On the Mid North Coast of New South Wales, Labor has promised a vast new national park to protect more than 12,000 koalas. But there’s a catch. The New South Wales government wants carbon credits to help pay for it. By ending planned logging, it could generate credits that are then sold to companies to offset their emissions. For the Greens, that creates a dilemma at a moment when both major parties are bleeding voters - voters who are walking straight past the Greens as an alternative. They want the forests protected, but have long opposed carbon offsets that allow big polluters to keep polluting. Now those two positions are about to collide. Today, co-chief executive officer of the Australia Institute Richard Denniss on koalas, carbon offsets and whether the Greens are still willing to pick the big fights. If you enjoy 7am, the best way you can support us is by making a contribution at 7ampodcast.com.au/support. Socials: Stay in touch with us on Instagram Guest: Co-chief executive officer of the Australia Institute, Richard Denniss Photo: AAP Image/David Wigley
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1I'm Daniel James, and you're listening to 7am. On the mid-north coast of New South Wales, Labor has promised a vast new national park to protect more than 12,000 koalas. But there's a catch. The New South Wales government wants carbon credits to help pay for it. By ending planned logging, it could generate credits that are then sold to companies to offset their emissions. For the Greens, that creates a dilemma. at a moment when both major parties are bleeding voters,
Speaker 1voters that are walking straight past the Greens as an alternative. They want the forest protected, but they have long opposed carbon offsets that allow big polluters to keep polluting. Now, those two positions are about to collide. Today, co-chief executive of the Australia Institute, Richard Dennis, on koalas, carbon offsets, and whether the Greens are still willing to pick the big fights. It's Monday, September 7. Richard, Labor's vote collapsed
Speaker 1in Sacred Harbour at the by-election, but the Greens didn't pick up those voters. We saw the same thing in Farah, and nationally support for Labor in the coalition has fallen, while the Greens have barely moved on that front. Why are voters deserting major parties but running straight past the Greens?
Speaker 2Look, I guess the why is contestable, but let's start with the what. Yeah, Labor lost half of their voters in Secret Harbour. I mean, that is enormous. Their primary vote went from about 40 to about 20, and the Greens' vote went down. Now, that's not necessarily an indictment on the Greens, but it's certainly an indictment on their ability to capture Labor voters fleeing Labor. So the what, I think, is really important. The votes are on the move. Australian
Speaker 2voters are looking for an alternative. Australian voters want something new. And what the polls and the election results show us is that they don't think that's the Greens. Why not? Partly, obviously, the message the Greens putting out clearly isn't capturing those people. No doubt the Greens would say, well, the media give One Nation far more attention than them. That's true. But here's a tip. That's not going to change. If the Greens, after 30 years of being treated poorly by the media, if their strategy is to hope the media will start
Speaker 2treating them well, that's not going to happen. But in the age of social media, the opportunity for the Greens to reach out directly should have never been higher. And Hanson's doing it. Hanson was doing very well on social media two, three years ago. I don't think anyone would say the Greens are doing that well on social media either. So what's going on? I don't think anyone can argue about it. Why is it going on? Are they too cautious? Are they kind of being a bit too centrist? Is it the media picking on them?
Speaker 1I don't know.
Speaker 2Maybe they think the times don't suit them. But if climate catastrophe and authoritarianism doesn't suit them, I don't know what would.
Speaker 1Yeah, we've just been through the hottest winter here in Victoria on record. So, you know, it's not like it's not an issue. When Larissa Waters took leadership, she promised a different style, less shoutiness, more constructive politics.
Speaker 3I think people are so sick of the carping and the chest beating and the arguing that they see in places like Question Time. They just want to know that we're there to work for them and that we're going to try and fix the problems that they're facing in their daily lives and that we're going to protect the climate and nature that sustains us all.
Speaker 1But Richard, one could argue that politics has never been shoutier. Do you think that type of leadership is right for this moment?
Speaker 2Again, that's up to voters to decide. To be clear, I run a think tank. I'm involved in public debate day in and day out. I always try to be polite to people, but I always try to speak as clearly as I can. I think when Larissa Waters says I don't want to be shouty, if she means I want to treat people with respect, great. I think we need more of that. But, you know, Jackie Lambie's shouty and people really responded when she displayed her sincere passion and emotion around how we're treating veterans. Drop the bloody cap.
Speaker 2Drop it, mate.
Speaker 4It is so unfair.
Speaker 2It is what we do not need. It is enough.
Speaker 1Veterans have had enough.
Speaker 4Leave us alone.
Speaker 2You know, shouting can mean different things to different people, but I think that saying I want to be constructive sounds like I don't want to have fights with the government. I want to work with them behind closed doors to make incremental change to policy. And I reckon at a point in time where... Former US Democrat voters voted for Trump to drain the swamp and former UK Labor voters voted for Farage because they're sick of the whole shitty system. In an environment where that's clearly happening in Australia as well,
Speaker 2I think there's a real risk if the Greens think that their main contribution to our democracy is is to be tinkering away, making small changes behind the scenes. There's a role for that, and there's at times a very important role. But if that's all you're doing, then again, in the age of social media, where the algorithm does amplify clarity, if you're trying to get a subtle nuanced message out about how we're disappointed with what Labor's doing, but we'd be slightly less disappointed if we tweaked it a little bit, If that's the Greens' approach, well, personally,
Speaker 2I think democracy needs big, clear choices, but it's up to the voters, and the voters seem to be saying the same thing.
Speaker 1Of course, the Greens had a very bruising 2025 federal election. When it comes to what went wrong, do you think voters thought the Greens were too obstructive, or that despite people like Max Chandler-Maver being loud and combative, the party still looked too much like part of the political establishment?
Speaker 2Yeah, look, I think it's complicated because the reality is the Greens' vote didn't really change at the federal election. They lost three lower house seats. But for 10 years, they'd had one member of parliament in the lower house, one, one, one, one. And then they got four, and then they went back to one. So obviously, everyone went, oh, you lost three seats. And that was devastating. And one of them was their leaders. I'm not trying to put lipstick on that pig. That was a tough election result. But if you look at the primary vote, it was flatlining. They didn't have a
Speaker 2collapse in their vote, but they did lose a couple of seats they won in Brisbane, arguably seats they won off the back of the Brisbane floods. So yeah, the problem is the stability of the Greens. They really just have been in that kind of 10% to 12% range for so long. Yes, they had a bad election result, but I think they really need to ask harder questions like, With climate change getting far worse, with authoritarianism on the march, not just globally here in Australia, what is the proposition that the Greens are putting to voters? And again, when
Speaker 2Democrat voters voted for Trump, it wasn't because they thought his sophisticated policy agenda was just the fix for the long to medium term needs of the US economy. It was people saying, this trickle-down shit didn't work, I'm over it, I want big change, I want someone who will actually fight for me. And the problem with saying, I'm going to tinker with Labor's agenda and I'm not going to be shouty, is I think voters hear, I'm not going to fight hard for you.
Speaker 1Coming up, have the Greens lost their appetite for a fight? Richard, you argue that the bigger problem is what the Greens are doing with the power they actually have, that they've become too satisfied with simply tinkering with Labor's agenda. What are some of the clearest examples of that approach?
Speaker 2Oh, there's a big one coming up. So to be clear, the global scientific consensus says that the world needs no more gas and no more coal mines built, right? We have enough. We actually need to use less than the ones we've already got. And at this point in history, where the last thing we need is new gas and coal, and the easiest place to get the revenue we need for services is to tax gas, Labor's trying to create some more carbon offsets at the moment. And the Greens are in balance of power on whether to create more
Speaker 2carbon offsets or not.
Speaker 5The New South Wales government announced the creation of the 476,000 hectare Great Koala National Park last year. And there's a proposal to use the park to create carbon credits worth hundreds of millions of dollars. That proposal faces a vote in the Senate next month with the Greens considering opposing the carbon credit arrangement.
Speaker 2And let's just make this really simple. If we increase the supply of carbon offsets, the price goes down, right? The more offsets there are, the more pollution there'll be and the cheaper the pollution will be. Yet the Greens are like, oh, we don't necessarily want to have a fight with Labor. We want to look constructive. Now, to be clear, the Greens haven't publicly said which way they'll go on this, but it just seems like a no-brainer. They could have spent the last month saying, we're the party that thinks we've got enough gas and coal. We don't think that coal mines should be buying offsets. You know, we actually just think we should stop subsidizing them. And
Speaker 2if people need money for national parks or to save koalas or anything else, well, let's tax gas. How hard is that? But instead of that, they're kind of stuck in this sort of centrist delusion of, oh, well, maybe if we make the offset slightly better, wouldn't that be better? Why on earth the Greens would get caught up defending offsets makes absolutely no sense to me unless your strategy is to just not have fights anymore.
Speaker 1So this is Labor's new native forest carbon credit scheme, which the Senate will vote on next week. Can you just explain a bit more about how this scheme actually works?
Speaker 2So what a carbon credit is, is a sort of like a ticket that says someone saved some pollution. So under this quite controversial new proposal, the New South Wales government is going to get these kind of pollution permission slips for creating a national park. New South Wales Labor is saying, oh, look, we'd like to sell these carbon offsets to BHP or Rio Tinto or anyone else that would like them. We want to sell these and that'll
Speaker 2give us some money. It's a complicated system.
Speaker 4But basically, if we were going to have a section of wilderness that was about to be lopped, but it wasn't, then a company can buy a carbon credit as an offset.
Speaker 2Now, I think there's lots of problems with that. Firstly, Labor had already promised to make the park. So from a scientific point of view, we're not actually getting any extra trees because they'd already promised to save them. Second, Australia's already awash with carbon offsets. We don't have a shortage of carbon offsets. Third, any new offsets will just push the price down lower. And fourth, why not just if we want to build national parks, if we want to have nice things, I think the Greens would just be on much stronger ground saying, well, how about we
Speaker 2tax gas and we can protect the koalas? Or how about the New South Wales government stop subsidising native forest logging, Chris Minns? Like Chris Minns, the New South Wales government owns a government-owned logging company that logs native forest. But the Greens are kind of falling into this idea that, you know, through privatisation, through financialisation, fancy offsets will solve these problems. Well, as an economist and as a voter, I think there's far shorter routes to victory. So, yeah, the Parliament will vote on this on the 15th. Again,
Speaker 2the Greens haven't said which way they'll go. Personally, I just think they've wasted a month of opportunity to say, how come Chris Minns and Chris Bowen are so keen on offsets? If they want to save forests, stop subsidising native forest logging. And if they want to tackle climate change, stop approving new gas and coal. There, I fixed it.
Speaker 1Isn't the political wedge for the Greens, though, if they vote this scheme down, doesn't Labor get to say they voted against protecting native forests and thousands of koalas? Wouldn't that play well in our dailies and in social media and wouldn't that be a bad outcome for the Greens politically?
Speaker 2Well what it would be would be a fight what it would be would be a public policy debate and boy I hope well no actually I hope the Greens just vote it down. first and foremost. And when they vote it down, I really hope that the Labor Party tries to mount that campaign because that will be fun. That will be fun. I would love to hear Chris Minns and Chris Bowen try to explain how while the New South Wales government had long promised to save a park, While the New South Wales government spends $ 30 million a year subsidising native forest logging elsewhere in New South Wales,
Speaker 2why it's the Greens' fault that the New South Wales Labor Party can't make a park they promised to make. And just to be clear, one of the arguments that New South Wales government has relied on is that, oh, we can't afford the park. We can't afford the park without the offsets.
Speaker 4This is one of the most important environmental initiatives that we've had anywhere in the country for over a decade. The Great Koala National Park is supported by so many people, and to have it stopped at the 11th hour would be a huge tragedy. So I think this makes sense.
Speaker 2Well, not only is Australia one of the richest countries in the world, and not only do we spend New South Wales taxpayers spend $ 20 or $ 30 million a year subsidising native forest logging, the Australian Institute's just run the numbers. And the offsets from this park will generate about 5% of the cost of operating this park over the next century. So 95% of the park is still going to be funded by taxpayers. I mean, this is A-grade bullshit. And yeah, let's hope we get to have this public debate about it.
Speaker 2And back to my earlier point, this is why I think the Greens aren't picking up votes. You actually need to have a big fight about important things to show voters that you're offering an alternative.
Speaker 1And finally, Richard, zooming out from all of this, does this show that the Greens are moving to the right or their policies basically have been where they've always been, but it's their strategy for pursuing them that's become more conservative?
Speaker 2Yeah, look, let me quote the economics editor of the Sydney Morning Herald. According to Ross Gittins, the truth is that the economist's lovely offset scheme is a sham Labor is using to make us think it cares about climate change when it doesn't. That's the economics editor of the Sydney Morning Herald. And the Greens are going to be to the right of the economics editor of one of the mainstream media outlets that they say won't give them a good run. Look, I hope this is all a storm in a teacup. I hope they just vote the
Speaker 2disallowance and we don't have more offsets. That'd be good. So maybe this is all hypothetical. But the idea that the Greens have missed a month's opportunity to differentiate themselves from Labor, to differentiate themselves from the neoliberals, seems pretty odd to me. So... Does Australia want the Greens to be more Mamdami or more Allegra Spender? I don't know. They're the political strategists. But when you're to the right of the economics editor of the mainstream media you think
Speaker 2criticises you or doesn't give you a good run, yeah, it doesn't look like you're really pushing that progressive boat out too far, does it?
Speaker 1Richard, thank you for your time. Thank you. Also in the news, social media users will be given a choice to opt out of their algorithm under draft laws expected to be unveiled by the federal government this week. Regular pop-up messages will be required, asking users if they want to stick with the algorithm or see only content from people they're following. The laws will also place the onus
Speaker 1on social media companies to identify and mitigate risks on their platforms, including the sharing of harmful content. And opposition leader Angus Taylor insists his proposal to slash the tobacco excise by 80% won't create more smokers. The Coalition hasn't modelled how the policy would affect smoking rates. But Taylor insists the price cut of more than $ 20 a packet won't increase the rate because illegal cigarettes were already available at that price. I'm Daniel James. Thanks for listening to 7am.
At COP31 in Türkiye, Australia has been helping lead global negotiations over the future of fossil fuels and the fight against climate change. But while the Albanese government pushes for stronger international action,...
Anthony Albanese runs a notoriously tight ship. Across his two terms as prime minister, there’s been very little leaking, very little sniping, and very few of his Labor Party colleagues willing to speak out against him....
This week, Australia’s leading health research body released its advice on puberty blockers, saying they should be available for some young people under 18. The Queensland and the Northern Territory governments, which...
In 1945, in the Crimean city of Yalta, three global superpowers - America, Great Britain and the Soviet Union - met to carve up the world between them, each claiming their own sphere of influence in the final year of...
Last week it was Qantas, last month it was NAB: two giants of Australian business cutting jobs due to the growth of AI. The explanations were familiar. Qantas says it will allow the airline to unlock innovation faster...