Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

7am

7am artwork

Jim Chalmers defends his budget

May 20, 202616 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

For two decades, we’ve had a tax policy that pushed up house prices, gave landlords huge advantages, and ultimately created an intergenerational wealth divide. A week ago, the government said it wanted to do something about that and announced changes to negative gearing and capital gains tax. But the budget hasn’t gone down well - for some, it doesn’t go far enough to make a real difference to the housing market. For others, particularly in business, changes to capital gains go too far. Today, Treasurer Jim Chalmers defends his budget. If you enjoy 7am, the best way you can support us is by making a contribution at 7ampodcast.com.au/support. Socials: Stay in touch with us on Instagram Guest: Treasurer Jim Chalmers Photo: AAP Image/Lukas Coch

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1I'm Ruby Jones and you're listening to seven AM. For two decades we've had a tax policy that pushed up house prices, gave landlords huge advantages, and ultimately created an intergenerational wealth divide. A week ago the government said it wanted to do something about that and announced changes to negative gearing and capital gains tax. But the budget hasn't gone down well. For some it doesn't go far enough to make a real difference to the housing market. For others,

Speaker 1particularly in business, changes to capital gains go too far. Today the Treasurer Jim Chalmers defends his budget. It's Thursday, May twenty one. Treasurer, welcome to seven AM. It's great to have you on the show.

Speaker 2Thanks very much, Ruby, thanks for having me back.

Speaker 1So it's been just over a week since you release the budget and fair to say a lot of people don't like it. Pole suggests that more than half of Australians believe that your changes will make them worse off. It was given the worst approval score since nineteen ninety three. You've already own a home, or an investment or an asset. This budget doesn't really affect them, so why would they ever sell their asset, you know, and then for new buyers it's like now I lose those benefits if I buy it.

Speaker 3I'm terrified though over the future it doesn't seem to be getting any better.

Speaker 4I'm a single one on a pension.

Speaker 1There's no way for me.

Speaker 3To own home.

Speaker 4I don't understand how this is going to free out properties for the younger generation, because as an investment property owner myself, I'm going to either hang on or sell it for more.

Speaker 5I think it will take a lot so treasure.

Speaker 1It's not going well, where do you think you've gone wrong?

Speaker 3Well, first of all, I think it's important to acknowledge that when you're making a significant change, a controversial change to the tax system, and obviously not everybody is going to be supportive of that. We had realistic expectation when we came to these views expressed in the policies in the budget, that they would be contentious, and so I think in the midst of a pretty full on scare campaign, in the midst of a big global oil shop which is putting extra pressure on people, and in a budget

Speaker 3which is full of hard decisions rather than handout, so I think the kind of reaction is not especially surprising. Our job is to try and do the right thing for the right reasons, even if it means paying a short term political cost.

Speaker 2In the polls that you.

Speaker 1Reference, I want to talk in a bit more detail about the changes to negative gearing. So existing investors are protected. They'll keep the old arrangements, which means that the impact of this is going to be limited, especially in the short term. So how worried are you that you've taken this big political hit for a policy that really only nudges the housing problem.

Speaker 3Well, first of all, I thought it was really important, or we thought it was really important that we wreck ignize and respect investment decisions that people have taken already, and so that's why there's those transitional arrangements in negat gearing. So if you're negatively gearing now, you can continue to do that. It's important to remember there as well, that at some point properties become positively geared, and so some of those investments will exit the negative gearing system, and if you want to make a new investment, you can negatively gear a new build. So we think that's the

Speaker 3right balance encouraging people to invest in more housing, supplier recognizing and respecting the decisions that people have taken already. Now, obviously, Ruby, there's going to be some people who think we should have gone further. There will be some people who much prefer the existing arrangements. They might be doing well out of the existing arrangements. Our job is to try and strike a series of fine balances, and I think we've struck the right one because this is all about housing. This is all about recognizing that the way that the housing market and the taxism intersex is working to get

Speaker 3that have shut out a whole generation of Australians from from home ownership and from aspiration more broadly, and so that's why we've taken these difficult decisions. There will always be strong views about policies like this, big economic reforms like this, but we're prepared, as I said before, to wear some of that criticism if it means getting too the right outcome.

Speaker 2We didn't want to be the government.

Speaker 3That left that can signed another generation to being locked out of housing because of the way that the tax system and housing market is broken.

Speaker 1Sure, but it's a modest increase that we're talking about when it comes to new homeowners seventy five thousand households over ten years. But there are millions of young people who say that they can't get into the housing market. So is there a part of you that wishes that you'd gone further, perhaps abolish negative gearing altogether.

Speaker 3No, I'm pretty confident in the balance that we struck, and you know, not everybody would agree that it's a that it's too modest to change.

Speaker 2As I said, there's always a range of views about it.

Speaker 3Seventy five thousand households which were rental households becoming homeowners. I think that's a substantial number, and it's also not the only thing we're doing in housing. The budget had important steps on youth homelessness. It had billions of dollars of investing in more housing supply, as well as making the tax system fairer for younger people who work and also in the housing market. So across the board, we're doing a lot on housing and we think it will shift the needle on a problem which has been a

Speaker 3really difficult problem, not just in our economy but in our society for a long time.

Speaker 6Now, more than forty business founders have written to the Prime Minister urging him to walk back controversial capital gains tax changes that could hit them when they decide to sell.

Speaker 1And one of the other big criticisms that you're facing at the moment is around the impact of the capital gains tax discount changes on business. So there is this growing campaign from the business community. There's been burrel memes, there's a joint letter from forty young founders who say that this is an aspiration ambush that's going to affect every growing business in Australia because if we tax risk taking in the same way that we tax ordinary income, then we left with the question why take the risk in the first place. So when you were designing these

Speaker 1changes to capital gains, why didn't you limit it to just property, Well.

Speaker 3Because we didn't want to replace one big distortion, which has been turbo charging house prices, with another distortion.

Speaker 2You know, there was a.

Speaker 3Big policy mistake made about a quarter of a century ago by Howard and Costello when they changed these arrangements away to what we are proposing now. Away from what we're proposing now, it made an investment in established housing way more attractive, and so we saw the decoupling of house prices and incomes around the turn of the century and which we're trying to fix that, and not by replacing one distortion with another distortion. But the really important thing to understand about that, Ruby, is if you look at a twenty year period in between when that policy

Speaker 3change was made, on average, what we saw is that investment in established housing was overcompensated for by the old arrangements, and investment in shares and medium density units and a whole bunch of other types of assets was actually under compensated. So by removing this distortion, we hope to rectify that. Now there is a campaign being run. I understand that there's also unfortunately a fair bit of misinformation being pushed around by our political opponents. You know, the forty seven cent campaign, for example, pretends that there's no CGT discount anymore.

Speaker 3That's obviously not true. We're just calculating the discount differently. There's a whole bunch of exemptions for small business. There actually four different exemptions, carve outs and concessions for small business, and all of them are staying in place. And so my job, one of the reasons why I'm grateful for this opportunity, Ruby, is to point out where there is misinformation about the changes that we're we're actually making it easier for people to make an investment based on good economic outcomes and not just the distortion introduced into the tax system in nineteen ninety nine.

Speaker 1And you've spoken about having further consultations these exemptions. So is there more on the table here exemptions being considered for startups?

Speaker 2For example, we are talking with the startup sector.

Speaker 3We actually began those conversations before the budget, and we made it really clear in black and white in the budget papers themselves that we understood that when it comes to calculating the cost base for startups that they are a bit of a different case. And so we were doing some private consultation before the budget and now publicly I've done a bit of that myself. My department, the Treasury Department's been doing that in a more formal way to see if we can find a way through which recognizes first of all how important startups to our economy, providing that dynamism in our economy which we really cherish

Speaker 3and value, and making sure that we can recognize that startups can be a bit of a different case in the tax system. So if we can find a way through there that would be good, but those conversations that consultation is still happening right now.

Speaker 1Still to come is the government using gas industry figures to justify its decision not to.

Speaker 5Introduce a gas tax.

Speaker 1You've introduced a gas reservation policy, but not a stronger gas export levy. And there is again another very strong online campaign around this, around the need for a gas tax.

Speaker 2No significant additional funding for nature. There is absolutely no way labor can deliver on their promise of knowing your extinctions with this level of funding.

Speaker 1Our entire budget on nature is less than a week of what a gas export tax would bring in.

Speaker 2We don't have a shortage of supply. We have a glut of greed. We maybe ed you sick.

Speaker 1And others have also argued that Australia just isn't getting a fair return from gas exports. So I mean, couldn't the budget have used that money?

Speaker 2Well, there's a bit of a tick up.

Speaker 3I've been prt receipts in the budget, but I understand that people have got strong views about taxing the gas companies more. I introduced some reforms in our first term in office so that the gas companies we're paying more tax sooner. But again I acknowledge that people would prefer we go further, and some people would prefer we go much further. I get that, I understand their arguments. From our point of view, we think there are good reasons to prioritize that gas reservation policy that you're right to

Speaker 3point to in your question, which is all about decoupling the Australian gas market from the roller coaster of international prices so that we can get more supply at cheaper prices for Australian industry. That's the first thing. But the second thing as well is we've got to make sure that we can secure this these two way supply arrangements with our refining partners in Asia, and so we prioritize those two things. And again I understand that's contentious. I mean,

Speaker 3you do pay very close attention to the arguments being run about different gas tax arrangements. But those are our two priorities for the time being, and I think they're really important priorities.

Speaker 1In the lead up to the budget, when this idea of a gas tax was being canvassed, your government was hosing down calls for it by saying that the gas industry already pays twenty two billion dollars in tax.

Speaker 3Well, look, they pay around about twenty two billion dollars and importantly as well, and I.

Speaker 1Noticed that figure, that twenty two billion that actually comes from the gas industry. They are quite proud of it. So why was the government taking the lobby group's word for how much tax they pay. I mean, you're the treasurer. So have you asked Treasury about that figure?

Speaker 2Yeah?

Speaker 3I think that was just our way of reminding people that the PRT is not the only tax that the gas companies pay.

Speaker 5I know that.

Speaker 3Again, I know it was controversial when those figures were announced. The figures I focus on in the PRRT went up a little bit in the budget, but again I acknowledged that for a number of a lot of people who might be listening to us or watching us today, I acknowledge that people would prefer us to go further. I've tried to explain why we've got these two other priorities at the same time. As the PRRT has gone up a bit, I know that people would like it to go up by much more.

Speaker 1You've spoken about people feeling disconnected and disregarded by the political class and anxious about the lack of opportunity that they see for themselves, and you've said you want to address those concerns. That's part of what this budget is about for you, addressing people's fears for the future. A week on from the budget, it doesn't feel like that's working. So do you think that you've underestimated people's grievances? Do you think that you still are?

Speaker 5Well?

Speaker 2I'm not sure. I think about it exactly like that.

Speaker 3I mean, I take the feedback inherent your question seriously, but I don't think anyone expected a week or week and a bit after the budget of any budget, that people would necessarily that there would be some kind of unanimous agreement about it. Obviously, these things are big and contentious, they're controversial. But that point that you made at the start of your question is really.

Speaker 2Important to me. I look around the world and I.

Speaker 3See whole generations or whole cohorts of people who are.

Speaker 2Feeling disconnected and disregarded.

Speaker 3I think this is a big, serious question for all of us, not just in our economy, but in our society. More importantly, this sense of people feeling like the economy is working in somebody else's interests and when you try and change that or address that, try and avoid that situation in Australia that we're seeing in other parts of the world, there will be resistance to that. We're seeing that resistance play out in some of our newspapers, we're seeing it in the language of our opponents. But that doesn't mean you shouldn't try. And when I look around the world and see the way that communities are fracturing,

Speaker 3particularly in an intergenerational sense, I take responsibility for trying to address that, even if it means that we cop a bit of political turbulence or a bit of grief or a bit of feedback about it, or even these misinformation scare campaigns, I think it's worth it to try and avoid the situation that we're seeing around the world.

Speaker 1Now.

Speaker 3Not everybody sees what's happening around the world and wants to take a different path to that. Some people, including our opponents, they want to kind of copy the very divisive politics that we're seeing in other parts of the world. I don't want to, and I think that one of the reasons people feel disconnected and disregarded is because of this sense that the economy.

Speaker 2Doesn't work for them. Anymore.

Speaker 3And that's why we're taking some of these difficult decisions, particularly in the housing market and where it intersects with the tax system, because we care enough about it to do something about it.

Speaker 1Treasure At, thank you so much for your time.

Speaker 2Appreciate it.

Speaker 5Ruby, thank you.

Speaker 1Also in the news, health officials across the country are working to control Australia's largest ep theoria outbreak on record. More than two hundred and twenty cases have been recorded across the country so far this year, with the vast majority in the Northern Territory and Western Australia. Diphtheria is a contagious bacterial infection that's preventable through vaccination, and authorities say crowded living conditions and low immunization rates in remote communities of fueling the outbreak, and Australia's Special Envoy to combat Islamophobia, Aftab Malik, is calling on the federal government

Speaker 1to respond to his recommendations to combat Islamophobia in Australia. Following a deadly shooting at a mosque in the United States, three people were killed at the Islamic Center of San Diego, with authorities saying the two teenage attackers had expressed broad hatred towards different religions and races. Their writings also reportedly referenced the twenty nineteen christ Church Mosk attack, in which fifty one people were killed and another forty shot. Alex says Australia cannot wait for a christ Church style attack before taking action on Islamophobia. I'm Ruby Jones. This is

Speaker 1seven am.

Speaker 4Thanks for listening.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Guests

  • Jim Chalmers Guest Inferred

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. How Albanese killed the climate wars

    Nov 21, 202615 minAudio

    At COP31 in Türkiye, Australia has been helping lead global negotiations over the future of fossil fuels and the fight against climate change. But while the Albanese government pushes for stronger international action,...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Ed Husic on being ‘left in the dark’ by his own government

    Nov 20, 202617 minAudio

    Anthony Albanese runs a notoriously tight ship. Across his two terms as prime minister, there’s been very little leaking, very little sniping, and very few of his Labor Party colleagues willing to speak out against him....

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Puberty blockers greenlit: So why are state bans still in place?

    Nov 19, 202615 minAudio

    This week, Australia’s leading health research body released its advice on puberty blockers, saying they should be available for some young people under 18. The Queensland and the Northern Territory governments, which...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Will Trump, Xi and Putin try to carve up the world?

    Nov 18, 202616 minAudio

    In 1945, in the Crimean city of Yalta, three global superpowers - America, Great Britain and the Soviet Union - met to carve up the world between them, each claiming their own sphere of influence in the final year of...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. AI job cuts at Bunnings, Qantas, NAB: ‘Mass unemployment is the business plan’

    Nov 17, 202616 minAudio

    Last week it was Qantas, last month it was NAB: two giants of Australian business cutting jobs due to the growth of AI. The explanations were familiar. Qantas says it will allow the airline to unlock innovation faster...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode