A vintage ribbon microphone and mixing desk on a wooden table in warm lamplight, with headphones and handwritten notes beside them

Pod Blog · Podcaster Story

Nobody Asked Them to Make These Shows

Justin McElroy started a joke advice show with his brothers. Robert Evans turned a book idea into a history juggernaut between reporting trips to war zones. Aaron Mahnke recorded a giveaway for his novels and accidentally built a storytelling company. Three podcasters who started before anyone gave them permission.

Nobody commissioned any of these shows. A joke advice podcast three brothers recorded from three different cities. A history show a comedy website editor carried around in his head as a book idea. A folklore show that started as a free file meant to sell self-published novels. None of them had a network, a marketing budget, or any reason to believe a stranger would press play.

Years later, all three shows are still running. Between them they have produced a television series, bestseller lists, a production company, a whole podcast network, live tours, and hundreds of millions of downloads. What Justin McElroy, Robert Evans, and Aaron Mahnke share is not a genre. It is a way of starting. Each of them began before anyone gave them permission, and each kept going long after the first burst of attention would have let him stop.

Justin McElroy

Justin McElroy grew up in Huntington, West Virginia, at a dinner table that doubled as a training ground. His father Clint hosted morning radio in Huntington for 40 years, and Justin has said the brothers built their rapport across that table, one-upping each other for laughs before they ever owned microphones. The raw material of the McElroy shows is not a format. It is a family that had been performing for each other their whole lives.

His own road to the microphone ran through print. In 2005 he joined the Ironton Tribune in Ohio as a reporter, and in 2006 he won an Ohio Associated Press award for best business reporting. The same stretch of his life held a loss he rarely builds material around. His mother Leslie died of cancer in 2005, after nearly 28 years of marriage to Clint. Justin was 24. He started his newspaper career the year he lost her, and his father remarried in February 2010, weeks before the brothers launched the show that changed everything.

From newspapers he moved to Joystiq in 2007, rising to managing editor, and in 2012 he left with Chris Grant and his brother Griffin to co-found the games site Polygon. By then the podcast had already begun. In April 2010 the three brothers, living in different cities, started My Brother, My Brother and Me as self-entertainment, a standing excuse to talk every week. The show posed as an advice program and answered questions with total confidence and no qualifications. By November 2010 it was drawing nearly 15,000 listens a week. In January 2011 it joined the Maximum Fun network. A six-episode television version followed in 2017, filmed in Huntington. In February 2026 the show aired its 800th episode, in its 16th year, having never missed its weekly rhythm.

The second show made him podcasting's most famous layman. Sawbones began in June 2013 with his wife, Dr. Sydnee McElroy, a family physician. She tells the story of some historical practice or medical figure, and Justin hears it cold, asking the questions a listener would ask. The premise was partly self-protection. As he put it on Bullseye, "It was also a way for us to avoid giving advice, which can get legally a little dicey." The show has passed 500 episodes, produced a book in 2018, and found a second life during the COVID years as a place listeners trusted for straight answers about vaccines and medical falsehoods.

The third show exists because his daughter was born. In the summer of 2014, with Justin about to take paternity leave, the brothers and their father recorded a one-off game of Dungeons and Dragons as a fill-in episode. Listeners demanded more, and The Adventure Zone spun off that December. Justin played Taako, an elf wizard whose great ambition includes inventing the taco. The first campaign ran 69 episodes. Its graphic novel adaptation became the first graphic novel ever to top the New York Times trade fiction bestseller list. Justin later sat in the game master's chair himself for a full campaign, and he is playing in the current season, Royale, which began in June 2025.

He also built one of the medium's great running bits out of corporate paperwork. Munch Squad, his segment reading fast food press releases aloud with total gravity, has run since about 2016. He explained the appeal in a 2023 interview. "I feel like making fun of not just corporations, but marketing for specific consumer products is as near to a victimless crime as you can get."

In April 2018 he and Griffin left Polygon, the site they had co-founded, to bet on the podcasts and their families. The bet held. But the work has started to bill him for it. Decades of games writing and performing left Justin with carpal tunnel problems serious enough for surgery in early 2026. On the show's 800th episode he told listeners he could no longer game for more than 10 minutes before his hands fell asleep. In May 2026 he stepped away from The Besties, the games podcast he had co-hosted since 2012, closing the games journalism chapter of his career. The podcasts continue. His test for what deserves his hours is written in the brothers' book. "Do I actually want to put in the time, my most precious resource on this planet, to make this thing exist on Earth?"

He built all of it without leaving Huntington. The family's annual Candlenights charity show raises money for Harmony House, which works to end homelessness in his hometown. In 2021 scientists named a newly discovered Appalachian millipede species for the family, Nannaria mcelroyorum, because the shows kept them company in the field. The oldest brother stayed home, and the audience came to him.

Robert Evans

Robert Evans learned his trade by volunteering for the assignments nobody wanted. At Cracked, where he worked from 2009 to 2017, he built the Personal Experience desk, a run of reported, first-person journalism hiding inside a comedy site. His method rested on a belief he stated plainly. "I think a very important component of good humor is compassion. I think that's also an important part of telling somebody's story, and of journalism." Then, in 2015, he spent a weekend reading every issue of the ISIS propaganda magazine for an article. His account of what that taught him has become his working rule. He learned that "the best way to get taken seriously as a journalist is to figure out what needs to be done but nobody else wants to do, because it sucks, and then do it."

The seed of his podcasting was older. He read King Leopold's Ghost at 19 and learned about the Belgian Congo, a historical crime on a scale he had never been taught in school. The anger stayed with him. Leopold II became the ninth subject of Behind the Bastards.

The reporting took him further out. He covered the war in the Donbas in 2015. He reported from Mosul while the city was being retaken from ISIS in 2016 and 2017. In July 2019 he crossed into northeast Syria with journalist Jake Hanrahan to interview the women fighting ISIS, a trip his own audience funded with more than $40,000 in donations. That reporting became The Women's War. At Bellingcat, where he wrote from 2018 to 2021, his analysis of the Christchurch shooter's manifesto argued that the document was a trap built for journalists, and editors at national outlets credited his piece with keeping coverage from falling into it. Users on 8chan answered by offering a bounty for his death. In 2020 he spent night after night reporting from the Portland protests in body armor and a helmet marked PRESS. Police shot him in the foot with a tear gas grenade, according to the lawsuit he joined, and a counter-protester's baton broke his hand that August.

Behind the Bastards arrived in the middle of all this, through an old connection. His former Cracked boss Jack O'Brien had moved to iHeart and asked if he had a show idea. Evans had been carrying the concept as a possible book. He has said since that the podcast form proved far better, that "it's done a thousand times better as a podcast than it ever could have done in a print medium." The first full episode, on Saddam Hussein as an erotic novelist, aired May 1, 2018, with comedian Jamie Loftus as the guest.

The format is a piece of engineering. Evans writes a long, sourced script about a dictator, grifter, executive, or cult leader, then reads it to a guest who has not seen it and reacts in real time. The audience learns at the guest's speed. The sources are published for anyone to check. The show settled into a twice-weekly cadence and never left it. By 2021 iHeart described it as consistently ranking among the top 10 most downloaded shows on its network, and that August the company built a network, Cool Zone Media, with Evans as head of content. In January 2026 the show began streaming on Netflix as a video podcast. Evans does not pretend the work is neutral. "I see journalism as a kind of activism," he told Strange Matters, and the show argues its case out loud.

His second show grew out of a sentence he kept hearing in war zones, from people who never believed collapse could reach them. It Could Happen Here began in 2019 as a short series laying out how a second American civil war could actually unfold, drawn from what he had seen in Ukraine, Iraq, and Syria. He relaunched it as a daily show in August 2021, and it still runs daily, now with a team around him. In his words, he wanted to warn people using lessons from "parts of the world that, I believed, were just a few years ahead of us on the path to calamity." The warning and the comedy sit side by side in his catalog, next to two novels and a history of vice. The through line is a reporter who reads the whole ugly document, goes to the place himself, and then tells you exactly what he found.

Aaron Mahnke

Aaron Mahnke will tell you the whole thing was an accident, and the record backs him up. "Lore was an accident," he said in 2017. "I was creating a giveaway to promote my self-published novels." Mahnke was a graphic designer in Massachusetts who wrote supernatural thrillers on the side. To grow his fiction newsletter he planned a short book of his five favorite New England myths. The file grew to 15,000 words. He recorded one story the way he would an audiobook and sent it to a friend, who told him to make it a podcast instead. He has called that conversation the accidental moment his career turned on.

Lore launched in March 2015. The early sound was rough, so he laid music under the narration to soften it, and the format locked in. Each episode runs under 45 minutes and braids several documented stories around one theme, told in his dry, unhurried voice over a piano score. The growth came from listeners passing episodes to friends, nothing else. About four months in, the show changed his working life. "It was about four months into releasing episodes that the show was big enough that I could get paid sponsors and those paychecks took the place of my design paychecks," he told Dropbox. By October 2015 Lore sat in the iTunes top 20, each episode cost him about 30 hours to write and produce, and Apple named it to the iTunes Best of 2015 list. By the spring of 2016 he had 1.6 million monthly listeners. The Academy of Podcasters named Lore its Best History Podcast that July. In November 2024 the show passed 500 million downloads. It has since reached 300 episodes, and in 2024 Mahnke was inducted into the Podcast Hall of Fame.

The rule underneath the show is stricter than the genre usually allows. "All of the material is from documented stories or historical events," he told The Guardian in 2015, and he publishes his sources for every episode. The monsters are folklore. The events underneath them are real, and he treats the difference as the whole point. His own description of the result is the one listeners would give. "In some ways, what I do is a modern campfire experience," he said, with a phone screen standing in for the firelight.

Success brought the usual second acts. Amazon turned Lore into a television series that premiered on Friday, October 13, 2017, with Mahnke narrating on camera. It ran two seasons. The books followed, a World of Lore trilogy and, in 2024, a Cabinet of Curiosities volume drawn from his second show. That show, Aaron Mahnke's Cabinet of Curiosities, began in 2018 and still runs twice a week, two strange true tales per episode.

The bigger second act is the company. Grim & Mild, the production banner Mahnke founded, now employs staff researchers and writers, including a folklorist, and works to an annual plan. His team maps about 30 topics a year. Researchers hand him outlines of 15 to 25 pages. He reads them on Friday, sits with them over the weekend, and writes the episode on Monday, recording as he goes. Under his executive production the company makes season-long series, the binaural horror event 13 Days of Halloween, and shows hosted by other people entirely. One of them, Noble Blood, is featured in the companion post to this one. Through all of it he kept the core job for himself. He still writes, narrates, and produces Lore personally, because the show has to carry his voice.

This fall he closed a circle. His new book, Exhumed, published in August 2026, digs into the history of the American vampire, and its story builds toward the 1892 exhumation of Mercy Brown in Rhode Island. That was the tale he opened the very first episode of Lore with, back when the podcast was a marketing idea that got away from him. Eleven years on, the accident is a company, a catalog, and a shelf of books, and the man who made it still gives the same advice he followed without knowing it. "You can't buy yourself an audience by buying a better mic."

Three different tempers, one shared habit. McElroy trusted his family. Evans trusted the primary source and his own two feet. Mahnke trusted the documented record and word of mouth. None of them waited for a gatekeeper, and none of them treats the audience as a metric. The audience is the reason the work exists, and on the evidence of a decade, the audience can tell.

Their PodSubs profiles and their shows are linked under this post. If you work on any of these shows, as a producer, editor, researcher, engineer, or guest, your credit belongs on the record too. Add it, and let the people who were in the room confirm it.

Their shows

Who is on this show?

My Brother, My Brother And Me

Think of the guest you still think about. The producer who makes the host sound smart. The editor who saves every episode. If a name is missing here, that person is invisible everywhere.

Add a credit

Who is on this show?

Sawbones: A Marital Tour of Misguided Medicine

Think of the guest you still think about. The producer who makes the host sound smart. The editor who saves every episode. If a name is missing here, that person is invisible everywhere.

Add a credit

Who is on this show?

The Adventure Zone

Think of the guest you still think about. The producer who makes the host sound smart. The editor who saves every episode. If a name is missing here, that person is invisible everywhere.

Add a credit

Who is on this show?

The Besties

Think of the guest you still think about. The producer who makes the host sound smart. The editor who saves every episode. If a name is missing here, that person is invisible everywhere.

Add a credit

Who is on this show?

Til Death Do Us Blart

Think of the guest you still think about. The producer who makes the host sound smart. The editor who saves every episode. If a name is missing here, that person is invisible everywhere.

Add a credit

Who is on this show?

Behind the Bastards

Think of the guest you still think about. The producer who makes the host sound smart. The editor who saves every episode. If a name is missing here, that person is invisible everywhere.

Add a credit

Who is on this show?

Behind the Insurrections

Think of the guest you still think about. The producer who makes the host sound smart. The editor who saves every episode. If a name is missing here, that person is invisible everywhere.

Add a credit

Who is on this show?

Behind the Police

Think of the guest you still think about. The producer who makes the host sound smart. The editor who saves every episode. If a name is missing here, that person is invisible everywhere.

Add a credit

Who is on this show?

It Could Happen Here

Think of the guest you still think about. The producer who makes the host sound smart. The editor who saves every episode. If a name is missing here, that person is invisible everywhere.

Add a credit

Who is on this show?

Lore

Think of the guest you still think about. The producer who makes the host sound smart. The editor who saves every episode. If a name is missing here, that person is invisible everywhere.

Add a credit

Who is on this show?

Aaron Mahnke's Cabinet of Curiosities

Think of the guest you still think about. The producer who makes the host sound smart. The editor who saves every episode. If a name is missing here, that person is invisible everywhere.

Add a credit

Who is on this show?

Grim & Mild Presents

Think of the guest you still think about. The producer who makes the host sound smart. The editor who saves every episode. If a name is missing here, that person is invisible everywhere.

Add a credit