Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

7am

7am artwork

Emily Maitlis on the three elections shaking up global politics

Oct 27, 202618 minAudio

This wasn’t the story global political analysts had been expecting to tell this week: In Brazil and Serbia, the youth are celebrating. Their hope for a democratic future has been restored after two shock election wins for the left that young voters helped deliver. But as the polling booths close today in what’s been described as one of Israel’s most consequential elections, it’s likely to be a very different story. Today, co-host of The News Agents Emily Maitlis on a blockbuster week of elections, the Trump-effect hanging over all three countries, and how the results could shape global politics. If you enjoy 7am, the best way you can support us is by making a contribution at 7ampodcast.com.au/support. Socials: Stay in touch with us on Instagram Guest: The News Agents co-host Emily Maitlis Photo: EPA/Isaac Fontana

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1This wasn't the story global political analysts had been expecting to tell this week.

Speaker 2I feel amazing. Finally, the best times have come.

Speaker 1In Brazil and Serbia, young people are celebrating. Their hope for a democratic future has been restored after shock election wins.

Speaker 3For the left, victories which young voters helped deliver.

Speaker 2The nights we've stayed in our universities, all the walks we've had from one.

Speaker 4City to another.

Speaker 1So is this the beginning of an anti-authoritarian wave? I'm Ruby Jones and you're listening to 7am. Today, co-host of the newsagents Emily Maitlis on a blockbuster week of elections and how opposition and support for Trump.

Speaker 3Is reshaping global politics. It's Wednesday, October 28. Emily, welcome back to 7am. It's great to have you on the show. It's great to be back.

Speaker 4Thanks, Ruby.

Speaker 3A huge week for global politics.

Speaker 1Three elections on three continents within the space of three days.

Speaker 3I thought we could start in Brazil.

Speaker 1Left-wing president Lula da Silva, he had this incredible comeback to defeat far-right Senator Flavio Bolsonaro.

Speaker 3Tell me about what happened.

Speaker 2It was so strange, really, because the Brazilian election works in two parts. There's the first one, the runoff, and then a month or so later, you get the second one, which is what we had on Sunday. And after the first round in the runoff, it looked almost definitive that Bolsonaro was going to win.

Speaker 1With nearly all votes counted, Bolsonaro finished first with 47% and Lula followed with 45%.

Speaker 2And somehow between that first round and what happened this weekend, Lula da Silva managed to get an army together. He literally called it Lula's army. It was 10.8 million people. people on his WhatsApp getting the vote out. Now, for so long, we have talked about the ability on the right, particularly in the sort of MAGA circles and the Trump circles, to get the vote out, to find the vote, you know, down the back of the sofa, behind the radiator, in places that nobody else is looking. And this time round,

Speaker 2it was Lula and his army that managed to basically mobilise a youth vote, a vote that came to him from the working class, a vote that came to him through TikTok, through social media. And he ended up winning by some 4 million votes, which is kind of not on anyone's bingo card.

Speaker 3It was so unusual.

Speaker 2And to put this in context, we've talked a lot, I think, over the last 12 to 24 months about the anti-incumbency, you know, everyone hates whoever's in power. Whatever country you're a part of, you kind of hate your own government, maybe as a result of COVID, maybe as a result of a lack of growth, maybe as a result of a sort of growing political frustrations and unease amongst the young. But this time around, it was an 80-year-old guy who has actually served three terms already. He was voted back in. Now, why was he voted back in?

Speaker 2That's your big question. Partly because Flavio Bolsonaro was the son of Jair Bolsonaro, who was so Trump-like, he actually tried to stage a coup last time round against the same opponent, Lula.

Speaker 3A day of raids and arrests. Investigations into an alleged military coup continue.

Speaker 5Just days before the inauguration of President-elect Lula da Silva.

Speaker 2And that actually ended up putting him behind bars for some 27 years. He also tried to stage an assassination plot against Lula.

Speaker 5They uncovered a military plot to kill the then-President-elect. Current and retired military officers were arrested, including one who was a member of former President Jair Bolsonaro's cabinet.

Speaker 2I mean, this is one bad hombre, right, who is now serving out his time in jail.

Speaker 3It was his son.

Speaker 2who was taking on the reins, who was trying to fight Lila da Silva. And I guess we will see the same playbook enacted. We've already heard from Flavio Bolsonaro that the son tonight, he doesn't believe the election results are right. He's going to fight it. It's the same old playbook we've heard from Trump. It's the same old playbook we heard from Jair Bolsonaro. And it seems that it is a generational trauma that is going to be passed down the Bolsonaro family. But as things stand, the Brazilians have never had an election overturned. And Lula, Lula,

Speaker 2this 80-year-old guy who comes from a very working class background, who lost a finger in a factory incident when he was, I think, a teenager. In other words, it is the living proof of what many Brazilians have been through, which is hardship and struggle. He has triumphed again.

Speaker 1And you talked about Bolsonaro working from the Trump playbook there. The right has had a lot of success in Latin America, many with Trump's backing. So how significant is Lula's victory in this region in that context? And how much of a setback is this for that right wing populist movement that Bolsonaro was a part of?

Speaker 2In South America, there have been eight recent elections, seven of which have brought right-wing authoritarian figures to power. And Trump just this weekend was hailing the fact that, you know, you've seen South America, it's moving in my direction, it's moving right. I can tell you this, in South America, it was all leaning big left.

Speaker 1It's all right now.

Speaker 6I They are becoming extremely conservative in a very positive way.

Speaker 2And he very much endorsed Bolsonaro, the son, this time round. Even last time, he threatened Lula's government with tariffs because he said he didn't want to see Jair Bolsonaro in prison. So Trump has been this ghost-like figure on the scene of the Brazilian election right the way through.

Speaker 3And the fact that essentially.

Speaker 2he was trying to weigh the scales in Bolsonaro's favor, actually gave Lula a whole new platform to say, do you really want this guy? Do you really want election interference? Do you really want America dominating? Do you really want the colonialists coming into Brazil again?

Speaker 3Is this what you want?

Speaker 2And I think that's a really interesting place that we've got to because first time round, the kind of, The Trump seal of approval did work. It worked for Jair Bolsonaro. It worked for Duterte in the Philippines. It worked for Orban in Hungary. This time round, I'm not sure that the Trump currency is working very well, quite frankly. I mean, we saw last April, it did not work in supporting Viktor Orban in Hungary. It did not work this time

Speaker 2around in supporting Jair Bolsonaro. It did not work in Serbia. in supporting Alexander Vucic, which, you know, was another race that we all thought was almost certain to go back to the right-wing authoritarian sort of Putin-loving leader, and it didn't.

Speaker 6An astonishing result for the student movement, which only was set up in the last months or so.

Speaker 3Let's talk a little bit about what happened in Serbia.

Speaker 1So, as you say, Alexander Vucic has been beaten by this student-led movement after 12 years in power.

Speaker 6They have now won. We understand they'll have 130 or 140 possibly seats in that parliament.

Speaker 1How much of a win is this for democracy and also for young people?

Speaker 2I mean, I think it is jaw-dropping, actually. To take you back to the history... Vucic has been in power for 12 years. He is pretty Putin-friendly. He's pretty Russian-friendly. He's very anti-EU. Serbia failed to impose sanctions on Russia after the invasion of Ukraine. And it looked like his grip on Serbia was pretty strong. Now, I have to take you back to explain this to a tragedy that happened about two years ago in December of 2024. When

Speaker 2an infrastructure project basically collapsed, it was over a railway station in Novi Sad, 16 people were killed.

Speaker 7The disaster occurred when on a sunny day, part of the roofing collapsed, which was along the entrance to the station and was filled with travellers. Rescuers worked through the night to free the dead and injured from under the rubble.

Speaker 2Nobody was taking responsibility for it. There was no accountability. There was no kind of consideration to how it had happened, how things had gone wrong.

Speaker 3And so it became.

Speaker 2Slightly bigger than the event itself, it became totemic as a way of saying this government doesn't care about us. And as a result of this, students were on the streets, protesters were on the streets. And out of these protests grew this party, which is called the Student List. Now, what is extraordinary about it is it is made up of people from all walks of life, cardiologists, nurses, many academics, teachers, NGOs, people,

Speaker 2in other words, who are not trained as politicians. They have not had decades in the parliament. They have come to this party from all walks of life and said, we want to break away from the Vucic politics, from the sort of pro-Russian, pro-Putin politics of Serbia. We want to see a fresh start. And they basically won this on an anti-corruption ticket again by mobilising the young, by mobilising this kind of ragtail bunch of people to come together. I mean, there is no leader yet. We don't really

Speaker 2know who's going to lead Serbia. We don't know what roles they're going to have, what policies they take on. But right now, What we can safely say is that this figure who was in power, who was really upending Serbia's democratic norms, is gone. His party remains. They have 100 or so seats in the parliament. So it's not the end of Vucic as a party. But I think we are starting to see something radical new happen. And again, it is a rejection of Trump. And I think what

Speaker 2you're starting to see now is, I call it, you know, it's the Mark Carney syndrome. Mark Carney basically won Canada because he stood up to Trump. And I think some of these opposition parties are finding that that's working in their favour too.

Speaker 1Still to come, Israel's election and how the Trump factor could play very differently for Netanyahu.

Speaker 4Does your party support the establishment of a Palestinian state in any of Israel's boundaries?

Speaker 3It's a hell no. Of course no.

Speaker 2No, definitely not.

Speaker 4No, no, no.

Speaker 7The clear answer is no. Clearly not, and we'll fight it tooth and nail in every which way we can.

Speaker 3It's wrong, it's stupid, it's against God.

Speaker 1Emily, these results in Brazil, in Serbia, they're both obviously wins for the left. That's not an option when it comes to Israel's election this week. That's a choice between the right, further right, the far right. So lay out the possibilities for me there.

Speaker 2Yeah, I was talking to one senior Israeli journalist who called it 50 shades of right wing. Look, on the ballot in Israel is the future of Netanyahu and the spectre of October the 7th, the massacre that left 1,200 dead. Israelis dead and obviously that led to then the destruction of Gaza and the up to 75,000 we think killed there. So to take you inside Israeli politics is a minefield

Speaker 2to be honest. It is a very complicated set of parties. There are 37 parties in all. We will not probably have a result for weeks because it's a PR system that involves a lot of wrangling, a lot of horse trading, and we have yet to work out which parties will agree to form a coalition. So as we go to the polls, or as Israelis go to the polls, I should say, it looks as if the opposition leader, Gadi Eisenkot,

Speaker 2a former leader of the IDF, the army leader, should have more seats. But neither he nor Netanyahu look as if they will be able to form a majority. Once the voting is done, they will each go back to their blocks. They will try and each form a party. Gary Eisenkot, if he gets the most number of seats, should have the first chance. The president, Herzog, will call on him to make the first attempt at forming a government. And he then has, I think, 28 days to try and form this government. What we know is that Netanyahu

Speaker 2is a mastermind at coalition politics. He understands how the horse trading works. He understands how, even if he hasn't got the most number of seats, he might be able to work his way with more of the parties to create what looks like a governing coalition.

Speaker 4I'm fueled by a mission. Right after 1979, when When the Iranian revolution took place, I said.

Speaker 2To put this in context, Netanyahu is not new to the political scene in Israel. He has dominated it for nearly three decades.

Speaker 4And I've dedicated the bulk of my adult life to try to prevent them from having the means to destroy us.

Speaker 2There's this extraordinary statistic I was reading over the weekend that approximately one in four days since Israel was founded as a state... has seen Netanyahu as the leader. I mean, it is an extraordinary amount of time to actually dominate one country. And so I think that gives you an indication of just how fraught this election is. If Netanyahu succeeds, I think a lot of people feel that he will

Speaker 2carry on on the trajectory that he has been going for the last four years, whether that is further war with Iran, further destruction of Gaza, further incursion of the West Bank with the settler areas, further incursions into Lebanon with his war on Hezbollah. If it spells the end of Netanyahu, no one is talking about a two-state solution yet. Nobody's actually talking about peace. But there is just the opening crack of possibility. that you start to talk about

Speaker 2a peace plan somewhere down the line. It goes from 99% impossible to 98% impossible, which doesn't sound hugely optimistic, but it does leave an opening for something to happen in that tiny little bit of space.

Speaker 1Okay, so if we're seeing this sort of reshaping of global politics now, As both an embrace and a rejection of Trump, where do you think Israel sits in this? Because if an association with Trump worked against Bolsonaro and against Vucic, how should we see his connection with Netanyahu? How do you think we'll see that play out in the election in Israel?

Speaker 2I would say that Israel is probably the one place where the Trump currency still works, actually. You have seen Trump twice in the space of five days. offer his support to Netanyahu, and Netanyahu seemed to be incredibly grateful for it. There are people who think that it is incredibly important for Israel to have the support of Donald Trump right now, or let's call it, you know, the American administration behind them. If they want to see another

Speaker 2war or a continuation of the war with Iran, if they want somebody to take that Iranian threat seriously, they think that is Trump. Now, let me spell it out. I think everyone who is supporting Netanyahu is delighted.

Speaker 3To see Trump backing him.

Speaker 2I think everyone who has decided that Netanyahu is A, corrupt, B, somebody who let October the 7th happen, who, in other words, has not kept their country safe, doesn't think that Trump is in any way helpful to the future of their country because actually, You know, he's put them on a collision course again with Iran. So I think Trump is different to the Israeli equation than he is to Serbia or to Brazil. But I still don't think that he

Speaker 2has the same impact on that election as he might have done two or three years ago.

Speaker 3Well, Emily, thank you so much.

Speaker 2Absolute pleasure.

Speaker 5Thank you.

Speaker 1Also in the news, the Prime Minister's claim that a $ 6 million grant awarded to his local golf club was to fix sewage issues has been rejected by department officials. They told a Senate Estimates hearing that the sewage works weren't part of the project. The grant came under scrutiny earlier this year after it was revealed that Anthony Albanese held an undisclosed honorary membership.

Speaker 2At the club.

Speaker 1And students would face national exams in years 6, 10 and 12 under a radical idea to overhaul our school system and fix inconsistencies across states. The report mourns different assessment levels, so-called grade creep, and unchecked AI use are threatening the integrity of our schools. The opposition says the proposal from a national party-backed think tank warrants serious consideration.

Speaker 3I'm Ruby Jones. This is 7am.

Speaker 1Thanks for listening.

Speaker 2Thank you.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. How Albanese killed the climate wars

    Nov 21, 202615 minAudio

    At COP31 in Türkiye, Australia has been helping lead global negotiations over the future of fossil fuels and the fight against climate change. But while the Albanese government pushes for stronger international action,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Ed Husic on being ‘left in the dark’ by his own government

    Nov 20, 202617 minAudio

    Anthony Albanese runs a notoriously tight ship. Across his two terms as prime minister, there’s been very little leaking, very little sniping, and very few of his Labor Party colleagues willing to speak out against him....

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Puberty blockers greenlit: So why are state bans still in place?

    Nov 19, 202615 minAudio

    This week, Australia’s leading health research body released its advice on puberty blockers, saying they should be available for some young people under 18. The Queensland and the Northern Territory governments, which...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Will Trump, Xi and Putin try to carve up the world?

    Nov 18, 202616 minAudio

    In 1945, in the Crimean city of Yalta, three global superpowers - America, Great Britain and the Soviet Union - met to carve up the world between them, each claiming their own sphere of influence in the final year of...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. AI job cuts at Bunnings, Qantas, NAB: ‘Mass unemployment is the business plan’

    Nov 17, 202616 minAudio

    Last week it was Qantas, last month it was NAB: two giants of Australian business cutting jobs due to the growth of AI. The explanations were familiar. Qantas says it will allow the airline to unlock innovation faster...

    Credit the people on this episode