Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

7am

7am artwork

Is Qantas sorry – or just sorry it got caught?

Aug 1, 202616 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

This week, 7am spoke with former Qantas chief executive Alan Joyce, as he returned to public life with a memoir defending many of the decisions he made during his final years at the airline. Joyce said the company was fighting for survival during the pandemic and that, while mistakes were made, the difficult decisions taken under his leadership were necessary to keep Qantas from going under. Today, we revisit our conversation with journalist and author Joe Aston, recorded after Qantas was handed a record $90 million penalty for illegally outsourcing 1,800 workers. It asks what those decisions cost, whether they really were necessary, and whether the airline has actually changed since Joyce’s departure. The episode originally aired in August 2025. If you enjoy 7am, the best way you can support us is by making a contribution at 7ampodcast.com.au/support. Socials: Stay in touch with us on Instagram Guest: Rampart founder and author of The Chairman's Lounge: The Inside Story of How Qantas Sold Us Out, Joe Aston Photo: AAP Image/Dean Lewins

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1I'm Daniel James, and you're listening to seven AM. This week, seven Am spoke with former Corners chief executive Alan Joyce as a return to public life with a memoir defending many of the decisions he made during his final years at the airline. Joyce said the company was fighting for survival during the pandemic and that while mistakes were made, the difficult decisions taken under his leadership were necessary to keep Quanters from going under. Today we revisit our conversation

Speaker 1with journalists and author Joe Aston, recorded after Connas was handed a record ninety million dollar penalty for illegally outsourcing eighteen hundred workers. It asked what those decisions cost, if they were really necessary, and whether the airline has actually changed since Joyce's departure. It's Sunday, August two. This episode was originally published in August twenty twenty five.

Speaker 2So Joe, thank you for joining me on zevn Am My Pleasure. On Monday, Contus was ordered to pay a ninety million dollar fine for illegally sacking eighteen hundred workers back during the pandemic, and in delivering his judgment, Justice Mike Auley called Contus the wrong kind of sorry, So tell me what you made of his comments and of the decision more broadly.

Speaker 3Well, I mean, I've been watching this case for a long time. It's been a marathon. The first try, the actual original liability trial, was in twenty twenty one, in the middle of lockdowns.

Speaker 2Federal Court will decide whether Quantus acted illegally when it sacked hundreds of Melbourne ground crew and.

Speaker 3Gave their jobs to a cheaper contractor the unionit You know, then Quantus had lost that case and then appealed straight to the Full Court.

Speaker 2The Federal Court found the decision to outsource about two thousand groundworkers was in breach of the Fair Worked Act Towns.

Speaker 3They lost that case in twenty twenty two, and then they appealed straight to the High Court and they lost that case in twenty twenty three.

Speaker 4The Court has dismissed unanimously Quantus's appeal. It now stands their actions against these Quantus families as the largest sacking in Australian corporate.

Speaker 3History, who were sent back to the Federal Court to decide on the compensation that they should pay to those workers, and that was decided in twenty twenty four that they should pay one hundred and twenty million dollars. Quantus has been forced to pay more than one hundred and twenty million dollars in compensation to workers whose jobs were legally outsourced during the pandemic about eighteen Only now in twenty twenty five have they been hit with their penalties. Quantas has just been fined ninety million dollars for illegally sacking eighteen hundred groundstaf five years ago. It's just been sort

Speaker 3of this incremental debacle unfolding, which Quantus until the very last minute was fighting. Even when they lost in the High Court, that then chairman of Quantus, Richard Gouter, was dismissing the ruling of the court and saying, well, look, we had sound commercial reasons for that decision. Justice Lee was quite brilliant in pointing out how completely silly that argument is. Of course they had sound commercial reasons. I mean, what kind of an outsourcing would it have been if they didn't have sound commercial reasons. It was just a

Speaker 3bizarre reasoning that they were offering. You know, we engaged in illegal behavior because it made us money. Now that doesn't make it okay, So it wasn't just the illegal outsourcing. It was the way they conducted themselves even when they were found to have done the wrong thing by a court afterwards. And Justice Lee also this is one of the big reasons why he didn't believe that they were really sorry. Only last year in twenty twenty four, Quantus was arguing in the compensation hearings that the workers should get zero dollars of compensation. That was actually the argument

Speaker 3being put to the court by Quantus, that the workers should not get any compensation at all. That's obviously not an argument that it suggests a company that is feeling contrite about its wrongdoing.

Speaker 2Okay, so we had the company at least initially arguing that there should be no compensation for workers. They have now been ordered to pay a ninety million dollar fine. So let's talk about that for a moment. How does that amount compare with what Quantus wanted versus what the union wanted.

Speaker 3Well, yeah, I mean the fine itself is staggering, by far, the biggest fine ever imposed on a company for a breach of general protections under the Act. The last highest ever was ten million dollars against the Commonwealth Bank for an underpayment issue that went over a decade. The fine is generally paid to the party that is bringing the case, and usually that party is a fair work combodsman who prosecutes breaches of the Act by employers. But of course

Speaker 3in this case, the ombodsman was fast asleep and the union decided to take the action itself. And that's why it's really unusual about this. That's such a huge amount of money is being paid to the union.

Speaker 2Right and so so does that money then go from the union to the workers? Have they said how to be divvied up?

Speaker 3So the penalties, ninety fifty of that goes to the union and then the other forty will go to the workers on top of one hundred and twenty million that they were already getting in compensation. But you know, if you look at how many workers were illegally sacked, there's eighteen hundred. It Actually, you know, this is not sort of life changing money for people who've lost their livelihoods. The forty million dollars split eighteen hundred ways, that's only twenty two thousand dollars per person. So for someone who's lost a long term, a good paying blue collar job,

Speaker 3that's not going to get them over line.

Speaker 2And it's been a year now since Quantus announced that it was slashing Allan Joyce's payout by almost ten million, and that was partly because of his handling of this. And at the time, Quantus knowledge the harm that had been done to their reputation, particularly with their customers, and they commissioned a review to tell them how to fix it. So what did that review end up saying and has the company implemented any changes?

Speaker 3Well, yeah, well the review was damning and the review found that Quantus had a terrible culture and it had a board that was too weak to challenge the CEO, Alan Joyce, And this case the legal sackings was one part of it. But you know, you remember there was also the ghost flights, the issue of COVID credits and the way customers were really poorly treated by those There was a huge amount of price gouging. There's a massive suite of issues that were affecting quantus reputation. Now, what has actually changed a lot of that is sort of

Speaker 3at the surface level. I think it's fair to say that Quantus under Vanessa Hudson is a company more focused on its customers and on its staff than it had been previously. But you know, does it still the highest possible faares that it can on routes where there's not very much competition? Absolutely? Does it still invest insufficiently in new aircraft to improve the experience and reliability for its customers. Absolutely, you know, and also, by the way, to reduce the

Speaker 3impact on the environment. So Quantus has changed its bedside manner. I think that's fair to say, and that's not nothing. That's an important thing. But if you look deeply, Quantus is still a very aggressive company.

Speaker 2Right, so the underlying strategy might not have changed even though Joyce is out of the picture. So what ongoing benefits does Joyce get as a result of the time that he spent there.

Speaker 3Well, I mean, you know, he made one hundred and thirty million dollars a CEO of Quantus. That's pretty good coin if you can get it. And he's got a golden ticket. It's like the one they give you in Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, except instead of instead of unlimited chocolate, it's unlimited first class flights for life.

Speaker 2After the break. What Quantus says it's learned and what its profits really show Joe Quantus for the past year has been run by Vanessa Hudson. So tell me a bit more about her and how she's approached her role.

Speaker 1SOFA.

Speaker 3Yeah, Well, Vanessa Hudson's even more of a Quantus lifer than Alan Joyce in that she started at the company. I think it was almost her second job in the audit department, which is a very exciting place as you can imagine, in nineteen ninety four, in her twenties, and has worked right across the company. When I worked at Quantas in the late two thousands, she was running customer product and service inflight product and service when the airline received its first day three eighties, and then she's gone

Speaker 3and run the American division of Quantus. She came back and was chief Customer Officer briefly and then became the chief financial officer. So she's really worked right across the company, and she became CEO in twenty twenty three. Her pitch to the board of Quantas for the job is I'm not going to change anything. I'm going to be just like Alan Joyce. Now, as Alan Joyce became absolutely toxic in the dying months of his reign, she had to very quickly change that plan and try to distinguish herself from Joyce and be someone different.

Speaker 5We want to get back to the national carrier that Australians can be proud of, that's known for going above and beyond. We understand we need to earn your trust back, not with what we say, but what we do and how we behave.

Speaker 3And she has to keep the shareholders happy, She has to make up with customers, and she has to make staff feel like it's worth going out there and putting themselves on the line every day. For those customers. She's sort of done pretty well. For the shareholders, they're very happy. The share prices more than double since she's been in charge. And in terms of making up with the customers, noises are made. But they'll never admit this. But every senior executive at Quantus knows that they only have to be so nice to their customers. But really they'll keep coming

Speaker 3back from more punishment because the customers just don't have other options.

Speaker 2And it's not just the chief executive who has changed. Last year, John Mullen became chair. So what impact has he had so far?

Speaker 6Ah?

Speaker 3Well, look, I think John Mullen is someone who has a really good sense of what the average person on the street thinks and feels. You know, he's somebody who's really quite in touch. And that's a good thing for Quantas because that's how this happened in the first place. Alan Joyce was living in his own world and his board was subservient to him. So even though they might have had doubts about how angry Australia was at Quantas, they weren't prepared to challenge Alan Joyce to do anything about it. Put it this way, there's no way in

Speaker 3the world that Vanessa Hudson is going to be telling John Mullen what to do. And there's no way in the world that John Mullen's going to be too afraid to pull Vanessa Hudson into line. And that's the way companies are supposed to be wrong.

Speaker 2Okay, And so have we heard from John Mullen since this ruling came down on Monday.

Speaker 3No, we haven't, and it's probably not for him to comment at this stage. But you know, look, there's no doubt that John Mullen has got Vanessa and her team really focused on cultural change. But I just find it really disappointing that given the opportunity, and everyone was pointing this out to them at the time in twenty twenty four that they continue to argue that the workers should get zero compensation because that's a really hard thing for them to defend, and it just opens them up to the absolutely legitimate criticism that they're all taught that the

Speaker 3cultural change is about a surface appearance and not actually about root and branch. You know, should we do the right thing even when it's expensive. Should we do the right thing even when it's painful. I think that's really agredible. And this is the thing about company culture. Everyone thinks that company culture is something that everyone is part of, and in some ways that's true, but the real truth of it is that company culture is really set by very few people at the top, and it is the values of the boss that emanates through the organization. And

Speaker 3Alan Joyce had some executives around him whose judgment was very poor when it came to ethical decision making, and the court has ultimately found that Joe.

Speaker 2There is this line in Justice Lee's ruling where he says that quantus is pleading virtue only when cornered and feigning contrition while harboring it. No genuine regret, and I think that really goes to everything that he kind of said when handing down this decision. So how does that square with the culture that you have observed at Quantus over y'all many many years of reporting on the company.

Speaker 3Well, it's confirmatory of what I was just saying about, you know, being very sorry, as saying that you're very sorry, but then saying to the court, well, please, we don't really want to pay these people any money for what we did to them. It's very hard to argue that that is actual, deep and profound cultural change and not just a sort of air brushing of the ugly things from view. Bear in mind, Quantus has a lot of reasons not to be sorry for doing this. Look at the numbers, right, So they've spent almost a quarter of

Speaker 3a billion dollars on this case, one hundred and twenty million dollars in compensation, ninety million dollar fine, at least twenty or twenty five million dollars in legal fees, and even then they're still ahead financially because although they've been publicly shamed and humiliated and the chairman had to resign and the CEO had to resign and all these all these executives had to resign and all sorts of calamity befell them. What actually happened is by sacking these people illegally, they saved one hundred and twenty five million dollars every

Speaker 3year on wages, and they avoided eight million dollars of equipment costs that they were going to have to invest in. So it's been five years now, but that's almost seven hundred million dollars they've already saved by doing what they did, versus the two hundred and something million dollars that they've had to pay for the infringement. So like, yeah, they have to look like they're sorry, but I bet there's plenty of people in the company who just very quietly say that was a ripper decision. We've made more money for our shareholders, and so you know, we all have

Speaker 3to send the right signals, but we do it again ten times out of ten. That's something the government needs to think really deeply about, because there's something wrong with a country where breaking the law is cheaper than complying with the law. We're breaking the law is so financially rewarding that, to me, signals are problem with the law.

Speaker 2Well, Joe, thank you so much for your time today.

Speaker 3My pleasure. Thanks Realby.

Speaker 1You can listen back to Our You with Alan Joyce titled Alan Joyce on Quantus Reputational Collapse at his Legacy. You'll find it in your podcast for published Monday, July twenty seven.

Speaker 3Seven.

Speaker 1I Am will be back tomorrow with an interview with journalists and filmmaker Abby Martin. Over five years, she's been investigating the hidden environmental footprint of the largest military in the world for a new documentary, Earth's Greatest Enemy, traveling from international wargames and military conferences to communities living with the toxic legacy of the US military's global presence.

Speaker 6I mean, the US military has air forces that are five times bigger than the next five biggest air powers combined. The amount of waste and emissions that are just being used just to fly around in pointless patrols and just to maintain mission readiness. I mean, just to wrap your mind around that. Compared to the average Australian driver road, it would be comparable to like twenty years driving straight to one flight mission of a Boing Pioces.

Speaker 1That'll be in your faet tomorrow I'm Daniel James. Thanks for listening to seven.

Speaker 3I am

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. How Albanese killed the climate wars

    Nov 21, 202615 minAudio

    At COP31 in Türkiye, Australia has been helping lead global negotiations over the future of fossil fuels and the fight against climate change. But while the Albanese government pushes for stronger international action,...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Ed Husic on being ‘left in the dark’ by his own government

    Nov 20, 202617 minAudio

    Anthony Albanese runs a notoriously tight ship. Across his two terms as prime minister, there’s been very little leaking, very little sniping, and very few of his Labor Party colleagues willing to speak out against him....

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Puberty blockers greenlit: So why are state bans still in place?

    Nov 19, 202615 minAudio

    This week, Australia’s leading health research body released its advice on puberty blockers, saying they should be available for some young people under 18. The Queensland and the Northern Territory governments, which...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Will Trump, Xi and Putin try to carve up the world?

    Nov 18, 202616 minAudio

    In 1945, in the Crimean city of Yalta, three global superpowers - America, Great Britain and the Soviet Union - met to carve up the world between them, each claiming their own sphere of influence in the final year of...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. AI job cuts at Bunnings, Qantas, NAB: ‘Mass unemployment is the business plan’

    Nov 17, 202616 minAudio

    Last week it was Qantas, last month it was NAB: two giants of Australian business cutting jobs due to the growth of AI. The explanations were familiar. Qantas says it will allow the airline to unlock innovation faster...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode