players. Fellow Cross bencher Nicolette Buller is considering joining, but the rest of the so called till Independence have so far are ruled it down. I'm Daniel James. Thank you for listening to seven AM. We'll be back tomorrow
At COP31 in Türkiye, Australia has been helping lead global negotiations over the future of fossil fuels and the fight against climate change. But while the Albanese government pushes for stronger international action,...
Anthony Albanese runs a notoriously tight ship. Across his two terms as prime minister, there’s been very little leaking, very little sniping, and very few of his Labor Party colleagues willing to speak out against him....
This week, Australia’s leading health research body released its advice on puberty blockers, saying they should be available for some young people under 18. The Queensland and the Northern Territory governments, which...
In 1945, in the Crimean city of Yalta, three global superpowers - America, Great Britain and the Soviet Union - met to carve up the world between them, each claiming their own sphere of influence in the final year of...
Last week it was Qantas, last month it was NAB: two giants of Australian business cutting jobs due to the growth of AI. The explanations were familiar. Qantas says it will allow the airline to unlock innovation faster...