Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

7am

7am artwork

Will the ‘Albo-rithm’ censor the internet?

Oct 12, 202614 minAudio
  • Apple Podcasts
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

The Coalition is saying that soon, you won’t be able to criticise the Prime Minister on the internet. It’s part of its campaign against Labor’s proposed Digital Duty of Care - which the opposition has branded the “Albo-rithm”, arguing it would give the government the power to decide what Australians can see and say online. So what’s actually in the government’s bill? And how far does it go towards addressing the harms created by social media and its algorithms? Today, Digital Rights Watch chair Lizzie O’Shea on whether Labor can force Big Tech to change what we’re served - and why Donald Trump’s White House has now weighed in. If you enjoy 7am, the best way you can support us is by making a contribution at 7ampodcast.com.au/support. Socials: Stay in touch with us on Instagram Guest: Chair of Digital Rights Watch, Lizzie O’Shea Photo: AAP Image/Lukas Coch

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Hey Phil, how would you describe Albo?

Speaker 2Albo is a leader who puts principle above popularity.

Speaker 3Albo is an absolute phenomenal golfer.

Speaker 2He always gets holes in.

Speaker 4One whenever he plays.

Speaker 5The Coalition is saying that soon you won't be able to criticise the Prime Minister on the internet. I don't trust Labor to censor Australian social media.

Speaker 4Do you?

Speaker 5It's part of its campaign against Labor's proposed digital duty of care, which the opposition has branded the Albo Rhythm. arguing it would give the government the power to decide what Australians can see and say online. So what's actually in the government's bill, and how far does it go to addressing the harms created by social media and its algorithms? I'm Ruby Jones, and you're listening to 7am. Today, Chair

Speaker 5of Digital Rights Watch Liz Yoshae, on whether Labor can force big tech to change what it serves us, and why Donald Trump's White House has now weighed in. It's Tuesday, October 13. Lizzie, when it comes to the government's digital duty of care, we've heard a lot about one particular part of this proposal, giving people the ability to switch off the algorithms that control their feed. But more broadly,

Speaker 5tell me about what's actually in this bill.

Speaker 4Yes, so the requirements of this bill is that it creates a digital duty of care on certain kinds of internet service providers, social media platforms and the like.

Speaker 6The same way that we have safety standards for cars, for food, for appliances, Australia is setting basic safety standards for the online tools and online services within our digital duty of care.

Speaker 4The proposal is that these services have to provide a safe online environment. And what that means is that they have to protect users from certain kinds of content.

Speaker 6So the kind of serious harms that we're talking about here, that adults will be prevented from engaging in online, child sexual exploitation, child abuse material, child grooming, violence, sexual violence, menacing, threatening or harassment, and the promotion of terrorism and extremency.

Speaker 4And then when it comes to children, there's a more expansive list, which includes things like bullying content, content about eating disorders and the like, as well as pornography. And the idea is that platforms and other internet service providers will have to protect people from that content. They'll have to conduct risk assessments as well, and they'll have to manage design features that are considered particularly harmful.

Speaker 5Okay, can you talk to me a little bit more about that, about what creating a duty of care actually solves that existing online safety laws haven't been able to?

Speaker 4Yeah, so online safety laws in Australia have been quite prescriptive. There's a bunch of codes and basic online safety expectations that have been set up. we're moving into a much more straightforward overarching concept where we say to platforms, for example, you have a duty of care. So it's not the user's obligation to work out what is harmful and protect themselves. There's this overarching duty of care owed to users and it puts the obligation back on the platform to do that work. Now, I think what's interesting also about the

Speaker 4duty of care is that it does impose the obligation to conduct risk assessments and rather than all this research and analysis kept within the company, then instead they'll have to do this work and share it with members of the public and others, which gives us a better understanding of what kinds of risks there are online.

Speaker 5And the big political argument now is over who gets to decide what harm actually is. The Coalition is calling this the Alborhythm. They say it gives the government the power to censor lawful speech.

Speaker 1Supporting or going forward with this digital duty of care legislation would be like putting Anthony Albanese in charge of refereeing a South Sydney Rabideaus game. He's a big Rabideaus fan. He can't be trusted to be the umpire.

Speaker 5One Nation is calling it CCP, communist style internet censorship.

Speaker 3So everything is about control the people. This stinks of the Marxism and communism. It's about controlling the people, your thought process. And once you do that, we've lost our democracy.

Speaker 5So under this draft, who actually decides what counts as harmful and what checks are there on that power?

Speaker 4Yeah, so I think the first thing to say is when you go online, what you see is a curated set of content that is designed by the businesses that run these online spaces. And they have particular motivations. Often they're trying to keep you online because they can expose you to advertising, which is their business model. They often have algorithms that prioritise certain kind of content that keep you online for as long as possible, and it tends to be more extreme. So the allegations or the claims that this is a real promotion of censorship have to

Speaker 4be understood in that context. The other big problem I've got with this bill currently is there is an issue of enforcement. How do we make sure that companies are complying When we look at the Safety Commissioner, it's a relatively well-resourced regulator, but currently that commissioner is regulating some of the largest companies in the world, and it's very difficult to do that effectively, even with a large budget. And there's a question around whether the regulator alone should be doing that work, whether we need, like what we've seen in places like the United States, the right of

Speaker 4people to bring actions directly against these platforms when they've caused harm. And I think there's some real utility in thinking through how enforcement could work outside of just the regulator being the sole source of enforcement.

Speaker 5Okay, so there's this broad acknowledgement, I think, that algorithms cause harm. So is what's being considered here enough, or do you think we need more transparency about how platforms are actually deciding what gets promoted and what gets suppressed in the first place.

Speaker 4So there's a whole section of the bill that kind of sits alongside the digital duty of care, which talks about user empowerment tools. And there is very little detail about what those user empowerment tools will be. So there is a lot of complexity around this, like how you make a user empowerment tool actually useful to users is a bit of a thorny question. There's been in other parts of the world, what has been described as malicious compliance, whereby some of these companies make it difficult to continue to maintain your preferences in what you might see in your feed, for example, having to go through lots of

Speaker 4pop-ups and the like and continually restate what your preferences are. And I think that is a problem, right? We have to work out ways in which we can make it as easy as possible to give people greater control over what their online space looks like. And we're working in this instance in dialogue with a bunch of companies that might have business incentives that work against that. So it would be a disappointing outcome, I think, if where it led to was people just defaulting back to what they currently have, which prioritises the interests of platforms, I think,

Speaker 4too often and can have really negative consequences. But we'll have to see how that detail unfolds. And I think there is a broader point here as well. How do we make sure that content that is monetised online or advertising content that appears in your feed is regulated? Advertising can be really harmful because You know, we know that some of the biggest advertisers on social media platforms are fast food, gambling companies, alcohol companies, and they're very precise in when they target you with particular forms of ads based on your browsing history, your user history, the time

Speaker 4of day, what you might be exhibiting in terms of your emotional state. Now, at the moment, advertising content is pretty much excluded from the digital duty of care, but there are, I think, some interesting ways in which we could start to look at that issue. including by creating ad libraries, for example, of all ads served on social media, which would give people a greater understanding of what kind of content is being prioritised in their feed that's paid for, that justifies the business model, and perhaps criticising or coming

Speaker 4to terms with what is the social licence to operate and whether we should have restrictions on advertising as it appears in your feed, for example.

Speaker 5Still to come, why Donald Trump is weighing in on all of this. Lizzie, the Trump administration has now made a formal submission attacking this proposal and asking for American social media companies to effectively be carved out of it.

Speaker 1Fears have been raised that new fines and taxes for tech giants could be regarded as extortion by Donald Trump.

Speaker 5How unusual is it to have the US government intervene publicly in Australian domestic legislation like this?

Speaker 4I mean, I'm not surprised on one level that the Trump administration has intervened into this discussion. The e-safety regime that we've had in place beforehand has also been criticised by the Trump administration in some of the early executive orders. Clearly, the United States understands the economic power of these large platforms operating in different parts of the world, and there's a clear alliance between big tech and the White House currently. And that is manifesting in these kinds of discussions. We've seen that in all sorts of contexts in relation to

Speaker 4the regulation of artificial intelligence, as well as social media platforms, often which are the same companies, I should say. And so I think there's a real sense that the White House gets its support from large tech, that this is the future of the American economy and American dominance and American imperialism. And so a real concern around initiatives that seek to undermine the effectiveness of that business model and the domination of US tech platforms around the world. I think the reality is that the government probably expected something

Speaker 4like this, but also that most Australians expect their lawmakers to make policy and law that suits them. So I think it is important that the Albanese government consider what it is that Australians want when they use this technology. and not just give in to diplomatic pressure from a White House that I don't think many Australians trust as a source of good policy.

Speaker 5And so if Australia did do what the US is asking and exempted American companies, what would actually be left of this law?

Speaker 4So there is a large number of companies that will be affected by the digital duty of care, but I think it's fair to say When we're talking about the digital duty of care, most people are thinking about large social media companies that provide services, including as accessed by children. That's quite clearly the framing of the legislation and particularly design features that we talked about before in terms of making sure that they're managed effectively as a component of the digital duty of care, but also giving people user empowerment tools. they're really aimed at social media platforms. So

Speaker 4I think if those companies were excluded, which I think would be unlikely at this point, given the politics of it, but if they were, I think it would greatly diminish the utility of this legislative initiative. And I think it would be a huge scandal.

Speaker 5And the government, it now has all of these submissions. So When we do finally see that bill, what will you be looking at to tell whether or not it will be effective and whether pressure from the US and tech companies has actually weakened it?

Speaker 4Yeah, so what I'll be looking for when this bill is ultimately tabled is I'd love to see some statements in what we call the extraneous materials, like the second reading speech, the explanatory memorandum, that talk about rights, like I mentioned before, like freedom of expression, freedom of the press and the like. so that that can be balanced as people who will have to interpret this legislation do that work. I would really love to see some greater consideration of how we can enforce this without putting too much onus on the regulator and give courts a role.

Speaker 4I actually think courts have a really important job in interpreting exactly some of the questions that we were talking about before, how rights intersect with each other, but also what might be considered harmful, how that reflects social values. Courts are well placed to do that over time as opposed to legislation which is enshrined in a particular moment. And so I think if we start to see some of those things implemented into the bill, then we'll know that the government has decided that this is important enough, I think, to risk the ire of the White House,

Speaker 4which I'm sure will still object, and really decide to make a policy stand that many people have been campaigning for for a long time and also many people expect in the electorate. And this is going to be a critical test for the government.

Speaker 5Lizzie, thank you so much for your time.

Speaker 4Thanks for having me.

Speaker 2Also in the news, the imam of a Melbourne mosque, which has been linked to the pilot accused of trying to hijack a FlyJubilee plane, has spoken out for the first time. Referring to false allegations, Samir Matadi didn't directly address the claims, but in a video posted on social media said, the righteous will always be attacked. It's after the United Arab Emirates Attorney General claimed the pilot had started to drift towards extremism while studying in Melbourne and became acquainted with people linked to the Broadmeadows Mosque. And

Speaker 2Barnaby Joyce has joined the Greens in calling for the government to block Australians from watching the live stream execution of a US prisoner. The former US Major, who fatally shot 13 unarmed soldiers in 2009, is set to be executed by firing squad in the US in December. Joyce likened the execution to a Roman amphitheatre, saying he doesn't agree with it. I'm Daniel James, thanks for listening to 7am. We'll be back tomorrow.

Speaker 4Music you

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. How Albanese killed the climate wars

    Nov 21, 202615 minAudio

    At COP31 in Türkiye, Australia has been helping lead global negotiations over the future of fossil fuels and the fight against climate change. But while the Albanese government pushes for stronger international action,...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Ed Husic on being ‘left in the dark’ by his own government

    Nov 20, 202617 minAudio

    Anthony Albanese runs a notoriously tight ship. Across his two terms as prime minister, there’s been very little leaking, very little sniping, and very few of his Labor Party colleagues willing to speak out against him....

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Puberty blockers greenlit: So why are state bans still in place?

    Nov 19, 202615 minAudio

    This week, Australia’s leading health research body released its advice on puberty blockers, saying they should be available for some young people under 18. The Queensland and the Northern Territory governments, which...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Will Trump, Xi and Putin try to carve up the world?

    Nov 18, 202616 minAudio

    In 1945, in the Crimean city of Yalta, three global superpowers - America, Great Britain and the Soviet Union - met to carve up the world between them, each claiming their own sphere of influence in the final year of...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. AI job cuts at Bunnings, Qantas, NAB: ‘Mass unemployment is the business plan’

    Nov 17, 202616 minAudio

    Last week it was Qantas, last month it was NAB: two giants of Australian business cutting jobs due to the growth of AI. The explanations were familiar. Qantas says it will allow the airline to unlock innovation faster...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode