Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

7am

7am artwork

Trump’s midterm reckoning

Nov 1, 202618 minAudio

When Donald Trump returned to the White House, he promised Americans a new era of prosperity. Now, as Americans prepare to vote in midterm elections, that promise is being tested, and the voters who put Trump in power could determine how much of that power he has left. With polls showing Democrats well placed to retake the House, and the Senate also within reach, Republican candidates are wrestling with the political cost of the president's unfulfilled promises, while Democrats hope to turn disillusionment into a political comeback after years of MAGA. Today, Director of the Australia Institute’s International and Security Affairs Program, Emma Shortis on an election that will test how deeply Trump has changed America, and whether another vision of the country can take hold. If you enjoy 7am, the best way you can support us is by making a contribution at 7ampodcast.com.au/support. Socials: Stay in touch with us on Instagram Guest: Director of the Australia Institute’s International Affairs Program, Emma Shortis Photo: AP Photo/Alex Brandon

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1The golden age of America begins right now.

Speaker 2When Donald Trump returned to the White House, he promised Americans a new era of prosperity.

Speaker 1And our top priority will be to create a nation that is proud, prosperous and free.

Speaker 2Now as Americans prepare to vote in midterm elections, that promise is being tested. And the voters that put Trump in power could determine how much of that power he has left. With polls showing Democrats have a strong chance of taking both houses, Republican candidates are wrestling with the cost of the president's unmet vision and a series of unfulfilled promises, while Democrats hope to turn disillusionment into a political comeback after years of MAGA. I'm Daniel James, and

Speaker 2you're listening to 7am. Today, Director of the Australia Institute's International Security Affairs Program, Emma Shortus, on an election that will test how deeply Trump has changed America and whether another vision of the country can take hold. It's Monday, November 2. Emma, good to see you. These are the most hotly anticipated midterms in quite some time.

Speaker 3Why?

Speaker 4Look, I think this... midterm cycle is being seen both as a big test of Trump's version of America and of American democracy itself. You know, the Trump administration has been engaged in a huge concerted effort for some time now to undermine the institutions of American democracy. And I think there's a sense that this is the big test of how well that might have worked.

Speaker 2On a podcast this month, Republican Senator Tom Tillis warned that his party was heading for a, quote, whoop-ass, unquote, in these midterms.

Speaker 3When the bullshit becomes policy that's problematic, you get this November, this thing that's going to happen 20 days from now, which I have on my countdown clock as whoop-ass.

Speaker 2Trump won a decisive victory just two years ago. So what's gone so badly wrong for the Republicans?

Speaker 4Look, I think in some ways, Dan, they're a victim of their own success. The Trump administration has been able to implement a huge suite of its policy commitments through things like Project 2025. And those policy commitments are always deeply unpopular. Things like the tariffs, things like mass deportations, which Americans overwhelmingly are opposed to and find incredibly cruel and have been organizing against. And so in that sense,

Speaker 4you know, his success is a problem for him, but so is his arrogance. You know, I think particularly the illegal war on Iran that Trump started with Netanyahu in Israel is having a huge impact on Americans. They are in the midst of a cost of living crisis and they can pin that on one guy, you know, it's Trump's fault. And so I think, What we're potentially seeing is a huge backlash to both, you know, the success of the Trump administration in implementing its policies and its

Speaker 4arrogance in doing so.

Speaker 2I think it's fair to say that Trump's victory in 2024 depended on winning over voters who might have traditionally supported the Democrats, particularly young men, Latino voters, working class Americans. Are those voters actually abandoning him now? And what does that tell us about why they voted for him in the first place?

Speaker 4I mean, I think TBC, Daniel, you know, we'll have to wait and see what those voters do in this election. But certainly polls are indicating that, you know, Trump's support, particularly amongst minority voters, you know, it was really striking last time around, as you rightly pointed out, that Trump did quite well with Latino voters, particularly in places like Florida. I think that is likely to change largely as a result of, you know, both cost of living, but also those mass deportation policies, which overwhelmingly, of course, are directed at non-white Americans. And so I think we'll see a

Speaker 4big shift there. I think also in young people, polls are indicating that many of the more left-wing Democratic candidates in places like Michigan are hugely popular with young people. And, you know, I think That tells us, of course, a number of things about the American voters' mindset, you know, that they are moving away from Trump, partly because he has created this cost of living crisis, but also because he hasn't delivered on the promises that he made to a number of those people, especially around the cost of living.

Speaker 4You know, Trump was elected on a promise to address that crisis and he's done precisely the opposite.

Speaker 3And Mr.

Speaker 5President, you've been saying for weeks that oil and gas prices are going to come down.

Speaker 2Oil is now back above $ 100 a barrel.

Speaker 5How do you explain this to Americans who are wondering when it's going.

Speaker 6To come down? Well, I think it's very easy to explain to America. All you have to do is say, will you let Iran have a nuclear weapon? And the answer is no. And they're doing very poorly. Their country is in shambles.

Speaker 4But I think it's worth, I just do want to say that there is this huge tendency, especially in American media, to overstate the influence of the swinging voter, you know, of that mainstream American, usually a white man who kind of swings between Democrats and Republicans. There's always a huge focus on them. The big outlets like New York Times are always looking for them and looking to talk to them in places like, you know, Maine or Michigan. But I think that The emphasis should actually be on turnout.

Speaker 4Turnout is what is going to matter, not small groups of swinging voters, I think.

Speaker 2Yeah, because there's expected to be about 100 million people turn out to vote, but there are 200 million people eligible to vote. So it's always been a massive problem. Trump is also facing growing dissent from within MAGA itself, the rusted-on supporters. His war with Iran has infuriated some of the most prominent American first forces, while other supporters have turned on him over the Epstein files. Are we seeing the MAGA movement begin to fall apart, or is that just wishful thinking?

Speaker 4I'm always worried, I guess, that it is wishful thinking, because this is a question we've been asking ourselves since Trump was first elected.

Speaker 2You've been burnt too many times.

Speaker 4I really have. We keep waiting for the Republicans to abandon Trump. We keep waiting for the thing that will happen that will make them all jump ship, and it hasn't happened yet. There are certainly signs that the coalition is fracturing, but there are always signs that the coalition is fracturing, and we've got to pay attention to the power dynamics within that coalition, I think. Certainly, The libertarian wing of that coalition is furious with Trump over both

Speaker 4the Iran war and the way he's dealt or hasn't dealt with the Epstein files. But it's worth emphasising that that part of the coalition doesn't have a huge amount of power. Now, that will matter absolutely for turnout. And it's certainly possible that if we do see a blue wave, you know, an overwhelming loss for Republicans, that they may begin to jump ship. But again, I think we've got to be very sceptical and we shouldn't underestimate just how much Trump has an eye and grip on the Republican Party.

Speaker 6Thank you very much. Hello, Texas.

Speaker 1This is a very special place to me.

Speaker 6Because, you know, I come back.

Speaker 2What should we read into the fact that President Trump has hit the hustings in places that have traditionally been red states?

Speaker 4I think this is a sign of just how much electoral trouble they think Republicans think they are in, quite rightly. You know, we are In a situation now where it looks like places like Texas, which hasn't had a Democrat win a statewide election since 1994, might have a Democrat in the Senate.

Speaker 1Seven days from now, the people of Texas are going to defeat Democrat communist James Tallarico.

Speaker 4You know, James Tallarico there, the Democratic candidate, is polling ahead. Not by much, you know, we're talking one or two percentage points, usually within the margin of error, but he's ahead and... Democratic candidates haven't been able to do that so far. In places like Kansas, it looks possible that Democrats will win there. And Kansas has an elected... a Democrat in the Senate since like the 1930s, like literally almost a century.

Speaker 2Since before the Wizard of Oz.

Speaker 4Yeah, that's a great benchmark. And so, you know, they are in trouble and Trump is, you know, because we've talked already about how turnout is so critical. That's what Trump is trying to drive. You know, he's trying to find those supporters in places like Kansas and get them to come out and vote because part of the problem is that support for Trump is not necessarily kind of disappearing from But it's waning, you know, it's lost its kind of virulence, I think. And there is a huge amount of mobilisation, of course, happening on the other side.

Speaker 4And so Trump's trying to drive this, you know, enthusiasm and turnout, which historically he's been very good at.

Speaker 2Still to come, should the Democrats go all in on the Mamdani approach? Emma, if we look at the Democrats, they seem to have settled on one central message for the midterms, and that is around the cost of living. But how big is the divide in the party over how to confront Trump and what kind of alternative to offer Americans? What are the tensions within all of that?

Speaker 4I think this is a battle for the soul of the Democratic Party is what we are seeing. It's been going on for a number of years, really, since the Biden years. But we're seeing this play out electorally where you have for the United States, kind of quite radically left-wing candidates who seem to have the momentum, you know, in places like Michigan with the Senate candidate there, Abdul El-Sayed, of course, in New York with Zoran Mamdani, and in a number of other places, you've seen this kind of radical resurgence of the young, vibrant wing of the Democratic Party.

Speaker 4And many of their policy positions are in kind of direct opposition to the more, I guess, mainstream establishment wing of the party, especially around key issues, of course, like Israel. And so they're united around the question of the cost of living, but not in how to address it. And they're not united on those other key issues. And you can already see a kind of fight for the narrative around where power lies in the Democratic Party. But I think it was really interesting to note that former President

Speaker 4Barack Obama, who still wields an enormous amount of influence in the party, was in Michigan over the weekend campaigning with Abdul El-Sayed.

Speaker 2Are you ready to go? Let's make Jocelyn Benson governor.

Speaker 1Let's make Abdul El-Sayed senator. Let's get on to the path of making this country better.

Speaker 7I love you, Detroit.

Speaker 4I think that tells us a bit about where power might be shifting in the party, but that it will be hard fought.

Speaker 2Yeah, so if we just take a brief look at Abdul El-Sayed, What does his popularity tell us about the potential direction of the Democratic Party? What sort of things is he espousing? What is resonating with voters there?

Speaker 4I think a number of things. You know, El-Sayed is unapologetically for the version of America that celebrates its racial diversity, it celebrates its democracy and its vibrancy.

Speaker 8America does not need us to cower backward when small-minded people tell us that we are not part of this place. America needs us to bring all that we have and all that we can contribute to the work of making America that great place it can yet be.

Speaker 4You know, it's such a stark contrast to Trump's version of America that this man, an Arab American, son of immigrants, a doctor, could be elevated to such a prominent position where everyone wants to talk to him. But I think he is part of a longer battle in the Democrats, particularly in Michigan, around how to deal with Trump, whether it's about kind of appealing to that mythical kind of centrist swing, usually white voter in the heart of the Rust Belt, in the kind of bellwether of American politics,

Speaker 4or whether it's about a broader appeal to the rest of America as well and to young people in particular. and to Arab Americans in Michigan who have been trying to tell the Democratic Party for years now that they want something more. They want a commitment to principle, to international law. They want the Democrats to stand up to Trump from a position of value and from a position of principle. Al-Said is the manifestation of that. In a way, he's the dream candidate of that. He is you know, eloquent.

Speaker 7To hold Trump accountable for this war, to end this war, to end these ridiculous tariffs. I mean, starting a tariff war with Canada is an insane thing to do, and we pay for it. Those would be the first two things we could do to really bring down prices immediately. Of course, you've been a critic of President Trump.

Speaker 4I think a lot of his politics has been described as confrontational, but it's not. I think it's just strong and coming from a position of principle and not willing to concede on cultural issues or allow Trump to kind of shift the ground under him.

Speaker 1I'm here to keep a jihadist Muslim Brotherhood member from becoming a United States Senator, and that's the fact.

Speaker 8I get that the President of the United States takes personal offense to my first name. He doesn't mind as much when it's a shared name from the Saudis who are funding his son-in-law's private equity. Doesn't seem to mind as much when it's the Qataris who are giving him a $ 400 million private jet.

Speaker 4So I think in a way it's emblematic of how this battle for the soul of the Democratic Party is playing out. And it's worth emphasising that El-Sayed is really popular in Michigan, but he's particularly popular with young people. In some polls, he's like sitting at 80% support among young people compared to his opposing candidate so you know there's potentially something radical happening in there um but again we've got to wait.

Speaker 2And see and finally emma if the democrats do manage to pull off a blue wave and take control of congress deliver a a whoop ass how much would that actually change donald trump's presidency i mean what would it mean for his agenda.

Speaker 4I think that's a great question, Daniel, and it's one that's really difficult to predict, I think, because it depends on how the Democrats behave, how they take it, and it depends on how Trump reacts, which I guess is a little bit more predictable. But certainly it will make Trump's life a lot more difficult. If Democrats control Congress, they can do things like investigate Trump and the people around him, investigate his family, his sons, his son-in-law, through pretty significant powers. Those committees have the power to subpoena people and compel them to provide evidence. So that may

Speaker 4make Trump's life more difficult. Of course, passing legislation becomes increasingly difficult. But it's worth saying that Trump hasn't really been doing that anyway. He's certainly been ignoring Congress governing through executive order And it's also true that we know when he feels cornered, when he feels weak, which he may well do if he doesn't have any control of Congress, he lashes out and he leans into the areas where he does have significant power. And I think that's why we're hearing, I guess, musings from the White House about,

Speaker 4and Trump himself, about renewing the war on Iran after the midterms and using overwhelming force there, because that's where Trump does have power and where Congress has historically been just unwilling to constrain the president. So I think in that sense, you know, it could radically affect Trump's presidency, but it could also make Trump's presidency even more radical.

Speaker 2Well, it sounds like a volatile situation is about to get more volatile. Emma, thanks for joining us again on 7am.

Speaker 4Always a pleasure. Thank you.

Speaker 2Tomorrow on 7am, Democracy Now! founder and independent journalist Amy Goodman has been keeping the bastards on us before some of us were born.

Speaker 5It's our job to go to where the silence is, and it is often not silent. People are organising, they're raucous, they're rowdy. That's where Democracy Now! lives. On the ground where people are describing their own experiences, there is nothing more powerful.

Speaker 2Now, at a time when it's never been more important to hold power to account, Goodman is speaking out on the dangers of training truth for access and why independent media needs to fight back. That'll be in your feed tomorrow. I'm Daniel James. Thanks so much for listening. you

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Ed Husic on being ‘left in the dark’ by his own government

    Nov 20, 202617 minAudio

    Anthony Albanese runs a notoriously tight ship. Across his two terms as prime minister, there’s been very little leaking, very little sniping, and very few of his Labor Party colleagues willing to speak out against him....

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Puberty blockers greenlit: So why are state bans still in place?

    Nov 19, 202615 minAudio

    This week, Australia’s leading health research body released its advice on puberty blockers, saying they should be available for some young people under 18. The Queensland and the Northern Territory governments, which...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Will Trump, Xi and Putin try to carve up the world?

    Nov 18, 202616 minAudio

    In 1945, in the Crimean city of Yalta, three global superpowers - America, Great Britain and the Soviet Union - met to carve up the world between them, each claiming their own sphere of influence in the final year of...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. AI job cuts at Bunnings, Qantas, NAB: ‘Mass unemployment is the business plan’

    Nov 17, 202616 minAudio

    Last week it was Qantas, last month it was NAB: two giants of Australian business cutting jobs due to the growth of AI. The explanations were familiar. Qantas says it will allow the airline to unlock innovation faster...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Jonathan Swan on Trump, the midterms, and the future of MAGA

    Nov 16, 202618 minAudio

    Two weeks after Donald Trump and the Republican party were handed a drubbing of historic proportions, the world is still unpacking what the midterm results mean for the US, Trump, and the rest of the world. Few are...

    Credit the people on this episode