Rick Morton was writing about the restructures happening at several universities earlier this year when documents from the University of Technology Sydney caught his eye. UTS had hired KPMG to help it save $100 million through a restructure. That restructure has now led to the announcement of 400 job losses, with the entire School of Education gone. Rick noticed that UTS had asked KPMG to provide a spreadsheet ranking researchers by how much money they were bringing in, which raised the questions - were they using this to inform their restructure? And if they were, what does that say about how Australian universities are grappling with the pressure to be profitable at a time when research and learning is under threat? If you enjoy 7am, the best way you can support us is by making a contribution at 7ampodcast.com.au/support. Socials: Stay in touch with us on Instagram Guest: Journalist Rick Morton
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Okay, So, Rick, a spreadsheet might not usually be the most exciting place to start a story necessarily, but this spreadsheet is different.
Speaker 2It was so red.
Speaker 1Hot that there were many people who.
Speaker 2Denied that it even existed for months.
Speaker 1So tell me about the spreadsheet, what is in it and when did you first hear about it?
Speaker 3First of all, Ruby, how dare you?
Speaker 4Spreadsheets are very exciting in my line of work, but particularly this one.
Speaker 1Rick Morton was writing about the crisis at Australian universities earlier this year when some documents from the University of Technology Sydney caught his eye. Uts said, hired the big consulting firm KPMG to help them save one hundred million dollars through a restructure, and.
Speaker 4It's a restructure we've now just seen start. They announced eleven hundred subjects will be axed, the entire School of Education is gone, and one hundred and sixty full time equivalent jobs in academic workforce are gone, and there's about to be two hundred and forty more across professional staff. So this is a significant kind of swinging cut across the university to save one hundred million dollars a year.
Speaker 1As he read through the documents, he noticed there was a request from UTS asking KPMG to create a master Excel spreadsheet, one that ranked researchers by how much money they were bringing in.
Speaker 4Now that's interesting to me because you can't make someone redundant purely based on performance. If they've got a performance issue such as not researching enough for bringing in enough money, that has to be dealt with under a separate part of the EBA. So why would UTS be asking for this breakdown from KPMG in a redundancy drive.
Speaker 1That question sent Rick on a hunt to find out was this list real, and what he found reveals a lot about the way Australian universities are grappling with the pressure to be profitable at a time when research and learning is under threat. I'm Ruby Jones, and you listening to seven AM Today journalist Rick Morton on UTS, KPMG and.
Speaker 2The secret Spreadsheet.
Speaker 1It's Thursday October two. Okay, so you hear about this spreadsheet. Clearly there are questions about what it is, how it's being used, and whether it's allowed to be used in that way. So tell me a bit more about how you go about finding out more about it.
Speaker 2And how the university responds.
Speaker 4It's a great question because you know, they could have explained this away. I wouldn't have believed the explanation potentially, but they could have said, look, we asked for it as an input, but we weren't using it to make any decisions.
Speaker 3We've got all this other work going on.
Speaker 4But what they ended up doing was it scenes from the outside trying to hide the fact that this spreadsheet was even handed over to the university. And that's when my spider sense as a journalist starts to go off. People were trying to get access to this thing. There was mentioned in all of these work orders. There were under Fredmin Information laws in New South Wales called Keeper people were putting in requests for access to the contracts, the work orders, the status reports, and in every one of these there is reference to this master Excel spreadsheet.
Speaker 3Which UTS has asked for.
Speaker 4And in the March contract signed by the Vice Chancellor this year, Andrew Parfitt not only said they'd asked for it, but that they'd completed it and so where is this thing right? And so fys get put in. There's one from the National Tertiary Education Union branch officials as another anonymous person who submits a keeper request and the FYS come back and there is no documentation. They say that we can't find this spreadsheet. Yes, it was asked for early on, but it never eventuated because the work was discontinued.
Speaker 4People say, this doesn't make any sense, so they're write back clarifying emails to the head of Corporate Information at the University of Technology, Sydney, who writes back, I can advise, however, that this master spreadsheetem quoting did not eventuate and was no longer required as an output of the OSI what they call the Operational Sustainability Initiative, that's.
Speaker 2The restructure, And I mean, what do we know about that. Does the spreadsheet exist?
Speaker 3It does?
Speaker 4It does, but only we only know this because people much smarter than me kept going back to the university saying, hang on a second, this doesn't make any sense because in the workhorder, not only do they say that this thing is requested, but there are clear status updates from KPMG that explain that the work has been discussed with the Deputy Vice Chancellor of Research, Professor Katherine McGrath, and that the analysis will be prepared.
Speaker 3You know.
Speaker 4In the contract signed by Parthad it says activity one point one validate diagnostic analysis was shown as completed before Christmas twenty twenty four, So what's going on here? And so people kept submitting more keeper requests. There was an internal review of the one that was put in by the Tertiary union and the barrister hired by a UTS to conduct that internal review was himself misled about the existence of this spreadsheet.
Speaker 1Right, tell me more about that. So the university hired this someone to look into their own response to these essentially freedom of information requests and tell me about what they told the barrister.
Speaker 4Yeah, So the barrister can only report and they're from Wentworth Chambers, so they're an independent legal expert. They can only report and find what they're told by the university and the university. This barrister sets out a bunch of questions, essentially saying this is what has been asked for. These are the contentions an issue for this internal review? Can you give me the detail of them? And one of those questions is was there a spreadsheet? And they say no, there was no spreadsheet. And the barrister in the internal review found that there was no excess spreadsheet, and again
Speaker 4people came back and said, we don't believe this, and it's only because of this kind of you know, months of pushing that suddenly low and behold the university finds.
Speaker 3The spreadsheet.
Speaker 2Coming up.
Speaker 1What this saga says about the state of Australia's universities. Okay, so they did not reveal the existence of the spreadsheet to Freedom of Information requests. They didn't tell the barrister they hired about the spreadsheet. So the university, I mean, for starters, are they breaking the law here by not revealing information they potentially should to an FOI request?
Speaker 4By their own admission, they told the barrister conducting the internal review that if this document existed then absolutely it should have been handed over under the Geeper law, the access to information public access law in New South Wales. And also accidentally not supplying it is not an excuse. You have to do a proper thorough search for these docums and it's when they're requested. Now, how hard could it have been to find this spreadsheet? Well, as it turns out, not very hard at all, because there is an email with it to the Deputy Vice Chancellor Research
Speaker 4Professor Catherine McGrath at her request discussing the breakdown or the research output by staff name, staff id, staff, position, category of research, category of employment. It's all there and we know that the DVCR, the Deputy Vice Chancellor of Research, was the senior person responsible for the Research Priority and Investment section of the KPMG restructure, So that would have
Speaker 4been the first person you go to and go, hey, you know that whole section of work that we paid for, that was listed in the work order, that was listed in the status updates that said there was an ex salesprea.
Speaker 3Sheeet did you get it? And we now know that she did because she asked for it.
Speaker 2How do we know that?
Speaker 4So in October last year there was an all day leadership retreat, but it was held at uts On campus, so I don't know how much of a retreat it was, but all the senior leaders were there, the vice Chancellor, the Deeputy Vice Chancellor Research, the vice Chancellor's chief of staff. They were all doing a hands on. There was a huge presentation from KPMG. Part of that presentation was about the Research Priority and Investment part of their work, which is Katherine McGrath's business and during that day she emails a KPMG partner.
Speaker 3We don't know the name because all the KPMG names are.
Speaker 4Redacted and says hi, I assume you have a list of all the individuals from level A through level E that are in the bottom twenty five percent or have no research er. It's kind of like research income or research outputs McGrath wrote, And that was on seventeenth of October. Would you be able to send that to me so I can get a sense of this now. The KPMG people were doing the retreat that day, but they respond the following week on the Monday. We hope that you were well and that you had a lovely weekend.
Speaker 3How nice. Twenty first of October.
Speaker 4For the initial diagnostic analysis work, we focused on identifying level D and E reason searches only who are in the bottom twenty fifth quartol for research income and publications, and the list of level DN E researches with zero income and or zero publication across the same three year period. Just for explanation, DNA are kind of like the most highly paid people at a university. So we're talking I think assistant or associate professors and professors DN and so if you're going to cut these people in a redundancy program,
Speaker 4you would save the most amount of money. So it's quite significant in that sense. And so that's how they set it out in the email. And then they attached to that email the spreadsheet which was password protected and it contained I counted them myself, eighteen pages of individual staff names for the Deputy Vice Chancellor Research.
Speaker 1Okay, so now that we know that it does exist and that's what's in it, what has the university said about why they have it and why they didn't reveal it for so long.
Speaker 3It's a question we still don't have a proper answer to.
Speaker 4But suddenly, when they are forced to hand it over, after you know, multiple requests from people, they insert a little context paragraph that says, oh, okay, yeah, look here is the spreadsheet. What happened was that it was part of a portion of work that was discontinued. It was discontinued in May this year and it was never finalized, but there was this spreadsheet that went to early on the Deputy Vice Chancellor Research and she decided to intervene. Now I asked them what intervene means? In this context.
Speaker 3It's weird. It's weird.
Speaker 4They kind of give you three options and say pick one. So they said, UTS has previously responded tokeeeper and information requests relating to KPMG documents.
Speaker 3Yeah, we know.
Speaker 4However, those responses did not include the list that has now been provided via this more recent keeper request. Yep, this may have been this is fun this part. This may have been due to search parameters being too broad, inaccurate assessment of the documents, or genuine human error. Do they tell us which one they think it is? No, so take your pick. They say, UTS takes its keep oblications very seriously. We can absolutely rule out any perceived or actual conflicts of interest.
Speaker 3Well, what happened?
Speaker 4Was it in an accurate assessment of documents? And if so, who did the inaccurate assessment? Because we all know what a spreadsheet looks like, we all know what was being asked for.
Speaker 3Was a genuine human error? Who made the error?
Speaker 4I asked them if they're going to retract the internal review the findings of the internal review, and they did not answer that question. So, you know, I don't know what happened. We're not any closer to the truth. On this front, but I think it does. It's a problem, right because it then speaks to this border issue of well, how transparent are the decisions being made? Not just in this restructure, but as we know from the governance inquiries in the universities across the country, there is a transparency problem across the entire sector. And this is a great
Speaker 4case study in how easily those two insparency issues can arise.
Speaker 1So the university has now admitted that the spreadsheet exists, but they have said they didn't rely on it in making decisions. And this is one story. This is one university, it's one spreadsheet, but it does speak to these broader issues, as you say, of governance in the sector. So what does it tell you about how universities are grappling with the pressure to be profitable versus their role, their public role as you say, as places of research and learning.
Speaker 3Yeah, it's not good.
Speaker 4I mean the parliamentary the Senate inquiry into governance Quality of governance at Australian Higher Education Institutions was the interim report was released just you know, a week and a half two weeks ago now, and in that there are so many examples, you know, there's an example from I think the NTEU branch at Monash University, where apparently the university commissioned this entire governance review of the council never told staff or students that it was happening. The governance review was apparently finished handed to the council, has never been made public.
Speaker 3What did it find? What say do people have in how these institutions are run.
Speaker 4We know more than we should now about what happened at Australian National University. The vice Chancellor's resigned, the chancellor's really bishop is still there. But there is a story at every university for this issue. And partly that is the fault of government regulation but also government funding.
Speaker 3And so universities have been brought to this.
Speaker 4Position of weakness by our own oversight and then they've panicked in the face of these terrible policies. Rightly so, well, the policy is bad, but they shouldn't panic. And the panic is now going to harm these institutions by gutting them.
Speaker 3Some would say you're reparably for years to come.
Speaker 2Well, Rick, thank you for your time.
Speaker 3I'm always happy to help Ruby, thank you.
Speaker 1And Rick Morton's recent book Meanstreak about the Coalition's deadly Robodette scheme was one of six winners of this year's Prime Minister's Literary Award, taking the award for nonfiction. So we just wanted to say congratulations from all of us at seven am. Also in the news today, a former Human Rights commissioner and one of Australia's most experienced international
Speaker 1legal experts is urging Australia to cut military ties with Israel, warning the government risks being complicit in genocide if it fails to act. Chris Sadoti, one of three commissioners selected by the Human Rights Council which found that Israel's war crimes in Gaza constituted genocide, has addressed the National Press Club. He says Camber needs to apply more comprehensive sanctions on Israel and ensure no Australian made parts were going into Israeli warplanes. And Prime Minister Anthony Abernezi has welcomed the
Speaker 1Trump Administration's proposed.
Speaker 2Peace plan for Gaza.
Speaker 1The US President announced the plan alongside the Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu on Tuesday, which involves Gaza being governed by a transitional committee headed by Donald Trump and includes a former British Prime Minister Tony Blair. The plan has received criticism, including from the Australian Greens, who say it removes the right of Palestinians to determine their own future.
Speaker 2I'm Ruby Jones. This is seven am. Thanks for listening.
At COP31 in Türkiye, Australia has been helping lead global negotiations over the future of fossil fuels and the fight against climate change. But while the Albanese government pushes for stronger international action,...
Anthony Albanese runs a notoriously tight ship. Across his two terms as prime minister, there’s been very little leaking, very little sniping, and very few of his Labor Party colleagues willing to speak out against him....
This week, Australia’s leading health research body released its advice on puberty blockers, saying they should be available for some young people under 18. The Queensland and the Northern Territory governments, which...
In 1945, in the Crimean city of Yalta, three global superpowers - America, Great Britain and the Soviet Union - met to carve up the world between them, each claiming their own sphere of influence in the final year of...
Last week it was Qantas, last month it was NAB: two giants of Australian business cutting jobs due to the growth of AI. The explanations were familiar. Qantas says it will allow the airline to unlock innovation faster...