For generations of Australians, Powderfinger songs are tied to first loves, long drives, share houses, break-ups and summers that still feel close enough to touch. They were written by people, played by a band, and carried by listeners into their own lives. Now, that music has been found inside the machinery of artificial intelligence, harvested into vast datasets without permission and without payment. At the same time, the federal government is fending off whistleblower claims of a “dirty deal” with tech giants that would give AI access to Australian music and art in exchange for billion dollar investments Today, Bernard Fanning on what happens when machines are trained on our songs, and who gets to tell Australian stories, us or AI. If you enjoy 7am, the best way you can support us is by making a contribution at 7ampodcast.com.au/support. Socials: Stay in touch with us on Instagram Guest: Bernard Fanning Photo: bernardfanning.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1For generations of Australians. Powder Finger songs are tied to first loves, long drives, share houses, breakups, and summers that still feel close enough to touch. They are written by people, played by a band, and carried by listeners into their own lives. Now that music has been found inside the machinery of artificial intelligence, harvested into vast data sets without commission and without payment. At the same time, the federal government is fending off whistleblower claims of a dirty deal
Speaker 1with tech giants that would see AI access to Australian art in exchange for billions of dollars of investment. I'm Daniel James and you're listening to seven AM today Bernard Fanning on what happens when machines are trained on our songs and who gets to tell Australian stories US or AI. It's Monday, July sixth Bernard Fanning, Welcome to seven AM.
Speaker 1For a whole generation of Australian's Powder Finger was the soundtrack of their youth. What did it feel like to hear that that soundtrack, the band's entire original catalog, had been used to train artificial intelligence without your consent?
Speaker 2Well, it feels like you've been robbed. I guess it's a violation. I mean, I'm not surprised. I wasn't surprised, to be honest. I mean, there's not many lengths that these tech companies won't go to to further their own agenda.
Speaker 3So, yeah, violated.
Speaker 1I guess it's very easy just to think of a catalog as a catalog, But can you give us some sort of idea of the years and the effort that went into creating that catalog they have it so quickly hoovered up by AI.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2So I had a look at that Atlantic site the other day which lists what's been used, and I think there was a It was around one hundred and fifty one hundred and fifty five powder Finger songs and then fifty five of mine, my own solo songs. So that's over seven or eight albums from powder Finger, which were kind of released between nineteen ninety four and two thousand and nine.
Speaker 3I think.
Speaker 2Plus I've made four or five albums myself, maybe more six, So that's you know, thirty years of work. Really, I mean I haven't only written two hundred songs in thirty years. I've probably written one thousand songs. But that's that's the ones that have been released and that were available to be scraped.
Speaker 1You're part of a group of Australian artists who are speaking out after a whistleblower acclaimed that the Federal government is considering doing a deal to let our companies train on Australian copyright material lock your music in exchange for these tech giants investing billions of dollars into data centers and hundreds of millions of dollars into a fund for artists. David Pocock has labeled it as the ultimate dirty deal.
Speaker 4When I raised this in the Senate, the Minister accused me of being reckless. He went on a personal attack, but didn't actually refute the claim, wouldn't rule it out, And I'm really concerned.
Speaker 1What do you think about it?
Speaker 3Yeah? I agree with him.
Speaker 2There's the thing that I don't understand about it is that it's even possible we as artists have entered into these agreements with labels or publishers or whatnot under those terms and for that to then be just undermined by changing changing legislation.
Speaker 3It seems absurd to me.
Speaker 2I can't understand why it's even under consideration, especially given the current federal government has made a big deal about what great supporters of the arts they are. You know, our Prime Minister is a DJ and our Arts Minister is a frequent a tender of gigs of Australian bands and whatnot.
Speaker 3So I'm a.
Speaker 2Little confused by it, to be honesstand, I don't really understand how it's even a consideration, but the fact that it is means that it's kind of incumbent on us to speak out about it and make people aware of it.
Speaker 1It would be a huge turnaround from the government, was just last year ruled out an exemption for data mining like this after criticism from the arts community.
Speaker 5I don't think at the moment, you know, AI understands what a lounge room in Shepherd and Victoria smells like. It's like the innate human quality of the art and the authenticity that you know, we strive to create that our audience strives for and expects from.
Speaker 3Us as artists.
Speaker 5And you know, quite simply, all we're trying to do is future proof that to make sure.
Speaker 1We have How disappointed were you to hear that the question marks around this issue are still there when you thought, like the rest of us, thought that this issue was resolved.
Speaker 3Well, I'm very disappointed.
Speaker 2I mean, I think everybody understands that that governments have responsibility to try to do the best by their constituents.
Speaker 3That is the theory, right.
Speaker 2It appears that there's a lot more weight given to corporate interests in the modern political age. There's obviously the economic considerations of jobs and whatnot that you know, the data centers would provide. However, temporarily I understand that, but if it comes at the cost of undermining Australian culture and a cultural identity, which is essentially what this will do. I mean, a machine can't write flame trees, you know,
Speaker 2it's just can't because it hasn't lived in a small town and experienced that anguish and those difficulties that take really deep thinking to process and put into a song or a piece of art.
Speaker 3And you know, this isn't just songwriters.
Speaker 2It's authors, it's it's visual artists, it's any journalists, you guys, academics, it's a I was trying to kind of think of an analogy, and this is very clumsy, but the best I could come up with was your neighbor who you don't know, comes over, gets your moa out of your shed, takes it back to his place Moses lawn, and then puts it in his shed. It's his then, and then
Speaker 2he rents that moa to all the other neighbors and he makes money off your moa. It's a ridiculous, absurd situation, and like I said, it's very clumsy, but it kind of that is essentially what's happening.
Speaker 1We should know that the government says these claims are inaccurate, But does that ease your fears at all? Or would you like more assurances from the government. I mean, I guess the government could just come out and say no, we're not going to do that.
Speaker 2Yeah, they could just rule it out. That would end any speculation. We wouldn't even be having this conversation if they did it. And people are rightly up in arms about the fact that this is even being contemplated. So I think most Australians would acknowledge how much the arts are struggling in the modern economy, and Australian music, live music in particular, is really struggling under that. So live
Speaker 2music is actually the way now that the musicians are able to derive an income because the streaming platforms have just completely stripped away the idea of being paid for your recordings.
Speaker 1But does it does it feel in some ways, Bernard, that you know, given what's happened to musicians and revenue for recording artists over the years, particularly through the streaming platforms, that if this was to go through in some way, that this could actually be the final blow for a lot of artists when it comes to a recording career in particular.
Speaker 2Well, I think so for a recording career. I don't think anything will stop people writing songs. Nothing will stop me. It's it's a compulsion, It's something that is kind of a requirement in your life, for your for your physical and mental health, you know. So I don't think people will stop doing it, it's just their ability to do it will be completely compromised. And I mean the biggest, the biggest question is what do we want our country
Speaker 2to be?
Speaker 3What sort of soul and identity do we want?
Speaker 2And I don't want to sort of lean into jingoistic rubbish, but there is something that Australian music hast has brought to especially contemporary music, in the last sixty years that is really unique.
Speaker 3It's really unique and that should be preserved.
Speaker 2And this idea that our music can be traded as an economic token, or our ideas are somehow able to be our property is able to be traded away, is ludicrous.
Speaker 1Coming up the responsibility we all have to protect Australia's art community ber at depressingly. A recent poll found ninety percent of listeners couldn't tell AI Generator songs from human made. We're increasingly seeing AI songs make it to the top of the music charts and a Sydney band, The Fair Yesterday hit out on Instagram after finding out that the act that played before them had a recent gig was actually AI Generated.
Speaker 2I saw that I played a gig at Bootleggers in Newtown, Sydney, and the artist that played before us was AI Generated.
Speaker 1Our band was playing as part of one of Bootleggers's mixed bag events, the lineups of which put.
Speaker 2Is the genie out of the bottle on this, I guess, I mean that kind of goes to a wider question about the regulation of AI, doesn't it, and the idea that it's it's wild West At the moment there is no regulation. I heard someone an expert talking about it recently, saying that the toys that his three year old plays with are way more heavily regulated than AI. And I think we're all cognizant of the danger that it poses.
Speaker 2I mean, this is not to blanket rule out that eye is useful. It's going to be incredibly useful in a lot of ways and help us to solve a lot of problems. But it's not going to it's not going to help us to process our experiences and our feelings and make them into a piece of art that are there for other people to enjoy and to take take some value from.
Speaker 1If you were starting out, either as a solo artist or starting out again with powdered Finger, how much more difficult would it be now to start the career or to sustain the career that you've had been using.
Speaker 2It would be unbelievably difficult. I mean, I don't think we can create the impression that it's ever been easy. You know, we were we were fortunate to come up in the nineties when the cost of living wasn't anywhere near as high as it is now. But we spent seven years before we were paid by powder Finger, just working my lawns, using the neighbors MOA and doing traffic survey, whatever it was we could do in between touring to
Speaker 2actually survive. And I know that young artists are doing that now. Most of them need to work full time to be able to just pay rent and eat. It's becoming increasingly difficult. And I mean part of that is is that music and in general film too, they've been devalued so much in the last twenty five years, so that now you know, you have a subscription model where you pay eleven bucks a month for the entire history of recorded music. You know, you are probably around the
Speaker 2same generation as me, Dan, and we used to pay thirty dollars for one album, mind you. You know, maybe two dollars of that went to the artiste, split six ways or whatever it was, right.
Speaker 1But it used to be it used to be an event too. But when that's a new powder Finger CD or album was coming out, you go down to the local music store and you line up and you get it, and it would be an event. And so it's of been devalued in that way as well. It's just so much more easy to consume with so little effort.
Speaker 3That's right.
Speaker 2And this is obviously we're talking about this as an Australian example, but this is also a gateway for that to happen to all the music that's ever been made, you know, and most of us that are interested in music treasure that. And I don't think many people would think that it's fair that it was just able to be used without permission and without payment, you know, And
Speaker 2and on.
Speaker 3Top of that, it's just it's fucking bad manners and.
Speaker 2That's seriously lacking in society these days.
Speaker 1Yeah, absolutely one percent.
Speaker 3Well on that.
Speaker 1I mean, we've talked about the government's responsibility and all of this. What about music fans? What responsibility do we have as listeners when it comes to AI?
Speaker 3Ah?
Speaker 2Well, I mean, are there many people out there going and searching for AI content? I mean, and I call it content on purpose because that's what it is. It's not music, it's content. It's just a series of ones and zeros that are aggregated, right. I Mean, we tend to think of musicians as people that you see a splendor in the grass or whatever. You know, you see them on stage and whatnot. But there's thousands more that are composers that write music for advertising for television or
Speaker 2whatever as well, that are obviously probably at even more danger than people that are writing music for kind of general public consumption as a band or whatever. So there's so many layers to this that the public has a responsibility I suppose to refrain from using it, but also that also goes to advertising agencies, film soundtrack directors and whatnot to not use it because it's actually undermining the
Speaker 2entire industry.
Speaker 1Yeah, there are several different points in which people can choose not to use it, and I guess that goes to listeners as well. Finally, Bernard, how do you see the future of music and art more broadly if we don't create solid boundaries and regulations around AI. What's your greatest fear?
Speaker 2Well, I think it's probably the extension of the idea that already exists that it's not a real job, you know, the idea that working on a piece of art or a film or whatever it is, or a song or a book is something that you should do as a hobby. And the devaluing of art has already been happening at pace for a quarter of a century, and this will accelerate it massively, absolutely massively.
Speaker 3I mean, there's.
Speaker 2Lots of kind of phrases like late stage capitalism and whatnot.
Speaker 3This is about money. This is about companies.
Speaker 2That are already incredibly powerful, have massive amounts of capital behind them, looking to save money for themselves at the expense of other people who are trying to create something. And it's a pretty clear representation of where we're at as a society worldwide that the money is the new god and it's taken center stage over everything because our leadership is failing on so many levels.
Speaker 1Yep, the stakes are very high. Bernard, thank you so much for coming and speaking to us in seven am.
Speaker 3No thanks, Dan, nice to talk to you.
Speaker 1Also in the news, the family of a tire teenager llegedly murdered by an Australian man says they want the legal process to take its course. In Thailand, people facing criminal charges are allowed to pay victims all their families compensation as a show of remorse and to reduce their jailed time, but the father of seventeen year old Tungannook Dolhammer says they don't want the accused money. If found guilty, forty five year old Simon Carmen could face life in jail or even the death penalty, and the Australian Space
Speaker 1Agency is examining suspected space debris which was assured north of Townsville over the week. Ken An exclusion zone remains around the four mystery objects found on Forest Beach. Experts say that the shape of the objects suggest they may have come from a large satellite or rocket. I'm Daniel James. Thanks for listening at seven am. We'll be back tomorrow.
At COP31 in Türkiye, Australia has been helping lead global negotiations over the future of fossil fuels and the fight against climate change. But while the Albanese government pushes for stronger international action,...
Anthony Albanese runs a notoriously tight ship. Across his two terms as prime minister, there’s been very little leaking, very little sniping, and very few of his Labor Party colleagues willing to speak out against him....
This week, Australia’s leading health research body released its advice on puberty blockers, saying they should be available for some young people under 18. The Queensland and the Northern Territory governments, which...
In 1945, in the Crimean city of Yalta, three global superpowers - America, Great Britain and the Soviet Union - met to carve up the world between them, each claiming their own sphere of influence in the final year of...
Last week it was Qantas, last month it was NAB: two giants of Australian business cutting jobs due to the growth of AI. The explanations were familiar. Qantas says it will allow the airline to unlock innovation faster...