It’s been revealed this week that Monash IVF has paid millions of dollars in secret settlements, after two nightmare mixups saw women implanted with the wrong embryos - one of them giving birth to a stranger’s baby. At least three families have now received compensation for the bungle, which was caused by human error. But these mistakes - at one of the oldest and most reputable clinics in the country - have had devastating consequences that reach far beyond the affected families, damaging the confidence of anyone relying on fertility treatment in Australia. In this episode, which first aired in June 2025, Ruby Jones speaks with writer and public health campaigner Hannah Bambra on why the IVF industry is so vulnerable to human error. If you enjoy 7am, the best way you can support us is by making a contribution at 7ampodcast.com.au/support. Socials: Stay in touch with us on Instagram Guest: Hannah Bambra, writer and public health campaigner Photo: AAP Image/Dean Lewins
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1I'm Daniel James and you're listening to seven AM. This week has been revealed that Monash IVF has paid millions of dollars in secret settlements after two nightmare mixups saw women in planet with the wrong embryos, one of them giving birth to a stranger's baby. At least three families have now received conversation for the bungle, which was caused by human error. But these mistakes that one of the oldest and most reputable clinics in the country have had
Speaker 1devastating consequences that reach far beyond the effective families, damaging the confidence of anyone relying on fertility treatment in Australia. In this episode, which was first aired in June twenty twenty five, Ruby Jones speaks with writer and public health campaigner Hanabambra on while the IVF industry is so vulnerable to human error.
Speaker 2It's Sunday, Mark, So, how you been looking into some pretty catastrophic erarors that have been happening at IVF clinics in Australia And some of these stories I think are pretty terrifying and almost unbelievable. Tell me about what's been coming to light.
Speaker 3So earlier this month, there was a couple at monash IVF in Clayton who were told that they received the wrong embryo. That was a queer couple and she received her own embryo instead of her partner's embryo, which wasn't on their plan, and this has been referred to as an incredibly rare human error. But it comes only two months after an announcement that at monash Ivf's Brisbane clinic,
Speaker 3someone gave birth to a stranger's.
Speaker 2Child, which I imagine would have been a pretty shocking to discover.
Speaker 4It's incredibly shocking.
Speaker 5There are urgent calls for tighter industry regulation tonight as new details emerge into what went wrong in the monash IVF bungle.
Speaker 6The two women were patients at monash IVF. Woman A had a number of embryo successfully frozen. Months later, when there was one less than she was initially told, doctors said they must have counted wrong, but really one had been transferred into woman B, who became pregnant.
Speaker 3Those people will be assumed to be the parents of that child, but they have no genetic links to that child, and that child is now nearly two years old, so it's taken a long time for that to come to light, and that would be a really confusing thing for the birth parents, for the child themselves, and for the couple who'se or individual whose embryo was used. And I can't help but think what if that was your last embryo that was given to a stranger.
Speaker 2And so when these stories of embryo mix ups came to light, what has the response been from monash IVF.
Speaker 3So monash IVF have apologized, and earlier this month, their CEO stepped down in.
Speaker 7A statement to the AX. On Thursday morning, Mono chavif For announced it's chief Michael Kannap, was out, two days after the company revealed it had incorrectly transferred the wrong embryo to a patient in Melbourne last week.
Speaker 3They've launched internal investigations and their clinical director has said that whenever there's humans in a system, there's going to be the potential for human error, but it's incredibly rare for that to happen. And I think the fact that there's now been two announcements in two months is really scary for people.
Speaker 2And having embryos mixed up in this way, I mean, this is on the higher end of things that can go wrong when you're talking about IVF, but people who have been to these providers have talked about other smaller but still very painful things that have happened to them as they've gone through that process. Can you tell me about some of the stories that you've heard.
Speaker 3Sure, So, as you said, receiving the wrong embryo is probably the most catastrophic mistake that could happen in a clinic, but it seems like these instances have been a platform for people to start sharing other really scary things that have happened to them in clinics as well. So there's one woman who I spoke to who had been to another major clinic based in Melbourne and she went through a round of IVF.
Speaker 4She was able to.
Speaker 3Extract three eggs during that process, and she would have already been feeling really vulnerable at that point because you do get given statistics like one in four eggs is likely to survive thaoring. But in this instance, all three eggs survived thawing, so it looked like it was going well, and then they just had to wait and see how many of those eggs turned into embryos. Because she was going through the process with her partner. One day she
Speaker 3received a call to say that two of those eggs had turned into embryos. And then the next day she received another call saying, actually, sorry, we were wrong. None of them have survived. And then they received another call later that day saying, actually, that was an ADMIN error.
Speaker 4Two of them did survive.
Speaker 3So, as you can imagine, there's a huge amount of grief that can come up in those kind of mistakes, and a lot of people say that they feel like they've failed as well. And then for that to just have been an ADMIN era really isn't good enough. You know. They're not treated with the bedside manner that they should receive when they're going through such a delicate and personal process.
Speaker 2Yeah, and there's obviously a huge impact of something like this on the people who are actually going through it, people like Stacy. But what message do you think it sends to others who might be considering IVF and are now seeing these mistakes play out.
Speaker 3Yeah, So people considering going through IVF now or about to go through the process obviously are seeing a real lack of public trust in IVF, and it's often something that they might have been saving for for a really long time, So I think people are really vulnerable by the time they get to this stage of considering IVF. Some people consider it to be their last hope, and other people have thought about it for a really long time. So I think seeing these kind of mistakes happen is
Speaker 3putting extra stress on people who are already already vulnerable and already trying to trust.
Speaker 2Coming up after the break, how Hannah's own IVF journey showed her what's wrong with the industry. Hannah, this is a personal story for you as well. Could you talk to me about your IVF journey.
Speaker 3Yeah, So two years ago I found myself single and in my thirties, and I received a diagnosis of polycystic ovary syndrome, and I decided to freeze my eggs. And for me, that was a really empowering decision, taking a bit of control of my fertility. And Monash IVF have been in the game for a really long time. They actually were part of Monash University and achieved the world's
Speaker 3first IVF pregnancy in the last century, so their reputation really appealed to me. I thought, if I'm going with the people who essentially invented iv for part of those early days, then I'm going to be in good hands.
Speaker 4But when I.
Speaker 3Actually started to engage with the clinic, I was really surprised by how old fashioned their approach was. I got a lot of questions about being single, which I was surprised about because I thought a lot of people would be going through this process, especially the initial egg freezing process by themselves or with a friend. And you know, there's quite stigmatizing language that can be used for people. If you are single or queer, you are still considered
Speaker 3socially infertile in Australia. It's kind of riddled with assumptions about why you might be going through this process and almost treating it like a lifestyle choice.
Speaker 2Yeah, it sounds like there are still very much inequities maked into the system.
Speaker 3I think so every form that I was given as a single person had a place for a partner to sign, which I think is really insensitive at the least, And it also really assumes that everyone going through IVF or using ART is.
Speaker 4A heterosexual couple, which just isn't true.
Speaker 3Nearly six percent of children in Australia are born to IVF now, so there's a huge range of people who need to use assisted reproductive technologies. Only recently was there some changes to the Medicare rebates. So previously you had to prove that you were medically infertile rather than socially infertile to be able to get any kind of Medicare rebates, and just as of late last year, they've changed that so you can get small rebates if you're a single
Speaker 3person or if you're in a same sex female couple, which is outdated language as well. And to be honest, the Medicare rebates don't really touch the edges of how much these processes cost.
Speaker 2And just to come back to the way that these companies operate, it seems like some of these mistakes are really only coming to light by chance, and sometimes a long time after they've actually happened. So do you think that there is an issue here in terms of oversight and transparency.
Speaker 3I think that's what's coming through in these stories. And I spoke to an embryologist, Lucy Lyons, who said that people in labs are really overworked and really tired. And the increasing corporatization of the IVF sector, which now brings in more than eight hundred and ten million dollars a year means that people aren't taking breaks, people aren't in labs that are adequately staffed. So even though the people
Speaker 3on the front lines might really care about what they're doing, there isn't that oversight or transparency baked into the process. As you said, a lot of these clinics are looking at how they can improve their bottom line, how they can get new people into the system, how they can continue to return profits to shareholders. But I don't think there's enough focus on people who are coming through and how personal this process is. There's nothing more personal in a way than trying to start a family.
Speaker 2Are there particular things that you, as someone who's gone through this process, would say that need to be changed that would have made it better fore you?
Speaker 3Yeah, So I spoke to another woman as well who said that she was left with a lot of unchecked grief and that a lot of people who go through this process don't have their expectations managed adequately. And I think a lot of it comes down to the way that things are communicated. So even ensuring that everyone who speaks to con humans has a background in trauma informed care would be a start making counseling mandatory for people
Speaker 3and helping them book those sessions would be really helpful.
Speaker 4I think. So sometimes you might go.
Speaker 3From a phlebotomis taking your blood, to a nurse who is going to tell you about the next step in your cycle, to an ultrasound technician who is about to deliver an ultrasound for you, and you need to repeat facts to everyone again and again, and they might all give you different information, which can be quite confusing. Consent isn't talked about enough either, And even in my experience when I went to get an internal ultrasound, there was
Speaker 3an example where someone said, Oh, this student's going to do your internal ultrasound today, isn't that great. It's the first time they've ever done an internal ultrasound, And there wasn't much thought around whether I actually consented to that process. When internal ultra sound is very personal and very invasive, and if someone is inserting something inside you, there needs to be a conversation about that. And I think that's really common across the board that there isn't training around
Speaker 3how to ensure that someone feels safe and someone feels in control of their own body and their own fertility, because that is essentially why they are seeking out IVF in the first place.
Speaker 2Well, Hannah, thank you for your time and for your reporting.
Speaker 4Thank you, Ruby.
Speaker 1I'm Daniel James. Tomorrow on seven AM, Killer Robots and AI on the Battlefield, we dig into the face off between the Pentagon and one of the world's biggest AI companies, So who should control the way AI is used in our current and future wars?
Speaker 5Without active ethical discussion, warfare will end up being a fight between two lots of machines, and only when those machines are fully destroyed will people actually start fighting. And then follow that to its logical conclusion and we'll get back to sticks and stones. But in a nutshell, it will be machines fighting machines unless we insist on human involvement for moral and ethical reasons.
Speaker 1Thanks for listening to seven AM. We'll be back tomorrow
At COP31 in Türkiye, Australia has been helping lead global negotiations over the future of fossil fuels and the fight against climate change. But while the Albanese government pushes for stronger international action,...
Anthony Albanese runs a notoriously tight ship. Across his two terms as prime minister, there’s been very little leaking, very little sniping, and very few of his Labor Party colleagues willing to speak out against him....
This week, Australia’s leading health research body released its advice on puberty blockers, saying they should be available for some young people under 18. The Queensland and the Northern Territory governments, which...
In 1945, in the Crimean city of Yalta, three global superpowers - America, Great Britain and the Soviet Union - met to carve up the world between them, each claiming their own sphere of influence in the final year of...
Last week it was Qantas, last month it was NAB: two giants of Australian business cutting jobs due to the growth of AI. The explanations were familiar. Qantas says it will allow the airline to unlock innovation faster...