It’s been nearly two decades since Australians have felt the sting of interest rates this high. Reserve Bank governor Michele Bullock says persistent inflation has forced the RBA to hike the official cash rate for the fifth time this year. But some experts fear the bank may have gone too far - risking tipping Australia into a recession. Today, Australia Institute chief economist Greg Jericho on why the RBA may have got it wrong, and the big corporate inflation-driver no one seems to be talking about. If you enjoy 7am, the best way you can support us is by making a contribution at 7ampodcast.com.au/support. Socials: Stay in touch with us on Instagram Guest: Australia Institute chief economist, Greg Jericho Photo: AAP Image/Dean Lewins
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1I'm Ruby Jones, and you're listening to 7am. It's been nearly two decades since Australians have felt the sting of interest rates this high. Reserve Bank Governor Michelle Bullock says persisted inflation left the RBA with no choice but to hike the official cash rate for the fifth time this year. But some experts fear they may have gone too far, risking sending Australia into a recession. Today, Chief Economist at
Speaker 1the Australia Institute, Greg Jericho, on why the RBA may have got it wrong and the big corporate inflation driver no one's talking about. It's Wednesday, November 4.
Speaker 2If we just let high inflation run, it will lead to even worse outcomes. Much higher prices, higher unemployment and lower growth. We are using the cash rate to stop that from happening. Some pain now will prevent even worse pain down the track.
Speaker 1Greg, the Reserve Bank has raised the cash rate for the fifth time this year, taking it to 4.85%. That's the highest interest rate we've seen in Australia in about 18 years. This is all about trying to reduce inflation. Bullock, she spoke about inflation a lot, about how it's higher than the RBA wants it to be. They expect it to now stay above 3% for the next year. And there's this fear that it could become embedded, meaning that people will just get used to high inflation rates. Tell
Speaker 1me what you make of that idea and of how the RBA is trying to address it.
Speaker 3Yeah, the RBA is really paranoid about our expectations of inflation today. being above 3%. And that's almost taken precedence on their decision making, which I think reflects the fact that the actual raising of rates isn't actually doing much to inflation. So they've sort of transferred a bit to, oh, well, it's not hurting, it's not bringing down inflation, but it's helping anchor inflationary expectations. And I think what it really
Speaker 3shows is that despite what the Reserve Bank governor is at pains to try and stress, and this was really obvious in her press conference after the announcement, is that the main reason we're seeing inflation go up is things outside the control of the Reserve Bank.
Speaker 1Okay, well, let's talk about that a little more, about the drivers of inflation. The RBA, they mentioned this idea of there being just too much demand in the economy. They did also mention the Middle East oil shock. Tell me what you see as the main causes of inflation at this point?
Speaker 3I mean, the main cause by far is the oil shock. In the September quarter, petrol prices made up around 45% of the increase in inflation. So if you took away petrol prices, the overall increase in inflation in the September quarter would have basically been half what it was. But It's not just that. It's the fact that it flows through to everything that is either manufactured using oil or requires oil to get transported around. It has a massive
Speaker 3flow-on effect, and it's undeniable that that is the main cause of inflation. And yet, the Reserve Bank is kind of suggesting, oh, no, that's just one part of it, and we've got to keep hiking up rates to counter all these other things, which is to me a really sort of almost hiking up just so people don't think that they're completely ineffectual.
Speaker 1Okay, well, what about the role of government spending? Albanese and Chalmers are under a lot of pressure on this.
Speaker 4Will the Treasurer finally take responsibility and admit his out-of-control spending is forcing Australian families to pay more for everything?
Speaker 1One recent poll showed that 40% of voters blame the government for interest rate rises.
Speaker 4They don't need inflation data to know that. They see it when they go to the supermarket, when they pay their energy bill, when they pay their insurance bill, when they pay their rent, when they try to buy a home. They're seeing inflation everywhere they look.
Speaker 1So what impact is government spending having on inflation? Is there a problem here?
Speaker 3I don't think so. I've been... probably a little bit of an outlier on this, but that's because I actually look at the numbers and what we're seeing, yeah, overall government spending is higher than it has been in the past. That's because in the past we didn't have an NDIS. It's amazing that when you actually have to pay for something you didn't pay for in the past, you're spending more money than in the past. But you take away the NDIS and overall government spending, certainly the federal government spending isn't that much above what it used to be.
Speaker 3But more importantly, in terms of what's actually driving inflation, what we've seen over the past year is that federal government spending especially, but even the state government spending, has had less and less of an impact on overall economic growth in the country. So it's not the case that government spending is contributing more and more to inflation. In fact, it's been slowing. So... I'm not a big believer in
Speaker 3this view that government spending is to blame. The figures show it's not. Obviously, people I don't think are blaming the government because they actually think government spending is too high. It's just they're doing it tough. They're really struggling and you always look to someone to blame and rightly or wrongly, the government is always the first one and it's the easiest one. So I think that's more of the case than the actual reality of what's going on.
Speaker 1Still to come... Does the RBA want to see more of us lose our jobs? Greg, there's been a lot of talk about government spending and its impact on inflation, but not really any mention of the corporate sector. So what responsibility does it have here in terms of fighting inflation?
Speaker 3Yeah, I mean, this is the thing that is massively under-talked about, especially by the Reserve Bank. You know, no mention of the fact that, okay, we've had oil prices soar, but we've had the Profit margins of petrol refiners or oil refiners like Ampol absolutely explode over the past six to nine months, much higher than needs to be. So their profits are going great, guns. And yet there's never
Speaker 3any suggestion of, oh, maybe Ampol shouldn't be having... many hundreds of a percent increase in their profits. It's all just, oh, no, well, that's the free market at play. And there's nothing said of it. I mean, Michelle Bullock, even in a press conference today when she was asked about the credit card surcharge being taken away and suggesting, oh, the reason why cafes might be raising their prices more than they need to to cover that cost is due to excess demand.
Speaker 2I don't think it's anything to do with surcharging. I think it's just another manifestation to the extent it's there. It's just another manifestation of the fact that demand for goods and services in the economy is higher than the ability to supply it so businesses can put up their prices.
Speaker 3I'm like, no, maybe it's due to the fact that they've seen, oh, here's a way we can raise the price of our coffee and blame someone else. And what they're actually doing is just increasing their profits. I mean, this is This is what companies do. This is what businesses do when they can increase profits and blame someone else. Blame, oh, the Reserve Bank charge. It's not our fault. We're not gouging you. That's what they do. And yet, there's never any sort of mention of this. Again, you look at the figures, we can see that you can break down
Speaker 3what's essentially driving inflation is that labour costs? Is it profits or is it sort of government spending? And in the first half of this year, it has definitely been profits that has had the outsized impact.
Speaker 1Can we talk about another set of figures? Greg, one of the striking things that's happening is around unemployment. So it's risen from 4.1% in January to 4.7% in September. Michelle Bullock said last week that she wasn't worried about how quickly unemployment was rising.
Speaker 5We're not worried about the pace of increase in the unemployment rate at this stage. We do forecast that it has to gradually move up. That is very different than saying that people have to lose their jobs. In fact we are forecasting that employment continues to grow.
Speaker 1What do you make of that?
Speaker 3Yeah, that was an extraordinary statement last week in Senate estimates to say that she wasn't worried about the pace of unemployment rising, as you say, 4.1% to 4.7%. You know, that's a very sharp increase in unemployment. And what we're seeing today in the forecast is that we're going to get even more. And this has been the problem with the Reserve Bank. Not only are they not really doing anything to help get inflation down, but all they're doing is causing unemployment to rise. In May, it was suggested
Speaker 3by the middle of 2028, unemployment would be 4.7%. Three months ago, it changed that and made it 4.8%. And now today, it's brought it out and saying, oh, it's going to be 5% and it's going to hit 5.1% at the end of 2028. You know, this is not good. The problem is the Reserve Bank thinks full employment is whatever employment is when inflation is below 3%. So I think most people would be genuinely shocked to realise that
Speaker 3the Reserve Bank thinks that to actually achieve full employment, unemployment needs to rise. That is absolutely what they believe and it's absolutely what they're trying to make happen. They are trying to get unemployment to rise. Now, the risk is that unemployment rises faster than they expected and all their projections so far have been wrong. It has risen faster than expected. And the problem with unemployment is once it starts going up fast, it generally tends to go
Speaker 3up even faster and higher And it's very hard to stop. And that's when you start looking at a recession.
Speaker 1Let's talk a little more about that. Back in September, Michelle Bullock said it would take 12 to 18 months for the full effect of interest rate rises to be felt. Last week, she acknowledged that we're waiting to see the full impact of the increases that the RBA has already made this year. So with unemployment rising and the economy slowing, is the Reserve Bank in danger of going bankrupt? too far too quickly here? And what is the danger of recession?
Speaker 3Yeah. I mean, I wouldn't want to put a number on it, but think about it. The last time they raised interest rates, that was at the end of September. And then when the September unemployment figures came out, we found that that had risen to 4.7%. Now, What that means is the impact of those rate rises hasn't had any effect on unemployment yet, and yet it is rising. And we're very much likely to see it rise even further.
Speaker 3The concern is, is it going to rise faster than the Reserve Bank hopes? I think the whole thing about this 12 to 18 months of impact is, well, what's impacting unemployment? inflation right now. It's oil prices. If, as the Reserve Bank actually does predict, in 12 to 18 months we start seeing oil prices go back down, well then in 12 to 18 months are we actually going to need the impact of interest rate rises now? Because
Speaker 3the drop in oil prices will do its job for it. I think what we're seeing here is the Reserve Bank just having this headlong rush to raise interest rates to look like that being tough to look like oh yeah we're across this so that everyone knows that we still care about inflation and there's not enough heed to the damage that it is doing to people's livelihoods and you know the real risk is that They basically just misjudge
Speaker 3the whole situation. They think that there's all this excess demand, which is code for, oh, we're all out there spending too much. There's too many people with jobs and our wages are growing too fast. Well, I haven't seen a lot of evidence of that. And if they've got that wrong, then that can make things turn dark pretty quickly.
Speaker 1Well, Greg, thank you for speaking with me.
Speaker 2No worries.
Speaker 5Great to chat.
Speaker 1Also in the news, Pauline Hanson says a One Nation volunteer allegedly attacked with a baseball bat in Victoria is in a serious but stable condition. The 60-year-old was allegedly assaulted outside his home in Torquay, southwest of Melbourne, on Sunday night after confronting people accused of interfering with his election signs. A 37-year-old man has been charged over the attack, while a 14-year-old boy has been cautioned. Victorian Premier Ben Carroll and opposition leader Jess Wilson have condemned the violence
Speaker 1as concerns grow about the safety of campaign volunteers ahead of the November 28 state election. And a second day of hearings has begun in the High Court in a challenge to Australia's under-16s social media ban. Reddit and the Digital Freedom Project argue the law unfairly restricts young people's ability to participate in political debate. with Reddit's barrister describing the ban as ill-targeted and overbroad. The federal government argues the restrictions are justified to protect children from online harm,
Speaker 1with the court's decision not expected for several months. I'm Ruby Jones. This is 7am. Thanks for listening.
At COP31 in Türkiye, Australia has been helping lead global negotiations over the future of fossil fuels and the fight against climate change. But while the Albanese government pushes for stronger international action,...
Anthony Albanese runs a notoriously tight ship. Across his two terms as prime minister, there’s been very little leaking, very little sniping, and very few of his Labor Party colleagues willing to speak out against him....
This week, Australia’s leading health research body released its advice on puberty blockers, saying they should be available for some young people under 18. The Queensland and the Northern Territory governments, which...
In 1945, in the Crimean city of Yalta, three global superpowers - America, Great Britain and the Soviet Union - met to carve up the world between them, each claiming their own sphere of influence in the final year of...
Last week it was Qantas, last month it was NAB: two giants of Australian business cutting jobs due to the growth of AI. The explanations were familiar. Qantas says it will allow the airline to unlock innovation faster...