Send us Fan Mail Abe Sutton, Director of the CMS Innovation Center and Deputy Administrator at CMS, joins Adam Goodman and Alison Anway on 13th & Park to break down one of the most consequential but least understood corners of the federal government: the agency responsible for testing new ways to pay for healthcare, improve outcomes, and lower costs for millions of Americans on Medicare and Medicaid. Sutton explains the core mission of the CMS Innovation Center in plain terms: move fast, test new payment models like a venture portfolio, and scale what works. He discusses the shift away from fee-for-service toward outcomes-based care, why downside risk is essential for changing physician behavior, and how the center is deploying models focused on drug innovation, digital therapeutics, and rural health access under the Trump administration's broader MAHA agenda. Drawing on his experience as a co-founder of healthcare companies that participated in CMS programs, Sutton offers a rare insider-outsider perspective on what it actually takes to get providers to invest in new care models. He talks about the importance of operational dependability, the challenge of designing payment bundles, and why productivity growth in healthcare has lagged every other sector of the economy. The conversation closes on a personal note, as Sutton reflects on watching his father navigate his grandmother's Parkinson's care and a dangerous medication interaction that first drew him to this work. His message to talented people in the private healthcare sector: the Innovation Center is hiring, and the chance to reshape care delivery for an entire nation is worth the trade-off. Chapters 0:00 Intro 1:29 What Does the CMS Innovation Center Do? 3:34 Why Congress Created the Center 4:24 The Venture Model for Healthcare 5:04 Fee-for-Service to Outcomes-Based Care 8:49 New Models: Elevate, Access, and More 10:45 Explaining Healthcare Reform to Americans 11:59 Digital Healthcare Tools and Older Adults 13:43 Blending Public and Private Sector Experience 16:00 Rural Healthcare and Digital Access 18:12 The CMS Leadership Team Under Dr. Oz 20:35 Why Healthcare? A Personal Story 22:29 MAHA and Taking Back Control Follow Us! X: https://x.com/13thandPark IG: https://www.instagram.com/13th_and_park/ LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/13thandpark TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@13th_and_park Follow Abe Sutton X: https://x.com/AbeSutton LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/abesutton #healthcare #medicaid #medicare #healthcarepolicy #cmsinnivationcenter #digitalhealth #maha #makingamericahealthyagain #ruralhealth #healthcareaccess #healthcarereform #federalpolicy #politicalpodcast #13thandpark #adamgoodman #healthinnovation #trumpadministration
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01My job is really about making healthcare logical. It's about getting the bureaucrats out of the exam room and so that you could actually engage and get care the right way.
SPEAKER_00When you think about it, healthcare in America is full of contradictions. Extraordinary innovation on the one hand, and on the other, an inefficient system that's been built on treating illness instead of preventing it. At the heart of changing that is the CMS Innovation Center, the part of CMS that tests new ways to pay for care, improve outcomes, and lower costs. Our guest today, Abe Sutton, leads that center as its director and also as the deputy administrator at CMS, with a federal health policy background and in the private sector actually built health care companies.
SPEAKER_00His mission: make innovation and the system work for patients faster. From Ballard Studios in the nation's capital, together with my co-host Allison Anway, it's 13th and Mark.
SPEAKER_03I never dreamed going into the White House. You risk your freedom. We in Congress will act together when we have to act. They deserve better and we owe them some results.
SPEAKER_01I believe this country's best days continue to remain ahead.
SPEAKER_00I have no idea the monster we unleashed.
SPEAKER_03I play every night and people love it. They're going berserk!
SPEAKER_00Well, I don't have any Emmy Awards behind me yet, but you know, I'm sure they're covered.
SPEAKER_03I'm so glad to be here on 13th in Park.
SPEAKER_00So, Abe, welcome to the set of 13th in Park. I know Allison, who is our health policy guru in the firm, will understand everything you're about to say. I'm gonna have to go to Chat GPT or something after this interview to understand what we just talked about in part, because you have one of those titles that sounds incredibly impressive, but it's also representing something highly technical. So when someone like me comes to you and says, Hey, Abe, what do you do?
SPEAKER_01Well, one, thank you for having me on. I'll try and not make it too technical for today's conversation. Right. Honestly, a big part of my job is translating what can be really technical work that the incredible folks at the CMS Innovation Center do to improve how Medicare and Medicaid pay for healthcare, to make care more affordable in this country, and translate it into plain English. That's my job. So it's great that you're putting me on the spot to do it. Don't accept wonkery, don't rely on chatbots to translate it. Let's try and get into the different types of payment models, the ways that we could approach care differently, change incentives so that doctors are empowered to care for patients in the way that you'd want your loved ones to be cared for.
SPEAKER_00Everyone has to be at the table for that conversation to really mean something, right?
SPEAKER_01100%. We get a ton of really helpful input from physician groups and organizations. We have a physician technical advisory committee that gives a ton of input on different thematic focus areas that we rely on. And then we engage with patient advocacy groups directly and with the people who will come in and join our models, hospitals, pharmaceutical companies, insurance companies. We take all that input together and then we go through the work of creating a different incentive structure and put it out in the world for people to come in and say, that makes sense for me. Let's pay for digital therapeutics in a new way and give patients on Medicare access to those for the first time ever.
SPEAKER_01Let's pay for pharmaceuticals in a way that is tied to the outcomes they deliver and ensures that Americans pay the most favored nation price for a drug and are not paying more than European countries. Let's get at the challenges of affordability in this country that President Trump, Secretary Kennedy, and Dr. Oz have identified and turned that into real policy quickly.
SPEAKER_00Congress created the CMS Innovation Center, right? What problem was it trying to solve when it did that?
SPEAKER_01So the core issue boils down to affordability. We pay too much for healthcare and do not get the quality of care that we want to have for every American across Medicare, Medicaid, and chip. And so our mission is to improve quality without harm uh without increasing cost, or to decrease cost without harming quality. If we could do that, we say this is a success, let's just run this in perpetuity, let's make it available to everyone. And Congress saw that if we could quickly translate policy into action, turning that into real payments that go out and change incentives and test and see if it works on a limited basis, we could really transform care delivery in this country.
SPEAKER_01It's daunting though, isn't it? It's a venture model. Right. So if you're a venture capitalist making investments, got a fund to deploy, you pick 20 different positions, you put some money into each, you recognize that not everyone will work out. But all you need is one to work out and 100x and you've returned the fund. Good point. The goal is not to produce a perfect model. The goal is to move fast and get out different incentive structures and learn and iterate over time and take the ones that work and spread them across the entire payment system. Because if we could do that, we could really change the trajectory so that people get better care, so that their loved ones have access to the support that they need, and that we have more affordable care delivery in this country for state Medicaid programs and the trust fund.
SPEAKER_03I mean, it feels like this move from sort of fee-for-service-based payment in Medicare and other, you know, healthcare payment models towards more outcomes-based, accountable care models, that is like the holy grail that we've been chasing and searching for decades now. Where do you think we are on that journey, on that search as of right now?
SPEAKER_01I'll give a lot of credit. I think there's a lot that we can learn from what came before us. So the first iteration of the innovation center was one that said, let's let a thousand flowers bloom, to take the direct phrase that people use. Yeah, I remember that. Right. I think we've had some learnings. One, if you're looking at accountable care in the manner you're alluding to, I think you need downside risk. I think in order to change incentives, you need to change the actual incentive. It can't be an optional upside-only thing that then you look at 18 months later and see if it worked.
SPEAKER_01That doesn't change things. It doesn't move the needle in behavior. Two, it's really complex and hard to design a bundled payment, taking a bunch of different services and putting it together for a period of time and knowing the right optimal approach. Like, should this look at 30 days of spend or 45? Well, how does that change the incentive for controlling costs and avoiding hospital readmissions? But which exact services should be included together? Is the physical therapy part of that bundle or excluded? What's the trigger event that initiates the bundle? Do we wait till a surgery is performed?
SPEAKER_01Or can we go upstream earlier than that and actually prevent the surgery from occurring in the first place? Making all those decisions takes a lot of time, a lot of effort. It's very easy to mess it up in some small way. And that's a challenge. And so stepping back thematically and getting to bigger challenges is the right way to focus the innovation center's time and effort. And learning from examples of what's been working in the private sector to reshape our efforts is a way to keep them grounded. And constantly iterating on that is important. The other thing I'll flag is if I want people to come in and participate in a model, they have to be able to depend on it.
SPEAKER_01If they look at it and see, hey, this is just going to change in the future in two years. I can't depend on this. It's then we really hard to get an investment committee to underwrite investment, to go to your board and say, we should undertake this. That will um suppress participation and make it harder to draw real conclusions of what it would be like if this was part of the Medicare program or if this is how a state approached things in Medicaid.
SPEAKER_00Is that kind of what drives you kind of get up in the morning every day thinking, okay, we're gonna have all sorts of new things we're gonna be looking at today. I'm confident we're gonna find something really powerful, but I can't be afraid to venture into the void, or we're never gonna get there.
SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell That's a large part of what I think what motivates our team is that mindset. I think there's also a balance in the portfolio. Given the 15 years of lessons that we have at the center and the expertise we can tap across other parts of CMS and other parts of the Department of Health and Human Services, and people who have gone on and done innovative things in the private sector and share expertise with us. As a result of all that input, I think there are some things we could look at where we're like, you know, this is a pretty safe bet. Like this will save money without harming quality. Odds are this will improve quality and not increase cost.
SPEAKER_01And then we also have some things that are further reaching, where we're like, wow, this would be so impactful if it worked out. And I think odds are it would, but I'm not at 90% certainty where we move forward and also test it. In any model I test, in order to give confidence to people to come in and participate, I work with the actuarial team at CMS and try and get to a scenario where in what we call the mid-case scenario. So this is the median outcome range. If you did a bell curve distribution, this is where the actuaries think we will fall.
SPEAKER_01I want to be in a scenario where we're saving money.
SPEAKER_03So of all the new models that have been introduced recently, the elevate model, the access model, do you have like a favorite? Which ones are you the most excited about? Their potential?
SPEAKER_01You can't ask me to choose by dating this, right?
SPEAKER_03Like pick a favorite child.
SPEAKER_01What I'll say is I'm excited about the potential we could unlock with this portfolio of models. So in healthcare, as opposed to other parts of the economy, we have not seen massive productivity growth this century. Now you're saying the thing, but we have, you know, we have electronic medical records, we have all these advancements. But the affordability of healthcare is fundamentally driven by the fact that labor is a very expensive input in a care delivery. And, you know, the number of folks you have to cover a certain number of patients in a hospital floor is not different than it was, you know, at the turn of the century.
SPEAKER_01A software engineer can produce a lot more than they could in the year 2000. A software engineer could produce a lot more than they could in the year 2025. We need to enhance productivity in healthcare. And the answer for how to do that, and therefore get to more affordable healthcare in this country, is drug innovation and new technologies. It's unleashing these areas of the economy that can drive healthcare productivity so that we get upstream, prevent you from needing that hospitalization, engage you post-discharge in the healthy behaviors and in the drug regimen that you need to be on so that you don't have a relapse and need to go back into the hospital, and pushing forward the envelope and innovating so that we have cures for things that we cannot treat today, and that we have broad access to those in this country.
SPEAKER_01So anything that we could do to unleash that growth in both of these areas is, I think, the key for making care more affordable for the American people in the long run. That's why four of our models focused on drugs, of the 10 that we've announced so far this term under President Trump's leadership, and two of them focus on technology in different ways.
SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell How do you make it understandable for Americans? All this innovation and the new models and whatever, how do you explain that to someone that is having difficulties accessing the system, or even if they have accessing the system, affording the care that they need? How do you get in that conversation?
SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell When you sit down with a doctor, how do you think they're paid for the time they spend with you? They're paid based off what somebody in a windowless room in Washington, D.C. says should be on a schedule of fees. Like literally, oh, 12-minute increment, we pay you X, 25-minute increment, we pay you Y. And so it's not about the time you spend together in the exam room and what they know they need is needed for your health. It's not about them just reviewing the record and sending you a text of what you need to do or answering a question via text if you have one.
SPEAKER_01And so my job is really about making healthcare logical. It's about getting the bureaucrats out of the exam room and so that you could actually engage and get care the right way and that the doctor could do what they know is right for you. So when I talk about what I do, it's about making healthcare simple, making it easy, making it look like other parts of the economy instead of something that's been disintermediated by the bureaucratic structure of how we pay for care.
SPEAKER_03You were talking a lot about the sort of acceleration and innovation when it comes to digital healthcare tools. And we've talked about this quite a bit on this show. And some of those tools and that sort of overarching theme of digital healthcare are included in some of your models. Talk a little bit more about the promise and maybe the limits of digital healthcare tools in the Medicare program, and especially when you're talking about older adults who maybe aren't as you know tech savvy or comfortable using technology.
SPEAKER_01When I think about the promise of an app that could help engage somebody and support them, I think about like the real world examples that like I use or my loved ones use. I think about like a wearable that you could have around your wrist or your finger that tracks your vital sign or your sleep patterns and like tells you how you're doing and reminds you not to eat so close to bed. But not everyone on Medicare or on Medicaid has access to in the same way. Well, what would it look like if we paid for engaging somebody and getting them to change their behavior in a way that meaningfully improves their health outcomes?
SPEAKER_01I don't want to pay for technology and have it on the fee schedule. People were just trying to deliver more and more technology to people, and who cares if they're actually using it? That's a pretty bad incentive structure. The point of digital technology is can you engage somebody and can you drive a better outcome? If you could do that, that's when we want to pay you from Medicare. So what we measure is improvement. Where are you on the baseline today? And then where are you a year from now? Did you have the person engaging with your app? And did you drive that improvement over time? And if you did, you should be paid for that.
SPEAKER_01If not, we shouldn't really be paying you. And in fact, I don't want to have an on-ramp for solutions that can't engage people and can't drive better health outcomes.
SPEAKER_00You're not alone in this administration. A lot of the leaders in healthcare have come with some experience in the private sector as well as the public sector. You have a background in federal policy in healthcare. You help build healthcare companies. I call that the blended experience. How has that really helped you and given you a perspective, maybe, that someone who only had one piece of that would not have if they were doing what you're trying to do today?
SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell Having co-founded companies that participated in CMS programs transformed my understanding of how these programs worked. Sure. We could have a really high-level policy conversation. That sounds really great. It doesn't reflect the reality of logging into the payment system and checking your results and being able to depend on those appearing monthly and knowing how to translate that and the format you receive it in into the risk ratifications for which patients you focus on. The operational aspects of our payment structures matter a ton for people actually acting on what we tell them.
SPEAKER_01It's not just this conceptual idea, it's real operational work that you have to do in the private sector. Being able to predict it, depend on it, and therefore invest off of it and hire staff off of it to ensure that you have that dietitian who's doing the review of the patients of how they're eating or doing the medical reconciliation work that you have a pharmacist on staff now to help with, that matters. And you're not going to make that investment unless you know that you could depend on the structure. And so I've tried to telegraph this is where we're going.
SPEAKER_01We laid out a strategy early on in this term based off Secretary Kennedy's priorities where Dr. Oswan to focus and President Trump's broad vision for the space. We are focused on making America healthy again. We're focused on evidence-based prevention. We're focused on empowering people to achieve their health goals, giving them the information they need, and ensuring that they can act on that information easily. And then choice and competition. The key to driving down costs and giving people options, that was all based off of the experience that I had operating and translating that into something from a policy perspective that could lead people to push forward.
SPEAKER_01Everything in the policy agenda is really shaped based off the needs we have in our healthcare sector and where people are not able to deliver care the right way today.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, you talk about gaps in our healthcare system. And the thing that immediately pops to my mind is rural healthcare. We have had several guests on the show that have talked about their experience either providing healthcare in a rural area or trying to access healthcare in a rural area, back to the topic of digital health. That feels like one of the most promising areas where, you know, sort of the digital democratization of healthcare could really make an impact. Is rural healthcare part of what you think about when you're putting together your models?
SPEAKER_01Yes. Rural healthcare is one of the core things we think about in our models, and also broadly at CMS as we shape our agenda. Dr. Oz was entrusted by Congress with responsibility for allocating the$50 billion rural health transformation program, an unprecedented investment in the health of rural America and the infrastructure there to care for it for the generation ahead. If I think about the potential there, uh it's astounding. This was a necessary step that Congress recognized and chose to back to invest in rural health care and the infrastructure there.
SPEAKER_01And Dr. Oz has taken the opportunity to make this a transformative moment in line with the name Rural Health Transformation Program, focusing on digital access, on workforce, on ensuring that rural communities have access to healthy prevention options beyond all of that infrastructure investment. An unprecedentedly fast effort to stand up in office to administer this, working with states across the country to give that support. In the innovation center, we have a rural lens on every single model we stand up.
SPEAKER_01That means that we consider the pathway for a rural participant into the model. When I think about our access model, which is the way we pay for digital therapeutics, we will pay more for engaging and supporting a rural participant, somebody who's living in a rural community, because frankly, it's harder to engage them. It's harder to get them to engage and live that healthier life. And you have to invest more to reach them, and therefore we should pay more for that. And so we've recognized that and taken that lens in the design of every single model. And so we've put that front and center.
SPEAKER_01And that I note is very close to the ambitions that Dr. Oz, Secretary Kennedy, and President Trump have for our healthcare system.
SPEAKER_00So when Dr. Oz was on the show, he said one of the biggest jobs he has is making sure all the people around him who are full of ideas and throwing them out don't kill each other right off because he wants to encourage everybody to put it out there on the table. Is that the kind of experience that you've had so far inside of government? And how important is that for us to really get at bottom line answers, maybe politics and bureaucracy prevented us from getting close to before?
SPEAKER_01So Dr. Oz has ensembled an incredible team. What we have in terms of the CMS leadership, the colleagues I have the privilege of working with every day, are just such an incredible crew of leaders. John Brooks came in with a depth of experience. I had the chance to work with John closely in the first Trump administration, but there is nobody who knows CMS payment policies better than John Brooks. Chris Klump, who came in with an entrepreneurial background and leads the Center for Medicare, in addition to serving now as chief counselor of HHS, the leadership that he brings in thinking through what our right priorities are and how to organize our team to run at them is inspirational.
SPEAKER_01Dan Broman, who runs the Center for Medicaid and Chip Services, another entrepreneurial background, a record of service to the country, and now brings the emphasis he had on supporting veterans, supporting people on Medicaid, to his role, running the Medicaid and chip team to ensure that we are supporting people, connecting them to new work opportunities, connecting them to resources so that they can not only achieve better health, but achieve a better life. We just have such an incredible group of leaders across the CMS team that Dr. Oz was able to call up, recruit, and convince to come in.
SPEAKER_01He's pretty compelling that way. He's incredible. And so when we're all sitting around with like Kim Brandt, who's on her third tour of duty at CMS, Steph Carlton, it's just such an incredible group of folks who are so inspiring. And what is incredible is that these different perspectives balance out well to get at here's an insight of how the private sector will react to this, here's how this industry will think about it, here's how this will help patients, and here's the legal pathways we have to pursue this. Let's find the best solution, let's force rank them, and then let's run at those two and find the best option and circle up next week with the path forward.
SPEAKER_01That's why we've been able to run at a really fast pace to turn policy into action. It's due to that group of leaders and how they're interacting with one another and really focused on doing what's right.
SPEAKER_00What got you involved in healthcare? Why was it healthcare that attracted you and uh clearly we can see your energy, you know, and talking about what you you do every day that still drives your passion that you can make a fundamental difference for people?
SPEAKER_01I think it boils down to a personal experience and seeing something up close early enough that you focused in and you're like, wow, this should work differently. I watched as my dad coordinated care for my grandmother. My grandmother uh had Parkinson's and the interaction it was a cardiology medication and like if to treat a heart issue, but the interaction with that with neurological pathways for her Parkinson's had that could have had a really bad effect. And I remember distinctly my dad catching this and like, all right, the cardiologist had put her on something, there was a bit of a decline, right?
SPEAKER_01We need to revert this, and he was able to correct that. But medical reconciliation is not something done for every patient in this country. I have conversations today with patients who have benefited in some ways from our payment models and have struggled in other ways with the systems that we have, with caregivers. And I'm reminded why I'm doing this because we need a care system that's easier to navigate, we need a system that is more affordable so that people can get the care that they need.
SPEAKER_01And that's why I'm here doing what I do. And it's what inspires so many of the people on my team. If I look across the people in the innovation center, these are some of the most selfless, dedicated civil servants that we have. People who could be earning three times as much in the private sector. There's a lot of lucrative roles in healthcare, but they chose to be here and we are hiring now. So my call to those listening to this who maybe work in healthcare but want to see it from the government side is to consider jumping ship, to consider volunteering and coming in. We offer long hours, low pay, and the chance to really make a difference.
SPEAKER_03Amazing.
SPEAKER_00We really value what you and so many around you are doing every day. We so badly need that. I was at this conversation uh last night, actually, with someone in the circle, so to speak, and I said, well, describe Maha and the whole revolution. And it really comes down to one concept: taking back control, allowing the American people, patients, to take back control, to feel they're in control again. Because that's that's the scary part of the healthcare system we have right now. It's too complicated. That I think underlies the philosophy of Maha.
SPEAKER_00That's the philosophy of reform and change that the president and you and Dr. Oz and everyone has been fighting for. And I can tell you, all of America should be cheering for that right now because selfishly it's going to help everybody. Thanks for being on the show. Thank you for having me on the
Send us Fan Mail Former Democratic Senator Bill Bradley of New Jersey and former Republican Senator Jack Danforth of Missouri join Adam Goodman on 13th and Park for a wide-ranging conversation about the state of...
Send us Fan Mail California State Senator Brian Jones joins Anthony on 13th and Park for a candid end-of-career conversation reflecting on 16 years in Sacramento, the unique pressures of leading a super minority caucus,...
Send us Fan Mail Adam Hasner, President of Florida Atlantic University and Florida's former House Majority Leader, joins Adam Goodman on 13th and Park for a conversation about what a college education should actually...
Send us Fan Mail Larry Sabato, founder of UVA's Center for Politics and the mind behind the legendary Sabato's Crystal Ball, joins Adam Goodman for his third appearance on 13th and Park. With Election Day closing in,...
Send us Fan Mail John Zecca, NASDAQ's Executive Vice President and Global Legal Chief, joins Adam Goodman on 13th and Park for a wide-ranging conversation on what makes American capital markets the envy of the world,...