Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

7am

7am artwork

‘A heap of hypocrisy’: Why Allegra Spender says the Helen Haines attack must change politics

Oct 21, 202617 minAudio
  • Apple Podcasts
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

You can see it in the drawn faces of the politicians lining up to speak about Helen Haines this week - Canberra has been shaken to its core. ASIO and the Australian Federal Police have been liaising with parliamentarians - some of whom say they no longer feel safe after the alleged attack, which left the beloved Victorian independent fighting for her life. But some of the same politicians offering their condolences have been responsible for the increasingly ugly, even violent, rhetoric on the floor of parliament - their words contributing to the very environment that’s made them feel unsafe. Today, Independent MP Allegra Spender on her own experience, the hypocrisy in parliament, and why she’s calling for change - regardless of what the driver’s motivations are found to be. If you enjoy 7am, the best way you can support us is by making a contribution at 7ampodcast.com.au/support. Socials: Stay in touch with us on Instagram Guest: Independent MP Allegra Spender Photo: AAP Image/James Ross

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1You can see it in the drawn faces of the politicians lining up to talk about Helen Haynes this week. Canberra has been shaken to its core.

Speaker 2So many of us are just in shock.

Speaker 3It's so hard to fathom how someone would want to hurt someone like Helen Haynes.

Speaker 1ASIO and the federal police have been liaising with parliamentarians, who say they no longer feel safe after the alleged attack, which left the beloved Victorian independent fighting for her life. But some of the same politicians offering their condolences have been responsible for the increasingly awful rhetoric on the floor of Parliament. Their words contributing to the environment that's made them feel unsafe. I'm Ruby Jones and you're listening to 7am. Today,

Speaker 1independent MP Allegra Spender on her own experience, the hypocrisy in Parliament and why she's calling for change, regardless of what the driver's motivations are found to be. It's Thursday, October 22. So, Allegra, it's been a couple of days now since your colleague Helen Haynes was attacked outside her electorate office. What kinds of conversations have you been having in the wake of that?

Speaker 3Well, I mean, firstly, you know, just with other people who know Helen and who know her family, because I think there's such a shared grief that someone who is so respected, so loved, such a moderate, restrained, respectful woman has been subject to this sort of violence. I mean, it is so devastating to those people who know her and to love her, who love her or who have admired her from afar. So I think those are the conversations, you know, many of the conversations I've been having. And,

Speaker 3you know, the love that's coming to Helen from all over the place is huge. And then there's obviously the concern that many have, including myself, about violence directed towards, you know, obviously parliamentarians, but more broadly, violence directed towards, you know, community to institutions at this time.

Speaker 1And when you first entered politics, decided to run, you already had some experience of public life, but how did you weigh up potentially to stepping into a public political role and how that would change your life and what it might expose you to.

Speaker 2Yeah, it's interesting.

Speaker 3I thought I'd get online hate and that's certainly been the case. I sort of was ready for that. But I didn't probably anticipate the level of sort of threat abuse that comes with a territory. And that is obviously concerning, you know, and I'm someone who, you know, I grew up in the area, I represent, you know, I'm very sort of visible in the area because not just because of my political role, but because I'm a mum, you know, I've got lots of friends and family in the area.

Speaker 2So I'm just around and about.

Speaker 3And so knowing that there's a sort of threat out there, you know, to you both for just doing your normal day, as well as when you are stepping up as a politician, that is, you know, it's concerning. But I've always been one of those people who just kind of gets on with these things and tries not to think about it.

Speaker 2And you're obviously not alone.

Speaker 1Lydia Thorpe this week shared that she wears a disguise to the supermarket and that there was months in which she couldn't live in her own house. Tanya Plibersek has spoken about how rape and death threats are increasingly common.

Speaker 4I mean, I couldn't even count the number of death threats, rape threats that I've had over the years, and, you know, including ones that have ended up in court.

Speaker 1It does seem like there is this more intense level of vitriol, especially when it comes to female politicians. Is that something that you've observed?

Speaker 3Well, I've seen absolutely the vitriol and the aggression. You know, I don't want to minimise the threats against male politicians. I think they're very extensive. I think some of the key differences with female politicians is particularly the sexualised nature of threats, particularly, you know, of people sort of said, you know, rhetorically rape you, you know, there's a very female, so very gendered kind of language used in relation to women. But, you know, the threads are there. And they have, you know, I'll be honest, I have been surprised at the scale

Speaker 3of them.

Speaker 1And there's been a lot of talk about the tone of conversation in public life and a rise in anger and in threatening language and what people feel like they can say on social media. But tell me a bit about what you observe kind of within the politics bubble about how politicians speak and the rhetoric and the way or the example that is set and what you've seen change.

Speaker 3Look, you know, I'm genuinely concerned about the level of aggression in public discourse, and that is online, but that also applies in parliament. You know, and I was speaking to someone today who said, look, politics has always.

Speaker 2Been, you know, pretty rough, pretty brutal. in the language. But I think that these are times where, you know, the sort.

Speaker 4Of brutality and aggression is amplified, you know, through social media and other channels, so that passing comments is.

Speaker 3You know, really can build and strengthen and also create a permissive environment where people say things and do things that, you know, like most of us, we weren't brought up to behave like that. And we wouldn't say and do those things in front of, you know, you know, grandparents or, you know, parents who have taught us, you know, what is acceptable and what isn't acceptable. And I think that applies to politics as well. You know, I've been in the chamber, I was really shocked. I remember hearing a politician say, rip him another one. And I was like,

Speaker 3in question time, it's like calling out that. And I was like, how is that acceptable in any workplace, let alone in the parliament of Australia? You know, we have had very visibly people calling for stoning of other politicians. This prime minister should be absolutely shamed and stoned in the square. You know, for someone to put a bag over their head. You know, these are the sorts of things that are part of public discourse. Now, you know, I accept you don't draw one bow from, you know, this to, you know, the absolutely tragic incident with Helen,

Speaker 3I think, but I think the point is, you know, there's an acceptance of aggression and sort of violent language in public life and which I think politics adds permission to and I think that we need to look in the mirror in our behaviour as well as urge the whole community not just to treat each other with respect but But to, you know, actually, you know, use of violent language, even if you're angry, just not okay. We need to, I think, be much clearer on that, that that's a violent rhetoric that has no place in this country.

Speaker 1Do you think there is some hypocrisy there from politicians offering condolences and also slamming what we see on social media when they've said inflammatory things themselves potentially in the past? And I mean, probably will again.

Speaker 3Yeah, look, and I think there is a heap of hypocrisy. And look, and I also accept people say things in the heat of the moment and probably go, oh God, I wish I didn't, I wish I hadn't said that. And I think as politicians, we need to be a bit more forthright when we've made a mistake and say, you know what, I shouldn't have said that.

Speaker 2It was a heat of the moment. I was wrong.

Speaker 3And I think we also need to be ready to call each other out, you know, including our friends, including the people that we, you know, we like are on the same side of, because I think there's some good evidence out of the US on this. When When politicians call out, you know, particularly violent rhetoric on their side or violent actions on their side, that's when people notice. You know, people, when you call out, you know, people on the other side, everyone goes, you're just playing politics. When you say about your own people they shouldn't have said that, you know, and that was wrong, then people,

Speaker 3you know, think you're actually serious. And I think that we need to be collectively doing that amongst ourselves as politicians but also in that broader community because we It is about setting community expectations here.

Speaker 2Now, I'm not naive.

Speaker 3That it's just about what goes on in question time. Obviously, social media has an enormous role to play here, and I think that is why the regulation, particularly of the algorithms, is really important. I've started to look into what can we do about some of the bots that are making up some of the outrage and amplifying this. But I also think we can't collectively let ourselves off the hook as a society because we some of the anger and the violence and the violent language that is being amplified on social media is being put out there by other Australians.

Speaker 3And I think that we've just got to, you know, again, take a collective look at ourselves in the mirror and say, yeah, we feel strongly about things. We might be angry. We might be under an enormous amount of pressure. And I'm very sympathetic to that. But we've also got to make sure we hold ourselves to our standards. We think about whether we'd want our kids, our parents, other people that we know and love to be subjected to some of the language that we use, you know, both online but also face-to-face in the streets, on call centres and things like that.

Speaker 1Still to come, how Allegra found out about a security threat from the media instead of the AFP. There have been calls for increased security for politicians. Is that something that you think is needed? How safe do you feel in your electorate?

Speaker 3Look, I mean, I generally do feel safe in my electorate, but I'll be honest, you know, some of the threats that have been sort of levelled against me, they were sort of brought to light by actually by media rather than by the AFP.

Speaker 4Good afternoon. We'll begin with those disturbing messages targeting female Sydney MPs. Allegra Spender and Kelly Sloan today referring threats of death and sexual violence to police, a wave of abuse triggered after they condemned a neo-Nazi group.

Speaker 3So I do think that there's a step up of security that is probably warranted or certainly worth examining. And I've just been on a call with the security services, ASIA, AFP and the Department of specifically in relation to this. But I also am realistic that I don't think you can, you know, securitise your way out of this. You know, we do need to look at the other factors. We need to have, you know, what they call as sort of hardened environments where it is harder.

Speaker 2To But if we want to be a democracy where.

Speaker 3You know, I can continue to do my weekly pop-up office anywhere in the community and talk to people who perhaps don't have the inclination to come and visit me or maybe they're a bit intimidated by a politician who can come and talk to me about what's really going on.

Speaker 2That's important.

Speaker 3And that's the kind of politics Helen championed. So we need to preserve, I think, our ability to do that. And I think that's also looking at then those cultural factors to say, you know what, you know, stop it with the violent rhetoric.

Speaker 2Stop it with that sort of aggression. We collectively as a country need to pull back.

Speaker 1What did the AFP and ASIO say? What sense are you getting of how they're treating this?

Speaker 3Look, I think they treat this hugely seriously. And, you know, I have a huge amount of respect for the security agencies and you know, and their enormous desire to keep Australians safe. And that includes, you know, politicians and public figures, as well as obviously whole communities. But I think that we need to be realistic about, you know, the threat environment that, you know, not just Australia operates in, that the world is operating in as well. And I think that is, you know, these are questions certainly I'm thinking

Speaker 3through is, do we have the funding settings right?

Speaker 2Do we have those hard settings right?

Speaker 3As well as are we doing enough on the cultural elements and, you know, are we leading enough in that world?

Speaker 1And police are still investigating the motivations behind what they're saying was a deliberate attack on Haynes. But if those motivations don't turn out to be explicitly political, does that change anything for you?

Speaker 3I think it doesn't change the overall environment, that there is threat out there. And this is, for Helen, you know, Whether or not it was politically motivated or not, Helen's life is completely changed, as is her family's. And I think, you know, the vulnerability of politicians, whether it was explicitly politically motivated, whether it was rage.

Speaker 2Whether it was mental illness, we don't know.

Speaker 3You know, that highlights the vulnerability of politicians. We always need to be careful about generalising from one particular incident to to a broader world. But what we do know is threats are going up and we've seen almost a fourfold increase in the level of threats to politicians in this country. You see that level of threat in our hospitals, in our schools, you know, in other environments. You know, you get being told constantly that you can't abuse people.

Speaker 3It's like, well, why do we all need those warnings? Surely we should know we can't abuse people. And you're seeing now something that's really concerned me is that McKinnon has found that around 9% of Australians think it's acceptable in some instances to use extreme tactics, including violence, to pursue a political outcome or political cause. Now, that I find really worrying, that we think that violence, that some proportion of Australia, non-trivial proportion of Australia, thinks that violence

Speaker 3is actually a tool. Because we as a country have been built on the fact that we resolve our differences and in the ballot box, through the courts, in our institutions. That's how we resolve differences in this country. And I think we've got a lot of work to do to just go, let's just remember what's made us the safe, secure country we are today. And we've got to keep on coming back to that.

Speaker 1And it's been reported among the independents that some of them have this catch cry, which Monique, Ryan had put on t-shirts, what would Helen do? Because she was seen as, yeah, so wise. So in this situation, how do you think she would want people to respond?

Speaker 2That's a beautiful question.

Speaker 3Helen, you know, I was thinking about Helen today because I was thinking about a question in relation to Helen. I was like, I wish I could just ask Helen this because she, Helen is incredibly measured. You know, she cares about the outcome. She doesn't care about the politics. And I always say, I say about Helen, like, I don't care what your politics is.

Speaker 2You may not disagree.

Speaker 3You may disagree with her policy, you know, but the people of Indi could not ask for a person who takes their job more seriously, who is more measured and thoughtful, who gathers the evidence and tries to judiciously weigh that. on the basis of her values. And so I think Helen treats everyone with respect. And I think that's what you see right now. The overwhelming outpouring of support for Helen is because of how she treats every single other person, you know, that certainly in the parliament and I think

Speaker 3very much in her community too. So I think Helen would be saying, treat other peoples as you would like to be treated.

Speaker 2We as a country are better than this.

Speaker 3We as a country should be so proud of where we have come and how we manage, how we disagree and how we can manage to disagree well, but we've got to.

Speaker 2Work on this.

Speaker 1Allegra, thank you so much for speaking with me.

Speaker 2Thanks so much for having me.

Speaker 1Also in the news, Brendan Nugent, the 43-year-old man accused of attacking Haynes, faced the Wangaratta Magistrates Court yesterday. He's charged with dangerous driving causing serious injury, intentionally causing serious injury, and the federal offence of causing harm to a Commonwealth public official.

Speaker 2He did not apply for bail.

Speaker 1His lawyer said he suffers from a rare neurological condition and is not currently medicated. Court documents have shown Nugent is also facing drug charges, while police have not ruled out further charges. And community opposition to one of Melbourne's largest data centres has smashed the value of one of Australia's biggest companies. The multi-billion dollar tech giant NextDC cut its net earnings and revenue forecasts by tens of millions of dollars after a neighbourhood dispute over power poles. Following the announcement, NextDC's stock plummeted by 40%. It comes after

Speaker 1AI data centre company Firmus spectacularly withdrew its application to list on the stock exchange after failing to gather enough investor interest.

Speaker 2I'm Ruby Jones.

Speaker 1This is 7am.

Speaker 2Thanks for listening.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. How Albanese killed the climate wars

    Nov 21, 202615 minAudio

    At COP31 in Türkiye, Australia has been helping lead global negotiations over the future of fossil fuels and the fight against climate change. But while the Albanese government pushes for stronger international action,...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Ed Husic on being ‘left in the dark’ by his own government

    Nov 20, 202617 minAudio

    Anthony Albanese runs a notoriously tight ship. Across his two terms as prime minister, there’s been very little leaking, very little sniping, and very few of his Labor Party colleagues willing to speak out against him....

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Puberty blockers greenlit: So why are state bans still in place?

    Nov 19, 202615 minAudio

    This week, Australia’s leading health research body released its advice on puberty blockers, saying they should be available for some young people under 18. The Queensland and the Northern Territory governments, which...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Will Trump, Xi and Putin try to carve up the world?

    Nov 18, 202616 minAudio

    In 1945, in the Crimean city of Yalta, three global superpowers - America, Great Britain and the Soviet Union - met to carve up the world between them, each claiming their own sphere of influence in the final year of...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. AI job cuts at Bunnings, Qantas, NAB: ‘Mass unemployment is the business plan’

    Nov 17, 202616 minAudio

    Last week it was Qantas, last month it was NAB: two giants of Australian business cutting jobs due to the growth of AI. The explanations were familiar. Qantas says it will allow the airline to unlock innovation faster...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode