Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

7am

7am artwork

Covid-level crisis? How Australia ignored fuel warnings

Mar 23, 202617 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

John Blackburn spent four decades in the Air Force, rising to Deputy Chief. For more than decade he’s been warning that Australia is too reliant on imported fuel, too light on reserves, and too exposed if a global crisis - just like this one - disrupts supply. Now, as more than hundred servos around the country run dry and a Trump ultimatum looms, threatening to make the fuel crisis worse, Australia is paying the price for our lack of preparedness. Today, Chair of the Institute of Economic Research Australia, John Blackburn on how Australia botched our emergency fuel plan, what we should do next, and why the Iran war is shaping up to be a covid-level crisis. If you enjoy 7am, the best way you can support us is by making a contribution at 7ampodcast.com.au/support. Socials: Stay in touch with us on Instagram Guest: John Blackburn, Chair of the Institute of Economic Research Australia Photo: AAP Image/Mick Tsikas

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1I'd say i'd put it at least at the same level as COVID. You're not going to have the sort of death rates and the risk we had there, but the effect on our society is going to be fundamental, and the follow on effects will probably last longer because we haven't learned from our COVID experience.

Speaker 2John Blackburn spent four decades in the Air Force, rising to Deputy chief. For years he's been warning that Australia is too reliant on imported fuel, too thin on reserves, and too exposed if a global crisis like this one disrupts supply.

Speaker 1In both sides of politics, despite repeated warnings and engagements, have failed to get it.

Speaker 2Now, as more than one hundred petrol stations run dry and a Trump ultimatum over the Iran war looms, threatening to make the fuel crisis even worse, the government's accused of failing the country by failing to prepare. I'm Nicole Johnston and you're listening to seven am today, Chair of the Institute of Economic Research Australia, John Blackburn on where the country's emergency fuel plan falls short and is it

Speaker 2too late to fix it. It's Tuesday, March twenty four, John, You've been wargaming a situation like this for over a decade, and now that it's here. What is it that you're worried about most? Is it price shocks or is it that we face an actual shortage?

Speaker 1Oh, we'll face an actual shortage, has no doubt about that. What I'm worried about the flower effects. It's far more than fuel. We're reacting to the fuel issue because the prices are hitting at us and we can see a problem coming. It's much more than that. When you think about the experts out of that particular part of the world, through the Strait of Homers. We're already seeing the effect on fertilizer prices. But it goes way beyond that, and which is why I've been saying, in addition to the fuel task Force, they've set up, good step, we need to have a non fuel task will set up because

Speaker 1these other shortages will impact the global market. So we have two things react to the current problem. What can we do as it starts to actually impact us because it hasn't impacted our supply chain yet, all the impact in our societies because of how we've reacted. So that's the next stage. But we've got to look beyond fuel.

Speaker 2So when you say we have to look beyond fuel, what is it you're talking about? What other products could we end up being short of?

Speaker 1Okay, so right now, about twenty percent of the world's oil goes through the stratuhornmals and about twenty five percent of liquid natural gas. That's going to have a huge effect. But there's the refined pratorium products and condensate. So here's a couple of things, sulfur and sulfuric acid, big supply. It's going to affect a lot of things in production and industry, high purity gases, specialty chemicals, chlorine, and caustic soda. About thirty something percent of the world's helium's coming out of there. Try and do an MRI without helium. There's a lot of other things. This will flow through to effects on the mining industry of how cop from cobalter

Speaker 1process to minium, ammonia, urea and nitrogen that's going to be affected. We've seen a thirty seven percent price increase in fertilizers, so this is much bigger than fuel.

Speaker 2So what do you think of how the government's handled it so far? Is it being clear about the scale, the nature of the risk, or do you think it should be much stronger so that people really know what this country's facing.

Speaker 1I mean to me, it almost echoes the Liberal government's response to COVID unclear, quite confused, and so where we are right now. The messaging is poor. It started to say we've got the most fuel we've had for fifteen years, as if we were taking credit for us.

Speaker 3Simply say, mister speaker, we entered this crisis with thirty six days worth of petrol, which is more than previous minister said was necessary in a worst case scenario.

Speaker 1I might return to that later. This Energy minister did not initiate the fuel stocks that was done with Angus Taylor. They've implemented it. So we start talking about I've got fifteen years not to worry about things under control. He didn't emphasize that eighty percent of the world's supply chain is still there. We're not going to run out. We're going to have some shortages and issues eventually. But because the messaging has been so poor, people are getting really concerned. They understandably start to panic, and we've driven up our consumption to about one hundred and fifty percent of what

Speaker 1it was. Now the supply chain is not designed for that. It's designed for the normal load.

Speaker 3Now, mister speaker, it is the case that demand has doubled, use has not.

Speaker 1Use has not.

Speaker 3Demand has doubled.

Speaker 1But we've got a bunch of children at the moment arguing of each other. So just listen to question time. It is absolutely pathetic. It's mostly these males trying to point score, sort of smirking about it.

Speaker 4And now the Minister for Energy has been caught unprepared for Australia's energy shortages, further punishing Australian households at the bowser and at the supermarket.

Speaker 3The leader of the Opposition appears to want to just completely dismiss the.

Speaker 1Fact that there is a war going on.

Speaker 4The Minister is providing information to the House on an important issue.

Speaker 1So I'm asking for everyone's assistance, show respect, show restrain the ministastical. I even watch Taining a plumba Secret. I think it's been set up by the Labor Party go head to head with Barnaby on seven's Breakfast Television. It was just stunning to watch.

Speaker 5The most helpful thing people could do is just by the fuel they need and know more. That's the most helpful thing people could do. And there is the same amount of still coming as we've previously had. Honestly, has grown up for a change, grown up.

Speaker 1So what instead of saying we've got a problem, lets both sides of politics works together. It's being used by both sides to point scool. This is absolute madness and it's a failure of leadership.

Speaker 3Would you urge businesses, for example, to be more flexible on work from home let people stay home? Well, I think that's a sensible thing to do in any environment. Really, you know, work from home has become an important part of it.

Speaker 1But in this Australian oil crisis.

Speaker 3My Australian working life, and again I think some people would already be doing that. There are other people for who and that's not an option.

Speaker 2The government's now saying Australian should consider working from home if it's an option to save fuel or to catch public transport, if they can do you think that's a good idea. And could we even get to a point where there's not enough fuel or it's become so expensive that there is no other option than for a lot of people to work from home.

Speaker 1Oh, absolutely, So we should be saying to Australians, look in order to make sure those reserves we've got are as much as possible to deal with what's coming at us. Yeah, let's work from home. Don't panic, but let's see how we can reduce our consumption. And for heaven, it's like, please don't go out and buy more than you absolutely have to have. That's just common sense. But I think the issue is because their messaging is confused. I don't think they've got the legislative authority at the federal level to actually start to control the market. And the reason

Speaker 1I say that is that one of the reports that came out in twenty nineteen said the Liquid Fuel Emergency Act is not fit for purpose. It takes so long to go through the various stages and then eventually to have the Governor General sign off a proclamation of an emergency. It won't work. So I really have this gut feel that they haven't changed the Act enough to actually allow a very rapid movement to hang on. We've got to do something and take control. I really suspect he hasn't got the tool set.

Speaker 2John other countries they're starting to prioritize their own oil and gas supply, and we've seen that especially in Asia, they're capping petrol prices, banning the export of refined products. But what is it that we can do here in Australia. Do we have levers to pull or can we negotiate better or even just pay more than everybody else.

Speaker 1It'll be a combination of things. So every year we export mostly to engineers, your single and Japan with guess, we export the equivalent to thirty one percent of our total transport fuel consumption in a year. We're actually an energy fossil fuel energy provider to the region. So what we need to say is we understand what you're doing. But with this energy we're exporting, let's work out how we can do a bilateral deal with each separate country. If we send this much either crude, all or condisate

Speaker 1energy to you, we want you in return to take part of that, refine that and send that back to us. And we're paying each other to do this because we also need to look after our people. If they say no, we're not going to do it, then we should be looking at Okay, who do we sell it to? And now people start saying, oh, but we've got contracts. This is not peacetime. We are in a war, but we are talking in public as if it's not a war. And that's a really big problem because people, well, it's

Speaker 1just life as normal, going to a couple of erykaans and I'll do them. I think, No, we're in a war circumstance. It's going to have an effect on us. Things are not blowing up down here, but we will have a major effect on our energy security and other things. So we have to change our mentality.

Speaker 2Coming up failing to game plan a rogue. President, John, you've been warning about our fuel reserves for over a decade now, and you wrote a report back in twenty thirteen you said Australia only had enough emergency stock to cover three days worth of pharmacy supplies, a week of chilled and frozen food, and three days worth of fuel to petrol stations. Has our situation improved much since then?

Speaker 1Well, no, funamentally. So I wrote a series of three reports and then we went on a whole campaign after that. Now let's talk about what's happened since I wrote those reports. Well, we've gone from on seven refineries we had then down to two and the contracts to support them have just been extended till twenty thirty, but there's no guarantee those two refineries will just style to stay open, so we're not thinking about what we're going to do. Then. The other thing is that back in twenty thirteen we didn't

Speaker 1have any mandated stocks. That was a huge vulnerability at the time. Now we were arguing to change that and eventually the government lessened at the time and thankfully we have mandated stocks, so that's a little improvement. Here's the other problem. The ability to move the fuel around the country is really a problem. We can no longer move fuel around the country by rail except for a small amount between Espirants and Carl Gurley. The mining systems have closed rail networks, but the rest of the country you either hire a ship to move it, which we don't control,

Speaker 1or you'd move in on trucks. So if you think about this logistics system no ships that we control seven refineries down to two no rail op think that as an artery that's supplied chain, well, it's been really constricted. You know, it's full of cholesterol and a bunch of other stuff. It's hard to make it move Thankfully with the stock mandates coming in, we've got a bit of an improvement, but overall the resilience of our energy system has gone downhill because of the failure of the two major political parties to take this seriously.

Speaker 2We've really seen the war in the Gulf Escalator. Over the last few days. We had Israel striker RAN's most important gas field, South Pas.

Speaker 5The hit on Iran's South Pas gas fielder first true sharp criticism from KATA given it has it shares that northern end of the facility.

Speaker 2And then the Iranians they retaliated by hitting Raslafan, the world's largest LNG planting.

Speaker 1Cutter, CEO of cut the Energy says that Iran's attack wiped out seventeen percent of Cutter's energy capacity for up to five years.

Speaker 2That is a Now Trump's issued an ultimatum. He says he'll destroy a Run's power plants if they don't reopen the strait of Hall moves.

Speaker 3President Donald Trump is threatening an enormous attack on Iran's energy infrastructure if Tehran doesn't allow free navigation through this.

Speaker 2Surely, if he went to that level, that would only make the energy crisis even worse. It seems that this is a really big crunch time right now.

Speaker 1So what you've got all the scenarios we did years ago. I mean in the military, I did a lot of scenario work, but also for this work, we never once contemplated that there will be a rogue US president. So what's happened. He's gone in there simplistically, and it's backfiring on him, and he's worried about the midterms, so he needs to finish it quickly. That damage in Qatar, from what I've been reading today, could take three to five years to repair. If you start blowing up the other parts of the energy system and Iran can retaliate because you don't need America's firepowder to do this, then we

Speaker 1are going to have not only an interruption whilst the war's on, just up for twenty percent out for a decade. I think could go that long. But we're at a very difficult time where if we're not careful and we allowed that guide to pressure us, that will be the dumbest thing that we've done in decades.

Speaker 2John, you're part of this group of nineteen former Defense Force leaders, and you've all called on the government to urgently roll out renewable energy, saying it's a matter of national security at this point. Now, of course the government it's saying that it is doing that, and it doesn't happen overnight. It takes time. So what is it that you actually want them to do now, because they can't do it straight away.

Speaker 1So another one is recognize their role in not actually having been prepared for this. That's the first important thing. And then start to work with across the parties. That's essential. We've got enough smart people in this country to actually work out what to do. We've actually got enough resources if we stop wasting them on stupid things like nucleus submarines and august. That's not going to happen, but we'll waste a lot of money. The solution, when you think about it, let's go to a simple level, what can we replace on the supply side. Well, biofuels certainly are key part of this, not the totality, So renewable diesels,

Speaker 1you know, sustainable aviation fuels, a bit of ethanol substitution in there. That is a very important one. But when you talk about it from the right side of politics, I'll just say right now, I don't support either side of politics, I'm a political from the right side. You'll get go you're greenees in your woke, No we're not. We need renewable fuels to substitute there to give us our energy security. That doesn't quite align with the rhetoric from the far right. But you also have to ensure

Speaker 1that you have fossil fuels. Could be perhaps take that huge amount of crude oil we export and find a way of refining a bit of that, because when I then face the argument from the far left, no more fossil fuels ever. Yeah, okay, but we're going through an energy transition. The fossil fuels also give you key chemicals, medicines, a whole bunch of stuff we need. So on either side of politics, you've got this black and white view. We are in a mess. It's a teamed approach and we have to use a whole range of things. There

Speaker 1is no coherent system plan in this country to look at that transition. And the last time we did a national energy security assessment which would allow us to understand our risk and vulnerabilities was two thousand and eleven. We're now running for fifteen years without a risk assessment. This is strategic stupidity on both sides of politics.

Speaker 2John, thank you so much for joining us.

Speaker 1You're most welcome. I hope I didn't depress you too much.

Speaker 2Also in the news, more than seventy five percent of ABC staff will walk off the job on Wednesday, in their first strike in twenty years. Severe disruptions lasting twenty four hours are expected across the Public Broadcasters News Services Union say the ABC's offer of a ten percent pay rise over three years falls short and doesn't address concerns about conditions and penalty rates. And Kyl Sanderlans has launched legal action against his former radio network over the end

Speaker 2of his one hundred million dollar contract. His lawyers say the termination was invalid because there was no active, serious misconduct or breach of the contract. Sandy Lands wants the remainder of his deal paid out in full, but ARN is defending its actions and will fight the shock jock in court. I'm Nicole Johnston. This is seven AM. Thanks for listening.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Guests

  • John Blackburn Guest Inferred

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. How Albanese killed the climate wars

    Nov 21, 202615 minAudio

    At COP31 in Türkiye, Australia has been helping lead global negotiations over the future of fossil fuels and the fight against climate change. But while the Albanese government pushes for stronger international action,...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Ed Husic on being ‘left in the dark’ by his own government

    Nov 20, 202617 minAudio

    Anthony Albanese runs a notoriously tight ship. Across his two terms as prime minister, there’s been very little leaking, very little sniping, and very few of his Labor Party colleagues willing to speak out against him....

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Puberty blockers greenlit: So why are state bans still in place?

    Nov 19, 202615 minAudio

    This week, Australia’s leading health research body released its advice on puberty blockers, saying they should be available for some young people under 18. The Queensland and the Northern Territory governments, which...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Will Trump, Xi and Putin try to carve up the world?

    Nov 18, 202616 minAudio

    In 1945, in the Crimean city of Yalta, three global superpowers - America, Great Britain and the Soviet Union - met to carve up the world between them, each claiming their own sphere of influence in the final year of...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. AI job cuts at Bunnings, Qantas, NAB: ‘Mass unemployment is the business plan’

    Nov 17, 202616 minAudio

    Last week it was Qantas, last month it was NAB: two giants of Australian business cutting jobs due to the growth of AI. The explanations were familiar. Qantas says it will allow the airline to unlock innovation faster...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode