Pat Cummins is adamant. He didn’t know sandpaper was being used to tamper with the ball in South Africa in 2018. But retired Australian batter, Usman Khawaja has a very different account. Eight long years after the scandal, the players who were in that dressing room are divided over who knew what. It’s the Australian sporting controversy that won’t go away. Today, journalist and Editor-in-Chief of Perceived Pressure, Daany Saeed, on the claims that have reignited sandpapergate, and the questions Australian cricket still hasn’t put to rest. If you enjoy 7am, the best way you can support us is by making a contribution at 7ampodcast.com.au/support. Socials: Stay in touch with us on Instagram Guest: Editor-In-Chief of Perceived Pressure, Daany Saeed Photo: AAP Image/Robbie Stephenson
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1When he says we all knew, if by that he means that we knew sandpaper was going out in the field, he's 100% wrong. I've said that consistently for the last eight years. I did not know that was happening.
Speaker 2Pat Cummins is adamant. He didn't know sandpaper was being used to tamper with the ball in South Africa in 2018. But retired Australian batter Usman Khawaja... has a very different account.
Speaker 3We were all involved in it as a team, as a squad, that was there in South Africa, and that's what I'm trying to project, because it's never black and white.
Speaker 2Eight long years after the scandal, the players who were in that dressing room are divided over who knew what. It's the Australian sporting controversy that won't go away. I'm Daniel James, and you're listening to 7am. Today, journalist and editor-in-chief at Perceived Pressure, Dani Saeed, and the claims they have reignited Sandpaper Gate and the questions Australian cricket still hasn't put to rest. It's Monday, November 16. Dani, great
Speaker 2to see you again. Before we get to the Usman Khawaja bombshell and the reaction to it, Can we go back to where it all began? Because Sandpapergate was a scandal that stopped the nation way back in 2018. Can you remind us what happened?
Speaker 4Yeah, so Australia was caught tampering with the ball. It's a tale as old as time in lots of cricketing contexts.
Speaker 2The umpires just getting together.
Speaker 4So Cameron Bancroft, who was a young player at the time, was caught on the big screen at Cape Town in South Africa, rubbing what was initially said to be a piece of tape with dirt granules.
Speaker 2It was.
Speaker 4It turned out to be sandpaper, a little yellow piece of sandpaper, on the ball.
Speaker 5So this is the umpires.
Speaker 2Having a chat to Cameron Bancroft. I think they're asking him about what he had in his pocket.
Speaker 4And that, for your non-cricketing listeners, contributes to swing. The ball goes the opposite direction to. What you would expect, and it also happens much later and much faster, so it's very difficult to play.
Speaker 6I'm going to come out and say, in my opinion, I think he's tempted with the ball.
Speaker 4So we had Captain Steve Smith, who was said to have known about it. He got a 12-month ban. David Warner, the vice captain, also got a 12-month ban. He was said to be the architect of the plan, who encouraged the young player, Cameron Bancroft, then at the age of 26, he got a nine-month ban. And so those are the three players that sort of got that ban from Create Australia and elicited the cultural review and the scandals that we are now still talking about eight years later.
Speaker 7Good evening. Thanks for coming. Appreciate it. To all of my teammates, to fans of cricket all over the world, and to all Australians who are disappointed and angry, I'm sorry.
Speaker 2The furor that ensued after that incident was really something to behold. It was the teary press conference from Steve Smith. We had the then Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull sticking the boot in. Australia was ridiculed on the world stage, the team booed by spectators. It was a complete mess, wasn't it? Yeah, it was.
Speaker 4It was a complete mess. And these were very heavy punishments. Normally, if you got caught ball tampering in international cricket, you might get a game suspension, maybe two. It was considered by Cricket Australia that the Australian public expected a harsher punishment because Australians expect that we play fair. And this went all the way up to the Prime Minister. Malcolm Turnbull was PM at the time and made remarks about it and said words to the effect of it was unthinkable.
Speaker 8But I have to say that the whole nation who holds those who wear the baggy green up on a pedestal about as high as you can get in Australia, certainly higher than any politician, that's for sure, this is a shocking disappointment.
Speaker 2And after the sandpaper, Kate, there was a big Cricket Australia investigation which found that the only players who knew about the ball tampering incident prior to it happening were Warner, Smith and Bancroft.
Speaker 6No other players... or support staff had prior knowledge. And this includes Darren Lehman, who despite inaccurate media reports, has not resigned from his position.
Speaker 2But now, what has Usman Khawaja said in his new book about the incident, and why has it sparked such controversy?
Speaker 4So this is a fascinating revelation in many ways and in many ways not a fascinating revelation at all because Usman Khawaja says that everybody knew. He has said that in interviews about the book and he says words to that effect in the book.
Speaker 3I mean, I'm not here to inflame the situation anymore. I was here to tell my truth, what I saw, what I felt and to stick with those three guys that were made out to be the only people who have taken it and I wanted that to be shown.
Speaker 7And.
Speaker 4That's not a crazy suggestion. International sport at that level is so highly drilled. They know exactly what they're doing all the time. It's very finely tuned. And so that's basically what Usman is coming out and saying. And so for a lot of the public, they didn't really believe the official Cricket Australia line that it was just these three guys. Cape Town was the only time that they'd ever done it and it happened to be the one time they got caught because the reality is that Australia's bowlers around that time, and this is bearing in mind
Speaker 4the bowlers involved were some of the best in the world, they still are, We're turning it around corners.
Speaker 2Quality reverse swinging delivery from Mitchell Stock. We've seen plenty of them so far in this series.
Speaker 4They were swinging the ball prodigiously at this period of time.
Speaker 3They've got him as well.
Speaker 2He dropped his head straight away. He looked for the finger.
Speaker 5He was hoping that.
Speaker 4Finger wasn't going to go.
Speaker 2What has Zuzman said about why he decided to speak out now?
Speaker 4This has been an issue of controversy because Usman does have a book out at the moment. This is part of the timing. And he says that he has essentially held onto it and that it has marked his conscience for a significant period of time and that he's had moments where he's wanted to speak out previously and that he's sort of been convinced against it or talked out of it or talked down At the time, he claims that he wanted to speak out completely and that everyone should take collective responsibility. And he says he went to
Speaker 4a number of key figures in Australian cricket in 2021 when Cameron Bancroft gave an interview to The Guardian that suggested that the bowlers knew. And in 2021, the bowlers put out a statement saying, a very specifically worded statement which they stand by, saying, we didn't know that a foreign substance was going to be taken out onto the field. And this is part of the tension that's very specifically worded denials. But this is what Usman Khawaja, I guess, is alleging and why he says he has waited till now.
Speaker 2After this story broke, Khawaja appeared on 7.30, where he faced, well, a bit of a grilling from Sarah Ferguson about who knew what and when. Can you talk us through how that played out?
Speaker 4I guess it is kind of baffling that he chose... the war room of 7.30 to put his feet to the fire when you've got a book to sell.
Speaker 5Usman Khawaja, welcome to 7.30.
Speaker 2Thanks for having me.
Speaker 4But essentially, Sarah Ferguson asks the natural question of, well, who did know? You're telling me that everybody, you say in your book, everybody knew. Did Pat Cummins know, the captain of the test team now? He was in the team at the time. Did he know?
Speaker 5There can be no doubt. about what it is you are saying, did Australian Captain Pat Cummins have prior knowledge that sandpaper was being used to change the surface of the ball?
Speaker 3I'm not going to answer that. I've written what I've written in my book. I've come out and.
Speaker 4So she pushes him for 12 minutes and says, well, you must be naming names, you're implicitly naming names, and you get stonewalled. And we see here, I guess, the tension that Usman has in his conscience between wanting to speak up and seek some justice for his mate, Davy Warner, who was the most harshly punished out of Sandpaper Gate. He initially received a lifetime ban from Australian leadership. He was largely credited publicly as the architect of the scandal.
Speaker 4And he's Usman Khawaja's childhood friend. This is to say Usman is trying to balance his responsibilities to his mates and to his teammates, and he does hold Pat Cummins and co in very high regard, but he's trying to balance that with the truth-telling element of his conscience. And so there's been descriptions of Usman as a traitor. The Australian read a cartoon of him driving a bus over his teammates. He's not a very good traitor, is he,
Speaker 4if he's not naming names?
Speaker 2Still to come, Australian Captain Pat Cummins hits back. Dani, let's talk about the response to these claims. On Friday morning, Pat Cummins came out and got on the front foot with a really strong denial in a press conference. What did he have to say?
Speaker 4He says that Usman's suggestions were complete and utter nonsense.
Speaker 1He says that I and others were architects of a scheme.
Speaker 2To bore Tampa with sandpaper.
Speaker 1That's complete and utter nonsense.
Speaker 4He very strongly denies the principle of almost all of us Usman's suggestions. He denies that there was ever a team meeting where Usman claimed or sought for the team to take collective responsibility. He denies, in line with the 2021 bowlers statement, that the bowlers knew, again, it was very specifically worded denial, but he denies that the bowlers knew about taking a foreign substance onto the field. And he expresses a real disappointment in Uzi as his friend.
Speaker 1Usman's a friend, but friends aren't casual with each other's lives and reputations. In his book, Uzi has been casual with my lives and the lives of many others.
Speaker 2And do you believe Cummins when it comes to his denials that he had no knowledge that this was going to happen?
Speaker 4I think you can believe both men. I think two things can be true. And the reason you can do that is because the bowlers have been very specific. And it was almost like a lawyer wrote that, that you can believe that the team is complicit in ball tampering. And you can believe that there is a general understanding, and Pat more or less admits to this, that there's a general understanding that we were always working on the ball and that we did that in line with a lot of other international teams at the time. And there was an arms race of sorts to try and figure
Speaker 4out the best way to manipulate the ball. And this has been happening in cricket for time immemorial. This is not a crazy suggestion. You can believe that Pat is aware and that the bowlers are aware of ball tampering generally. And that's probably the essence of what Usman is saying and that's why he speaks about it in terms of my truth and my understanding and my recollection. And that's sort of the pub test phrasing of it. But you can also believe, and it can be true, that the bowlers didn't know that Cameron Bancroft specifically was going to
Speaker 4take out a foreign substance in that session at Cape Town. Because as Usman describes in the book, it was kind of panic stations in that specific session. And Cameron Bancroft, to an extent, went a little bit rogue. And it really is, it's a very graphic account of the moment that they were caught on the big screen at Newlands tampering with the ball. But it was a fight, flight or freeze scenario for Cameron Bancroft in Usman's retelling. And so you can have those two things be technically true,
Speaker 4but the pub test of it is that you believe one or the other. And so I think that's where the public debate has gone and the public line of questioning has gone is who do you believe, Usman and his mates or Pat and his mates? And the reality is there's probably an in-between there that is true, but no one really wants to admit to the extent to which that is true.
Speaker 2The one person who was backing him, as you said, is his great mate, David Warner. What has he had to say and what's been the response from other players and coaches from that time?
Speaker 4Yeah, so David Warner has said that everything that Usman is saying is 100% correct, is what he said.
Speaker 1And Uzi, I throw my full support behind you.
Speaker 4I thank you for what you've done. It's 100% accurate what you've said. David has bit his tongue for a really long time on this. It's well known in creating circles. It's well known in journalistic circles that David will be writing a book of his own and There is a sense that Usman has laid down himself a little bit to take the bullets of a lot of the revelations that David will support in his retelling of the book.
Speaker 4So there is that. There's Chad Sayers, who was a reserve fast bowler in that tour and selected for the following test match, I believe, and says that Usman's recollections are correct. He stands by that.
Speaker 1But.
Speaker 4Chad says also brings into this debate the question of, well, why did he wait eight years? And a number of players, a number of coaches that have disputed Usman's recollection have questioned his motives, have taken the cynical side and said, well, why wait eight years? Usman says, well, my career was on the line. It's not tenable to be part of that team and also speak as candidly as he has.
Speaker 2People who have read the book have said that Usman has done a very good job at painting the broader culture within the team. at the time, and that to get to the point of sandpaper gate didn't happen in a vacuum. And if you read the book, it doesn't come across as particularly surprising. But it does seem like whenever there is a scandal on or off field, these teams and these sporting codes close ranks to protect the players, sometimes at the expense of justice. Is that what's happened here?
Speaker 4Perhaps, perhaps. I think there is a sense from the Australian public that this has happened and that David Warner in particular, who has had his livelihood significantly affected, whose public reputation will never recover from what Cricket Australia say was his role in Sandpaper Gate, there is a sense in the Australian public that the penalties were very, very harsh. They were harsher than any other ball-tampering penalty previously given. And in retrospect.
Speaker 2Including South African players and English players.
Speaker 4Exactly right. Exactly right. And so there is a sense that we were too harsh to placate a public that was very angry in the moment and that woke up. It's worth bearing in mind that the South African series and the South African scandal happened in the middle of the night for Australians on the East Coast particularly. And we woke up to news that it was a very visceral kind of way to discover what had happened. And we had an anger in the public that authorities felt needed to be acted on. And I think that was reflected. I mentioned Malcolm Turnbull as Prime Minister at the time
Speaker 4when he remarked on it. Lusman Khawaja says in the book, and Malcolm Turnbull has since criticised Khawaja for this, says that Malcolm Turnbull was trying to save his prime ministership. But there was a sense from the public that they wanted to see a visceral sort of justice delivered. I'm not sure whether that has happened here. Whether we'll ever see some sort of justice is another question. I know a journalist that was at the press conference wanted to ask Pat. He didn't get to, but he wanted to ask Pat, does the Australian public deserve to know? Will
Speaker 4we ever? Or is that something that will remain within the walls of Cricket Australia and the test team? I suspect it will be the latter.
Speaker 2Thanks for being with us today, Dani. Really appreciate it.
Speaker 4Thanks so much, Daniel. I really appreciate it.
Speaker 2Always good. Also in the news, airlines are still struggling to clear a backlog of delayed and cancelled flight services after flights right across the US were grounded for five hours over the weekend. the government has blamed the nationwide shutdown on a program to replace old copper wires with new fibre ones. It caused a major air traffic communications failure,
Speaker 2affecting 20,000 flights. And in a world first, a SpaceX rocket has successfully returned to its launch pad in Texas after orbiting the Earth several times. It marks the first ever recovery of a spaceship, a key milestone for rocket reusability. I'm Daniel James. Thanks for listening to 7am. We'll be back tomorrow.
At COP31 in Türkiye, Australia has been helping lead global negotiations over the future of fossil fuels and the fight against climate change. But while the Albanese government pushes for stronger international action,...
Anthony Albanese runs a notoriously tight ship. Across his two terms as prime minister, there’s been very little leaking, very little sniping, and very few of his Labor Party colleagues willing to speak out against him....
This week, Australia’s leading health research body released its advice on puberty blockers, saying they should be available for some young people under 18. The Queensland and the Northern Territory governments, which...
In 1945, in the Crimean city of Yalta, three global superpowers - America, Great Britain and the Soviet Union - met to carve up the world between them, each claiming their own sphere of influence in the final year of...
Last week it was Qantas, last month it was NAB: two giants of Australian business cutting jobs due to the growth of AI. The explanations were familiar. Qantas says it will allow the airline to unlock innovation faster...