Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

7am

7am artwork

Peter Garrett on ‘the AUKUS deception’

Nov 8, 202615 minAudio
  • Apple Podcasts
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

The submarines are still years away, but the decisions reshaping Australia’s defence posture are already being made. That’s one of the central warnings from the AUKUS Public Inquiry, which last week called for the submarine deal to be scrapped. Its lead commissioner, former environment minister Peter Garrett, says the consequences of AUKUS go well beyond its cost - it’s also about Australia’s growing role in America’s military strategy, and our ability to make decisions for ourselves. Today, lead Commissioner for the AUKUS inquiry Peter Garrett, on what the inquiry revealed about the deal Australia signed, and why he says the government owes Australians an explanation. If you enjoy 7am, the best way you can support us is by making a contribution at 7ampodcast.com.au/support. Socials: Stay in touch with us on Instagram Guest: Lead Commissioner for the AUKUS Inquiry Peter Garrett Photo: AAP Image/Con Chronis

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1I'm Daniel James, and you're listening to 7am. The submarines are still years away, but the decisions reshaping Australia's defence posture are already being made. That's one of the central warnings from the public inquiry into AUKUS, which last week called for the submarine deal to be scrapped. Its lead commissioner, former Environment Minister Peter Garrett, says the consequences of AUKUS go well beyond its cost. It's also about Australia's growing

Speaker 1role in America's military strategy and our ability to make decisions for ourselves. Today, lead commissioner for the AUKUS inquiry, Peter Garrett, on what the inquiry revealed about the deal Australia signed and why he says the government owes Australians an explanation. It's Monday, November 9. Peter, thank you for joining us on 7am again. Your report is titled Surrendering Australia,

Speaker 1the Orcas Deception. What is the deception you're referring to?

Speaker 2The deception, Daniel, is that the majority of Australians were not aware when Scott Morrison announced the Orcas deal five years ago that they would have a bill for $ 33 million a day for the next 30 years for submarines that may or may not arrive, that in the interim there'd be increasing integration and interoperability with the United States forces, in particular the establishment effectively of a de facto US base in Stirling in Western Australia, that in the event

Speaker 2that the deal didn't succeed, Australia would have no recourse and no opportunities for compensation of any kind, but that in fact Australia was compensating the United Kingdom and the United States if something went wrong in terms of nuclear risk, And finally, that Australia was subsidising UK and US shipbuilding or submarine building facilities in the interim so that they could continue to build their own submarines in order to meet the fulfilment for AUKUS. And I think this is

Speaker 2something which we came to realise many, many people were unaware of.

Speaker 3It was a deception.

Speaker 2Our findings cohere with these majority and expert views.

Speaker 3And we concluded, and I quote.

Speaker 2that AUKUS is the worst, most costly and riskiest defence decision ever made by an Australian government and without adequate scrutiny.

Speaker 1There are 18 principal findings in the report. A lot of them are things listeners would be familiar with. The high cost, the risk to national sovereignty, the nuclear risk, the increased risk of war, being dragged into a war. What were the most important takeaways for you that you think people should know?

Speaker 2One of them was that essentially our Australian sovereignty was being compromised by AUKUS and that essentially it reflected a reversal in a way of a consensus that had broadly held for the last 30 or 40 years that when we talk about defence of Australia, we're talking about defence of Australia. That's what the white papers in the past have said. That's what our armed forces are meant to be doing, likewise navies. Now what we're talking about under

Speaker 2the new AUKUS-derived forward posture integrated strategy is essentially allowing and being a part of the US military strategy to contain China by forward projection. It's called deterrence and defence.

Speaker 3And I think.

Speaker 2Most people, including ourselves as commissioners, weren't completely aware of how profound that change had been.

Speaker 3And the other final thing.

Speaker 2is that there are already a significant amount of activities going on sort of under the banner of AUKUS. Legislation that's passing through the Commonwealth Parliament, which essentially gives AUKUS decisions, including, say, for the location of this yet-to-materialise high-level radioactive waste dump because of the waste from the AUKUS subs, they're nuclear-powered, a significant amount of information that has been provided by to justify AUKUS by both the Commonwealth and the South Australian governments to a British parliamentary inquiry into AUKUS, but

Speaker 2they've never bothered to actually provide that information in the same way to Australians. I mean, it's really striking. And the greater majority of advice that we received, including from experts and people with a wealth of experience, was that the deal was really not in Australia's national interest.

Speaker 1When we last spoke, we were wondering how many people would actually turn up and present to the inquiry. And it turned out that You heard from 150 witnesses, among them former ministers and prime ministers. What testimony stayed with you the most, Peter?

Speaker 2Well, I think the testimonies from both Malcolm Turnbull and former prime ministers, Gareth Evans and Bob Carr, were particularly powerful.

Speaker 4There's no question that it involves a massive sacrifice of Australian sovereignty.

Speaker 5No question about that.

Speaker 4And one of.

Speaker 2My threshold points is that this is the worst possible time.

Speaker 4To be sacrificing sovereignty.

Speaker 2The testimony that we received from former defence ministers on the coalition side who were in favour of AUKUS, that was Christopher Pyne and Linda Reynolds, was also interesting in as much as it confirmed some of our concerns about AUKUS, but it came from people that were pro-AUKUS.

Speaker 5Do I think they'll deliver it on time and on budget? No, I don't.

Speaker 6I can say that now because I'm not in public life anymore, but I don't think they will.

Speaker 2I mean, Pyne basically said, look, Yes, Stirling is effectively a US base.

Speaker 6While it's not called a base, it will effectively be a US-UK-Australia submarine base. Now, many people might not think that's a good thing, but from an AUKUS point of view, it is a very important part of AUKUS for the United States because they want a submarine base in the Indian Ocean for obvious strategic purposes.

Speaker 2And Linda Reynolds, who's a Western Australian... confirmed that, in fact, Stirling would be a likely nuclear target.

Speaker 5As soon as we built Stirling, actually made Stirling, it became a target.

Speaker 7And Henderson now increasingly, because we've got the naval shipbuilders there.

Speaker 2No, I mean, these were astonishing statements to be made by people that were in favour.

Speaker 5We have not taken this issue seriously.

Speaker 7And I know there's, I think somebody's going to present here today is talking about emergency response.

Speaker 5But it's much, much further than that. It is all fixable. But we have to take the threat seriously.

Speaker 2I think the other part of testimony which was really telling for us came from retired Admiral Peter Briggs, who has been a senior naval officer and headed up the submarine side of the Navy for many, many years. And he's been quite a staunch critic of AUKUS. There's probably no one in the country that knows and understands submarines better. So he was able to take us through many of the technical issues around why the AUKUS deal was so bad.

Speaker 3AUKUS is a terrible one-sided deal.

Speaker 2We therefore recommend that notice be given immediately to scrap AUKUS before more money is wasted and the many risks inherent in the project allowed to escalate.

Speaker 1Your recommendations are pretty strong. The big one being that AUKUS should be immediately scrapped Is there nothing that's salvageable about this deal at all for you?

Speaker 3Certainly not Pillar 1.

Speaker 2So AUKUS has got two parts to it called Pillar 1 and Pillar 2. Simply put, Pillar 1 is the second-hand submarines that we're due to purchase from the United States and then the five brand-new big AUKUS submarines that are meant to be built, firstly in the UK and then assembled in Australia. Pillar 2 is about emerging technology, cybernetics, drones... undersea connections, AI and so on and so forth. But pillar one, the submarines should be scrapped now. And it's pretty basic. It's costing a fortune. And there's no likelihood

Speaker 2that they'll arrive on time, if at all. And we have no approved and agreed plan for the disposal of the high-level radioactive nuclear waste that these submarines produce.

Speaker 3I mean, the United Kingdom and the United States haven't managed to do that over 40 years.

Speaker 2And... The terms of the AUKUS agreement require countries, if they want to pull out, to give 12 months' notice. And in a healthy relationship between two democracies, like the United States and Australia, who have a long-term relationship, there may be differences of opinion, but the relationship should be able to stand it.

Speaker 1Still to come, could AUKUS increase the risk of war? Peter, there would be some pretty serious ramifications between Australia and the US if AUKUS was to be scrapped. Whether we like it or not, the United States is still a key part of Australia's defence strategy. Would scrapping this do potentially irreparable damage to the relationship?

Speaker 2We don't believe that it need do that, and we think that there are plenty of historical examples that show that when Australia has chosen to disagree with the United States on a matter, and quite often we don't, of course, quite often we just follow them into war, but on those occasions when Australia's made that decision, the relationship has withstood that difference. I mean, for the United States, the biggest issue about AUKUS was not the submarines themselves.

Speaker 3It's the Ford.

Speaker 2Basing, landing of the B-52s in Tyndall in the Northern Territory, and them being able to rotate, in inverted commas, their own submarines into through ports in Australia, but particularly at the moment, sterling in Western Australia. Now, that is a really significant and important national conversation that Australians must have anyway.

Speaker 1As we look at the deal, and particularly Pillar 1 in terms of the August Agreement, the government says that the submarines as part of that, which of course is the main ticket item when it comes to AUKUS, will help prevent a war. Why do you think they could actually make war more likely?

Speaker 2Well, I'm not sure whether they themselves will make war more likely, but they certainly won't do the opposite, i.e. make defence more practical, because they're attack submarines. Former Chief of the Defence Force Chris Barry, who was one of the commissioners on the inquiry, has pointed out on a number of occasions, and other defence experts have as well, the main purpose for the AUKUS submarines is to hunt down other nuclear-powered submarines, presumably the submarines of China.

Speaker 4When I look at the globe and ask myself, where are Australia's primary defence interests? They're all south of the equator. And I think the whole idea that we're going to march off and do whatever against China as routine deployment of a submarine force is not soundly based. Because I think we're a country that wants to look after our own defence interests, but we don't want to be threatening anybody else.

Speaker 3So... We look at the Collins-class submarines that we have now. Now they're old.

Speaker 2They're much smaller than the AUKUS submarines. The AUKUS submarines are massive, particularly the as-yet-designed and built subs, the five big ones that come from the UK to begin with.

Speaker 3They're absolutely immense.

Speaker 2And the possibility of them operating effectively around Australia's littoral waters to the north of Australia, which is shallow water territory, I mean, it's highly problematic. And It's simply not conceivable for the Defence Department, with the resources and the person power that it has, to be able to manage that effectively at all.

Speaker 4I am sure most people in this room would share a perception that the strategic circumstances around the globe right now are not looking real good.

Speaker 3And I think you could.

Speaker 4Ask yourself, What's the likelihood of general war breaking out in the next three or four years? I think it's unacceptably high, to be truthful.

Speaker 3But you know what? The orca steel is not going to solve that problem.

Speaker 2This is a massive thought bubble that hasn't been thought through in any way, shape or form. And attempting to re-engineer a justification for it is almost impossible, which is why I think the government's been so silent on the matter.

Speaker 1Do you hold any hope at all that the government will actually respond to any of these recommendations or make a statement in relation to the report or the inquiry?

Speaker 3No, not if their past approach to it is any indication.

Speaker 2And our first recommendation, Daniel, was actually, I think, the most important one and really is to everybody listening and to your listeners and their friends and family and workmates and what have you. And that is This is only going to change if and when public opinion and public sentiment ensures that there's a proper national conversation and that any politician, any government has to be accountable for those decisions and that expense.

Speaker 3Of taxpayers' money.

Speaker 2But I could walk down into a shopping centre in any capital city in Australia and talk to 100 people and, you know, no disrespect to any of the people I speak to, but I would be very surprised if one in 100 said, had their heads around this, and how can they be expected to because the government's kept it secret.

Speaker 3For so long?

Speaker 2There's no doubt in our minds as commissioners that the AUKUS deal, as we understand it, and everything that goes with it, has no social licence.

Speaker 1Well, Peter, thanks for coming on 7am and thanks for all your work on this. It's an important part of the national conversation that needed.

Speaker 2To be had.

Speaker 3Thanks for having us, Dan. All the best.

Speaker 1Also in the news, Benjamin Netanyahu's biggest rival, Gadi Eisenkot, has been given 28 days to try and form a government in Israel. Netanyahu is fighting to hold onto office after his coalition lost its majority in Israel's deadlocked election last month. If Eisenkot succeeds in forming a coalition, he'll take over as Prime Minister. And as the COP31 climate summit kicks off in Turkey today, Australia's climate leadership has been called into question. Three independent United Nations appointment experts

Speaker 1have criticised our continued approval of oil and gas projects, arguing it's inconsistent with our rhetoric on the world stage. In response, the Albanese government has defended its climate record, saying our 2035 target is among the most ambitious in the world. I'm Daniel James. Thanks for listening to 7am.

Speaker 3We'll be back tomorrow.

Speaker 1Music you

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. How Albanese killed the climate wars

    Nov 21, 202615 minAudio

    At COP31 in Türkiye, Australia has been helping lead global negotiations over the future of fossil fuels and the fight against climate change. But while the Albanese government pushes for stronger international action,...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Ed Husic on being ‘left in the dark’ by his own government

    Nov 20, 202617 minAudio

    Anthony Albanese runs a notoriously tight ship. Across his two terms as prime minister, there’s been very little leaking, very little sniping, and very few of his Labor Party colleagues willing to speak out against him....

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Puberty blockers greenlit: So why are state bans still in place?

    Nov 19, 202615 minAudio

    This week, Australia’s leading health research body released its advice on puberty blockers, saying they should be available for some young people under 18. The Queensland and the Northern Territory governments, which...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Will Trump, Xi and Putin try to carve up the world?

    Nov 18, 202616 minAudio

    In 1945, in the Crimean city of Yalta, three global superpowers - America, Great Britain and the Soviet Union - met to carve up the world between them, each claiming their own sphere of influence in the final year of...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. AI job cuts at Bunnings, Qantas, NAB: ‘Mass unemployment is the business plan’

    Nov 17, 202616 minAudio

    Last week it was Qantas, last month it was NAB: two giants of Australian business cutting jobs due to the growth of AI. The explanations were familiar. Qantas says it will allow the airline to unlock innovation faster...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode