For generations of Australians, David Jones was somewhere people would dress up to go shopping: the Christmas windows, the fashion parades, and the excitement of taking home something special in those black and white houndstooth bags. Now, after 188 years, the department store has entered voluntary administration. Its stores are still trading, but thousands of workers face an uncertain future. And the new owner, if one can be found, will have to decide how much of the business can survive. Today, ABC business reporter Daniel Ziffer on a retail institution overtaken by changing habits, what it says about the economy, and whether Australians still want what department stores have to offer. If you enjoy 7am, the best way you can support us is by making a contribution at 7ampodcast.com.au/support. Socials: Stay in touch with us on Instagram Guest: ABC business journalist Daniel Ziffer Photo: AAP Image/Dan Himbrechts
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1For generations of Australians, David Jones was somewhere people would dress up to go shopping. The Christmas windows, the fashion parades, the excitement of taking home something special in those black and white houndstooth bags. Now, after 188 years, the department store has ended voluntary administration. Its stores are still trading,
Speaker 1but thousands of workers face an uncertain future. And a new owner, if one can be found, will have to decide how much the business can survive. I'm Daniel James, and you're listening to 7am. Today, ABC business reporter Daniel Ziffer on a retail institution overtaken by changing habits, what it says about the economy, and whether Australians still want what department stores have to offer. It's Friday, November 6. Dan,
Speaker 1it's difficult to put into words the significance of David Jones. This is the oldest... department store in the world operating under its original name. It holds a lot of nostalgia for a lot of people. It's the place where I bought my first tie. How significant is David Jones in the psyche of Australian retail?
Speaker 2It's absolutely massive.
Speaker 3It's one of those names that has just always been there through modern life.
Speaker 4Thousands of shoppers crowded the Bourke Street Mall in anticipation of the annual Meyer and David Jones stock-taking sales.
Speaker 3These department stores took up the best real estate in our biggest cities and then expanded to have flagship stores in our flashiest suburbs at the biggest shopping centres.
Speaker 4Survival of the fittest to be first through the doors to pounce on the bargains.
Speaker 3They are a model that has been under challenge for a long time. This is a really substantial day because this is a name that has resonated to mean a premium luxury experience, designer goods for decades and beyond a century. So it is extremely substantial that the company is now so imperiled that it is likely to remain in some form, but certainly a much more compressed form than it has been in the past.
Speaker 1Despite its iconic branding and its place in the lives of so many of us, it's been going downhill for a while now. When did we first know something was wrong?
Speaker 3This particular moment has been coming, but let's go back about.
Speaker 2Just a bit over 10 years.
Speaker 3The Woolworths Company in South Africa, which has no link whatsoever to the supermarket chain in Australia, bought David Jones for $ 2.
Speaker 21 billion.
Speaker 3Within a decade, they'd sold it to a private equity firm for $ 100 million. That's how substantial it's been in just the destruction of value as it's had these really high fixed costs. It's got a lot of stores. It has a lot of staff.
Speaker 2Now, with this.
Speaker 3Particular moment for David Jones, it's been coming for some months. We've had a lot of chatter about the difficulty it had.
Speaker 5The luxury retailer recently losing major brands like Chanel, Christian Dior and Gucci.
Speaker 3The flashpoint most recently was that its landlords, some of whom are listed companies, listed on the stock exchange, did put out a notice saying they haven't paid rent.
Speaker 5Talks with landlords are underway and many stores may close. It's borrowed emergency funds to keep trading through Black Friday and Christmas.
Speaker 3That is the flashing red alarm that you are right near the line of collapsing financially.
Speaker 1So when private equity firm Anchorage Capital took over, what was its plan for David Jones and what worked and what didn't work?
Speaker 3Well, I think its plan was that it would, using its magic, be able to squeeze value out and be able to avoid the missteps that other department stores have had. Department stores, I always think, they're a bit like newspapers. They had these immense advantages. They had brand recognition with department stores, physical sites in the best parts of the city, distribution channels, relationships with suppliers. And then when the internet came, both newspapers and department stores.
Speaker 2Squandered all of them.
Speaker 3For a long time, they desperately avoided online shopping. They did not take advantage of that, and they saw their consumers go elsewhere.
Speaker 2Now, there have been other forces as well.
Speaker 3Chief among them is probably the motor car, which has enabled people to not have to shop in the city. They shop at large suburban places closer to where they live, or they go to big box stores that specialize. You know, Maya is listed, so we have a bit more financial information about it. It's worth $ 400 million. JB Hi-Fi is worth a billion. You know, they have just been able to better harness the internet, retain their customers, and give them a less premium experience. There's less customer service. It
Speaker 3is more of a transaction. But that's where a lot of consumers had wanted to go. And they've been looking for just better value, probably, rather than a better experience.
Speaker 1So, Dan, what does administration actually mean for David Jones now and for his stores? And, you know, we mustn't forget the human element here, the thousands of employees that are now caught up in all of this.
Speaker 3So administration allows a company to reset. Essentially, it looks at its debts and it looks at who it owes money to and the queue of those people and allows them to make changes. Essentially, we will see a reshaping of David Jones. They will probably tear up some of those large rental contracts in places that are unprofitable. Generally, these will be outer suburban stores in your less flash areas. They just haven't been making money. But when those stores close,
Speaker 3there'll be an obvious impact on the people who work there. Now, there are pretty solid protections in Australian law for workers who are caught up in this. But we've seen as these companies get closer to the line, everything tightens up. So it's most likely the brand will continue, but it's probably in a much compressed form where a lot of the unprofitable sites are sold off or given back to the owners and they try and make it work in
Speaker 3a different, tighter model.
Speaker 1What's it likely to mean for people that have gift cards or gift vouchers with David Jones at the moment?
Speaker 2They're probably in all sorts of trouble.
Speaker 3If you have a David Jones gift voucher, you'd want to be spending it soon because those kind of assets are not treated particularly well in voluntary administration processes.
Speaker 2You are a creditor, right?
Speaker 3You have some money on your David Jones voucher, but you're a long way down the list on.
Speaker 2The people that they are trying to satisfy.
Speaker 3So If you do have a David Jones gift card, you would want to be spending that money. Otherwise, you will most likely be donating it to the administrators.
Speaker 1Still to come, can the beloved department store be salvaged? Dan, this isn't just a problem for David Jones. We know that department stores are in decline globally. Can you give us an idea of the broader picture here when it comes to the world's department stores?
Speaker 3Yeah, we've seen some of the biggest names in department stores around the world have to restructure. Selfridges, Saks Fifth Avenue, consumer preferences have changed. People don't as much go to these stores that have everything and do their shopping. They're still a really big part of some of our massive shopping centres and some of our central cities but often in them you'll find brands that you can then walk outside the door and that place has its own boutique
Speaker 3where they make up much higher margin where they keep the money Even inside the department stores, often they are renting that space. A huge amount of their money comes from renting space to different brands that they essentially have their own shop within the shop. So they make money from the rent, but they don't make as much money from the sale. So there's all of these forces on consumers. We've talked about online shopping, which has always been going to ramp up and take more and more of a percentage of what's called the wallet. It's a percentage of how much is spent by retailers. These are shops from
Speaker 3another time. That doesn't mean that they'll disappear. They evolve. But retail evolves. There are brands that didn't exist five years ago that are doing really well. There are brands that have existed for more than 100 years that are in real trouble. There's no guarantees because essentially what you're doing is you are offering something and asking people to give you money for it. There are always going to be competitors and changes and challenges. And David Jones has been caught in the pincer of these, particularly in an incredibly tough retail environment that we have at the moment
Speaker 3where people have really constrained amounts of money that they can spend. Spending more and more on the necessities of life, what's called non-discretionary items, food, fuel, housing, leaving less and less.
Speaker 2To go to the department store and pick up something nice.
Speaker 1We've talked about how much the retail landscape has changed, particularly, as you mentioned, Dan, online shopping. But what about the fashion industry specifically? How has the rise of fast fashion, international luxury brands and specialist retailers changed changed the landscape too?
Speaker 2Oh, massively.
Speaker 3I think of Melbourne's Bourke Street Mall, which is probably the busiest retail space, one of the busiest in Australia. When I think of the mall, it is now bookended at one end by H & M in the former general post office and at the other by Zara. Between them, you have Maya and David Jones. Across the road, you have JD Sports that sells sneakers and athletic ski.
Speaker 2You have Rebel Sport who've.
Speaker 3Taken a huge amount of money from the kind of athletics and fashion areas so you have all these competitors in fast fashion you know i remember 20 years ago really wasn't available in australia even though these brands were in the world you know you could go to other countries and you'd see zara uniclo primark all of these kind of fast fashion brands, they were always coming here. And then once they did, it was an absolute flood of accessibility, of access to rapidly changing fashion at quite
Speaker 3low prices. So the department stores had to reassess who they are.
Speaker 2The other thing we have to talk about as well.
Speaker 3Is the rise of Kmart and discount variety stores like Big W and Target. Kmart is the most dominant and it's had a really substantial impact. It has created essentially a floor of every item available for extremely low prices all the time. So all of these pressures on these very large businesses that probably due to their size, their history, less able to be nimble, less able to move as quickly as smaller upstart chains.
Speaker 1So what does the future of David Jones look like? Administrators are looking for a new owner. But do you think anyone will want to buy it?
Speaker 3That's a really good question. I think someone will, but at what price? They'll be looking at all of these factors on retail and going, do I really want to invest in these massive stores in highly expensive locations with a lot of staff that make money, but... have a pretty difficult future. All the challenges that exist now are going to exist in a year. They might get different. They might get worse. But it has an incredible brand. It has a deep, loyal customer base and a loyalty
Speaker 3program that makes money and gets a lot of data about what these people buy and what they want to buy. So I think it has a real future, but certainly not at nearly 40 stores spread across the nation, across the suburbs. it's more likely to be a very targeted and focused premium offering. We've seen them do that. They sell food. They have restaurants in their place. They do fashion parades in the stores that then sell, you know, really expensive clothes. So this can work. And there's a
Speaker 3lot of very smart people right now who'll be looking at the books and trying to work out if they can make it work. I do expect them to survive, but certainly not in the way that they are now.
Speaker 1And finally, Dan, is there anything that we should be reading into this collapse in relation to what it says about the broader Australian economy at the moment, at a time where people are doing it tough at certain ends of the economy? Is there anything we can read into this that tells us or red flags something that's happening broader within the economy?
Speaker 2Oh, it's really tight. We have a very uneven economy.
Speaker 3There are people who are doing fine and others who are absolutely struggling. This comes at a time where retailers say, this is the kind of tightest, worst retail environment they've had in a very long time. You have this real constraint on people's ability to spend, real fear people have about rising unemployment, will they keep their job? And often what these things do is they constrain spending more than they probably need to. People get more worried about things that haven't happened yet rather than what's happening at the moment.
Speaker 2But we have undeniable costs.
Speaker 3You know, most people have liquid fuel based cars and the cost of that has gone up insanely.
Speaker 2They have rents or mortgages.
Speaker 3All of which are at extremely high levels. The flip side of that, of course, is there is a cohort who have paid off their housing, who have more money coming into them, particularly if they are savers and they're getting a much higher interest rate than they know what to do with.
Speaker 2So we have all these different.
Speaker 3Levels of the economy, but there's no doubt that there is a tightness. People are concerned about the economy. And we've had in the past few years with Mr. Trump, with conflict, just a massive injection of uncertainty.
Speaker 2Into our economic systems.
Speaker 3And people are really attuned to that. Even if they've got very stable lives, you know, kind of stable expenses, they're really attuned that things are more expensive, that their wages aren't keeping pace. And, you know, when you have the governor of the Reserve Bank saying, look, we're probably not going to go into a recession, but it will feel like one, people kind of go, yeah, it already does now.
Speaker 1Dan, thank you so much for your time.
Speaker 2Always a joy.
Speaker 1Also in the news, a major national survey has found Australians are more pessimistic about the nation's future and believe the country is more divided. The Scanlon Foundation's annual report, which surveyed 10,000 Australians, found almost half believe Australia's system of government needs major change or should be replaced. Around 59% believe immigration levels are too high, the highest figure on record. However, a majority still believe multiculturalism has been good for Australia.
Speaker 1and a 40-year-old Perth woman has faced court, charged with allegedly stalking Green Senator Jordan Steele-John. Police allege the woman, who has been charged with aggravated stalking with intent to intimidate and demanding property by written threats, is a former partner of the Senator. The charges come as Senator Steele-John remains on leave from Parliament, following separate allegations of misconduct involving women, which he strongly denies. The WA Greens have commissioned an independent investigation into those allegations. I'm Daniel James.
Speaker 1Thank you so much for listening to 7am. We'll be back tomorrow.
At COP31 in Türkiye, Australia has been helping lead global negotiations over the future of fossil fuels and the fight against climate change. But while the Albanese government pushes for stronger international action,...
Anthony Albanese runs a notoriously tight ship. Across his two terms as prime minister, there’s been very little leaking, very little sniping, and very few of his Labor Party colleagues willing to speak out against him....
This week, Australia’s leading health research body released its advice on puberty blockers, saying they should be available for some young people under 18. The Queensland and the Northern Territory governments, which...
In 1945, in the Crimean city of Yalta, three global superpowers - America, Great Britain and the Soviet Union - met to carve up the world between them, each claiming their own sphere of influence in the final year of...
Last week it was Qantas, last month it was NAB: two giants of Australian business cutting jobs due to the growth of AI. The explanations were familiar. Qantas says it will allow the airline to unlock innovation faster...