An effort by Congress to rein in President Trump’s war in Iran has failed. Democrats and a few Republicans tried to use the War Powers Resolution to force Trump to get approval from Congress to keep fighting - but it didn’t pass. Now the war is dragging in more countries, fuelling a global crisis and dividing nations. Today Jasmine El-Gamal, former Pentagon adviser and founder of Averos Strategies, on Trump’s war - is it ego, blind ambition or part of a plan to reshape the world? If you enjoy 7am, the best way you can support us is by making a contribution at 7ampodcast.com.au/support. Socials: Stay in touch with us on Instagram Guest: Jasmine El-Gamal, founder and CEO of Averos Strategies Photo: Abbas Hassan/TASS/Sipa USA
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1We're doing very well on.
Speaker 2The warfront. To put it mildly, I would say somebody said, on a scale of.
Speaker 1Ten, where would you're adit?
Speaker 2I said about a fifteen.
Speaker 3If we didn't not everyone agrees with that.
Speaker 4This is going to make the operation in Libya look like child's play. There is no question this is war. They have contempt for the American people. They have contempt for the American people because they think that they can carry out the biggest war in the Middle East since or back in Afghanistan without a single vote, without a single discussion.
Speaker 3In an effort by Congress to reign in President Trump's war in Iran has failed. Democrats and a few Republicans tried to use the War Powers Resolution to force Trump to get approval from Congress to keep fighting, but it didn't pass. Now the war is dragging in even more countries, fuelling a global crisis and dividing nations.
Speaker 5The biggest questions are around what are the true objectives of this war and how can they be achieved? What is the off ramp, how do we get out of this? What is going to be enough for this administration to declare victory.
Speaker 3I'm Nicole Johnston and you're listening to seven AM today. Jasmine Algamo, founder of Viral Strategies, on Trump's war. Is it ego blind ambition or part of a plan to reshape the world?
Speaker 6It's Friday, March six.
Speaker 3Jasmine, You've been at the heart of US policy in the Middle East, working in the Department of Defense through the Gauntanamo Bay controversy in the Arab Spring. Did you ever expect to see the region in the middle of a war like this?
Speaker 5H Well, I didn't expect it, but I was afraid of it. This is something that myself and other analysts have been warning about for the better part of two years now, really in the post October seventh security environment in the Middle East, and so last year before the Twelve Day War, we were previewing this type of scenario exactly when we were cautioning against using military force before
Speaker 5exhausting all diplomatic options. And the scenario that we're seeing today, this scorched earth kind of tactics by the Iranian regime to survive is exactly what we have predicted.
Speaker 3Ran the Gulf countries and the rest of the world, they're all trying to work out what is President Trump's goal here, and it seems to keep changing. He's mentioned missiles.
Speaker 2Our objectives are clear.
Speaker 7First, were.
Speaker 2Destroying Orens missile capabilities, and you see.
Speaker 6That the navy.
Speaker 2Second, we're annihilating their navy. We've knocked out already ten ships.
Speaker 1The nuclear program, ensuring that the world's number one sponsor of TERA can never obtain a nuclear weapon, never going to have a nuclear weapon.
Speaker 3Cutting off the proxies like HAZBLA. But what do you think the goal is or is this really about ego so that Trump can say that he's the one who took down Hamina.
Speaker 5Great question, Nicole. I think with Trump you can never rule out ego one hundred percent. But I think it's important here to just insert a bit more nuanced into the question, because I don't think that only Donald Trump and the US are involved in this or were involved in the decision to go to war. But of course the Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Israel's national security interests as he sees them, were very much intertwined in this case.
Speaker 7Once they have the weapons of delivery ballistic missiles ICBMs intercontinental ballistic missiles, they will threaten every city in the United States.
Speaker 5And of course personal protection. We know that Prime Minister Natania, who is facing corruption trial. We know he has an election coming up that he's desperate to win to maintain immunity. We know that Donald Trump has midterm elections coming up, and he wants to say that he did something that no one could ever do. So you have a lot of you know, both personal political professional reasoning went into this, and in explaining it to the American public, the President and his national security staff have given a wide range
Speaker 5of competing reasons and justifications. Importantly, most of which came more than two days after the start of military operations and Jasmine.
Speaker 3Domestically, how is Trump trying to justify these to his base and what does the American public think of it all?
Speaker 5I would largely say that Americans are against going to war in the Middle East. Again, that Donald Trump campaigned on an electoral platform to explicitly stay out of conflicts and wars in the Middle East, and otherwise he campaigned on being a president of peace and.
Speaker 2These and these stupid, endless wars. I saved the United But that's one of the reasons Washington doesn't like me. They love those endless wars.
Speaker 5Peace through strength, yes, but what we're seeing now certainly is not strength. It's utter recklessness. And so the way he's justifying it is that he's trying to state that Iran was posing an imminent threat to the United States, that they were working towards nuclear capacity, that they were working towards long range intercontinental ballistic missiles that could strike the US homeland, and that they were refusing to make any concessions in negotiations. All of those things have been
Speaker 5proven incorrect by the intelligence community in the United States that was not assessing that Iran posed an imminent threat. And according to the Omani foreign minister who was a mediator in these talks, who said the day before strikes began on US television that the Iranians had made concessions that they did not even make with President Obama when he was negotiating the JCPOA or the Iran deal back then. What has Iran agreed to to you that they have
Speaker 5never done before?
Speaker 6Can you give us any sense?
Speaker 8The thing and most important achievement, I believe is the agreement that Iran will never ever have a nuclear material that would create able I think it is within our.
Speaker 6Reach coming up.
Speaker 3Jasmine's message to the PM don't choose might.
Speaker 6Overright, Jasmine.
Speaker 3Trump has made it clear that this isn't going to be a quick Venezuela style raid. But how much criticism and on the other side support for it is there inside the government? What are the debates that we're hearing.
Speaker 5The biggest debate right now is about what is going to be enough for this administration to declare victory. Is it the number of missiles shot down? Is it the number of leaders killed?
Speaker 2Well, most of the people we had in mind are dead, So you know, we had some in mind from that group that is dead, and now we have another group. They may be dead also based on reports. So I guess you have a third wave coming. I'm pretty sure we're not going to know anybody.
Speaker 5When President Trump was asked what his worst case scenario was, he said that the Supreme Leader who was just assassinated would be replaced by someone even worse, and he acknowledged that that is a possibility. And indeed, that is what CIA assessments stated was that that was a real possibility. So we're looking here at potentially a protracted operation, a protracted war with potentially billions more spent in US dollars
Speaker 5taxpayer money. And again, Nicole, I can't stress enough how the administration has not been able to articulate when and how this is over.
Speaker 9The answers are very unsatisfying. They have shifting goals, different goals all the time, different answers every day. And I am truly worried about Mission Creep when there's no set plan when you came.
Speaker 5So we're looking now at prospects for the future. You know what happens now with President Trump checking off that congressional box and feeling very empowered. Where can things go from here? And what I worry about, of course, is further escalation with greater and greater risks of miscalculation, and of course the tremendous human cost that we're seeing absorbed by people throughout the region.
Speaker 3Here in Australia, our Prime Minister is supporting the war.
Speaker 7We support the United State detecting to prevent Iran from obtaining a nuclear weapon and to prevent Iran from continuing to threaten international peace and security.
Speaker 3And you're in London at the moment where kir Stamer's comments at the start of the war got him in trouble with Trump.
Speaker 10This government does not believe in regime change from the Skies and I thank him for his question. The lessons of history have taught us that it is important when we make decisions like this that we established there is a lawful basis for what the United kDa.
Speaker 2Extra hours, So we are very surprised this is not Winston Churchill that we're dealing with now.
Speaker 3Stama has since shifted the country's position. Could you tell us a little bit about the UK's own difficult balancing act and what its role in this war is turning out to be.
Speaker 5Absolutely, the UK is trying to strike a balancing act. They're trying to balance their own national security interests. So anything that happens in the Middle East is much more likely to impact Europe and the UK and of course other countries in the region, and the US doesn't have to bear the brunt of that. So you see different countries in Europe trying to stake their positions. The Spanish Prime Minister has come out very strongly, very clearly and says Spain says no to war.
Speaker 11We must learn from history and cannot play Russian roulette with the fate of millions of people. The powers involved in this conflict must immediately cease hostilities and commit to dialogue and diplomacy.
Speaker 5And on the other end of the spectrum, you have Chancellor Mertz in Germany unequivocal support to President Trump, going so far as to state explicitly that international law doesn't really pertain to this situation at this time. And we have just been through two years of watching the double standards of the international community applied between the wars in Ukraine and Gaza and lamenting the loss of respect for
Speaker 5international law. Which if we don't have international law, if we cannot count on it, then so what do we have? The law of the jungle? Where might is right? What is the message that people get from that, that countries get from that, Arm up, be stronger, because that's the only way you will be able to protect yourself. And so we have this scenario now where countries like Australia and Germany saying that international law essentially doesn't matter, that a US president can decide to go to war illegally
Speaker 5and that other countries in the free world will back him up. What precedent is that setting and is it worth it? That's what I would ask the Australian leadership right now. Is this worth it?
Speaker 3I know it's impossible to really know, but what do you think the strategy of Iran is at this point, because they seem to be going for this steady, consistent pace of attacks, keeping up the pressure on the Gulf and at the same time throwing the world into chaos.
Speaker 5Iran strategy is simple two things. One survive, just survive another day. And two make the cost of this war so high on as many actors as possible so as to scare them off and have the US back down.
Speaker 3It seems that the people of Iran are almost being forgotten in all of this. There's been a lot of focus on the Gulf, on Israel, and on the US. Does it feel like they've almost been sidelined in this war? They're just sitting back with no idea what will happen next.
Speaker 5The Iranian people really stand to be the biggest losers, you know, really, no matter what the outcome is. At this point, they were told by Donald Trump to go out into the streets and take advantage of this once in a generation or multiple generation opportunity. At the same time, you have the IRGC still intact. You have the besiege that claan close paramilitary force roaming the streets, you know, intimidating people, trying to quell unrest before it even begins. Already,
Speaker 5human rights organizations are saying about a thousand people have been killed in Iran, including one hundred and eighty school children, girls between the age of seven and twelve years old. And so you have to think from the Iranian perspective, the US President, the Israeli Prime Minister, the Iranian leadership, they have all gambled so recklessly with the lives of ninety million people who have already been through so much,
Speaker 5so much hardship, so much economic hardship, and otherwise they're completely cut off from the world. The people can't reach their families inside of Iran from outside. No one really knows what's going on in their days lives. And you just have to feel that it's incredibly tragic for world leaders to be so callous with the lives of an entire population.
Speaker 6Jasmine, thanks so much for joining us.
Speaker 5Pleasure, thank you for having me.
Speaker 3Also in the news, monash IVF has paid millions of dollars in secret settlements after two nightmare mixups which saw women implanted with the wrong embryos. At least three families have now received compensation, reported to be in the millions. Monash has investigated the bungles which resulted in a Queensland woman giving birth to a stranger's baby. It found both cases were due to human error, and Australia and Canada will deepen ties on critical minerals, defense, vaccines and AI.
Speaker 3Anthony Albanezi and Mark Carney announced the move in a joint press conference in Canberra during the Canadian PM's whirlwind visit. Carney has offered to team up with Australia as strategic cousins to push back against dominant superpowers. I'm Nicole Johnston. This is seven AM. Thanks for listening.
At COP31 in Türkiye, Australia has been helping lead global negotiations over the future of fossil fuels and the fight against climate change. But while the Albanese government pushes for stronger international action,...
Anthony Albanese runs a notoriously tight ship. Across his two terms as prime minister, there’s been very little leaking, very little sniping, and very few of his Labor Party colleagues willing to speak out against him....
This week, Australia’s leading health research body released its advice on puberty blockers, saying they should be available for some young people under 18. The Queensland and the Northern Territory governments, which...
In 1945, in the Crimean city of Yalta, three global superpowers - America, Great Britain and the Soviet Union - met to carve up the world between them, each claiming their own sphere of influence in the final year of...
Last week it was Qantas, last month it was NAB: two giants of Australian business cutting jobs due to the growth of AI. The explanations were familiar. Qantas says it will allow the airline to unlock innovation faster...